Association between heavy metals and antibiotic-resistant human pathogens in environmental reservoirs: A review

Highlights

Heavy metals can act as co-selecting agents and promote antibiotic resistance.

Most frequent resistances to heavy metals are observed for zinc and cadmium.

P. aeruginosa and E. coli are commonly resistant to heavy metals and antibiotics.

Heavy metals proliferate antibiotic resistance through co- and cross-resistance.

Heavy metal and antibiotic resistances are common near anthropogenic activities.

Abstract

Antibiotic resistance in human pathogens can proliferate under selective pressures. Heavy metals in environmental reservoirs may contribute to selecting antibiotic-resistant strains. To determine the associations between heavy metals and antibiotic resistance, a literature review was conducted to systematically collect and categorize evidence for co-occurrence of resistance to heavy metals and antibiotics within human pathogenic bacteria in water, wastewater, and soil. In total, 42 publications adhered to inclusion criteria. Across the reservoirs, zinc and cadmium were the most commonly observed heavy metals associated with resistance to antibiotics. Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Escherichia coli were the most commonly studied bacteria with reported co-occurrence of resistance to several heavy metals and antibiotic classes. As co-selecting agents, prevalence of heavy metals in the environment can proliferate resistance to heavy metals and antibiotics through co-resistance and cross-resistance mechanisms. In comparing different reservoirs, soils and sediments harbor higher heavy metal and antibiotic resistances compared to water environments. Additionally, abiotic factors such as pH can affect the solubility and hence, the availability of heavy metals to bacterial pathogens. Overall, our review demonstrates heavy metals act as co-selecting agents in the proliferation of antibiotic resistance in human pathogens in multiple environmental reservoirs. More studies that include statistical data are needed to further describe the exposure-response relationships between heavy metals and antibiotic resistance in different environmental media. Moreover, integration of culture-based and molecular-based methods in future studies are recommended to better inform our understanding of bacterial co- and cross-resistance mechanisms to heavy metals and antibiotics.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Zinc / Cadmium / Copper / Lead / E. coli / P. aeruginosa

References

[1] Abskharon R N, Hassan S H, Gad El-Rab S M, Shoreit A A (2008). Heavy metal resistant of E. coli isolated from wastewater sites in Assiut City, Egypt. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 81(3): 309–315

[2] Ali N M, Mazhar S A, Mazhar B, Imtiaz A, Andleeb S (2017). Antibacterial activity of different plant extracts and antibiotics on pathogenic bacterial isolates from wheat field water. Pakistan Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, 30(4): 1321–1325

[3] Anssour L, Messai Y, Estepa V, Torres C, Bakour R (2016). Characteristics of ciprofloxacin-resistant Enterobacteriaceae isolates recovered from wastewater of an Algerian hospital. Journal of Infection in Developing Countries, 10(07): 728–734

[4] Ashbolt N J, Amézquita A, Backhaus T, Borriello P, Brandt K K, Collignon P, Coors A, Finley R, Gaze W H, Heberer T, Lawrence J R, Larsson D G, McEwen S A, Ryan J J, Sch�nfeld J, Silley P, Snape J R, Van den Eede C, Topp E (2013). Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) for environmental development and transfer of antibiotic resistance. Environmental Health Perspectives, 121(9): 993–1001

[5] Aviles M, Codina J C, Perez-Garcia A, Cazorla F, Romero P, De Vicente A (1993). Occurrence of Resistance to Antibiotics and Metals and of Plasmids in Bacterial Strains Isolated from Marine Environments. Oxford, UK: Pergamon Press

[6] Ayrapetyan M, Williams T C, Oliver J D (2015). Bridging the gap between viable but non-culturable and antibiotic persistent bacteria. Trends in Microbiology, 23(1): 7–13

[7] Baker-Austin C, Wright M S, Stepanauskas R, McArthur J V (2006). Co-selection of antibiotic and metal resistance. Trends in Microbiology, 14(4): 176–182

[8] Bauer A W, Kirby W M, Sherris J C, Turck M (1966). Antibiotic susceptibility testing by a standardized single disk method. American Journal of Clinical Pathology, 45(4_ts): 493–496

[9] Becerra-Castro C, Machado R A, Vaz-Moreira I, Manaia C M (2015). Assessment of copper and zinc salts as selectors of antibiotic resistance in Gram-negative bacteria. The Science of the Total Environment, 530-531: 367–372

[10] Cardonha A M, Vieira R H, Rodrigues D P, Macrae A, Peirano G, Teophilo G N (2004). Fecal pollution in water from storm sewers and adjacent seashores in Natal, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil. International Microbiology: The Official Journal of the Spanish Society for Microbiology, 7(3): 213–218

[11] CDC (2013). Antibiotic Resistace Threats in the United States. Center for Disease Control and Prevention: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

[12] Chen P, Chen C, Li X (2018). Transport of antibiotic resistance plasmids in porous media and the influence of surfactants. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 12(2): 5

[13] Chernousova S, Epple M (2013). Silver as antibacterial agent: Ion, nanoparticle, and metal. Angewandte Chemie (International ed. In English), 52(6): 1636–1653

[14] Choudhury P, Kumar R (1996). Association of metal tolerance with multiple antibiotic resistance of enteropathogenic organisms isolated from coastal region of deltaic Sunderbans. The Indian Journal of Medical Research, 104: 148–151

[15] Cox G, Wright G D (2013). Intrinsic antibiotic resistance: Mechanisms, origins, challenges and solutions. International Journal of Medical Microbiology: IJMM, 303(6-7): 287–292

[16] Davies J, Davies D (2010). Origins and evolution of antibiotic resistance. Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews: MMBR, 74(3): 417–433

[17] De J, Ramaiah N, Mesquita A, Verlekar X N (2003). Tolerance to various toxicants by marine bacteria highly resistant to mercury. Marine Biotechnology (New York, N.Y.), 5(2): 185–193

[18] De Niederhäusern S, Bondi M, Anacarso I, Iseppi R, Sabia C, Bitonte F, Messi P (2013). Antibiotics and heavy metals resistance and other biological characters in Enterococci isolated from surface water of Monte Cotugno Lake (Italy). Journal of Environmental Science and Health. Part A, Toxic/Hazardous Substances & Environmental Engineering, 48(8): 939–946

[19] de Vicente A, Avilés M, Codina J C, Borrego J J, Romero P (1990). Resistance to antibiotics and heavy metals of Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolated from natural waters. The Journal of Applied Bacteriology, 68(6): 625–632

[20] Deredjian A, Colinon C, Brothier E, Favre-Bonté S, Cournoyer B, Nazaret S (2011). Antibiotic and metal resistance among hospital and outdoor strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Research in Microbiology, 162(7): 689–700

[21] Dhakephalkar P K, Chopade B A (1994). High levels of multiple metal resistance and its correlation to antibiotic resistance in environmental isolates of Acinetobacter. Biometals, 7(1): 67–74

[22] Djouadi L N, Selama O, Abderrahmani A, Bouanane-Darenfed A, Abdellaziz L, Amziane M, Fardeau M L, Nateche F (2017). Multiresistant opportunistic pathogenic bacteria isolated from polluted rivers and first detection of nontuberculous mycobacteria in the Algerian aquatic environment. Journal of Water and Health, 15(4): 566–579

[23] Dodd M C (2012). Potential impacts of disinfection processes on elimination and deactivation of antibiotic resistance genes during water and wastewater treatment. Journal of Environmental Monitoring: JEM, 14(7): 1754–1771

[24] Ferreira da Silva M, Vaz-Moreira I, Gonzalez-Pajuelo M, Nunes O C, Manaia C M (2007). Antimicrobial resistance patterns in Enterobacteriaceae isolated from an urban wastewater treatment plant. FEMS Microbiology Ecology, 60(1): 166–176

[25] Filali B K, Taoufik J, Zeroual Y, Dzairi F Z, Talbi M, Blaghen M (2000). Waste water bacterial isolates resistant to heavy metals and antibiotics. Current Microbiology, 41(3): 151–156

[26] Gillings M R, Stokes H W (2012). Are humans increasing bacterial evolvability? Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 27(6): 346–352

[27] Gorovtsov A V, Sazykin I S, Sazykina M A (2018). The influence of heavy metals, polyaromatic hydrocarbons, and polychlorinated biphenyls pollution on the development of antibiotic resistance in soils. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 25(10): 9283–9292

[28] Habi S, Daba H (2009). Plasmid incidence, antibiotic and metal resistance among enterobacteriaceae isolated from Algerian streams. Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences: PJBS, 12(22): 1474–1482

[29] Haq R, Zaidi S K, Shakoori A R (1999). Cadmium resistant Enterobacter cloacae and Klebsiella sp. isolated from industrial effluents and their possible role in cadmium detoxification. World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology, 15(2): 283–290

[30] Hassen A, Saidi N, Cherif M, Boudabous A (1998). Resistance of environmental bacteria to heavy metals. Bioresource Technology, 64(1): 7–15

[31] Heck K, De Marco É G, Duarte M W, Salamoni S P, Van Der Sand S (2015). Pattern of multiresistant to antimicrobials and heavy metal tolerance in bacteria isolated from sewage sludge samples from a composting process at a recycling plant in southern Brazil. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 187(328)

[32] Hu Q, Dou M N, Qi H Y, Xie X M, Zhuang G Q, Yang M (2007). Detection, isolation, and identification of cadmium-resistant bacteria based on PCR-DGGE. Journal of Environmental Sciences (China), 19(9): 1114–1119

[33] Ji X, Shen Q, Liu F, Ma J, Xu G, Wang Y, Wu M (2012). Antibiotic resistance gene abundances associated with antibiotics and heavy metals in animal manures and agricultural soils adjacent to feedlots in Shanghai, China. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 235-236: 178–185

[34] Kaur S, Kamli M R, Ali A (2011). Role of arsenic and its resistance in nature. Canadian Journal of Microbiology, 57(10): 769–774

[35] Kenneth T (2012). Online textbook of bacteriology (Madison, WI, USA: http://textbookofbacteriology.net/index.html; Last accessed Dec 20, 2018)

[36] Khan S, Beattie T K, Knapp C W (2017). The use of minimum selectable concentrations (MSCs) for determining the selection of antimicrobial resistant bacteria. Ecotoxicology (London, England), 26(2): 283–292

[37] Knapp C W, Callan A C, Aitken B, Shearn R, Koenders A, Hinwood A (2017). Relationship between antibiotic resistance genes and metals in residential soil samples from Western Australia. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 24(3): 2484–2494

[38] Lemire J A, Harrison J J, Turner R J (2013). Antimicrobial activity of metals: Mechanisms, molecular targets and applications. Nature Reviews. Microbiology, 11(6): 371–384

[39] Madigan M, Bender K S, Buckley D H, Sattley W M, Stahl D A (2017). Brock Biology of Microorganisms. New York, NY, USA: Pearson

[40] Mandal M, Mandal S, Pal N K (2002). Prevalence of multidrug, heavy metal and pesticide resistant enteropathogenic bacteria in the Hooghly River water. Environment and Ecology, 20(3): 634–639

[41] Manegabe B J, Marie-Médiatrice N K, Barr Dewar J, Christian S B (2017). Antibiotic resistance and tolerance to heavy metals demonstrated by environmental pathogenic bacteria isolated from the Kahwa River, Bukavu Town, Democratic Republic of the Congo. International Journal of Environmental Studies, 74(2): 290–302

[42] Martins V V, Zanetti M O B, Pitondo-Silva A, Stehling E G (2014). Aquatic environments polluted with antibiotics and heavy metals: A human health hazard. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 21(9): 5873–5878

[43] Matyar F, Kaya A, Dinçer S (2008). Antibacterial agents and heavy metal resistance in Gram-negative bacteria isolated from seawater, shrimp and sediment in Iskenderun Bay, Turkey. The Science of the Total Environment, 407(1): 279–285

[44] Mirzaei N, Rastegari H, Kargar M (2013). Antibiotic resistance pattern among gram negative mercury resistant bacteria isolated from contaminated environments. Jundishapur Journal of Microbiology, 6(10): 634–639

[45] Mourão J, Marçal S, Ramos P, Campos J, Machado J, Peixe L, Novais C, Antunes P (2016). Tolerance to multiple metal stressors in emerging non-typhoidal MDR Salmonella serotypes: A relevant role for copper in anaerobic conditions. The Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy, 71(8): 2147–2157

[46] O’Neill J (2016). Review on Antimicrobial Resistance: Tackling Drug-Resistant Infections Globally. London,: Welcome Trust and HM Government

[47] Oyetibo G O, Ilori M O, Adebusoye S A, Obayori O S, Amund O O (2010). Bacteria with dual resistance to elevated concentrations of heavy metals and antibiotics in Nigerian contaminated systems. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 168(1-4): 305–314

[48] Pal C, Bengtsson-Palme J, Kristiansson E, Larsson D G J (2015). Co-occurrence of resistance genes to antibiotics, biocides and metals reveals novel insights into their co-selection potential. BMC Genomics, 16(964)

[49] Pathak S P, Gopal K (1994). Antibiotic-resistance and metal tolerance among Coliform sp. from drinking-water in a hilly area. Journal of Environmental Biology, 15(2): 139–147

[50] Patra S, Das T K, Avila C, Cabello V, Castillo F, Sarkar D, Lahiri S, Jana B B (2012). Cadmium tolerance and antibiotic resistance in Escherichia coli isolated from waste stabilization ponds. Indian Journal of Experimental Biology, 50(4): 300–307

[51] Puzanov A V, Baboshkina S V, Gorbachev I V (2012). Characteristics of heavy metal migration in the natural-anthropogenic anomalies of the North-Western Altai. Geochemistry International, 50(4): 358–366

[52] Roane T M, Kellogg S T (1996). Characterization of bacterial communities in heavy metal contaminated soils. Canadian Journal of Microbiology, 42(6): 593–603

[53] Safari Sinegani A A, Younessi N (2017). Antibiotic resistance of bacteria isolated from heavy metal-polluted soils with different land uses. Journal of Global Antimicrobial Resistance, 10: 247–255

[54] Schneider S, Schweisfurth R (1991). Species and genera of Enterobacteriaceae in River Neckar and after river bank filtration and their resistance patterns to antibiotics and heavy metal salts. Water Science and Technology, 24(2): 315–320

[55] Seginkova Z, Kralikova K (1993). Monitoring the contemporary resistance of Escherichia coli and Salmonella Sp. strains isolated from aquatic environment to antibiotics and ions of heavy-metals. Ekologia (Bratislava), 12(1): 111–118

[56] Sepahy A A, Sharifian S, Zolfaghari M R, Dermany M K, Rashedi H (2015). Study on heavy metal resistant fecal coliforms isolated from industrial, urban wastewater in Arak, Iran. International Journal of Environmental of Research, 9(4): 1217–1224

[57] Silveira E, Freitas A R, Antunes P, Barros M, Campos J, Coque T M, Peixe L, Novais C (2014). Co-transfer of resistance to high concentrations of copper and first-line antibiotics among Enterococcus from different origins (humans, animals, the environment and foods) and clonal lineages. The Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy, 69(4): 899–906

[58] Soltan M E S (2001). Isolation and characterization of antibiotic and heavy metal-resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa from different polluted waters in Sohag district, Egypt. Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology, 11(1): 50–55

[59] Turki Y, Ouzari H, Mehri I, Ben Aissa R, Hassen A (2012). Biofilm formation, virulence gene and multi-drug resistance in Salmonella Kentucky isolated in Tunisia. Food Research International, 45(2): 940–946

[60] Ventola C L (2015). The antibiotic resistance crisis: Part 1: Causes and threats. P&T: A Peer-Reviewed Journal for Formulary Management, 40(4): 277–283

[61] Verma T, Ramteke P W, Garg S K (2004). Occurrence of chromium resistant thermotolerant coliforms in tannery effluent. Indian Journal of Experimental Biology, 42(11): 1112–1116

[62] Vignaroli C, Pasquaroli S, Citterio B, Di Cesare A, Mangiaterra G, Fattorini D, Biavasco F (2018). Antibiotic and heavy metal resistance in enterococci from coastal marine sediment. Environmental Pollution (Barking, Essex : 1987), 237: 406–413

[63] Wang S, Wang H (2015). Adsorption behavior of antibiotic in soil environment: a critical review. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 9(4): 565–574

[64] WHO (2015). Global action plan on antimicrobial resistance. Geneva: World Health Organization

[65] WHO (2017). Prioritization of pathogens to guide discovery, research and development of new antibiotics for drug resistant bacterial infections, including tuberculosis. Geneva: World Health Organization

[66] Wnorowski A U (1993). Resistance to antibiotics of heavy metal‐tolerant and heavy metal‐sensitive bacterial strains. Journal of Environmental Science and Health. Part A: Environmental Science and Engineering and Toxicology, 28(1): 203–215

[67] Ye J, Rensing C, Su J, Zhu Y G (2017). From chemical mixtures to antibiotic resistance. Journal of Environmental Sciences (China), 62: 138–144

[68] Yilmaz F, Orman N, Serim G, Kochan C, Ergene A, Icgen B (2013). Surface water-borne multidrug and heavy metal-resistant Staphylococcus isolates characterized by 16S rDNA sequencing. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 91(6): 697–703

[69] Zeng X X, Tagn J X, Jiang P, Liu H W, Dai Z M, Liu X D (2010). Isolation, characterization and extraction of mer gene of Hg²⁺ resisting strain D-2. Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China, 20(3): 507–512

[70] Zeng X X, Tang J X, Liu X D, Jiang P (2009). Isolation, identification and characterization of cadmium-resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa strain E-1. Journal of Central South University of Technology, 16(3): 416–421

[71] Zhang G, Liu X, Sun K, Zhao Y, Lin C (2010). Sorption of tetracycline to sediments and soils: Assessing the roles of pH, the presence of cadmium and properties of sediments and soils. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering in China, 4(4): 421–429

Acknowledgements

We thank Hannah Rempel for her helpful insights during the search protocol development. We acknowledge funding support from the Oregon State University start-up funds.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2019 Higher Education Press and Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature