Aerosol exposure assessment during reclaimed water utilization in China and risk evaluation in case of Legionella

Abstract

• The Chinese population exposure habits were surveyed.

• The risks of three scenarios of reclaimed water utilization were evaluated by QMRA.

• The risks were markedly higher than the threshold (10⁻⁴ pppy) recommended by WHO.

• The risks were age-, educational background-, region- and gender-specific.

Reclaimed water utilization provides an effective way to alleviate water shortage. However, the residual pathogens in the recycled water like Legionella, could be spread into the air as aerosols through water-to-air transmission process. Inhaling the aerosols by the people nearby increases their susceptibility to diseases. For estimating the health risks associated with the potential exposure of airborne Legionella emitted from the urban use of reclaimed water in China, nationwide questionnaire was designed to investigate the exposure habits of Chinese population in different scenarios. Quantitative microbial risk assessment (QMRA) served as the suitable explanatory tool to estimate the risk. The results indicated that annual infection probability of populations exposed to Legionella for three scenarios, 0.0764 (95% CI: 0.0032–0.6880) for road cleaning, 1.0000 (95% CI: 0.1883–1.0000) for greenfield irrigation, 0.9981 (95% CI: 0.0784–1.0000) for landscape fountain, were markedly higher than the threshold recommended by WHO (10⁻⁴ per person per year (pppy)) according to the concentration distribution of Legionella in the reclaimed water. An age-, educational background-, region- and gender-specific data in annual infection probability also showed different tendencies for some subpopulations. This study provides some detailed information on the health risks from the water reuse in China and will be useful to promote the safe application of reclaimed water in water-deficient areas.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Legionella / QMRA / Reclaimed water / Aerosol / Water reuse

References

[1] Armstrong T W (2005). A quantitative microbial risk assessment model for human inhalation exposure to Legionella. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Philadelphia: Drexel University

[2] Armstrong T W, Haas C N (2007). A quantitative microbial risk assessment model for Legionnaires’ disease: Animal model selection and dose-response modeling. Risk Analysis, 27(6): 1581–1596

[3] Benin A L, Benson R F, Besser R E (2002). Trends in legionnaires disease, 1980–1998: Declining mortality and new patterns of diagnosis. Clinical Infectious Diseases, 35(9): 1039–1046

[4] Bogosian G, Bourneuf E V (2001). A matter of bacterial life and death. EMBO Reports, 2(9): 770–774

[5] Caicedo C, Rosenwinkel K H, Exner M, Verstraete W, Suchenwirth R, Hartemann P, Nogueira R (2019). Legionella occurrence in municipal and industrial wastewater treatment plants and risks of reclaimed wastewater reuse: Review. Water Research, 149: 21–34

[6] Camann D E, Moore B E, Harding H J, Sorber C A (1988). Microorganism levels in air near spray irrigation of municipal wastewater: The Lubbock infection surveillance study. Journal- Water Pollution Control Federation, 60(11): 1960–1970

[7] Chhipi-Shrestha G, Hewage K, Sadiq R (2017). Microbial quality of reclaimed water for urban reuses: Probabilistic risk-based investigation and recommendations. Science of the Total Environment, 576: 738–751

[8] Collins S, Jorgensen F, Willis C, Walker J (2015). Real-time PCR to supplement gold-standard culture-based detection of Legionella in environmental samples. Journal of Applied Microbiology, 119(4): 1158–1169

[9] de Man H, Bouwknegt M, van Heijnsbergen E, Leenen E J T M, van Knapen F, de Roda Husman A M (2014). Health risk assessment for splash parks that use rainwater as source water. Water Research, 54: 254–261

[10] Dorevitch S, Panthi S, Huang Y, Li H, Michalek A M, Pratap P, Wroblewski M, Liu L, Scheff P A, Li A (2011). Water ingestion during water recreation. Water Research, 45(5): 2020–2028

[11] Douglas P, Fecht D, Jarvis D (2021). Characterising populations living close to intensive farming and composting facilities in England. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(3): 40 doi.org/10.1007/s11783-020-1332-z

[12] Douwes J, Thorne P, Pearce N, Heederik D (2003). Bioaerosol health effects and exposure assessment: progress and prospects. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, 47(3): 187–200

[13] ECDC (2017). Facts about Legionnaires’ Disease. Stockholm: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control PMID:12639832

[14] Eisenstein L, Bodager D, Ginzl D (2008). Outbreak of giardiasis and cryptosporidiosis associated with a neighborhood interactive water fountain--Florida, 2006. Journal of Environmental Health, 71(3): 18–22, quiz 49–50

[15] Fisman D N, Lim S, Wellenius G A, Johnson C, Britz P, Gaskins M, Maher J, Mittleman M A, Victor Spain C, Haas C N, Newbern C (2005). It’s not the heat, it’s the humidity: Wet weather increases legionellosis risk in the greater Philadelphia metropolitan area. Journal of Infectious Diseases, 192(12): 2066–2073

[16] Gordon S B, Read R C (2002). Macrophage defences against respiratory tract infections. British Medical Bulletin, 61(1): 45–61

[17] Guyonnet D, Come B, Perrochet P, Parriaux A (1999). Comparing two methods for addressing uncertainty in risk assessments. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 125(7): 660–666

[18] Haas C, Rose J, Gerba C (2014). Quantitative microbial risk assessment (Second Edition / Electronic version ed.).New York: John Wiley and Sons

[19] Haas C N, Rose J B, Gerba C P (1999). Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment. New York: John Wiley and Sons

