Integrated risk assessment framework for transformation products of emerging contaminants: what we know and what we should know

Abstract

● A better risk assessment can combine the improved non-target analysis method.

● Multi-evidence is advised in molecular determination and risk-based prioritization.

● Combining omics, multi-endpoint EDA, and machine learning to assess product risks.

The continuous input of various emerging contaminants (ECs) has inevitably introduced large amounts of transformation products (TPs) in natural and engineering water scenarios. Structurally similar to the precursor species, the TPs are expected to possess comparative, if not more serious, environmental properties and risks. This review summarizes the state-of-the-art knowledge regarding the integrated risk assessment frameworks of TPs of ECs, mainly involving the exposure- and effect-driven analysis. The inadequate information within existing frameworks that was essential and critical for developing a better risk assessment framework was discussed. The main strategic improvements include (1) non-targeted product analysis in both laboratory and field samples, (2) omics-based high-throughput toxicity assessment, (3) multichannel-driven mode of action in conjugation with effect-directed analysis, and (4) machine learning technology. Overall, this review provides a concise but comprehensive insight into the optimized strategy for evaluating the environmental risks and screening the key toxic products from the cocktail mixtures of ECs and their TPs in the global water cycle. This facilitates deciphering the mode of toxicity in complex chemical mixtures and prioritizing the regulated TPs among the unknown products, which have the potential to be considered a class of novel “ECs” of great concern.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Risk assessment frameworks / Transformation products / Emerging contaminants / High-throughput toxicity screening / Water treatment

References

[1] Altenburger R , Scholz S , Schmitt-Jansen M , Busch W , Escher B I . (2012). Mixture toxicity revisited from a toxicogenomic perspective. Environmental Science & Technology, 46(5): 2508–2522

[2] Brack W (2003). Effect-directed analysis: a promising tool for the identification of organic toxicants in complex mixtures? Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 377(3): 397–407

[3] Brack W , Aissa S A , Backhaus T , Dulio V , Escher B I , Faust M , Hilscherova K , Hollender J , Hollert H , Müller C . . (2019). Effect-based methods are key: the European collaborative project solutions recommends integrating effect-based methods for diagnosis and monitoring of water quality. Environmental Sciences Europe, 31: 10

[4] Brinkmann M , Montgomery D , Selinger S , Miller J G P , Stock E , Alcaraz A J , Challis J K , Weber L , Janz D , Hecker M . . (2022). Acute toxicity of the tire rubber-derived chemical 6PPD-quinone to four fishes of commercial, cultural, and ecological importance. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 9(4): 333–338

[5] Brockmeier E K , Hodges G , Hutchinson T H , Butler E , Hecker M , Tollefsen K E , Garcia-Reyero N , Kille P , Becker D , Chipman K . . (2017). The role of omics in the application of adverse outcome pathways for chemical risk assessment. Toxicological Sciences, 158(2): 252–262

[6] Cao G , Wang W , Zhang J , Wu P , Zhao X , Yang Z , Hu D , Cai Z . (2022). New evidence of rubber-derived quinones in water, air, and soil. Environmental Science & Technology, 56(7): 4142–4150

[7] Challis J K , Popick H , Prajapati S , Harder P , Giesy J P , McPhedran K , Brinkmann M . (2021). Occurrences of tire rubber-derived contaminants in cold-climate urban runoff. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 8(11): 961–967

[8] Chibwe L , Titaley I A , Hoh E , Simonich S L M . (2017). Integrated framework for identifying toxic transformation products in complex environmental mixtures. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 4(2): 32–43

[9] Deng Y , Zhang Y , Ren H . (2022). Multi-omic studies on the toxicity variations in effluents from different units of reclaimed water treatment. Water Research, 208: 117874

[10] Escher B I, Aїt-Aїssa S, Behnisch P A, Brack W, Brion F, Brouwer A, Buchinger S, Crawford S E, du Pasquier D, Hamers T, et al. (2018). Effect-based trigger values for in vitro and in vivo bioassays performed on surface water extracts supporting the environmental quality standards (EQS) of the European water framework directive. Science of the Total Environment, 628–629: 748–765

[11] Escher B I , Fenner K . (2011). Recent advances in environmental risk assessment of transformation products. Environmental Science & Technology, 45(9): 3835–3847

[12] Escher B I , Stapleton H M , Schymanski E L . (2020). Tracking complex mixtures of chemicals in our changing environment. Science, 367(6476): 388–392

[13] Evich M G , Davis M J B , McCord J P , Acrey B , Awkerman J A , Knappe D R U , Lindstrom A B , Speth T F , Tebes-Stevens C , Strynar M J . . (2022). Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances in the environment. Science, 375(6580): eabg9065

[14] Fang W , Peng Y , Yan L , Xia P , Zhang X . (2020). A tiered approach for screening and assessment of environmental mixtures by omics and in vitro assays. Environmental Science & Technology, 54(12): 7430–7439

[15] Feng X , Li D , Liang W , Ruan T , Jiang G . (2021). Recognition and prioritization of chemical mixtures and transformation products in chinese estuarine waters by suspect screening analysis. Environmental Science & Technology, 55(14): 9508–9517

[16] Fenner K , Scheringer M , Hungerbühler K . (2000). Persistence of parent compounds and transformation products in a level IV multimedia model. Environmental Science & Technology, 34(17): 3809–3817

[17] Gao J , Song J , Ye J , Duan X , Dionysiou D D , Yadav J S , Nadagouda M N , Yang L , Luo S . (2021). Comparative toxicity reduction potential of UV/sodium percarbonate and UV/hydrogen peroxide treatments for bisphenol A in water: an integrated analysis using chemical, computational, biological, and metabolomic approaches. Water Research, 190: 116755

[18] Guo K , Wu Z , Chen C , Fang J . (2022). UV/chlorine process: an efficient advanced oxidation process with multiple radicals and functions in water treatment. Accounts of Chemical Research, 55(3): 286–297

[19] Gupta S , Aga D , Pruden A , Zhang L , Vikesland P . (2021). Data analytics for environmental science and engineering research. Environmental Science & Technology, 55(16): 10895–10907

[20] Han Y , Zhao J , Huang R , Xia M , Wang D . (2018). Omics-based platform for studying chemical toxicity using stem cells. Journal of Proteome Research, 17(1): 579–589

[21] Hensen B , Olsson O , Kümmerer K . (2020). A strategy for an initial assessment of the ecotoxicological effects of transformation products of pesticides in aquatic systems following a tiered approach. Environment International, 137: 105533

[22] Hernandez A F , Buha A , Constantin C , Wallace D R , Sarigiannis D , Neagu M , Antonijevic B , Hayes A W , Wilks M F , Tsatsakis A . (2019). Critical assessment and integration of separate lines of evidence for risk assessment of chemical mixtures. Archives of Toxicology, 93(10): 2741–2757

[23] Hiki K , Asahina K , Kato K , Yamagishi T , Omagari R , Iwasaki Y , Watanabe H , Yamamoto H . (2021). Acute toxicity of a tire rubber-derived chemical, 6PPD quinone, to freshwater fish and crustacean species. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 8(9): 779–784

[24] Hites R A, Jobst K J (2018). Is nontargeted screening reproducible? Environmental Science & Technology, 52(21): 11975–11976

[25] Hollender J, Schymanski E L, Singer H P, Ferguson P L (2017). Nontarget screening with high resolution mass spectrometry in the environment: Ready to go? Environmental Science & Technology, 51(20): 11505–11512

[26] Huang R , Ma C , Ma J , Huangfu X , He Q . (2021). Machine learning in natural and engineered water systems. Water Research, 205: 117666

[27] Jobst K J , Shen L , Reiner E J , Taguchi V Y , Helm P A , McCrindle R , Backus S . (2013). The use of mass defect plots for the identification of (novel) halogenated contaminants in the environment. Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 405(10): 3289–3297

[28] Johannessen C , Helm P , Lashuk B , Yargeau V , Metcalfe C D . (2022). The tire wear compounds 6PPD-quinone and 1,3-diphenylguanidine in an urban watershed. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 82(2): 171–179

[29] Johannessen C , Helm P , Metcalfe C D . (2021). Detection of selected tire wear compounds in urban receiving waters. Environmental Pollution, 287: 117659

[30] Johnson A C , Jin X , Nakada N , Sumpter J P . (2020). Learning from the past and considering the future of chemicals in the environment. Science, 367(6476): 384–387

[31] Kar S , Sanderson H , Roy K , Benfenati E , Leszczynski J . (2020). Ecotoxicological assessment of pharmaceuticals and personal care products using predictive toxicology approaches. Green Chemistry, 22(5): 1458–1516

[32] Labib S , Williams A , Kuo B , Yauk C L , White P A , Halappanavar S . (2017). A framework for the use of single-chemical transcriptomics data in predicting the hazards associated with complex mixtures of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Archives of Toxicology, 91(7): 2599–2616

[33] Lai A , Clark A M , Escher B I , Fernandez M , McEwen L R , Tian Z , Wang Z , Schymanski E L . (2022). The next frontier of environmental unknowns: substances of unknown or variable composition, complex reaction products, or biological materials (UVCBs). Environmental Science & Technology, 56(12): 7448–7466

