Seismic analysis of semi-gravity RC cantilever retaining wall with TDA backfill

Abstract

The seismic behavior of Tire Derived Aggregate (TDA) used as backfill material of 6.10 m high retaining walls was investigated based on nonlinear time-history Finite Element Analysis (FEA). The retaining walls were semi-gravity reinforced concrete cantilever type. In the backfill, a 2.74 m thick conventional soil layer was placed over a 3.06 m thick TDA layer. For comparison purpose, a conventional all soil-backfill model was also developed, and the analysis results from the two models under the Northridge and Takatori earthquakes were compared. The FEA results showed that both models did not experience major damage in the backfill under the Northridge earthquake. However, under the Takatori earthquake, the TDA-backfill model developed substantially large displacement in the retaining walls and in the backfill compared with the soil-backfill model. Regions of large plastic strain were mainly formed in the TDA layer, and the soil over the TDA layer did not experience such large plastic strain, suggesting less damage than the soil-backfill model. In addition, the acceleration on the backfill surface of the TDA-backfill model decreased substantially compared with the soil-backfill model. If an acceleration sensitive structure is placed on the surface of the backfill, the TDA backfill may induce less damage to it.

Keywords

TDA (Tire Derived Aggregate) / scrap tires / retaining wall / seismic analysis / Finite Element Analysis

References

[1] RMA.  U.S. Scrap Tire Management Summary.  Rubber Manufacturers Association,  2013

[2] Basel Convention.  Technical guidelines for the environmentally sound management of used and waste pneumatic tyres,  2011

[3] ETRMA.  End of life tyres: A valuable resource with growing potential.  European Tyre and Rubber Manufacturers' Association,  2011

[4] WBCSD.  End-of-Life Tires (ELTs): a Framework for Effective Management Systems.  World Business Council for Sustainable Development,  2010

[5] Humphrey  D N.  Scrap tires in local construction projects.  In: Where the Rubber Meets the Road.  2004

[6] ASTM.  ASTM Standard D6270: Standard Practice for Use of Scrap Tires in Civil Engineering Applications.  West Conshohocken, PA: ASTM International,  2008

[7] Ahn  I S,  Cheng  L,  Fox  P,  Wright  J,  Patenaude  S,  Fujii  B.  Material properties of large-size Tire Derived Aggregate for civil engineering applications.  Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering,  2015,  27( 9):  04014258

[8] Humphrey  D N.  Civil engineering applications of tire shreds.  In: The Tire Industry Conference. Hilton Head, SC,  1999

[9] Lee  H,  Roh  H.  The use of recycled tire chips to minimize dynamic earth pressure during compaction of backfill.  Construction & Building Materials,  2007,  21( 5):  1016– 1026

[10] Dodson  T.  Camas Valley-Nuns Creek, Highway 35 Landslide: Plans, Construction Sequencing and Staging.  Oregon State Highway Division, Geotechnical Group,  1990

[11] Edil  T B,  Bosscher  P J,  Eldin  N N.  Development of Engineering Criteria for Shredded or Whole Tires in Highway Applications (Interim Report).  Wisconsin Department of Transportation,  1990

[12] Geisler  E,  Cody  W K,  Niemi  M K.  Tires for subgrade support.  In: Annual Conference on Forest Engineering. Coeur D’Alene, ID,  1989

[13] Humphrey  D N.  Specifications- Test section, Tire chip fill as insulation, Richmond, Maine.  Dept. of Civil Eng., University of Maine: Orono, Maine,  1992

[14] Kasampalis  T,  Perkoulidis  G,  Karagiannidis  A. Sensitivity Analysis of Different Construction, Financial and Logistics Schemes.  Laboratory of Heat Transfer and Environmental Engineering, Aristotle University Thessaloniki,  2011

[15] Humphrey  D N.  Tire derived aggregate as lightweight fill for embankments and retaining walls.  In: Hazarika, Yasuhara, eds. Scrap Tire Derived Geomaterials- Opportunities and Challenges.  London: Taylor & Francis Group,  2008

