Technologies for pollutant removal and resource recovery from blackwater: a review

Abstract

● Blackwater is the main source of organics and nutrients in domestic wastewater.

● Various treatment methods can be applied for resource recovery from blackwater.

● Blackwater treatment systems of high integration and efficiency are the future trend.

● More research is needed for the practical use of blackwater treatment systems.

Blackwater (BW), consisting of feces, urine, flushing water and toilet paper, makes up an important portion of domestic wastewater. The improper disposal of BW may lead to environmental pollution and disease transmission, threatening the sustainable development of the world. Rich in nutrients and organic matter, BW could be treated for resource recovery and reuse through various approaches. Aimed at providing guidance for the future development of BW treatment and resource recovery, this paper presented a literature review of BWs produced in different countries and types of toilets, including their physiochemical characteristics, and current treatment and resource recovery strategies. The degradation and utilization of carbon (C), nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) within BW are underlined. The performance of different systems was classified and summarized. Among all the treating systems, biological and ecological systems have been long and widely applied for BW treatment, showing their universality and operability in nutrients and energy recovery, but they are either slow or ineffective in removal of some refractory pollutants. Novel processes, especially advanced oxidation processes (AOPs), are becoming increasingly extensively studied in BW treatment because of their high efficiency, especially for the removal of micropollutants and pathogens. This review could serve as an instructive guidance for the design and optimization of BW treatment technologies, aiming to help in the fulfilment of sustainable human excreta management.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Blackwater / Water-flushing toilet / Sanitation / Nutrient recovery / Water reuse / Sustainable development

References

[1] Aburto-Medina A, Shahsavari E, Khudur L S, Brown S, Ball A S. (2020). A review of dry sanitation systems. Sustainability (Basel), 12(14): 5812

[2] Adhikari J R, Lohani S P. (2019). Design, installation, operation and experimentation of septic tank: UASB wastewater treatment system. Renewable Energy, 143: 1406–1415

[3] Al-Jamal W, Mahmoud N. (2009). Community onsite treatment of cold strong sewage in a UASB-septic tank. Bioresource Technology, 100(3): 1061–1068

[4] Andersson K, Otoo M, Nolasco M. (2018). Innovative sanitation approaches could address multiple development challenges. Water Science and Technology, 77(4): 855–858

[5] Anglada A, Urtiaga A, Ortiz I. (2009). Contributions of electrochemical oxidation to waste-water treatment: fundamentals and review of applications. Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 84(12): 1747–1755

[6] Banik S, Bandyopadhyay S, Ganguly S. (2003). Bioeffects of microwave: a brief review. Bioresource Technology, 87(2): 155–159

[7] Barbosa S G, Rodrigues T, Peixoto L, Kuntke P, Alves M M, Pereira M A, Ter Heijne A. (2019). Anaerobic biological fermentation of urine as a strategy to enhance the performance of a microbial electrolysis cell (MEC). Renewable Energy, 139: 936–943

[8] Boyjoo Y, Pareek V K, Ang M. (2013). A review of greywater characteristics and treatment processes. Water Science and Technology, 67(7): 1403–1424

[9] Butkovskyi A, Ni G, Hernandez Leal L, Rijnaarts H H, Zeeman G. (2016). Mitigation of micropollutants for black water application in agriculture via composting of anaerobic sludge. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 303: 41–47

[10] Butkovskyi A, Sevenou L, Meulepas R J W, Hernandez Leal L, Zeeman G, Rijnaarts H H M. (2018). Micropollutant removal from black water and grey water sludge in a UASB-GAC reactor. Water Science and Technology, 77(4): 1137–1148

[11] Cai T, Park S Y, Li Y. (2013). Nutrient recovery from wastewater streams by microalgae: status and prospects. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 19: 360–369

[12] Castro C J, Goodwill J E, Rogers B, Henderson M, Butler C S. (2014). Deployment of the microbial fuel cell latrine in Ghana for decentralized sanitation. Journal of Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene for Development : a Journal of the International Water Association, 4(4): 663–671

[13] Cecconet D, Callegari A, Hlavinek P, Capodaglio A G. (2019). Membrane bioreactors for sustainable, fit-for-purpose greywater treatment: a critical review. Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy, 21(4): 745–762

[14] Cheng S K, Li Z F, Uddin S M N, Mang H P, Zhou X Q, Zhang J, Zheng L, Zhang L L. (2018). Toilet revolution in China. Journal of Environmental Management, 216: 347–356

[15] Chun D, Lim C R, Lee H S, Yoon W S, Lee T K, Kim D K. (2018). Electrochemical treatment of urine by using Ti/IrO₂/TiO₂ electrode. Journal of Water Process Engineering, 26: 1–9

[16] CidC AAbiola FStarklM (2022). Can international nonsewered sanitation standards help solve the global sanitation crisis? Environmental Science & Technology, 56(2): 699–706

[17] Cid C A, Jasper J T, Hoffmann M R. (2018a). Phosphate recovery from human waste via the formation of hydroxyapatite during electrochemical wastewater treatment. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, 6(3): 3135–3142

