Uncovering the germanium sustainability up to 2050 in China

Abstract

Germanium, a critical yet often overlooked metal, has experienced significant shifts in its global market, largely driven by China’s dominant role. However, concerns are growing over the sustainability of germanium supply in China due to imbalances in mining, manufacturing, recycling, and rising demand. In this study, we employ substance flow analysis to provide a quantitative assessment of China’s germanium flow system in 2019, and we project future demand and anthropogenic mineral generation up to 2050 using stock-driven models. Our results indicate that by 2050, domestic demand for germanium will increase to 164–187 t—double the demand in 2019—with infrared optics and solar cells being the primary drivers. A supply shortage is anticipated before 2040, although recycling through urban mining could meet around 30% of the demand. These findings underscore the urgent need to address emerging supply challenges and offer critical insights for policymakers and stakeholders to inform strategic decision-making.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Critical metal / Germanium / Substance flow analysis / Recycling / Sustainability

Highlight

	● Germanium has undergone profound metamorphoses of its global market over decades.
	● China’s total domestic demand for germanium will reach 164–187 t in 2050.
	● A shortage crisis of germanium is likely to occur before 2040.
	● Recycling from germanium waste potentially meets about 30% of demand.

References

[1] Alexandre C P, Christoph H, Philippe L, Antoine B, Stéphanie M, Jacques V, Bertrand L, Andrea T, Axel T, Guido S. (2022). Losses and lifetimes of metals in the economy. Nature Sustainability, 5(8): 717–726

[2] Arroyo F, Font O, Chimenos J M, Fernández-Pereira C, Querol X, Coca P. (2014). IGCC fly ash valorisation: optimisation of Ge and Ga recovery for an industrial application. Fuel Processing Technology, 124: 222–227

[3] Arroyo F, Font O, Fernandez-Pereira C, Querol X, Juan R, Ruiz C, Coca P. (2009). Germanium recovery from gasification fly ash: evaluation of end-products obtained by precipitation methods. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 167(1−3): 582–588

[4] BIO by Deloitte. (2015). Study on Data for a Raw Material System Analysis: Roadmap and Test of the Fully Operational MSA for Raw Materials. Prepared for the European Commission, DG GROW. Brooklyn: BIO by Deloitte,

[5] Bosi M, Attolini G. (2010). Germanium: epitaxy and its applications. Progress in Crystal Growth and Characterization of Materials, 56(3−4): 146–174

[6] BrunnerP H, Rechberger H (2016). Handbook of Material Flow Analysis: For Environmental, Resource, and Waste Engineers. 2nd ed. Boca Raton: CRC Press

[7] Chen W Q, Graedel T E. (2015). Improved alternatives for estimating in-use material stocks. Environmental Science & Technology, 49(5): 3048–3055

[8] Cordella M, Alfieri F, Sanfelix J, Donatello S, Kaps R, Wolf O. (2020). Improving material efficiency in the life cycle of products: a review of EU ecolabel criteria. International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 25(5): 921–935

[9] Cullen J M, Cooper D R. (2022). Material flows and efficiency. Annual Review of Materials Research, 52: 525–559

[10] Deng T, Zhang Y, Fu C. (2023). Modelling dynamic interactions between material flow and stock: a review of dynamic material flow analysis. Ecological Indicators, 156: 111098

[11] European Commission. (2020). Study on the EU’s List of Critical Raw Materials, Factsheets on Critical Raw Materials. Brussels: Publications Office of the European Union,

[12] Gómez M, Xu G, Li J, Zeng X. (2023). Securing indium utilization for high-tech and renewable energy industries. Environmental Science & Technology, 57(6): 2611–2624

[13] GraedelT E, Allwood J, BiratJ P, BuchertM, Hageluken C, ReckB K, SibleyS F, Sonnemann G (2011). What do we know about metal recycling rates? Journal of Industrial Ecology, 15(3): 355–366

[14] Graedel T E, Barr R, Chandler C, Chase T, Choi J, Christoffersen L, Friedlander E, Henly C, Jun C, Nassar N T. . (2012). Methodology of metal criticality determination. Environmental Science & Technology, 46(2): 1063–1070

[15] JorgensonJ D (2006). Germanium Recycling in the United States in 2000. Reston: U.S. Geological Survey

[16] LiJ, Eheliyagoda D, GengY, YangZ, ZengX (2022). Examining the influence of copper recycling on prospective resource supply and carbon emission reduction. Fundamental Research, doi: 10.1016/j.fmre.2022.09.022

[17] Licht C, Peiró L T, Villalba G. (2015). Global substance flow analysis of gallium, germanium, and indium: quantification of extraction, uses, and dissipative losses within their anthropogenic cycles. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 19(5): 890–903

[18] LinB L, Guo J, XuG F (2020). Application prospect and development suggestions of germanium in the new situation. Natural Resources Information, 10: 61–666666

[19] MelcherF, Buchholz P (2012). Current and Future Germanium Availability from Primary Sources. Berlin: Deutsche Rohstoffagentur

[20] MelcherF, Buchholz P (201201). Critical Metals Handbook. Keyworth: The British Geological Survey

[21] Meng Y M, Hu R Z, Huang X W, Gao J F. (2017). Germanium in magnetite: a preliminary review. Acta Geologica Sinica, 91(2): 711–726

[22] MercerC N (2015). Germanium: Giving Microelectronics an Efficiency Boost. Reston: U.S. Geological Survey

[23] Moskalyk R R. (2004). Review of germanium processing worldwide. Minerals Engineering, 17(3): 393–402

[24] Murakami S, Oguchi M, Tasaki T, Daigo I, Hashimoto S. (2010). Lifespan of commodities, Part I. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 14(4): 598–612

[25] Nguyen T H, Lee M S. (2021). A review on germanium resources and its extraction by hydrometallurgical method. Mineral Processing and Extractive Metallurgy Review, 42(6): 406–426

[26] Oguchi M, Murakami S, Tasaki T, Daigo I, Hashimoto S. (2010). Lifespan of commodities, part II. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 14(4): 613–626

[27] Patel M, Karamalidis A K. (2021). Germanium: a review of its US demand, uses, resources, chemistry, and separation technologies. Separation and Purification Technology, 275: 118981

[28] Reck B K, Graedel T E. (2012). Challenges in metal recycling. Science, 337(6095): 690–695

[29] Reportlinker(2019). Global and China Optical Fiber Preform Industry Report, 2019–2025. Dublin: Research and Markets

[30] Robertz B, Verhelle J, Schurmans M. (2015). The primary and secondary production of germanium: a life-cycle assessment of different process alternatives. Journal of the Minerals Metals & Materials Society, 67(2): 412–424

[31] Seredin V V, Dai S F, Sun Y Z, Chekryzhov I Y. (2013). Coal deposits as promising sources of rare metals for alternative power and energy-efficient technologies. Applied Geochemistry, 31: 1–11

[32] ShanksW C P III, KimballB E, TolcinA C, GubermanD E (2017). Germanium and indium. In: Schulz K J, DeYoung J J H, Seal R R II, Bradley D C, eds. Critical mineral resources of the United States—Economic and Environmental Geology and Prospects for Future Supply. Reston: U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1802, I1–I27

[33] Shao L, Zhang H, Zhang T, Cao S, Lan T. (2023). Securing the supply of clean energy metals to achieve carbon reduction: a review. Carbon Footprints, 2(3): 16

[34] SunJ Z, Chen B W, ShangH, MoX L, WenJ K (2022). Research progress in biohydrometallurgy of rare metals and heavy nonferrous metals with an emphasis on China. In: Ouchi, T, Azimi G, Forsberg K, Kim H, Alam S, Neelameggham N R, Baba A A, Peng H, eds. Rare Metal Technology 2022. The Minerals, Metals & Materials Series. Cham: Springer

[35] Sverdrup H U, Olafsdottir A H. (2023). Modelling the dynamics of the industrial vanadium cycle using the WORLD7 Integrated Assessment Model. Resources. Environment and Sustainability, 13: 100121

[36] Swart P, Dewulf J, Van Langenhove H, Moonens K, Dessein K, Quaeyhaegens C. (2011). Assessment of the overall resource consumption of germanium wafer production for high concentration photovoltaics. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 55(12): 1119–1128

[37] Tao J, Tao Z, Liu Z H. (2021). Review on resources and recycling of germanium, with special focus on characteristics, mechanism and challenges of solvent extraction. Journal of Cleaner Production, 294: 126217

[38] ThomasC L (2021). 2018 Minerals Yearbook: Germanium. Reston: U.S. Geological Survey

[39] WeckendS, Wade A, HeathG (2016). End of Life Management: Solar Photovoltaic Panels. Masdar: International Renewable Energy Agency,NSW: International Energy Agency Photovoltaic Power Systems

[40] Wen H J, Zhu C W, Du S J, Fan Y, Luo C G. (2020). Gallium(Ga), germanium(Ge), thallium(Tl) and cadmium(Cd) resources in China. Chinese Science Bulletin, 65(33): 3688–3699

[41] YangJ, Hu X, SundqvistL, ErikssonJ, Yli-Rantala E, BachérJ, DrzazgaM, Retegan T (2018). Production Technologies of CRM from Primary Resources: SCRREEN Deliverables D4.1. Brussels: European Union

[42] Zhang L, Xu Z. (2018). A critical review of material flow, recycling technologies, challenges and future strategy for scattered metals from minerals to wastes. Journal of Cleaner Production, 202: 1001–1025

[43] Zhao G, Geng Y, Tang C, Hao H, Bleischwitz R, Tian X. (2022). Improving aluminium resource efficiency in China: based upon material flow analysis and entropy analysis. Circular Economy, 1(1): 100005

[44] ZimmermannT, Goessling-Reisemann S, SanderK (2013). Potential availability of secondary scarce metals from selected applications in Germany. In: Ludwig C, Matasci C, Edelmann X, eds. Natural Resources: Sustainable Targets, Technologies, Lifestyles and Governance. Villigen, Villigen PSI, St. Gallen: World Resources Forum, 283–288

[45] Zimmermann T, Gößling-Reisemann S. (2014). Recycling potentials of critical metals: analyzing secondary flows from selected applications. Resources, 3(1): 291–318

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Higher Education Press 2025