[16] Humphrey  D N,  Whetten  N,  Weaver  J,  Recker  K,  Cosgrove  T A.  TDA as lightweight fill for embankments and retaining walls.  In: Recycled Materials in Geotechnical Applications. ASCE,  1998

[17] Nelson  B E.  Using tire chips for roadway embankment fill.  In: N.Y. State TDA Workshop,  2009

[18] Whetten  N,  Weaver  J,  Humphrey  D N,  Stanford  T.  Rubber meets the road in Maine.  Civil Engineering (New York, N.Y.),  1997,  67( 9):  60– 63

[19] Reid  R A,  Soupir  S P.  Mitigation of void development under bridge approach slabs using rubber tire chips.  In: Recycled Materials in Geotechnical Applications, ASCE,  1998

[20] Tatlisoz  N,  Edil  T B,  Benson  C H.  Interaction between reinforcing geosynthetics and soil-tire chip mixtures.  Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering,  1998,  124( 11):  1109– 1119

[21] Tweedie  J J,  Humphrey  D N,  Sandford  T C.  Tire shreds as lightweight retaining wall backfill: active conditions.  Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering,  1998,  124( 11):  1061– 1070

[22] Tweedie  J J,  Humphrey  D N,  Stanford  T C.  Full scale field trials of tire chips as lightweight retaining wall backfill, at-rest conditions.  In: Transportation Research Record 1619. Transportation Research Board,  1998,  64– 71

[23] Humphrey  D N,  Eaton  R A.  Field performance of tire chips as subgrade insulation for rural roads.  In: the Sixth International Conference on Low-Volume Roads. Transportation Research Board,  1995

[24] Lawrence  B,  Humphrey  D N,  Chen  L H.  Field trial of tire shreds as insulation for paved roads.  In: The Tenth International Conference on Cold Regions Engineering: Putting Research into Practice. ASCE,  1999

[25] Wolfe  S L,  Humphrey  D N,  Wetzel  E A.  Development of tire shred underlayment to reduce groundborn vibrations from LTR track.  In: GeoTrans 2004. ASCE,  2004

[26] Jesionek  K S,  Humphrey  D N,  Dunn  R J.  Overview of shredded tire applications in landfills.  In: Tire Industry Conference. Clemson Univ., South Carolina,  1998

[27] Park  J K,  Edil  T B,  Kim  J Y,  Huh  M,  Lee  S H,  Lee  J J.  Suitability of shredded tires as a substitute for a landfill leachate collection medium.  Waste Management & Research,  2003,  21( 3):  278– 289

[28] Lassiter  A.  Septic system trench TDA-a national overview.  In: New York State TDA Workshop,  2009

[29] Zicari  L.  New York state Tire Derived Aggregate program.  In: New York State TDA Workshop,  2009

[30] Tweedie  J J,  Humphrey  D N,  Sandford  T C.  Tire shreds as lightweight retaining wall backfill: active conditions.  Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering,  1998,  124( 11):  1061– 1070

[31] Ahn  I S,  Cheng  L.  Tire Derived Aggregate for retaining wall backfill under earthquake loading.  Construction & Building Materials,  2014,  57:  105– 116

[32] Mock  E,  Cheng  L.  Performance of retaining walls with and without sound wall under seismic load. Earthquakes and Structures.  2015,  7( 6):  909– 935

[33] Caltrans.  Revised Standard Plan RSP B3-1A, in Retaining Wall Type 1 (Case 1).  Sacramento, CA: California Department of Transportation,  2012

[34] Caltrans.  Bridge Design Specifications.  Sacramento, CA: California Department of Transportation,  2004

[35] Mualchin  L.  Seismic hazard assessment for bridge engineering in California.  In: the 13th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering.  Vancouver, B.C., Canada,  2004

[36] Humphrey  D N.  Civil Engineering Applications Using Tire Derived Aggregate (TDA).  California Integrated Waste Management Board,  2003

[37] Ahn  I S,  Cheng  L.  Retaining Wall Shake-Table Test and Design using Tire Derived Aggregates as Backfill.  California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery; California Department of Transportation.  University of California-Davis,  2014