A review on sustainable reuse applications of Fenton sludge during wastewater treatment

Highlights

• The sustainable approaches related to Fenton sludge reuse systems are summarized.

• Degradation mechanism of Fenton sludge heterogeneous catalyst is deeply discussed.

• The efficient utilization directions of Fenton sludge are proposed.

Abstract

The classical Fenton oxidation process (CFOP) is a versatile and effective application that is generally applied for recalcitrant pollutant removal. However, excess iron sludge production largely restricts its widespread application. Fenton sludge is a hazardous solid waste, which is a complex heterogeneous mixture with Fe(OH)₃, organic matter, heavy metals, microorganisms, sediment impurities, and moisture. Although studies have aimed to utilize specific Fenton sludge resources based on their iron-rich characteristics, few reports have fully reviewed the utilization of Fenton sludge. As such, this review details current sustainable Fenton sludge reuse systems that are applied during wastewater treatment. Specifically, coagulant preparation, the reuse of Fenton sludge as an iron source in the Fenton process and as a synthetic heterogeneous catalyst/adsorbent, as well as the application of the Fenton sludge reuse system as a heterogeneous catalyst for resource utilization. This is the first review article to comprehensively summarize the utilization of Fenton sludge. In addition, this review suggests future research ideas to enhance the cost-effectiveness, environmental sustainability, and large-scale feasibility of Fenton sludge applications.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Fenton sludge / Heavy metals / Coagulant / Iron source / Heterogeneous catalyst

References

[1] Ahmad M, Rajapaksha A U, Lim J E, Zhang M, Bolan N, Mohan D, Vithanage M, Lee S S, Ok Y S (2014). Biochar as a sorbent for contaminant management in soil and water: A review. Chemosphere, 99: 19–33

[2] Badawy M I, Ali M E (2006). Fenton’s peroxidation and coagulation processes for the treatment of combined industrial and domestic wastewater. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 136(3): 961–966

[3] Barb W G, Baxendale J H, George P, Hargrave K R (1949). Reactions of ferrous and ferric ions with hydrogen peroxide. Nature, 163(4148): 692–694

[4] Bautista P, Mohedano A F, Casas J A, Zazo J A, Rodriguez J J (2008). An overview of the application of Fenton oxidation to industrial wastewaters treatment. Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology (Oxford, Oxfordshire), 83(10): 1323–1338

[5] Belete Y Z, Ziemann E, Gross A, Bernstein R (2021). Facile activation of sludge-based hydrochar by Fenton oxidation for ammonium adsorption in aqueous media. Chemosphere, 273: 128526

[6] Bello M M, Abdul Raman A A, Asghar A (2019). A review on approaches for addressing the limitations of Fenton oxidation for recalcitrant wastewater treatment. Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 126: 119–140

[7] Benatti C T, Costa A C, Tavares C R (2009). Characterization of solids originating from the Fenton’s process. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 163(2–3): 1246–1253

[8] Benatti C T, Tavares C R, Guedes T A (2006). Optimization of Fenton’s oxidation of chemical laboratory wastewaters using the response surface methodology. Journal of Environmental Management, 80(1): 66–74

[9] Bolobajev J, Kattel E, Viisimaa M, Goi A, Trapido M, Tenno T, Dulova N (2014). Reuse of ferric sludge as an iron source for the Fenton-based process in wastewater treatment. Chemical Engineering Journal, 255: 8–13

[10] Bolobajev J, Trapido M, Goi A (2016a). Role of organic wastewater constituents in iron redox cycling for ferric sludge reuse in the fenton-based treatment. International Journal of Environmental and Ecological Engineering, 10: 39944

[11] Bolobajev J, Trapido M, Goi A (2016b). Interaction of tannic acid with ferric iron to assist 2,4,6-trichlorophenol catalytic decomposition and reuse of ferric sludge as a source of iron catalyst in Fenton-based treatment. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, 187: 75–82

