Introduction
Hemophilia B is an X-linked, monogenic hereditary disorder. It is characterized by a deficiency of blood coagulation factor IX (FIX), resulting in a diminished clotting capability of blood. It occurs in 1 of every 25 000 to 30 000 live males who were born with the most common mutation on chromosome Xq27.1. The disease has been broadly classified as mild, moderate, or severe according to the level of FIX coagulant activity, which corresponds to 5% to 40%, 1% to 5% and<1% of normal, respectively [
1].
The major clinical feature of hemophilia B is continuous bleeding after or even without trauma or injury. Bleeding can occur in various tissue, particularly in the joints. Without effective treatment, soft-tissue hematomas and hemarthrosis could lead to tissue damage and chronic hemophilic arthropathy over time. In addition, bleeding in critically closed spaces can be life-threatening. Current treatment of hemophilia B relies on protein replacement therapy (PRT). PRT restores hemostasis, thereby reducing the mortality of patients [
2,
3]. However, because of the short half-life of the protein in blood circulation, PRT only has transient therapeutic effects. Requiring frequently periodic injections, the treatment of PRT is expensive and is also associated with complications, such as infectious diseases. Recent clinical trials of liver-directed gene therapy for HB have been performed at St Jude Children’s Research Hospital and University College, London. It involved self-complementary AAV8-FIX vectors and demonstrated encouraging results with relative safety [
4]. Nevertheless, further investigations are needed to increase FIX coagulant activity, reduce vector doses, and eliminate host immune responses.
Many reported studies have demonstrated that the expression level of a gene could be significantly improved by codon optimization [
5–
7]. Ward reported that codon optimization of human factor VIII cDNA led to an unprecedented 29- to 44-fold increase in factor VIII expression [
8]. Identical doses of AAV8 vector containing codon-optimized hFVIII cDNA resulted in dramatic improvements in clotting time, with average aPTTs declining from 78±8 s to 37±2 s [
9]. Additionally, hFIX expression of scAAV2/8-LP1-hFIXco was almost 4-fold higher compared with that of scAAV2/8-LP1-hFIX by tail vein administration of 2×10
9 vector particles [
5]. However, the integrated application of codon optimization technology based on upgraded codon adaption index (CAI), increased GC content, and removal of repeated sequences may further improve expression of hFIX without altering the amino acid sequence. Hydrodynamic administration represents a promising approach to study gene expression in liver and has become a common method for DNA delivery in rodents [
10–
12]. Recently, hydrodynamic tail vein injection has been applied to evaluate the control elements that drive reporter gene expression in the liver [
13–
15]. In the present work, therapeutic cassettes were constructed to direct liver-specific gene expression. The codons for human
FIX were optimized, and R338L mutation was introduced [
16] to increase the expression and activity of FIX. Then, the best regulatory sequences from liver-specific expressed proteins including albumin [
17–
19], prealbumin [
20–
22], α1-antitrypsin [
23,
24], and prothrombin [
25] were screened for their ability to drive the transgene expression. These regulatory sequences were used in hFIX expression cassettes and were evaluated in HB mice via hydrodynamic delivery method.
Materials and methods
Construction of human FIX plasmids
Diagrams of the plasmid constructs are presented in Fig. 1A and 1B. The full sequence of scAAV-LP1-hFIXco [
5] was synthesized and sequenced prior to cloning into pUC57-Kan to create scAAV-LP1-hFIXco-SJ. A new hFIX expression cassette that included a codon-optimized h
FIX (by OptimumGene
TM codon optimization analysis) was sub-cloned into pUC57-Kan to construct scAAV-Alb-hFIXco-SIH. The full sequence of hFIXco-SIH was outlined in Supplementary Material. pcDNA 3.1(-)-FIXwt was a gift from Wenbin Wang (Shanghai Institute of Hematology, Shanghai, China). The h
FIX cDNA was obtained from pcDNA 3.1(-)-FIXwt by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification and sub-cloned into scAAV-polyadenylation signal (polyA) at the
EcoRI/
BglII sites. scAAV-hFIX-polyA was digested with
EcoRI and
SpeI to release h
FIX and the SV40 late polyA tail. This fragment was then inserted into scAAV-LP1-hFIXco-SJ at
EcoRI and
SpeI to substitute hFIXco-SJ and the SV40 late polyA to construct scAAV-LP1-hFIX. The scAAV-LP1-hFIXco-SIH plasmid was constructed by digesting scAAV-LP1-hFIX at
EcoRI and
BglII. scAAV-Alb-hFIXco-SIH was digested at
EcoRI and
BglII to release the h
FIX fragment, which was subsequently inserted into scAAV-LP1-hFIX.