[34] Lapointe M , Rochman C M , Tufenkji N . (2022). Sustainable strategies to treat urban runoff needed. Nature Sustainability, 5(5): 366–369

[35] Liu Q , Li L , Zhang X , Saini A , Li W , Hung H , Hao C , Li K , Lee P , Wentzell J J B . . (2021). Uncovering global-scale risks from commercial chemicals in air. Nature, 600(7889): 456–461

[36] Lorenz S , Amsel A K , Puhlmann N , Reich M , Olsson O , Kümmerer K . (2021). Toward application and implementation of in silico tools and workflows within benign by design approaches. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, 9(37): 12461–12475

[37] Mahler B J , Nowell L H , Sandstrom M W , Bradley P M , Romanok K M , Konrad C P , van Metre P C . (2021). Inclusion of pesticide transformation products is key to estimating pesticide exposures and effects in small U.S. streams. Environmental Science & Technology, 55(8): 4740–4752

[38] Menger F , Boström G , Jonsson O , Ahrens L , Wiberg K , Kreuger J , Gago-Ferrero P . (2021). Identification of pesticide transformation products in surface water using suspect screening combined with national monitoring data. Environmental Science & Technology, 55(15): 10343–10353

[39] Mijangos L , Krauss M , de Miguel L , Ziarrusta H , Olivares M , Zuloaga O , Izagirre U , Schulze T , Brack W , Prieto A . . (2020). Application of the sea urchin embryo test in toxicity evaluation and effect-directed analysis of wastewater treatment plant effluents. Environmental Science & Technology, 54(14): 8890–8899

[40] Monaghan J , Jaeger A , Agua A R , Stanton R S , Pirrung M , Gill C G , Krogh E T . (2021). A direct mass spectrometry method for the rapid analysis of ubiquitous tire-derived toxin N-(1,3-Dimethylbutyl)-N′-phenyl-p-phenylenediamine quinone (6-PPDQ). Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 8(12): 1051–1056

[41] Neale P A , O’Brien J W , Glauch L , König M , Krauss M , Mueller J F , Tscharke B , Escher B I . (2020). Wastewater treatment efficacy evaluated with in vitro bioassays. Water Research X, 9: 100072

[42] Ng C A , Scheringer M , Fenner K , Hungerbuhler K . (2011). A framework for evaluating the contribution of transformation products to chemical persistence in the environment. Environmental Science & Technology, 45(1): 111–117

[43] North M , Vulpe C D . (2010). Functional toxicogenomics: mechanism-centered toxicology. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 11(12): 4796–4813

[44] Pochiraju S S , Linden K , Gu A Z , Rosenblum J . (2020). Development of a separation framework for effects-based targeted and non-targeted toxicological screening of water and wastewater. Water Research, 170: 115289

[45] Prasse C , Ford B , Nomura D K , Sedlak D L . (2018). Unexpected transformation of dissolved phenols to toxic dicarbonyls by hydroxyl radicals and UV light. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 115(10): 2311–2316

[46] Rauert C , Charlton N , Okoffo E D , Stanton R S , Agua A R , Pirrung M C , Thomas K . (2022). Concentrations of tire additive chemicals and tire road wear particles in an australian urban tributary. Environmental Science & Technology, 56(4): 2421–2431

[47] Richardson S D , Ternes T A . (2022). Water analysis: emerging contaminants and current issues. Analytical Chemistry, 94(1): 382–416

[48] Sauer U G , Deferme L , Gribaldo L , Hackermüller J , Tralau T , van Ravenzwaay B , Yauk C , Poole A , Tong W , Gant T W . (2017). The challenge of the application of omics technologies in chemicals risk assessment: background and outlook. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology, 91: S14–S26

[49] Schenker U , Scheringer M , Macleod M , Martin J W , Cousins I T , Hungerbühler K . (2008). Contribution of volatile precursor substances to the flux of perfluorooctanoate to the arctic. Environmental Science & Technology, 42(10): 3710–3716

[50] Schröder S , San-Román M F , Ortiz I . (2021). Dioxins and furans toxicity during the photocatalytic remediation of emerging pollutants: triclosan as case study. Science of the Total Environment, 770: 144853

[51] Shen H , McHale C M , Smith M T , Zhang L . (2015). Functional genomic screening approaches in mechanistic toxicology and potential future applications of CRISPR-Cas9. Mutation Research/Reviews in Mutation Research, 764: 31–42

[52] Tang F H M , Lenzen M , McBratney A , Maggi F . (2021). Risk of pesticide pollution at the global scale. Nature Geoscience, 14(4): 206–210