[18] Cid C A, Qu Y, Hoffmann M R. (2018b). Design and preliminary implementation of onsite electrochemical wastewater treatment and recycling toilets for the developing world. Environmental Science. Water Research & Technology, 4(10): 1439–1450

[19] Connelly S, Pussayanavin T, J. Randle-Boggis R, Wicheansan A, Jampathong S, Keating C, Z. Ijaz U, T. Sloan W, Koottatep T. (2019). Solar septic tank: next generation sequencing reveals effluent microbial community composition as a useful index of system performance. Water (Basel), 11(12): 2660

[20] Davey C J, Thomas N, McAdam E J. (2022). Downscaling reverse osmosis for single-household wastewater reuse: towards low-cost decentralised sanitation through a batch open-loop configuration. Journal of Water Reuse and Desalination, 12(2): 191–205

[21] De Graaff M S, Temmink H, Zeeman G, Buisman C J N. (2010). Anaerobic treatment of concentrated black water in a UASB reactor at a short HRT. Water (Basel), 2(1): 101–119

[22] Dorji U, Dorji P, Shon H, Badeti U, Dorji C, Wangmo C, Tijing L, Kandasamy J, Vigneswaran S, Chanan A, Phuntsho S. (2022). On-site domestic wastewater treatment system using shredded waste plastic bottles as biofilter media: pilot-scale study on effluent standards in Bhutan. Chemosphere, 286: 131729

[23] Englehardt J D, Wu T, Tchobanoglous G. (2013). Urban net-zero water treatment and mineralization: Experiments, modeling and design. Water Research, 47(13): 4680–4691

[24] Escapa A, Mateos R, Martinez E J, Blanes J. (2016). Microbial electrolysis cells: an emerging technology for wastewater treatment and energy recovery: from laboratory to pilot plant and beyond. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 55: 942–956

[25] Feng Y, Yang L, Liu J, Logan B E. (2016). Electrochemical technologies for wastewater treatment and resource reclamation. Environmental Science. Water Research & Technology, 2(5): 800–831

[26] Fidjeland J, Svensson S E, Vinneras B. (2015). Ammonia sanitization of blackwater for safe use as fertilizer. Water Science and Technology, 71(5): 795–800

[27] Florentino A P, Sharaf A, Zhang L, Liu Y. (2019a). Overcoming ammonia inhibition in anaerobic blackwater treatment with granular activated carbon: the role of electroactive microorganisms. Environmental Science. Water Research & Technology, 5(2): 383–396

[28] Florentino A P, Xu R, Zhang L, Liu Y. (2019b). Anaerobic digestion of blackwater assisted by granular activated carbon: from digestion inhibition to methanogenesis enhancement. Chemosphere, 233: 462–471

[29] Gao M, Guo B, Zhang L, Zhang Y, Liu Y. (2019a). Microbial community dynamics in anaerobic digesters treating conventional and vacuum toilet flushed blackwater. Water Research, 160: 249–258

[30] GaoMZhangL FlorentinoA PLiuY (2019b). Performance of anaerobic treatment of blackwater collected from different toilet flushing systems: Can we achieve both energy recovery and water conservation? Journal of Hazardous Materials, 365: 44–52

[31] Gao T, Xiao K, Zhang J, Xue W, Wei C, Zhang X, Liang S, Wang X, Huang X. (2022). Techno-economic characteristics of wastewater treatment plants retrofitted from the conventional activated sludge process to the membrane bioreactor process. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 16(4): 49

[32] Gell K, Ruijter F J, Kuntke P, Graaff M, Smit A L. (2011). Safety and effectiveness of struvite from black water and urine as a phosphorus fertilizer. Journal of Agricultural Science (Toronto), 3(3): 67–80

[33] Gil-Carrera L, Escapa A, Mehta P, Santoyo G, Guiot S R, Moran A, Tartakovsky B. (2013). Microbial electrolysis cell scale-up for combined wastewater treatment and hydrogen production. Bioresource Technology, 130: 584–591

[34] Gonzalez-Rivas N, Reyes-Pérez H, Barrera-Díaz C E. (2019). Recent advances in water and wastewater electrodisinfection. ChemElectroChem, 6(7): 1978–1983

[35] Gros M, Ahrens L, Leven L, Koch A, Dalahmeh S, Ljung E, Lundin G, Jonsson H, Eveborn D, Wiberg K. (2020). Pharmaceuticals in source separated sanitation systems: fecal sludge and blackwater treatment. Science of the Total Environment, 703: 135530

[36] Guo X S, Liu Z H, Chen M X, Liu J X, Yang M. (2014). Decentralized wastewater treatment technologies and management in Chinese villages. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 8(6): 929–936

[37] Hamedi H, Ehteshami M, Mirbagheri S A, Rasouli S A, Zendehboudi S. (2019). Current status and future prospects of membrane bioreactors (MBRs) and fouling phenomena: a systematic review. Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, 97(1): 32–58

[38] Haque R, Mondal D, Kirkpatrick B D, Akther S, Farr B M, Sack R B, Petri W A. (2003). Epidemiologic and clinical characteristics of acute diarrhea with emphasis on Entamoeba histolytica infections in preschool children in an urban slum of Dhaka, Bangladesh. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 69(4): 398–405

