Investigation of the Vibration Behavior of Fluidelastic Instability in Closely Packed Square Tube Arrays

Abstract

Flow-induced vibrations in heat exchanger tubes have led to numerous accidents and economic losses in the past. Fluidelastic instability is the most critical flow-induced vibration mechanism in heat exchangers. Both experimental and computational studies conducted to determine fluidelastic instability were presented in this paper. In the experiment, a water channel was built, and a closely packed normal square tube array with a pitch-to-diameter ratio of 1.28 was tested, and significant fluidelastic instability was observed. A numerical model adopting large-eddy simulation and moving mesh was established using ANSYS CFX, and results showed good agreement with the experimental findings. The vibration behaviors of fluidelastic instability were discussed, and results showed that the dominant vibration direction of the tubes changed from streamwise to transverse beyond a critical velocity. A 180° phase lag between adjacent tubes was observed in both the experiment and simulations. Normal and rotated square array cases with pitch-to-diameter ratios of 1.28 and 1.5 were also simulated. The results of this study provide better insights into the vibration characteristics of a square tube array and will help improve the fundamental research and safety design of heat exchangers.

Keywords

Fluidelastic instability / Dominant vibration direction / Phase lag / Square tube array / Heat exchanger

References

[1] Price SJ. A review of theoretical-models for fluidelastic instability of cylinder arrays in cross-flow. J Fluids Struct, 1995, 9(5): 463-518.

[2] Chen SS. Zamrik SY, Dietrich D. Flow induced vibration. Pressure vessel and piping: Design technology, 1982-a decade of progress, 1982, New York: ASME 301-312.

[3] Paidoussis MP. A review of flow induced vibrations in reactors and reactor components. J Nucl Eng Des, 1983, 74: 31-60.

[4] Weaver DS, Fitzpatrick JA. A review of cross-flow induced vibrations in heat exchanger tube arrays. J Fluids Struct, 1988, 2(1): 73-93.

[5] Chen SS. Instability mechanisms and stability criteria of a group of circular cylinders subjected to cross flow I: theory. J Vib Acoust Stress Reliab Des, 1983, 105: 51-58.

[6] Chen SS. Instability mechanisms and stability criteria of a group of circular cylinders subjected to cross flow II: numerical results and discussion. J Vib Acoust Stress Reliab Des, 1983, 105: 253-260.

[7] Paidoussis MP, Price SJ. The mechanisms underlying flow-induced instabilities of cylinder arrays in crossflow. J Fluid Mech, 1988, 187: 45-59.

[8] Khalifa A, Weaver D, Ziada S. A single flexible tube in a rigid array as a model for fluidelastic instability in tube bundles. J Fluids Struct, 2012, 34(4): 14-32.

[9] Tanaka H, Takahara S. Fluid elastic vibrations of tube array in cross flow. J Sound Vib, 1981, 77(1): 19-37.

[10] Tanaka H, Takahara S, Ohta K. Flow-induced vibrations in tube arrays with various pitch-to-diameter ratios. ASME J Press Vessel Technol, 1982, 104: 168-174.

[11] Weaver DS, Yeung HC. Approach flow direction effects on the cross-flow induced vibrations of a square array of tubes. J Sound Vib, 1983, 87(3): 469-482.

[12] Price SJ, Paidoussis MP. The flow-induced response of a single flexible cylinder in an in-line array of rigid cylinders. J Fluids Struct, 1989, 3(1): 61-82.

[13] Chen SS, Zhu S, Jendrzejczyk JA. Fluid damping and fluid stiffness of a tube in crossflow. ASME J Press Vessel Technol, 1994, 116(4): 370-383.

[14] Al-Kaabi SA, Khulief YA, Said SA. Prediction of flow-induced vibrations in tubular heat exchangers-part II: experimental investigation. J Pressure Vessel Technol, 2009, 131(1): 011302

[15] Scott P (1987) Flow visualization of cross-flow induced vibrations in tube arrays. Dissertation, McMaster University, Hamilton

[16] Austermann R, Popp K. Stability behaviour of single flexible cylinder in a rigid array of different geometry subjected to cross flow. J Fluids Struct, 1995, 9(3): 303-322.

[17] Moulinec C, Hunt JCR, Nieuwstadt FTM. Disappearing wakes and dispersion in numerically simulated flows through tube bundles. Flow Turbul Combust, 2004, 73: 95-116.

[18] Moulinec C, Pourquié MJBM, Boersma BJ, et al. Direct numerical simulation on a Cartesian mesh of the flow through a tube bundle. Int J Comput Fluid Dyn, 2004, 18(1): 1-14.

[19] Hassan YA, Ibrahim WA. Turbulence prediction in two-dimensional bundle flows using large eddy simulation. Nucl Technol J, 1997, 119: 11-28.

[20] Barsamian HR, Hassan YA. Large eddy simulation of turbulent crossflow in tube bundles. Nucl Eng Des J, 1997, 172: 103-122.

[21] Hassan YA, Barsamian HR. Turbulence simulation in tube bundle geometries using the dynamic subgrid-scale model. Nucl Technol J, 1999, 128(1): 58-74.

[22] Bouris D, Bergeles G. Two dimensional time dependent simulation of the subcritical flow in a staggered tube bundle using a subgrid scale model. Int J Heat Fluid Flow, 1999, 20(2): 105-114.

[23] Rollet-Miet P, Laurence D, Ferziger JH. LES and RANS of turbulent flow in tube bundles. Int J Heat Fluid Flow, 1999, 20(3): 241-254.

[24] Benhamadouche S, Laurence D. LES, coarse LES, and transient RANS comparisons on the flow across a tube bundle. Int J Heat Fluid Flow, 2003, 24(4): 470-479.

[25] Liang C, Papadakis G. Large eddy simulation of cross-flow through a staggered tube bundle at subcritical Reynolds number. J Fluids Struct, 2007, 23(8): 1215-1230.

[26] Kevlahan NKR. The role of vortex wake dynamics in the flow-induced vibration of tube arrays. J Fluids Struct, 2011, 27(5–6): 829-837.

[27] Hassan M, El Bouzidi S (2012) Unsteady fluid forces and the time delay in a vibrating tube subjected to cross flow. In: Flow-induced vibration 2012, Dublin

[28] El Bouzidi S, Hassan M, Fernandez LL et al (2014). Numerical characterization of the area perturbation and time lag for a vibrating tube subjected to cross-flow. In: Proceedings of the ASME 2014 pressure vessels and piping division conference, Anaheim

[29] Shinde V, Marcel T, Hoarau Y, et al. Numerical simulation of the fluid–structure interaction in a tube array under cross flow at moderate and high Reynolds number. J Fluids Struct, 2014, 47(5): 99-113.

[30] Berland J, Deri E, Adobes A (2014) Large-eddy simulation of cross-flow induced vibrations of a single flexible tube in a normal square tube array. In: Proceedings of the ASME 2014 pressure vessels and piping division conference, Anaheim

[31] Wu H, Tan W, Nie QD. A numerical model for fluid-elastic instability of a square tube array. J Vib Shock, 2013, 32(21): 102-106.

[32] Connors HJ (1970) Fluidelastic vibration of tube arrays excited by cross flow. In: Proceeding of the ASME winter annual meet, vol 41, pp 93–107

[33] Moore CV. ASME boiler and pressure vessel code, 1984, New York: American Society of Mechanical Engineers.

[34] Pettigrew MJ, Taylor CE. Fluidelastic instability of heat exchanger tube bundles: review and design recommendations. J Pressure Vessel Technol, 1991, 113(2): 242-256.