The hFIXco-SJ R338L (AGG→CTA) mutation [
16] and the hFIXco-SIH R338L (CGG→CTA) mutation were introduced using the QuickChange II-XL site-directed mutagenesis kit (Stratagene) to generate scAAV-LP1-hFIXco-SJ-R338L, scAAV-LP1-hFIXco-SIH-R338L, and scAAV-Alb-hFIXco-SIH-R338L.
The scAAV-Pre-hFIXco-SIH-R338L construct was cloned by replacing the albumin enhancer and promoter in scAAV-Alb-hFIXco-SIH-R338L with the human prothrombin enhancer and prealbumin promoter at the XhoI/HindIII sites. scAAV-Chi-hFIXco-SIH-R338L was constructed similarly by replacing with the chimeric albumin enhancer and the chimeric promoter. Elements of all constructed plasmids are listed in Table 1.
Animal procedures
All mice were housed in a specific pathogen-free environment with a normal diet. All experimental procedures were approved by the Studies Ethics Committee of Ruijin Hospital Affiliated to Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine (Reference number: SYXK2011-0113). All animals were handled in accordance with Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee guidelines. Animals used in this study had a C57BL/6 genetic background. FIX-deficient (FIX
null) mice were obtained from Dr. Guowei Zhang (Hangzhou Normal University) [
26]. Separated PCR reactions were performed to identify hemophilia-affected (-/- or -/Y), carrier (+/-), and wild type (+/+ or+/Y) animals. Genomic DNA was initially prepared with blood collected from retro-orbital bleeding and was applied to standard PCR reactions. A common reverse primer (AACAGGGATAGTAAGATTGTTCC) was applied in combination with either a mutant forward primer (TCCTGTCATCTCACCTTGCTC) or a wild type forward primer (TGGAAGCAGTATGTTGGTAAGC) to identify the mutant and wild type alleles, respectively. All primers were synthesized from Genewiz (Suzhou, China). A 35-cycle PCR program (94 °C for 30 s, 55 °C for 30 s, and 72 °C for 45 s) was performed with a 2 min elongation step at 72 °C upon completion of all cycles.
Hydrodynamic injections were performed with male HB mice (-/Y), as described previously [
27,
28]. HB mice were injected with 120 μg of endotoxin-free plasmid DNA in 2.0 ml saline via the tail vein within 5 s to 10 s. Blood was collected at 24 h to 48 h after hydrodynamic injection by retro-orbital bleeding with sodium citrate as an anticoagulant at a final concentration of 0.38% (wt/vol). The blood sample was then centrifuged at 4 °C for 10 min at 9000 rpm in a microcentrifuge. The plasma was collected and stored at -80 °C for use in the FIX assays.
Determination of hFIX levels and coagulant activity
Plasma levels of hFIX in mice were detected by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) according to a previously described method [
29]. A monoclonal antibody against the hFIX heavy chain (AHIX-5041 monoclonal antibody, Hematologic Technologies Inc., US) was used to capture the protein. A goat anti-human FIX polyclonal antibody was used as the secondary antibody (GAFIX-APHRP, Affinity Biological Inc.). A standard curve was generated with serial dilutions of normal human pooled plasma. Human FIX coagulant activity in collected plasma samples were determined through a chromogenic assay (BIOPHEN Factor IX, Hyphen Biomed, Neuville-sur-Oise, France) and calculated with a standard curve generated with a series of diluted normal human pooled plasma.
Results
Codon optimization of hFIX cDNA
Codon optimization of FIX was performed with an OptimumGeneTM algorithm in which codon adaptation index, codon usage frequency, and mRNA structure optimization were considered. To reach a higher level of expression, the codon usage bias in human was increased by upgrading the CAI from 0.72 to 0.87. The GC content and unfavorable peaks were modulated to prolong the half-life of FIX mRNA. The stem-loop structures affecting ribosomal binding efficiency and stability of mRNA were broken. In addition, the negative cis-acting sites were successfully modified by the optimization process. The information on codon optimization is shown in Fig. 2, including the CAI (Fig. 2A), GC contents (Fig. 2B), and the frequency of codon usage (Fig. 2C).
