Recent progress in econophysics: Chaos, leverage, and business cycles as revealed by agent-based modeling and human experiments

Abstract

Agent-based modeling and controlled human experiments serve as two fundamental research methods in the field of econophysics. Agent-based modeling has been in development for over 20 years, but how to design virtual agents with high levels of human-like “intelligence” remains a challenge. On the other hand, experimental econophysics is an emerging field; however, there is a lack of experience and paradigms related to the field. Here, we review some of the most recent research results obtained through the use of these two methods concerning financial problems such as chaos, leverage, and business cycles. We also review the principles behind assessments of agents’ intelligence levels, and some relevant designs for human experiments. The main theme of this review is to show that by combining theory, agent-based modeling, and controlled human experiments, one can garner more reliable and credible results on account of a better verification of theory; accordingly, this way, a wider range of economic and financial problems and phenomena can be studied.

Keywords

agent-based modeling / controlled human experiment / minority game / econophysics / chaos / leverage / business cycle

References

[1] H. E.Stanley, V.Afanasyev, L. A. N.Amaral, S. V.Buldyrev, A. L.Goldberger,S.Havlin, H.Leschhorn, P.Maass, R. N.Mantegna, C.Peng, P. A.Prince, M. A.Salinger, M. H. R.Stanley, and G. M.Viswanathan, Anomalous fluctuations in the dynamics of complex systems: From DNA and physiology to econophysics, Physica A224(1–2), 302 (1996)

[2] J. P.Huang, Experimental econophysics: Complexity, self-organization, and emergent properties, Phys. Rep. 564, 1 (2015)

[3] H. E.Stanley, Scaling, universality, and renormalization: Three pillars of modern critical phenomena, Rev. Mod. Phys. 71(2), S358(1999)

[4] M. H. R.Stanley, L. A. N.Amaral, S. V.Buldyrev, S.Havlin, H.Leschhorn, P.Maass, M. A.Salinger, and H. E.Stanley, Scaling behavior in the growth of companies, Nature379(6568), 804(1996)

[5] R. N.Mantegnaand H. E.Stanley, Scaling behaviour in the dynamics of an economic index, Nature376(6535), 46(1995)

[6] D.Challetand Y. C.Zhang, Emergence of cooperation and organization in an evolutionary game, Physica A246(3–4), 407(1997)

[7] D.Challetand Y. C.Zhang, On the minority game: Analytical and numerical studies, Physica A256(3–4), 514(1998)

[8] D.Challet, M.Marsili, and Y. C.Zhang, Modeling market mechanism with minority game, Physica A276(1–2), 284(2000)

[9] D.Challetand M.Marsili, Phase transition and symmetry breaking in the minority game, Phys. Rev. E60(6), R6271(1999)

[10] D.Challet, M.Marsili, and R.Zecchina, Statistical Mechanics of Systems with Heterogeneous Agents: Minority Games, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84(8), 1824(2000)

[11] R. N.Mantegna, and H. E.Stanley, Introduction to Econophysics: Correlations and Complexity in Finance, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000

[12] N. F.Johnson, P.Jefferies, andP. M.Hui, Financial Market Complexity, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003

[13] D.Challet, M.Marsili, and Y. C.Zhang, Minority Games: Interacting Agents in Financial Markets, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005

[14] J.Voit, The Statistical Mechanics of Financial Markets, Berlin: Springer, 2005

[15] A.Chakraborti, I. M.Toke, M.Patriarca, and F.Abergel, Econophysics review (I): Empirical facts, Quant. Finance11(7), 991(2011)

[16] A.Chakraborti, I. M.Toke, M.Patriarca, and F.Abergel, Econophysics review (II): Agent-based models, Quant. Finance11(7), 1013(2011)

[17] D.Sornette, Physics and financial economics (1776– 2014): Puzzles, Ising and agent-based models, Rep. Prog. Phys. 77(6), 062001(2014)

[18] D. C.Rapaport, The Art of Molecular Dynamics Simulation, 2nd Ed., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004

