The current phosphate recycling situation in China and Germany: a comparative review

Abstract

Phosphorus (P) is an indispensable element for organisms but the primary source of P—mineral phosphate resources—are non-renewable. Agricultural production has a high demand for fossil phosphate resources, but the resulting phosphate-rich residues are lack of management. This leads to rapid reserves depletion and severe phosphate pollution risks. One sustainable way is to reuse the phosphate dispersed in various residues such as sewage sludge and livestock manure. Diverse techniques have emerged to recover phosphate from wastes to close the phosphate cycle. While it is a global issue, the regional situations regarding potential phosphate scarcity and its management differ strongly. China is rich in phosphate resources, but over-exploitation has greatly increased the risk of phosphate rocks depletion, while in Germany the P resources depend on imports, but there is commitment to keep a balance between import and utilization. This had led to great differences in the way the two countries deal with the “re-use” of phosphate in waste. China is now in a transition phase from the simple terminal pollution control to “waste” reuse and nutrient resources recycling. One sign of this tendency is the mandatory garbage classification and preparation for further processing and recycling. This was first implemented in Shanghai in 2019, whereas Germany has been following the legal framework for waste management since the 19th century. There are a series of laws to control the nutrient loss from municipal and agricultural activities, as for instance with sewage sludge ordinance and fertilizer legislation. Many of these laws have been newly revised recently. Sewage sludge cannot be directly utilized on farmland as organic fertilizer any more. Alternatively, phosphate and other nutrients should be recovered from sewage sludge. Advanced phosphate recovery technologies and related nutrient recycling schemes are proceeding. This review summarizes the current situation of phosphate-containing residues management and phosphate reuse in China and Germany. The state legislation and policies, which would affect the phosphate recycling concept are presented as well. As there are various kinds of phosphate-containing residues, different phosphate recovery technologies can be applied. Those technologies are discussed from their mechanism and suitability.

Keywords

phosphate recovery / manure / sewage sludge / ordinances / technologies

References

[1] Cordell D, Neset T S. Phosphorus vulnerability: a qualitative framework for assessing the vulnerability of national and regional food systems to the multi-dimensional stressors of phosphorus scarcity. Global Environmental Change, 2014, 24: 108–122

[2] Némery J, Garnier J. The fate of phosphorus. Nature Geoscience, 2016, 9(5): 343–344

[3] Sosa O A. Phosphorus redox reactions as pinch hitters in microbial metabolism. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2018, 115(1): 7–8

[4] Pasek M. A role for phosphorus redox in emerging and modern biochemistry. Current Opinion in Chemical Biology, 2019, 49: 53–58

[5] Cordell D, Drangert J O, White S. The story of phosphorus: global food security and food for thought. Global Environmental Change, 2009, 19(2): 292–305

[6] Peñuelas J, Poulter B, Sardans J, Ciais P, van der Velde M, Bopp L, Boucher O, Godderis Y, Hinsinger P, Llusia J, Nardin E, Vicca S, Obersteiner M, Janssens I A. Human-induced nitrogen-phosphorus imbalances alter natural and managed ecosystems across the globe. Nature Communications, 2013, 4(1): 2934

[7] Smil V. Phosphorus in the environment: natural flows and human interferences. Annual Review of Energy and the Environment, 2000, 25(1): 53–88

[8] Jasinski S M. Phosphate Rock Statistics and Information: Mineral Commodity Summaries. Phosphate Rock, 2018. Available at USGS-National Minerals Information Center website on March 15, 2019

[9] Federal Ministry for the Environment. Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety, General Information Wastewater: Sewage Treatment Plant. Available at Federal Ministry for the Environment (BMU in German) website on March 15, 2019

[10] Desmidt E, Ghyselbrecht K, Zhang Y, Pinoy L, Van der Bruggen B, Verstraete W, Rabaey K, Meesschaert B. Global phosphorus scarcity and full-scale P-recovery techniques: a review. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 2015, 45(4): 336–384

[11] Scholz R W, Ulrich A E, Eilittä M, Roy A. Sustainable use of phosphorus: a finite resource. Science of the Total Environment, 2013, 461–462: 799–803

[12] Linderholm K, Tillman A M, Mattsson J E. Life cycle assessment of phosphorus alternatives for Swedish agriculture. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2012, 66: 27–39

[13] Rittmann B E, Mayer B, Westerhoff P, Edwards M. Capturing the lost phosphorus. Chemosphere, 2011, 84(6): 846–853

[14] Liu Y, Villalba G, Ayres R U, Schroder H. Global phosphorus flows and environmental impacts from a consumption perspective. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 2008, 12(2): 229–247

