Effective interventions on health effects of Chinese rural elderly under heat exposure

Highlights

● Education and subsidy were effective interventions during short-term heat exposure.

● A new index was defined to evaluate the intervention performance.

● Blood pressure and sleep duration were more heat-sensitive for the elderly.

Abstract

Due to climate change, the heatwave has become a more serious public health threat with aging as an aggravating factor in recent years. There is a pressing need to detect the most effective prevention and response measures. However, the specific health effects of interventions have not been characterized on an individual scale. In this study, an intervention experiment was designed to explore the health effects of heat exposure at the individual level and assess the effects of different interventions based on a comprehensive health sensitivity index (CHSI) in Xinyi, China. Forty-one subjects were recruited randomly, and divided into one control group and three intervention groups. Interventions included education (Educate by lecturing, offering relative materials, and communication), subsidy support (offer subsidy to offset the cost of running air conditioning), and cooling-spray (install a piece of cooling-spray equipment in the yard). Results showed that systolic blood pressure (SBP) and deep sleep duration (DSD) were significantly affected by short-term heat exposure, and the effects could be alleviated by three types of interventions. The estimated CHSI indicated that the effective days of the education group were longer than other groups, while the lower CHSI of the subsidy group showed lower sensitivity than the control group. These findings provide feasible implementation strategies to optimize Heat-health action plans and evaluate the intervention performance.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

High temperature / Health effect / Comprehensive evaluation / Intervention / Rural elderly

References

[1] Aghamohammadi N , Fong C S , Idrus M H M , Ramakreshnan L , Sulaiman N M . (2021). Environmental heat-related health symptoms among community in a tropical city. Science of the Total Environment, 782 : 146611

[2] Anderson G B , Bell M L . (2011). Heat waves in the United States: mortality risk during heat waves and effect modification by heat wave characteristics in 43 U. S. communities. Environmental Health Perspectives, 119( 2): 210– 218

[3] Ban J , Shi W , Cui L , Liu X , Jiang C , Han L , Wang R , Li T . (2019). Health-risk perception and its mediating effect on protective behavioral adaptation to heat waves. Environmental Research, 172 : 27– 33

[4] Bose-O’Reilly S , Daanen H , Deering K , Gerrett N , Huynen M M T E , Lee J , Karrasch S , Matthies-Wiesler F , Mertes H , Schoierer J . . (2021). COVID-19 and heat waves: New challenges for healthcare systems. Environmental Research, 198 : 111153

[5] Brennan M , O’Shea P M , Mulkerrin E C . (2020). Preventative strategies and interventions to improve outcomes during heatwaves. Age and Ageing, 49( 5): 729– 732

[6] Cai W , Zhang C , Suen H P , Ai S , Bai Y , Bao J , Chen B , Cheng L , Cui X , Dai H . . (2021). The 2020 China report of the Lancet Countdown on health and climate change. Lancet Public Health, 6( 1): e64– e81

[7] Carrillo A E Flouris A D Herry C L Notley S R Macartney M J Seely A J E Wright Beatty H E Kenny G P ( 2019). Age-related reductions in heart rate variability do not worsen during exposure to humid compared to dry heat: A secondary analysis. Temperature (Austin, Tex.), 6( 4): 341− 345

[8] Chen K , Huang L , Zhou L , Ma Z , Bi J , Li T . (2015). Spatial analysis of the effect of the 2010 heat wave on stroke mortality in Nanjing, China. Scientific Reports, 5( 1): 10816

[9] Chen K , Zhou L , Chen X , Ma Z , Liu Y , Huang L , Bi J , Kinney P L . (2016). Urbanization level and vulnerability to heat-related mortality in Jiangsu Province, China. Environmental Health Perspectives, 124( 12): 1863– 1869

[10] Chen Q , Ding M , Yang X , Hu K . (2017). Spatially explicit assessment of heat health risks using multi-source data: A case study of the Yangtze River Delta Region, China. Journal of Geo-Information Science, 19( 11): 1475– 1484

[11] Chen R , Yin P , Wang L , Liu C , Niu Y , Wang W , Jiang Y , Liu Y , Liu J , Qi J . . (2018). Association between ambient temperature and mortality risk and burden: Time series study in 272 main Chinese cities. BMJ (Clinical Research Ed.), 363 : k4306

[12] Cheng J , Xu Z , Bambrick H , Su H , Tong S , Hu W . (2018). Heatwave and elderly mortality: An evaluation of death burden and health costs considering short-term mortality displacement. Environment International, 115 : 334– 342

[13] Deng Y , Cao B , Liu B , Zhu Y . (2020). Effects of local heating on thermal comfort of standing people in extremely cold environments. Building and Environment, 185 : 107256

[14] Ebi K L . (2019). Effective heat action plans: research to interventions. Environmental Research Letters, 14 : 122001

[15] Fouillet A , Rey G , Laurent F , Pavillon G , Bellec S , Guihenneuc-Jouyaux C , Clavel J , Jougla E , Hémon D . (2006). Excess mortality related to the August 2003 heat wave in France. International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health, 80( 1): 16– 24

[16] Gasparrini A Armstrong B ( 2011). The impact of heat waves on mortality. Epidemiology (Cambridge, Mass.), 22( 1): 68−73

[17] Guo P Tang M ( 2015). The effect of high temperature on human cardiovascular system and blood sugar. Chinese Journal of Convalescent Medicine, 24(2): 176− 178 (in Chinese)

[18] Guo Y , Gasparrini A , Armstrong B G , Tawatsupa B , Tobias A , Lavigne E , Coelho M S Z S , Pan X , Kim H , Hashizume M . . (2017). Heat wave and mortality: A multicountry, multicommunity study. Environmental Health Perspectives, 125( 8): 087006

[19] Han J , Miao C , Duan Q , Wu J , Lei X , Liao W . (2020). Variations in start date, end date, frequency and intensity of yearly temperature extremes across China during the period 1961–2017. Environmental Research Letters, 15( 4): 045007

[20] Hendel M Azos-Diaz K Tremeac B ( 2016). Behavioral adaptation to heat-related health risks in cities. Energy and Buildings: S0378778816317212

[21] Huang L , Huang Y , Liu P , Wang G , Bi J . (2020). Research on regional comprehensive environmental risk assessment method system. China Environmental Science, 40( 12): 5468– 5474

[22] Huang L , Yang Q , Li J , Chen J , He R , Zhang C , Chen K , Dong S G , Liu Y . (2018). Risk perception of heat waves and its spatial variation in Nanjing, China. International Journal of Biometeorology, 62( 5): 783– 794

[23] Jay O , Capon A , Berry P , Broderick C , de Dear R , Havenith G , Honda Y , Kovats R S , Ma W , Malik A . . (2021). Reducing the health effects of hot weather and heat extremes: From personal cooling strategies to green cities. Lancet, 398( 10301): 709– 724

[24] Kaiser R Le Tertre A Schwartz J Gotway C A Daley W R Rubin C H ( 2007). The effect of the 1995 heat wave in Chicago on all-cause and cause-specific mortality. American Journal of Public Health, 97( Suppl 1): S158− S162

[25] Kim Y M , Kim S , Cheong H K , Ahn B , Choi K . (2012). Effects of heat wave on body temperature and blood pressure in the poor and elderly. Environmental Health and Toxicology, 27 : e2012013

[26] Li J , Xu X , Wang J , Zhao Y , Song X P , Liu Z D , Cao L N , Jiang B F , Liu Q Y . (2016a). Analysis of a community-based intervention to reduce heat-related illness during heat waves in Licheng, China: A Quasi-experimental study. Biomed Environmental Science, 29( 11): 802– 813

[27] Li Q Su H Shi Y Wang L Wu D ( 2016b). Temporal-spatial change characteristics of summer heatwaves in Jiangsu-Zhejiang-Shanghai region during 1961–2010. Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin, 25( 3): 506− 513 (in Chinese)

[28] Lou J , Ban J , Zhang T , Wang P , Wu Y , Huang L , Li T , Bi J . (2021). An intervention study of the rural elderly for improving exposure, risk perception and behavioral responses under high temperature. Environmental Research Letters, 16( 5): 055029

[29] Lu P , Zhao Q , Xia G , Xu R , Hanna L , Jiang J , Li S , Guo Y . (2021). Temporal trends of the association between ambient temperature and cardiovascular mortality: A 17-year case-crossover study. Environmental Research Letters, 16( 4): 045004

[30] Madaniyazi L , Zhou Y , Li S , Williams G , Jaakkola J J , Liang X , Liu Y , Wu S , Guo Y . (2016). Outdoor temperature, heart rate and blood pressure in Chinese adults: Effect modification by individual characteristics. Scientific Reports, 6( 1): 21003

[31] Martinez G S , Linares C , Ayuso A , Kendrovski V , Boeckmann M , Diaz J . (2019). Heat-health action plans in Europe: Challenges ahead and how to tackle them. Environmental Research, 176 : 108548

[32] Masato G , Bone A , Charlton-Perez A , Cavany S , Neal R , Dankers R , Dacre H , Carmichael K , Murray V . (2015). Improving the health forecasting alert system for cold weather and heat-waves in england: A proof-of-concept using temperature-mortality relationships. PLoS One, 10( 10): e0137804

[33] Matzarakis A , Laschewski G , Muthers S . (2020). The heat health warning system in germany: Application and warnings for 2005 to 2019. Atmosphere, 11( 2): 170

[34] Mayrhuber E A S , Duckers M L A , Wallner P , Arnberger A , Allex B , Wiesboeck L , Wanka A , Kolland F , Eder R , Hutter H P . . (2018). Vulnerability to heatwaves and implications for public health interventions: A scoping review. Environmental Research, 166 : 42– 54

[35] Meade R D , Akerman A P , Notley S R , McGinn R , Poirier P , Gosselin P , Kenny G P . (2020). Physiological factors characterizing heat-vulnerable older adults: A narrative review. Environment International, 144 : 105909

[36] Morais L , Lopes A , Nogueira P . (2021). Human health outcomes at the neighbourhood scale implications: Elderly’s heat-related cardiorespiratory mortality and its influencing factors. Science of the Total Environment, 760 : 144036

[37] Nogueira P , Paixao E , Falcao J . (2005). Behaviour of the Portuguese population during hot seasons and the heat wave of august 2003. Revista Portuguesa de Saude Publica, 23( 2): 3– 18

[38] Pennisi E ( 2020). Living with heat. Science (New York, N.Y.), 370( 6518): 778− 781

[39] Qu C Bi J Huang L Li F Yang J ( 2010). Dynamic comprehensive evaluation on regional environmental risk. Acta Scicentific Natural of Universities Pekinesis, 46( 3): 477− 482 (in Chinese)

[40] Sheridan S C . (2007). A survey of public perception and response to heat warnings across four North American cities: An evaluation of municipal effectiveness. International Journal of Biometeorology, 52( 1): 3– 15

[41] Song X , Zhang Z , Chen Y , Wang P , Xiang M , Shi P , Tao F . (2014). Spatiotemporal changes of global extreme temperature events (ETEs) since 1981 and the meteorological causes. Natural Hazards, 70( 2): 975– 994

[42] Takahashi N , Nakao R , Ueda K , Ono M , Kondo M , Honda Y , Hashizume M . (2015). Community trial on heat related-illness prevention behaviors and knowledge for the elderly. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 12( 3): 3188– 3214

[43] Tamura K Uchida K Ishigami T ( 2021). An interesting link between quality of sleep and a measure of blood pressure variability. Journal of Clinical Hypertension (Greenwich, Conn.), 23( 2): 331− 333

[44] Tan J Zheng Y ( 2013). Temporal and spatial distribution characteristics of heat waves in main capital cities of China. Meteorological Science and Technology, 41( 2): 347− 351 (in Chinese)

[45] Tsang T W , Mui K W , Wong L T . (2021). Investigation of thermal comfort in sleeping environment and its association with sleep quality. Building and Environment, 187 : 107406

[46] Wang J Meng B Pei T Du Y Zhang J Chen S Tian B Zhi G ( 2021). Mapping the exposure and sensitivity to heat wave events in China’s megacities. Science of the Total Environment, 755( Pt 1): 142734

[47] Wang Q Q , Yu Y , Li Y H , Ding Z , Chen X D . (2018). Evaluation the impact of community intervention on heat wave in Nanjing, China. Chinese Journal of Preventive Medicine, 52( 2): 188– 190

[48] Watts N , Amann M , Arnell N , Ayeb-Karlsson S , Beagley J , Belesova K , Boykoff M , Byass P , Cai W , Campbell-Lendrum D . . (2021). The 2020 report of The Lancet Countdown on health and climate change: responding to converging crises. Lancet, 397( 10269): 129– 170

[49] Watts N , Amann M , Arnell N , Ayeb-Karlsson S , Belesova K , Boykoff M , Byass P , Cai W , Campbell-Lendrum D , Capstick S . . (2019). The 2019 report of the Lancet Countdown on health and climate change: Ensuring that the health of a child born today is not defined by a changing climate. Lancet, 394( 10211): 1836– 1878

[50] Wei J , Mi Y , Li Y , Xin B , Wang Y . (2021). Factors associated with awareness, treatment and control of hypertension among 3579 hypertensive adults in China: Data from the China health and nutrition survey. BMC Public Health, 21( 1): 423

[51] Wu Y Lou J Li T Wang Q Ban J Sun X Huang L ( 2020). Analysis of individual difference in rural vulnerable groups’ risk perception of heat waves and their protective behavior. Journal of Environmental Hygiene, 10(1): 25− 30 (in Chinese)

[52] Yang J , Zhou M , Ren Z , Li M , Wang B , Liu L , Ou C Q , Yin P , Sun J , Tong S , Wang H , Zhang C , Wang J , Guo Y , Liu Q . (2021). Projecting heat-related excess mortality under climate change scenarios in China. Nature Communications, 12( 1): 1039

[53] Ye D , Yin J , Chen Z , Zheng Y , Wu R . (2013). Spatiotemporal change characteristics of summer heatwaves in China in 1961–2010. Progressus Inquisitiones de Mutatione Climatis, 9( 1): 15– 20

[54] Zhang A , Hu W , Li J , Wei R , Lin J , Ma W . (2019a). Impact of heatwaves on daily outpatient visits of respiratory disease: A time-stratified case-crossover study. Environmental Research, 169 : 196– 205

[55] Zhang N , Cao B , Zhu Y . (2019b). Effects of pre-sleep thermal environment on human thermal state and sleep quality. Building and Environment, 148 : 600– 608

[56] Zhang N , Cao B , Zhu Y X . (2018). Indoor environment and sleep quality: A research based on online survey and field study. Building and Environment, 137 : 198– 207

[57] Zheng Y Ding X Wu R Yin J( 2012). Temporal and spatial feature analyses of summer high temperature and heat wave in Jiangsu Province in past 50 years. Jounal of Natural Disasters, 21( 2): 43− 50 (in Chinese)

[58] Zhou L Chen K Chen X Jing Y Ma Z Bi J Kinney P L( 2017). Heat and mortality for ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke in 12 cities of Jiangsu Province, China. Science of the Total Environment, 601−602: 271− 277

[59] Zhou X Liu J ( 2018). High-temperature Operation on the blood pressure and blood lipids of workers in Iron and Steel Enterprises of Urumqi. Industrial Health and Occupational Diseases, 44( 1): 18− 20, 23 (in Chinese)

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China (No. 2020YFC1807502); the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 41822709).

Electronic Supplementary Material

Supplementary material is available in the online version of this article at https://doi.org/10.1007/s11783-022-1545-4 and is accessible for authorized users.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2022 Higher Education Press