Preliminary techno-economic analysis of three typical decentralized composting technologies treating rural kitchen waste: a case study in China

Highlights

● Decentralized composting (DC) is a profitable KW treating technology.

● SAC and BEC were economically attractive in rural area, while HDC was unprofitable.

● KW handling subsidy plays a vital role in making DC profitable.

● SAC and BEC have great potential in promoting rural KW treatment.

Abstract

This study was designed to evaluate whether the decentralized rural kitchen waste (KW) composting technologies used in China can be widely applied. To this end, we completed a techno-economic analysis of three typical types of KW compositing, namely solar-assisted (SAC), bio-enhanced (BEC), and heat-dewatering composting (HDC). These evaluations revealed that all three technologies produce composting products that meet China’s organic fertilizer standard and that both SAC and BEC are economically self-sustaining and generate net profits (18824.94 and 17791.52 US$/a) and positive net present values (32133.11 and 25035.93 US$). Subsequent sensitivity analysis demonstrated that the KW-handling subsidy plays a critical role in making decentralized composting economically attractive. Based on these analyses, we believe that reducing the coverage area of SAC, reducing the operating cost of BEC and HDC, upgrading composting products, and strengthening secondary pollution control would aid in supporting the technological improvement of these processes. Moreover, providing appropriate subsidies and promulgating specific standards and policies for KW fertilizer are key strategies for decentralized rural KW composting management.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Techno-economic analysis / Sensitivity analysis / Rural kitchen waste / Decentralized composting / Organic fertilizer

References

[1] Bekchanov M , Mirzabaev A . (2018). Circular economy of composting in Sri Lanka: opportunities and challenges for reducing waste related pollution and improving soil health. Journal of Cleaner Production, 202: 1107–1119

[2] Bian B , Hu X , Zhang S , Lv C , Yang Z , Yang W , Zhang L . (2019). Pilot-scale composting of typical multiple agricultural wastes: parameter optimization and mechanisms. Bioresource Technology, 287: 121482

[3] Bruni C , Akyol C , Cipolletta G , Eusebi A L , Caniani D , Masi S , Colón J , Fatone F . (2020). Decentralized community composting: past, present and future aspects of Italy. Sustainability (Basel), 12(8): 3319

[4] Chen T , Zhao Y , Qiu X , Zhu X , Liu X , Yin J , Shen D , Feng H . (2021). Economics analysis of food waste treatment in China and its influencing factors. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(2): 33

[5] Ermolaev E , Sundberg C , Pell M , Smårs S , Jonsson H . (2019). Effects of moisture on emissions of methane, nitrous oxide and carbon dioxide from food and garden waste composting. Journal of Cleaner Production, 240: 118165

[6] Gao M , Yang Z , Guo Y , Chen M , Qiu T , Sun X , Wang X . (2021). The size distribution of airborne bacteria and human pathogenic bacteria in a commercial composting plant. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(3): 39

[7] Gronewold A D , Wolpert R L . (2008). Modeling the relationship between most probable number (MPN) and colony-forming unit (CFU) estimates of fecal coliform concentration. Water Research, 42(13): 3327–3334

[8] Hartman J C . (2000). On the equivalence of net present value and market value added as measures of a project’s economic worth. Engineering Economist, 45(2): 158–165

[9] Kuang Y , Lin B . (2021). Public participation and city sustainability: evidence from urban garbage classification in China. Sustainable Cities and Society, 67: 102741

[10] Kwan T H , Ong K L , Haque M A , Kulkarni S , Lin C S K . (2019). Biorefinery of food and beverage waste valorisation for sugar syrups production: techno-economic assessment. Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 121: 194–208

[11] Li H , Qiu Y , Yao T , Han D , Gao Y , Zhang J , Ma Y , Zhang H , Yang X . (2021). Nutrients available in the soil regulate the changes of soil microbial community alongside degradation of alpine meadows in the northeast of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau. Science of the Total Environment, 792: 148363

[12] Li X , Bi F , Han Z , Qin Y , Wang H , Wu W . (2019). Garbage source classification performance, impact factor, and management strategy in rural areas of China: a case study in Hangzhou. Waste Management (New York, N.Y.), 89: 313–321

[13] Lin L , Shah A , Keener H , Li Y . (2019). Techno-economic analyses of solid-state anaerobic digestion and composting of yard trimmings. Waste Management (New York, N.Y.), 85: 405–416

[14] Lin X , Wang Z , Li J . (2021). Identifying the factors dominating the spatial distribution of water and salt in soil and cotton yield under arid environments of drip irrigation with different lateral lengths. Agricultural Water Management, 250: 106834

[15] Liu F , Liu H , Yang N , Wang L . (2021). Comparative study of municipal solid waste incinerator fly ash reutilization in China: environmental and economic performances. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 169: 105541

[16] Liu K , Han T , Huang J , Asad S , Li D , Yu X , Huang Q , Ye H , Hu H , Hu Z , Zhang H . (2020a). Links between potassium of soil aggregates and pH levels in acidic soils under long-term fertilization regimes. Soil & Tillage Research, 197: 104480

[17] Liu S , Oshita S , Makino Y , Wang Q , Kawagoe Y , Uchida T . (2016). Oxidative capacity of nanobubbles and its effect on seed germination. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, 4(3): 1347–1353

[18] Liu Z , Wang X , Wang F , Bai Z , Chadwick D , Misselbrook T , Ma L . (2020b). The progress of composting technologies from static heap to intelligent reactor: benefits and limitations. Journal of Cleaner Production, 270: 122328

[19] Lu S F , Feng S J . (2020). Comprehensive overview of numerical modeling of coupled landfill processes. Waste Management (New York, N.Y.), 118: 161–179

[20] Ma J , Hipel K W , Hanson M L . (2018a). An evaluation of the social dimensions in public participation in rural domestic waste source-separated collection in Guilin, China. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 190(1): 35

[21] Ma J , Zhang L , Mu L , Zhu K , Li A . (2018b). Thermally assisted bio-drying of food waste: synergistic enhancement and energetic evaluation. Waste Management (New York, N.Y.), 80: 327–338

[22] Ma W , Wenga T , Frandsen F J , Yan B , Chen G . (2020). The fate of chlorine during MSW incineration: vaporization, transformation, deposition, corrosion and remedies. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science, 76: 100789

[23] Manu M K , Kumar R , Garg A . (2019). Decentralized composting of household wet biodegradable waste in plastic drums: effect of waste turning, microbial inoculum and bulking agent on product quality. Journal of Cleaner Production, 226: 233–241

[24] Matei P M , Sánchez-Báscones M , Bravo-Sánchez C T , Martín-Ramos P , Martín-Villullas M T , García-González M C , Hernández-Navarro S , Navas-Gracia L M , Martín-Gil J . (2016). Hygienization and control of Diplodia seriata fungus in vine pruning waste composting and its seasonal variability in open and closed systems. Waste Management (New York, N.Y.), 58: 126–134

[25] Moreno-Caselles J , Moral R , Perez-Murcia M , Perez-Espinosa A , Rufete B . (2002). Nutrient value of animal manures in front of environmental hazards. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 33(15–18): 3023–3032

[26] Pai S , Ai N , Zheng J . (2019). Decentralized community composting feasibility analysis for residential food waste: a Chicago case study. Sustainable Cities and Society, 50: 101683

[27] ShahABaralN RManandharA (2016). Technoeconomic Analysis and Life Cycle Assessment of Bioenergy Systems. Advances in Bioenergy. Amsterdam: Elsevier

[28] Sharma S , Panneerselvam P , Castillo R , Manohar S , Raj R , Ravi V , Buresh R J . (2019). Web-based tool for calculating field-specific nutrient management for rice in India. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems, 113(1): 21–33

[29] Thapa S , Mejer H , Thamsborg S M , Lekfeldt J D , Wang R , Jensen B , Magid J , Meyling N V . (2017). Survival of chicken ascarid eggs exposed to different soil types and fungi. Applied Soil Ecology, 121: 143–151

[30] Wang A , Zhang L , Shi Y , Rozelle S , Osborn A , Yang M . (2017). Rural solid waste management in China: status, problems and challenges. Sustainability (Basel), 9(4): 506

[31] Wang H , Xu J , Sheng L . (2019). Study on the comprehensive utilization of city kitchen waste as a resource in China. Energy, 173: 263–277

[32] Wei Y , Wang N , Lin Y , Zhan Y , Ding X , Liu Y , Zhang A , Ding G , Xu T , Li J . (2021). Recycling of nutrients from organic waste by advanced compost technology: a case study. Bioresource Technology, 337: 125411

[33] Xin L , Li X , Bi F , Yan X , Wang H , Wu W . (2021). Accelerating food waste composting course with biodrying and maturity process: a pilot study. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, 9(1): 224–235

[34] Xu Y , Gong H , Dai X . (2021). High-solid anaerobic digestion of sewage sludge: achievements and perspectives. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(4): 71

[35] Yang F , Li Y , Han Y , Qian W , Li G , Luo W . (2019). Performance of mature compost to control gaseous emissions in kitchen waste composting. Science of the Total Environment, 657: 262–269

[36] Yoshizaki T , Shirai Y , Hassan M A , Baharuddin A S , Abdullah N M R , Sulaiman A , Busu Z . (2012). Economic analysis of biogas and compost projects in a palm oil mill with clean development mechanism in Malaysia. Environment, Development and Sustainability, 14(6): 1065–1079

[37] ZhangSWangJChenXGuiJSunYWuD (2021). Industrial-scale food waste composting: effects of aeration frequencies on oxygen consumption, enzymatic activities and bacterial community succession. Bioresource Technology, 320(Pt A): 124357

[38] Zhu L , Jia X , Li M , Wang Y , Zhang J , Hou J , Wang X . (2021). Associative effectiveness of bio-organic fertilizer and soil conditioners derived from the fermentation of food waste applied to greenhouse saline soil in Shandong Province, China. Applied Soil Ecology, 167: 104006

Acknowledgements

This work was financially supported by the Zhejiang Province Key Research and Development Project (Nos. 2019C03006 and 2021C03024).

Electronic Supplementary Material

Supplementary material is available in the online version of this article at https://doi.org/10.1007/s11783-023-1647-7 and is accessible for authorized users.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2023 Higher Education Press