Thermo-optic phase shifters based on silicon-on-insulator platform: state-of-the-art and a review

Abstract

Silicon photonic platforms offer relevance to large markets in many applications, such as optical phased arrays, photonic neural networks, programmable photonic integrated circuits, and quantum computation devices. As one of the basic tuning devices, the thermo-optic phase shifter (TOPS) plays an important role in all these applications. A TOPS with the merits of easy fabrication, low power consumption, small thermal time constant, low insertion loss, small footprint, and low crosstalk, is needed to improve the performance and lower the cost of the above applications. To meet these demands, various TOPS have been proposed and experimentally demonstrated on different foundry platforms In this paper, we review the state-of-the-art of TOPS, including metal heater, doped silicon, silicide, with silicon substrate undercut for heat insulation, folded waveguide structure, and multi-pass waveguide structure. We further compare these TOPSs and propose the directions of the future developments on TOPS.

Key words： Thermo-optic phase shifter; Photonic integrated circuits (PICs); Optical switches; Silicon photonics

References

1 Su, Y., Zhang, Y., Qiu, C., Guo, X., Sun, L.: Silicon photonic platform for passive waveguide devices: materials, fabrication, and applications. Adv. Mater. Technol. 5(8), 1901153 (2020)

2 Rahim, A., Spuesens, T., Baets, R., Bogaerts, W.: Open-access silicon photonics: current status and emerging initiatives. In: Proceedings of the IEEE, pp. 2313–2330. (2018)

3 Rahim, A., Goyvaerts, J., Szelag, B., Fedeli, J.-M., Absil, P., Aalto, T., Harjanne, M., Littlejohns, C., Reed, G., Winzer, G., Lischke, S., Zimmermann, L., Knoll, D., Geuzebroek, D., Leinse, A., Geiselmann, M., Zervas, M., Jans, H., Stassen, A., Domínguez, C., Muñoz, P., Domenech, D., Lena, A., Lemme, M.C., Baets, R.: Open-access silicon photonics platforms in europe. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. 25(5), 1–18 (2019)

4 Shen, Y., Harris, N.C., Skirlo, S., Prabhu, M., Baehr-Jones, T., Hochberg, M., Sun, X., Zhao, S., Larochelle, H., Englund, D., Soljačić, M.: Deep learning with coherent nanophotonic circuits. Nat. Photonics 11(7), 441–446 (2017)

5 Bogaerts, W., Rahim, A.: Programmable photonics: an opportunity for an accessible large-volume PIC ecosystem. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. (2020)

6 Baghdadi, R., Gould, M., Gupta, S., Tymchenko, M., Bunandar, D., Ramey, C., Harris, N.C.: Dual slot-mode NOEM phase shifter. Opt. Express 29(12), 19113–19119 (2021)

7 Kang, G., Kim, S.H., You, J.B., Lee, D.S., Yoo, H., Ha, Y.G., Kim, J.H., Yoo, D.E., Lee, D.W., Youn, C.H., Yu, K.: Silicon-based optical phased array using electro-optic p-i-n phase shifters. IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. 31, 1685–1688 (2019)

8 Quack, N., Sattari, H., Takabayashi, A.Y., Zhang, Y., Verheyen, P., Bogaerts, W., Edinger, P., Errando-Herranz, C., Gylfason, K.B.: MEMS-enabled silicon photonic integrated devices and circuits. IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 56(1), 1–10 (2020)

9 Yamashita, T., Kim, S., Kato, H., Qiu, W., Semba, K., Fujimaki, A., Terai, H.: π phase shifter based on NbN-based ferromagnetic Josephson junction on a silicon substrate. Sci. Rep. 10(1), 13687 (2020)

10 Landry, A., Son, T.V., Haché, A.: Optical modulation at the interface between silicon and a phase change material. Optik (Stuttgart) 209(6), 164585 (2020)

11 Kieninger, C., Füllner, C., Zwickel, H., Kutuvantavida, Y., Kemal, J.N., Eschenbaum, C., Elder, D.L., Dalton, L.R., Freude, W., Randel, S., Koos, C.: Silicon-organic hybrid (SOH） Mach–Zehnder modulators for 100 GBd PAM4 signaling with sub-1 dB phase-shifter loss. Opt. Express 28(17), 24693–24707 (2020)

12 Xie, Y., Shi, Y., Liu, L., Wang, J., Priti, R., Zhang, G., Liboiron-Ladouceur, O., Dai, D.: Thermally-reconfigurable silicon photonic devices and circuits. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. 26(5), 1–20 (2020)

13 Qiao, L., Tang, W., Chu, T.: 32 × 32 silicon electro-optic switch with built-in monitors and balanced-status units. Sci. Rep. 7(1), 42306 (2017)

14 Edinger, P., Errando-Herranz, C., Gylfason, K.B.: Low-loss MEMS phase shifter for large scale reconfigurable silicon photonics. In: 2019 IEEE 32nd International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS). IEEE (2019)

15 Jacques, M., Samani, A., El-Fiky, E., Patel, D., Xing, Z., Plant, D.V.: Optimization of thermo-optic phase-shifter design and miti-gation of thermal crosstalk on the SOI platform. Opt. Express 27(8), 10456–10471 (2019)

16 Campenhout, J.V., Green, W., Assefa, S., Vlasov, Y.A.: Integrated NiSi waveguide heaters for CMOS-compatible silicon thermooptic devices. Opt. Lett. 35(7), 1013–1015 (2010)

17 Qiang, X., Zhou, X., Wang, J., Wilkes, C.M., Loke, T., O’Gara, S., Kling, L., Marshall, G.D., Santagati, R., Ralph, T.C., Wang, J.B., O’Brien, J.L., Thompson, M.G., Matthews, J.C.F.: Largescale silicon quantum photonics implementing arbitrary two-qubit processing. Nat. Photonics 12(9), 534–539 (2018)

18 Priti, R.B., Liboiron-Ladouceur, O.: A broadband rearrangeable non-blocking MZI-based thermo-optic O-band switch in the silicon-on-insulator. In: Advanced Photonics 2017 (IPR, NOMA, Sensors, Networks, SPPCom, PS). Optical Society of America, PM4D–2 (2017)

19 Horst, F., Green, W.M., Assefa, S., Shank, S.M., Vlasov, Y.A., Offrein, B.J.: Cascaded Mach–Zehnder wavelength filters in silicon photonics for low loss and flat pass-band WDM (de-)multi-plexing. Opt. Express 21(10), 11652–11658 (2013)

20 Zhuang, L., Zhu, C., Xie, Y., Burla, M., Roeloffzen, C.G.H., Hoekman, M., Corcoran, B., Lowery, A.J.: Nyquist-filtering (de) multiplexer using ring resonator assisted interferometer circuit. J. Lightwave Technol. 34(8), 1732–1738 (2016)

21 Yu, L., Yin, Y., Shi, Y., Dai, D., He, S.: Thermally tunable silicon photonics microdisk resonator with graphene transparent nanoheaters. Optica 3(2), 159–166 (2016)

22 Guha, B., Cardenas, J., Lipson, M.: Athermal silicon microring resonators with titanium oxide cladding. Opt. Express 21(22), 26557–26563 (2013)

23 Bahadori, M., Gazman, A., Janosik, N., Rumley, S., Zhu, Z., Polster, R., Cheng, Q., Bergman, K.: Thermal rectification of integrated micro heaters for microring resonators in silicon photonics platform. J. Lightwave Technol. 36(3), 773–788 (2018)

24 Pintus, P., Hofbauer, M., Manganelli, C.L., Fournier, M., Gundavarapu, S., Lemonnier, O., Gambini, F., Adelmini, L., Meinhart, C., Kopp, C., Testa, F., Zimmermann, H., Oton, C.J.: PWM-driven thermally tunable silicon microring resonators: design, fabrication, and characterization. Laser Photonics Rev. 13(9), 1800275 (2019)

25 DeRose, C.T., Kekatpure, R.D., Trotter, D.C., Starbuck, A., Wendt, J.R., Yaacobi, A., Watts, M.R., Chettiar, U., Engheta, N., Davids, P.S.: Electronically controlled optical beam-steering by an active phased array of metallic nanoantennas. Opt. Express 21(4), 5198–5208 (2013)

26 Sun, J., Timurdogan, E., Yaacobi, A., Zhan, S., Hosseini, E.S., Cole, D.B., Watts, M.R.: Large-scale silicon photonic circuits for optical phased arrays. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. 20(4), 264–278 (2014)

27 Huang, C., Jha, A., Lima, T.F., Tait, A.N., Shastri, B.J., Prucnal, P.R.: On-chip programmable nonlinear optical signal processor and its applications. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. 99, 1–11 (2020)

28 Sugita, A., Jinguji, K., Takato, N., Katoh, K., Kawachi, M.: Bridge-suspended silica-waveguide thermo-optic phase shifter and its application to Mach–Zehnder type optical switch. IEICE Trans. (1976–1990) 73(1), 105–109 (1990)

29 Gu, J., Zhao, Z., Feng, C., Liu, M., Chen, R.T., Pan, D.Z.: Towards area-efficient optical neural networks: an FFT-based architecture. In: 2020 25th Asia and South Pacific Design Automation Conference (ASP-DAC), pp. 476–481. IEEE (2020)

30 Pour Fard, M.M., Williamson, I.A.D., Edwards, M., Liu, K., Pai, S., Bartlett, B., Minkov, M., Hughes, T.W., Fan, S., Nguyen, T.A.: Experimental realization of arbitrary activation functions for optical neural networks. Opt. Express 28(8), 12138–12148 (2020)

31 Qin, G., Zhu, Q., Su, Y.: Fast wavelength seeking in a silicon dual-ring switch based on artificial neural networks. J. Lightwave Technol. 38(18), 5078–5085 (2020)

32 Wang, J., Bonneau, D., Villa, M., Silverstone, J.W., Santagati, R., Miki, S., Yamashita, T., Fujiwara, M., Sasaki, M., Terai, H., Tanner, M., Natarajan, C.M., Hadfield, R.H., O’Brien, J.L., Thompson, M.G.: Chip-to-chip quantum photonic interconnect by path-polarization interconversion. Optica 3(4), 407–413 (2016)

33 Wang, J., Paesani, S., Ding, Y., Santagati, R., Skrzypczyk, P., Salavrakos, A., Tura, J., Augusiak, R., Mančinska, L., Bacco, D., Bonneau, D., Silverstone, J.W., Gong, Q., Acín, A., Rottwitt, K., Oxenløwe, L.K., O’Brien, J.L., Laing, A., Thompson, M.G.: Multidimensional quantum entanglement with large-scale integrated optics. Science 360(6386), 285–291 (2018)

34 Silverstone, J.W., Bonneau, D., Ohira, K., Suzuki, N., Yoshida, H., Iizuka, N., Ezaki, M., Natarajan, C.M., Tanner, M.G., Hadfield, R.H., Zwiller, V., Marshall, G.D., Rarity, J.G., O’Brien, J.L., Thompson, M.G.: On-chip quantum interference between silicon photon-pair sources. Nat. Photonics 8(2), 104–108 (2014)

35 Chung, S.W., Abediasl, H., Hashemi, H.: A monolithically integrated large-scale optical phased array in silicon-on-insulator CMOS. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 53(1), 275–296 (2018)

36 Van Acoleyen, K., Bogaerts, W., Jágerská, J., Le Thomas, N., Houdré, R., Baets, R.: Off-chip beam steering with a one-dimensional optical phased array on silicon-on-insulator. Opt. Lett. 34(9), 1477–1479 (2009)

37 Chen, S., Shi, Y., He, S., Dai, D.: Compact 8-channel thermally reconfigurable optical add/drop multiplexer on silicon. IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. 28(17), 1874–1877 (2016)

38 Bogaerts, W., Pérez, D., Capmany, J., Miller, D.A.B., Poon, J., Englund, D., Morichetti, F., Melloni, A.: Programmable photonic circuits. Nature 586(7828), 207–216 (2020)

39 Pérez-López, D., López, A., DasMahapatra, P., Capmany, J.: Multipurpose self-configuration of programmable photonic circuits. Nat. Commun. 11(1), 6359 (2020)

40 Liao, S., Ding, Y., Peucheret, C., Yang, T., Dong, J., Zhang, X.: Integrated programmable photonic filter on the silicon-on-insulator platform. Opt. Express 22(26), 31993–31998 (2014)

41 Xie, Y., Zhuang, L., Boller, K.J., Lowery, A.J.: Lossless microwave photonic delay line using a ring resonator with an integrated semiconductor optical amplifier. J. Opt. 19(6), 065802 (2017)

42 Hashizume, Y., Katayose, S., Tsuchizawa, T., Watanabe, T., Itoh, M.: Low-power silicon thermo-optic switch with folded waveguide arms and suspended ridge structures. Electron. Lett. 48(19), 1234–1235 (2012)

43 Densmore, A., Janz, S., Ma, R., Schmid, J.H., Xu, D.X., Delâge, A., Lapointe, J., Vachon, M., Cheben, P.: Compact and low power thermo-optic switch using folded silicon waveguides. Opt. Express 17(13), 10457 (2009)

44 Smith, F., Wang, W., Wang, X., Li, Y., Cheng, X., Wu, H.: A design study of efficiency enhancement in silicon photonic thermo-optic phase shifters. In: 2019 IEEE Optical Interconnects Conference (OI). IEEE (2019)

45 Passaro, V., Magno, F., Tsarev, A.: Investigation of thermo-optic effect and multi-reflector tunable filter/multiplexer in SOI waveguides. Opt. Express 13(9), 3429–3437 (2005)

46 De, S., Das, R., Varshney, R.K., Schneider, T.: Design and simulation of thermo-optic phase shifters with low thermal crosstalk for dense photonic integration. IEEE Access: Pract. Innov. Open Solut. 8, 141632–141640 (2020)

47 Giuseppe, C., Luigi, S., Ivo, R.: Advance in thermo-optical switches: principles, materials, design, and device structure. Opt. Eng. (Redondo Beach, Calif.) 50(7), 071112 (2011)

48 Watts, M.R., Sun, J., DeRose, C., Trotter, D.C., Young, R.W., Nielson, G.N.: Adiabatic thermo-optic Mach–Zehnder switch. Opt. Lett. 38(5), 733–735 (2013)

49 Liu, S., Tian, Y., Li, Y., Feng, G., Guo, J.: Comparison of thermos-optic phase-shifters implemented on CUMEC silicon photonics platform. In: Seventh Symposium on Novel Photo-electronic Detection Technology and Application. (2020)

50 Masood, A., Pantouvaki, M., Lepage, G., Verheyen, P., Van Campenhout, J., Absil, P., Van Thourhout, D., Bogaerts, W.: Comparison of heater architecture for thermal control of silicon photonics circuits. In: IEEE 10th International Conference on Group IV Photonics. IEEE (2013)

51 Harris, N.C., Ma, Y., Mower, J., Baehr-Jones, T., Englund, D., Hochberg, M., Galland, C.: Efficient, compact and low loss thermo-optic phase shifter in silicon. Opt. Express 22(9), 10487–10493 (2014)

52 Fang, Q., Song, J.F., Liow, T.Y., Cai, H., Yu, M.B., Lo, G.Q., Kwong, D.L.: Ultralow power silicon photonics thermo-optic switch with suspended phase arms. IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. 23(8), 525–527 (2011)

53 Lu, Z., Murray, K., Jayatilleka, H., Chrostowski, L.: Michelson interferometer thermo-optic switch on SOI with a 50-µW power consumption. In: 2016 IEEE Photonics Conference (IPC). IEEE (2016)

54 Sun, P., Reano, R.M.: Submilliwatt thermo-optic switches using free-standing silicon-on-insulator strip waveguides. Opt. Express 18(8), 8406–8411 (2010)

55 Yu, H., Ying, D., Pantouvaki, M., Van Campenhout, J., Absil, P., Hao, Y., Yang, J., Jiang, X.: Trade-off between optical modulation amplitude and modulation bandwidth of silicon micro-ring modulators. Opt. Express 22(12), 15178–15189 (2014)

56 Song, J., Fang, Q., Tao, S.H., Liow, T.Y., Yu, M.B., Lo, G.Q., Kwong, D.L.: Fast and low power Michelson interferometer thermo-optical switch on SOI. Opt. Express 16(20), 15304– 15311 (2008)

57 Celo, D., Goodwill, D.J., Jiang, J., Dumais, P., Li, M., Bernier, E.: Thermo-optic silicon photonics with low power and extreme resilience to over-drive. In: 2016 IEEE Optical Interconnects Conference (OI). IEEE (2016)

58 Murray, K., Lu, Z., Jayatilleka, H., Chrostowski, L.: Dense dissimilar waveguide routing for highly efficient thermo-optic switches on silicon. Opt. Express 23(15), 19575–19585 (2015)

59 Chung, S., Nakai, M., Hashemi, H.: Low-power thermo-optic silicon modulator for large-scale photonic integrated systems. Opt. Express 27(9), 13430–13459 (2019)

60 Qiu, H., Liu, Y., Luan, C., Kong, D., Guan, X., Ding, Y., Hu, H.: Energy-efficient thermo-optic silicon phase shifter with well-balanced overall performance. Opt. Lett. 45(17), 4806–4809 (2020)

61 Miller, S.A., Chang, Y.C., Phare, C.T., Shin, M.C., Zadka, M., Roberts, S.P., Stern, B., Ji, X., Mohanty, A., Jimenez Gordillo, O.A., Dave, U.D., Lipson, M.: Large-scale optical phased array using a low-power multi-pass silicon platform. Optica 7(1), 3–6 (2020)

62 Alves, A.R., Declercq, S., Khan, M.U., Wang, M., Van Iseghem, L., Bogaerts, W.: Column-row addressing of thermo-optic phase shifters for controlling large silicon photonic circuits. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. https://doi.org/10.1109/JSTQE.2020.2975669 (2020)