Synthetically engineered microbes reveal interesting principles of cooperation

Abstract

Cooperation is ubiquitous in biological systems. However, if natural selection favors traits that confer an advantage to one individual over another, then helping others would be paradoxical. Nevertheless, cooperation persists and is critical in maintaining homeostasis in systems ranging from populations of bacteria to groupings of mammals. Developing an understanding of the dynamics and mechanisms by which cooperation operates is critical in understanding ecological and evolutionary relationships. Over the past decade, synthetic biology has emerged as a powerful tool to study social dynamics. By engineering rationally controlled and modulatable behavior into microbes, we have increased our overall understanding of how cooperation enhances, or conversely constrains, populations. Furthermore, it has increased our understanding of how cooperation is maintained within populations, which may provide a useful framework to influence populations by altering cooperation. As many bacterial pathogens require cooperation to infect the host and survive, the principles developed using synthetic biology offer promise of developing novel tools and strategies to treat infections, which may reduce the use of antimicrobial agents. Overall, the use of engineered cooperative microbes has allowed the field to verify existing, and develop novel, theories that may govern cooperative behaviors at all levels of biology.

Key words： synthetic biology; engineered bacteria; cooperation; cheater; quorum sensing

Acknowledgements

Our research is supported by a President’s Faculty Research and Development Grant #335318 and #335304 through Nova Southeastern University. The author’s declare that they do not have any conflicts of interest.

References

1 Nowak M A. Five rules for the evolution of cooperation. Science, 2006, 314(5805): 1560–1563

2 Axelrod R, Hamilton W D. The evolution of cooperation. Science, 1981, 211(4489): 1390–1396

3 Fehr E, Fischbacher U. Social norms and human cooperation. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 2004, 8(4): 185–190

4 Shan W, Hamilton W. Country—specific advantage and international cooperation. Strategic Management Journal, 1991, 12(6): 419–432

5 Hardin G. The tragedy of the commons. Science, 1968, 162(3859): 1243–1248

6 Feeny D, Berkes F, McCay B J, Acheson J M. The tragedy of the commons: twenty-two years later. Human Ecology, 1990, 18(1): 1–19

7 Hamilton W. The evolution of altruistic behavior. American Naturalist, 1963, 97(896): 354–356

8 Eldakar O T, Wilson D S. Eight criticisms not to make about group selection. Evolution, 2011, 65(6): 1523–1526

9 Wilson D S, Wilson E O. Rethinking the theoretical foundation of sociobiology. Quarterly Review of Biology, 2007, 82(4): 327–348

10 Rapoport A, Chammah A M. Prisoner’s dilemma: A study in conflict and cooperation. Michigan: University of Michigan press, 1965: 31–44

11 Doebeli M, Hauert C. Models of cooperation based on the Prisoner’s Dilemma and the Snowdrift game. Ecology Letters, 2005, 8(7): 748–766

12 Allee W C. Cooperation among animals. American Journal of Sociology, 1951, 1: 93–95

13 Seger J. Cooperation and conflict in social insects. Behavioural Ecology: An Evolutionary Approach, 1991, 338–373

14 West S A, El Mouden C, Gardner A. Sixteen common misconceptions about the evolution of cooperation in humans. Evolution and Human Behavior, 2011, 32(4): 231–262

15 Gintis H, Bowles S, Boyd R, Fehr E. Explaining altruistic behavior in humans. Evolution and Human Behavior, 2003, 24(3): 153–172

16 Sober E, Wilson D S. Unto others: The evolution and psychology of unselfish behavior. Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1999, 6–14

17 Tanouchi Y, Smith R, You L. Engineering microbial systems to explore ecological and evolutionary dynamics. Current Opinion in Biotechnology, 2012, 23(5): 791–797

18 Benner S A, Sismour A M. Synthetic biology. Nature Reviews. Genetics, 2005, 6(7): 533–543

19 Jusiak B, Daniel R, Farzadfard F, Nissim L, Purcell O, Rubens J, Lu T K. Synthetic gene circuits. Reviews in Cell Biology and Molecular Medicine, 2014, 1‒56

20 Khalil A S, Collins J J. Synthetic biology: Applications come of age. Nature Reviews. Genetics, 2010, 11(5): 367–379

21 Bracho O R, Manchery C, Haskell E C, Blanar C A, Smith R P. Circumvention of learning increases intoxication efficacy of nematicidal engineered bacteria. ACS Synthetic Biology, 2016, 5(3): 241–249

22 Escalante A E, Rebolleda-Gómez M, Benítez M, Travisano M. Ecological perspectives on synthetic biology: Insights from microbial population biology. Frontiers in Microbiology, 2015, 6: 1–10

23 Pianka E R. On r- and K-selection. American Naturalist, 1970, 104(940): 592–597

24 Miller M B, Bassler B L. Quorum sensing in bacteria. Annual Review of Microbiology, 2001, 55(1): 165–199

25 Berendsen R L, Pieterse C M, Bakker P A. The rhizosphere microbiome and plant health. Trends in Plant Science, 2012, 17(8): 478–486

26 Antunes L C M, Ferreira R B R, Buckner M M C, Finlay B B. Quorum sensing in bacterial virulence. Microbiology, 2010, 156(8): 2271–2282

27 De Kievit T R, Gillis R, Marx S, Brown C, Iglewski B H. Quorum-sensing genes in Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms: Their role and expression patterns. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 2001, 67(4): 1865–1873

28 De Kievit T R, Iglewski B H. Bacterial quorum sensing in pathogenic relationships. Infection and Immunity, 2000, 68(9): 4839–4849

29 Stewart P S, Costerton J W. Antibiotic resistance of bacteria in biofilms. Lancet, 2001, 358(9276): 135–138

30 Darch S E, West S A, Winzer K, Diggle S P. Density-dependent fitness benefits in quorum-sensing bacterial populations. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2012: 8259–8263

31 Pai A, Tanouchi Y, You L. Optimality and robustness in quorum sensing (QS)-mediated regulation of a costly public good enzyme. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2012, 109(48): 19810–19815

32 An J H, Goo E, Kim H, Seo Y S, Hwang I. An J H, Goo E, Kim H, Seo Y-S, Hwang I. Bacterial quorum sensing and metabolic slowing in a cooperative population. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2014, 111(41): 14912–14917

33 Allee W, Emerson A, Park O, Park T, Schmidt K. Principles of Animal Ecology. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA, 1949, 416–425

34 Driscoll W W, Espinosa N J, Eldakar O T, Hackett J D. Allelopathy as an emergent, exploitable public good in the bloom-forming microalga Prymnesium parvum. Evolution, 2013, 67(6): 1582–1590

35 Liebhold A M, Tobin P C. Exploiting the Achilles heels of pest invasions: Allee effects, stratified dispersal and management of forest insect establishment and spread. New Zealand Journal of Forestry Science, 2010, 40: S25–S33

36 Robinet C, Lance D R, Thorpe K W, Onufrieva K S, Tobin P C, Liebhold A M. Dispersion in time and space affect mating success and Allee effects in invading gypsy moth populations. Journal of Animal Ecology, 2008, 77(5): 966–973

37 Tobin P C, Berec L, Liebhold A M. Exploiting Allee effects for managing biological invasions. Ecology Letters, 2011, 14(6): 615–624

38 Hackney E E, McGraw J B. Experimental demonstration of an Allee effect in American ginseng. Conservation Biology, 2001, 15(1): 129–136

39 Smith R, Tan C, Srimani J, Pai A, Riccione K, Song H, You L. Programmed Allee effect results in a tradeoff between population spread and survival. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2014, 111(5): 1969–1974

40 Myers R A, Hutchings J A, Barrowman N J. Why do fish stocks collapse? The example of cod in Atlantic Canada. Ecological Applications, 1997, 7(1): 91–106

41 Myers R, Barrowman N, Hutchings J, Rosenberg A. Population dynamics of exploited fish stocks at low population levels. Science, 1995, 269(5227): 1106–1108

42 Dai L, Vorselen D, Korolev K S, Gore J. Generic indicators for loss of resilience before a tipping point leading to population collapse. Science, 2012, 336(6085): 1175–1177

43 Dai L, Korolev K S, Gore J. Relation between stability and resilience determines the performance of early warning signals under different environmental drivers. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2015, 112(32): 10056–10061

44 Liebhold A M, Tobin P C. Population ecology of insect invasions and their management. Annual Review of Entomology, 2008, 53(1): 387–408

45 Visick K L, Foster J, Doino J, McFall-Ngai M, Ruby E G. Vibrio fischeri lux genes play an important role in colonization and development of the host light organ. Journal of Bacteriology, 2000, 182(16): 4578–4586

46 Bahassi E M, O’Dea M H, Allali N, Messens J, Gellert M, Couturier M. Interactions of CcdB with DNA gyrase. Journal of Biological Chemistry, 1999, 274(16): 10936–10944

47 Dai L, Korolev K S, Gore J. Slower recovery in space before collapse of connected populations. Nature, 2013, 496(7445): 355–358

48 Ratzke C, Gore J. Self-organized patchiness facilitates survival in a cooperatively growing Bacillus subtilis population. Nature Microbiology, 2016: 16022

49 Wong C M, Zhou Y, Ng R W, Kung H F, Jin D Y. Cooperation of yeast peroxiredoxins Tsa1p and Tsa2p in the cellular defense against oxidative and nitrosative stress. Journal of Biological Chemistry, 2002, 277(7): 5385–5394

50 Boulant J A. Hypothalamic mechanisms in thermoregulation. Federation Proceedings, 1981, 40(14): 2843-50

51 Stephens P A, Frey-Roos F, Arnold W, Sutherland W J. Model complexity and population predictions. The alpine marmot as a case study. Journal of Animal Ecology, 2002, 71(2): 343–361

52 Liermann H, Hilborn. Depensation: Evidence, models and implications. Fish and Fisheries, 2001, 2(1): 33–58

53 Aizenman E, Engelberg-Kulka H, Glaser G. An Escherichia coli chromosomal “addiction module” regulated by guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate: A model for programmed bacterial cell death. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 1996, 93(12): 6059–6063

54 Misselwitz B, Barrett N, Kreibich S, Vonaesch P, Andritschke D, Rout S, Weidner K, Sormaz M, Songhet P, Horvath P, Chabria M, Vogel V, Spori D M, Jenny P, Hardt W D. Near surface swimming of Salmonella typhimurium explains target-site selection and cooperative invasion. PLoS Pathogens, 2012, 8(7): e1002810

55 Tan C, Smith R P, Srimani J, Riccione K, Prasada S, Kuehn M, You L. The inoculum effect and band-pass bacterial response to periodic antibiotic treatment. Molecular Systems Biology, 2012, 8(1): 679–688

56 Lee H H, Molla M N, Cantor C R, Collins J J. Bacterial charity work leads to population-wide resistance. Nature, 2010, 467(7311): 82–85

57 Vega N M, Allison K R, Samuels A N, Klempner M S, Collins J J. Salmonella typhimurium intercepts Escherichia coli signaling to enhance antibiotic tolerance. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2013, 110(35): 14420–14425

58 Meredith H R, Srimani J K, Lee A J, Lopatkin A J, You L. Collective antibiotic tolerance: Mechanisms, dynamics and intervention. Nature Chemical Biology, 2015, 11(3): 182–188

59 Nedelcu A M, Driscoll W W, Durand P M, Herron M D, Rashidi A. On the paradigm of altruistic suicide in the unicellular world. Evolution, 2011, 65(1): 3–20

60 Ackermann M, Stecher B, Freed N E, Songhet P, Hardt W D, Doebeli M. Self-destructive cooperation mediated by phenotypic noise. Nature, 2008, 454(7207): 987–990

61 Rice K C, Bayles K W. Death’s toolbox: Examining the molecular components of bacterial programmed cell death. Molecular Microbiology, 2003, 50(3): 729–738

62 Ameisen J C. The origin of programmed cell death. Science, 1996, 272(5266): 1278–1279

63 Brown S P, West S A, Diggle S P, Griffin A S. Social evolution in micro-organisms and a Trojan horse approach to medical intervention strategies. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences, 2009, 364(1533): 3157–3168

64 Moran N A, Degnan P H, Santos S R, Dunbar H E, Ochman H. The players in a mutualistic symbiosis: Insects, bacteria, viruses, and virulence genes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2005, 102(47): 16919–16926

65 Breznak J A. Symbiotic relationships between termites and their intestinal microbiota. Symposia of the Society for Experimental Biology, 1975, 29: 559–580

66 Glaser R. The intracellular bacteria of the cockroach in relation to symbiosis. Journal of Parasitology, 1946, 32(5): 483–489

67 Uhlig H H, Powrie F. Dendritic cells and the intestinal bacterial flora: a role for localized mucosal immune responses. Journal of Clinical Investigation, 2003, 112(5): 648–651

68 Wintermute E H, Silver P A. Dynamics in the mixed microbial concourse. Genes & Development, 2010, 24(23): 2603–2614

69 Wintermute E H, Silver P A. Emergent cooperation in microbial metabolism. Molecular Systems Biology, 2010, 6(1): 820–833

70 Shou W, Ram S, Vilar J M G. Synthetic cooperation in engineered yeast populations. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2007, 104(6): 1877–1882

71 Brenner K, Karig D K, Weiss R, Arnold F H. Engineered bidirectional communication mediates a consensus in a microbial biofilm consortium. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2007, 104(44): 17300–17304

72 Brenner K, You L, Arnold F H. Engineering microbial consortia: A new frontier in synthetic biology. Trends in Biotechnology, 2008, 26(9): 483–489

73 Hu B, Du J, Zou R Y, Yuan Y J. An environment-sensitive synthetic microbial ecosystem. PLoS One, 2010, 5(5): e10619

74 Kerner A, Park J, Williams A, Lin X N. A programmable Escherichia coli consortium via tunable symbiosis. PLoS One, 2012, 7(3): e34032

75 Mee M T, Collins J J, Church G M, Wang H H. Syntrophic exchange in synthetic microbial communities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2014, 111(20): 2149–2156

76 Berryman A A. The orgins and evolution of predator-prey theory. Ecology, 1992, 73(5): 1530–1535

77 Balagadde F K, Song H, Ozaki J, Collins C H, Barnet M, Arnold F H, Quake S R, You L. A synthetic Escherichia coli predator-prey ecosystem. Molecular Systems Biology, 2008, 4: 187

78 Wangersky P J. Lotka-Volterra population models. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 1978, 9(1): 189–218

79 Sun G Q, Jin Z, Liu Q X, Li L. Dynamical complexity of a spatial predator-prey model with migration. Ecological Modelling, 2008, 219(1-2): 248–255

80 Yuan S, Xu C, Zhang T. Spatial dynamics in a predator-prey model with herd behavior. Chaos (Woodbury, N.Y.), 2013, 23(3): 033102

81 Song H, Payne S, Gray M, You L. Spatiotemporal modulation of biodiversity in a synthetic chemical-mediated ecosystem. Nature Chemical Biology, 2009, 5(12): 929–935

82 Yamamura N, Higashi M, Behera N, Yuichiro Wakano J. Evolution of mutualism through spatial effects. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 2004, 226(4): 421–428

83 Poisot T, Bever J D, Thrall P H, Hochberg M E. Dispersal and spatial heterogeneity allow coexistence between enemies and protective mutualists. Ecology and Evolution, 2014, 4(19): 3841–3850

84 Park J, Kerner A, Burns M A, Lin X N. Microdroplet-enabled highly parallel co-cultivation of microbial communities. PLoS One, 2011, 6(2): e17019

85 Wilson W, Morris W, Bronstein J. Coexistence of mutualists and exploiters on spatial landscapes. Ecological Monographs, 2003, 73(3): 397–413

86 Brenner K, Arnold F H. Self-organization, layered structure, and aggregation enhance persistence of a synthetic biofilm consortium. PLoS One, 2011, 6(2): e16791

87 Chuang J S, Rivoire O, Leibler S. Cooperation and Hamilton’s rule in a simple synthetic microbial system. Molecular Systems Biology, 2010, 6: 398

88 Chuang J S, Rivoire O, Leibler S. Simpson’s paradox in a synthetic microbial system. Science, 2009, 323(5911): 272–275

89 Gore J, Youk H, van Oudenaarden A. Snowdrift game dynamics and facultative cheating in yeast. Nature, 2009, 459(7244): 253–256

90 Griffin A S, West S A, Buckling A. Cooperation and competition in pathogenic bacteria. Nature, 2004, 430(7003): 1024–1027

91 West S A, Pen I, Griffin A S. Cooperation and competition between relatives. Science, 2002, 296(5565): 72–75

92 Celiker H, Gore J. Competition between species can stabilize public—goods cooperation within a species. Molecular Systems Biology, 2012, 8(1): 621

93 Bergstrom T, Blume L, Varian H. On the private provision of public goods. Journal of Public Economics, 1986, 29(1): 25–49

94 Driscoll W W, Pepper J W. Theory for the evolution of diffusible external goods. Evolution, 2010, 64(9): 2682–2687

95 Zhang F, Kwan A, Xu A, Süel G M. A synthetic quorum sensing system reveals a potential private benefit for public good production in a biofilm. PLoS One, 2015, 10(7): e0132948

96 Waite A J, Shou W. Adaptation to a new environment allows cooperators to purge cheaters stochastically. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2012, 109(47): 19079–19086

97 Chen A, Sanchez A, Dai L, Gore J. Dynamics of a producer-freeloader ecosystem on the brink of collapse. Nature Communications, 2014, 5: 3713

98 Venturi V, Bertani I, Kerényi Á, Netotea S, Pongor S. Co-swarming and local collapse: Quorum sensing conveys resilience to bacterial communities by localizing cheater mutants in Pseudomonas aeruginosa. PLoS One, 2010, 5(4): e9998

99 Bihary D, Tóth M, Kerényi Á, Venturi V, Pongor S. Modeling bacterial quorum sensing in open and closed environments: potential discrepancies between agar plate and culture flask experiments. Journal of Molecular Modeling, 2014, 20(7): 1–6

100 Pepper J W. The evolution of bacterial social life: From the ivory tower to the front lines of public health. Evolution, Medicine, and Public Health, 2014, 2014(1): 65–68

101 Ross-Gillespie A, Weigert M, Brown S P, Kümmerli R. Gallium-mediated siderophore quenching as an evolutionarily robust antibacterial treatment. Evolution, Medicine, and Public Health, 2014, 2014(1): 18–29

102 Hood M I, Skaar E P. Nutritional immunity: Transition metals at the pathogen-host interface. Nature Reviews. Microbiology, 2012, 10(8): 525–537

103 Skaar E P. The battle for iron between bacterial pathogens and their vertebrate hosts. PLoS Pathogens, 2010, 6(8): e1000949

104 Köhler T, Buckling A, van Delden C. Cooperation and virulence of clinical Pseudomonas aeruginosa populations. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2009, 106(15): 6339–6344

105 Merlo L M F, Pepper J W, Reid B J, Maley C C. Cancer as an evolutionary and ecological process. Nature Reviews. Cancer, 2006, 6(12): 924–935

106 Pepper J W. Defeating pathogen drug resistance: Guidance from evolutionary theory. Evolution, 2008, 62(12): 3185–3191

107 Boehm T, Folkman J, Browder T, O’Reilly M S. Antiangiogenic therapy of experimental cancer does not induce acquired drug resistance. Nature, 1997, 390(6658): 404–407

108 Folkman J. Angiogenesis. Annual Review of Medicine, 2006, 57: 1–18

109 Duan F, March J C. Engineered bacterial communication prevents Vibrio cholerae virulence in an infant mouse model. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2010, 107(25): 11260–11264

110 Saeidi N, Wong C K, Lo T M, Nguyen H X, Ling H, Leong S S J, Poh C L, Chang M W. Engineering microbes to sense and eradicate Pseudomonas aeruginosa, a human pathogen. Molecular Systems Biology, 2011, 7(1): 521