[12] Cao G M, Sheng M, Niu W F, Fei Y L, Li D (2009). Regeneration and reuse of iron catalyst for Fenton-like reactions. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 172(2–3): 1446–1449

[13] Chen L, Ma J, Li X, Zhang J, Fang J, Guan Y, Xie P (2011). Strong enhancement on fenton oxidation by addition of hydroxylamine to accelerate the ferric and ferrous iron cycles. Environmental Science & Technology, 45(9): 3925–3930

[14] Cheng M, Ma W, Li J, Huang Y, Zhao J, Wen Y, Xu Y (2004). Visible-light-assisted degradation of dye pollutants over Fe(III)-loaded resin in the presence of H₂O₂ at neutral pH values. Environmental Science & Technology, 38(5): 1569–1575

[15] Chu J H, Kang J K, Park S, Lee C (2020). Application of magnetic biochar derived from food waste in heterogeneous sono-Fenton-like process for removal of organic dyes from aqueous solution. Journal of Water Process Engineering. 37: 101455

[16] Dantas E R B, Silva E J, Lopes W S, do Nascimento M R, Leite V D, de Sousa J T (2020). Fenton treatment of sanitary landfill leachate: Optimization of operational parameters, characterization of sludge and toxicology. Environmental Technology, 41(20): 2637–2647

[17] De Laat J, Gallard H É (1999). Catalytic decomposition of hydrogen peroxide by Fe(III) in homogeneous aqueous solution: mechanism and kinetic modeling. Environmental Science & Technology, 33(16): 2726–2732

[18] Demarchis L, Minella M, Nisticò R, Maurino V, Minero C, Vione D (2015). Photo-Fenton reaction in the presence of morphologically controlled hematite as iron source. Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology A Chemistry, 307–308: 99–107

[19] Deng Y, Englehardt J D (2006). Treatment of landfill leachate by the Fenton process. Water Research, 40(20): 3683–3694

[20] Di Iaconi C, Del Moro G, De Sanctis M, Rossetti S (2010). A chemically enhanced biological process for lowering operative costs and solid residues of industrial recalcitrant wastewater treatment. Water Research, 44(12): 3635–3644

[21] Diya’uddeen B H, Rahim Pouran S, Abdul Aziz A R, Daud W M (2015). Fenton oxidative treatment of petroleum refinery wastewater: process optimization and sludge characterization. RSC Advances, 5(83): 68159–68168

[22] Duan X, Sun H, Shao Z, Wang S (2018). Nonradical reactions in environmental remediation processes: Uncertainty and challenges. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, 224: 973–982

[23] Ensing B, Buda F, Baerends E J (2003). Fenton-like chemistry in water: Oxidation catalysis by Fe(III) and H₂O₂. Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 107(30): 5722–5731

[24] Fan F (2016). The preparation of efficient magnetic polymeric ferric sulfate with recycled fenton iron sludge. Dissertation for the Master Degree. Guilin: Guangxi University (in Chinese)

[25] Fan S, Tang J, Wang Y, Li H, Zhang H, Tang J, Wang Z, Li X (2016). Biochar prepared from co-pyrolysis of municipal sewage sludge and tea waste for the adsorption of methylene blue from aqueous solutions: Kinetics, isotherm, thermodynamic and mechanism. Journal of Molecular Liquids, 220: 432–441

[26] Fang G, Gao J, Liu C, Dionysiou D D, Wang Y, Zhou D (2014). Key role of persistent free radicals in hydrogen peroxide activation by biochar: Implications to organic contaminant degradation. Environmental Science & Technology, 48(3): 1902–1910

[27] Fernandez J, Bandara J, Kiwi J, Lopez A, Albers P (1998). Efficient photo-assisted Fenton catalysis mediated by Fe ions on Nafion membranes active in the abatement of non-biodegradable azo-dye. Chemical Communications, 14(14): 1493–1494

