Local Persistence of Large Benthic Foraminifera (LBF) under Increasing Urban Development: A Case Study from Zanzibar (Unguja), East Africa

Abstract

Coastal marine management is vital for socio-ecological sustainability of developing, tropical ecosystems, which calls for diverse tools to monitor and assess water quality. The carbonate-dominated habitats off Zanzibar were chosen for study due to potential water quality degradation in a rapidly developing tourist destination heavily reliant on its coral reefs. These reefs are largely unmonitored and subject to local and global stressors. A widely used method for assessing reef health, as an early detection method of ecological changes, is the application of large benthic foraminiferal bioindicators, i.e., the FoRAM Index. We expected to find poor water quality conditions in the unmanaged reefs supported by stress-toelerant (opportunistic) foraminiferal assemblages. The dissolved inorganic nitrogen and phosphate values derived from untreated sewage effluent from Stone Town were highly variable (ranging 0.05–3.77 and 0.05–1.45 µM, respectively), moderate, and occasionally approached or exceeded critical threshold values for oligotrophic ecosystems. The analysis of total assemblages indicated an abundance of symbiont-bearing large benthic foraminifera, dominated by prolific Amphistegina species, comparatively low-moderate diversity, high FI values (7.6 on average), and high coral cover. A water quality gradient was reflected by subtle assemblage differences, suggesting that LBF can provide early warning signals of benthic changes, indicating the importance of long-term monitoring programs in vulnerable, rapidly developing coastal ecosystems exposed to increasing pressures.

Keywords

carbonate / coral reef / bioindicator / FoRAM Index / nutrients / sewage effluent / Western Indian Ocean / coastal development / coastal marine management

References

Ali O, Omar M, Yusuf S. Population Growth and Unemployment in Zanzibar. International Journal of Sciences: Basic and Applied Research, 2021, 59(2): 36-17

Belanger C L. Evaluating Taphonomic Bias of Paleoecological Data in Fossil Benthic Foraminiferal Assemblages. PALAIOS, 2011, 26(12): 767-778.

Bell P R F. Eutrophication and Coral Reefs—Some Examples in the Great Barrier Reef Lagoon. Water Research, 1992, 26(5): 553-568.

Berkeley A, Perry C T, Smithers S G. Taphonomic Signatures and Patterns of Test Degradation on Tropical, Intertidal Benthic Foraminifera. Marine Micropaleontology, 2009, 73(3/4): 148-163.

Björk M, Mohammad S, Bjorklund M, . Coralline Algae, Important Coral Reef Builders Threatened by Pollution. AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment, 1995, 24: 502-505.

Bravo H, Cannicci S, Huyghe F, . Ecological Health of Coral Reefs in Zanzibar. Regional Studies in Marine Science, 2021, 48: 102014

Carilli J, Walsh S. Benthic Foraminiferal Assemblages from Kiritimati (Christmas) Island Indicate Human-Mediated Nutrification Has Occurred over the Scale of Decades. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 2012, 456 87-99.

Chasens S A. Foraminifera of the Kenya Coastline. Journal of Foraminiferal Research, 1981, 11(3): 191-202.

Clarke K R, Ainsworth M. A Method of Linking Multivariate Community Structure to Environmental Variables. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 1993, 92: 205-219.

Clarke, K. R., Gorley, R. N., 2015. PRIMER V7: User Manual/Tutorial. PRIMER-E, Plymouth

Cleary D, Polónia A, Renema W, . Coral Reefs next to a Major Conurbation: A Study of Temporal Change (1985–2011) in Coral Cover and Composition in the Reefs of Jakarta, Indonesia. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 2014, 501: 89-98.

Debenay, J. -P., 2012. A Guide to 1 000 Foraminifera from Southwestern Pacific: New Caledonia. Publications Scientifiques du Muséum. Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle Paris, Paris. 385

Díaz-Pérez L, Rodríguez-Zaragoza F A, Ortiz M, . Correction: Coral Reef Health Indices Versus the Biological, Ecological and Functional Diversity of Fish and Coral Assemblages in the Caribbean Sea. PLoS One, 2016, 11(11): e0167252

Done T J. Phase Shifts in Coral Reef Communities and Their Ecological Significance. Hydrobiologia, 1992, 247 1 121-132.

Engel B E, Hallock P, Price R E, . Shell Dissolution in Larger Benthic Foraminifers Exposed to pH and Temperature Extremes: Results from an in situ Experiment. Journal of Foraminiferal Research, 2015, 45(2): 190-203.

Fajemila O T, Langer M R, Lipps J H. Spatial Patterns in the Distribution, Diversity and Abundance of Benthic Foraminifera around Moorea (Society Archipelago, French Polynesia). PLoS One, 2015, 10(12): e0145752

Halfar J, Godinez-Orta L, Riegl B, . Living on the Edge: High-Latitude Porites Carbonate Production under Temperate Eutrophic Conditions. Coral Reefs, 2005, 24 4 582-592.

Hallock, P., 2012. The FORAM Index Revisited: Uses, Challenges and Limitations. In: Yellowlees, D., Hughes, T. P., eds., Proceedings of the 12th International Coral Reef Symposium, Cairns, Australia. James Cook University, Cairns

Hallock P, Lidz B H, Cockey-Burkhard E M, . Foraminifera as Bioindicators in Coral Reef Assessment and Monitoring: The Foram Index. Coastal Monitoring through Partnerships, 2003, Netherlands, Dordrecht: Springer, 221-238

Hallock P, Schlager W. Nutrient Excess and the Demise of Coral Reefs and Carbonate Platforms. PALAIOS, 1986, 1(4): 389-398.

Heron-Allen E, Earland A. The Foraminifer of the Kerimba Archipelago (Portuguese East Africa), Part I. Transactions of the Zoological Society of London, 1914, 20(12): 363-390.

Heron-Allen E, Earland A. The Foraminifera of the Kerimba Archipelago Portugicese East Africa, Part II. Transactions of the Zoological Society of London, 1915, 20(17): 543-794.

Herrán N, Narayan G R, Reymond C E, . Calcium Carbonate Production, Coral Cover and Diversity along a Distance Gradient from Stone Town: A Case Study from Zanzibar, Tanzania. Frontiers in Marine Science, 2017, 4: 412

Hughes T P. Catastrophes, Phase Shifts, and Large-Scale Degradation of a Caribbean Coral Reef. Science, 1994, 265(5178): 1547-1551.

Humphreys A F, Halfar J, Ingle J C, . Effect of Seawater Temperature, pH, and Nutrients on the Distribution and Character of Low Abundance Shallow Water Benthic Foraminifera in the Galápagos. PLoS One, 2018, 13(9): e0202746

Humphreys A F, Halfar J, Rivera F, . Variable El Niño-Southern Oscillation Influence on Biofacies Dynamics of Eastern Pacific Shallow-Water Carbonate Systems. Geology, 2016, 44 7 571-574.

Johnstone R W, Muhando C A, Francis J. The Status of the Coral Reefs of Zanzibar: One Example of a Regional Predicament. AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment, 1998, 27(8): 700-707

Khamis Z A, Kalliola R, Käyhkö N. Geographical Characterization of the Zanzibar Coastal Zone and Its Management Perspectives. Ocean and Coastal Management, 2017, 149 116-134.

Lange G -M, Jiddawi N. Economic Value of Marine Ecosystem Services in Zanzibar: Implications for Marine Conservation and Sustainable Development. Ocean & Coastal Management, 2009, 52(10): 521-532.

Lange I D, Perry C T, Alvarez-Filip L. Carbonate Budgets as Indicators of Functional Reef “Health”: A Critical Review of Data Underpinning Census-Based Methods and Current Knowledge Gaps. Ecological Indicators, 2020, 110: 105857

Langer M R, Thissen J M, Makled W A, . The Foraminifera from the Bazaruto Archipelago (Mozambique). Neues Jahrbuch für Geologie und Paläontologie, 2013, 267(2): 155-170.

Langer M R. Assessing the Contribution of Foraminiferan Protists to Global Ocean Carbonate Production. Journal of Eukaryotic Microbiology, 2008, 55(3): 163-169.

Lapointe B E, Barile P J, Matzie W R. Anthropogenic Nutrient Enrichment of Seagrass and Coral Reef Communities in the Lower Florida Keys: Discrimination of Local Versus Regional Nitrogen Sources. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 2004, 308(1): 23-58.

Laws E A, Redalje D G. Effect of Sewage Enrichment on the Phytoplankton Population of a Subtropical Estuary. Pacific Science, 1979, 33 129-144.

Lee J J, Hallock P. Algal Symbiosis as the Driving Force in the Evolution of Larger Foraminifera. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1987, 503(1): 330-347.

Loeblich A R, Tappan H. Foraminifera from the Sahul Shelf and Timor Sea. Special Publication (Cushman Foundation for Foraminiferal Research) No. 31, 1994, Cambridge: Harvard University, 661

Lugomela C, Lyimo T J, Bryceson I, . Trichodesmium in Coastal Waters of Tanzania: Diversity, Seasonality, Nitrogen and Carbon Fixation. Hydrobiologia, 2002, 477(1/2/3): 1-13.

Lybolt M, Neil D, Zhao J-X, . Instability in a Marginal Coral Reef: The Shift from Natural Variability to a Human-Dominated Seascape. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 2011, 9(3): 154-160.

Mahongo S, Shaghude Y. Modelling the Dynamics of the Tanzanian Coastal Waters. Journal of Oceanography and Marine Science, 2014, 5(1): 1-7.

McClanahan T R. Seasonality in East Africa’s Coastal Waters. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 1988, 44: 191-199.

McClanahan T R, Ateweberhan M, Graham N, . Western Indian Ocean Coral Communities: Bleaching Responses and Susceptibility to Extinction. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 2007, 337: 1-13.

Mmochi A J, Tobey J, Jiddawi N, . Richmond M D, Francis J, . Establishing the Status of the Environment and Environmental Changes in Tanzania Coastal Waters. Marine Science Development in Tanzania and Eastern Africa, 2001, Stone Town, Zanzibar: Western Indian Ocean Marine Science Association (WIOMSA), 451-466

Mohammed S M. Pollution by Industry and Other Users of Chemicals, 1990, Zanzibar: Commission for Lands and Environment, 33

Mohammed S M. Pollution Management in Zanzibar: The Need for a New Approach. Ocean & Coastal Management, 2002, 45(4/5): 301-311.

Moynihan M A, Baker D M, Mmochi A J. Isotopic and Microbial Indicators of Sewage Pollution from Stone Town, Zanzibar, Tanzania. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 2012, 64(7): 1348-1355.

Muhando C A. Coral Reef Monitoring in Tanzania: An Analysis of the Last 20 Years. Western Indian Ocean Journal of Marine Science, 2010, 8(2): 203-214.

Müller G, Gastner M. The “Karbonat-Bombe”, a Simple Device for the Determination of the Carbonate Content in Sediments, Soils, and other Materials. Journal of Mineralogy and Geochemistry, 1971, 10: 446-469.

Muzuka A N N, Dubi A M, Muhando C A, . Impact of Hydrographic Parameters and Seasonal Variation in Sediment Fluxes on Coral Status at Chumbe and Bawe Reefs, Zanzibar, Tanzania. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science, 2010, 89(2): 137-144.

Narayan G R, Reymond C E, Stuhr M, . Response of Large Benthic Foraminifera to Climate and Local Changes: Implications for Future Carbonate Production. Sedimentology, 2022, 69(1): 121-161.

Narayan, G. R., Westphal, H., 2016. Are Zanzibar’s Reefs Undergoing Ecological Change? Foraminifera Bio-Indicators for Monitoring And Assessment of Reef Ecosystems in the Western Indian Ocean. In: Birkeland, C., Coles, S. L., Spies, N. P., eds., Proceedings of the 13th International Coral Reef Symposium, Honolulu, Hawaii. International Society for Coral Reef Studies, Honolulu. 207–215

Narayan Y R, Lybolt M, Zhao J -X, . Holocene Benthic Foraminiferal Assemblages Indicate Long-Term Marginality of Reef Habitats from Moreton Bay, Australia. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 2015, 420: 49-64.

Narayan Y R, Pandolfi J M. Benthic Foraminiferal Assemblages from Moreton Bay, South-East Queensland, Australia: Applications in Monitoring Water and Substrate Quality in Subtropical Estuarine Environments. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 2010, 60(11): 2062-2078.

Nordlund L M, Kloiber U, Carter E, . Chumbe Island Coral Park—Governance Analysis. Marine Policy, 2013, 41: 110-117.

Nyanda F, Mtei R P, Mohammed S M, . Nutrient and Bacteria Concentrations in the Coastal Waters off Zanzibar Town. Western Indian Ocean Journal of Marine Science, 2016, 15(2): 9-17

Nyandwi N. The Effects of Monsoons on the East African Coastal Current through the Zanzibar Channel, Tanzania. Journal of Ocean Technology, 2013, 8(4): 64-74

Obura D. The Diversity and Biogeography of Western Indian Ocean Reef-BuildingCorals. PLoS One, 2012, 7(9): e45013

Obura D O. Resilience and Climate Change: Lessons from Coral Reefs and Bleaching in the Western Indian Ocean. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science, 2005, 63 3 353-372.

Obura D O, Aeby G, Amornthammarong N, . Coral Reef Monitoring, Reef Assessment Technologies, and Ecosystem-Based Management. Frontiers in Marine Science, 2019, 6: 580

Painter S C. The Biogeochemistry and Oceanography of the East African Coastal Current. Progress in Oceanography, 2020, 186 102374

Patterson R T, Fishbein E. Re-Examination of the Statistical Methods Used to Determine the Number of Point Counts Needed for Micropaleontological Quantitative Research. Journal of Paleontology, 1989, 63(2): 245-248.

Pereira C P G. Foraminiferal Distribution and Ecology in the Fringing Reef Complex of the Coast, Near Mombasa, Kenya, 1979, Aberystwyth: University of Wales, 480

Prazeres M, Martínez-Colón M, Hallock P. Foraminifera as Bioindicators of Water Quality: The FoRAM Index Revisited. Environmental Pollution, 2020, 257 113612

Prazeres M, Uthicke S, Pandolfi J M. Influence of Local Habitat on the Physiological Responses of Large Benthic Foraminifera to Temperature and Nutrient Stress. Scientific Reports, 2016, 6 21936

Rehren J, Samoilys M, Reuter H, . Integrating Resource Perception, Ecological Surveys, and Fisheries Statistics: A Review of the Fisheries in Zanzibar. Reviews in Fisheries Science & Aquaculture, 2022, 30(1): 1-18.

Renema W. Habitat Selective Factors Influencing the Distribution of Larger Benthic Foraminiferal Assemblages over the Kepulauan Seribu. Marine Micropaleontology, 2008, 68(3/4): 286-298.

Renema W. Terrestrial Influence as a Key Driver of Spatial Variability in Large Benthic Foraminiferal Assemblage Composition in the Central Indo-Pacific. Earth-Science Reviews, 2018, 177 514-544.

Renema W, Beaman R J, Webster J M. Mixing of Relict and Modern Tests of Larger Benthic Foraminifera on the Great Barrier Reef Shelf Margin. Marine Micropaleontology, 2013, 101: 68-75.

Renema W, Troelstra S R. Larger Foraminifera Distribution on a Mesotrophic Carbonate Shelf in SW Sulawesi (Indonesia). Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 2001, 175(1/2/3/4): 125-146.

Resig J M. Age and Preservation of Amphistegina (Foraminifera) in Hawaiian Beach Sand: Implication for Sand Turnover Rate and Resource Renewal. Marine Micropaleontology, 2004, 50(3/4): 225-236.

Reymond C E, Mateu-Vicens G, Westphal H. Foraminiferal Assemblages from a Transitional Tropical Upwelling Zone in the Golfe D’ Arguin, Mauritania. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science, 2014, 148: 70-84.

Reymond C E, Roff G, Chivas A R, . Millennium-Scale Records of Benthic Foraminiferal Communities from the Central Great Barrier Reef Reveal Spatial Differences and Temporal Consistency. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 2013, 374: 52-61.

Reymond C E, Uthicke S, Pandolfi J M. Inhibited Growth in the Photosymbiont-Bearing Foraminifer Marginopora vertebralis from the Nearshore Great Barrier Reef, Australia. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 2011, 435: 97-109.

Reymond, C. E., Uthicke, S., Pandolfi, J. M., 2012. Tropical Foraminifera as Indicators of Water Quality and Temperature. In: Yellowlees, D., Hughes, T. P., eds., Proceedings of the 12th International Coral Reef Symposium, Cairns, Australia. James Cook University, Cairns

Reymond C E, Zihrul K-S, Halfar J, . Heterozoan Carbonates from the Equatorial Rocky Reefs of the Galápagos Archipelago. Sedimentology, 2016, 63(4): 940-958.

Romero J, Lee K S, Pérez M, . Larkum A W D, Orth R J, Duarte C M, . Nutrient Dynamics in Seagrass Ecosystems. Seagrasses: Biology, Ecology and Conservation, 2006, Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, 227-254

Schmidt C, Titelboim D, Brandt J, . Extremely Heat Tolerant Photo-Symbiosis in a Shallow Marine Benthic Foraminifera. Scientific Reports, 2016, 6: 30930

Shaghude Y, Wannas K O. Morphology and Sediment Distribution of the Zanzibar Channel. AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment, 1998, 27 729-733.

Shaghude Y W, Wannäs K O. Mineralogical and Biogenic Composition of the Zanzibar Channel Sediments. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science, 2000, 51(4): 477-489.

Shaghude Y W, Wannäs K O, Mahongo S B. Biogenic Assemblage and Hydrodynamic Settings of the Tidally Dominated Reef Platform Sediments of the Zanzibar Channel. Western Indian Ocean Journal of Marine Science, 2002, 1(2): 107-116

Staehr P A, Sheikh M, Rashid R, . Managing Human Pressures to Restore Ecosystem Health of Zanzibar Coastal Waters. Journal of Aquaculture & Marine Biology, 2018, 7(2): 59-70.

Steneck R S, Arnold S N, Boenish R, . Managing Recovery Resilience in Coral Reefs Against Climate-Induced Bleaching and Hurricanes: A 15-Year Case Study from Bonaire, Dutch Caribbean. Frontiers in Marine Science, 2019, 6: 265

Stuhr M, Cameron L P, Blank-Landeshammer B, . Divergent Proteomic Responses Offer Insights into Resistant Physiological Responses of a Reef-Foraminifera to Climate Change Scenarios. Oceans, 2021, 2(2): 281-314.

Stuhr M, Reymond C E, Rieder V, . Reef Calcifiers are Adapted to Episodic Heat Stress but Vulnerable to Sustained Warming. PLoS One, 2017, 12(7): e0179753

Thissen J M. The foraminifera of the Zanzibar Archipelago (Tanzania, East Africa), 2014, Bonn, Germany: University of Bonn, 225

Thissen J M, Langer M R. Spatial Patterns and Structural Composition of Foraminiferal Assemblages from the Zanzibar Archipelago (Tanzania). Palaeontographica Abteilung A, 2017, 308 1/2/3 1-67.

Thomas A, Baptiste A, Martyr-Koller R, . Climate Change and Small Island Developing States. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 2020, 45 1-27.

Uthicke S, Altenrath C. Water Column Nutrients Control Growth and C: N Ratios of Symbiont-Bearing Benthic Foraminifera on the Great Barrier Reef, Australia. Limnology and Oceanography, 2010, 55(4): 1681-1696.

Weinmann A E, Langer M R. Diverse Thermotolerant Assemblages of Benthic Foraminiferal Biotas from Tropical Tide and Rock Pools of Eastern Africa. Revue de Micropaléontologie, 2017, 60(4): 511-523.

Wentworth C K. A Scale of Grade and Class Terms for Clastic Sediments. Journal of Geology, 1922, 30(5): 377-392.