[39] Harder R, Wielemaker R, Larsen T A, Zeeman G, Oberg G. (2019). Recycling nutrients contained in human excreta to agriculture: pathways, processes, and products. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 49(8): 695–743

[40] Haupt D, Muddemann T, Kunz U, Sievers M. (2019). Evaluation of a new electrochemical concept for vacuum toilet wastewater treatment: comparison with ozonation and peroxone processes. Electrochemistry Communications, 101: 115–119

[41] Hawkins B T, Rogers T W, Davey C J, Stoner M H, McAdam E J, Stoner B R. (2019). Improving energy efficiency of electrochemical blackwater disinfection through sequential reduction of suspended solids and chemical oxygen demand. Gates Open Research, 2: 50

[42] Hawkins B T, Sellgren K L, Klem E J D, Piascik J R, Stoner B R. (2017). Electrochemical disinfection of repeatedly recycled blackwater in a free-standing, additive-free toilet. Water and Environment Journal: the Journal/the Chartered Institution of Water and Environmental Management, 31(4): 545–551

[43] Hong Y, Huang G, An C, Song P, Xin X, Chen X, Zhang P, Zhao Y, Zheng R. (2019). Enhanced nitrogen removal in the treatment of rural domestic sewage using vertical-flow multi-soil-layering systems: experimental and modeling insights. Journal of Environmental Management, 240: 273–284

[44] Huang Q, Liu Y, Dhar B R. (2021). Pushing the organic loading rate in electrochemically assisted anaerobic digestion of blackwater at ambient temperature: insights into microbial community dynamics. Science of the Total Environment, 781: 146694

[45] Huang X, Qu Y, Cid C A, Finke C, Hoffmann M R, Lim K, Jiang S C. (2016). Electrochemical disinfection of toilet wastewater using wastewater electrolysis cell. Water Research, 92: 164–172

[46] Hyun K S, Lee S J. (2009). Biofilm/membrane filtration for reclamation and reuse of rural wastewaters. Water Science and Technology, 59(11): 2145–2152

[47] Jin Z, Lv C, Zhao M, Zhang Y, Huang X, Bei K, Kong H, Zheng X. (2018a). Black water collected from the septic tank treated with a living machine system: HRT effect and microbial community structure. Chemosphere, 210: 745–752

[48] Jin Z, Xie X, Zhou J, Bei K, Zhang Y, Huang X, Zhao M, Kong H, Zheng X. (2018b). Blackwater treatment using vertical greening: efficiency and microbial community structure. Bioresource Technology, 249: 175–181

[49] Jin Z, Zheng Y, Li X, Dai C, Xu K, Bei K, Zheng X, Zhao M. (2020). Combined process of bio-contact oxidation-constructed wetland for blackwater treatment. Bioresource Technology, 316: 123891

[50] Kamranvand F, Davey C J, Sakar H, Autin O, Mercer E, Collins M, Williams L, Kolios A, Parker A, Tyrrel S, Cartmell E, McAdam E J. (2018). Impact of fouling, cleaning and faecal contamination on the separation of water from urine using thermally driven membrane separation. Separation Science and Technology, 53(9): 1372–1382

[51] Kamranvand F, Davey C J, Williams L, Parker A, Jiang Y, Tyrrel S, McAdam E J. (2020). Ultrafiltration pretreatment enhances membrane distillation flux, resilience and permeate quality during water recovery from concentrated blackwater (urine/faeces). Separation and Purification Technology, 253: 117547

[52] Karak T, Bhattacharyya P. (2011). Human urine as a source of alternative natural fertilizer in agriculture: a flight of fancy or an achievable reality. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 55(4): 400–408

[53] Khalid M, Hashmi I, Khan S J. (2017). Performance evaluation of membrane-based septic tank and its reuse potential for irrigating crops. Water Environment Research, 89(8): 744–751

[54] Khumalo N, Nthunya L, Derese S, Motsa M, Verliefde A, Kuvarega A, Mamba B B, Mhlanga S, Dlamini D S. (2019). Water recovery from hydrolysed human urine samples via direct contact membrane distillation using PVDF/PTFE membrane. Separation and Purification Technology, 211: 610–617

[55] Kivaisi A K. (2001). The potential for constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment and reuse in developing countries: a review. Ecological Engineering, 16(4): 545–560

[56] Knerr H, Rechenburg A, Kistemann T, Schmitt T G. (2011). Performance of a MBR for the treatment of blackwater. Water Science and Technology, 63(6): 1247–1254

[57] Kocbek E, Garcia H A, Hooijmans C M, Mijatovic I, Lah B, Brdjanovic D. (2020). Microwave treatment of municipal sewage sludge: evaluation of the drying performance and energy demand of a pilot-scale microwave drying system. Science of the Total Environment, 742: 140541

[58] Kozminykh P, Heistad A, Ratnaweera H C, Todt D. (2016). Impact of organic polyelectrolytes on coagulation of source-separated black water. Environmental Technology, 37(14): 1723–1732

[59] Kujawa-Roeleveld K, Elmitwalli T, Zeeman G. (2006). Enhanced primary treatment of concentrated black water and kitchen residues within DESAR concept using two types of anaerobic digesters. Water Science and Technology, 53(9): 159–168

