The physics underlying Gutenberg-Richter in the earth and in the moon

Abstract

The linear Gutenberg-Richter relationship is well-established. In any region of the Earth, the logarithm of the number of earthquakes, greater than any magnitude, is proportional to magnitude. This means that the underlying physics is non-linear and not purely elastic. This nonlinear physics has not been resolved. Here we suggest that a new understanding of fluid-rock deformation provides the physics underlying Gutenberg-Richter: where the fluid-saturated microcracks in almost all in situ rocks are so closely-spaced that they verge on failure and fracture, and hence are critical-systems which impose fundamentally-new properties on conventional sub-critical geophysics. The observation of linear Gutenberg-Richter relationship in moonquakes suggests that residual fluids exist at depth in the Moon.

Keywords

critical-system / Gutenberg-Richter relationship / New Geophysics / residual fluid in moonquake / shear-wave splitting / shear-wave time-delay

References

[1] Angerer E, Crampin S, Li X Y, . Processing, Modelling, and Predicting Time-Lapse Effects of Overpressured Fluid-Injection in a Fractured Reservoir. Geophysical Journal International, 2002, 149: 267-280.

[2] Bak P. How Nature Works: The Science of Self-Organized Criticality, 1996 New York: Springer-Verlag

[3] Bak P, Tang C. Earthquakes as a Self-Organized Critical Phenomenon. Journal of Geophysical Research, 1989, 94: 15635-15637.

[4] Chen C, Rundle J B, Li H C, . Critical Point Theory of Earthquakes: Observations of Correlated and Cooperative Behavior on Earthquake Fault Systems. Geophysical Research Letters, 2006, 33 L18302

[5] Crampin S. A Review of the Effects of Crack Geometry on Wave Propagation through Aligned Cracks. Canadian Journal of Exploration Geophysics, 1993, 29: 3-17.

[6] Crampin S. The Fracture Criticality of Crustal Rocks. Geophysical Journal International, 1994, 118: 428-438.

[7] Crampin S. Calculable Fluid-Rock Interactions. Journal of the Geological Society, 1999, 156: 501-514.

[8] Crampin S. Aligned Cracks not LPO as the Cause of Mantle Anisotropy. EGS-AGU-EUG Joint Assembly, Nice 2003. Geophysical Research Abstracts, 2003, 5 00205.

[9] Crampin S, . Van Cotthem A, Charlier R, Thimus J F, . The New Geophysics: A New Understanding of Fluid-Rock Deformation. Multiphysics Coupling and Long Term Behaviour in Rock Mechanics, 2006 London: Taylor and Francis, 539-544.

[10] Crampin S. Misunderstandings in Comments and Replies about the ICEF Report, 2012

[11] Crampin S, Gao Y. Plate-Wide Deformation before the Sumatra-Andaman Earthquake. Journal of Asian Earth Science, 2012, 46: 61-69.

[12] Crampin S, Gao Y. The New Geophysics. Terra Nova, 2013, 25: 173-180.

[13] Crampin S, Kirkwood S C. Velocity Variations in Systems of Anisotropic Symmetry. J. Geophys., 1981, 49: 35-42.

[14] Crampin S, Peacock S. A Review of Shear-Wave Splitting in the Compliant Crack-Critical Anisotropic Earth. Wave Motion, 2005, 41: 59-77.

[15] Crampin S, Peacock S. A Review of the Current Understanding of Shear-Wave Splitting and Common Fallacies in Interpretation. Wave Motion, 2008, 45: 675-722.

[16] Crampin S, Zatsepin S V. Modelling the Compliance of Crustal Rock: II—Response to Temporal Changes before Earthquakes. Geophysical Journal International, 1997, 129: 495-506.

[17] Crampin S, Volti T, Stefánsson R. A Successfully Stress-Forecast Earthquake. Geophysical Journal International, 1999, 138: F1-F5.

[18] Crampin S, Volti T, Chastin S, . Indication of High Pore-Fluid Pressures in a Seismically-Active Fault Zone. Geophysical Journal International, 2002, 151: F1-F5.

[19] Crampin S, Volti T, Stefánsson R. Response to “A Statistical Evaluation of a ‘Stress-Forecast’ Erthquake” by Seher, T., Main, I. G.. Geophysical Journal International, 2004, 157: 194-199.

[20] Crampin S, Peacock S, Gao Y, . The Scatter of Time-Delays in Shear-Wave Splitting above Small Earthquakes. Geophysical Journal International, 2004, 156: 39-44.

[21] Crampin S, Gao Y, Peacock S. Stress-Forecasting (not Predicting) Earthquakes: A Paradigm Shift?. Geology, 2008, 36: 427-430.

[22] Crampin S, Gao Y, De Santis A. A Few Earthquake Conundrums Resolved. Journal of Asian Earth Science, 2013, 62: 501-509.

[23] Davies P. Davies P. The New Physics: A Synthesis. The New Physics, 1989 London: Cambridge University Press, 1-6.

[24] Duennebier F, Sutton G H. Thermal Moonquakes. Journal of Geophysical Research, 1974, 79: 4351-4363.

[25] Duennebier F, Dorman J, Lammlein D, . Meteoroid Flux from Passive Seismic Experimental Data. Proceedings, Lunar Science Conference, 1975, 6: 2417-2426.

[26] Frolich C, Nakamura Y. Possible Extra-Solar-System Cause for Certain Lunar Seismic Events. Icarus, 2006, 185: 21-28.

[27] Gao Y, Crampin S. Observations of Stress Relaxation before Earthquakes. Geophysical Journal International, 2004, 157: 578-582.

[28] Gao Y, Crampin S. Shear-Wave Splitting and Earthquake Forecasting. Terra Nova, 2008, 20: 440-448.

[29] Geller R J. Earthquake Prediction: A Critical Review. Geophysical Journal International, 1997, 131: 425-450.

[30] Geller R J, Jackson D D, Kagan Y Y, . Earthquakes cannot be Predicted. Science, 1997, 275: 1616-1623.

[31] Gutenberg B, Richter C F. Magnitude and Energy of Earthquakes. Annali di Geofisica, 1956, 9: 1-15.

[32] Hauri E H, Saal A E, Rutherford M J, . Volatile Content of Lunar Volcanic Glasses and the Volatile Depletion of the Moon. Proceedings of 45th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference, 2014

[33] Lammlein D R, Latham G V, Dorman J, . Lunar Seismicity, Structure, and Tectonics. Reviews of Geophysics and Space Physics, 1974, 12: 1-21.

[34] Li S, Milliken R E. Quantitative Mapping of Hydration in Lunar Pyroclaswtic Deposits: Insights into Water from the Lunar Interior. Proceedings of 45th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference, 2014

[35] Lorenz E N. Predictability: Does the Flap of a Butterfly’s Wings in Brazil Set off a Tornado in Texas?. Proceedings of 139th Annual Meeting, 1972 Washington D.C: American Association of Advances in Science

[36] Main I G, Peacock S, Meredith P G. Scattering Attenuation and the Fractal Geometry of Fracture Systems. Pure and Applied Geophysics, 1990, 133: 283-304.

[37] Nakamura Y. Shallow Moonquakes: How They Compare with Earthquakes. Proceedings, Lunar Science Conference, 1980, 11: 1847-1853.

[38] Nakamura Y. New Identification of Deep Moonquakes in the Apollo Lunar Seismic Data. Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors, 2003, 139: 197-205.

[39] Nakamura Y. Farside Deep Moonquakes and Deep Interior of the Moon. Journal of Geophysical Research, 2005, 110 E01001.

[40] Nakamura Y, Latham G V, Dorman H J. Apollo Lunar Seismic Experiment-Final Summary. Journal of Geophysical Research, 1982, 87: A117-A123.

[41] Oberst J. Unusually High Stress Drops Associated with Shallow Moonquakes. Journal of Geophysical Research, 1987, 92: 1397-1405.

[42] Oberst J, Nakamura Y. A Search for Clustering among the Meteoroid Impacts Detected by the Apollo Lunar Seismic Network. Icarus, 1991, 91: 315-325.

[43] Richter C F. Elementary Seismology, 1958 San Francisco: W. H. Freeman and Co.

[44] Robinson K L, Barnes J J, Tartèse R, . Primitive Lunar Water in Evolved Rocks?. Proceedings of 45th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference, 2014

[45] Rundle J B, Turcotte D L, Shcherbakov R, . Statistical Physics Approach to Understanding the Multiscale Dynamics of Earthquake Fault Systems. Reviews of Geophysics, 2003, 41(4): 1-30.

[46] Saal A E, Hauri E H, Casio M L, . Volatile Content of Lunar Volcanic Glasses and the Presence of Water in the Moon’s Interior. Nature, 2008, 454: 192-195.

[47] Savage M K. Seismic Anisotropy and Mantle Deformation: What Have We Learned from Shear Wave Splitting?. Reviews of Geophysics, 1999, 37: 65-106.

[48] Tartèse R, Barnes J J, Anand M, . Water Content and Hydrocarbon Isotropic Composition of Apatite in KREEP and High-Al Mare Basalts: New Perspectives of Water in the Moon. Proceedings of 45th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference, 2014

[49] Turcotte D L. Fractal and Chaos in Geology and Geophysics, 1992 London: Cambridge University Press

[50] Volti T, Crampin S. A Four-Year Study of Shear-Wave Splitting in Iceland: 2. Temporal Changes before Earthquakes and Volcanic Eruptions. New Insights into Structural Interpretation and Modelling, 2003, 212: 135-149.