Uncertainty Visualisation of a 3D Geological Geometry Model and Its Application in GIS-Based Mineral Resource Assessment: A Case Study in Huayuan District, Northwestern Hunan Province, China

Abstract

This paper reports an application of uncertainty visualisation of a regional scale (1:50 000) 3D geological geometry model to be involved in GIS-based 3D mineral potential assessment of the Xiangxibei lead-zinc mineral concentration area in northwestern Hunan District, China. Three-dimensional (3D) geological modelling is a process of interpretation that combines a set of input measurements in geometry. Today, technology has become a necessary part of GIS-based deep prospecting. However, issues of sparse data and imperfect understanding exist in the process so that there are several uncertainties in 3D geological modelling. And these uncertainties are inevitably transmitted into the post-processing applications, such as model-based mineral resource assessment. Thus, in this paper, first, a big-data-based method was used to estimate the uncertainty of a 3D geological model; second, a group of expectations of geological geometry uncertainty were calculated and integrated into ore-bearing stratoisohypse modelling, which is one of the major favourable parameters of assessment for Lead-Zinc (Pb-Zn) deep prospectivity mapping in northwestern Hunan; and finally, prospecting targets were improved.

Keywords

uncertainty / 3D geological modelling / Monte Carlo simulation / prospectivity mapping

References

[1] Allmendinger R W, Siron C R, Scott C P. Structural Data Collection with Mobile Devices: Accuracy, Redundancy, and Best Practices. Journal of Structural Geology, 2017, 102: 98-112.

[2] Bárdossy G, Fodor J. Traditional and New Ways to Handle Uncertainty in Geology. Natural Resources Research, 2001, 10(3): 179-187.

[3] Bistacchi A, Massironi M, Dal Piaz G V, . 3D Fold and Fault Reconstruction with an Uncertainty Model: An Example from an Alpine Tunnel Case Study. Computers & Geosciences, 2008, 34(4): 351-372.

[4] Bradley D C, Leach D L. Tectonic Controls of Mississippi Valley-Type Lead-Zinc Mineralization in Orogenic Forelands. Mineralium Deposita, 2003, 38(6): 652-667.

[5] Calcagno P, Chilès J P, Courrioux G, . Geological Modelling from Field Data and Geological Knowledge. Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors, 2008, 171(1/2/3/4): 147-157.

[6] Carmichael T, Ailleres L. Method and Analysis for the Upscaling of Structural Data. Journal of Structural Geology, 2016, 83: 121-133.

[7] Caumon G, Collon-Drouaillet P, Le-Carlier-de-Veslud C, . Surface-Based 3D Modeling of Geological Structures. Mathematical Geosciences, 2009, 41(8): 927-945.

[8] Caumon, G., Tertois, A.-L., Zhang, L., 2007. Elements for Stochastic Structural Perturbation of Stratigraphic Models. Proceedings of Petroleum Geostatistics. EAGE

[9] Chen J P, Yu P P, Shi R, . Research on Three-Dimensional Quantitative Prediction and Evaluation Methods of Regional Concealed Ore Bodies. Earth Science Frontiers, 2014, 21(5): 211-220. (in Chinese with English Abstract)

[10] Cheng M, Hu M, Bao Z, . Discussion on the Geological Features and Genesis of the Limei Pb-Zn Ore Concentration Belt in Northwestern Hunan Province. Geology and Exploration, 2011, 47(2): 251-260. (in Chinese with English Abstract)

[11] Chilès J P, Delfiner P. Modeling Spatial Uncertainty, 2012, New York: Wiley

[12] Cox L A. Artifactual Uncertainty in Risk Analysis. Risk Analysis, 1982, 2(3): 121-135.

[13] Deutsch C V. Geostatistical Reservoir Modeling, 2002, Oxford: Oxford University press

[14] Dong X L, Berti-Equille L, Srivastava D. Integrating Conflicting Data. Proceedings of the VLDB Endowment, 2009, 2(1): 550-561.

[15] Duan Q F. The Research of the Metallogenic Regularity of Strata-bound Zinc-Lead Deposits from Sinian-Cambrian in the Western Hunan and Eastern Hubei: [Dissertation], 2014, Wuhan: China University of Geosciences (in Chinese with English Abstract)

[16] Eisenhart C. Expression of the Uncertainties of Final Results: Clear Statements of the Uncertainties of Reported Values are Needed for Their Critical Evaluation. Science, 1968, 160(3833): 1201-1204.

[17] Evren P -C, Jérémie G, Vitaliy O, . Drillhole Uncertainty Propagation for Three-Dimensional Geological Modeling Using Monte Carlo. Tectonophysics, 2018, 16(39): 747-748

[18] Fisher N I, Lewis T, Embleton B J J. Statistical Analysis of Spherical Data, 1993, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

[19] Frank T, Tertois A L, Mallet J L. 3D-Reconstruction of Complex Geological Interfaces from Irregularly Distributed and Noisy Point Data. Computers & Geosciences, 2007, 33(7): 932-943.

[20] Fu S. Discussion on Formation Rules of High-Grade Pb-Zn Ore in Western Hunan. Nonferrous Metal (Mining Section), 2011, 63(6): 27-35. (in Chinese with English Abstract)

[21] Galera C, Bennis C, Moretti I, . Construction of Coherent 3D Geological Blocks. Computers & Geosciences, 2003, 29(8): 971-984.

[22] Giraud J, Pakyuz-Charrier E, Jessell M, . Uncertainty Reduction through Geologically Conditioned Petrophysical Constraints in Joint Inversion. Geophysics, 2017, 82(6): ID19-ID34.

[23] Glinsky M E, Asher B, Hill R, . Integration of Uncertain Subsurface Information into Multiple Reservoir Simulation Models. The Leading Edge, 2005, 24(10): 990-999.

[24] Gnedenko B V, Kolmogorov A N, Gnedenko B V, . Limit Distributions for Sums of Independent, 1954, Cambridge: Addison-Wesley

[25] Gümplová P. Justice and Rights to Natural Resources. Constellations, 2018, 25(1): 175-177.

[26] Hornik K, Grün B. On Conjugate Families and Jeffreys Priors for von Mises-Fisher Distributions. Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference, 2013, 143(5): 992-999.

[27] Hou E K, Wu L X. An Object Oriented Three Dimensional Topological Data Model Based on Component for Geology Modeling. Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University, 2002, 27(5): 467-472. (in Chinese with English Abstract)

[28] Huang G F, Jia B H, Sun H Q, . China’s National Mineral Resource Assessment Achievement Report: Mineral Potential Mapping in Hunan Province, 2011, Changsha: Hunan Institute of Geological Survey, 253-310

[29] Huang Z Y, Ding H, Xu J H. A Faster Algorithm for Truth Discovery via Range Cover. Algorithmica, 2019, 81(10): 4118-4133.

[30] Jessell M W, Ailleres L, de Kemp E A. Towards an Integrated Inversion of Geoscientific Data: What Price of Geology?. Tectonophysics, 2010, 490(3/4): 294-306.

[31] Jessell M W, Aillères L, Kemp E, . Next Generation Three-Dimension Geologic Modeling and Inversion. Society of Economic Geologists Special Publication, 2014, 18(18): 261-272

[32] Lajaunie C, Courrioux G, Manuel L. Foliation Fields and 3D Cartography in Geology: Principles of a Method Based on Potential Interpolation. Mathematical Geology, 1997, 29(4): 571-584.

[33] Leach D L, Bradley D C, Huston D, . Sediment-Hosted Lead-Zinc Deposits in Earth History. Economic Geology, 2010, 105(3): 593-625.

[34] Leach D L, Bradley D, Lewchuk M T, . Mississippi Valley-Type Lead-Zinc Deposits through Geological Time: Implications from Recent Age-Dating Research. Mineralium Deposita, 2001, 36(8): 711-740.

[35] Li N, Song X L, Li C B, . 3D Geological Modeling for Mineral System Approach to GIS-Based Prospectivity Analysis: Case Study of an MVT Pb-Zn Deposit. Natural Resources Research, 2019, 28(3): 995-1019.

[36] Li N, Song X L, Xiao K Y, . Part II: A Demonstration of Integrating Multiple-Scale 3D Modelling into GIS-Based Prospectivity Analysis: A Case Study of the Huayuan-Malichang District, China. Ore Geology Reviews, 2018, 95(1–4): 292-305.

[37] Li N, Xiao K Y, Yin J N, . A Method of 3D Buffer Analysis of Boundary Representation. Journal of Computer-Aided Design and Computer Graphics, 2015, 27(9): 1625-1636. (in Chinese with English Abstract)

[38] Li Q, Li Y L, Gao J, . A Confidence-Aware Approach for Truth Discovery on Long-Tail Data. Proceedings of the VLDB Endowment, 2014, 8(4): 425-436.

[39] Li, Q., Li, Y., Gao, J., et al., 2014b. Resolving Conflicts in Heterogeneous Data by Truth Discovery and Source Reliability Estimation. Proceedings of the 2014 ACM SIGMOD International Conference on Management of Data. 1187–1198

[40] Li, H., Zhao, B., Fuxman, A., 2014. The Wisdom of Minority: Discovering and Targeting the Right Group of Workers for Crowdsourcing. Proceedings of the 23rd International Conference on World Wide Web. April, 2014, Seoul

[41] Li Y L, Gao J, Meng C S, . A Survey on Truth Discovery. ACM SIGKDD Explorations Newsletter, 2016, 17(2): 1-16.

[42] Lindsay M D, Perrouty S, Jessell M W, . Making the Link between Geological and Geophysical Uncertainty: Geodiversity in the Ashanti Greenstone Belt. Geophysical Journal International, 2013, 195(2): 903-922.

[43] Lindsay M D, Aillères L, Jessell M W, . Locating and Quantifying Geological Uncertainty in Three-Dimensional Models: Analysis of the Gippsland Basin, Southeastern Australia. Tectonophysics, 2012, 546–547: 10-27.

[44] MacEachren A M, Robinson A, Hopper S, . Visualizing Geo-spatial Information Uncertainty: What We Know and What We Need to Know. Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 2005, 32(3): 139-160.

[45] Malengreau B, Lénat J F, Froger J L. Structure of Réunion Island (Indian Ocean) Inferred from the Interpretation of Gravity Anomalies. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research, 1999, 88(3): 131-146.

[46] Mallet J L. Discrete Smooth Interpolation in Geometric Modelling. Computer-Aided Design, 1992, 24(4): 178-191.

[47] Mann C J, Davis J C, Herzfeld U C. Computers in Geology—25 Years of Progress, 1993, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 241-254

[48] Mardia K V, El-Atoum S A M. Bayesian Inference for the von Mises-Fisher Distribution. Biometrika, 1976, 63(1): 203-206.

[49] Maxelon M, Mancktelow N S. Three-Dimensional Geometry and Tectonostratigraphy of the Pennine Zone, Central Alps, Switzerland and Northern Italy. Earth-Science Reviews, 2005, 71(3/4): 171-227.

[50] Moretti I. Working in Complex Areas: New Restoration Workflow Based on Quality Control, 2D and 3D Restorations. Marine and Petroleum Geology, 2008, 25(3): 205-218.

[51] Nearing G S, Tian Y D, Gupta H V, . A Philosophical Basis for Hydrological Uncertainty. Hydrological Sciences Journal, 2016, 61(9): 1666-1678.

[52] Pakyuz-Charrier E, Giraud J, Ogarko V, . Drillhole Uncertainty Propagation for Three-Dimensional Geological Modeling Using Monte Carlo. Tectonophysics, 2018, 747/748(9): 16-39.

[53] Pakyuz-Charrier E, Lindsay M, Ogarko V, . Monte Carlo Simulation for Uncertainty Estimation on Structural Data in Implicit 3-D Geological Modeling, a Guide for Disturbance Distribution Selection and Parameterization. Solid Earth, 2018, 9(2): 385-402.

[54] Perrouty S, Lindsay M D, Jessell M W, . 3D Modeling of the Ashanti Belt, Southwest Ghana: Evidence for a Litho-Stratigraphic Control on Gold Occurrences within the Birimian Sefwi Group. Ore Geology Reviews, 2014, 63: 252-264.

[55] Shannon C E. A Mathematical Theory of Communication. Bell System Technical Journal, 1948, 27(3): 379-423.

[56] Sivia D. Skilling J. Data Analysis: A Bayesian Tutorial, 2006, Oxford: OUP Oxford

[57] Snedecor G W, Cochran W G. Statistical Methods, 1989 Eight Edition Ames, Iowa: Iowa State University Press

[58] Thiele S T, Jessell M W, Lindsay M, . The Topology of Geology 1: Topological Analysis. Journal of Structural Geology, 2016, 91: 27-38.

[59] Thore P, Shtuka A, Lecour M, . Structural Uncertainties: Determination, Management, and Applications. Geophysics, 2002, 67(3): 840-852.

[60] Truffert C, Egal E, Le Goff E, . Gravity Modellings of the Cadomian Active Margin of Northern Brittany. Tectonophysics, 2001, 331(1/2): 81-97.

[61] Viard T, Caumon G, Lévy B. Adjacent Versus Coincident Representations of Geospatial Uncertainty: Which Promote Better Decisions?. Computers & Geosciences, 2011, 37(4): 511-520.

[62] Wang H, Wellmann J F, Li Z, . A Segmentation Approach for Stochastic Geological Modeling Using Hidden Markov Random Fields. Mathematical Geosciences, 2016, 49(2): 145-177.

[63] Wei H T, Xiao K Y, Shao Y J, . Modeling-Based Mineral System Approach to Prospectivity Mapping of Stratabound Hydrothermal Deposits: A Case Study of MVT Pb-Zn Deposits in the Huayuan Area, Northwestern Hunan Province, China. Ore Geology Reviews, 2020, 120(5): 103368

[64] Wellmann J F. Uncertainties have a Meaning: Quantitative Interpretation of the Relationship between Subsurface Flow and Geological Data Quality: [Dissertation], 2011, Perth: University of Western Australia

[65] Wellmann J F, Finsterle S, Croucher A. Integrating Structural Geological Data into the Inverse Modelling Framework of ITOUGH2. Computers & Geosciences, 2014, 65 3 95-109.

[66] Wellmann J F, Horowitz F G, Schill E, . Towards Incorporating Uncertainty of Structural Data in 3D Geological Inversion. Tectonophysics, 2010, 490(3/4): 141-151.

[67] Wellmann J F, Regenauer-Lieb K. Uncertainties Have a Meaning: Information Entropy as a Quality Measure for 3-D Geological Models. Tectonophysics, 2012, 526–529(6): 207-216.

[68] Wellmann J F, Thiele S T, Lindsay M D, . Pynoddy 1.0: An Experimental Platform for Automated 3-D Kinematic and Potential Field Modelling. Geoscientific Model Development, 2016, 9(3): 1019-1035.

[69] Wu Q, Xu H, Zou X K. An Effective Method for 3D Geological Modeling with Multi-Source Data Integration. Computers & Geosciences, 2005, 31(1): 35-43.

[70] Wu Y X, Wang C Y, Wei Y. The Fine Geological Interpretation Technology Based on 3D Seismic Data. Safety in Coal Mines, 2013, 44(07): 88-90. 94 (in Chinese with English Abstract)

[71] Xiao K Y, Li N, Porwal A, . GIS-Based 3D Prospectivity Mapping: A Case Study of Jiama Copper-Polymetallic Deposit in Tibet, China. Ore Geology Reviews, 2015, 71(11): 611-632.

[72] Xue C J, Lü G X, Gao W L, . Lithofacies paleogeographic Analysis of Ore-Bearing Layers in Qingxudong period and Metallogenic Prediction in Limei Ore Field in Huayuan, Western Hunan, China. Earth Science Frontiers, 2017, 24(2): 159-175. (in Chinese with English Abstract)

[73] Yang S, Lao K. Geological Characteristics and Ore Indicators of Lead-Zinc Deposits in Northwestern Hunan, China. Geological Bulletin of China, 2007, 26(7): 899-908

[74] Yin X, Han J, Philip S Y. Truth Discovery with Multiple Conflicting Information Providers on the Web. IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering, 2008, 20(6): 796-808.

[75] Zhang B Y, Wu X B, Wang L F. Three-Dimensional Geological Modeling and the Application Cases. Contributions to Geology and Mineral Resources Research, 2013, 8(3): 344-351. (in Chinese with English Abstract)

[76] Zhang, X. Y., Peng, Y. Y., Xiong, Y. W., et al., 2013. Report of Regional Geological Survey (1:50 000) in the Huayuan District, Malichang district, Heku District, Duoxi District, People’s Republic of China. Hunan Institute of Geological Survey (in Chinese)

[77] Zhao P D. Quantitative Mineral Prediction and Deep Mineral Exploration. Earth Science Frontiers, 2007, 14(5): 1-10. (in Chinese with English Abstract)