1 Background and research progress
The NBMs have the layered structure, in which atoms combine with each other through strong chemical bonds and the weak van der Waals force. So, the NBMs have many characteristics different from corresponding block materials. However, different dimensions of carbon structural materials show different properties, such as 0D fullerenes [
1], lD carbon nanotubes [
2], 2D graphene [
3], and 3D graphene. And these materials were found and studied in chronological order: 3D graphite, 0D fullerenes, 1D carbon nanotubes, and 2D graphene. Hence, narrow-bandgap 2D materials have an attractive application prospect in the field of optics and electronics. There is a quantum limit effect in the vertical narrow-bandgap 2D plane direction, which can be controlled by the number of layers of the material. The bandgap varies widely, which has great potential in the application of broadband response photonic devices. Because of the weak van der Waals force between the layers, NBMs are used to prepare heterogeneous junction materials, and the problems caused by the mismatch of interface lattice can be effectively suppressed. Meanwhile, surface is passivated naturally without suspension bonds due to the van der Waals force between layers, which makes it easier to combine NBMs with photonic devices. This is the reason why NBMs are used in fiber lasers. The technology of employing these narrow-bandgap materials as saturable absorbers (SAs) has promoted the development of ultrafast laser generation. And the structures of these materials are shown in Fig. 1 [
4–
10].
In 2004, Geim and Novoselov
et al. reported that graphene [
3] was obtained by stripping off with adhesive tape and its related physical properties were studied, which triggered a boom in the research on NBMs worldwide. In 2016, Chernysheva
et al. used carbon nanotubes (CNTs) in ytterbium (Yb), bismuth (Bi), erbium (Er), thulium (Tm) and holmium-doped fiber lasers to achieve integrated operation in fiber laser cavity, which makes carbon nanotubes make outstanding progress in the application of fiber optics [
11]. The valence bands and conduction bands encounter at the Dirac points of the single-layer graphene, which leads to a semi-metallic band structure without the bandgap. Ultrawide band ranging from far-infra-red (FIR) to ultraviolet (UV) region interacts with electromagnetic waves [
12–
16]. The mechanism of energy level description for various nonlinear optical (NLO) [
17–
23] processes in graphene is shown in Fig. 2(a) [
24–
29]. And the Raman spectra and constant spectra of graphene sheets with the different number of layers that measured on quartz are shown in Figs. 2(b) and (c). Figures 2(d)– (f) show the optical contrast spectra in order to identify the thickness of graphene sheets covered on the fiber core area.
TMDCs, including MoS
2, WS
2, WSe
2 and so on, are another kind of significant narrow-bandgap optoelectronic materials. For several years, the unique optoelectronic properties of TMDCs have led to a worldwide research boom [
6,
30–
33]. In 2015, Robert
et al. used MoS
2, WS
2, and WSe
2 to realize its application as a multifunctional, broadband saturable absorption material in fiber laser Q-switching and mode-locking [
34]. The expression of transition metal sulfide is MX
2 (M=W, Mo, etc; X=S, Se, or Te). The 3D MX
2 has enormously important properties, such as semiconductor properties, semimetallic magnetism [
35], and superconductivity [
36]. It can be used as lubricant, catalyst, solar cell, supercapacitor, and rechargeable battery [
31,
36–
40]. The lattice structure of the layered MX
2 nanosheet is composed of two hexagonal MX
2, with a layer of metal atoms between the two sulfur atoms, forming a sandwich structure. The lattice structures of TMDCs are shown in Figs. 3(a) and (b). Figure 3(c) [
31] shows the optical bandgap versus the layer number for the typical TMDCs and other NBMs. MX
2 nanosheets possess many advantages, such as the special electrostatic coupling effect, large carrier mobility, high-intensity current storage characteristics, strong visible absorption, and good chemical and mechanical properties [
42–
45]. Therefore, MX
2 nanosheet can be applied in many fields, such as effect transistor [
46–
49], photoelectric transistors [
50,
51], integrated circuit [
52], chemical sensors [
53], light-emitting diodes [
54], and solid-state laser devices [
55–
61].
The emergence of a novel NBM black phosphorus (BP) [
62] fills the gap between graphene and TMDCs (0–1 eV). The bandgap of BP can be adjusted from 0.3 to 2 eV [
7,
63] with the decrease of the number of layers. As a kind of excellent 2D material, BP nanosheets can be applied to electronic equipment. The field effect transistors made by BP also have some attractive features, such as an on-off ratio of 10
5 (ultrathin equipment) at room temperature, excellent current saturation characteristics, about 1000 cm
2·V
−1·s
−1 (10 nm thick BP) field effect electron mobility [
64]. Therefore, the BP has a broad range of latent applications in the field of photonics [
65–
72], such as infrared band luminescence, light detection and modulation [
73–
75].
The monolayer BP nanosheet has direct bandgap and high charge mobility, which makes it widely used in the field of 2D photoelectricity. Figures 4(a) and (b) show the optical absorption of various layers of BP along the
x and
y directions, respectively [
76]. Continuous modulation of the bandgap of BP nanosheet can be achieved by external stress or external electric field [
77], which can be applied in solar cells, photonics devices, etc. [
78,
79].
Topological insulators (TIs) of group V chalcogenide also possess a layered structure with the large interlayer van der Waals gap. And TI is a 2D photoelectric material with internal insulation and electric conduction at the surface or edge. TI has a Dirac cone structure similar to graphene [
80] due to its strong spin orbit coupling. In the body of TI, the electron energy band structure is similar to the conventional insulator, and the Fermi energy level is between the conduction band and valence band. The surface state is determined by the topological structure of its body electron state and is hardly affected by impurities and disorder, so it is very stable. The surface state structure of TI is similar to graphene energy band structure, which has no bandgap and the inverted cone intersects with the Dirac point. In 2013, the phase diagram evolution of the dynamical properties of Dirac fermions with doping content was established by Chen
et al. [
81], as shown in Fig. 5(a). And Fig. 5(b) shows the evolution of surface state band structure and electron self-energy with the composition in Bi
2Te
3−xSe
x system. Up to now, the strong TI materials have been confirmed by experiments including Sb
2Se
3, Bi
2Se
3, Bi
2Te
3, Sb
2Te
3, etc. These materials are protected by time inversion symmetry so that they can resist disorder effects and local disturbance. Hence, these materials have potential applications in the field of electronics and optoelectronics [
82–
89].