[15] Wilfert P, Dugulan A I, Goubitz K, Korving L, Witkamp G J, Van Loosdrecht M C M. Vivianite as the main phosphate mineral in digested sewage sludge and its role for phosphate recovery. Water Research, 2018, 144(1): 312–321

[16] De Vrieze J, Colica G, Pintucci C, Sarli J, Pedizzi C, Willeghems G, Bral A, Varga S, Prat D, Peng L, Spiller M, Buysse J, Colsen J, Benito O, Carballa M, Vlaeminck S E. Resource recovery from pig manure via an integrated approach: a technical and economic assessment for full-scale applications. Bioresource Technology, 2019, 272: 582–593

[17] Peinemann J C, Krenz L M M, Pleissner D. Is seashell powder suitable for phosphate recovery from fermentation broth? New Biotechnology, 2019, 49(25): 43–47

[18] Ye Y, Ngo H H, Guo W, Liu Y, Li J, Liu Y, Zhang X, Jia H. Insight into chemical phosphate recovery from municipal wastewater. Science of the Total Environment, 2017, 576: 159–171

[19] Liu Y, Kumar S, Kwag J H, Ra C. Magnesium ammonium phosphate formation, recovery and its application as valuable resources: a review. Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 2013, 88(2): 181–189

[20] Petzet S, Peplinski B, Cornel P. On wet chemical phosphorus recovery from sewage sludge ash by acidic or alkaline leaching and an optimized combination of both. Water Research, 2012, 46(12): 3769–3780

[21] Adam C, Peplinski B, Michaelis M, Kley G, Simon F G. Thermochemical treatment of sewage sludge ashes for phosphorus recovery. Waste Management, 2009, 29(3): 1122–1128

[22] Rosmarin A. The precarious geopolitics of phosphorous, down to earth. Science and Environment Fortnightly, 2004: 27–34

[23] Zhang W F, Ma W Q, Zhang F S, Ma J. Comparative analysis of the superiority of China’s phosphate rock and development strategies with that of the United States and Morocco. Journal of Natural Resources, 2005, 20(3): 378–386 (in Chinese)

[24] Zhao X, Cai M D, Dong Q Q, Li Y J, Shen J B. Advances of mechanisms and technology pathway of efficient utilization of medium-low grade phosphate rock resources. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers, 2018, 24(4): 1121–1130 (in Chinese)

[25] Li G H, van Ittersum M K, Leffelaar P A, Sattari S Z, Li H G, Huang G Q, Zhang F S. A multi-level analysis of China’s phosphorus flows to identify options for improved management in agriculture. Agricultural Systems, 2016, 144: 87–100

[26] Gilbert N. Environment: the disappearing nutrient. Nature, 2009, 461(7265): 716–718

[27] Huang R, Fang C, Lu X, Jiang R, Tang Y. Transformation of phosphorus during (hydro)thermal treatments of solid biowastes: reaction mechanisms and implications for P reclamation and recycling. Environmental Science & Technology, 2017, 51(18): 10284–10298

[28] Hukari S, Nättorp A, Kabbe C. P-REX: sustainable sewage sludge management fostering phosphorous recovery and energy efficiency. Project supported by the European Commission within the Seventh Frame-work Programme Grant agreement No. 308645. Available at Zenodo website on April 8, 2019

[29] Scholz R W, Roy A H. Global TraPs Response to the EU Consultative Communication on the Sustainable Use of Phosphorus, December 1, 2013. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions. Available at European Commission website on March 7, 2019

[30] Tartakovsky D, Stern E, Broday D M. Indirect estimation of emission factors for phosphate surface mining using air dispersion modeling. Science of the Total Environment, 2016, 556(15): 179–188

[31] Kratz S, Schick J, Schnug E. Trace elements in rock phosphates and P containing mineral and organo-mineral fertilizers sold in Germany. Science of the Total Environment, 2016, 542(Part B): 1013–1019

[32] Zheng J H, Wang W G, Cao X H, Feng X Z, Xing W Q, Ding Y M, Dong Q, Shao Q X. Responses of phosphorus use efficiency to human interference and climate change in the middle and lower reaches of the Yangtze River: historical simulation and future projections. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2018, 201: 403–415

[33] Mayer B K, Baker L A, Boyer T H, Drechsel P, Gifford M, Hanjra M A, Parameswaran P, Stoltzfus J, Westerhoff P, Rittmann B E. Total value of phosphorus recovery. Environmental Science & Technology, 2016, 50(13): 6606–6620

