A systematic review of current and emergent manipulator control approaches

Abstract

Pressing demands of productivity and accuracy in today’s robotic applications have highlighted an urge to replace classical control strategies with their modern control counterparts. This recent trend is further justified by the fact that the robotic manipulators have complex nonlinear dynamic structure with uncertain parameters. Highlighting the authors’ research achievements in the domain of manipulator design and control, this paper presents a systematic and comprehensive review of the state-of-the-art control techniques that find enormous potential in controlling manipulators to execute cutting-edge applications. In particular, three kinds of strategies, i.e., intelligent proportional-integral-derivative (PID) scheme, robust control and adaptation based approaches, are reviewed. Future trend in the subject area is commented. Open-source simulators to facilitate controller design are also tabulated. With a comprehensive list of references, it is anticipated that the review will act as a first-hand reference for researchers, engineers and industrial-interns to realize the control laws for multi-degree of freedom (DOF) manipulators.

Key words： robot control; robust and nonlinear control; adaptive control; intelligent control; industrial manipulators; robotic arm

Acknowledgements

Special thanks to Raza Ul Islam, Research Associate, CAST, COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Islamabad, Pakistan for his kind help in implementation of various control strategies.

References

1 Khan H, Iqbal J, Baizid K, . Longitudinal and lateral slip control of autonomous wheeled mobile robot for trajectory tracking. Frontiers of Information Technology & Electronic Engineering, 2015, 16(2): 166–172

2 Spong M W, Vidyasagar M. Robot Dynamics and Control. 3rd ed. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 2008

3 Iqbal J, Tsagarakis N G, Fiorilla A E, . A portable rehabilitation device for the hand. In: 2010 Annual International Conference of the IEEE on Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC). Buenos Aires: IEEE, 2010, 3694–3697 doi:10.1109/IEMBS.2010.5627448

4 Iqbal J, Tsagarakis N, Caldwell D. Design optimization of a hand exoskeleton rehabilitation device. In: Proceedings of Workshop on Understanding the Human Hand for Advancing Robotic Manipulation, Robotics Science and Systems (RSS). Seattle, 2009, 44–45

5 Iqbal J, Tsagarakis N G, Caldwell D G. A human hand compatible optimised exoskeleton system. In: 2010 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Biomimetics (ROBIO). Tianjin: IEEE, 2010, 685–690

6 Iqbal J, Tsagarakis N G, Caldwell D G. A multi-DOF robotic exoskeleton interface for hand motion assistance. In: 2011 Annual International Conference of the IEEE on Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC). Boston: IEEE, 2011, 1575–1578

7 Iqbal J, Tsagarakis N, Fiorilla A E, . Design requirements of a hand exoskeleton robotic device. In: 14th IASTED International Conference on Robotics and Applications (RA). Massachusetts, 2009, 44–51

8 Khan A A, un Nabi S R, Iqbal J. Surface estimation of a pedestrian walk for outdoor use of power wheelchair based robot. Life Science Journal, 2013, 10(3): 1697–1704

9 Iqbal J, Tsagarakis N, Caldwell D. Design of a wearable direct-driven optimized hand exoskeleton device. In: Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference on Advances in Computer-Human Interactions (ACHI). Gosier: IARIA, 2011, 142–146

10 Azeem M M, Iqbal J, Toivanen P, . Emotions in robots. In: Chowdhry B S, Shaikh F K, Akbar Hussain D M, , eds. Emerging Trends and Applications in Information Communication Technologies. Berlin: Springer, 2012, 144–153

11 Naveed K, Iqbal J, ur Rahman H. Brain controlled human robot interface. In: 2012 International Conference on Robotics and Artificial Intelligence (ICRAI). Rawalpindi: IEEE, 2012, 55–60

12 Iqbal J, Pasha S M, Baizid K, . Computer vision inspired real-time autonomous moving target detection, tracking and locking. Life Science Journal, 2013, 10(4): 3338–3345

13 Iqbal J, Pasha M, Riaz-un-Nabi, . Real-time target detection and tracking: A comparative in-depth review of strategies. Life Science Journal, 2013, 10(3): 804–813

14 Iqbal J, Heikkila S, Halme A. Tether tracking and control of ROSA robotic rover. In: 10th International Conference on Control, Automation, Robotics and Vision (ICARCV). Hanoi: IEEE, 2008, 689–693

15 Iqbal J, Saad M R, Tahir A M, . State estimation technique for a planetary robotic rover. Revista Facultad de Ingeniería, 2014, 73: 58–68

16 Iqbal J, Tahir A, Islam R U, . Robotics for nuclear power plants—Challenges and future perspectives. In: 2012 2nd International Conference on Applied Robotics for the Power Industry (CARPI). Zurich: IEEE, 2012, 151–156 doi:10.1109/CARPI.2012.6473373

17 Baizid K, Chellali R, Yousnadj A, . Modelling of robotized site and simulation of robot’s optimum placement and orientation zone. In: 21st IASTED International Conference on Modelling and Simulation (MS). Canada, 2010, 9–16

18 Meddahi A, Baizid K, Yousnadj A, . API based graphical simulation of robotized sites. In: IASTED International Conference on Robotics and Applications. Cambridge, 2009, 485–492

19 Groover M P, Weiss M, Nagel R N, . Industrial Robotics: Technology, Programming and Applications. McGraw-Hill Education, 2008

20 Fu K S, Gonzalez R C, Lee C S G. Robotics: Control Sensing Vision and Intelligence. McGraw-Hill Education, 2008

21 Bamdad M. Analytical dynamic solution of a flexible cable-suspended manipulator. Frontiers of Mechanical Engineering, 2013, 8(4): 350–359

22 Baizid K, Yousnadj A, Meddahi A, . Time scheduling and optimization of industrial robotized tasks based on genetic algorithms. Robotics and Computer Integrated Manufacturing, 2015, 34: 140–150

23 Asfahl C. Robots and Manufacturing Automation. 2nd ed. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1992

24 Visioli A. Research trends for PID controllers. Acta Polytechnica, 2012, 52(5): 144–150

25 Blevins T. PID advances in industrial control. In: Preprints IFAC Conference on Advances in PID Control. Brescia, 2012

26 McMillan G K. Industrial applications of PID control. In: Vilanova R, Visioli A, eds. PID Control in the Third Millennium. London: Springer, 2012, 415–461

27 Brogårdh T. Present and future robot control development—An industrial perspective. Annual Reviews in Control, 2007, 31(1): 69–79

28 Brogårdh T. Robot control overview: An industrial perspective. Modeling, Identification and Control, 2009, 30(3): 167–180

29 Khan M F, Iqbal J, Islam R U. Control strategies for robotic manipulators. In: 2012 International Conference on Robotics and Artificial Intelligence (ICRAI). Rawalpindi: IEEE, 2012, 26–33

30 Craig J J. Introduction to Robotics. Addison-Wesley Reading, MA, 2006

31 Liang C, Ceccarelli M. Feasible workspace regions for general two-revolute manipulator. Frontiers of Mechanical Engineering, 2011, 6(4): 397–408

32 Islam R U, Iqbal J, Manzoor S, . An autonomous image—Guided robotic system simulating industrial applications. In: 2012 7th International Conference on System of Systems Engineering (SoSE). Genoa: IEEE, 2012, 344–349

33 Manzoor S, Islam R U, Khalid A, . An open-source multi-DOF articulated robotic educational platform for autonomous object manipulation. Robotics and Computer-integrated Manufacturing, 2014, 30(3): 351–362

34 Álvarez Chavarría J S, Jiménez Builes J A, Ramírez Patiño J F. Design cycle of a robot for learning and the development of creativity in engineering. DYNA, 2011, 78(170): 51–58

35 Ajwad S A, Ullah M I, Islam R U, . Modeling robotic arms-A review and derivation of screw theory based kinematics. In: International Conference on Engineering & Emerging Technologies. Lahore, 2014, 66–69

36 Yime-Rodríguez E, Peña-Cortés C A, Rojas-Contreras W M. The dynamic model of a four control moment gyroscope system. DYNA, 2014, 81(185): 41–47

37 Márton L, Lantos B. Control of robotic systems with unknown friction and payload. IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, 2011, 19(6): 1534–1539

38 Iqbal J, Islam R U, Khan H. Modeling and analysis of a 6 DOF robotic arm manipulator. Canadian Journal on Electrical and Electronics Engineering, 2012, 3(6): 300–306

39 Iqbal J, un Nabi S R, Khan A A, . A novel track-drive mobile robotic framework for conducting projects on robotics and control systems. Journal of Life Science, 2013, 10(3): 130–137

40 Ajwad S A, Iqbal U, Iqbal J. Hardware realization and control of multi-degree of freedom articulated robotic arm. In: Emerging Trends and Applications in Information Communication Technologies, Communications in Computer and Information Science (CCIS). Berlin: Springer2015 (i<?Pub Caret?>n press)

41 Fei Y, Wu Q. Tracking control of robot manipulators via output feedback linearization. Frontiers of Mechanical Engineering in China, 2006, 1(3): 329–335

42 Nagaraj B, Murugananth N. A comparative study of PID controller tuning using GA, EP, PSO and ACO. In: 2010 IEEE International Conference on Communication Control and Computing Technologies (ICCCCT). Ramanathapuram: IEEE, 2010, 305–313

43 Tan W, Liu J, Chen T, . Comparison of some well-known PID tuning formulas. Computers & Chemical Engineering, 2006, 30(9): 1416–1423

44 Foley M W, Julien R H, Copeland B R. A comparison of PID controller tuning methods. Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2005, 83(4): 712–722

45 Iqbal J, Tsagarakis N G, Caldwell D G. Human hand compatible underactuated exoskeleton robotic system. Electronics Letters, 2014, 50(7): 494–496

46 Iqbal J, Khan H, Tsagarakis N G, . A novel exoskeleton robotic system for hand rehabilitation—Conceptualization to prototyping. Biocybernetics and Biomedical Engineering, 2014, 34(2): 79–89

47 Iqbal U, Samad A, Nissa Z, . Embedded control system for AUTAREP—A novel AUTonomous articulated robotic educational platform. Technical Gazette, 2014, 21(6): 1255–1261

48 Ajwad S, Ullah M, Baizid K, . A comprehensive state-of-the-art on control of industrial articulated robots. Journal of the Balkan Tribological Association, 2014, 20(4): 499–521

49 Ullah M I, Ajwad S A, Islam R U, . Modeling and computed torque control of a 6 degree of freedom robotic arm. In: 2014 International Conference on Robotics & Emerging Allied Technologies in Engineering (iCREATE). Islamabad: IEEE, 2014, 133–138

50 Piltan F, Sulaiman N, Jalali A, . Design of model free adaptive fuzzy computed torque controller: Applied to nonlinear second order system. International Journal of Robotics and Automation, 2011, 2(4): 232–244

51 Sharkawy A B, Othman M M, Khalil A M A. A robust fuzzy tracking control scheme for robotic manipulators with experimental verification. Intelligent Control and Automation, 2011, 2(2): 100–111

52 Chen Y, Ma G, Lin S, . Adaptive fuzzy computed-torque control for robot manipulator with uncertain dynamics. International Journal of Advanced Robotic Systems, 2012, 9: 237–245

53 Leines M T, Yang J S. LQR control of an under actuated planar biped robot. In: 2011 6th IEEE Conference on Industrial Electronics and Applications (ICIEA). Beijing: IEEE, 2011, 1684–1689

54 Simmons G, Demiris Y. Optimal robot arm control using the minimum variance model. Journal of Robotic Systems, 2005, 22(11): 677–690

55 Islam R U, Iqbal J, Khan Q. Design and comparison of two control strategies for multi-DOF articulated robotic arm manipulator. Control Engineering and Applied Informatics, 2014, 16(2): 28–39

56 Wai R J, Muthusamy R. Fuzzy-neural-network inherited sliding-mode control for robot manipulator including actuator dynamics. IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks and Learning Systems, 2013, 24(2): 274–287

57 Nabaee A R, Piltan F, Ebrahimi M M, . Design intelligent robust partly linear term SMC for robot manipulator systems. International Journal of Intelligent Systems and Applications, 2014, 6: 58–71

58 Hacioglu Y, Arslan Y Z, Yagiz N. MIMO fuzzy sliding mode controlled dual arm robot in load transportation. Journal of the Franklin Institute, 2011, 348(8): 1886–1902

59 Corradini M L, Fossi V, Giantomassi A, . Discrete time sliding mode control of robotic manipulators: Development and experimental validation. Control Engineering Practice, 2012, 20(8): 816–822

60 Laghrouche S, Mehmood A, Bagdouri M E. Study of the nonlinear control techniques for single acting VGT pneumatic actuator. International Journal of Vehicle Design, 2012, 60(3/4): 264–285

61 Camacho E F, Alba C B. Model Predictive Control. Springer, 2013

62 Wang L. Model Predictive Control System Design and Implementation Using MATLAB®. London: Springer, 2009

63 Henmi T, Deng M, Inoue A. Adaptive control of a two-link planar manipulator using nonlinear model predictive control. In: 2010 International Conference on Mechatronics and Automation (ICMA). Xi’an: IEEE, 2010, 1868–1873

64 Mazdarani H, Farrokhi M. Adaptive neuro-predictive control of robot manipulators in work space. In: 2012 17th International Conference on Methods and Models in Automation and Robotics (MMAR). Miedzyzdrojie: IEEE, 2012, 349–354

65 Rojas–Moreno A, Valdivia–Mallqui R. Embedded position control system of a manipulator using a robust nonlinear predictive control. In: 2013 16th International Conference on Advanced Robotics (ICAR). Montevideo: IEEE, 2013, 1–6

66 Copot C, Lazar C, Burlacu A. Predictive control of nonlinear visual servoing systems using image moments. IET Control Theory & Applications, 2012, 6(10): 1486–1496

67 Wang L, Chai S, Rogers E, . Multivariable repetitive-predictive controllers using frequency decomposition. IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, 2012, 20(6): 1597–1604

68 Gu D W. Robust Control Design with MATLAB®. London: Springer, 2005

69 Montano O E, Orlov Y. Discontinuous H. ∞-control of mechanical manipulators with frictional joints. In: 2012 9th International Conference on Electrical Engineering, Computing Science and Automatic Control (CCE). Mexico City: IEEE, 2012, 1–6

70 Chen C. Robust self-organizing neural-fuzzy control with uncertainty observer for MIMO nonlinear systems. IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems, 2011, 19(4): 694–706

71 Siqueira A A G, Terra M H. Mixed model-based/neural network H∞ impedance control of constrained manipulators. In: IEEE International Conference on Control and Automation (ICCA). Christchurch: IEEE, 2009, 1901–1906

72 Yang Z, Fukushima Y, Qin P. Decentralized adaptive robust control of robot manipulators using disturbance observers. IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, 2012, 20(5): 1357–1365

73 Kim Y, Seok J, Noh I, . An adaptive disturbance observer for a two-link robot manipulator. In: International Conference on Control, Automation and Systems (ICCAS). Seoul: IEEE, 2008, 141–145

74 He Z, Xie W. Improved disturbance observer based control structure. In: Chinese Control and Decision Conference (CCDC). Guilin: IEEE, 2009, 1015–1020

75 Parsa M, Farrokhi M. Robust nonlinear model predictive trajectory free control of biped robots based on nonlinear disturbance observer. In: 2010 18th Iranian Conference on Electrical Engineering (ICEE). Isfahan: IEEE, 2010, 617–622

76 Mohammadi A, Tavakoli M, Marquez H. Disturbance observer-based control of non-linear haptic teleoperation systems. IET Control Theory & Applications, 2011, 5(18): 2063–2074

77 Mohammadi A, Marquez H J, Tavakoli M. Disturbance observer-based trajectory following control of nonlinear robotic manipulators. In: Proceedings of the 23rd Canadian Congress of Applied Mechanics. 2011

78 Mohammadi A, Tavakoli M, Marquez H, . Nonlinear disturbance observer design for robotic manipulators. Control Engineering Practice, 2013, 21(3): 253–267

79 Laghrouche S, Ahmed F S, Mehmood A. Pressure and friction observer-based backstepping control for a VGT pneumatic actuator. IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, 2014, 22(2): 456–467

80 Arimoto S. Passivity-based control [robot dynamics]. In: IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA) (Volume 1). San Francisco: IEEE, 2000, 227–232

81 Shibata T, Murakami T. A null space force control based on passivity in redundant manipulator. In: ICM2007 4th IEEE International Conference on Mechatronics. Kumamoto: IEEE, 2007, 1–6

82 Ott C, Albu-Schaffer A, Kugi A, . On the passivity-based impedance control of flexible joint robots. IEEE Transactions on Robotics, 2008, 24(2): 416–429

83 Kawai H, Murao T, Sato R, . Passivity-based control for 2DOF robot manipulators with antagonistic bi-articular muscles. In: 2011 IEEE International Conference on Control Applications (CCA). Denver: IEEE, 2011, 1451–1456

84 Foudil A, Hadia S. Passivity based control of a 3-DOF robot manipulator. In: International Conference on Communication, Computer & Power (ICCCP). Muscat, 2007, 56–59

85 Bouakrif F, Boukhetala D, Boudjema F. Passivity-based controller-observer for robot manipulators. In: 3rd International Conference on Information and Communication Technologies: From Theory to Applications. Damascus: IEEE, 2008, 1–5

86 Landau I D, Lozano R, M’Saad M, . Adaptive Control: Algorithms, Analysis and Applications. London: Springer, 2011

87 Sun T, Pei H, Pan Y, . Neural network-based sliding mode adaptive control for robot manipulators. Neurocomputing, 2011, 74(14-15): 2377–2384

88 Aseltine J, Mancini A, Sarture C. A survey of adaptive control systems. IRE Transactions on Automatic Control. 1958, 6(1): 102–108

89 Åström K J, Wittenmark B. On self tuning regulators. Automatica, 1973, 9(2): 185–199

90 Slotine J J E, Li W. On the adaptive control of robot manipulators. International Journal of Robotics Research, 1987, 6(3): 49–59

91 Lozano R, Brogliato B. Adaptive control of robot manipulators with flexible joints. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 1992, 37(2): 174–181

92 Huang S, Tan K K, Lee T H. Adaptive friction compensation using neural network approximations. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, Part C: Applications and Reviews, 2000, 30(4): 551–557

93 Purwar S, Kar I N, Jha A N. Adaptive control of robot manipulators using fuzzy logic systems under actuator constraints. In: 2004 IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems (Volume 3). IEEE, 2004, 1449–1454

94 Schindele D, Aschemann H. Adaptive friction compensation based on the LuGre model for a pneumatic rodless cylinder. In: Industrial Electronics, 2009. IECON’09 35th Annual Conference of IEEE. Porto: IEEE, 2009, 1432–1437

95 Garpinger O, Hägglund T, Cederqvist L. Software for PID design: Benefits and pitfalls. In: 2nd IFAC Conference on Advances in PID Control. Brescia, 2012, 2(1): 140–145

96 Jara C A, Candelas F A, Gil P, . Ejs+EjsRL: An interactive tool for industrial robots simulation, computer vision and remote operation. Robotics and Autonomous Systems, 2011, 59(6): 389–401

97 Corke P I. A robotics toolbox for MATLAB. IEEE Robotics & Automation Magazine, 1996, 3(1): 24–32

98 Corke P. Robotics, Vision and Control: Fundamental Algorithms in MATLAB. Berlin: Springer, 2011

99 Falconi R, Melchiorri C. Roboticad: An educational tool for robotics. In: Proceedings of the 17th IFAC World Congress. Korea, 2008, 9111–9116

100 Žlajpah L. Integrated environment for modelling, simulation and control design for robotic manipulators. Journal of Intelligent & Robotic Systems, 2001, 32(2): 219–234

101 Maza J I, Ollero A. HEMERO: A MATLAB-Simulink toolbox for robotics. In: 1st Workshop on Robotics Education and Training. Germany, 2001, 43–50

102 Alsina P J. ROBOTLAB: A software for robot graphic simulation. Simpósio Brasileiro de Automação Inteligente, 1997, 465–470

103 Nethery J F, Spong M W. Robotica: A mathematica package for robot analysis. IEEE Robotics & Automation Magazine, 1994, 1(1): 13–20

104 Dean-Leon E, Nair S, Knoll A. User friendly Matlab-toolbox for symbolic robot dynamic modeling used for control design. In: 2012 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Biomimetics (ROBIO). Guangzhou: IEEE, 2012, 2181–2188

105 Rohmer E, Singh S P, Freese M. V-REP: A versatile and scalable robot simulation framework. In: 2013 IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems (IROS). Tokyo: IEEE, 2013, 1321–1326

106 Breijs A, Klaassens B, Babuska R. Matlab design environment for robotic manipulators. In: 16th IFAC World Congress. Prague, 2005, 1331–1336

107 Shah S V, Nandihal P V, Saha S K. Recursive dynamics simulator (ReDySim): A multibody dynamics solver. Theoretical and Applied Mechanics Letters, 2012, 2: 063011

108 Ferreira N F, Machado J T. RobLib: An educational program for robotics. In: Symposium on Robot Control (SYROCO). Vienna, 2000, 563–568

109 Arm6x Manual. Concurrent Dynamics International, 2014

110 Fueanggan S, Chokchaitam S. Dynamics and kinematics simulation for robots. In: International Association of Computer Science and Information Technology—Spring Conference. Singapore: IEEE, 2009, 136–140