[53] Tian Z , Zhao H , Peter K T , Gonzalez M , Wetzel J , Wu C , Hu X , Prat J , Mudrock E , Hettinger R . . (2021). A ubiquitous tire rubber–derived chemical induces acute mortality in coho salmon. Science, 371(6525): 185–189

[54] Vinggaard A M , Bonefeld-Jørgensen E C , Jensen T K , Fernandez M F , Rosenmai A K , Taxvig C , Rodriguez-Carrillo A , Wielsøe M , Long M , Olea N . . (2021). Receptor-based in vitro activities to assess human exposure to chemical mixtures and related health impacts. Environment International, 146: 106191

[55] Vione D , Carena L . (2020). The possible production of harmful intermediates is the “dark side” of the environmental photochemistry of contaminants (potentially adverse effects, and many knowledge gaps). Environmental Science & Technology, 54(9): 5328–5330

[56] von Gunten U (2018). Oxidation processes in water treatment: Are we on track? Environmental Science & Technology, 52(9): 5062–5075

[57] Wang B , Yu G . (2022). Emerging contaminant control: from science to action. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 16(6): 81

[58] Wang W , Wu Q , Huang N , Xu Z , Lee M , Hu H . (2018). Potential risks from UV/H₂O₂ oxidation and UV photocatalysis: a review of toxic, assimilable, and sensory-unpleasant transformation products. Water Research, 141: 109–125

[59] Wang X , Yu N , Yang J , Jin L , Guo H , Shi W , Zhang X , Yang L , Yu H , Wei S . (2020). Suspect and non-target screening of pesticides and pharmaceuticals transformation products in wastewater using QTOF-MS. Environment International, 137: 105599

[60] Washington J W , Rosal C G , Ulrich E M , Jenkins T M . (2019). Use of carbon isotopic ratios in nontargeted analysis to screen for anthropogenic compounds in complex environmental matrices. Journal of Chromatography. A, 1583: 73–79

[61] Xia P , Zhang H , Peng Y , Shi W , Zhang X . (2020). Pathway-based assessment of single chemicals and mixtures by a high-throughput transcriptomics approach. Environment International, 136: 105455

[62] Yang K , Zhang Z , Hu K , Peng B , Wang W , Liang H , Yan C , Wu M , Wang Y . (2023). Untargeted metabolomic analysis of pregnant women exposure to perfluorooctanoic acid at different degrees. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 17(3): 28

[63] Yang Y, Zhang X, Jiang J, Han J, Li W, Li X, Yee Leung K M, Snyder S A, Alvarez P J J (2022). Which micropollutants in water environments deserve more attention globally? Environmental Science & Technology, 56(1): 13–29

[64] Yu Y , Wu L . (2015). Determination and occurrence of endocrine disrupting compounds, pharmaceuticals and personal care products in fish (Morone saxatilis). Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 9(3): 475–481

[65] Zhang S , Ye C , Li J , Yu X , Feng M . (2021). Treatment-driven removal efficiency, product formation, and toxicity evolution of antineoplastic agents: current status and implications for water safety assessment. Water Research, 206: 117729

[66] Zhang S , Yin Q , Zhang S , Manoli K , Zhang L , Yu X , Feng M . (2022). Chlorination of methotrexate in water revisited: deciphering the kinetics, novel reaction mechanisms, and unexpected microbial risks. Water Research, 225: 119181

[67] Zhang X , Xia P , Wang P , Yang J , Baird D J . (2018). Omics advances in ecotoxicology. Environmental Science & Technology, 52(7): 3842–3851

[68] Zhong S , Zhang K , Bagheri M , Burken J G , Gu A , Li B , Ma X , Marrone B L , Ren Z J , Schrier J , Shi W , Tan H , Wang T , Wang X , Wong B M , Xiao X , Yu X , Zhu J J , Zhang H . (2021). Machine learning: New ideas and tools in environmental science and engineering. Environmental Science & Technology, 55: 12741–12754

[69] Zwart N , Jonker W , Broek R , de Boer J , Somsen G , Kool J , Hamers T , Houtman C J , Lamoree M H . (2020). Identification of mutagenic and endocrine disrupting compounds in surface water and wastewater treatment plant effluents using high-resolution effect-directed analysis. Water Research, 168: 115204

[70] Zwart N , Nio S L , Houtman C J , de Boer J , Kool J , Hamers T , Lamoree M H . (2018). High-throughput effect-directed analysis using downscaled in vitro reporter gene assays to identify endocrine disruptors in surface water. Environmental Science & Technology, 52(7): 4367–4377

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Higher Education Press