[60] Lai A C K, Tan T F, Li W S, Ip D K M. (2018). Emission strength of airborne pathogens during toilet flushing. Indoor Air, 28(1): 73–79

[61] Lam L, Kurisu K, Hanaki K. (2015). Comparative environmental impacts of source-separation systems for domestic wastewater management in rural China. Journal of Cleaner Production, 104: 185–198

[62] Lansing S, Maile-Moskowitz A, Eaton A. (2017). Waste treatment and energy production from small-scale wastewater digesters. Bioresource Technology 245(Pt A), 801–809

[63] Latifian M, Holst O, Liu J. (2014). Nitrogen and phosphorus removal from urine by sequential struvite formation and recycling process. Clean (Weinheim), 42(8): 1157–1161

[64] Li M, Song G, Liu R, Huang X, Liu H. (2022). Inactivation and risk control of pathogenic microorganisms in municipal sludge treatment: a review. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 16(6): 70

[65] Li S M, Wu Z Z, Liu G Q. (2019). Degradation kinetics of toilet paper fiber during wastewater treatment: effects of solid retention time and microbial community. Chemosphere, 225: 915–926

[66] Liu H, Leng F, Guan Y, Yao Y, Li Y, Xu S. (2017). Simultaneous pollutant removal and electricity generation in a combined ABR-MFC-MEC system treating fecal wastewater. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution, 228(5): 179

[67] Liu H, Lv Y, Xu S, Chen Z, Lichtfouse E. (2020). Configuration and rapid start-up of a novel combined microbial electrolytic process treating fecal sewage. Science of the Total Environment, 705: 135986

[68] Luostarinen S, Rintala J. (2007). Anaerobic on-site treatment of kitchen waste in combination with black water in UASB-septic tanks at low temperatures. Bioresource Technology, 98(9): 1734–1740

[69] LuostarinenS ARintalaJ A (2005). Anaerobic on-site treatment of black water and dairy parlour wastewater in UASB-septic tanks at low temperatures. Water Research, 39(2–3): 436–448

[70] Ma H, Guo Y, Qin Y, Li Y Y. (2018). Nutrient recovery technologies integrated with energy recovery by waste biomass anaerobic digestion. Bioresource Technology, 269: 520–531

[71] Magri M E, Fidjeland J, Jonsson H, Albihn A, Vinneras B. (2015). Inactivation of adenovirus, reovirus and bacteriophages in fecal sludge by pH and ammonia. Science of the Total Environment, 520: 213–221

[72] Makhmalbaf M, Hosseini S M, Aghdaei H A, Niasar M S, Shoraka S, Yadegar A, Baradaran Ghavami S, Shahrokh S, Moshari M, Malekpour H, Zali M R, Mohebbi S R. (2022). Detection of SARS-CoV-2 genome in stool and plasma samples of laboratory confirmed Iranian COVID-19 patients. Frontiers in Molecular Biosciences, 9: 865129

[73] Manga M, Camargo-Valero M A, Anthonj C, Evans B E. (2021). Fate of faecal pathogen indicators during faecal sludge composting with different bulking agents in tropical climate. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health, 232: 113670

[74] Masi F, El Hamouri B, Abdel Shafi H, Baban A, Ghrabi A, Regelsberger M. (2010). Treatment of segregated black/grey domestic wastewater using constructed wetlands in the Mediterranean basin: the zer0-m experience. Water Science and Technology, 61(1): 97–105

[75] MawiooP MRweyemamu AGarciaH AHooijmansC MBrdjanovic D (2016). Evaluation of a microwave based reactor for the treatment of blackwater sludge. Science of the Total Environment, 548–549: 72–81

[76] Meinzinger F, Oldenburg M. (2009). Characteristics of source-separated household wastewater flows: a statistical assessment. Water Science and Technology, 59(9): 1785–1791

[77] Meng Y, Liu W, Fiedler H, Zhang J, Wei X, Liu X, Peng M, Zhang T. (2021). Fate and risk assessment of emerging contaminants in reclaimed water production processes. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(5): 104

[78] Moges M E, Todt D, Heistad A. (2018). Treatment of source-separated blackwater: a decentralized strategy for nutrient recovery towards a circular economy. Water (Basel), 10(4): 463

[79] Moñino P, Jimenez E, Barat R, Aguado D, Seco A, Ferrer J. (2016). Potential use of the organic fraction of municipal solid waste in anaerobic co-digestion with wastewater in submerged anaerobic membrane technology. Waste Management (New York, N.Y.), 56: 158–165

[80] Murat Hocaoglu S, Atasoy E, Baban A, Insel G, Orhon D. (2013). Nitrogen removal performance of intermittently aerated membrane bioreactor treating black water. Environmental Technology, 34(19): 2717–2725

[81] Murat Hocaoglu S, Insel G, Ubay Cokgor E, Baban A, Orhon D. (2010). COD fractionation and biodegradation kinetics of segregated domestic wastewater: black and grey water fractions. Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 85(9): 1241–1249

[82] Murat Hocaoglu S, Insel G, Ubay Cokgor E, Orhon D. (2011). Effect of low dissolved oxygen on simultaneous nitrification and denitrification in a membrane bioreactor treating black water. Bioresource Technology, 102(6): 4333–4340

[83] Nagy J, Mikola A, Pradhan S K, Zseni A. (2019). The utilization of struvite produced from human urine in agriculture as a natural fertilizer: a review. Periodica Polytechnica. Chemical Engineering, 63: 478–484

[84] NhamoGNhemachena CNhamoS (2019). Is 2030 too soon for Africa to achieve the water and sanitation sustainable development goal? Science of the Total Environment, 669: 129–139

[85] Oarga Mulec A, Hanssen J F, Jenssen P D, Bulc T G. (2019). A comparison of various bulking materials as a supporting matrix in composting blackwater solids from vacuum toilets. Journal of Environmental Management, 243: 78–87

[86] Oarga Mulec A, Mihelič R, Walochnik J, Griessler Bulc T. (2016). Composting of the solid fraction of blackwater from a separation system with vacuum toilets: effects on the process and quality. Journal of Cleaner Production, 112: 4683–4690

[87] Ødegaard H. (2016). A road-map for energy-neutral wastewater treatment plants of the future based on compact technologies (including MBBR). Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 10(4): 2

[88] Odey E A, Li Z, Zhou X, Kalakodio L. (2017). Fecal sludge management in developing urban centers: a review on the collection, treatment, and composting. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 24(30): 23441–23452

[89] Orner K D, Mihelcic J R. (2018). A review of sanitation technologies to achieve multiple sustainable development goals that promote resource recovery. Environmental Science. Water Research & Technology, 4(1): 16–32

[90] Oteng-Peprah M, Acheampong M A, DeVries N K. (2018). Greywater characteristics, treatment systems, reuse strategies and user perception: a review. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution, 229(255): 1–16

[91] PalmquistHHanaeus J (2005). Hazardous substances in separately collected grey- and blackwater from ordinary Swedish households. Science of the Total Environment, 348(1–3): 151–163

[92] Pan W, Ouyang H, Tan X, Deng R, Gu L, He Q. (2022). Anaerobic dynamic membrane bioreactors for synthetic blackwater treatment under room temperature and mesophilic conditions. Bioresource Technology, 355: 127295

[93] Patel A, Mungray A A, Mungray A K. (2020). Technologies for the recovery of nutrients, water and energy from human urine: a review. Chemosphere, 259: 127372

[94] Pathak B, Chakravarty I. (2019). SANITATION AND HEALTH A movement visualizing Gandhi’s Dream. Indian Journal of Medical Research, 149(7): 73–75

[95] Paulo P L, Azevedo C, Begosso L, Galbiati A F, Boncz M A. (2013). Natural systems treating greywater and blackwater on-site: integrating treatment, reuse and landscaping. Ecological Engineering, 50: 95–100

[96] Paulo P L, Galbiati A F, Magalhães Filho F J C, Bernardes F S, Carvalho G A, Boncz M Á. (2019). Evapotranspiration tank for the treatment, disposal and resource recovery of blackwater. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 147: 61–66

[97] Pecson B M, Barrios J A, Jimenez B E, Nelson K L. (2007). The effects of temperature, pH, and ammonia concentration on the inactivation of Ascaris eggs in sewage sludge. Water Research, 41(13): 2893–2902

[98] Pecson B M, Nelson K L. (2005). Inactivation of Ascaris suum eggs by ammonia. Environmental Science & Technology, 39(20): 7909–7914

[99] Pedrouso A, Tocco G, Val del Río A, Carucci A, Morales N, Campos J L, Milia S, Mosquera-Corral A. (2020). Digested blackwater treatment in a partial nitritation-anammox reactor under repeated starvation and reactivation periods. Journal of Cleaner Production, 244: 118733

[100] Pype M L, Donose B C, Marti L, Patureau D, Wery N, Gernjak W. (2016). Virus removal and integrity in aged RO membranes. Water Research, 90: 167–175

[101] Radjenovic J, Sedlak D L. (2015). Challenges and opportunities for electrochemical processes as next-generation technologies for the treatment of contaminated water. Environmental Science & Technology, 49(19): 11292–11302

[102] Rahman M M, Salleh M A M, Rashid U, Ahsan A, Hossain M M, Ra C S. (2014). Production of slow release crystal fertilizer from wastewaters through struvite crystallization: a review. Arabian Journal of Chemistry, 7(1): 139–155

[103] Rao S M, Mogili N V. (2021). Transformation and fate of urea in pit-toilet blackwater after discharge to environment. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 28(16): 19901–19910

[104] Ren X, Wang Q, Chen H, Dai X, He Q. (2022). Removal effect and mechanism of typical pharmaceuticals and personal care products by AAO-MBR and UV/Chlorine in black water. Journal of Cleaner Production, 346: 131104

[105] Reynaert E, Greenwood E E, Ndwandwe B, Riechmann M E, Sindall R C, Udert K M, Morgenroth E. (2020). Practical implementation of true on-site water recycling systems for hand washing and toilet flushing. Water Research X, 7: 100051

[106] Robles A, Aguado D, Barat R, Borras L, Bouzas A, Gimenez J B, Marti N, Ribes J, Ruano M V, Serralta J, Ferrer J, Seco A. (2020). New frontiers from removal to recycling of nitrogen and phosphorus from wastewater in the Circular Economy. Bioresource Technology, 300: 122673

[107] Rogers T W, Rogers T S, Stoner M H, Sellgren K L, Lynch B J, Forbis-Stokes A A, Stoner B R, Hawkins B T. (2018). A granular activated carbon/electrochemical hybrid system for onsite treatment and reuse of blackwater. Water Research, 144: 553–560

[108] Rose C, Parker A, Jefferson B, Cartmell E. (2015). The characterization of feces and urine: a review of the literature to inform advanced treatment technology. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 45(17): 1827–1879

[109] Saeed T, Afrin R, Al-Muyeed A, Miah M J, Jahan H. (2021). Bioreactor septic tank for on-site wastewater treatment: floating constructed wetland integration. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 9(4): 105606

[110] Sahondo T, Hennessy S, Sindall R C, Chaudhari H, Teleski S, Lynch B J, Sellgren K L, Stoner B R, Grego S, Hawkins B T. (2020). Field testing of a household-scale onsite blackwater treatment system in South Africa. Science of the Total Environment, 703: 135469

[111] Sakurai K S I, Pompei C M E, Tomita I N, Santos-Neto A J, Silva G H R. (2021). Hybrid constructed wetlands as post-treatment of blackwater: an assessment of the removal of antibiotics. Journal of Environmental Management, 278: 111552

[112] Santiago-Díaz A L, Garcia-Albortante J, Salazar-Pelaez M L. (2019). UASB-septic tank as an alternative for decentralized wastewater treatment in Mexico. Environmental Technology, 40(14): 1780–1792

[113] Sawatdeenarunat C, Nguyen D, Surendra C, Shrestha S, Rajendran K, Oechsner H, Xie L, Khanal S K. (2016). Anaerobic biorefinery: current status, challenges, and opportunities. Bioresource Technology, 215: 304–313

[114] Schmitt R J P, Morgenroth E, Larsen T A. (2017). Robust planning of sanitation services in urban informal settlements: an analytical framework. Water Research, 110: 297–312

[115] Schoen M E, Garland J. (2017). Review of pathogen treatment reductions for onsite non-potable reuse of alternative source waters. Microbial Risk Analysis, 5: 25–31

[116] Sharma P, Mutnuri S. (2019). Nutrient recovery and microbial diversity in human urine fed microbial fuel cell. Water Science and Technology, 79(4): 718–730

[117] Shi X J, Chen Z, Lu Y, Shi Q, Wu Y H, Hu H Y. (2021). Significant increase of assimilable organic carbon (AOC) levels in MBR effluents followed by coagulation, ozonation and combined treatments: Implications for biostability control of reclaimed water. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(4): 68

[118] Silva G H R , Sueitt A P E, Haimes S, Tripidaki A, van Zwieten R, Vasconcelos Fernandes T (2019) Feasibility of closing nutrient cycles from black water by microalgae-based technology. Algal Research, 44: 101715

[119] Simha P, Ganesapillai M. (2017). Ecological Sanitation and nutrient recovery from human urine: How far have we come? A review. Sustainable Environment Research, 27(3): 107–116

[120] Singh R P, Kun W, Fu D. (2019). Designing process and operational effect of modified septic tank for the pre-treatment of rural domestic sewage. Journal of Environmental Management, 251: 109552

[121] Skulberg O M. (2000). Microalgae as a source of bioactive molecules: experience from cyanophyte research. Journal of Applied Phycology, 12(3/5): 341–348

[122] Sun H J, Mohammed A N, Liu Y. (2020). Phosphorus recovery from source-diverted blackwater through struvite precipitation. Science of the Total Environment, 743: 140747

[123] Tannock S J, Clarke W P. (2016). The use of food waste as a carbon source for on-site treatment of nutrient-rich blackwater from an office block. Environmental Technology, 37(18): 2368–2378

[124] Tansel B, Lunn G, Monje O. (2018). Struvite formation and decomposition characteristics for ammonia and phosphorus recovery: a review of magnesium-ammonia-phosphate interactions. Chemosphere, 194: 504–514

[125] Tao J, Mancl K M, Tuovinen O H. (2011). A potential sanitary sewer overflow treatment technology: Fixed-media bioreactors. Water Environment Research, 83(8): 714–721

[126] Tao W, Fattah K P, Huchzermeier M P. (2016). Struvite recovery from anaerobically digested dairy manure: a review of application potential and hindrances. Journal of Environmental Management, 169: 46–57

[127] Teoh M M, Chung T S, Yeo Y S. (2011). Dual-layer PVDF/PTFE composite hollow fibers with a thin macrovoid-free selective layer for water production via membrane distillation. Chemical Engineering Journal, 171(2): 684–691

[128] TervahautaTRani SHernandez LealLBuismanC JZeemanG (2014a). Black water sludge reuse in agriculture: are heavy metals a problem? Journal of Hazardous Materials, 274: 229–236

[129] Tervahauta T, van der Weijden R D, Flemming R L, Hernandez Leal L, Zeeman G, Buisman C J. (2014b). Calcium phosphate granulation in anaerobic treatment of black water: a new approach to phosphorus recovery. Water Research, 48: 632–642

[130] Thostenson J O, Mourouvin R, Hawkins B T, Ngaboyamahina E, Sellgren K L, Parker C B, Deshusses M A, Stoner B R, Glass J T. (2018). Improved blackwater disinfection using potentiodynamic methods with oxidized boron-doped diamond electrodes. Water Research, 140: 191–199

[131] Todt D, Dorsch P. (2015). Nitrous oxide emissions in a biofilm loaded with different mixtures of concentrated household wastewater. International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 12(11): 3405–3416

[132] Todt D, Heistad A, Jenssen P D. (2015). Load and distribution of organic matter and nutrients in a separated household wastewater stream. Environmental Technology, 36(12): 1584–1593

[133] Todt D, Jenssen P D. (2015). Particle removal in a novel sequential mechanical filter system loaded with blackwater. Water Science and Technology, 71(9): 1407–1413

[134] Todt D, Jenssen P D, Klemencic A K, Oarga A, Bulc T G (2014). Removal of particles in organic filters in experimental treatment systems for domestic wastewater and black water. Journal of Environmental Science and Health Part A—Toxic/Hazardous Substances & Environmental Engineering 49(8), 948–954

[135] Tun L L, Jeong D, Jeong S, Cho K, Lee S, Bae H. (2016). Dewatering of source-separated human urine for nitrogen recovery by membrane distillation. Journal of Membrane Science, 512: 13–20

[136] UdertK MLarsen T AGujerWIwaProgrammeC (2003). 3rd World Water Congress: Efficient Water Supply and Water Reuse, 71–78

[137] UN (2015) Goal 6: Ensure access to water and sanitation for all. Website at www.un.org (Accessed 20 March, 2020)

[138] van Voorthuizen E, Zwijnenburg A, van der Meer W, Temmink H. (2008). Biological black water treatment combined with membrane separation. Water Research, 42(16): 4334–4340

[139] van Voorthuizen E M, Zwijnenburg A, Wessling M. (2005). Nutrient removal by NF and RO membranes in a decentralized sanitation system. Water Research, 39(15): 3657–3667

[140] Vasconcelos Fernandes T, Shrestha R, Sui Y, Papini G, Zeeman G, Vet L E, Wijffels R H, Lamers P. (2015). Closing domestic nutrient cycles using microalgae. Environmental Science & Technology, 49(20): 12450–12456

[141] Vasconcelos Fernandes T, Suarez-Munoz M, Trebuch L M, Verbraak P J, Van de Waal D B. (2017). Toward an ecologically optimized N:P recovery from wastewater by microalgae. Frontiers in Microbiology, 8: 1742

[142] Vogl A, Bischof F, Wichern M. (2016). Single chamber microbial fuel cells for high strength wastewater and blackwater treatment: a comparison of idealized wastewater, synthetic human blackwater, and diluted pig manure. Biochemical Engineering Journal, 115: 64–71

[143] Vuppaladadiyam A K, Merayo N, Prinsen P, Luque R, Blanco A, Zhao M. (2019). A review on greywater reuse: quality, risks, barriers and global scenarios. Reviews in Environmental Science and Biotechnology, 18(1): 77–99

[144] Walter X A, Stinchcombe A, Greenman J, Ieropoulos I. (2017). Urine transduction to usable energy: a modular MFC approach for smartphone and remote system charging. Applied Energy, 192: 575–581

[145] Walton W E. (2012). Design and management of free water surface constructed wetlands to minimize mosquito production. Wetlands Ecology and Management, 20(3): 173–195

[146] Wang X R, Hui E C M, Sun J X. (2017). Population migration, urbanization and housing prices: evidence from the cities in China. Habitat International, 66: 49–56

[147] Wei S P, van Rossum F, van de Pol G J, Winkler M K H. (2018). Recovery of phosphorus and nitrogen from human urine by struvite precipitation, air stripping and acid scrubbing: a pilot study. Chemosphere, 212: 1030–1037

[148] Welling C M, Sasidaran S, Kachoria P, Hennessy S, Lynch B J, Teleski S, Chaudhari H, Sellgren K L, Stoner B R, Grego S, Hawkins B T. (2020). Field testing of a household-scale onsite blackwater treatment system in Coimbatore, India. Science of the Total Environment, 713: 136706

[149] Wendland C, Deegener S, Behrendt J, Toshev P, Otterpohl R. (2007). Anaerobic digestion of blackwater from vacuum toilets and kitchen refuse in a continuous stirred tank reactor (CSTR). Water Science and Technology, 55(7): 187–194

[150] Whitton R, Fane S, Jarvis P, Tupper M, Raffin M, Coulon F, Nocker A. (2018). Flow cytometry-based evaluation of the bacterial removal efficiency of a blackwater reuse treatment plant and the microbiological changes in the associated non-potable distribution network. Science of the Total Environment, 645: 1620–1629

[151] Wigginton K R, Ye Y, Ellenberg R M. (2015). Emerging investigators series: the source and fate of pandemic viruses in the urban water cycle. Environmental Science. Water Research & Technology, 1(6): 735–746

[152] Wilsenach J A, Schuurbiers C A H, van Loosdrecht M C M. (2007). Phosphate and potassium recovery from source separated urine through struvite precipitation. Water Research, 41(2): 458–466

[153] WithersP J AJordanPMayL JarvieH PDeal N E (2014). Do septic tank systems pose a hidden threat to water quality? Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 12(2): 123–130

[154] Wojciechowska E. (2005). Application of microwaves for sewage sludge conditioning. Water Research, 39(19): 4749–4754

[155] Wu S, Carvalho P N, Müller J A, Manoj V R, Dong R. (2016). Sanitation in constructed wetlands: A review on the removal of human pathogens and fecal indicators. Science of the Total Environment, 541: 8–22

[156] Xu R, Xu S, Zhang L, Florentino A P, Yang Z, Liu Y. (2019). Impact of zero valent iron on blackwater anaerobic digestion. Bioresource Technology, 285: 121351

[157] Yang H, Wright J A, Gundry S W. (2012). Improve access to sanitation in China. Nature, 488(7409): 32

[158] Yang L, Si B, Tan X, Xu J, Xu W, Zhou L, Chen J, Zhang Y, Zhou X. (2022). Valorization of livestock manure for bioenergy production: a perspective on the fates and conversion of antibiotics. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 183: 106352

[159] Yee R A, Alessi D S, Ashbolt N J, Hao W D, Konhauser K, Liu Y. (2019). Nutrient recovery from source-diverted blackwater: optimization for enhanced phosphorus recovery and reduced co-precipitation. Journal of Cleaner Production, 235: 417–425

[160] You X, Yang L, Zhou X, Zhang Y. (2022). Sustainability and carbon neutrality trends for microalgae-based wastewater treatment: a review. Environmental Research, 209: 112860

[161] Yu C, Yin W, Yu Z, Chen J, Huang R, Zhou X. (2021). Membrane technologies in toilet urine treatment for toilet urine resource utilization: a review. RSC Advances, 11(56): 35525–35535

[162] Zahed M A, Salehi S, Tabari Y, Farraji H, Ataei-Kachooei S, Zinatizadeh A A, Kamali N, Mahjouri M. (2022). Phosphorus removal and recovery: state of the science and challenges. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 29(39): 58561–58589

[163] Zamalloa C, Arends J B A, Boon N, Verstraete W. (2013). Performance of a lab-scale bio-electrochemical assisted septic tank for the anaerobic treatment of black. New Biotechnology, 30(5): 573–580

[164] Zha X, Ma J, Tsapekos P, Lu X. (2019). Evaluation of an anaerobic baffled reactor for pretreating black water: potential application in rural China. Journal of Environmental Management, 251: 109599

[165] Zhang L, Guo B, Zhang Q, Florentino A, Xu R, Zhang Y, Liu Y. (2019a). Co-digestion of blackwater with kitchen organic waste: effects of mixing ratios and insights into microbial community. Journal of Cleaner Production, 236: 117703

[166] Zhang L, Xu M, Liu Y. (2019b). Pretreatment for anaerobic blackwater treatment: ultrasonication and thermal hydrolysis. Journal of Environmental Engineering and Science, 14(1): 32–36

[167] Zhang Q Y, Li R, Guo B, Zhang L, Liu Y. (2021). Thermophilic co-digestion of blackwater and organic kitchen waste: impacts of granular activated carbon and different mixing ratios. Waste Management (New York, N.Y.), 131: 453–461

[168] Zhang Y, Li Z, Zhao Y, Chen S, Mahmood I B. (2013). Stabilization of source-separated human urine by chemical oxidation. Water Science and Technology, 67(9): 1901–1907

[169] Zhang Z, Wang J, Hu Y, Wang L. (2022). Microwaves, a potential treatment for bacteria: a review. Frontiers in Microbiology, 13: 888266

[170] Zhou L, Wang H, Zhang Z, Zhang J, Chen H, Bi X, Dai X, Xia S, Alvarez-Cohen L, Rittmann B E. (2021). Novel perspective for urban water resource management: 5R generation. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(1): 16

[171] Zhou X Q, Li Z F, Zheng T L, Yan Y C, Li P Y, Odey E A, Mang H P, Uddin S M N. (2018). Review of global sanitation development. Environment International, 120: 246–261

[172] Zhou Y, Guo B, Zhang L, Zou X, Yang S, Zhang H, Xia S, Liu Y. (2020). Anaerobically digested blackwater treatment by simultaneous denitrification and anammox processes: feeding loading affects reactor performance and microbial community succession. Chemosphere, 241: 125101

[173] Ziemba C, Larive O, Deck S, Huisman T, Morgenroth E. (2019). Comparing the anti-bacterial performance of chlorination and electrolysis post-treatments in a hand washing water recycling system. Water Research X, 2: 100020

[174] Zitnik M, Sunta U, Torkar K G, Klemencic A K, Atanasova N, Bulc T G. (2019). The study of interactions and removal efficiency of Escherichia coli in raw blackwater treated by microalgae Chlorella vulgaris. Journal of Cleaner Production, 238: 117865

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Higher Education Press