[28] Gamaralalage D, Sawai O, Nunoura T (2017). Sludge reuse in Fenton oxidation of crepe rubber wastewater and palm oil mill effluent. In: The 28th Annual Conference of JSMCWM, 2017. Tokyo: JSMCWM, 5–6

[29] Garade A C, Bharadwaj M, Bhagwat S V, Athawale A A, Rode C V (2009). An efficient γ-Fe₂O₃ catalyst for liquid phase air oxidation of p-hydroxybenzyl alcohol under mild conditions. Catalysis Communications, 10(5): 485–489

[30] Ge J, Guha B, Lippincott L, Cach S, Wei J, Su T L, Meng X (2020). Challenges of arsenic removal from municipal wastewater by coagulation with ferric chloride and alum. Science of the Total Environment, 725: 138351

[31] Ghernaout D, Elboughdiri N, Ghareba S (2020). Fenton technology for wastewater treatment: dares and trends. Open Access Library Journal, 7(01): 1–26

[32] Guedes A M, Madeira L M, Boaventura R A, Costa C A (2003). Fenton oxidation of cork cooking wastewater--overall kinetic analysis. Water Research, 37(13): 3061–3069

[33] Guo S, Yuan N, Zhang G, Yu J C (2017). Graphene modified iron sludge derived from homogeneous Fenton process as an efficient heterogeneous Fenton catalyst for degradation of organic pollutants. Microporous and Mesoporous Materials, 238: 62–68

[34] Guvenc S Y, Varank G (2021). Degradation of refractory organics in concentrated leachate by the Fenton process: Central composite design for process optimization. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 15(1): 2

[35] Hou X, Huang X, Jia F, Ai Z, Zhao J, Zhang L (2017). Hydroxylamine promoted goethite surface fenton degradation of organic pollutants. Environmental Science & Technology, 51(9): 5118–5126

[36] Hua W (2017). Fenton wastewater treatment sludge disposal and recovery of iron salits using technology. Dissertation for the Master Degree. Guangzhou: South China University of Technology (in Chinese)

[37] Ighalo J O, Adeniyi A G (2020). Adsorption of pollutants by plant bark derived adsorbents: An empirical review. Journal of Water Process Engineering, 35: 101228

[38] Ince N H, Apikyan I G (2000). Combination of activated carbon adsorption with light-enhanced chemical oxidation via hydrogen peroxide. Water Research, 34(17): 4169–4176

[39] Jain B, Singh A K, Kim H, Lichtfouse E, Sharma V K (2018). Treatment of organic pollutants by homogeneous and heterogeneous Fenton reaction processes. Environmental Chemistry Letters, 16(3): 947–967

[40] Kattel E, Trapido M, Dulova N (2016). Treatment of landfill leachate by continuously reused ferric oxyhydroxide sludge-activated hydrogen peroxide. Chemical Engineering Journal, 304: 646–654

[41] Kavitha V, Palanivelu K (2004). The role of ferrous ion in Fenton and photo-Fenton processes for the degradation of phenol. Chemosphere, 55(9): 1235–1243

[42] Kishimoto N, Kitamura T, Kato M, Otsu H (2013). Reusability of iron sludge as an iron source for the electrochemical Fenton-type process using Fe²+/HOCl system. Water Research, 47(5): 1919–1927

[43] Klein K, Kivi A, Dulova N, Zekker I, Molder E, Tenno T, Trapido M, Tenno T (2016). A pilot study of three-stage biological-chemical treatment of landfill leachate applying continuous ferric sludge reuse in Fenton-like process. Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy, 19(2): 541–551

[44] Leifeld V, Dos Santos T P M, Zelinski D W, Igarashi-Mafra L (2018). Ferrous ions reused as catalysts in Fenton-like reactions for remediation of agro-food industrial wastewater. Journal of Environmental Management, 222: 284–292

[45] Leng L, Yuan X, Huang H, Shao J, Wang H, Chen X, Zeng G (2015). Bio-char derived from sewage sludge by liquefaction: Characterization and application for dye adsorption. Applied Surface Science, 346: 223–231

[46] Li C W, Chen Y M, Chiou Y C, Liu C K (2007). Dye wastewater treated by Fenton process with ferrous ions electrolytically generated from iron-containing sludge. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 144(1–2): 570–576

[47] Liao Q, Sun J, Gao L (2009). Degradation of phenol by heterogeneous Fenton reaction using multi-walled carbon nanotube supported Fe₂O₃ catalysts. Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects, 345(1–3): 95–100

[48] Lin S S, Gurol M D (1998). Catalytic decomposition of hydrogen peroxide on iron oxide: Kinetics, mechanism, and implications. Environmental Science & Technology, 32(10): 1417–1423

[49] Mahiroglu A, Tarlan-Yel E, Sevimli M F (2009). Treatment of combined acid mine drainage (AMD—flotation circuit effluents from copper mine via Fenton’s process. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 166(2–3): 782–787

[50] Mahtab M S, Farooqi I H, Khursheed A (2021a). Zero Fenton sludge discharge: A review on reuse approach during wastewater treatment by the advanced oxidation process. International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 10: 1–14

[51] Mahtab M S, Islam D T, Farooqi I H (2021b). Optimization of the process variables for landfill leachate treatment using Fenton based advanced oxidation technique. Engineering Science and Technology, an International Journal, 24(2): 428–435

[52] Meng H, Nie C, Li W, Duan X, Lai B, Ao Z, Wang S, An T (2020). Insight into the effect of lignocellulosic biomass source on the performance of biochar as persulfate activator for aqueous organic pollutants remediation: Epicarp and mesocarp of citrus peels as examples. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 399: 123043

[53] Neyens E, Baeyens J (2003). A review of classic Fenton’s peroxidation as an advanced oxidation technique. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 98(1–3): 33–50

[54] Oturan M A, Aaron J J (2014). Advanced oxidation processes in water/wastewater treatment: Principles and applications: A review. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 44(23): 2577–2641

[55] Paciolla M D, Davies G, Jansen S A (1999). Generation of hydroxyl radicals from metal-loaded humic acids. Environmental Science & Technology, 33(11): 1814–1818

[56] Pan X, Gu Z, Chen W, Li Q (2021). Preparation of biochar and biochar composites and their application in a Fenton-like process for wastewater decontamination: A review. Science of the Total Environment, 754: 142104

[57] Páramo-Vargas J, Granados S G, Maldonado-Rubio M I, Peralta-Hernández J M (2016). Up to 95% reduction of chemical oxygen demand of slaughterhouse effluents using Fenton and photo-Fenton oxidation. Environmental Chemistry Letters, 14(1): 149–154

[58] Rossi A F, Martins R C, Quinta-ferreira R M (2013). Reuse of homogeneous Fenton’s sludge from detergent industry as Fenton’s catalyst. Journal of Advanced Oxidation Technologies, 16(2): 298–305

[59] Sabhi S, Kiwi J (2001). Degradation of 2,4-dichlorophenol by immobilized iron catalysts. Water Research, 35(8): 1994–2002

[60] Shahrifun N A, Ab’lah N N, Hussain H, Aris A, Omar Q, Ahmad N (2015). Reusability of Fenton sludge to reduce COD and color on palm oil mill secondary effluent (POMSE). Advanced Materials Research, 1113: 486–491

[61] Shahrifun S A, Hussain H, Omar Q (2016). Optimization of solar Fenton Oxidation and comparison of recycle wet and dried Fenton sludge in treating palm oil mill secondary effluent. Jurnal Teknologi, 78(6–7): 61–67

[62] Shen M, Huang Z, Luo X, Ma Y, Chen C, Chen X, Cui L (2020a). Activation of persulfate for tetracycline degradation using the catalyst regenerated from Fenton sludge containing heavy metal: Synergistic effect of Cu for catalysis. Chemical Engineering Journal, 396: 125238

[63] Shen M, Huang Z, Qiu L, Chen Z, Xiao X, Mo X, Cui L (2020b). Recycling of Fenton sludge containing Ni as an efficient catalyst for tetracycline degradation through peroxymonosulfate activation. Journal of Cleaner Production, 268: 122174

[64] Shukla P, Wang S, Sun H, Ang H, Tadé M (2010). Adsorption and heterogeneous advanced oxidation of phenolic contaminants using Fe loaded mesoporous SBA-15 and H₂O₂. Chemical Engineering Journal, 164(1): 255–260

[65] Sillanpää M, Ncibi M C, Matilainen A (2018). Advanced oxidation processes for the removal of natural organic matter from drinking water sources: A comprehensive review. Journal of Environmental Management, 208: 56–76

[66] Tan X, Liu Y, Gu Y, Xu Y, Zeng G, Hu X, Liu S, Wang X, Liu S, Li J (2016). Biochar-based nano-composites for the decontamination of wastewater: A review. Bioresource Technology, 212: 318–333

[67] Tang Y, Ren H, Yang P, Li H, Zhang J, Qu C, Chen G (2019). Treatment of fracturing fluid waste by Fenton reaction using transition metal complexes catalyzes oxidation of hydroxypropyl guar gum at high pH. Environmental Chemistry Letters, 17(1): 559–564

[68] Tao X, Ma W, Li J, Huang Y, Zhao J, Yu J C (2003). Efficient degradation of organic pollutants mediated by immobilized iron tetrasulfophthalocyanine under visible light irradiation. Chemical Communications, 1(1): 80–81

[69] Tong S, Shen J, Jiang X, Li J, Sun X, Xu Z, Chen D (2021). Recycle of Fenton sludge through one-step synthesis of aminated magnetic hydrochar for Pb²⁺ removal from wastewater. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 406: 124581

[70] Umar M, Aziz H A, Yusoff M S (2010). Trends in the use of Fenton, electro-Fenton and photo-Fenton for the treatment of landfill leachate. Waste Management, 30(11): 2113–2121

[71] Voelker B M, Sulzberger B (1996). Effects of Fulvic acid on Fe (II) oxidation by hydrogen peroxide. Environmental Science & Technology, 30(4): 1106–1114

[72] Walling C (1975). Fenton’s reagent revisited. Accounts of Chemical Research, 8(4): 125–131

[73] Wang H, Xiao K, Yang J, Yu Z, Yu W, Xu Q, Wu Q, Liang S, Hu J, Hou H, Liu B (2020). Phosphorus recovery from the liquid phase of anaerobic digestate using biochar derived from iron-rich sludge: A potential phosphorus fertilizer. Water Research, 174: 115629

[74] Wang J, Wang S (2018). Activation of persulfate (PS) and peroxymonosulfate (PMS) and application for the degradation of emerging contaminants. Chemical Engineering Journal, 334: 1502–1517

[75] Wang M, Zhao Z, Zhang Y (2018). Sustainable strategy for enhancing anaerobic digestion of waste activated sludge: driving dissimilatory iron reduction with Fenton sludge. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, 6(2): 2220–2230

[76] Wang M, Zhao Z, Zhang Y (2019). Disposal of Fenton sludge with anaerobic digestion and the roles of humic acids involved in Fenton sludge. Water Research, 163: 114900

[77] Wang N, Zheng T, Zhang G, Wang P (2016). A review on Fenton-like processes for organic wastewater treatment. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 4(1): 762–787

[78] Xiao S, Cheng M, Zhong H, Liu Z, Liu Y, Yang X, Liang Q (2020). Iron-mediated activation of persulfate and peroxymonosulfate in both homogeneous and heterogeneous ways: A review. Chemical Engineering Journal, 384: 123265

[79] Xu Z X, Song H, Deng X Q, Zhang Y Y, Xue-Qin M, Tong S Q, He Z X, Wang Q, Shao Y W, Hu X (2019). Dewatering of sewage sludge via thermal hydrolysis with ammonia-treated Fenton iron sludge as skeleton material. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 379: 120810

[80] Yi Y, Huang Z, Lu B, Xian J, Tsang E P, Cheng W, Fang J, Fang Z (2020). Magnetic biochar for environmental remediation: A review. Bioresource Technology, 298: 122468

[81] Yoo H, Cho S, Ko S (2001). Modification of coagulation and Fenton oxidation processes for cost-effective leachate treatment. Journal of Environmental Science and Health. Part A, Toxic/Hazardous Substances & Environmental Engineering, 36(1): 39–48

[82] Yoon K, Cho D W, Tsang D C W, Bolan N, Rinklebe J, Song H (2017). Fabrication of engineered biochar from paper mill sludge and its application into removal of arsenic and cadmium in acidic water. Bioresource Technology, 246: 69–75

[83] Zhang H, Liu J, Ou C, Faheem, Shen J, Yu H, Jiao Z, Han W, Sun X, Li J, Wang L (2017). Reuse of Fenton sludge as an iron source for NiFe₂O₄ synthesis and its application in the Fenton-based process. Journal of Environmental Sciences-China, 53: 1–8

[84] Zhang H, Xue G, Chen H, Li X (2018). Magnetic biochar catalyst derived from biological sludge and ferric sludge using hydrothermal carbonization: Preparation, characterization and its circulation in Fenton process for dyeing wastewater treatment. Chemosphere, 191: 64–71

[85] Zhang H, Xue G, Chen H, Li X (2019a). Hydrothermal synthesizing sludge-based magnetite catalyst from ferric sludge and biosolids: Formation mechanism and catalytic performance. Science of the Total Environment, 697: 133986

[86] Zhang J (2013). Fenton iron mud preparation of ferrous sulfate and polymeric ferric sulfate and its application. Dissertation for the Master Degree. Nanning: Guangxi University (in Chinese)

[87] Zhang Y, Guo S, Zhou J, Li C, Wang G (2010). Flue gas desulfurization by FeSO₄ solutions and coagulation performance of the polymeric ferric sulfate by-product. Chemical Engineering and Processing, 49(8): 859–865

[88] Zhang M, Dong H, Zhao L, Wang D, Meng D (2019b). A review on Fenton process for organic wastewater treatment based on optimization perspective. Science of the Total Environment, 670: 110–121

[89] Zhou R, Zhang W (2017). Reuse of ferric sludge by ferrous sulfide in the fenton process for nonylphenol ethoxylates wastewater treatment. Computational Water, Energy, and Environmental Engineering, 6(01): 89–96

[90] Zhou Y, Fang X, Wang T, Hu Y, Lu J (2017). Chelating agents enhanced CaO₂ oxidation of bisphenol A catalyzed by Fe³⁺ and reuse of ferric sludge as a source of catalyst. Chemical Engineering Journal, 313: 638–645

[91] Zhu L, Shen D, Luo K H (2020). A critical review on VOCs adsorption by different porous materials: Species, mechanisms and modification methods. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 389: 122102

[92] Zhu S, Huang X, Ma F, Wang L, Duan X, Wang S (2018). Catalytic removal of aqueous contaminants on N-doped graphitic biochars: Inherent roles of adsorption and nonradical mechanisms. Environmental Science & Technology, 52(15): 8649–8658

Acknowledgements

We thank LetPub for its linguistic assistance during the preparation of this manuscript. L. Gao acknowledges the financial support of the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 5210040121), Jiangsu Provincial Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province (No. BK20210498) and the fellowship of China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (No. 2021M693420).

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2021 Higher Education Press