The exploration of graphene-based mid-IR pulsed lasers started in 2012, with several groups reporting developments around 2 μm. Typical saturable absorbers were in the form of either graphene-polymer composite films or chemical-vapor deposition (CVD) grown graphene followed by transferring to metal or dielectric mirrors. For fiber lasers, liquid exfoliated graphene-based composite films were first used to demonstrate a
Q-switched laser [
20] and a mode-locked thulium fiber laser [
21], respectively. The use of composite films ensures higher absorption and larger modulation depth, which is desirable for pulsed operation in fiber lasers. On the other hand, single-layer CVD graphene-based saturable absorber mirror has the advantages of high transmittance (~ 97%) and controllable and scalable fabrication. The relatively smaller modulation depth (typically below 1%) of single-layer graphene makes it a good alternative to the widely used SESAMs. The first CVD graphene enabled mode-locked solid-state crystal laser was based on a Tm-doped calcium lithium niobium gallium garnet (Tm:CLNGG) gain media, where the generation of 60 mW, 729 fs pulses at a wavelength of 2018 nm was achieved [
22]. Graphene was transferred onto a dielectric mirror and the device was operated in the reflectance mode as a cavity end mirror [
22]. By transferring graphene to a transparent dielectric substrate, a Tm:Lu
2O
3 crystal laser was mode-locked in such a way that shorter (~410 fs) and more powerful (~270 mW) pulses were obtained [
23]. Thus far, the longest wavelength graphene enabled mode-locked solid-state laser is based on a Cr: ZnSe laser, operating at 2500 nm, in which graphene transferred onto a CaF
2 substrate acted as an absorber in the transmission mode [
24]. The laser features a further reduced pulse duration of 226 fs, with 80 mW output power. Graphene-based saturable absorber devices can take other forms such as those directly deposited on SiC substrates.
Q-switched operation of a Tm:YAG laser was demonstrated using such a device [
25], but the use of such devices is not widely applicable to fiber lasers.