In recent years, bismuthene has attracted much attention because of its unique electro–mechanical properties and excellent stability [
90–
93]. Bismuthene as a kind of excellent candidates for the application of spintronic devices does not require strong external magnetic field on account of its inherent spin–orbit coupling features [
94,
95]. It also has semi-metallic properties in comparison with the metal materials, and its long Fermi wavelength of electronic properties is conducive to the research in the field of condensed matter physics [
96,
97]. If the bismuthene turns narrower than the Fermi wavelength, the transform from the semimetal to semiconductor may occur due to quantum confinement effects [
98]. Figure 6(a) exhibits the diagram of the saturable absorption of bismuthene [
99]. In order to obtain the saturable absorption of bismuthene, the intensity ought to completely fill the lower energy level to attain the standard of photon excitation. The optical absorption spectra of few-layer bismuthene solution is shown in Fig. 6(b), and the inset is the amplified NIR absorption region. And the UV-vis-NIR spectrum is shown in Fig. 6(c) [
99].
Since 2004, when monolayer graphene was discovered by the scientists at the University of Manchester in the UK, graphene has caused a worldwide research boom. The nonlinear optical properties of graphene and its applications in passively Q-switched, mode-locked lasers and optical limiters are also widely studied. In 2009, Wang
et al. [
98] from Dublin Trinity College discovered that graphene dispersion had an anti-saturation absorption effect under the radiation of 532-nm and 1064-nm nanosecond pulse, and they had explained that the principle came from the nonlinear scattering of the solution. In the same year, Bao
et al. [
26] achieved the saturable absorption of the low-layer graphene nanosheet under the femtosecond pulse of 1550 nm for the first time, which realized successfully the mode-locking output pulse in the fiber laser. In 2010, Yu
et al. [
101] of Shandong University reported the saturable absorption characteristics of graphene in the 1.34 µm band and realized the application of Q-switching in the solid-state laser. Subsequently, the researchers also realized the saturable absorption characteristics of graphene in the visible-ultraviolet-near infrared and even in the terahertz band. The tunable ultrafast mode-locked and Q-switched laser output in broadband can be achieved based on this material [
102–
104]. In addition, the third-order nonlinear refractive index coefficient of graphene has been reported. In 2010, the nonlinear optical properties of graphene were explored using the four-wave mixing method by Hendry
et al. [
105] from the University of Exeter, and they pointed out that the third-order nonlinear polarization rate of graphene under the action of picosecond pulse in near-infrared band is eight orders of magnitude higher than that of dielectric material. Subsequently, the researchers used nanosecond and femtosecond lasers to obtain the nonlinear refractive index and polarization rate of graphene, which was several orders of magnitude higher than that of general medium materials under the same experimental conditions [
106,
107].
With the boom of graphene research, the graphene-like nanomaterials also come into researchers’ view. TMDCs are a kind of graphene-like nanomaterials, and single-layer structure of TMDCs has high-intensity photoluminescence characteristics in terms of optical properties. Moreover, theoretical calculations prove that single-layer TMDCs have unique photoelectron characteristics, and their exciton has selectivity, super-strong exciton binding energy and stress controllable banding width in the Brillouin energy valley. Therefore, the third-order nonlinear optics of TMDCs has aroused great interest in recent years. In 2013, Wang
et al. [
108] of Shanghai Institute of Optics and Fine Mechanics studied the saturable absorption characteristics of the few-layer MoS
2 dispersion under the action of femtosecond laser at 800 nm band for the first time. The results showed that the saturable absorption performance of MoS
2 dispersion under the same experimental conditions is better than that of graphene dispersion with the same concentration. In 2016, the nonlinear optical characteristics and physical mechanism of TMDCs had been further systematically studied by this research group, and the nonlinear optical functional control and shear strategy of such materials also have been proposed and verified [
109]. Figure 7(a) shows the calculated band structures of TMDCs, such as bulk MoS
2, quadrilayer MoS
2, bilayer MoS
2, and monolayer MoS
2 [
110]. The spin splitting of the bands at the K and K′ points on the corners of the Brillouin zone [
55,
111] is exhibited in Fig. 7(b), and the colors of orange and blue indicate up and down spin polarization. The reflection and photo-luminescence spectra of ultrathin MoS
2 layers are shown in Fig. 7(c) [
110]. And the layer dependence of photo-luminescence efficiency in MoS
2 with the different thickness is exhibited in Fig. 7(d). In 2014, Zhang
et al. [
55] of Shenzhen University confirmed that single-layer MoS
2 has nonlinear optical characteristics from visible to near-infrared band, and successfully realized the mode-locked ultrashort pulse laser output in the near-infrared band based on this material. In the same year, Cheng
et al. [
112] from Harbin Engineering University reported that the nonlinear characteristics of MoS
2 can shift from saturable absorption to anti-saturable absorption with the increase of power. Meanwhile, Zhang
et al. [
113] of Lanzhou University prepared the different sizes of TMDCs by using the method of distributed centrifugation, and obtained that the nonlinear optical properties are directly related to the sizes of materials.
In 2015, Mao
et al. [
114] reported that the few-layer WS
2 nanosheets obtained by liquid phase method have the characteristics of saturable absorption and can be applied in the mode-locked laser. Qiu
et al. [
115] of Zhejiang University prepared the few-layer MoS
2 nanosheets with high yield and uniform thickness by hydrothermal method, which proved its saturable absorption characteristic in the band of 800–1550 nm, and they also achieved Q-switched laser output in the near-infrared band based on this material. Subsequently, in order to achieve excellent Q-switched pulse laser output, the optical absorption rate of the material was enhanced by changing the morphology, and atoms and other methods were added to enhance the saturable absorption performance of materials. In addition, this research group used solid phase method to synthesize ultrathin MoS
2 and WS
2 nanosheets, which realized its optical limiting effect at the band of 800 nm, and its optical limiting threshold was much lower than that of traditional optical limiting materials.