For this study, a previously described hFIX expression cassette (scAAV-LP1-hFIXco-SJ) was selected as a positive control [
4,
5]. Our codon-optimized h
FIX and wild type h
FIX were constructed under the same control elements in LP1-hFIXco-SIH and LP1-hFIX-WT plasmids, respectively. To test the expression mediated by these constructs
in vivo, the LP1-hFIX-WT, LP1-hFIXco-SIH, and LP1-hFIXco-SJ plasmids were delivered into HB mice at a dose of 200 μg per mouse by hydrodynamic injection, and blood was collected 36 h after injection via retro-orbital eye bleeding.
Protein levels of hFIX in mouse plasma were detected by ELISA. As shown in Fig. 3, the transgene expression mediated by the hFIXco-SIH cassette was 3- to 4-fold higher than that by the wild type counterpart. Hydrodynamic administration of the LP1-hFIX-WT, LP1-hFIXco-SIH and LP1-hFIXco-SJ plasmids resulted in 47%, 162% and 157% of the normal hFIX protein individually, as compared with the pooled human plasma. In the control mice injected with saline, FIX protein was hardly detected. These data indicated that hFIX expression was increased at the protein level because of our codon optimization strategy.
Further increase of clotting activity in hFIXco-SIH-harbing HB mice by R338L mutation
To further enhance the clotting activity of hFIX to reach therapeutic effect with lower doses, a previously described hyper-functional R338L mutation was introduced into the hFIXco-SIH transgene. Human FIX with R338L mutation was evaluated in HB mice via hydrodynamic injection. The FIXco-SIH-R338L transgene displayed 6- to 8-fold coagulant activity compared with FIXco-SIH and the previously published FIXco-SJ (Fig. 4A and 4B), and such activity was also greater than that of FIXco-SJ-R338L. In addition, our codon-optimized transgene further promoted the protein expression to 120% of normal, whereas the positive control hFIXco-SJ and its R338L mutant transgenes resulted in about 109% of normal protein (Fig. 4C and 4D). Considering the coagulant efficiency, our codon-optimized hFIX transgene with an R388L mutation demonstrated the highest coagulant activity among the hFIX transgenes tested in HB mice.
Comparison of liver-specific hFIX expression cassettes driven by various regulatory elements
The transgene with the best performance, hFIXco-R338L, was selected for the construction of liver-specific expression cassettes. Each of the five plasmids (LP1-hFIXco-SJ, LP1-hFIXco-SIH-R338L, Alb-hFIXco-SIH-R338L, Chi-hFIXco-SIH-R338L, and Pre-hFIXco-SIH-R338L) was hydrodynamically delivered into mice using 120 μg of plasmid DNA at a final volume of 2 ml per mouse. Compared with LP1-hFIXco-SJ, which served as the positive control, the Pre-hFIXco-SIH-R338L cassette exhibited the highest level of hFIX clotting activity (Fig. 5). The coagulant activities of the hFIX protein of the 5 transgene cassettes were ranked as follows: LP1-hFIXco-SJ<Alb-hFIXco-SIH-R338L<Chi-hFIXco-SIH-R338L<LP1-hFIXco-SIH-R338L<Pre-hFIXco-SIH-R338L. In addition, higher protein expression levels were obtained from all newly constructed cassettes (except for Alb-hFIXco-SIH-R338L) compared with the control cassette.
Discussion
The expression efficiency of therapeutic transgenes applied in liver-directed gene therapy relies on not only the gene sequence, but also the regulatory elements, such as the enhancer, promoter, intron, and polyA. Previous studies demonstrated that a wide variety of factors influenced gene expression [
15,
31]. Ideally, a transgene cassette with high liver specificity and transcriptional activity should meet several requirements. First, it should have restricted expression only in the hepatocytes. Second, it could drive gene transcription efficiently to reach the therapeutic efficacy. Third, for the AAV vector, the size of the cassette should be sufficiently small for efficient packaging. Thus, considering the above requirements, all regulatory elements selected for driving transgene expression in this study were liver specific, small, and with high transcriptional activity.
To optimize the
FIX transgene cassette, we made the following modifications: first, the h
FIX coding sequence was manipulated under OptimumGene
TM codon optimization analysis with high frequent codons and GC content adjustment; second, a hyper-functional FIX-R338L mutation was introduced to increase the coagulant activity of FIX; third, the strong regulatory elements was designed; and fourth, the Kozak sequence was added immediately in front of the start codon to modulate translation initiation efficiency [
32].
