Similitude design for the vibration problems of plates and shells: A review

Abstract

Similitude design plays a vital role in the analysis of vibration and shock problems encountered in large engineering equipment. Similitude design, including dimensional analysis and governing equation method, is founded on the dynamic similitude theory. This study reviews the application of similitude design methods in engineering practice and summarizes the major achievements of the dynamic similitude theory in structural vibration and shock problems in different fields, including marine structures, civil engineering structures, and large power equipment. This study also reviews the dynamic similitude design methods for thin-walled and composite material plates and shells, including the most recent work published by the authors. Structure sensitivity analysis is used to evaluate the scaling factors to attain accurate distorted scaling laws. Finally, this study discusses the existing problems and the potential of the dynamic similitude theory for the analysis of vibration and shock problems of structures.

Key words： review; dynamic; similitude; vibration; model test

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the National Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 11572082), the Excellent Talents Support Program in Institutions of Higher Learning in Liaoning Province of China (Grant No. LJQ2015038), the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities of China (Grant Nos. N150304004 and N140301001), and the Key Laboratory for Precision & Non-traditional Machining of Ministry of Education, Dalian University of Technology (Grant No. JMTZ201602).

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest, including specific financial interests and relationships relevant to the subject of this paper.

References

1 Harris H G, Sabnis G. Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 1999

2 Ramu M, Prabhu R V, Thyla P R. Development of structural similitude and scaling laws for elastic models. Thematic Orientation of the Journal Manufacturing Engineering, 2011, 67–69

3 Simitses G J, Starnes Jr J H, Rezaeepazhand J. Structural similitude and scaling laws for plates and shells: A review. In: Durban D, Givoli D, Simmonds J G, eds. Advances in the Mechanics of Plates and Shells. Springer Netherlands, 2001, 295–310

4 Bažant Z P. Size effect on structural strength: A review. Archive of Applied Mechanics, 1999, 69(9 – 10): 703–725

5 Bažant Z P. Size effect. International Journal of Solids and Structures, 2000, 37(1 – 2): 69–80

6 Galilei G, Weston J. Mathematical Discourses Concerning Two New Sciences Relating to Mechanicks and Local Motion : In Four Dialogues. Printed for John Hooke, at the Flower-de-Luce Against St. Dunstan’s Church in Fleet-Street. London, 1730

7 Buckingham E. On physically similar systems, illustrations of the use of dimensional equations. Physical Review, 1914, 4(4): 345–376

8 Dieterich J S. Scale Models in Engineering Fundamental and Applications. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1977

9 Birkhoff G. Mathematics for engineers—III: Dimensional analysis of partial differential equations. Electrical Engineering, 1948, 67(12): 1185–1188

10 Langhaar H L. Dimensional Analysis and Theory of Models. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1951

11 Buckingham E. The principle of similitude. Nature, 1915, 96: 396–397

12 Goodier J N. Dimensional Analysis. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1950, 1035–1045

13 Wissmann J W. Dynamic Stability of Space Vehicles Structural Dynamics Model Testing. National Aeronautics and Space Administration Technical Report NASA CR-1195. 1968

14 Macagno E O. Historico-critical review of dimensional analysis. Journal of the Franklin Institute, 1971, 292(6): 391–402

15 Szues E. Similitude and Modeling. Elsevier, 2012

16 David F W, Butterworths N H. Experimental Modeling in Engineering. Elsevier, 2013

17 Wissmann J W. Dynamic Stability of Space Vehicles Structural Dynamics Model Testing. National Aeronautics and Space Administration Technical Report NASA CR-1195. 1968

18 Krayterman B, Sabnis G M. Similitude theory: Plates and shells analysis. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 1984, 110(9): 1247–1263

19 Torkamani S, Jafari A A, Navazi H M. Scaled down models for free vibration analysis of orthogonally stiffened cylindrical shells using similitude theory. In: Proceedings of 26th Congress of International Council of the Aeronautical Sciences. 2008

20 Torkamani S, Navazi H M, Jafari A A, Structural similitude in free vibration of orthogonally stiffened cylindrical shells. Thin-walled Structures, 2009, 47(11): 1316–1330

21 Ramu M, Prabhu Raja V, Thyla P R. Establishment of structural similitude for elastic models and validation of scaling laws. KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering, 2013, 17(1): 139–144

22 Kline S J. Similitude and Approximation Theory. New York: McGraW-Hill, 1965

23 Szücs E. Fundamental Studies in Engineering (II), Similitude and Modeling. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1980, 138

24 Wu J J. Dynamic analysis of a rectangular plate under a moving line load using scale-beams and scaling laws. Composite Structures, 2005, 83(19 – 20): 1646–1658

25 Morton J. Scaling of impact loaded carbon-fibre composites. AIAA Journal, 1988, 26(8): 989–994

26 Simitses G J, Rezaeepazhand J. Structural Similitude and Scaling Laws for Laminated Beam-plates. NASA Technical Report NASA-CR-190585. 1992

27 Kure K. Model tests with ocean structures. Applied Ocean Research, 1981, 3(4): 171–176

28 Adrezin R, Bar-Avi P, Benaroya H. Dynamic response of compliant offshore structures—Review. Journal of Aerospace Engineering, 1996, 9(4): 114–131

29 Vassalos D. Physical modelling and similitude of marine structures. Ocean Engineering, 1998, 26(2): 111–123

30 Winsor F. Evaluation of methods to remove inertial force from measured model wave impact force signals. Ocean Engineering, 2003, 30(1): 47–84

31 Asgarian B, Mohebbinejad A, Soltani R H. Simplified method to assess dynamic response of jacket type offshore platforms subjected to wave loading. In: Proceedings of ASME 2004 23rd International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering. Vancouver, 2004, 685–692

32 Ou J, Long X, Li Q, Vibration control of steel jacket offshore platform structures with damping isolation systems. Engineering Structures, 2007, 29(7): 1525–1538

33 Elshafey A A, Haddara M R, Marzouk H. Dynamic response of offshore jacket structures under random loads. Marine Structures, 2009, 22(3): 504–521

34 Sutherland L S, Guedes Soares C. Scaling of impact on low fibre-volume glass-polyester laminates. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing, 2007, 38(2): 307–317

35 Bachynski E E, Motley M R, Young Y L. Dynamic hydroelastic scaling of the underwater shock response of composite marine structures. Journal of Applied Mechanics, 2012, 79(1): 014501–0145 07

36 Aguiar de Souza V, Kirkayak L, Suzuki K, Experimental and numerical analysis of container stack dynamics using a scaled model test. Ocean Engineering, 2012, 39: 24–42

37 Wang S, Yang D, Liu N. Investigation of acoustic scale effects and boundary effects for the similitude model of underwater complex shell-structure. Journal of Marine Science and Application, 2007, 6(1): 31–35

38 Sato J A, Vecchio F J, Andre H M. Scale-model testing of reinforced concrete under impact loading conditions. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 1989, 16(4): 459–466

39 Kim N S, Lee J H, Chang S P. Equivalent multi-phase similitude law for pseudo-dynamic test on small scale reinforced concrete models. Engineering Structures, 2009, 31(4): 834–846

40 Pototzky A S. Scaling laws applied to a modal formulation of the aero servo elastic equations. In: Proceedings of 43rd AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics, and Materials Conference. Denver, 2002 1–11

41 Jordan T L, Hutchinson M A, Watkins V E, National Aeronautics and Space Administration Langley Research Center’s design criteria for small unmanned aerial vehicle development. 2007.

42 Hunt G K. Similarity Requirements for Aero-elastic Models of Helicopter Rotors. Aeronautical Research Council CP 1245. 1973

43 Ghee T A, Kelley H L. Exploratory Flow Visualization Investigation of Mast-mounted Sights in Presence of a Rotor. NASA Technical Report NASA-TM-4634. 1995

44 Wereley N M, Kamath G M. Bringing relevance to freshman aerospace engineering: Demonstration of a model scale Comanche helicopter lag mode damper. International Journal of Engineering Education, 1997, 13(5): 369–375

45 Singleton J D, Yeager W T. Important scaling parameters for testing model-scale helicopter rotors. Journal of Aircraft, 2000, 37(3): 396–402

46 Mixson J S, Catherine J J. Comparison of Experimental Vibration Characteristics Obtained from a 1/5-scale Model and from a Full-scale Saturn sa-1. NASA Technical Report NASA-TN-D-2215. 1964

47 Kunz P J. Aerodynamics and design for ultra-low Reynolds number flight. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Palo Alto: Stanford University, 2003

48 Cagliostro D J, Florence A L, Abrahamson G R. Scale modelling in LMFBR safety. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 1979, 55(2): 235–247

49 Quercetti T, Müller K, Schubert S. Comparison of experimental results from drop testing of spent fuel package design using full scale prototype model and reduced scale model. Packaging, Transport, Storage & Security of Radioactive Material, 2008, 19(4): 197–202

50 Aquaro D, Zaccari N, Di Prinzio M, Numerical and experimental analysis of the impact of a nuclear spent fuel cask. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 2010, 240(4): 706–712

51 Torkamani S, Navazi H M, Jafari A A, et al. Structural similitude in free vibration of orthogonally stiffened cylindrical shells. Thin-walled Structures, 2009, 47(11): 1316–1330

52 Simitses G J. Buckling of moderately thick laminated cylindrical shells: A review. Composites Part B: Engineering, 1996, 27(6): 581–587

53 Rezaeepazhand J, Simitses G J. Use of scaled-down models for predicting vibration response of laminated plates. Composite Structures, 1995, 30(4): 419–426

54 Simitses G J. Structural similitude for flat laminated surfaces. Composite Structures, 2001, 51(2): 191–194

55 Simitses G J, Rezaeepazhand J. Structural similitude and scaling laws for buckling of cross-ply laminated plates. Journal of Thermoplastic Composite Materials, 1995, 8(3): 240–251

56 Singhatanadgid P, Ungbhakorn V. Scaling laws for vibration response of anti-symmetrically laminated plates. Structural Engineering and Mechanics, 2002, 14(3): 345–364

57 Ungbhakorn V, Singhatanadgid P. Similitude invariants and scaling laws for buckling experiments on anti-symmetrically laminated plates subjected to biaxial loading. Composite Structures, 2003, 59(4): 455–465

58 Rezaeepazhand J, Wisnom M R. Scaled models for predicting buckling of delaminated orthotropic beam-plates. Composite Structures, 2009, 90(1): 87–91

59 Rezaeepazhand J, Yazdi A A. Similitude requirements and scaling laws for flutter prediction of angle-ply composite plates. Composites Part B: Engineering, 2011, 42(1): 51–56

60 Yazdi A A, Rezaeepazhand J. Structural similitude for flutter of delaminated composite beam-plates. Composite Structures, 2011, 93(7): 1918–1922

61 Singhatanadgid P, Ungbhakorn V. Scaling laws for vibration response of anti-symmetrically laminated plates. Structural Engineering and Mechanics, 2002, 14(3): 345–364

62 Wu J J. The complete-similitude scale models for predicting the vibration characteristics of the elastically restrained flat plates subjected to dynamic loads. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2003, 268(5): 1041–1053

63 Wu J J. Prediction of the dynamic characteristics of an elastically supported full-size flat plate from those of its complete-similitude scale model. Composite Structures, 2006, 84(3 – 4): 102–114

64 Frostig Y, Simitses G J. Similitude of sandwich panels with a ‘soft’ core in buckling. Composites Part B: Engineering, 2004, 35(6 – 8): 599–608

65 Shokrieh M M, Askari A. Similitude study of impacted composite laminates under buckling loading. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 2013, 139(10): 1334–1340

66 Rezaeepazhand J, Simitses G J, Starnes J H Jr. Scale models for laminated cylindrical shells subjected to axial compression. Composite Structures, 1996, 34(4): 371–379

67 Rezaeepazhand J, Simitses G J. Design of scaled down models for predicting shell vibration response. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1996, 195(2): 301–311

68 Rezaeepazhand J, Simitses G J. Structural similitude for vibration response of laminated cylindrical shells with double curvature. Composites Part B: Engineering, 1997, 28(3): 195–200

69 Ungbhakorn V, Singhatanadgid P. Similitude and physical modeling for buckling and vibration of symmetric cross-ply laminated circular cylindrical shells. Journal of Composite Materials, 2003, 37(19): 1697–1712

70 Ungbhakorn V, Wattanasakulpong N. Structural similitude and scaling laws of anti-symmetric cross-ply laminated cylindrical shells for buckling and vibration experiments. International Journal of Structural Stability and Dynamics, 2007, 07(04): 609–627

71 Chouchaoui C S, Ochoa O O. Similitude study for a laminated cylindrical tube under tension, torsion, bending, internal and external pressure. Part I: Governing equations. Composite Structures, 1999, 44(4): 221–229

72 Chouchaoui C S, Parks P, Ochoa O O. Similitude study for a laminated cylindrical tube under tension, torsion, bending, internal and external pressure. Part II: Scale models. Composite Structures, 1999, 44(4): 231–236

73 Derisi B, Hoa S, Hojjati M. Similitude study on bending stiffness and behavior of composite tubes. Journal of Composite Materials, 2012, 46(21): 2695–2710

74 Yazdi A A. Prediction flutter boundaries of laminated cylindrical shells using scaling laws. Journal of Aerospace Engineering, 2014, 27(1): 86–92

75 Qin G, Duan H, Luo Z, Similitude analysis on mechanical parameters of thin walled shells. Advanced Engineering Forum, 2011, 2–3: 936–941

76 Wen H M, Jones N. Experimental investigation of the scaling laws for metal plates struck by large masses. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1993, 13(3): 485–505

77 Drazetic P, Ravalard Y, Dacheux F, Applying non-direct similitude technique to the dynamic bending collapse of rectangular section tubes. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 1994, 15(6): 797–814

78 Oshiro R E, Alves M. Scaling impacted structures. Archive of Applied Mechanics, 2004, 74(1 – 2): 130–145

79 Alves M, Oshiro R E. Scaling impacted structures when the prototype and the model are made of different materials. International Journal of Solids and Structures, 2006, 43(9): 2744–2760

80 Oshiro R E, Alves M. Scaling of cylindrical shells under axial impact. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2007, 34(1): 89–103

81 Oshiro R E, Alves M. Predicting the behaviour of structures under impact loads using geometrically distorted scaled models. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 2012, 60(7): 1330–1349

82 Trimiño L F, Cronin D S. Non-direct similitude technique applied to the dynamic axial impact of bonded crush tubes. International Journal of Impact Engineering, 2014, 64: 39–52

83 Luo Z, Zhu Y, Zhao X, Determination method of dynamic distorted scaling laws and applicable structure size intervals of a rotating thin-wall short cylindrical shell. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C: Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science, 2015, 229(5): 806–817

84 Luo Z, Wang Y, Zhu Y, The dynamic similitude design method of thin walled structures and experimental validation. Shock and Vibration, 2016, 2016(2016): 1–11

85 Luo Z, Zhu Y, Chen X, Determination method of the structure size intervals of dynamic distorted model of elastic cantilever thin plate. Advances in Mechanical Engineering, 2014, 6(8): 203–212

86 Luo Z, Zhang K, Han Q, Similarity design method of test model of thin-walled short cylindrical shell with complex annular labyrinth. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2013, 49(21): 132–139 (in Chinese)

87 Luo Z, Zhu Y, Wang Y, Study of the structure size interval of incomplete geometrically similitude model of the elastic thin plates. Journal of Measurements in Engineering, 2013, 1(4): 207–218

88 Luo Z, Zhu Y, Chen X, Study of the structure size interval of similar test model of the laminated composite plate. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2013, 33(6): 870–874 (in Chinese)

89 Luo Z, Zhao X, Zhu Y, Determination method of the structure size interval of dynamic similar models for predicting vibration characteristics of the isotropic sandwich plates. Journal of Vibroengineering, 2014, 16(2): 608–622

90 Zhu Y, Luo Z, Zhao X, Determination method of the structure size interval of dynamic similar models for predicting vibration characteristics of the coated thin plates. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C: Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science, 2015, 229(1): 59–68

91 Luo Z, Wang Y, Zhu Y, The similitude design method of thin-walled annular plates and determination of structural size intervals. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C: Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science, 2016, 230(13): 2158–2168

92 Luo Z, Wang Y, Zhai J, Accurate prediction approach of dynamic characteristics for a rotating thin walled annular plate considering the centrifugal stress requirement. Journal of Vibroengineering, 2016, 18(5): 3104–3116

93 Luo Z, Zhu Y, Liu H, Dynamic similitude design method of the distorted model on variable thickness cantilever plates. Applied Sciences, 2016, 6(8): 228–235