With these materials emerging subsequently, the TIs also come into researchers’ horizons. In 2012, Bernard
et al. [
116] of the Brussels Free University of Belgium first realized the saturable absorption characteristics of the topological insulator Bi
2Te
3 in the communication band. In the same year, Wen
et al. [
117,
118] took the lead in utilizing the saturable absorption characteristics of two TI materials, Bi
2Se
3 and Bi
2Te
3, to realize the mode-locked pulse output in the fiber laser. In 2013, this group measured the nonlinear refractive index [
119] of Bi
2Se
3 by Z-scan method under the action of near-infrared femtosecond laser for the first time. In 2014, Jung
et al. [
120,
121] realized the applications of passively mode-locked and Q-switched lasers in the 2 µm band based on TIs materials. In 2016, the researchers in Zhejiang University prepared Bi
2Te
3 nanosheets with high yield and uniform size and thickness by adding surfactant PVP into the solvent thermal method. The output performance of Q-switched laser output was obtained based on TI by using this method, which is superior to TI made by liquid phase stripping. Meanwhile, a ternary topological insulator Bi
2SeTe
2 possessing excellent saturable absorption performance was prepared by solvent heating method and the theoretical work verified the performance [
83].
Recently, many researchers have paid attention to novel diazo-metal-elements materials such as As, Se, and Bi [
122,
123] with the rapid development of these flexible NBMs. The bismuthene has the semimetallic features and narrow-bandgap of 0.4 eV with single-layer structure [
124,
125]. And the bismuthene can be translated from semimetal into semiconductor on account of the effect of quantum confinement. In 2016, Zhang
et al. [
126] investigated the arsenene, phosphorene, antimonene and bismuthene that have the high carrier mobility and the narrow bandgap. In 2018, Lu
et al. [
99] reported a ring cavity fiber laser based on bismuthene with the modulation depth of 2.03% and experimentally achieved conventional solitons with the pulse duration of 652 fs, which shows that bismuthene is a novel narrow bandgap material for the ultrafast photonics. In the same year, Yang
et al. [
127] reported a Tm-doped fiber ring cavity laser and successfully obtained a 2 µm output with pulse duration of 1 ns. Chai and Wang
et al. [
9,
10] also reported the Yb-doped fiber laser and Er-doped fiber laser based on bismuthene, respectively.
The unique optic–electronic properties of these narrow bandgap materials [
128–
130] enable them to have great application prospects in the construction of micro-nano opto–electronic devices.
2 Nonlinear optics of novel NBMs
The third-order nonlinear optical properties of NBM have been a hot research area for several years, including saturable absorption, anti-saturable absorption, and so on. The saturable absorption describes that the optical absorption rate of a material decreases with the enhancement of incident light and eventually becomes a constant. A material with the saturable absorption property can be regarded as SA and used as passively mode-locked or Q-switched element in the fiber lasers [
131–
136]. Since its emergence, the laser has been moving toward the direction of tunable, short pulse and high energy output. The passively mode-locked technique uses saturable absorption characteristics to realize the continuous narrowing of the pulse duration, thus generates the required ultrashort optical pulse [
137–
140]. The passively Q-switched technique [
141–
144] is used to insert the Q-switched element with fixed parameters into the laser cavity, and the saturable absorption characteristic of the Q-switched elements is used to adjust the Q-value. When the stimulated radiation occurs, the inverted particles stored in the high energy level of the gain fiber can quickly transit back to the low energy level and release huge amounts of energy in a very short time, which can result in high-energy pulse output.
At present, the most widely used SA is the semiconductor SA [
145–
150]. However, there are some disadvantages such as high price, complicated production process, narrow wavelength range, and low output energy. Therefore, it is very important to find a SA with advantages of broadband tunable nonlinear absorption, ultralow loss, high damage threshold, ultrashort response time, high modulation depth and ultralow cost. As a novel kind of materials, narrow-bandgap photoelectric materials have unique saturable absorption properties, which have a good application prospect in pulsed laser generation. Moreover, narrow-bandgap photoelectric materials also have unique anti-saturable absorption properties, hence, it has potential applications in laser limiting.
2.1 Optical nonlinear absorption
Light absorption is a fundamental interaction between substance and light. And it can be divided into linear absorption and nonlinear absorption. A phenomenon in which the absorption coefficient of a substance varies with the intensity of incident light is called nonlinear absorption, and the opposite is the linear absorption. Nonlinear absorption is a nonlinear effect under the action of highly coherent light, which has been widely studied. Due to different absorption mechanisms of substance, nonlinear absorption can be divided into saturable absorption [
151–
155], anti-saturable absorption, two-photon absorption, and carrier absorption. The saturable absorption and twophoton absorption are the most important and common nonlinear absorption effects. These nonlinear absorption properties are as follows.
2.1.1 Saturable absorption
When the intensity of excited light reaches a certain value, the phenomenon that the absorption coefficient of the material decreases instead of increases is called saturable absorption, which is mainly caused by the principle of Pauli incompatibility. When the excitation intensity is weak, the electrons in the valence band absorb the photon energy and are excited to the conduction band. At the same time, they are gradually cooled and arranged due to the restriction of the Pauli Exclusion Principle. When the electron energy state in the Fermi level is filled, the incident intensity is called saturable intensity. As the light keeps on increasing, the redundant photons will no longer be absorbed by the electrons in the valence band, but move transparently through the acting medium.
From the macro perspective, the light transmittance will gradually increase when the energy of the excitation light increases. When the energy reaches the saturable intensity, the transmittance will no longer increase but gradually move to a stable value. This nonlinear effect is widely used in solid-state and fiber mode-locked lasers or passively Q-switched lasers [
156–
165].
2.1.2 Anti-saturable absorption
Contrary to the saturable absorption, the absorption coefficient of the medium increases in accordance with the increase of light intensity. The mechanism is that the electrons in the low energy state are excited and then jump to the high energy electron state. When the absorption crosses the section of the excited state is more excellent than the absorption cross section of the ground state, which is called the reverse saturation absorption. From the macro perspective, under high power laser excitation, the transmission rate of medium decreases instead of increases, which can be used in the optical limiting devices.