Codon optimization is considered as an effective strategy to improve the gene expression level. It reportedly increases the steady-state mRNA level [
33] and alleviates translation inefficiency caused by ribosomal pauses at rare codons [
34,
35]. A large number of software tools have been implemented to design synthetic genes for sequence optimization. The first generation of the tools focused primarily on codon usage optimization and unique restriction site incorporation. In recent years, sequence design tools that aimed to construct optimal protein-coding sequences adhered to multiple objectives, such as codon bias, codon context bias, RNA secondary structure, ribosomal binding site, restriction sites, hidden stop codons, and other motif avoidance. However, the best kind of codon selection is still unknown. Thus, experimental validation is needed after the preliminary selection with software, and further refinement in the gene design software is required [
36–
39]. In this study, we synthesized the h
FIXco cDNA according to the frequency of codon usage in humans by OptimumGene
TM software. The experiments were then performed to compare the protein expression levels with or without codon optimization, namely, the levels of hFIXco-SIH and hFIX-WT. Results showed that the expression level of hFIXco-SIH was about 3.4 times that of hFIX-WT (162%/47%). In addition, the expression level of hFIXco-SIH was slightly higher than that of the control, hFIXco-SJ. The comparative results of hFIXco-SIH with or without the gain-of-function R338L mutation are consistent with a previous report, in which FIX-R338L had a specific activity that was 5 times to 10 times as high as the wild type
FIX [
16].
The promoters of genes with liver-specific expression have always been chosen for the construction of transgene cassettes [
40]. However, such promoters were typically large, with low and short-lasting transcriptional activity [
41,
42]. These disadvantages have limited their applications in liver-targeted gene therapy. Previous studies on such promoters have shown that a cluster of cis-acting regulatory elements located immediately upstream of the transcription start site (TSS) were generally capable of directing the transcription of an already identified hepatocyte-specific gene [
43]. Analysis of the regulatory components of albumin indicated that binding sites for hepatocyte nuclear factor 1 (HNF-1), NF-Y, and C/EBP were present at -107/-99, -90/-84, and -65/-49, respectively, upstream of the encoding sequence [
17,
18,
44,
45]. Four binding sites in prealbumin promoter are present for C/EBP or C/EBP-related factors, two sites for HNF-3, two sites for HNF-4, and one site for HNF-1 [
20,
22,
46,
47]. The 5′ proximal regulatory region of the human α1-antitrypsin (
α1-AT) gene contained multiple or single binding sites for transcription factors, including C/EBP, HNF-3, and HNF-1 for liver-specific expression [
23,
24,
48]. HNF-3 and HNF-4 were identified as crucial to prealbumin and α1-antirypsin (α1-AT) expression, but neither of them had binding sites in the albumin promoter proximal region [
20]. The lack of binding sites for these two transcription factors might explain the mediocre hFIX expression and activity by the transgenes driven by the albumin promoter/enhancer elements (Fig. 5).
Based on the previous studies, transcription factor binding sites upstream of liver-specific genes were chosen to design regulatory sequences of high liver specificity and activity for expression cassettes [
43,
49]. We designed a new chimeric promoter composed of the distant regulatory region of prealbumin [
22] and the proximal region of albumin [
17]. This chimeric promoter contains four kinds of binding sites for critical transcription factors, including HNF-1, HNF-3, HNF-4, and C/EBP. Chi-hFIXco-SIH-R338L, under the control of the chimeric promoter and the core albumin enhancer elements, achieved a higher hFIX expression at protein level and coagulant activity. Notably, the hFIXco-SIH-R338L construct driven by the prothrombin/prealbumin enhancer and prealbumin promoter displayed the greatest coagulant activity of hFIX in HB mice with high hFIX protein level. Compared with scAAV-LP1-hFIXco-SJ, both scAAV-Chi-hFIXco-SIH-R338L and scAAV-Pre-hFIXco-SIH-R338L displayed higher levels of expression and hFIX coagulant activity. Thus, better therapeutic efficacy may be achieved with both cassettes above via AAV-mediated gene therapy in hemophilia B. However, excess level of FIX activity and AAV vector may lead to thrombosis and/or immune disease. Thus, we need further investigations to achieve ideal therapeutic efficacy and avoid side effects.
In summary, we have constructed a number of liver-specific hFIX expression cassettes. These cassettes have demonstrated relatively high hFIX expression and activity compared with an hFIX cassette that is currently in trial. This design is promising for HB gene therapy mediated by AAV vectors. In addition, regarding the recent progress in clinical application of non-viral constructs targeting the human liver, our configuration could be an optional therapeutic strategy that delivers naked DNA to the liver. Our data showed that the FIX expression level correlated well with the types and amounts of liver-specific transcription factor binding sites in the cassettes. In conclusion, this study provides information on the optimization of transgene cassettes for gene therapy.
Higher Education Press and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg