Recycled materials in railroad substructure: an energy perspective

Abstract

Given that the current ballasted tracks in Australia may not be able to support faster and significantly heavier freight trains as planned for the future, the imminent need for innovative and sustainable ballasted tracks for transport infrastructure is crucial. Over the past two decades, a number of studies have been conducted by the researchers of Transport Research Centre (TRC) at the University of Technology Sydney (UTS) to investigate the ability of recycled rubber mats, as well as waste tyre cells and granulated rubber to improve the stability of track substructure including ballast and subballast layers. This paper reviews four applications of these novel methods, including using recycled rubber products such as CWRC mixtures (i.e., mixtures of coal wash (CW) and rubber crumbs (RC)) and SEAL mixtures (i.e., mixtures of steel furnace slag, CW and RC) to replace subballast/capping materials, tyre cells reinforcements for subballast/capping layer and under ballast mats; and investigates the energy dissipation capacity for each application based on small-scale cyclic triaxial tests and large-scale track model tests. It has been found that the inclusion of these rubber products increases the energy dissipation effect of the track, hence reducing the ballast degradation efficiently and increasing the track stability. Moreover, a rheological model is also proposed to investigate the effect of different rubber inclusions on their efficiency to reduce the transient motion of rail track under dynamic loading. The outcomes elucidated in this paper will lead to a better understanding of the performance of ballast tracks upgraded with resilient rubber products, while promoting environmentally sustainable and more affordable ballasted tracks for greater passenger comfort and increased safety.

References

[1.] Wang S, Burton D, Herbst AH, Sheridan J, Thompson MC. The effect of the ground condition on high-speed train slipstream. J Wind Eng Ind Aerodyn 2018, 172 230-243

[2.] Zhang Y, Zhang A, Wang J. Exploring the roles of high-speed train, air and coach services in the spread of COVID-19 in China. Transp Policy 2020, 94 34-42

[3.] McIntosh J, Newman P, Glazebrook G. Why fast trains work: an assessment of a fast regional rail system in Perth, Australia. J Transport Technol 2013, 3 37-47

[4.] Biabani MM, Ngo NT, Indraratna B. Performance evaluation of railway subballast stabilised with geocell based on pull-out testing. Geotext Geomembr 2016, 44 4 579-591

[5.] Leshchinsky B, Ling HI. Numerical modeling of behavior of railway ballasted structure with geocell confinement. Geotext Geomembr 2013, 36 33-43

[6.] Zhao M, Zhang L, Zou X, Zhao H. Research progress in two-direction reinforced composite foundation formed by geocell reinforced mattress and gravel piles. China J Highway Transport 2009, 22 1 1-10

[7.] Indraratna B, Qi Y, Ngo TN, Rujikiatkamjorn C, Neville T, Ferreira FB, Shahkolahi A. Use of geogrids and recycled rubber in railroad infrastructure for enhanced performance. Geosciences 2019, 9 1 30

[8.] Leng J, Gabr MA. Characteristics of geogrid-reinforced aggregate under cyclic load. Transp Res Rec 2002, 1786 1 29-35

[9.] Indraratna B, Ngo NT, Rujikiatkamjorn C. Behavior of geogrid-reinforced ballast under various levels of fouling. Geotext Geomembr 2011, 29 3 313-322

[10.] Liu C, Indraratna B, Rujikiatkamjorn C. An analytical model for particle-geogrid aperture interaction. Geotext Geomembr 2020, 49 41-44

[11.] Göbel CH, Weisemann UC, Kirschner RA. Effectiveness of a reinforcing geogrid in a railway subbase under dynamic loads. Geotext Geomembr 1994, 13 2 91-99

[12.] Qi Y, Indraratna B, Heitor A, Vinod JS. Effect of rubber crumbs on the cyclic behavior of steel furnace slag and coal wash mixtures. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng 2018, 144 2 04017107

[13.] Fonseca J, Riaz A, Bernal-Sanchez J, Barreto D, McDougall J, Miranda-Manzanares M, Marinelli A, Dimitriadi V. Particle-scale interactions and energy dissipation mechanisms in sand–rubber mixtures. Géotech Lett 2019, 9 4 263-268

[14.] Kim H-K, Santamarina JC. Sand–rubber mixtures (large rubber chips). Can Geotech J 2008, 45 10 1457-1466

[15.] Navaratnarajah SK, Indraratna B. Use of rubber mats to improve the deformation and degradation behavior of rail ballast under cyclic loading. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng 2017, 143 6 04017015

[16.] Costa PA, Calçada R, Cardoso AS. Ballast mats for the reduction of railway traffic vibrations. Numerical study. Soil Dyn Earthq Eng 2012, 42 137-150

[17.] Jayasuriya C, Indraratna B, Ngo TN. Experimental study to examine the role of under sleeper pads for improved performance of ballast under cyclic loading. Transport Geotech 2019, 19 61-73

[18.] Indraratna B, Qi Y, Jayasuriya C, Rujikiatkamjorn C, Arachchige CM. Use of recycled rubber inclusions with granular waste for enhanced track performance. Transport Eng 2021, 6 100093

[19.] Indraratna B, Qi Y, Tawk M, Heitor A, Rujikiatkamjorn C, Navaratnarajah SK (2020) Advances in ground improvement using waste materials for transportation infrastructure. In: Proceedings of the institution of civil engineers-ground improvement, pp 1–44

[20.] Indraratna B, Sun Q, Grant J. Behaviour of subballast reinforced with used tyre and potential application in rail tracks. Transport Geotech 2017, 12 26-36

[21.] Mohajerani A, Burnett L, Smith JV, Markovski S, Rodwell G, Rahman MT, Kurmus H, Mirzababaei M, Arulrajah A, Horpibulsuk S. Recycling waste rubber tyres in construction materials and associated environmental considerations: a review. Resour Conserv Recycl 2020, 155 104679

[22.] Sol-Sánchez M, Thom N, Moreno-Navarro F, Rubio-Gamez M, Airey G. A study into the use of crumb rubber in railway ballast. Constr Build Mater 2015, 75 19-24

[23.] Koohmishi M, Azarhoosh A. Hydraulic conductivity of fresh railway ballast mixed with crumb rubber considering size and percentage of crumb rubber as well as aggregate gradation. Constr Build Mater 2020, 241 118133

[24.] Arachchige CM, Indraratna B, Qi Y, Vinod JS, Rujikiatkamjorn C (2021) Geotechnical characteristics of a rubber intermixed ballast system. Acta Geotech 1–12

[25.] Indraratna B, Qi Y, Heitor A. Evaluating the properties of mixtures of steel furnace slag, coal wash, and rubber crumbs used as subballast. J Mater Civ Eng 2018, 30 1 04017251

[26.] Qi Y, Indraratna B. Energy-based approach to assess the performance of a granular matrix consisting of recycled rubber, steel-furnace slag, and coal wash. J Mater Civ Eng 2020, 32 7 04020169

[27.] Qi Y, Indraratna B. The influence of rubber inclusion on the dynamic response of rail track. J Mater Civ Eng 2021, 34 2 04021432

[28.] Tawk M, Qi Y, Indraratna B, Rujikiatkamjorn C, Heitor A. Behavior of a mixture of coal wash and rubber crumbs under cyclic loading. J Mater Civ Eng 2021, 33 5 04021054

[29.] Saberian M, Li J, Nguyen B, Wang G. Permanent deformation behaviour of pavement base and subbase containing recycle concrete aggregate, coarse and fine crumb rubber. Constr Build Mater 2018, 178 51-58

[30.] Arulrajah A, Naeini M, Mohammadinia A, Horpibulsuk S, Leong M. Recovered plastic and demolition waste blends as railway capping materials. Transport Geotech 2020, 22 100320

[31.] Naeini M, Mohammadinia A, Arulrajah A, Horpibulsuk S, Leong M. Stiffness and strength characteristics of demolition waste, glass and plastics in railway capping layers. Soils Found 2019, 59 6 2238-2253

[32.] Disfani MM, Tsang H-H, Arulrajah A, Yaghoubi E. Shear and compression characteristics of recycled glass-tire mixtures. J Mater Civ Eng 2017, 29 6 06017003

[33.] Wang D, Tawk M, Indraratna B, Heitor A, Rujikiatkamjorn C. A mixture of coal wash and fly ash as a pavement substructure material. Transport Geotech 2019, 21 100265

[34.] Kim B, Prezzi M, Salgado R. Geotechnical properties of fly and bottom ash mixtures for use in highway embankments. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng 2005, 131 7 914-924

[35.] Kaniraj SR, Gayathri V. Geotechnical behavior of fly ash mixed with randomly oriented fiber inclusions. Geotext Geomembr 2003, 21 3 123-149

[36.] Signes CH, Fernández PM, Perallón EM, Franco RI. Characterisation of an unbound granular mixture with waste tyre rubber for subballast layers. Mater Struct 2015, 48 12 3847-3861

[37.] Rujikiatkamjorn C, Indraratna B, Chiaro G. Compaction of coal wash to optimise its utilisation as water-front reclamation fill. Geomech Geoeng 2013, 8 1 36-45

[38.] Kaliboullah CI. Behaviour of compacted coalwash under saturated condition incorporating particle breakage 2016 School of Civil, Mining and Environmental Engineering, University of Wollongong

[39.] Chiaro G, Indraratna B, Tasalloti SA, Rujikiatkamjorn C (2015) Optimisation of coal wash-slag blend as a structural fill. Institution of Civil Engineers: Ground Improvement

[40.] Tawk M, Indraratna B. Role of rubber crumbs on the stress-strain response of a coal wash matrix. J Mater Civ Eng 2021, 33 3 04020480

[41.] Indraratna B, Rujikiatkamjorn C, Tawk M, Heitor A. Compaction, degradation and deformation characteristics of an energy absorbing matrix. Transport Geotech 2019, 19 74-83

[42.] Indraratna B, Lackenby J, Christie D. Effect of confining pressure on the degradation of ballast under cyclic loading. Geotechnique 2005, 55 4 325-328

[43.] Qi Y, Indraratna B, Heitor A, Vinod JS. Closure to “effect of rubber crumbs on the cyclic behavior of steel furnace slag and coal wash mixtures”. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng 2019, 145 1 07018035

[44.] Feng Z-Y, Sutter KG. Dynamic properties of granulated rubber/sand mixtures. Geotech Test J 2000, 23 3 338-344

[45.] Li B, Huang M, Zeng X. Dynamic behavior and liquefaction analysis of recycled-rubber sand mixtures. J Mater Civ Eng 2016, 28 11 04016122

[46.] Jeffs T, Tew GP (1991) A review of track design procedures: sleepers and ballast, in Railways of Australia, Melbourne, Australia

[47.] Indraratna B, Nimbalkar S, Rujikiatkamjorn C. Enhancement of rail track performance through utilisation of geosynthetic inclusions. Geotech Eng J SEAGS AGSSEA 2014, 45 1 17-27

[48.] ASTM-D4885-01 (2018) Standard test method for determining performance strength of geomembranes by the wide strip tensile method. ASTM International

[49.] American Society for Testing and Materials (2003) D3999-91. Standard test methods for the determination of the modulus and damping properties of soils using the cyclic triaxial apparatus. In: Annual Book of ASTM Standard

[50.] Indraratna B, Sun Q, Heitor A, Grant J. Performance of rubber tire-confined capping layer under cyclic loading for railroad conditions. J Mater Civ Eng 2018, 30 3 06017021

[51.] Indraratna B, Salim W, Rujikiatkamjorn C. Advanced rail geotechnology-ballasted track 2011 CRC Press

[52.] Kaewunruen S, Remennikov AM. Sensitivity analysis of free vibration characteristics of an in situ railway concrete sleeper to variations of rail pad parameters. J Sound Vib 2006, 298 1–2 453-461

[53.] Johansson A, Nielsen JC, Bolmsvik R, Karlström A, Lundén R. Under sleeper pads—influence on dynamic train–track interaction. Wear 2008, 265 9–10 1479-1487

[54.] Tiwari B, Ajmera B, Moubayed S, Lemmon A, Styler K (2012) Soil modification with shredded rubber tires. In: GeoCongress 2012: state of the art and practice in geotechnical engineering, Oakland, California, March 25–29, pp 3701–3708

[55.] Sol-Sánchez M, Moreno-Navarro F, Rubio-Gámez MC. Viability of using end-of-life tire pads as under sleeper pads in railway. Constr Build Mater 2014, 64 150-156

[56.] Ajmera B, Tiwari B, Koirala J (2016) Geotechnical properties of clays modified with recycled crumb rubber. In: Geotechnical and structural engineering congress 2016, Phoenix, Arizona, February 14–17

[57.] DIN (2010) Mechanical vibration—resilient elements used in railway tracks. Part V: Laboratory test procedures for under-ballast mats. German Institute for Standardization, Berlin

[58.] Bolton M, Nakata Y, Cheng Y. Micro-and macro-mechanical behaviour of DEM crushable materials. Géotechnique 2008, 58 6 471-480

[59.] Liu M, Gao Y, Liu H. An elastoplastic constitutive model for rockfills incorporating energy dissipation of nonlinear friction and particle breakage. Int J Numer Anal Methods Geomech 2014, 38 9 935-960

[60.] Nimbalkar S, Indraratna B. Improved performance of ballasted rail track using geosynthetics and rubber shockmat. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng 2016, 142 8 04016031

[61.] Indraratna B, Nimbalkar S, Christie D, Rujikiatkamjorn C, Vinod J. Field assessment of the performance of a ballasted rail track with and without geosynthetics. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng 2010, 136 7 907-917

[62.] Punetha P, Nimbalkar S, Khabbaz H. Analytical evaluation of ballasted track substructure response under repeated train loads. Int J Geomech 2020, 20 7 04020093

[63.] Nimbalkar S, Indraratna B, Dash SK, Christie D. Improved performance of railway ballast under impact loads using shock mats. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng 2012, 138 3 281-294

[64.] Chen JY, Ummin O, Yu T, Qi YJ (2013) Applications of Rayleigh wave detection technique and polymer grouting technology in waterproof construction. In: Applied mechanics and materials. Trans Tech Publ.