[20] Hamilton K A, Hamilton M T, Johnson W, Jjemba P, Bukhari Z, LeChevallier M, Haas C N, Gurian P L (2019). Risk-based critical concentrations of legionella pneumophila for indoor residential water uses. Environmental Science & Technology, 53(8): 4528–4541

[21] Han Y, Li L, Wang Y, Ma J, Li P, Han C, Liu J (2020). Composition, dispersion, and health risks of bioaerosols in wastewater treatment plants: A review. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(3): 38 doi.org/10.1007/s11783-020-1330-1

[22] Harwood V J, Levine A D, Scott T M, Chivukula V, Lukasik J, Farrah S R, Rose J B (2005). Validity of the indicator organism paradigm for pathogen reduction in reclaimed water and public health protection. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 71(6): 3163–3170

[23] Hines S A, Chappie D J, Lordo R A, Miller B D, Janke R J, Lindquist H A, Fox K R, Ernst H S, Taft S C (2014). Assessment of relative potential for Legionella species or surrogates inhalation exposure from common water uses. Water Research, 56: 203–213

[24] Hong P Y, Mantilla-Calderon D, Wang C (2020). Metagenomics as a tool to monitor reclaimed-water quality. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 86(16): e00724–20

[25] Jiang J, Yao M, Hwang J, Wang C (2021). Bioaerosol: A key vessel between environment and health. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(3): 49 doi.org/10.1007/s11783-021-1422-6 PMID: 34002119

[26] Jung J H, Lee J E, Kim S S (2009). Thermal effects on bacterial bioaerosols in continuous air flow. Science of the Total Environment, 407(16): 4723–4730

[27] Kahn R A, Fu H, Roy C R (2002). Cellular hijacking: A common strategy for microbial infection. Trends in Biochemical Sciences, 27(6): 308–314

[28] Li H, Chien S H, Hsieh M K, Dzombak D A, Vidic R D (2011). Escalating water demand for energy production and the potential for use of treated municipal wastewater. Environmental Science & Technology, 45(10): 4195–4200

[29] Liu K, Fu H, Chen H (2018). Research on the influencing mechanism of traditional cultural values on citizens’ behavior regarding the reuse of recycled water. Sustainability, 10(1): 1–15

[30] Lu F, Hu T, Wei S, Shao L, He P (2020). Bioaerosolization behavior along sewage sludge biostabilization. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(3): 45 doi.org/10.1007/s11783-020-1339-5

[31] Muller D, Edwards M L, Smith D W (1983). Changes in iron and transferrin levels and body temperature in experimental airborne legionellosis. Journal of Infectious Diseases, 147(2): 302–307

[32] Nielsen M C, Jiang S C (2020). Can cyanotoxins penetrate human skin during water recreation to cause negative health effects? Harmful Algae, 98: 101872

[33] Sales-Ortells H, Agostini G, Medema G (2015). Quantification of waterborne pathogens and associated health risks in urban water. Environmental Science & Technology, 49(11): 6943–6952

[34] Seidl M, Da G, Ausset P, Haenn S, Gehin E, Moulin L (2016). Evaluating exposure of pedestrians to airborne contaminants associated with non-potable water use for pavement cleaning. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 23(7): 6091–6101

[35] Shakhawat C, Tahir H, Neil B (2006). Fuzzy rule-based modelling for human health risk from naturally occurring radioactive materials in produced water. Journal of Environmental Radioactivity, 89(1): 1–17

[36] Thomas R J, Webber D, Hopkins R, Frost A, Laws T, Jayasekera P N, Atkins T (2011). The cell membrane as a major site of damage during aerosolization of Escherichia coli. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 77(3): 920–925

[37] Troldborg M, Duckett D, Allan R, Hastings E, Hough R L (2017). A risk-based approach for developing standards for irrigation with reclaimed water. Water Research, 126: 372–384

[38] U.S. EPA (1999). Legionella: Human Health Criteria Document. Office of Science and Technology, Office of Water, Washington, DC. EPA-822-R-99e001. Washington, DC: U.S. EPA

[39] U.S. EPA (2012). Recreational Water Quality Criteria, 820-F-12e058. Washington, DC: U.S. EPA

[40] U.S. EPA (2015a). Water Recycling and Reuse: The Environmental Benefits.Washington, DC: U.S. EPA

[41] U.S. EPA (2015b). What are Water Quality Standards?Washington, DC: U.S. EPA

[42] U.S. EPA (2019). EPA/600/R-18/259F. Update for Chapter 3 of the Exposure Factors Handbook. Ingestion of Water and Other Select Liquids[S]. February 2019. Washington, DC: U.S. EPA

[43] Valero N, de Simón M, Gallés P, Izquierdo N, Arimon J, González R, Manzanares-Laya S, Avellanes I, Gómez A (2017). Street cleaning trucks as potential sources of Legionella pneumophila. Emerging Infectious Diseases, 23(11): 1880–1882

[44] Vergara G, Rose J B, Gin K Y H (2016). Risk assessment of noroviruses and human adenoviruses in recreational surface waters. Water Research, 103: 276–282

[45] Whiley H, Taylor M (2016). Legionella detection by culture and qPCR: Comparing apples and oranges. Critical Reviews in Microbiology, 42(1): 65–74

[46] WHO (2011). World Health Organization. Guidelines for Drinking-Water Quality (4th ed.). Genève: World Health Organization

[47] Xie W, Li Y, Bai W, Hou J, Ma T, Zeng X, Zhang L, An T (2020). The source and transport of bioaerosols in the air: A review. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(3): 44 doi.org/10.1007/s11783-020-1336-8

[48] Zadeh L A (1965). Fuzzy sets. Information and Control, 8(3): 338–353

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Higher Education Press