[34] Nättorp A, Kabbe C, Matsubae K, Ohtake H. Development of phosphorus recycling in Europe and Japan. In: Ohtake H, Tsuneda S, eds. Phosphorus recovery and recycling. Singapore: Springer, 2019, 3–27

[35] Tong C, Hall C A, Wang H. Land use change in rice, wheat and maize production in China (1961–1998). Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2003, 95(2–3): 523–536

[36] Ma L, Guo J H, Velthof G L, Li Y M, Chen Q, Ma W Q, Oenema O, Zhang F S. Impacts of urban expansion on nitrogen and phosphorus flows in the food system of Beijing from 1978 to 2008. Global Environmental Change, 2014, 28: 192–204

[37] Tian H, Gao J, Hao J, Lu L, Zhu C, Qiu P. Atmospheric pollution problems and control proposals associated with solid waste management in China: a review. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 2013, 252–253: 142–154

[38] Ramalho C E, Hobbs R J. Time for a change: dynamic urban ecology. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 2012, 27(3): 179–188

[39] National Bureau of Statistics, Ministry of Environmental Protection, People’s Republic of China. China Statistical Yearbook on Environment. Beijing: China Statistics Press, 2011 (in Chinese)

[40] Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of the People’ Republic of China. The plan for promoting the pilot project of recycling agricultural wastes. Available at Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of the People’s Republic of China website on April 3, 2019 (in Chinese)

[41] Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of the People’ Republic of China. Thoughts and suggestions on treatment and utilization of livestock and poultry manure. Available at Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of the People’s Republic of China website on March 21, 2019 (in Chinese)

[42] Li F, Cheng S K, Yu H L, Yang D W. Waste from livestock and poultry breeding and its potential assessment of biogas energy in rural China. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2016, 126: 451–460

[43] National Development and Reform Commission of the People’s Republic of China. The 13th Five-Year Plan of the national rural biogas project. Available at Government of the People’s Republic of China website on March 5, 2019

[44] Jia W, Qin W, Zhang Q, Wang X, Ma Y, Chen Q. Evaluation of crop residues and manure production and their geographical distribution in China. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2018, 188(1): 954–965

[45] Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of the People’ Republic of China. National plan for sustainable agricultural development (2015–2030). Available at Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of the People’s Republic of China website on March 12, 2019

[46] He K, Zhang J B, Zeng Y M, Zhang L. Households’ willingness to accept compensation for agricultural waste recycling: taking biogas production from livestock manure waste in Hubei, P. R. China as an example. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2016, 131: 410–420

[47] Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Global agricultural production statistics. Available at FAOSTAT website on April 18, 2019

[48] Oehmichen K, Thrän D. Fostering renewable energy provision from manure in Germany—where to implement GHG emission reduction incentives. Energy Policy, 2017, 110: 471–477

[49] Kuhn T, Kokemohr L, Holm-Müller K. A life cycle assessment of liquid pig manure transport in line with EU regulations: a case study from Germany. Journal of Environmental Management, 2018, 217: 456–467

[50] Scheftelowitz M, Daniel-Gromke J, Rensberg N, Denysenko V, Hildebrand K, Naumann K, Ziegler D, Witt J U A. Stromerzeugung aus Biomasse (Vorhaben IIa Biomasse) (preliminary report). Leipzig, Germany: Deutsches Biomasseforschungszentrum, 2014

[51] Trade Association Biogas. Number of biogas plants in Germany in the years 1992 to 2019. Available at Statista website on April 23, 2019 (in German)

[52] Schoumans O F, Rulkens W H, Oenema O, Ehlert P A I. Phosphorous recovery from animal manure: technical opportunities and agro-economical perspectives. Available at Wageningen University and Research website on March 11, 2019

[53] Wang M J. Land application of sewage sludge in China. Science of the Total Environment, 1997, 197(1–3): 149–160

[54] Petzet S, Cornel P. Towards a complete recycling of phosphorus in wastewater treatment—options in Germany. Water Science and Technology, 2011, 64(1): 29–35

[55] News (anonymous). Status, development and incentive policy demand of urban sludge treatment and disposal industrialization in China. Available at h2o-China website on March 15, 2019 (in Chinese)

[56] Federal Ministry for the Environment. Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety (BMU). Waste Management in Germany 2018—facts, data, diagrams 2018. Available at Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conversion and Nuclear Safety website on March 11, 2019

[57] Roskosch A. New German Sewage Sludge Ordinance. HELCOM Workshop on sewage sludge handling practices, Vilnius, 2017. Available at German Federal Environment Agency on March 21, 2019

[58] Kuhn T. The revision of the German Fertiliser Ordinance in 2017. Food and Resource Economics, Discussion Paper, 2017: 2

[59] Teil I. Sewage sludge ordinance. Bundesgesetzblatt, 1992, 15: 912–934 (in German)

[60] German Bundestag Scientific Services. Authorization of fertilizers with nitrification and urease inhibitors. Available at German Bundestag website on March 10, 2019 (in German)

[61] Hou Y, Wei S, Ma W Q, Roelcke M, Nieder R, Shi S L, Wu J C, Zhang F S. Changes in nitrogen and phosphorus flows and losses in agricultural systems of three megacities of China, 1990–2014. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2018, 139: 64–75

[62] Huang R, Fang C, Zhang B, Tang Y. Transformations of phosphorus speciation during (hydro)thermal treatments of animal manures. Environmental Science & Technology, 2018, 52(5): 3016–3026

[63] Editorial Board of Energy of China. Opinions on accelerating the construction of ecological civilization. Energy of China, 2015, 37(5): 1 (in Chinese)

[64] General Office of the State Council of the People’s Republic of China. Strategic planning for rural revitalization. Available at Xinhua News Agency of the People’s Republic of China website on April 3, 2019 (in Chinese)

[65] Ministry of Ecology and Environment of the People’ Republic of China. Action plan for tackling agricultural and rural pollution control (000014672/2018-03290). Available at Ministry of Ecology and Environment of the People’s Republic of China website on April 3, 2019 (in Chinese)

[66] Ren J Z, Liang H W, Dong L, Gao Z Q, He C, Pan M, Sun L. Sustainable development of sewage sludge-to-energy in China: barriers identification and technologies prioritization. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2017, 67: 384–396

[67] General Office of the State Council of the People’s Republic of China. The disposal methods include land use, landfill and comprehensive utilization of building materials, 2017. Available at Rural Energy and Environment Agency, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs website on April 5, 2019 (in Chinese)

[68] Rahman M M, Salleh M A M, Rashid U, Ahsan A, Hossain M M, Ra C S. Production of slow release crystal fertilizer from wastewaters through struvite crystallization—a review. Arabian Journal of Chemistry, 2014, 7(1): 139–155

[69] Römer W. Plant availability of P from recycling products and phosphate fertilizers in a growth-chamber trial with rye seedlings. Journey of Plant Nutrition and Plant Science, 2006, 169: 826–883

[70] Thomsen K. Struvite-K, sustainable recovery of pure phosphate from sewage sludge and biomass ash. Available at Chemical and Biochemical Engineering, Technical University of Denmark website on April 3, 2019

[71] Daneshgar S, Buttafava A, Callegari A, Capodaglio A G. Economic and energetic assessment of different phosphorus recovery options from aerobic sludge. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2019, 223: 729–738

[72] van Lier R J M, Buisman C J N. Crystalactor® technology and its applicationsin the mining and metallurgical industry. Available at Paques Technology B.V. website on April 8, 2019

[73] Petruzzelli D, Dell’Erba A, Liberti L, Notarnicola M, Sengupta A K. A phosphate-selective sorbent for the REM NUT® process: field experience at Massafra Wastewater Treatment Plant. Reactive & Functional Polymers, 2004, 60: 195–202

[74] Shi L, Simplicio W S, Wu G X, Hu Z H, Hu H Y, Zhan X M. Nutrient recovery from digestate of anaerobic digestion of livestock manure: a review. Current Pollution Report, 2018, 4(2): 74–83

[75] Cornel P, Schaum C. Phosphorus recovery from wastewater: needs, technologies and costs. Water Science and Technology, 2009, 59(6): 1069–1076

[76] Petzet S, Peplinski B, Bodkhe S Y, Cornel P. Recovery of phosphorus and aluminium from sewage sludge ash by a new wet chemical elution process (SESAL-Phos-recovery process). Water Science and Technology, 2011, 64(3): 693–699

[77] Antakyali D, Meyer C, Preyl V, Maier W, Steinmetz H. Large-scale application of nutrient recovery from digested sludge as struvite. Water Practice and Technology, 2013, 8(2): 256–262

[78] Nieminen J. Phosphorous recovery and recycling from municiple wastewater sludge. Espoo: Aalto University, 2010

[79] Desmidt E, Ghyselbrecht K, Zhang Y, Pinoy L, van der Bruggen B, Verstraete W, Rabaey K, Meesschaert B. Global phosphorus scarcity and full-scale P-recovery techniques: a review. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 2015, 45(4): 336–384

[80] Wang T F, Zhai Y B, Zhu Y, Li C T, Zeng G N. A review of the hydrothermal carbonization of biomass waste for hydrochar formation: process conditions, fundamentals, and physicochemical properties. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2018, 90: 223–247

[81] Gollakota A R K, Kishore N, Gu S. A review on hydrothermal liquefaction of biomass. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2018, 81(Part1): 1378–1392

[82] Kruse A. Hydrothermal biomass gasification. Journal of Supercritical Fluids, 2009, 47(3): 391–399

[83] Patel B, Guo M, Izadpanah A, Shah N, Hellgardt K. A review on hydrothermal pre-treatment technologies and environmental profiles of algal biomass processing. Bioresource Technology, 2016, 199: 288–299

[84] Havukainen J, Horttanainen M, Linnanen L. Feasibility of ASH DEC-process in treating sewage sludge and manure ash in Finland. Available at Lappeenranta University of Technology website on April 27, 2019

[85] News (anonymous). AVA-CO2 develops phosphorus recovery process. Membrane Technology, 2015, 2015(1): 6

[86] Ehrnström M S. Recovery of phosphorous from HTC converted municiple sewage sludge. Dissertation for the Master’s Degree.Luleå, Sweden: Luleå University of Technology, 2016

[87] Heilmann S M, Molde J S, Timler J G, Wood B M, Mikula A L, Vozhdayev G V, Colosky E C, Spokas K A, Valentas K J. Phosphorus reclamation through hydrothermal carbonization of animal manures. Environmental Science & Technology, 2014, 48(17): 10323–10329

[88] Becker G C, Wüst D, Köhler H, Lautenbach A, Kruse A. Novel approach of phosphate-reclamation as struvite from sewage sludge by utilising hydrothermal carbonization. Journal of Environmental Management, 2019, 238: 119–125

[89] Heidari M, Dutta A, Acharya B, Mahmud S. A review of the current knowledge and challenges of hydrothermal carbonization for biomass conversion. Journal of the Energy Institute, 2018. doi:10.1016/j.joei.2018.12.003

[90] Mašek O, Luque R, Lin C, Wilson K, Clark J. Biochar in thermal and thermochemical biorefinery-production of biochar as a coproduct. Handbook of Biofuels Production, 2nd ed. UK: Woodhead Publishing, 2016

[91] Yu G, Zhang Y, Guo B, Funk T, Schideman L. Nutrient flows and quality of bio-crude oil produced via catalytic hydrothermal liquefaction of low-lipid Microalgae. BioEnergy Research, 2014, 7(4): 1317–1328

[92] Wang C, Zhu W, Chen C, Zhang H, Fan Y, Mu B, Zhong J. Behavior of phosphorus in catalytic supercritical water gasification of dewatered sewage sludge: the conversion pathway and effect of alkaline additive. Energy & Fuels, 2019, 33(2): 1290–1295

[93] Li H, Zhao X, Zhang T, Kruse A, Ohtake H, Tsuneda S. Hydrothermal process for extracting phosphate from animal manure. Phosphorus recovery and recycling. Singapore: Springer, 2019, 33: 377–389

[94] Ehmann A, Bach I M, Laopeamthong S, Bilbao J, Lewandowski I. Can phosphate salts recovered from manure replace conventional phosphate fertilizer? Agriculture, 2017, 7(1): 1

[95] Barker A V, Pilbeam D J. Handbook of plant nutrition. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 2007

[96] Sun Y, Gao B, Yao Y, Fang J, Zhang M, Zhou Y, Chen H, Yang L. Effects of feedstock type, production method, and pyrolysis temperature on biochar and hydrochar properties. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2014, 240: 574–578

[97] Liu Y, Rahman M M, Kwag J H, Kim J H, Ra C. Eco-friendly production of maize using struvite recovered from swine wastewater as a sustainable fertilizer source. Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences, 2011, 24(12): 1699–1705

[98] Melia P M, Cundy A B, Sohi S P, Hooda P S, Busquets R. Trends in the recovery of phosphorus in bioavailable forms from wastewater. Chemosphere, 2017, 186: 381–395

Acknowledgements

The work was funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) (328017493/GRK 2366), the Project Bio-SuPex (BMBF 031B0606), RePhoR-MV (BMBF 84130080) and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (31401944).

Compliance with ethics guidelines

ƒQing Xue, Xinyue He, Saskia D. Sachs, Gero C. Becker, Tao Zhang, and Andrea Kruse declare that they have no conflicts of interest or financial conflicts to disclose.ƒThis article does not contain any studies with human or animal subjects performed by any of the authors.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s) 2019. Published by Higher Education Press. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0)