An experimental study on the effects of friction modifiers on wheel–rail dynamic interactions with various angles of attack

Abstract

By modifying friction to the desired level, the application of friction modifiers (FMs) has been considered as a promising emerging tool in the railway engineering for increasing braking/traction force in poor adhesion conditions and mitigating wheel/rail interface deterioration, energy consumption, vibration and noise. Understanding the effectiveness of FMs in wheel–rail dynamic interactions is crucial to their proper applications in practice, which has, however, not been well explained. This study experimentally investigates the effects of two types of top-of-rail FM, i.e. FM-A and FM-B, and their application dosages on wheel–rail dynamic interactions with a range of angles of attack (AoAs) using an innovative well-controlled V-track test rig. The tested FMs have been used to provide intermediate friction for wear and noise reduction. The effectiveness of the FMs is assessed in terms of the wheel–rail adhesion characteristics and friction rolling induced axle box acceleration (ABA). This study provides the following new insights into the study of FM: the applications of the tested FMs can both reduce the wheel–rail adhesion level and change the negative friction characteristic to positive; stick–slip can be generated in the V-Track and eliminated by FM-A but intensified by FM-B, depending on the dosage of the FMs applied; the negative friction characteristic is not a must for stick–slip; the increase in ABA with AoA is insignificant until stick–slip occurs and the ABA can thus be influenced by the applications of FM.

Keywords

Friction modifier / V-track test rig / Adhesion / Wheel–rail dynamic interaction / Angle of attack / Axle box acceleration

References

[1.] Li Z Arias-Cuevas O Lewis R Gallardo-Hernández EA. Rolling-Sliding laboratory tests of friction modifiers in leaf contaminated wheel–rail contacts. Tribol Lett, 2008 33 3–4 97-109

[2.] Arias-Cuevas O Li Z Lewis R Gallardo-Hernández EA. Rolling-Sliding laboratory tests of friction modifiers in dry and wet wheel–rail contacts. Wear, 2010 268 3–4 543-551

[3.] Eadie DT Elvidge D Oldknow K Stock R Pointner P Kalousek J Klauser P. The effects of top of rail friction modifier on wear and rolling contact fatigue: full-scale rail–wheel test rig evaluation, analysis and modelling. Wear, 2008 265 9–10 1222-1230

[4.] Idárraga Alarcón G Burgelman N Meza JM Toro A Li Z. The influence of rail lubrication on energy dissipation in the wheel/rail contact: a comparison of simulation results with field measurements. Wear, 2015 330–331 533-539

[5.] Eadie DT Kalousek J Chiddick KC. The role of high positive friction (HPF) modifier in the control of short pitch corrugations and related phenomena. Wear, 2002 253 1–2 185-192

[6.] Eadie DT Santoro M Kalousek J. Railway noise and the effect of top of rail liquid friction modifiers: changes in sound and vibration spectral distributions in curves. Wear, 2005 258 7–8 1148-1155

[7.] Eadie DT Santoro M Oldknow K Oka Y. Field studies of the effect of friction modifiers on short pitch corrugation generation in curves. Wear, 2008 265 9–10 1212-1221

[8.] Yang Z Deng X Li Z. Numerical modeling of dynamic frictional rolling contact with an explicit finite element method. Tribol Int, 2019 129 214-231

[9.] Harmon M Lewis R. Review of top of rail friction modifier tribology. Tribol—Mater Surf Interfaces, 2016 10 3 150-162

[10.] Areiza YA Garcés SI Santa JF Vargas G Toro A. Field measurement of coefficient of friction in rails using a hand-pushed tribometer. Tribol Int, 2015 82 Part B 274-279

[11.] Spiryagin M Wu Q Polach O . Problems, assumptions and solutions in locomotive design, traction and operational studies. Railw Eng Sci, 2022

[12.] Matsumoto A Sato Y Ohno H . Improvement of bogie curving performance by using friction modifier to rail/wheel interface. Wear, 2005 258 7–8 1201-1208

[13.] Eadie DT Santoro M Powell W. Local control of noise and vibration with KELTRACK™ friction modifier and Protector® trackside application: an integrated solution. J Sound Vib, 2003 267 3 761-772

[14.] Liu X Meehan PA. Investigation of squeal noise under positive friction characteristics condition provided by friction modifiers. J Sound Vib, 2016 371 393-405

[15.] Stock R Stanlake L Hardwick C Yu M Eadie D Lewis R. Material concepts for top of rail friction management: classification, characterisation and application. Wear, 2016 366–367 225-232

[16.] Lewis SR Lewis R Evans G Buckley-Johnstone LE. Assessment of railway curve lubricant performance using a twin-disc tester. Wear, 2014 314 1–2 205-212

[17.] Naeimi M Li Z Petrov RH Sietsma J Dollevoet R. Development of a new downscale setup for wheel–rail contact experiments under impact loading conditions. Exp Tech, 2017 42 10 1-17

[18.] Shrestha S Spiryagin M Wu Q. Real-time multibody modeling and simulation of a scaled bogie test rig. Railw Eng Sci, 2020 28 2 146-159

[19.] Tao G Wen Z Jin X Yang X. Polygonisation of railway wheels: a critical review. Railw Eng Sci, 2020 28 4 317-345

[20.] Zhang P Moraal J Li Z. Design, calibration and validation of a wheel-rail contact force measurement system in V-Track. Measurement, 2021 175 109105

[21.] de Beer FG Janssens MHA Kooijman PP. Squeal noise of rail-bound vehicles influenced by lateral contact position. J Sound Vib, 2003 267 3 497-507

[22.] Baek K-S Kyogoku K Nakahara T. An experimental study of transient traction characteristics between rail and wheel under low slip and low speed conditions. Wear, 2008 265 9–10 1417-1424

[23.] Chen H Namura A Ishida M Nakahara T. Influence of axle load on wheel/rail adhesion under wet conditions in consideration of running speed and surface roughness. Wear, 2016 366–367 303-309

[24.] Gallardo-Hernandez EA Lewis R. Twin disc assessment of wheel/rail adhesion. Wear, 2008 265 9–10 1309-1316

[25.] Fletcher DI Lewis S. Creep curve measurement to support wear and adhesion modelling, using a continuously variable creep twin disc machine. Wear, 2013 298–299 57-65

[26.] Monk-Steel AD Thompson DJ de Beer FG Janssens MHA. An investigation into the influence of longitudinal creepage on railway squeal noise due to lateral creepage. J Sound Vib, 2006 293 3–5 766-776

[27.] Lewis SR Lewis R Richards P Buckley-Johnstone LE. Investigation of the isolation and frictional properties of hydrophobic products on the rail head, when used to combat low adhesion. Wear, 2014 314 1–2 213-219

[28.] Olofsson U Lyu Y. Open system tribology in the wheel–rail contact—a literature review. Appl Mech Rev, 2017 69 6 060803

[29.] Wu Q Spiryagin M Cole C. Train energy simulation with locomotive adhesion model. Railw Eng Sci, 2020 28 1 75-84

[30.] Rail Safety and Standards Board (2010) Guidance on testing of wheel slide protection systems fitted on rail vehicles, GM/GN2695, London

Funding

H2020 European Institute of Innovation and Technology(826255)