2.1.3 Two-photon absorption
Two-photon absorption refers to the process in which the medium energizes or combines two photons of the same energy or different energy to excite the electrons in the low energy state of the valence band to the high energy state under strong light excitation. It is important to note that the two photons absorbed can be the same photons or different photons. In the excitation process, the electron absorbs a single photon and is excited to a virtual electron state, almost simultaneously. And another photon is absorbed by the same electron and is excited to a higher excited state. Since the interval is very short, we can think of two photons being simultaneously absorbed and excited to a high energy state. Similar to the anti-saturable absorption, this phenomenon is also applied to optical limiting devices [
27,
166–
173].
2.1.4 Carrier absorption
When the frequency of incident light is less than the bandwidth of the semiconductor, electrons cannot form an energy band transition, and electrons absorb photons to form free carriers (electrons or holes) at the same time. The free carrier is still restrained by the surrounding charge, but it is in an excited state. When the frequency of incident light is greater than the band width of the semiconductor and the energy transition occurs (saturable absorption or two-photon absorption), the electron excited to the conduction band cannot exist and also forms a large number of free carriers. These carriers continue to absorb photon energy, and they are excited to other energy levels as carriers.
2.2 The measurement methods of nonlinear absorption
The methods of measuring nonlinear absorption characteristics of materials include nonlinear interferometry [
174], four-wave mixing, three-wave mixing [
175], ellipsometry, beam distortion and Z-scan. Although the first three methods are highly precise, the required equipment is very complex and expensive, and the calculation of ellipsometry is relatively complicated. The beam distortion method is very strict and has large errors. The experimental equipment and analysis required by Z-scan is relatively simple and the data is relatively accurate. Hence, this is the main experimental method described in this paper.
The Z-scan method was first adopted by Sheik–Bahae
et al. in 1989. In the following years, they gradually improved this method and launched corresponding theoretical model to figure out the nonlinear refractive index and nonlinear absorption coefficient of substances. This method is very simple and flexible and the data is considerably accurate. Hence, it is quickly accepted by researchers, and has been rapidly developed and improved. The open Z-scan method is mainly used to measure the nonlinear absorption performance of the materials. Figure 8(a) shows the commonly used Z-scan experiment device [
176]. The type of the excitation laser light source has a wavelength of 1030 nm. The excitation pulse width is 340 fs and the frequency is 100 Hz. The beam waist radius is about 32 µm at 1030 nm. The beam is focused through focal length lens. Behind the lens is a moving platform, and the center of the moving platform is near the beam waist of the laser beam. The sample can be moved in the axial direction of the beam by moving the platform. The laser is divided into two beams with equal energy using a beam splitter, then the incident and output energy of the sample are recorded in real time with two energy meters and transmitted the data to the computer for analysis. The normalized transmittance curves with the different testing energy values are shown in Fig. 8(b), which indicates clear saturable absorption responses in the different energy values, and the SA performance exhibits the excellent stability with the increase of pulse energy. The fitting values of the nonlinear coefficient and their fitted curves are shown in Fig. 8(c).
As seen in Fig. 8(a) [
176], the power density of the incident laser is low when the sample is far away from the beam waist. At this time, the absorption form of the sample is mainly linear absorption with little change in transmission energy. As the sample gets closer to the beam waist, the incident optical power density increases gradually, and the sample will show nonlinear absorption effect. When the output energy curve presents a symmetric wave peak, it indicates that the sample has a saturable absorption effect, as shown in Fig. 8(b). In contrast, when the output energy curve is a symmetrical wave trough, the sample is reflected as the optical limiting effect. Notably, in the Z-scan measurement, the thickness of sample used in the experiment is smaller than the Rayleigh length of the beam. When a moderate aperture is added to the back of the sample, we call it a closed aperture Z-scan. Combined with the results of an open Z-scan, the nonlinear refractive index of the sample can be obtained.
3 The preparation of NBMs
The development of batch manufacturing methods of high-quality NBMs is the key and foundation to realize the in-dustrial application of optoelectronic devices. Generally, the preparation methods of NBMs are divided into top-down method and bottom-up method. The top-down method includes mechanical exfoliation method and liquid phase exfoliation method. While the bottom-up method includes liquid phase synthesis, chemical vapor deposition (CVD), epitaxial growth (EG) and other methods. Here are some common methods of stripping and synthesizing NBMs [
177–
180].
3.1 Mechanical exfoliation method
In 2004, Geim and Novoselov
et al. [
1] were the first to realize the preparation of monolayer graphene by solid-phase mechanical exfoliation. Some scaly debris can be obtained by rubbing the surface of the layered material, and there are even NBMs with a monolayered structure in this detritus. The general way is to press the tape paper onto the surface of the corresponding block material, and NBMs will be attached to the surface of the tape paper after removing the tape paper. The NBMs obtained by this method have a high degree of crystal crystallization and can be easily screened out by an optical microscope. Through further tests, for example, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), high resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and atomic force microscopy (AFM), more information about its morphology, thickness, and size can be revealed. Due to the common structural features of the weak van der Waals binding between layers of NBMs, the mechanical exfoliation method is also applicable to the preparation of other graphene-like NBMs. In this way, many layered and crystalline materials can be stripped out, such as boron nitride (BN), MoS
2, NbSe
2, MoSe
2, WS
2, WSe
2, and Bi
2Te
3 [
180–
183].
The advantages of this method are simple operation, high efficiency, low cost, and wide adaptability. The size of single-sheet NBMs can reach tens of microns in the transverse, and possess better crystallization and surface cleanliness. Hence, it has excellent photoelectric properties. However, this is a relatively original method that was first used to strip graphene. Its obvious disadvantage is that the samples obtained by this method are mostly multilayer structures, and has less samples with few-layer or single-layer structures. This method cannot realize the mass production of NBMs and cannot meet the needs of the industry.
3.2 Liquid phase exfoliation method
In 2010, Ruoff
et al. [
184] reported for the first time that the high-performance preparation of graphene oxide (GO) was achieved by liquid phase exfoliation method, and graphene could be obtained more efficiently by subsequent reduction. Since then, researchers have conducted extensive research on the impact of the solution on the effect of liquid phase exfoliation graphene and developed a more systematic theory [
185–
188]. In this method, many researchers realized the preparation of TMDCs (such as WS
2, MoS
2, MoSe
2, TaSe
2, MoTe
2, and NbSe
2), BP, TIs, h-BN dispersion recently [
179,
189–
194]. Liquid phase exfoliation is a method of dispersing LBM powders in specific solvents and peeling LBM from the surface of the corresponding powder particles by means of high power ultrasonic vibration.
The common solvent is anhydrous, but ultra-pure water solutions are also available for some materials. Under the action of solvent, the LBM is separated into small structural units. After a long period of stasis, the NBMs dissolved in the solvent will be stratified, and the larger particles will gradually precipitate. The upper suspension contains a large number of single-layer or multilayer narrow-bandgap nanoparticles. In addition, the whole stratification process can be accelerated by centrifugal action.
The advantages of this method are simple, safe, low cost, and suitable for mass production. The surface of materials can be chemically modified at the same time. While the drawback is that the NBMs obtained are irregular in shape and not uniform in thickness, and the physical and chemical properties are easily changed due to the action of surface dispersion.
3.3 Liquid phase synthesis method
The liquid phase synthesis method takes water or other organic solvents as reaction medium to dissolve or disperse the particles of NBMs. It can realize the crystallization and growth of NBMs in the reaction medium under heating and (or) high pressure conditions, and separate the products through precipitation, centrifugation, washing, drying and other steps after the end of the reaction. This method regulates the growth, shape, size and surface chemistry of crystals by adding the specific surfactant (such as PVP) in the reaction solution and controlling the reaction temperature, reaction time, etc., which can obtain various shapes of nanosheets and nanobelts [
37,
38].
Generally, the advantages of this method are that the product has good crystallization and it can realize the mass production. But it is difficult to obtain single layer NBMs, and its production needs longer reaction time. Most importantly, the liquid phase reaction will inevitably adsorb surfactant and other substances on the surface of the product, which will have the certain impact on the properties of the material itself [
40,
41,
195].
3.4 Chemical vapor deposition (CVD) method
Currently, the large area uniform NBMs (like graphene) can be synthesized by chemical vapor deposition method, which shows good commercial prospects. And CVD method is the most widely used technology to prepare high-quality NBMs (especially graphene). CVD method is a preparation technique for the formation of target material by chemical reaction on the substrate surface under the action of heat, laser, plasma and another additional energy, and it is of great importance and can be applied in many fields such as optoelectronic devices and semiconductor industry. The most typical example of NBMs produced by CVD is the preparation of high-quality graphene materials [
5,
178,
196–
198]. Although the mechanical exfoliation method can get high-performance few-layer and single layer graphene, it cannot be applied to the industrial production.
However, the CVD method cannot realize the low-cost production of large-size and high-quality graphene [
5,
199–
201], researchers have successfully prepared monolayer, double-layer and multilayer graphene of wafer scale, which are widely used in flexible transparent optoelectronic devices. CVD technology also shows great potential in the preparation of TMDCs, and researchers have successfully achieved controlled growth of high quality TMDCs on a variety of substrates [
202–
205]. The merit of this method is that it can get the shapes of sample that people need [
206–
211]. It requires much energy to grow NBMs based on this method, so the damage rate of growth on copper substrate sheet is relatively higher. And partial inhomogeneity still exists in NBMs grown by this method.
3.5 Epitaxial growth (EG) method
The epitaxial growth method is a technique for growing high quality thin films on crystalline substrates [
212]. Under the condition of ultrahigh vacuum, the precursor steam is produced by the heat evaporator with various kinds of precursor materials, which is collimated through the holes to form the molecular beam or atomic beam, and then sprayed to the single crystal substrate at the appropriate temperature [
213,
214]. By controlling the molecular beam or atomic beam to scan the substrate, the molecules or atoms can grow on the substrate layer by layer according to the crystal arrangement [
215].
The obvious characteristic of EG method is that the deposition rate is very slow, and it can prepare highly crystalline film with crystal growth orientation, controllable composition and precisely adjustable thickness. The merit of this method is that it can produce high quality semiconductor heterojunctions or superlattices by periodically turning on or off the specific evaporation sources. Hence, this is a very important preparation method in the semiconductor industry [
216,
217].
4 The applications of flexible narrow-bandgap materials
4.1 Pulse laser generation based on narrow-bandgap materials
4.1.1 Pulsed laser based on graphene SA
Graphene SAs have made the generation of pulsed laser from the visible to infrared range on account of their ultrafast recovery time, ultrawide nonlinear optical response bandwidth and super saturable absorption [
24,
218–
221]. Bao
et al. firstly obtained mode-locked operation based on graphene SA in an Er-doped fiber laser (EDFL) that is operated at 1565 nm with the output pulse width of 756 fs [
222]. In 2012, mode-locked operation in a midinfrared (MIR) fiber laser based on graphene SA was reported by Zhang
et al. for the first time [
223]. The solid state lasers [
103] have been successfully achieved in the infrared region with the evolution of pulse laser based on graphene SA. The experimental schematic diagram for ultrafast fiber laser is shown in Fig. 9(a) [
224]. SAs based on graphene have been applied for the generation of microsecond pulse from NIR to MIR lasers. Figure 9(b) exhibits the adjustable output spectra from Q-switched fiber laser near the third low loss telecommunication wavelength based on graphene SAs [
224].
4.1.2 Solid state laser based on MoS2 SA
With the successful achievement of pulse lasers employing graphene SA, there has been an enormous number of descriptions on the pulsed lasers applying narrow-bandgap semiconductors of dichalcogenides of Mo, such as MoS
2. And for the monolayer MoS
2 whose bandgap is 1.8 eV corresponding the wavelength of 689 nm, because the exit of the edge state and the defect state conduces to the operation of MoS
2 SA in the NIR and MIR, it allows the description of fiber lasers at the wavelengths far longer than the fundamental exciton absorption wavelength [
225]. Wang
et al. [
226] were the first group to demonstrate a solid state pulsed laser based on the MoS
2 SA using the bulk Q-switched cavity. In 2016, Chen
et al. found hot excitons form quickly after charge transfer based on the MoS
2/WS
2 heterostructure material [
227]. The schematic instructions of ultrafast visible and IR microspectroscopy are shown in Fig. 10(a). Figure 10(b) exhibits the image of the transient absorption change for a MoS
2/WS
2 heterostructure material. Figures 10(c) and (d) show the evolution of the absorption changes in WS
2 monolayer (in blue), MoS
2 monolayer (in red), and the MoS
2/WS
2 heterostructure (in green). The signal of the MoS
2/WS
2 heterostructure and the sum of the WS
2 and MoS
2 monolayers are shown in Fig. 10(e).
In 2017, Yan
et al. found that WS
2 SA displayed excellent nonlinear optical properties and was applied for the generation of ultrafast pulses, as shown in Fig. 11 [
228]. Nonlinear absorption curve of few-layer WS
2 and the construction of the fiber laser based on few-layer WS
2 SA are exhibited in Figs. 11(a) and (b), respectively. Figures 11(c)–(f) show the output power, output spectrum, RF spectrum and the autocorrelation trace, respectively.
In 2014, Luo
et al. rapidly extended the operation wavelength of Q-switched laser based on MoS
2 SA up to 2 µm region [
61], and this proposed laser can achieve the higher output power and the lower repetition rate in comparison to others reports based on MoS
2 SA [
286]. The mode-locked pulse still can not be generated in solid state lasers based on a bulk-cavity due to the high nonsaturable loss of MoS
2 SAs, but it can be obtained in the fiber lasers. The mode-locked pulse in a Yb-doped fiber laser based on MoS
2 SA was first obtained by Li
et al. [
229] with the center wavelength of 1070.5 nm, the pulse width of 726 ps and the output spectrum bandwidth of 1.7 nm. And this fiber laser system has many advantages, such as flexible maneuverability, compact construction, and low cost characteristics, which make this system compatible and flexible for applications in reality.
4.1.3 Pulsed fiber laser based on BP SA
The emergence of BP fills the gap between graphene and TMDCs (0–1 eV). The bandgap of BP can be adjusted from 0.3 eV (multilayer) to 2 eV (single layer) with the decreasing number of layers, which can be applied in the field of ultrafast photonics [
230–
234]. BP shows unique electric and optical properties, which can be regarded as the excellent SA for the applications of NIR and MIR region. Chen
et al. [
165] firstly reported BP SA in a communication band of 1550 nm. And the SA was made by employing mechanically exfoliated BP few-layer sheets and coated on the fiber ferrule. Their group employed an EDFL to obtain mode-locked pulse with the output pulse duration of 946 fs. But the main barrier that utilizes these strong absorption matearials to achieve high power output of the lasers is the low thermal damage threshold on account of the heating of the lasers. Lee
et al. [
16] searched a method that deposits BP onto side-polished fiber, where the saturable absorption takes place through the interaction between BP and evanescent interaction. This method can be employed to optimize the fiber laser operating at a higher power. In recent years, a microfiber-based BP quantum dot (QD) SA has been studied to display the strong nonlinear response at the wavelength of 1.56 µm, which indicates the latent value for the generation of ultrashort pulse [
235,
236]. Figure 12(a) exhibits the configuration of an Er-doped fiber laser based on BPQD SA, and the output features of pulses are shown in Figs. 12(b)– (e). While no obvious change of central wavelength and spectral bandwidth can be observed, which indicates that the mode-locked state is very stable [
235].
4.1.4 Pulsed fiber laser based on PbS SA
Recently, due to the advantages of small bandgap, high laser-induced damage threshold, excellent nonlinear absorption efficient and easy integration, there are some novel materials attracting researchers’ attention, such as PbS nanoparticles and QDs, bismuthene, and Mxene. Hence, these novel materials are the promising optical devices in pulsed fiber lasers.
In 2018, Zhang’s group and Yun’s group both achieved mode-locked fiber laser based on the PbS nanoparticles and PbS QDs, respectively. As shown in Fig. 13, the mode-locked pulse with pulse width of 1.01 ps and spectrum width of 2.93 nm is obtained in an Er-doped fiber laser based on PbS NPs [
237]. The experimental setup is shown in Fig. 13(a), and the results are shown in Figs. 13(b)–(e), respectively. In the same year, Yun
et al. [
238] realized a transform-limited soliton pulse with pulse duration of 559 fs and 3 dB bandwidth of 4.78 nm at the center wavelength of 1563 nm by incorporating PbS QDs into a fiber laser. The experimental setup is displayed in Fig. 14(a) and the results are shown in Figs. 14(b)–(e). Due to the nonlinear saturable absorption characteristics of PbS QDs, this material has practical applications in many fields, such as near-infrared (NIR) pulsed lasers and modulators.
Few-layered bismuthene, as a mono-elemental novel NBMs purely composed by the element of bismuth, has been theoretically predicted to possess an obviously enhanced stability and excellent optical responses. Few-layered bismuthene also has various significant properties, such as high carrier mobility, high stability, and excellent nonlinear optical transmission. Therefore, this material, as SA, has attracted tremendous interest in the application of fiber laser.
4.1.5 Pulsed fiber laser based on bismuthene SA
In 2018, Wang
et al. [
10] employed the few-layered bismuthene as the SA in the fiber laser. And the mode-locker is made by depositing the few-layered bismuthene on a microfiber. They successfully obtained the ultrashort pulse with duration of 621.5 fs, the spectrum bandwidth of 10.35 nm at the central wavelength of 1557.5 nm and fundamental repetition rate of 22.74 MHz, which can be seen in Figs. 15(a)–(d). And also they achieved the bound state soliton with the modulation period of 0.8 nm and pulse width of 525.5 fs in the proposed fiber laser at different pump power and polarization state, which can be seen in Figs. 15(e) and (f). Chai
et al. [
9] studied the Yb-doped ring fiber laser using bismuthene for the generation of ultrashort pulse based on evanescent field. And they successfully achieved the conventional solitons with duration of 30.25 ps at the wavelength of 1034.4 nm. The characteristics of output are shown in Figs. 16(a)–(d), respectively. In the same year, Yang
et al. [
127] achieved the Tm-doped fiber laser based on a 17-layer thickness bismuthene. The schematic diagram is exhibited in Fig. 17(a). And the output pulse with duration of 1 nm and 3 dB spectrum bandwidth of 4.5 nm was obtained, as shown in Figs. 17(b) and (c), accordingly.
In recent years, many studies based on bismuthene [
9,
10,
99,
127,
239–
241] have emerged. And the researches about the fiber laser were concluded in Table 1. Hence, we demonstrate that the study of bismuthene can be regarded as a novel direction of up-and-coming SA materials with high stability and excellent nonlinear optical characterizations. In addition to the materials mentioned above, the variety of 2D materials has constantly been enriched in recent years, such as TIs [
242–
244], MXene [
245–
247], antimonene [
248], and perovskite [
249], which exhibit sundry properties, therefore they are the promising candidates for the applications of ultrafast photonics.
4.1.6 The various pulse laser technologies
Different from the semiconductor saturable absorber mirrors (SESAMs) that have the limited saturable absorption bandwidth, the NBMs have wide saturable absorption bandwidth. And the fabrication cost of SESAMs is much higher than that of NBMs. The SESAMs operate in reflection while the NBMs integrate into solid state or fiber lasers in different ways. As for solid state laser, the simplest way to manufacture SA is to deposit the NBMs dispersion on a flat substrate, such as mirrors or the quartz glass plates, and in this way, it makes the SA operates in transmission or reflection. As for fiber lasers, various methods have been stated for the NBMs SA integrated in the system. As shown in Fig. 18 [
222,
250–
253], the SA can be fabricated by deposition of the NBMs dispersion on the surface of fiber connector, or on side-polished fiber or tapered fiber.
4.2 Optical modulation based on NBMs
4.2.1 The typical methods of optical modulation based on NBMs
The NBMs’optical response to the incident light can be characterized through dielectric constant or conductivity or refractive index, and it can be modified by the external field such as optical, magnetic, or electric field, and temperature or pressure. Hence, the light that propagates through the certain NBMs can be modulated by another beam light (called as all-optical modulation) or the electric field (called as electro-optical modulation). The typical methods of optical modulation based on NBMs are divided into three types through the different applied external fields, such as thermal heating, electrical gating, and optical excitation, as exhibited in Fig. 19 [
254]. And the optical excitation and the external electrical gating adjust the complex refractive index and the carrier density of the NBMs, which can be applied in the generation of the amplitude modulation and phase modulation. The thermal heating produced in the NBMs, whether electrical-induced or the optical-induced, is spread to the transparent substrate or waveguide, which elevates the temperature and then altering the real part of the refractive index, which is generally utilized for the phase modulation.
As for monolayer graphene, the Fermi energy of material is apparently varied to modify the optical transition of interband when inflicting the bias electric field. Figure 20(a) shows the gate voltage dependent reflection rate of graphene on a silicon substrate, and the inset figure demonstrates the interband transition of the monolayer graphene. While the all-optic method for the optical modulation based on NBMs is used by applying the ultrashort pulses to regulate the propagation of the signal, providing the ultrafast response based on the optical nonlinear effects [
255]. Due to the relatively low density of state and zero bandgap of graphene, optical excitation generates the nonequilibrium carriers in the valence band and conduction band, which results in the extremely strong saturable absorption with the ultrashort response time [
256]. And it can be widely applied in mode-locked fiber lasers and the optical modulators. Figure 20(b) [
257] shows the theoretical and experimental results of the nonlinear refractive index based on graphene. Due to the high thermal conductivity of the graphene at the room temperature, the NBMs diffuse the heat to their surrounding materials, which could be used as the heat generator and conductor [
258,
259].
4.2.2 The typical systems of optical modulation based on NBMs
The typical systems of optical modulation include free space optical modulation [
255,
256], fiber-based optical modulation [
262–
265], and chip integrated optical modulation. There are many different structures of the optical modulation listed follows. Sensale-Rodriguez
et al. [
266] put forward a kind of wideband graphene terahertz (THz) modulator and achieved by the intraband transition in 2012, as shown in Fig. 21(a). As shown in Fig. 21(b), a gating voltage is used between a back ring-shaped contact on the substrate and a top contact on monolayer graphene to adjust the Fermi level of graphene. Figure 21(c) exhibits the modulator composes of the accumulated graphene pairs with capacitive-coupled 2D hole gases (2DHG) in the valence band and 2D electron gases (2DEG) in the conduction band, so that it can surmount potentially limited modulation by using a single-layer graphene [
267]. At zero bias (
Vg = 0 V), it causes the minimum loss of insertion or the attenuation of signal when the Fermi level is at the Dirac point of all layers of graphene. When the bias voltage is applied, 2DEGs are in one of the graphene layers linked to the negative electrode and 2DHGs are in another of graphene layers linked to the positive electrode, which leads to the near-zero terahertz transmission.
In 2014, Wen
et al. [
268] achieved a maximum modulation depth of 94% based on an all-optical structure where the 1550 nm incident light acts as the incident light to excite carrier in graphene and cause the third-order nonlinear effect, as exhibited in Fig. 22(a). And Fig. 22(b) shows the time domain THz transmittance of graphene on germanium (GOG) represented by dashed curves and germanium (Ge) represented by the solid curves without and with the photo-doping, respectively, and the inset figure is the peak–peak amplitude with the variation of pump power. The experimental configuration for the measurements of modulation features is shown in Fig. 22(c).
In free space modulation configurations in which the pump light passes through and interacts with the material merely once, the interaction between light and matter is generally not robust enough for the employments that required large modulation depth (MD). The LBM is integrated with a variety of the resonant structures in order to boost the interaction between the light and material, and the structures have many types, such as Fano resonant structures shown in Figs. 23(a) and (b). Figures 23(c) and (d) show the photonic crystal cavities, metasurfaces structures, respectively. And the metal plasmonic antenna arrays structures. All these structures are designed to process a Fano or plasmonic resonance at THz or MIR wavelength. Figure 23(a) shows a diagram of adjustable plasmonic equipment possessing 3 dB cutoff frequency of 30 MHz that will be further enhanced to the range of gigahertz (GHz) [
269]. It convinces that the structures of hybrid metal graphene are excellent factors for the production of ultrahigh speed electrical-controllable optoelectronic and optical facilities. Figure 23(b) uses the electrically adjustable interband transitions in graphene to charge the intensity of the plasmonic resonance [
270]. Figure 23(c) shows an all-optical structure [
271]. Due to the possibility of flexibly controlling its complex refractive index, when a pump power is reduced to tens of milliwatts, it will lead to a resonance wavelength shift of 3.5 nm. And these graphene integrated metamaterials exhibit the possibility of modifying both phase and intensity of the light in the interaction between light and materials. As shown in Fig. 23(d) [
272], Bumki
et al. demonstrated that the linear modulation of THz wave and the gating induced sustaining switching can be obtained in a metamaterial, in which the integration of a thin and gated graphene layer is successfully achieved. A THz pump wave is modulated by the intensity change of 47% and phase rotation of 32.2° at the same time, offering the new opportunities for the employment in polarization rotators, thin optical modulators, and nonreciprocal devices.
With the booming studies of these novel materials, including graphene, TMDCs, BP, h-BN, TIs, semimetal materials and various narrow-bandgap semiconductors, they have already been widely researched for different applications including photodetector [
273–
275], biomedical [
276–
280], sensors [
281–
283], battery [
284,
285], and so on. These novel materials show many merits, such as great optical and electric properties, and the prefect nonlinear optical response exhibited with the strong or reverse saturable absorption. These narrow-bandgap emerging materials exhibit excellent elements for the application in the fields of ultrafast photonics and nonlinear optics due to their simple accessibility employing the methods of mechanical exfoliation or liquid phase exfoliation and easy integration of devices. SAs prepared by these various NBMs have obvious differences in the saturable intensity, modulation depth and relaxation time. All these differences rely on the intrinsic and extrinsic characteristics of materials and the fabrication procedures.
According to the above analysis, first of all, from the material band gap, the graphene band gap ranging from 0 to 0.25 eV. MoS2 has a special energy band structure different from graphene, that is, the indirect band gap. Its forbidden band width is 1.29 eV, and the forbidden band width will increase as the number of molybdenum disulfide layers decreases. The band gap of the monolithic MoS2 is 1.8 eV, and the band structure also becomes a direct band gap at this time. Therefore, the monolithic MoS2 is not only a semiconductor material, but also has photocatalytic activity. The band gap of WS2 is 2 eV. The band gap of black phosphorous (BP) can be adjusted from 0.3 eV (multilayer) to 2 eV (single layer), and it is also a material with adjustable band gap. The band gap of PbS is 0.4 eV, and the band gap of Bi is about 0.14 eV. It can be seen that the band gaps of the above materials are very small, which is very suitable for mode-locked pulse lasers. Furthermore, graphene can be used as a saturable absorber to generate pulses ranging from visible light to infrared in pulsed lasers due to its ultra-fast recovery time, ultra-wide nonlinear optical response bandwidth, and super-saturated absorption. Because the exit of edge states and defect states helps MoS2 SA work in near-infrared and MIR, it is possible to describe fiber lasers with wavelengths far exceeding the exciton absorption wavelength. In solid-state lasers based on volumetric cavity, due to the highly unsaturated loss of MoS2 SAs, mode-locked pulses still cannot be generated, but mode-locked pulses can be obtained in fiber lasers. However, the Q-switch produced in the solid-state laser can achieve higher output power and lower repetition rate, which shows that this material is more suitable for realizing the function similar to Q-switch in laser. The narrow band gap and adjustable band gap of black phosphorous (BP) make it very suitable for ultrafast photonics. Therefore, when studying ultrashort pulse fiber lasers, we can find that materials with a narrower band gap are more advantageous in achieving mode-locking performance, because the smaller the band gap is, the larger the range of light absorption will be, and the wider the range of applications for ultrafast photonics.
5 Conclusions and outlook
These novel and flexible NBMs have vast applications in the fields of mode-locker, Q-switcher, modulator, detector, transistor and optical limiter. They have realized short pulses generation based on mode locking and Q-switching both in solid-state and fiber laser. Up to now, the optical modulation based on NBMs has acquired great achievements in many aspects, and covering from theoretical optimal design and analysis, the preparation of the materials, the integration methods between materials and devices to the structures of modulator. These results indicate the excellent opportunities of employing NBMs for many types of optical modulation, such as free space optical modulation, fiber-based amplitude modulation, and fiber-based phase modulation.
The materials discussed in this article are all narrow band gap materials with very excellent nonlinear optical properties. However, each material also has its own morphology, such as light absorption intensity and element composition. These factors all directly or indirectly affect its scope of application. These characteristics of the material can be observed through its characterization results. The narrow band gap material studied in this article also has excellent light absorption properties, and the smaller the band gap the material has, the larger the absorption spectrum and the wider the application range of ultrafast photonics. Therefore, materials with a narrow band gap are more suitable for infrared ultrafast photonics applications.
Nevertheless, the studies are focused on the characteristics of these NBMs, while as for the practical applications are still a vast challenge. The biggest challenge in commercial SAs exists in long term stability of these NBMs, particular under the operation of high pump power. But the intelligent structures of laser partly figure out this problem. For a more thorough solution, we can add organic modification materials on the surface of the material. The SAs made of phosphorous, chalcogenides or the polymers like polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) and polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) should avoid the thermal damage and oxidization. Thermal damage will affect the thermal shock resistance of the material, and oxidation will change some properties of the material. In order to prevent thermal damage and oxidation of materials, we need to passivate the materials. Although BP as a novel family member of NBMs has superior photoelectric characteristics, the low environmental stability is one of the biggest adverse factors restricting its practical application, and it is also an important research topic in the field of these NBMs. Therefore, not all narrow band gap materials are suitable for fiber lasers. When we use a material, we should make full investigation to determine whether the material is suitable for the desired effect according to its characteristics.
It is one of the most significant research directions to study and apply the nonlinear optical features of these novel NBMs as SA in laser pulse generation and modulation. This field has obtained fruitful achievements, but there are still some problems to be solved at the same time, including how to enhance the laser-induced damage threshold of NBMs (especially TMDCs, TIs, and BP) and environmental stability in the process of application, and integration with fiber optic devices more effectively in the applications of fiber laser. These are all topics that need further studies in near future.