Review on remediation technologies for arsenic-contaminated soil

Highlights

• Recent progress of As-contaminated soil remediation technologies is presented.

• Phytoextraction and chemical immobilization are the most widely used methods.

• Novel remediation technologies for As-contaminated soil are still urgently needed.

• Methods for evaluating soil remediation efficiency are lacking.

• Future research directions for As-contaminated soil remediation are proposed.

Abstract

Arsenic (As) is a top human carcinogen widely distributed in the environment. As-contaminated soil exists worldwide and poses a threat on human health through water/food consumption, inhalation, or skin contact. More than 200 million people are exposed to excessive As concentration through direct or indirect exposure to contaminated soil. Therefore, affordable and efficient technologies that control risks caused by excess As in soil must be developed. The presently available methods can be classified as chemical, physical, and biological. Combined utilization of multiple technologies is also common to improve remediation efficiency. This review presents the research progress on different remediation technologies for As-contaminated soil. For chemical methods, common soil washing or immobilization agents were summarized. Physical technologies were mainly discussed from the field scale. Phytoextraction, the most widely used technology for As-contaminated soil in China, was the main focus for bioremediation. Method development for evaluating soil remediation efficiency was also summarized. Further research directions were proposed based on literature analysis.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Arsenic, field-scale / Immobilization / Phytoextraction / Soil washing

References

[1] Abou Jaoude L, Garau G, Nassif N, Darwish T, Castaldi P (2019). Metal(loid)s immobilization in soils of Lebanon using municipal solid waste compost: Microbial and biochemical impact. Applied Soil Ecology, 143: 134–143

[2] Achal V, Pan X L, Fu Q L, Zhang D Y (2012). Biomineralization based remediation of As(III) contaminated soil by Sporosarcina ginsengisoli. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 201–202: 178–184

[3] Alozie N, Heaney N, Lin C (2018). Biochar immobilizes soil-borne arsenic but not cationic metals in the presence of low-molecular-weight organic acids. Science of the Total Environment, 630: 1188–1194

[4] Amrate S, Akretche D E, Innocent C, Seta P (2006). Use of cation-exchange membranes for simultaneous recovery of lead and EDTA during electrokinetic extraction. Desalination, 193(1–3): 405–410

[5] An J, Jeong B, Nam K (2019). Evaluation of the effectiveness of in situ stabilization in the field aged arsenic-contaminated soil: Chemical extractability and biological response. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 367: 137–143

[6] Anh B T K, Minh N N, Ha N T H, Kim D D, Kien N T, Trung N Q, Cuong T T, Danh L T (2018). Field survey and comparative study of Pteris vittata and Pityrogramma calomelanos grown on arsenic contaminated lands with different soil pH. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 100(5): 720–726

[7] Arenas-Lago D, Abreu M M, Andrade Couce L, Vega F A (2019). Is nanoremediation an effective tool to reduce the bioavailable As, Pb and Sb contents in mine soils from Iberian Pyrite Belt? Catena, 176: 362–371

[8] Beiyuan J, Li J S, Tsang D C W, Wang L, Poon C S, Li X D, Fendorf S (2017). Fate of arsenic before and after chemical-enhanced washing of an arsenic-containing soil in Hong Kong. Science of the Total Environment, 599–600: 679–688

[9] Chen C H, Chiou I J (2008). Remediation of heavy metal-contaminated farm soil using turnover and attenuation method guided with a sustainable management framework. Environmental Engineering Science, 25(1): 11–32

[10] Chen T, Lei M, Wan X, Yang J, Zhou X (2018a). Twenty years of research and development on soil pollution and remediation in China. Luo Y, Tu C, eds. Singapore: Springer Singapore, 465–476

[11] Chen Y, Xu J, Lv Z, Xie R, Huang L, Jiang J (2018b). Impacts of biochar and oyster shells waste on the immobilization of arsenic in highly contaminated soils. Journal of Environmental Management 217, 646–653

[12] Claveria R J R, Perez T R, Apuan M J B, Apuan D A, Perez R E C (2019). Pteris melanocaulon Fee is an As hyperaccumulator. Chemosphere, 236: 124380

[13] Cui M, Lee Y, Choi J, Kim J, Han Z, Son Y, Khim J (2018). Evaluation of stabilizing materials for immobilization of toxic heavy metals in contaminated agricultural soils in China. Journal of Cleaner Production, 193: 748–758

[14] da Silva E B, Mussoline W A, Wilkie A C, Ma L Q (2019). Arsenic removal and biomass reduction of As-hyperaccumulator Pteris vittata: Coupling ethanol extraction with anaerobic digestion. Science of the Total Environment, 666: 205–211

[15] Doherty S J, Tighe M K, Wilson S C (2017). Evaluation of amendments to reduce arsenic and antimony leaching from co-contaminated soils. Chemosphere, 174: 208–217

[16] Dolphen R, Thiravetyan P (2019). Reducing arsenic in rice grains by leonardite and arsenic–resistant endophytic bacteria. Chemosphere, 223: 448–454

[17] Doyle J R, Blais J M, Holmes R D, White P A (2012). A soil ingestion pilot study of a population following a traditional lifestyle typical of rural or wilderness areas. Science of the Total Environment, 424: 110–120

[18] Eze V C, Harvey A P (2018). Extractive recovery and valorisation of arsenic from contaminated soil through phytoremediation using Pteris cretica. Chemosphere, 208: 484–492

[19] Franchi E, Cosmina P, Pedron F, Rosellini I, Barbafieri M, Petruzzelli G, Vocciante M (2019). Improved arsenic phytoextraction by combined use of mobilizing chemicals and autochthonous soil bacteria. Science of the Total Environment, 655: 328–336

[20] Ghosh P, Rathinasabapathi B, Ma L Q (2011). Arsenic-resistant bacteria solubilized arsenic in the growth media and increased growth of arsenic hyperaccumulator Pteris vittata L. Bioresource Technology, 102(19): 8756–8761

[21] Gil-Díaz M, Alonso J, Rodríguez-Valdés E, Gallego J R, Lobo M C (2017). Comparing different commercial zero valent iron nanoparticles to immobilize As and Hg in brownfield soil. Science of the Total Environment, 584–585: 1324–1332

[22] Gil-Díaz M, Rodríguez-Valdés E, Alonso J, Baragaño D, Gallego J R, Lobo M C (2019). Nanoremediation and long-term monitoring of brownfield soil highly polluted with As and Hg. Science of the Total Environment, 675: 165–175

[23] Gosselin M, Zagury G J (2020). Metal(loid)s inhalation bioaccessibility and oxidative potential of particulate matter from chromated copper arsenate (CCA)-contaminated soils. Chemosphere, 238: 124557

[24] Gusiatin Z M (2014). Tannic acid and saponin for removing arsenic from brownfield soils: Mobilization, distribution and speciation. Journal of Environmental Sciences (China), 26(4): 855–864

[25] Gustave W, Yuan Z F, Sekar R, Chang H C, Zhang J, Wells M, Ren Y X, Chen Z (2018). Arsenic mitigation in paddy soils by using microbial fuel cells. Environmental Pollution, 238: 647– 655

[26] Habibul N, Hu Y, Sheng G P (2016). Microbial fuel cell driving electrokinetic remediation of toxic metal contaminated soils. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 318: 9–14

[27] Han Y H, Liu X, Rathinasabapathi B, Li H B, Chen Y S, Ma L Q (2017). Mechanisms of efficient As solubilization in soils and As accumulation by As-hyperaccumulator Pteris vittata. Environmental Pollution, 227: 569–577

[28] Im J, Yang K, Jho E H, Nam K (2015). Effect of different soil washing solutions on bioavailability of residual arsenic in soils and soil properties. Chemosphere, 138: 253–258

[29] Isosaari P, Sillanpää M (2012). Effects of oxalate and phosphate on electrokinetic removal of arsenic from mine tailings. Separation and Purification Technology, 86: 26–34

[30] Jang M, Hwang J S, Choi S I (2007). Sequential soil washing techniques using hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide for remediating arsenic-contaminated soils in abandoned iron-ore mines. Chemosphere, 66(1): 8–17

[31] Jeon E K, Ryu S R, Baek K (2015). Application of solar-cells in the electrokinetic remediation of As-contaminated soil. Electrochimica Acta, 181: 160–166

[32] Jho E H, Im J, Yang K, Kim Y J, Nam K (2015). Changes in soil toxicity by phosphate-aided soil washing: Effect of soil characteristics, chemical forms of arsenic, and cations in washing solutions. Chemosphere, 119: 1399–1405

[33] Kertulis-Tartar G M, Ma L Q, Tu C, Chirenje T (2006). Phytoremediation of an arsenic-contaminated site using Pteris vitrata L.: A two-year study. International Journal of Phytoremediation, 8(4): 311–322

[34] Kim W S, Jeon E K, Jung J M, Jung H B, Ko S H, Seo C I, Baek K (2014). Field application of electrokinetic remediation for multi-metal contaminated paddy soil using two-dimensional electrode configuration. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 21(6): 4482–4491

[35] Ko M S, Kim J Y, Park H S, Kim K W (2015). Field assessment of arsenic immobilization in soil amended with iron rich acid mine drainage sludge. Journal of Cleaner Production, 108: 1073–1080

[36] Ko M S, Park H S, Lee J U (2017). Influence of indigenous bacteria stimulation on arsenic immobilization in field study. Catena, 148: 46–51

[37] Lazo P, Cullaj A, Arapi A, Deda T (2007). Trace metals and other contaminants in the environment. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 237–256

[38] Lee K Y, Bosch J, Meckenstock R U (2012). Use of metal-reducing bacteria for bioremediation of soil contaminated with mixed organic and inorganic pollutants. Environmental Geochemistry and Health, 34(S1): 135–142

[39] Li J, Ding Y, Wang K, Li N, Qian G, Xu Y, Zhang J (2020). Comparison of humic and fulvic acid on remediation of arsenic contaminated soil by electrokinetic technology. Chemosphere, 241: 125038

[40] Li J T, Gurajala H K, Wu L H, Van Der Ent A, Qiu R L, Baker A J M, Tang Y T, Yang X E, Shu W S (2018). Hyperaccumulator plants from China: A synthesis of the current state of knowledge. Environmental Science & Technology, 52(21): 11980–11994

[41] Liang Q, Zhao D (2014). Immobilization of arsenate in a sandy loam soil using starch-stabilized magnetite nanoparticles. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 271: 16–23

[42] Lin K Y, Chen Y M, Chen L F, Wang M K, Liu C C (2017). Remediation of arsenic-contaminated soil using alkaline extractable organic carbon solution prepared from wine-processing waste sludge. Soil & Sediment Contamination, 26(6): 569–583

[43] Liu S, Zhang F, Chen J, Sun G X (2011). Arsenic removal from contaminated soil via biovolatilization by genetically engineered bacteria under laboratory conditions. Journal of Environmental Sciences (China), 23(9): 1544–1550

[44] Ma L Q, Komar K M, Tu C, Zhang W H, Cai Y, Kennelley E D (2001). A fern that hyperaccumulates arsenic. Nature, 409(6820): 579

[45] Mallick I, Islam E, Kumar Mukherjee S. (2015). Fundamentals and application potential of arsenic-resistant bacteria for bioremediation in rhizosphere: A review. Soil & Sediment Contamination, 24(6): 704–718

[46] Mallick I, Mukherjee S K (2015). Bioremediation potential of an arsenic immobilizing strain Brevibacillus sp. KUMAs1 in the rhizosphere of chilli plant. Environmental Earth Sciences, 74(9): 6757–6765

[47] Mao X, Han F X, Shao X, Arslan Z, Mccomb J, Chang T, Guo K, Celik A (2016). Remediation of lead-, arsenic-, and cesium-contaminated soil using consecutive washing enhanced with electro-kinetic field. Journal of Soils and Sediments, 16(10): 2344–2353

[48] Marwa N, Singh N, Srivastava S, Saxena G, Pandey V, Singh N (2019). Characterizing the hypertolerance potential of two indigenous bacterial strains (Bacillus flexus and Acinetobacter junii) and their efficacy in arsenic bioremediation. Journal of Applied Microbiology, 126(4): 1117–1127

[49] Ministry of Environment, Government of Japan (2006). Enforcement status of agricultural land-soil pollution prevention law in 2005 fiscal year. MOE, Japan

[50] Mohd S, Kushwaha A S, Shukla J, Mandrah K, Shankar J, Arjaria N, Saxena P N, Khare P, Narayan R, Dixit S, Siddiqui M H, Tuteja N, Das M, Roy S K, Kumar M (2019). Fungal mediated biotransformation reduces toxicity of arsenic to soil dwelling microorganism and plant. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 176: 108–118

[51] Morais M A, Gasparon M, Delbem I D, Caldeira C L, Freitas E T F, Ng J C, Ciminelli V S T (2019). Gastric/lung bioaccessibility and identification of arsenic-bearing phases and sources of fine surface dust in a gold mining district. Science of the Total Environment, 689: 1244–1254

[52] Mukhopadhyay S, Mukherjee S, Hashim M A, Sen Gupta B (2017). Remediation of arsenic contaminated soil using phosphate and colloidal gas aphron suspensions produced from Sapindus mukorossi. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 98(3): 366–372

[53] Navazas A, Hendrix S, Cuypers A, González A (2019). Integrative response of arsenic uptake, speciation and detoxification by Salix atrocinerea. Science of the Total Environment, 689: 422–433

[54] Nijboer M H, Okx J P, Beinat E, Van Drunen M A, Janssen R, Res Ctr K (1998). REC: A decision support system for comparing soil remediation options based on risk reduction, environmental merit and costs. London: Thomas Telford Services Ltd.

[55] Petkova K, Jurkovic L, Simonovicova A, Cernansky S Sgem (2013). Geoconference on ecology, economics, education and legislation, Sgem 2013, Vol I. Sofia: Stef92 Technology Ltd., 757–763

[56] Pratush A, Kumar A, Hu Z (2018). Adverse effect of heavy metals (As, Pb, Hg, and Cr) on health and their bioremediation strategies: A review. International Microbiology, 21(3): 97–106

[57] Qiao J T, Liu T X, Wang X Q, Li F B, Lv Y H, Cui J H, Zeng X D, Yuan Y Z, Liu C P (2018). Simultaneous alleviation of cadmium and arsenic accumulation in rice by applying zero-valent iron and biochar to contaminated paddy soils. Chemosphere, 195: 260–271

[58] Qiu R, Zou Z, Zhao Z, Zhang W, Zhang T, Dong H, Wei X (2010). Removal of trace and major metals by soil washing with Na₂EDTA and oxalate. Journal of Soils and Sediments, 10(1): 45–53

[59] Ramírez-Rodríguez A E, Bañuelos-Hernández B, García-Soto M J, Govea-Alonso D G, Rosales-Mendoza S, Alfaro De La Torre M C, Monreal-Escalante E, Paz-Maldonado L M T (2019). Arsenic removal using Chlamydomonas reinhardtii modified with the gene acr3 and enhancement of its performance by decreasing phosphate in the growing media. International Journal of Phytoremediation, 21(7): 617–623

[60] Rasmussen S B, Jensen J K, Borggaard O K (2015). A laboratory test of NOM-assisted remediation of arsenic and copper contaminated soils. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 3(4, Part B): 3020–3023

[61] Rebitzer G, Ekvall T, Frischknecht R, Hunkeler D, Norris G, Rydberg T, Schmidt W P, Suh S, Weidema B P, Pennington D W (2004). Life cycle assessment: Part 1: Framework, goal and scope definition, inventory analysis, and applications. Environment International, 30(5): 701–720

[62] RoyChowdhury A, Sarkar D, Datta R (2019). A combined chemical and phytoremediation method for reclamation of acid mine drainage-impacted soils. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 26(14): 14414–14425

[63] Ryu S-R, Jeon E-K, Baek K (2017). A combination of reducing and chelating agents for electrolyte conditioning in electrokinetic remediation of As-contaminated soil. Journal of the Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers, 70: 252–259

[64] Samiee F, Leili M, Faradmal J, Torkshavand Z, Asadi G (2019). Exposure to arsenic through breast milk from mothers exposed to high levels of arsenic in drinking water: Infant risk assessment. Food Control, 106: 106669

[65] Singh M, Srivastava P K, Verma P C, Kharwar R N, Singh N, Tripathi R D (2015a). Soil fungi for mycoremediation of arsenic pollution in agriculture soils. Journal of Applied Microbiology, 119(5): 1278–1290

[66] Singh S, Shrivastava A, Barla A, Bose S (2015b). Isolation of arsenic-resistant bacteria from Bengal delta sediments and their efficacy in arsenic removal from soil in association with Pteris vittata. Geomicrobiology Journal, 32(8): 712–723

[67] Soares Guimarães L H, Segura F R, Tonani L, Von-Zeska-Kress M R, Rodrigues J L, Calixto L A, Silva F F, Batista B L (2019). Arsenic volatilization by Aspergillus sp. and Penicillium sp. isolated from rice rhizosphere as a promising eco-safe tool for arsenic mitigation. Journal of Environmental Management, 237: 170–179

[68] Souri Z, Karimi N, Sandalio L M (2017). Arsenic hyperaccumulation strategies: An overview. Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology, 5: 67–74

[69] Tanda S, Licbinsky R, Hegrova J, Faimon J, Goessler W (2019). Arsenic speciation in aerosols of a respiratory therapeutic cave: A first approach to study arsenicals in ultrafine particles. Science of the Total Environment, 651: 1839–1848

[70] Tiberg C, Kumpiene J, Gustafsson J P, Marsz A, Persson I, Mench M, Kleja D B (2016). Immobilization of Cu and As in two contaminated soils with zero-valent iron: Long-term performance and mechanisms. Applied Geochemistry, 67: 144–152

[71] Tong H, Liu C, Hao L, Swanner E D, Chen M, Li F, Xia Y, Liu Y, Liu Y (2019). Biological Fe(II) and As(III) oxidation immobilizes arsenic in micro-oxic environments. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 265: 96–108

[72] Wan X, Lei M (2018). Intercropping efficiency of four arsenic hyperaccumulator Pteris vittata populations as intercrops with Morus alba. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 25(13): 12600–12611

[73] Wan X, Lei M, Chen T (2016). Cost–benefit calculation of phytoremediation technology for heavy-metal-contaminated soil. Science of the Total Environment, 563–564: 796–802

[74] Wang L, Cho D-W, Tsang D C W, Cao X, Hou D, Shen Z, Alessi D S, Ok Y S, Poon C S (2019). Green remediation of As and Pb contaminated soil using cement-free clay-based stabilization/solidification. Environment International, 126: 336–345

[75] Wang Q, Xiong D, Zhao P, Yu X, Tu B, Wang G (2011). Effect of applying an arsenic-resistant and plant growth-promoting rhizobacterium to enhance soil arsenic phytoremediation by Populus deltoides LH05–17. Journal of Applied Microbiology, 111(5): 1065–1074

[76] Wang Y, Ma F, Zhang Q, Peng C, Wu B, Li F, Gu Q (2017). An evaluation of different soil washing solutions for remediating arsenic-contaminated soils. Chemosphere, 173: 368–372

[77] Wei M, Chen J J, Wang X W (2016). Removal of arsenic and cadmium with sequential soil washing techniques using Na₂EDTA, oxalic and phosphoric acid: Optimization conditions, removal effectiveness and ecological risks. Chemosphere, 156: 252–261

[78] Wen Y, Marshall W D (2011). Simultaneous mobilization of trace elements and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) compounds from soil with a nonionic surfactant and [S,S]-EDDS in admixture: Metals. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 197: 361–368

[79] Xie Q E, Yan X L, Liao X Y, Li X (2009). The arsenic hyperaccumulator fern Pteris vittata L. Environmental Science & Technology, 43(22): 8488–8495

[80] Yamamura S, Yamamoto N, Ike M, Fujita M (2005). Arsenic extraction from solid phase using a dissimilatory arsenate-reducing bacterium. Journal of Bioscience and Bioengineering, 100(2): 219–222

[81] Yan H L, Gao Y W, Wu L L, Wang L Y, Zhang T, Dai C H, Xu W X, Feng L, Ma M, Zhu Y G, He Z Y (2019). Potential use of the Pteris vittata arsenic hyperaccumulation-regulation network for phytoremediation. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 368: 386–396

[82] Yang J, Yang S S, Lei M, Yang J X, Wan X M, Chen T B, Wang X L, Guo G H, Guo J M, Liu S Q (2018). Comparison among soil additives for enhancing Pteris vittata L.: Phytoremediation of As-contaminated soil. International Journal of Phytoremediation, 20(13): 1300–1306

[83] Yang Z, Wu Z, Liao Y, Liao Q, Yang W, Chai L (2017). Combination of microbial oxidation and biogenic schwertmannite immobilization: A potential remediation for highly arsenic-contaminated soil. Chemosphere, 181: 1–8

[84] Yoon Y, Kim S, Chae Y, Jeong S W, An Y J (2016). Evaluation of bioavailable arsenic and remediation performance using a whole-cell bioreporter. Science of the Total Environment, 547: 125–131

[85] Yu Z, Zhou L, Huang Y, Song Z, Qiu W (2015). Effects of a manganese oxide-modified biochar composite on adsorption of arsenic in red soil. Journal of Environmental Management, 163: 155–162

[86] Yuan C, Chiang T S (2008). Enhancement of electrokinetic remediation of arsenic spiked soil by chemical reagents. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 152(1): 309–315

[87] Zhang Y, Wan X M, Lei M (2017). Application of arsenic hyperaccumulator Pteris vittata L. to contaminated soil in Northern China. Journal of Geochemical Exploration, 182: 132– 137

[88] Zhao R R, Li X J, Zhang Z G, Zhao G H (2016). KH₂PO₄-aided soil washing for removing arsenic from water-stable soil aggregates collected in southern China. Environmental Engineering Research, 21(3): 304–310

[89] Zhou Y, Niu L, Liu K, Yin S, Liu W (2018). Arsenic in agricultural soils across China: Distribution pattern, accumulation trend, influencing factors, and risk assessment. Science of the Total Environment, 616–617: 156–163

[90] Zhu N, Qiao J, Yan T (2019). Arsenic immobilization through regulated ferrolysis in paddy field amendment with bismuth impregnated biochar. Science of the Total Environment, 648: 993–1001

Acknowledgements

Financial support was provided by the Innovation Academy for Green Manufacture, Chinese Academy of Sciences (Grant No. IAGM-2019-A16-5), the National Key Research and Development Program of China (Grant No. 2018YFC1800302), and the Youth Innovation Promotion Association of the Chinese Academy of Sciences.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2019 Higher Education Press and Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature