Gaps, challenges and possible solution for prediction of wheel–rail rolling contact fatigue crack initiation

Abstract

The prediction of wheel/rail rolling contact fatigue (RCF) crack initiation during railway operations is an important task. Since RCF crack evolution is influenced by many factors, its prediction process is complex. This paper reviews the existing approaches to predict RCF crack initiation. The crack initiation region is predicted by the shakedown map. By combining the shakedown map with various initiation criteria and the critical plane method, the crack initiation life is calculated. The classification, methodologies, theories and applications of these approaches are included in this paper. The advantages and limitations of these methods are analyzed to provide recommendation for RCF crack initiation prediction. This review highlights that wheel/rail dynamic characteristic, complex working conditions, surface defects and wear all affect the RCF crack initiation. The optimal selection of criteria is essential in the crack initiation prediction. Based on the research gap regarding the challenging process of crack initiation prediction detailed in this review, a proposed prediction process of RCF crack initiation is proposed to achieve a more accurate result.

References

[1.] Zhao X, Li Z. The solution of frictional wheel–rail rolling contact with a 3D transient finite element model. Wear 2011, 271 1–2 444-452

[2.] Krishna VV, Hossein-Nia S, Casanueva C, Stichel S, Trummer G, Six K. Rail RCF damage quantification and comparison for different damage models. Railw Eng Sci 2022, 30 1 23-40

[3.] Jiang X, Li X, Li X, Cao S. Rail fatigue crack propagation in high–speed wheel/rail rolling contact. Railw Eng Sci 2017, 25 3 178-184

[4.] Zhang S, Spiryagin M, Lin Q . Study on wear and rolling contact fatigue behaviours of defective rail under different slip ratio and contact stress conditions. Tribol Int 2022, 169 107491

[5.] Zhang S, Spiryagin M, Ding HH . Rail rolling contact fatigue formation and evolution with surface defects. Int J Fatigue 2022, 158 106762

[6.] Hu Y, Guo L, Maiorino M . Comparison of wear and rolling contact fatigue behaviours of bainitic and pearlitic rails under various rolling–sliding conditions. Wear 2020, 460–461 203455

[7.] Hu Y, Zhou L, Ding H . Microstructure evolution of railway pearlitic wheel steels under rolling–sliding contact loading. Tribol Int 2021, 154

[8.] Tao GQ, Wen ZF, Jin XS, Yang XX. Polygonisation of railway wheels: a critical review. Railw Eng Sci 2020, 28 4 317-345

[9.] Steenbergen M. Rolling contact fatigue: spalling versus transverse fracture of rails. Wear 2017, 380–381 96-105

[10.] Steenbergen M, Dollevoet R. On the mechanism of squat formation on train rails—part II: growth. Int J Fatigue 2013, 47 373-381

[11.] Sato Y. Design of rail head profiles with full use of grinding. Wear 1991, 144 1–2 363-372

[12.] Al–Juboori A, Wexler D, Li H, . Squat formation and the occurrence of two distinct classes of white etching layer on the surface of rail steel. Int J Fatigue 2017, 104 52-60

[13.] Li ZL, Zhao X, Esveld C, Dollevoet R, Molodova M. An investigation into the causes of squats—correlation analysis and numerical modeling. Wear 2008, 265 9–10 1349-1355

[14.] Zhu H, Li H, Al–Juboori A, . Understanding and treatment of squat defects in a railway network. Wear 2020, 442–443

[15.] Ringsberg JW. Life prediction of rolling contact fatigue crack initiation. Int J Fatigue 2001, 23 7 575-586

[16.] Aquib AM, Srivastava JP, Duhan NR, Sarkar PK. Rolling contact fatigue and wear in rail steels: an overview. Mater Sci Eng 2018, 1

[17.] Ringsberg JW. Cyclic ratchetting and failure of a pearlitic rail steel. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct 2000, 23 9 747-758

[18.] Taraf M, Zahaf EH, Oussouaddi O, Zeghloul A. Numerical analysis for predicting the rolling contact fatigue crack initiation in a railway wheel steel. Tribol Int 2010, 43 3 585-593

[19.] Ringsberg JW, Loo-Morrey M, Josefson BL. Prediction of fatigue crack initiation for rolling contact fatigue. Int J Fatigue 2000, 22 3 205-215

[20.] Jianxi W, Yude X, Songliang L, Liying W. Probabilistic prediction model for initiation of RCF cracks in heavy-haul railway. Int J Fatigue 2011, 33 2 212-216

[21.] Liu YM, Stratman B, Mahadevan S. Fatigue crack initiation life prediction of railroad wheels. Int J Fatigue 2006, 28 7 747-756

[22.] Ekberg A, Kabo E. Fatigue of railway wheels and rails under rolling contact and thermal loading—an overview. Wear 2005, 258 7–8 1288-1300

[23.] Akama M, Matsuda H, Doi H, Tsujie M. Fatigue crack initiation life prediction of rails using theory of critical distance and critical plane approach. J Comput Sci Technol 2012, 6 2 54-69

[24.] Ringsberg JW, Bjarnehed H, Johansson A, Josefson BL. Rolling contact fatigue of rails—finite element modelling of residual stresses, strains and crack initiation. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit 2000, 214 1 7-19

[25.] Ringsberg JW, Josefson BL. Finite element analyses of rolling contact fatigue crack initiation in railheads. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2001, 215 4 243-259

[26.] McDowell DL, Dunne FPE. Microstructure–sensitive computational modeling of fatigue crack formation. Int J Fatigue 2010, 32 9 1521-1542

[27.] Ishida M, Abe N. Experimental study on rolling contact fatigue from the aspect of residual stress. Wear 1996, 191 1–2 65-71

[28.] Makoto A. Development of finite element model for analysis of rolling contact fatigue cracks in wheel/rail systems. QR RTRI 2007, 48 1 8-14

[29.] Deng X, Naeimi M, Li Z, Qian Z, Dollevoet R (2014) Residual fatigue life evaluation of rail at squats seeds using 3D explicit finite element analysis. In: Proceedings of the international conference on ageing of materials and structures, Delft, pp 1–10

[30.] Williams JA. The influence of repeated loading, residual stresses and shakedown on the behaviour of tribological contacts. Tribol Int 2005, 38 9 786-797

[31.] Ekberg A, Kabo E, Andersson H. An engineering model for prediction of rolling contact fatigue of railway wheels. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct 2002, 25 10 899-909

[32.] Kapoor A. A re-evaluation of the life to rupture of ductile metals by cyclic plastic strain. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct 1994, 17 2 201-219

[33.] Vo KD (2015) Damage analysis of wheel/rail contact associated to high adhesion condition. Dissertation, University of Wollongong

[34.] Jiang Y, Sehitoglu H. A model for rolling contact failure. Wear 1999, 224 1 38-49

[35.] Johnson KL. Contact mechanics 1985 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

[36.] Johnson KL. The strength of surfaces in rolling contact. Proc Inst Mech Eng C J Mech Eng Sci 1989, 203 3 151-163

[37.] Ponter ARS, Hearle AD, Johnson KL. Application of the kinematical shakedown theorem to rolling and sliding point contacts. J Mech Phys Solids 1985, 33 4 339-362

[38.] F.S. Vicente MPG,. Shakedown limits and uses in railroad engineering. J Mater Civ Eng 2019, 31 11 04019282

[39.] Vicente FSGM. Use of the fatigue index to study rolling contact wear. Wear 2019, 436–437 203036

[40.] Jones CP, Tyfour WR, Beynon JH, Kapoor A. The effect of strain hardening on shakedown limits of a pearlitic rail steel. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 1997, 211 2 131-140

[41.] Makino T, Kato T, Hirakawa K. The effect of slip ratio on the rolling contact fatigue property of railway wheel steel. Int J Fatigue 2012, 36 1 68-79

[42.] Halama R, Fajkoš R, Matušek P, Bábková P, Fojtík F, Václavek L. Contact defects initiation in railroad wheels—experience, experiments and modelling. Wear 2011, 271 1–2 174-185

[43.] Lu C (2012) A study on rolling contact fatigue of high–speed emu wheels. Dissertation, Southwest Jiaotong University (in Chinese)

[44.] Wang YG, Chun L, Zhao X, Wen ZF. Rolling contact fatigue of Chinese high speed wheel: observations and simulations. J Mech Eng 2018, 54 4 150-157

[45.] Jiang YY, Xu BQ, Sehitoglu H. Three–dimensional elastic–plastic stress analysis of rolling contact. J Tribol 2002, 124 4 699-708

[46.] Ringsberg JW, Franklin FJ, Josefson BL. Fatigue evaluation of surface coated railway rails using shakedown theory. Int J Fatigue 2005, 27 6 680-694

[47.] Zhuang Y, Wang K-Y, Li H-X, Wang M, Chen L. Application of three-dimensional shakedown solutions in railway structure under multiple Hertz loads. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng 2019, 117 328-338

[48.] Foletti S, Desimone HJ. Application of shakedown maps under variable loads. Eng Fract Mech 2007, 74 4 527-538

[49.] Armstrong P, Frederick CO. A mathematical representation of the multiaxial Bauschinger effect. Mater High Temp 2014, 24 1 1-26

[50.] Lemitre J, Chaboche JL. Mechanics of solid materials 1990 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

[51.] Bower AF. Cyclic hardening properties of hard-drawn copper and rail steel. J Mech Phys Solids 1989, 37 4 455-470

[52.] Jiang Y, Sehitoglu H. Modeling of cyclic ratchetting plasticity, Part I: development of constitutive relations. J Appl Mech 1996, 63 3 720-725

[53.] Xin L, Markine VL, Shevtsov IY. Numerical procedure for fatigue life prediction for railway turnout crossings using explicit finite element approach. Wear 2016, 366–367 167-179

[54.] Naeimi M, Li ZL, Dollevoet R. Nucleation of squat cracks in rail, calculation of crack initiation angles in three dimensions. J Phys: Conf Ser 2015, 628

[55.] El-sayed HM, Lotfy M, Zohny HNE, Riad HS. Prediction of fatigue crack initiation life in railheads using finite element analysis. Ain Shams Eng J 2018, 9 4 2329-2342

[56.] Ekh M, Johansson A, Thorberntsson H, Josefson BL. Models for cyclic ratchetting plasticity—integration and calibration. J Eng Mater Technol 2000, 122 1 49

[57.] Bari S, Hassan T. Anatomy of coupled constitutive models for ratcheting simulation. Int J Plast 2000, 16 3–4 381-409

[58.] Smith KN, Watson P, Topper TH. A stress-strain function for the fatigue of metals. Mater Test 2009, 51 5 276-285

[59.] Socie DF. Multiaxial fatigue damage models. J Eng Mater Technol 1987, 109 4 293-298

[60.] Lykins CD, Mall S, Jain V. An evaluation of parameters for predicting fretting fatigue crack initiation. Int J Fatigue 2000, 22 8 703-716

[61.] Fatemi A, Socie DF. A critial plane approach to multiaxial fatigue damage including out–of–phase loading. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct 1988, 11 3 149-165

[62.] Liu QY, Wang WJ, He CG. Fundamentals and applications of Tribology 2015 Chengdu Southwest Jiaotong University Press(in Chinese)

[63.] Chen X, S. Xu D,. A critical plane-strain energy density criterion for multiaxial low-cycle fatigue under non-proportional loading. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct 1999, 22 8 679-686

[64.] Han C, Chen X, Ki K. Evaluation of multiaxial fatigue criteria under irregular loading. Int J Fatigue 2002, 24 9 913-922

[65.] Basseville S, Cailletaud G. An evaluation of the competition between wear and crack initiation in fretting conditions for Ti–6Al–4V alloy. Wear 2015, 328–329 443-455

[66.] Lykins CD, Mall S, Jain V. Combined experimental–numerical investigation of fretting fatigue crack initiation. Int J Fatigue 2001, 8 23 703-711

[67.] Bower AF (1987) Some aspects of plastic flow, residual stress and fatigue cracks due to rolling and sliding contact. Dissertation, University of Cambridge

[68.] Bannantine JA, Comer JJ, Handrock JL. Fundementals of metal fatigue analysis 1990 Upper Sandle River Prentice Hall

[69.] Farley J, Wrobel LC, Mao K. Low cycle fatigue simulation and fatigue life prediction of multilayer coated surfaces. Wear 2010, 269 9–10 639-646

[70.] Li Y (2017) Study on the effect of residual stress on fatigue crack initiation and propagation of rail. Dissertation, Shijiazhuang Tiedao University (in Chinese)

[71.] Zhou Y, Mu DS, Kuang KF, Zheng XF, Han YB. Analysis on rail wear and crack initiation and recommendation on rail selection in urban rail transit. J Traffic Transp Eng 2018, 18 4 82-89

[72.] Zhou Y, Mu D, Han Y, Huang X, Zhang C. Prediction method for rail crack initiation based on nonlinear fatigue damage cumulation. J Lanzhou Jiangtong Univ 2018, 37 3 27-36

[73.] Zhou Y, Han Y, Mu D, Huang X. Effects of friction coefficient on rolling contact fatigue crack initiation and wear growth. J Tongji Univ (Nat Sci) 2018, 46 3 1392-1402

[74.] Mohammadzadeh S, Sharavi M, Keshavarzian H. Reliability analysis of fatigue crack initiation of railhead in bolted rail joint. Eng Fail Anal 2013, 29 132-148

[75.] W.L., Deng TS, Wen ZF, Jin XS,. Prediction on rolling contact fatigue crack initiation life of rails. Lubr Eng 2013, 38 8 46-51

[76.] Zhou Y, Han Y, Mu D, Zhang C, Huang X. Prediction of the coexistence of rail head check initiation and wear growth. Int J Fatigue 2018, 112 289-300

[77.] Wang J, Xu Y, Lian S, Fang Y. Simulation of predicting RCF crack initiation life of rails under random wheel/rail forces. J China Railw Soc 2010, 32 3 66-70

[78.] Aghababaei R, Zhao K. Micromechanics of material detachment during adhesive wear: a numerical assessment of Archard's wear model. Wear 2021, 1–2 203739

[79.] Chang C, Wang C, Jin Y. Study on numerical method to predict wheel/rail profile evolution due to wear. Wear 2010, 269 3–4 167-173

[80.] Arizon JD, Verlinden O, Dehombreux P. Prediction of wheel wear in urban railway transport: comparison of existing models. Veh Syst Dyn 2007, 45 9 849-866

[81.] Zhou Y, Yu M, Jiang JN. Effects of rail hardness on rail wear and head check initiation. Transp Res Rec 2016, 2545 1 55-65

[82.] Miner MA. Cumulative damage in fatigue. Appl Mech Trans ASME 1945, 12 3 A159-A164

[83.] Bolton PJ, Clayton P. Rolling–sliding wear damage in rail and tyre steels. Wear 1984, 93 2 145-165

[84.] Lewis R, Olofsson U. Mapping rail wear regimes and transitions. Wear 2004, 257 7–8 721-729

[85.] Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce RS, Olofsson U . Mapping railway wheel material wear mechanisms and transitions. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part FJ Rail Rapid Transit 2010, 224 3 125-137

[86.] Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce RS. Wear mechanisms and transitions in railway wheel steels. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part J J Eng Tribol 2004, 218 6 467-478

[87.] Yang B. Simulation analysis of wheel wear based on the model of Tγ/A—wear rate. J Mech Eng 2017, 53 22 101-108

[88.] Butini E, Marini L, Meacci M, Meli E, Wang WJ. An innovative model for the prediction of wheel–rail wear and rolling contact fatigue. Wear 2019, 436–437 203025

[89.] Innocenti A, Marini L, Meli E, Pallini G, Rindi A. Development of a wear model for the analysis of complex railway networks. Wear 2014, 309 1–2 174-191

[90.] Ignesti M, Malvezzi M, Marini L, Meli E, Rindi A. Development of a wear model for the prediction of wheel and rail profile evolution in railway systems. Wear 2012, 284–285 1-17

[91.] Tyfour WR, Beynon JH, Kapoor A. Deterioration of rolling contact fatigue life of pearlitic rail steel due to dry–wet rolling–sliding line contact. Wear 1996, 197 1–2 255-265

[92.] Zeng D, Xu T, Liu W, Lu L, Zhang J, Gong Y. Investigation on rolling contact fatigue of railway wheel steel with surface defect. Wear 2020, 446–447

[93.] Wu Q, Spiryagin M, Wolfs P, Cole C. Traction modelling in train dynamics. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2018, 233 4 1-14

[94.] Andersson R, Torstensson PT, Kabo E, Larsson F, Ekberg A. Integrated analysis of dynamic vehicle–track interaction and plasticity induced damage in the presence of squat defects. Wear 2016, 366–367 139-145

[95.] Kabo E, Ekberg A. Fatigue initiation in railway wheels—a numerical study of the influence of defects. Wear 2002, 253 1–2 26-34

[96.] Kabo E, Ekberg A. Material defects in rolling contact fatigue of railway wheels—the influence of defect size. Wear 2005, 258 7–8 1194-1200

[97.] Seo J, Kwon S, Lee D. Effects of surface defects on rolling contact fatigue of rail. Procedia Eng 2011, 10 1274-1278

[98.] Zhao X, Wang Z, Wen Z, Wang H, Zeng D. The initiation of local rolling contact fatigue on railway wheels: an experimental study. Int J Fatigue 2020, 132

[99.] Golmohammadi Z, Sadeghi F. A coupled multibody finite element model for investigating effects of surface defects on rolling contact fatigue. J Tribol 2019, 141 4 1-11

[100.] Li Z, Zhao X, Dollevoet R. An approach to determine a critical size for rolling contact fatigue initiating from rail surface defects. Int J Rail Transp 2016, 5 1 16-37

[101.] Cantini S, Cervello S. The competitive role of wear and RCF: Full scale experimental assessment of artificial and natural defects in railway wheel treads. Wear 2016, 366–367 325-337

Funding

National Natural Science Foundation of China(52272443); Autonomous Research Project of State Key Laboratory(2022TPL-04); State Scholarship Fund of the China Scholarship Council(202007000128); Australian Research Council Discovery Early Career Award(DE210100273)