Recent advances in the electrochemical oxidation water treatment: Spotlight on byproduct control

Highlights

• Byproduct formation mechanisms during electrochemical oxidation water treatment.

• Control byproduct formation by quenchers.

• Process optimization to suppress byproduct formation.

Abstract

Electrochemical oxidation (EO) is a promising technique for decentralized wastewater treatment, owing to its modular design, high efficiency, and ease of automation and transportation. The catalytic destruction of recalcitrant, non-biodegradable pollutants (per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), pharmaceuticals, and personal care products (PPCPs), pesticides, etc.) is an appropriate niche for EO. EO can be more effective than homogeneous advanced oxidation processes for the degradation of recalcitrant chemicals inert to radical-mediated oxidation, because the potential of the anode can be made much higher than that of hydroxyl radicals (E_OH = 2.7 V vs. NHE), forcing the direct transfer of electrons from pollutants to electrodes. Unfortunately, at such high anodic potential, chloride ions, which are ubiquitous in natural water systems, will be readily oxidized to chlorine and perchlorate. Perchlorate is a to-be-regulated byproduct, and chlorine can react with matrix organics to produce organic halogen compounds. In the past ten years, novel electrode materials and processes have been developed. However, spotlights were rarely focused on the control of byproduct formation during EO processes in a real-world context. When we use EO techniques to eliminate target contaminants with concentrations at μg/L-levels, byproducts at mg/L-levels might be produced. Is it a good trade-off? Is it possible to inhibit byproduct formation without compromising the performance of EO? In this mini-review, we will summarize the recent advances and provide perspectives to address the above questions.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Electrochemical water treatment / Byproducts / Perchlorate

References

[1] Almassi S, Li Z, Xu W, Pu C, Zeng T, Chaplin B P (2019). Simultaneous adsorption and electrochemical reduction of N-nitrosodimethylamine using carbon-Ti₄O₇ composite reactive electrochemical membranes. Environmental Science & Technology, 53(2): 928–937

[2] Almassi S, Samonte P R V, Li Z, Xu W, Chaplin B P (2020). Mechanistic investigation of haloacetic acid reduction using carbon-Ti₄O₇ composite reactive electrochemical membranes. Environmental Science & Technology, 54(3): 1982–1991

[3] Anglada A, Ibanez R, Urtiaga A, Ortiz I (2010). Electrochemical oxidation of saline industrial wastewaters using boron-doped diamond anodes. Catalysis Today, 151(1–2): 178–184

[4] Anglada A, Urtiaga A, Ortiz I (2009). Pilot scale performance of the electro-oxidation of landfill leachate at boron-doped diamond anodes. Environmental Science & Technology, 43(6): 2035–2040

[5] Bagastyo A Y, Batstone D J, Kristiana I, Gernjak W, Joll C, Radjenovic J (2012). Electrochemical oxidation of reverse osmosis concentrate on boron-doped diamond anodes at circumneutral and acidic pH. Water Research, 46(18): 6104–6112

[6] Bagastyo A Y, Batstone D J, Rabaey K, Radjenovic J (2013). Electrochemical oxidation of electrodialysed reverse osmosis concentrate on Ti/Pt–IrO₂, Ti/SnO₂–Sb and boron-doped diamond electrodes. Water Research, 47(1): 242–250

[7] Barazesh J M, Hennebel T, Jasper J T, Sedlak D L (2015). Modular advanced oxidation process enabled by cathodic hydrogen peroxide production. Environmental Science & Technology, 49(12): 7391–7399

[8] Barazesh J M, Prasse C, Wenk J, Berg S, Remucal C K, Sedlak D L (2018). Trace element removal in distributed drinking water treatment systems by cathodic H₂O₂ production and UV photolysis. Environmental Science & Technology, 52(1): 195–204

[9] Bejan D, Guinea E, Bunce N J (2012). On the nature of the hydroxyl radicals produced at boron-doped diamond and Ebonex® anodes. Electrochimica Acta, 69: 275–281

[10] Bergmann M, Koparal A, Iourtchouk T (2014). Electrochemical advanced oxidation processes, formation of halogenate and perhalogenate species: A critical review. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 44(4): 348–390

[11] Bond T, Goslan E H, Parsons S A, Jefferson B (2012). A critical review of trihalomethane and haloacetic acid formation from natural organic matter surrogates. Environmental Technology Reviews, 1(1): 93–113

[12] Boyce S D, Hornig J F (1983). Reaction pathways of trihalomethane formation from the halogenation of dihydroxyaromatic model compounds for humic acid. Environmental Science & Technology, 17(4): 202–211

[13] Brillas E, Sirés I, Oturan M A (2009). Electro-Fenton process and related electrochemical technologies based on Fenton’s reaction chemistry. Chemical Reviews, 109(12): 6570–6631

[14] Buxton G V, Greenstock C L, Helman W P, Ross A B (1988). Critical review of rate constants for reactions of hydrated electrons, hydrogen atoms and hydroxyl radicals (OH/O⁻ in aqueous solution. Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data, 17(2): 513–886

[15] Carter K E, Farrell J (2008). Oxidative destruction of perfluorooctane sulfonate using boron-doped diamond film electrodes. Environmental Science & Technology, 42(16): 6111–6115

[16] Chaplin B P (2014). Critical review of electrochemical advanced oxidation processes for water treatment applications. Environmental Science. Processes & Impacts, 16(6): 1182–1203

[17] Chaplin B P (2019). The prospect of electrochemical technologies advancing worldwide water treatment. Accounts of Chemical Research, 52(3): 596–604

[18] Chaplin B P, Schrader G, Farrell J (2009). Electrochemical oxidation of N-nitrosodimethylamine with boron-doped diamond film electrodes. Environmental Science & Technology, 43(21): 8302–8307

[19] Chen B (2011). Hydrolytic stabilities of halogenated disinfection byproducts: review and rate constant quantitative structure–property relationship analysis. Environmental Engineering Science, 28(6): 385–394

[20] Cho K, Qu Y, Kwon D, Zhang H, Cid C A, Aryanfar A, Hoffmann M R (2014). Effects of anodic potential and chloride ion on overall reactivity in electrochemical reactors designed for solar-powered wastewater treatment. Environmental Science & Technology, 48(4): 2377–2384

[21] Connick R E (1947). The interaction of hydrogen peroxide and hypochlorous acid in acidic solutions containing chloride ion. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 69(6): 1509–1514

[22] Consonni V, Trasatti S, Pollak F, O’grady W (1987). Mechanism of chlorine evolution on oxide anodes study of pH effects. Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry and Interfacial Electrochemistry, 228(1–2): 393–406

[23] Cotillas S, Llanos J, Rodrigo M A, Cañizares P (2015). Use of carbon felt cathodes for the electrochemical reclamation of urban treated wastewaters. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, 162: 252–259

[24] Deng S, Yu Q, Huang J, Yu G (2010). Removal of perfluorooctane sulfonate from wastewater by anion exchange resins: effects of resin properties and solution chemistry. Water Research, 44(18): 5188–5195

[25] Gayen P, Chaplin B P (2017). Fluorination of boron-doped diamond film electrodes for minimization of perchlorate formation. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 9(33): 27638–27648

[26] Gordon G, Tachiyashiki S (1991). Kinetics and mechanism of formation of chlorate ion from the hypochlorous acid/chlorite ion reaction at pH 6–10. Environmental Science & Technology, 25(3): 468–474

[27] Hong H, Xiong Y, Ruan M, Liao F, Lin H, Liang Y (2013). Factors affecting THMs, HAAs and HNMs formation of Jin Lan Reservoir water exposed to chlorine and monochloramine. Science of the Total Environment, 444: 196–204

[28] Horányi G, Bakos I (1992). Experimental evidence demonstrating the occurrence of reduction processes of ClO₄⁻ ions in an acid medium at platinized platinum electrodes. Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry, 331(1–2): 727–737

[29] Huang X, Qu Y, Cid C A, Finke C, Hoffmann M R, Lim K, Jiang S C (2016). Electrochemical disinfection of toilet wastewater using wastewater electrolysis cell. Water Research, 92: 164–172

[30] Hubler D K, Baygents J C, Chaplin B P, Farrell J (2014). Understanding chlorite, chlorate and perchlorate formation when generating hypochlorite using boron doped diamond film electrodes. ECS Transactions, 58(35): 21–32

[31] Jasper J T, Shafaat O S, Hoffmann M R (2016). Electrochemical transformation of trace organic contaminants in latrine wastewater. Environmental Science & Technology, 50(18): 10198–10208

[32] Jasper J T, Yang Y, Hoffmann M R (2017). Toxic byproduct formation during electrochemical treatment of latrine wastewater. Environmental Science & Technology, 51(12): 7111–7119

[33] Jawando W, Gayen P, Chaplin B P (2015). The effects of surface oxidation and fluorination of boron-doped diamond anodes on perchlorate formation and organic compound oxidation. Electrochimica Acta, 174: 1067–1078

[34] Jung Y J, Baek K W, Oh B S, Kang J W (2010). An investigation of the formation of chlorate and perchlorate during electrolysis using Pt/Ti electrodes: The effects of pH and reactive oxygen species and the results of kinetic studies. Water Research, 44(18): 5345–5355

[35] Kesselman J M, Weres O, Lewis N S, Hoffmann M R (1997). Electrochemical production of hydroxyl radical at polycrystalline Nb-doped TiO₂ electrodes and estimation of the partitioning between hydroxyl radical and direct hole oxidation pathways. Journal of Physical Chemistry B, 101(14): 2637–2643

[36] Krishtalik L (1981). Kinetics and mechanism of anodic chlorine and oxygen evolution reactions on transition metal oxide electrodes. Electrochimica Acta, 26(3): 329–337

[37] Le T X H, Haflich H, Shah A D, Chaplin B P (2019). Energy-efficient electrochemical oxidation of perfluoroalkyl substances using a Ti₄O₇ reactive electrochemical membrane anode. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 6(8): 504–510

[38] Li T, Farrell J (2000). Reductive dechlorination of trichloroethene and carbon tetrachloride using iron and palladized-iron cathodes. Environmental Science & Technology, 34(1): 173–179

[39] Li X F, Mitch W A (2018). Drinking water disinfection byproducts (DBPs) and human health effects: multidisciplinary challenges and opportunities. Environmental Science & Technology, 52(4): 1681–1689

[40] Liang S, Pierce R D Jr, Lin H, Chiang S Y, Huang Q J (2018). Electrochemical oxidation of PFOA and PFOS in concentrated waste streams. Remediation Journal, 28(2): 127–134

[41] Lin Z, Yao W, Wang Y, Yu G, Deng S, Huang J, Wang B (2016). Perchlorate formation during the electro-peroxone treatment of chloride-containing water: effects of operational parameters and control strategies. Water Research, 88: 691–702

[42] Liu J, Choe J K, Wang Y, Shapley J R, Werth C J, Strathmann T J (2015). Bioinspired complex-nanoparticle hybrid catalyst system for aqueous perchlorate reduction: Rhenium speciation and its influence on catalyst activity. ACS Catalysis, 5(2): 511–522

[43] Liu J, Han M, Wu D, Chen X, Choe J K, Werth C J, Strathmann T J (2016). New bioinspired perchlorate reduction catalyst with significantly enhanced stability via rational tuning of rhenium coordination chemistry and heterogeneous reaction pathway. Environmental Science & Technology, 50(11): 5874–5881

[44] Luo H, Li C, Wu C, Dong X (2015). In situ electrosynthesis of hydrogen peroxide with an improved gas diffusion cathode by rolling carbon black and PTFE. RSC Advances, 5(80): 65227–65235

[45] Mahmudov R, Shu Y, Rykov S, Chen J, Huang C P (2008). The reduction of perchlorate by hydrogenation catalysts. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental, 81(1–2): 78–87

[46] Mao R, Lan H, Yan L, Zhao X, Liu H, Qu J (2018). Enhanced indirect atomic H* reduction at a hybrid Pd/graphene cathode for electrochemical dechlorination under low negative potentials. Environmental Science. Nano, 5(10): 2282–2292

[47] Mao R, Li N, Lan H, Zhao X, Liu H, Qu J, Sun M (2016). Dechlorination of trichloroacetic acid using a noble metal-free graphene-Cu foam electrode via direct cathodic reduction and atomic H*. Environmental Science & Technology, 50(7): 3829–3837

[48] Martínez‐Huitle C A, Brillas E, (2008). Electrochemical alternatives for drinking water disinfection. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 47(11): 1998–2005

[49] Martínez-Huitle C A, Rodrigo M A, Sirés I, Scialdone O (2015). Single and coupled electrochemical processes and reactors for the abatement of organic water pollutants: A critical review. Chemical Reviews, 115(24): 13362–13407

[50] McCurry D L, Ishida K P, Oelker G L, Mitch W A (2017). Reverse osmosis shifts chloramine speciation causing Re-formation of NDMA during potable reuse of wastewater. Environmental Science & Technology, 51(15): 8589–8596

[51] Mostafa E, Reinsberg P, Garcia-Segura S, Baltruschat H (2018). Chlorine species evolution during electrochlorination on boron-doped diamond anodes: In-situ electrogeneration of Cl₂, Cl₂O and ClO₂. Electrochimica Acta, 281: 831–840

[52] Navalon S, Alvaro M, Garcia H (2008). Carbohydrates as trihalomethanes precursors. Influence of pH and the presence of Cl⁻ and Br⁻ on trihalomethane formation potential. Water Research, 42(14): 3990–4000

[53] Niu J, Lin H, Gong C, Sun X (2013). Theoretical and experimental insights into the electrochemical mineralization mechanism of perfluorooctanoic acid. Environmental Science & Technology, 47(24): 14341–14349

[54] Park H, Vecitis C D, Hoffmann M R (2009). Electrochemical water splitting coupled with organic compound oxidation: The role of active chlorine species. Journal of Physical Chemistry C, 113(18): 7935–7945

[55] Pourmoghaddas H, Stevens A A (1995). Relationship between trihalomethanes and haloacetic acids with total organic halogen during chlorination. Water Research, 29(9): 2059–2062

[56] Qi Y, Shang C, Lo I M (2004). Formation of haloacetic acids during monochloramination. Water Research, 38(9): 2375–2383

[57] Radjenović J, Farré M J, Mu Y, Gernjak W, Keller J (2012). Reductive electrochemical remediation of emerging and regulated disinfection byproducts. Water Research, 46(6): 1705–1714

[58] Richardson S D, Plewa M J, Wagner E D, Schoeny R, Demarini D M (2007). Occurrence, genotoxicity, and carcinogenicity of regulated and emerging disinfection by-products in drinking water: A review and roadmap for research. Mutation Research/Reviews in Mutation Research, 636(1–3): 178–242

[59] Rook J J (1977). Chlorination reactions of fulvic acids in natural waters. Environmental Science & Technology, 11(5): 478–482

[60] Rusanova M Y, Polášková P, Muzikař M, Fawcett W R (2006). Electrochemical reduction of perchlorate ions on platinum-activated nickel. Electrochimica Acta, 51(15): 3097–3101

[61] Schaefer C, Fuller M, Condee C, Lowey J, Hatzinger P (2007). Comparison of biotic and abiotic treatment approaches for co-mingled perchlorate, nitrate, and nitramine explosives in groundwater. Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, 89(3–4): 231–250

[62] Schaefer C E, Andaya C, Burant A, Condee C W, Urtiaga A, Strathmann T J, Higgins C P (2017). Electrochemical treatment of perfluorooctanoic acid and perfluorooctane sulfonate: Insights into mechanisms and application to groundwater treatment. Chemical Engineering Journal, 317: 424–432

[63] Schaefer C E, Andaya C, Urtiaga A (2015). Assessment of disinfection and by-product formation during electrochemical treatment of surface water using a Ti/IrO₂ anode. Chemical Engineering Journal, 264: 411–416

[64] Selbes M, Beita-Sandí W, Kim D, Karanfil T (2018). The role of chloramine species in NDMA formation. Water Research, 140: 100–109

[65] Sérodes J B, Rodriguez M J, Li H, Bouchard C (2003). Occurrence of THMs and HAAs in experimental chlorinated waters of the Quebec City area (Canada). Chemosphere, 51(4): 253–263

[66] Sun Y X, Wu Q Y, Hu H Y, Tian J (2009). Effects of operating conditions on THMs and HAAs formation during wastewater chlorination. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 168(2–3): 1290–1295

[67] Thurman E M (2012). Organic Geochemistry of Natural Waters. Berlin: Springer Science & Business Media, 90–92

[68] Trasatti S (1984). Electrocatalysis in the anodic evolution of oxygen and chlorine. Electrochimica Acta, 29(11): 1503–1512

[69] Trasatti S (1987). Progress in the understanding of the mechanism of chlorine evolution at oxide electrodes. Electrochimica Acta, 32(3): 369–382

[70] Urbansky E T, Schock M (1999). Issues in managing the risks associated with perchlorate in drinking water. Journal of Environmental Management, 56(2): 79–95

[71] USEPA (2010). Comprehensive Disinfectants and Disinfection Byproducts Rules (Stage 1 and Stage 2): Quick Reference Guide. Available online at the website of www.epa.gov/ground-water-and-drinking-water (accessed May 03, 2020)

[72] Vellanki B P, Batchelor B, Abdel-Wahab A (2013). Advanced reduction processes: A new class of treatment processes. Environmental Engineering Science, 30(5): 264–271

[73] Wagner E D, Plewa M J (2017). CHO cell cytotoxicity and genotoxicity analyses of disinfection by-products: an updated review. Journal of Environmental Sciences (China), 58: 64–76

[74] Wang D, Huang C, Chen J, Lin H, Shah S (2007). Reduction of perchlorate in dilute aqueous solutions over monometallic nano-catalysts: Exemplified by tin. Separation and Purification Technology, 58(1): 129–137

[75] Wang L, Lu J, Li L, Wang Y, Huang Q (2020). Effects of chloride on electrochemical degradation of perfluorooctanesulfonate by Magnéli phase Ti₄O₇ and boron doped diamond anodes. Water Research, 170: 115254

[76] Wasberg M, Horányi G (1995). The reduction of ClO₄- ions on Rh electrodes. Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry, 385(1): 63–70

[77] Xia C, Xia Y, Zhu P, Fan L, Wang H (2019). Direct electrosynthesis of pure aqueous H₂O₂ solutions up to 20% by weight using a solid electrolyte. Science, 366(6462): 226–231

[78] Yang S, Fernando S, Holsen T M, Yang Y (2019a). Inhibition of perchlorate formation during the electrochemical oxidation of perfluoroalkyl acid in groundwater. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 6(12): 775–780

[79] Yang Y, Hoffmann M R (2016). Synthesis and stabilization of blue-black TiO₂ nanotube arrays for electrochemical oxidant generation and wastewater treatment. Environmental Science & Technology, 50(21): 11888–11894

[80] Yang Y, Kao L C, Liu Y, Sun K, Yu H, Guo J, Liou S Y H, Hoffmann M R (2018). Cobalt-doped black TiO₂ nanotube array as a stable anode for oxygen evolution and electrochemical wastewater treatment. ACS Catalysis, 8(5): 4278–4287

[81] Yang Y, Lin L, Tse L K, Dong H, Yu S, Hoffmann M R (2019b). Membrane-separated electrochemical latrine wastewater treatment. Environmental Science. Water Research & Technology, 5(1): 51–59

[82] Yang Y, Shin J, Jasper J T, Hoffmann M R (2016). Multilayer heterojunction anodes for saline wastewater treatment: Design strategies and reactive species generation mechanisms. Environmental Science & Technology, 50(16): 8780–8787

[83] Yao W, Fu J, Yang H, Yu G, Wang Y (2019). The beneficial effect of cathodic hydrogen peroxide generation on mitigating chlorinated by-product formation during water treatment by an electro-peroxone process. Water Research, 157: 209–217

[84] Yu Q, Zhang R, Deng S, Huang J, Yu G (2009). Sorption of perfluorooctane sulfonate and perfluorooctanoate on activated carbons and resin: Kinetic and isotherm study. Water Research, 43(4): 1150–1158

[85] Yu X Y (2004). Critical evaluation of rate constants and equilibrium constants of hydrogen peroxide photolysis in acidic aqueous solutions containing chloride ions. Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data, 33(3): 747–763

[86] Yuan S, Li Z, Wang Y (2013). Effective degradation of methylene blue by a novel electrochemically driven process. Electrochemistry Communications, 29: 48–51

[87] Zaky A M, Chaplin B P (2013). Porous substoichiometric TiO₂ anodes as reactive electrochemical membranes for water treatment. Environmental Science & Technology, 47(12): 6554–6563

[88] Zaky A M, Chaplin B P (2014). Mechanism of p-substituted phenol oxidation at a Ti₄O₇ reactive electrochemical membrane. Environmental Science & Technology, 48(10): 5857–5867

[89] Zhang C, He D, Ma J, Waite T D (2018). Active chlorine mediated ammonia oxidation revisited: Reaction mechanism, kinetic modelling and implications. Water Research, 145: 220–230

[90] Zhuo Q, Deng S, Yang B, Huang J, Wang B, Zhang T, Yu G (2012). Degradation of perfluorinated compounds on a boron-doped diamond electrode. Electrochimica Acta, 77: 17–22

[91] Zöllig H, Remmele A, Fritzsche C, Morgenroth E, Udert K M (2015). Formation of chlorination byproducts and their emission pathways in chlorine mediated electro-oxidation of urine on active and nonactive type anodes. Environmental Science & Technology, 49(18): 11062–11069

Acknowledgement

This work is supported by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF INV-003227).

Open Access

This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2020 The Author(s) 2020. This article is published with open access at link.springer.com and journal.hep. com.cn