[19] D. P.Landauand K.Binder, A Guide to Monte Carlo Simulations in Statistical Physics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014

[20] K.Binderand D.Heermann, Monte Carlo Simulation in Statistical Physics: An Introduction, 5th Ed., Berlin: Springer, 2010

[21] L.Tesfatsionand K. L.Judd(Eds.), Handbook of Computational Economics: Agent-based Computational Economics (Vol. 2), Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2006

[22] A model approach, Nature460(7256), 667(2009)

[23] M.Niaziand A.Hussain, Agent-based tools for modeling and simulation of self-organization in peer-to-peer, ad hoc, and other complex networks, IEEE Commun. Mag. 47(3), 166(2009)

[24] E.Bonabeau, Agent-based modeling: Methods and techniques for simulating human systems, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA99(Suppl. 3), 7280(2002)

[25] N.Gilbertand K. G.Troitzsch, Simulation for the Social Scientist, Buckingham: Open University Press, 1999

[26] D.Samuelson, Designing organizations, OR/MS Today27, 6 (2000)

[27] D.Samuelson, Agents of change, OR/MS Today32, 26(2005)

[28] D. A.Samuelsonand C. M.Macal, Agent-based modeling comes of age, OR/MS Today33, 34(2006)

[29] R.Sun, Cognition and Multi-agent Interaction: From Cognitive Modeling to Social Simulation, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006

[30] R.Awwad, S.Asgari, and A.Kandil, Developing a virtual laboratory for construction bidding environment using agent-based modeling, J. Comput. Civ. Eng. 29(6), 04014105(2015)

[31] L.Tesfatsion, Agent-based computational economics: Growing economies from the bottom up, Artif. Life8(1), 55(2002)

[32] R. M.Axelrod, The Complexity of Cooperation: Agent-based Models of Competition and Collaboration, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1997

[33] W. A.Brockand C. H.Hommes, A rational route to randomness, Econometrica65(5), 1059(1997)

[34] R.Leombruniand M.Richiardi, Industry and Labor Dynamics: The Agent-based Computational Economics Approach, Singapore: World Scientific, 2004

[35] W. A.Brock, C. H.Hommes, andF. O. O.Wagener, More hedging instruments may destabilize markets, J. Econ. Dyn. Control33(11), 1912(2009)

[36] J. D.Farmerand D.Foley, The economy needs agentbased modelling, Nature460(7256), 685(2009)

[37] M.Holcombe, S.Coakley, M.Kiran, S.Chin, C.Greenough, D.Worth, S.Cincotti, M.Raberto, A.Teglio, C.Deissenberg, S.van der Hoog, H.Dawid, S.Gemkow, P.Harting, and M.Neugart, Large-scale modeling of economic systems, Complex Syst. 22, 175(2013)

[38] D.Colander, P.Howitt, A.Kirman, A.Leijonhufvud, and P.Mehrling, Beyond DSGE models: Toward an empirically based macroeconomics, Am. Econ. Rev. 98(2), 236(2008)

[39] T.Płatkowskiand M.Ramsza, Playing minority game, Physica A323, 726(2003)

[40] S. H.Kellert, In the Wake of Chaos: Unpredictable Order in Dynamical Systems, Chicago: University of Chicago press, 1994

[41] C.Werndl, What are the new implications of chaos for unpredictability? Br. J. Philos. Sci.60(1), 195(2009)

[42] C.Kyrtsouand W. C.Labys, Evidence for chaotic dependence between US inflation and commodity prices, J. Macroecon. 28(1), 256(2006)

[43] C.Kyrtsouand W. C.Labys, Detecting positive feedback in multivariate time series: The case of metal prices and US inflation, Physica A377(1), 227(2007)

[44] D.Hristu-Varsakelisand C.Kyrtsou, Evidence for nonlinear asymmetric causality in US inflation, metal, and stock returns, Discrete Dyn. Nat. Soc. 2008, 1 (2008)

[45] C.Kyrtsouand M.Terraza, Is it possible to study chaotic and ARCH behaviour jointly? Application of a noisy Mackey–Glass equation with heteroskedastic errors to the Paris Stock Exchange returns series, Comput. Econ. 21(3), 257(2003)

[46] L. A.Safonov, E.Tomer, V. V.Strygin, Y.Ashkenazy, and S.Havlin, Multifractal chaotic attractors in a system of delay-differential equations modeling road traffic, Chaos12(4), 1006(2002)

[47] E. F.Brighamand J. F.Houston, Fundamentals of Financial Management, Boston: Cengage Learning, 2012

[48] F.Saita, Value at Risk and Bank Capital Management: Risk Adjusted Performances, Capital Management and Capital Allocation Decision Making, New York:Academic Press, 2010

[49] P. M.Madhani, Rebalancing fixed and variable pay in a sales organization: A business cycle perspective, Compens. Benefits Rev. 42(3), 179(2010)

[50] H.Levy, M.Levy, and S.Solomon, Microscopic Simulation of Financial Markets: From Investor Behavior to Market Phenomena, New York: Academic Press, 2000

[51] S. M.de Oliveira, P. M. C.de Oliveira, and D.Stauffer, Evolution, Money, War, and Computers: Non- Traditional Applications of Computational Statistical Physics, Stuttgart-Leipzig: Teubner, 1999

[52] J. M.Epstein,Generative Social Science: Studies in Agent-Based Computational Modeling, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2007

[53] M. A.Niaziand A.Hussain, Cognitive Agent-based Computing-I: A Unified Framework for Modeling Complex Adaptive Systems Using Agent-based & Complex Network-based Methods, Berlin: Springer, 2012

[54] H. A.Simon, The Sciences of the Artificial, Cambridge: MIT Press, 1996

[55] J. M.Galán, L. R.Izquierdo, S. S.Izquierdo, J. I.Santos, R.Del Olmo, A.López-Paredes, and B.Edmonds, Errors and artefacts in agent-based modelling, JASSS-J ARTIF SOC S12, 1 (2009)

[56] J. P.Huang, Econophysics: Using the Methods and Ideas of Physics to Discuss some Economic or Financial Problems, Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2013(in Chinese)

[57] W. B.Arthur, Inductive reasoning and bounded rationality, Am. Econ. Rev. 84, 406(1994)

[58] H.Gintis, Game Theory Evolving: A Problem-centered Introduction to Modeling Strategic Behavior, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000

[59] P.Jefferies, M. L.Hart, P. M.Hui, and N. F.Johnson, From market games to real-world markets, Eur. Phys. J. B20(4), 493(2001)

[60] D.Challet, M.Marsili, and Y. C.Zhang, Stylized facts of financial markets and market crashes in Minority Games, Physica A294(3–4), 514(2001)

[61] K. F.Yip, P. M.Hui, T. S.Lo, and N. F.Johnson, Efficient resource distribution in a minority game with a biased pool of strategies, Physica A321(1–2), 318(2003)

[62] T.Chmuraand T.Pitz, Successful strategies in repeated minority games, Physica A363(2), 477(2006)

[63] J.Kimand T.Wilhelm, What is a complex graph? Physica A387(11), 2637(2008)

[64] A. L.Barabási, R.Albert, and A.Wood, Emergence of scaling in random networks, Science286(5439), 509(1999)

[65] D. J.Wattsand S. H.Strogatz, Collective dynamics of “small-world” networks, Nature393(6684), 440(1998)

[66] L. A. N.Amaral, A.Scala, M.Barthelemy, and H. E.Stanley, Classes of small-world networks, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA97(21), 11149(2000)

[67] A.Majdandzic, B.Podobnik, S. V.Buldyrev, D. Y.Kenett, S.Havlin, and H.Eugene Stanley, Spontaneous recovery in dynamical networks, Nat. Phys. 10(1), 34(2013)

[68] D. Q.Li, B. W.Fu, Y. P.Wang, G. Q.Lu, Y.Berezin, H. E.Stanley, and S.Havlin, Percolation transition in dynamical traffic network with evolving critical bottlenecks, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA112(3), 669(2015)

[69] S. V.Buldyrev, R.Parshani, G.Paul, H. E.Stanley, and S.Havlin, Catastrophic cascade of failures in interdependent networks, Nature464(7291), 1025(2010)

[70] R.Parshani, S. V.Buldyrev, and S.Havlin, Interdependent networks: Reducing the coupling strength leads to a change from a first to second order percolation transition, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105(4), 048701(2010)

[71] Y. W.Chen, L. F.Zhang, and J. P.Huang, The Watts– Strogatz network model developed by including degree distribution: Theory and computer simulation, J. Phys. A40(29), 8237(2007)

[72] G.Yang, Y.Chen, and J. P.Huang, The highly intelligent virtual agents for modeling financial markets, Physica A443, 98(2016)

[73] T.Preis, H. S.Moat, H. E.Stanley, and S. R.Bishop, Quantifying the advantage of looking forward, Sci. Rep. 2, 350(2012)

[74] C. H.Yeung, K. Y. M.Wong, and Y. C.Zhang, Models of financial markets with extensive participation incentives, Phys. Rev. E77(2), 026107(2008)

[75] L. X.Zhong, D. F.Zheng, B.Zheng, and P. M.Hui, Effects of contrarians in the minority game, Phys. Rev. E72(2), 026134(2005)

[76] O. P.Hauser, D. G.Rand, A.Peysakhovich, and M. A.Nowak, Cooperating with the future, Nature511(7508), 220(2014)

[77] S.Biswas, A.Ghosh, A.Chatterjee, T.Naskar, and B. K.Chakrabarti, Continuous transition of social efficiencies in the stochastic-strategy minority game, Phys. Rev. E85(3), 031104(2012)

[78] B.Zheng, T.Qiu, and F.Ren, Two-phase phenomena, minority games, and herding models, Phys. Rev. E69(4), 046115(2004)

[79] M.Anghel, Z.Toroczkai, K. E.Bassler, and G.Korniss, Competition-driven network dynamics: Emergence of a scale-free leadership structure and collective efficiency, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92(5), 058701(2004)

[80] D.Challetand M.Marsili, Criticality and market efficiency in a simple realistic model of the stock market, Phys. Rev. E68(3), 036132(2003)

[81] W.Wang, Y.Chen, and J. P.Huang, Heterogeneous preferences, decision-making capacity, and phase transitions in a complex adaptive system, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA106(21), 8423(2009)

[82] X. H.Li, G.Yang, and J. P.Huang, Chaotic-periodic transition in a two-sided minority game, Front. Phys. 11(4), 118901(2016)

[83] J. C.RochetandJ.Tirole, Platform competition in twosided markets, J. Eur. Econ. Assoc. 1(4), 990(2003)

[84] G. G.Parkerand M. W.Van Alstyne, Two-sided network effects: A theory of information product design, Manage. Sci. 51(10), 1494(2005)

[85] Y.Zhangand W. H.Wan, States and transitions in mixed networks, Front. Phys. 9(4), 523(2014)

[86] Y. H.Chen, W.Wu, G. C.Liu, H. S.Tao, and W. M.Liu, Quantum phase transition of cold atoms trapped in optical lattices, Front. Phys. 7(2), 223(2012)

[87] Y.Liangand J. P.Huang, Robustness of critical points in a complex adaptive system: Effects of hedge behavior, Front. Phys. 8(4), 461(2013)

[88] B. B.Mandelbrotand J. W.Van Ness, Fractional Brownian motions, fractional noises and applications, SIAM Rev. 10(4), 422(1968)

[89] P.Bak, C.Tang, and K.Wiesenfeld, Self-organized criticality: An explanation of the 1/fnoise, Phys. Rev. Lett. 59(4), 381(1987)

[90] F. S.Gharehchopoghand Z. A.Dizaji, A new chaos agent based approach in prediction of the road accidents with hybrid of PSO optimization and chaos optimization algorithms: A case study, Int. J. Acad. Res. 6(2), 108(2014)

[91] S.Das, D.Goswami, S.Chatterjee, and S.Mukherjee, Stability and chaos analysis of a novel swarm dynamics with applications to multi-agent systems, Eng. Appl. Artif. Intell. 30, 189(2014)

[92] T.Yang, Z.Meng, D.Dimarogonas, and K.Johansson, Periodic behaviors for discrete-time second-order multiagent systems with input saturation constraints, IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst., II Express Briefs63(7), 663(2016)

[93] S.Kalemli-Ozcan, B.Sorensen, and S.Yesiltas,Leverage across firms, banks, and countries, J. Int. Econ. 88(2), 284(2012)

[94] T.Adrianand H. S.Shin, Liquidity and leverage, J. Financ. Intermed. 19(3), 418(2010)

[95] R.Kollmannand S.Zeugner, Leverage as a predictor for real activity and volatility, J. Econ. Dyn. Control36(8), 1267(2012)

[96] H.Jinand X. Y.Zhou, Greed, leverage, and potential losses: A prospect theory perspective, Math. Finance23(1), 122(2013)

[97] F.Coricelli, N.Driffield, S.Pal, and I.Roland, When does leverage hurt productivity growth? A firm-level analysis, J. Int. Money Finance31(6), 1674(2012)

[98] L.Lang, E.Ofek, and R.Stulz, Leverage, investment, and firm growth, J. Financ. Econ. 40(1), 3 (1996)

[99] R. R.Chen, N. K.Chidambaran, M. B.Imerman, and B. J.Sopranzetti, Liquidity, leverage, and Lehman: A structural analysis of financial institutions in crisis, J. Bank. Finance45, 117(2014)

[100] S.Thurner, J. D.Farmer, and J.Geanakoplos, Leverage causes fat tails and clustered volatility, Quant. Finance12(5), 695(2012)

[101] J.Carmassi, D.Gros, and S.Micossi, The global financial crisis: Causes and cures, J. Common Mark. Stud. 47(5), 977(2009)

[102] V. V.AcharyaandS.Viswanathan, Leverage, moral hazard, and liquidity, J. Finance66(1), 99(2011)

[103] A.FostelandJ.Geanakoplos, Leverage cycles and the anxious economy, Am. Econ. Rev. 98(4), 1211(2008)

[104] S.Poledna, S.Thurner, J. D.Farmer, and J.Geanakoplos, Leverage-induced systemic risk under Basle II and other credit risk policies, J. Bank. Finance42, 199(2014)

[105] I.Kiemaand E.Jokivuolle, Does a leverage ratio requirement increase bank stability? J. Bank. Finance39, 240(2014)

[106] G.Yang, C. G.Zhu, K. N.An, and J. P.Huang, Overall fluctuations and fat tails in an artificial financial market: The two-sided impact of leveraged trading, Phys. Lett. A379(34–35), 1857(2015)

[107] R.Contand J. P.Bouchaud, Herd behavior and aggregate fluctuations in financial markets, Macroecon. Dyn. 4(02), 170(2000)

[108] J. D.Farmer, Market force, ecology and evolution, Ind. Corp. Change11(5), 895(2002)

[109] R.Cont, Empirical properties of asset returns: stylized facts and statistical issues, Quant. Finance1(2), 223(2001)

[110] C. G.Zhu, G.Yang, K. N.An, and J. P.Huang, The leverage effect on wealth distribution in a controllable laboratory stock market, PLoS One9(6), e100681(2014)

[111] C.Aymannsand J. D.Farmer, The dynamics of the leverage cycle, J. Econ. Dyn. Control50, 155(2015)

[112] T.Breuer, M.Jandačka, M.Summer, and H. J.Vollbrecht, Endogenous leverage and asset pricing in double auctions, J. Econ. Dyn. Control53, 144(2015)

[113] T.Fischerand J.Riedler, Prices, debt and market structure in an agent-based model of the financial market, J. Econ. Dyn. Control48, 95(2014)

[114] K. S.Korolevand D. R.Nelson, Competition and cooperation in one-dimensional Stepping-Stone models, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107(8), 088103(2011)

[115] S. A.West, I.Pen, and A. S.Griffin, Cooperation and competition between relatives, Science296(5565), 72(2002)

[116] E.Elliottand L. D.Kiel, Exploring cooperation and competition using agent-based modeling, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA99(Suppl.3), 7193(2002)

[117] M.Anghel, Z.Toroczkai, K. E.Bassler, and G.Korniss, Competition-driven network dynamics: Emergence of a scale-free leadership structure and collective efficiency, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92(5), 058701(2004)

[118] P.Liand H. B.Duan, Robustness of cooperation on scale-free networks in the evolutionary prisoner’s dilemma game, EPL105(4), 48003(2014)

[119] M.Assaf, M.Mobilia, and E.Roberts, Cooperation dilemma in finite populations under fluctuating environments, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111(23), 238101(2013)

[120] A.Szolnoki, A.Antonioni, M.Tomassini, and M.Perc, Binary birth-death dynamics and the expansion of cooperation by means of self-organized growth, EPL105(4), 48001(2014)

[121] C. M.Song, Z. H.Qu, N.Blumm, and A. L.Barabási, Limits of predictability in human mobility, Science327(5968), 1018(2010)

[122] X. H.Li, G.Yang, K. N.An, and J. P.Huang, Human behavioral regularity, fractional Brownian motion, and exotic phase transition, Phys. Lett. A380(37), 2912(2016)

[123] N.Xi, P.Ormerod, and Y. G.Wang, Technological innovation, business cycles and self-organized criticality in market economies, EPL97(6), 68005(2012)

[124] S.Gualdi, J. P.Bouchaud, G.Cencetti, M.Tarzia, and F.Zamponi, Endogenous crisis waves: Stochastic model with synchronized collective behavior, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114(8), 088701(2015)

[125] M.Ciccarelliand B.Mojon, Global inflation, Rev. Econ. Stat. 92(3), 524(2010)

[126] A. W.Bowmanand A.Azzalini, Applied Smoothing Techniques for Data Analysis, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997

[127] N. S.Altman, An introduction to kernel and nearestneighbor nonparametric regression, Am. Stat. 46, 175(1992)

[128] P.Bak, C.Tang, and K.Wiesenfeld, Self-organized criticality: An explanation of the 1/fnoise, Phys. Rev. Lett. 59(4), 381(1987)

[129] B. D.Malamudand D. L.Turcotte, Self-affine time series: Measures of weak and strong persistence, J. Stat. Plan. Inference80(1–2), 173(1999)

[130] M.Niemann, H.Kantz, and E.Barkai, Fluctuations of 1/fnoise and the low-frequency cutoff paradox, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110(14), 140603(2013)

[131] A.Godecand R.Metzler, Linear response, fluctuationdissipation, and finite-system-size effects in superdiffusion, Phys. Rev. E88(1), 012116(2013)

[132] T.Qiu, Z. K.Zhang, and G.Chen, Information filtering via a scaling-based function, PLoS One8(5), e63531(2013)

[133] M. S.Taqqu, V.Teverovsky, and W.Willinger, Estimators for long-range dependence: An empirical study, Fractals03(04), 785(1995)

[134] E. J.Erlingsson, A.Teglio, S.Cincotti, H.Stefansson, J. T.Sturluson, and M.Raberto, Housing market bubbles and business cycles in an agent-based credit economy, Economics8, 1 (2014)

[135] R.Grilli, G.Tedeschi, and M.Gallegati, Markets connectivity and financial contagion, J. Econ. Interact. Coord. 10(2), 287(2015)

[136] J. P.Huang, Experimental Econophysics: Properties and Mechanisms of Laboratory Markets, Berlin: Springer, 2015

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2017 Higher Education Press and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg