Confined masonry as practical seismic construction alternative–the experience from the 2014 Cephalonia Earthquake

Abstract

During August 1953 three strong earthquakes of magnitude ranging from 6.3 to 7.2 shook the Ionian Island of Cephalonia (Kefalonia), Greece, and destroyed almost the entire building stock of the Island which consisted primarily of traditional unreinforced masonry (URM) houses. The authorities went on to restructuring of the building stock, using a structural system that is most like what is known today as confined masonry. They designed about 14 types of one- to two-storey buildings providing the engineers with detailed construction plans. These buildings are known as “Arogi” buildings (Arogi in Greek meaning Aid). On the 24th of January and 3rd of February 2014, two earthquakes of magnitude 6.1 and 6.0 struck the island, causing significant soil damages, developing excessively high ground accelerations. Surprisingly, no damage was reported in the “Arogi” buildings. The seismic behavior of the buildings is examined by FEM linear analysis and it is compared to that of URM structures. Computed results illustrate that the displacements of identical URM buildings would be about twice the magnitudes observed in the corresponding “Arogi” ones, with the implication that the earthquake sequence of 2014 would have caused critical damage should the type of structure be of the URM type. Furthermore, it is illustrated that this low cost alternative method of construction is a very effective means of producing earthquake resilient structures, whereas further reduction of seismic displacement may be achieved in the order of 50% with commensurate effects on damage potential, when reinforced slabs are used to replace the timber roofs.

Keywords

Cephalonia / confined masonry / comparative FEM analysis / unreinforced masonry / seismic damage

References

[1] Scordilis E M, Karakaisis G F, Karakostas B G, Panagiotopoulos D G, Comninakis P E, Papazachos B C. Evidence for Transform Faulting in the Ionian Sea: the Cephalonia Island Earthquake Sequence of 1983. Pure and Applied Geophysics, 1985, 123(3): 388–397

[2] Louvari E, Kiratzi A A, Papazachos B C. The CTF and its extension to western Lefkada Island. Tectonophysics, 1999, 308: 223–236

[3] Sachpazi M, Hirn A, Clément C, Haslinger F, Laigle M, Kissling E, Charvis P, Hello Y, Lépine J C, Sapin M, Ansorge J. Western Hellenic subduction and Cephalonia Transform: local earthquakes and plate transport and strain. Tectonophysics, 2000, 319(4): 301–319

[4] Pérouse E, Chamot-Rooke N, Rabaute A, Briole P, Jouanne F, Georgiev I, Dimitrov D. Bridging onshore and offshore present-day kinematics of central and eastern Mediterranean: Implications for crustal dynamics and mantle flow. Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems, 2012, 13(9): 371–387

[5] Ganas A, Elias P, Bozionelos G, Papathanassiou G, Avallone A, Papastergios A, Valkaniotis S, Parcharidis I, Briole P. Coseismic deformation, field observations and seismic fault of the 17 November 2015M=6.5, Lefkada Island, Greece earthquake. Tectonophysics, 2016, 687: 210–222

[6] Papaioannou Chr. Report of Institute of Engineering Seismology and Earthquake EngineeringResearch and Technical Institute, Strong Ground Motion Of The February 3, 2014 (in Greek)

[7] Karastathis V K, Mouzakiotis E, Ganas A, Papadopoulos G A. High-precision relocation of seismic sequences above a dipping Moho: the case of the January–February 2014 seismic sequence on Cephalonia island (Greece). Solid Earth, 2015, 6(1): 173–184

[8] Boncori M J P, Papoutsis I, Pezzo G, Tolomei C, Atzori S, Ganas A, Karastathis V, Salvi S, Kontoes C, Antonioli A. 2015, The February 2014 Cephalonia Earthquake (Greece): 3D Deformation Field and Source Modeling from Multiple SAR Techniques. Seismological Research Letters, 2015, 86(1): 124–137

[9] Valkaniotis S, Ganas A, Papathanassiou G, Papanikolaou M. Field observations of geological effects triggered by the January–February 2014 Cephalonia (Ionian Sea, Greece) earthquakes. Tectonophysics, 2014, 630: 150–157

[10] Papathanassiou G, Ganas A, Valkaniotis S. Recurrent liquefaction-induced failures triggered by 2014 Cephalonia, Greece earthquakes: Spatial distribution and quantitative analysis of liquefaction potential. Engineering Geology, 2016, 200: 18–30

[11] Pavlatos D. 1988, Coram Populo, Editor Municipality of Argostoli, Greece

[12] Tomaževič M, Klemenc I. Seismic behaviour of confined masonry walls. Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 1997, 26(10): 1059–1071

[13] Astroza M, Moroni O, Salinas C. Seismic behavior qualification methodology for confined masonry buildings. In: Proceedings of the 12th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, 2000, 1123–1124

[14] Astroza M, Moroni O, Brzev S, Tanner J. Seismic performance of engineered masonry buildings in the 2010 Maule Earthquake. Earthquake Spectra, 2012, 28(S1 No. S1): S385–S406

[15] Brzev S N. Earthquake-resistant confined masonry construction, national information center of earthquake engineering. Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, 2007

[16] Karantoni F B, Fardis M N, Vintzileou E, Harisis A. Effectiveness of Seismic Strengthening Interventions. In: Proceedings of the International Conference on Structural Preservation of the Architectural Heritage, Rome, 1993, 549–556

[17] EN 1996–1-1, 2005. Eurocode 6: Design of Masonry Structures- Part 1–1: General Rules for Reinforced and Unreinforced. Masonry Structures. Europ. Comm. for Standardization: Brussels

[18] EN 1998–3:2020:E. Eurocode 8, Design of Structures for Earthquake Resistance- Part 3: Assessment and retrofitting of Buildings, Brussels: European Committee for Standardization. Brussels

[19] Theodoulidis N, Karakostas Ch, Lekidis V, Makra K, Margaris B, Morfidis K, Papaioannou Ch, Rovithis E, Salonikios T, Savvaidis A. The Cephalonia, Greece, January 26 (M6.1) and February 3, 2014 (M6.0) earthquakes: near-fault ground motion and effects on soil and structures. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2016, 14(1): 1–38

[20] Clough R.W., Penzien J. Dynamics of Structures, New York: Mc Graw Hill, 1975

[21] Karantoni F, Papadopoulos M, Pantazopoulou S J. Simple seismic assessment of traditional unreinforced masonry buildings. International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 2016, 10(8): 1055–1077

[22] Karantoni F.V., Pantazopoulou S. J. Criteria guiding seismic upgrading of traditional masonry buildings. In: Proceedings 12th Canadian Masonry Symposium, Vancouver, 2013

[23] Pardalopoulos S, Pantazopoulou S J, Ignatakis Ch. 2016, “Practical seismic assessment of unreinforced masonry historical buildings. Earthquakes and Structures, 2016, 11(2): 195–215

[24] Marques R, Lourenço P B. Possibilities and comparison of structural component models for the seismic assessment of modern unreinforced masonry buildings. Computers & Structures, 2011, 89(21–22): 2079–2091

[25] Page A W. The biaxial compressive strength of brick masonry. Proceedings- Institution of Civil Engineers, 1981, 71(Part 2): 893–906

[26] Page A W. The strength of brick masonry under biaxial tension-compression. Int J of Mason Constr, 1983, 3(1): 26–31

[27] Ganz H R, Thurlimann B. Test on the biaxial strength of masonry. Report No. 7502–3 Institute of Structural Engineering, Zurich, 1982

[28] Mann W, Müller H. Nachrechnung der Wandversuche mit einem erweiterten Schubbruchmodell unter Berücksichtigung der Spannungen in den Stossfugen, Anlage 2 zum Forschungsbericht: Untersuchungen zum Tragverhalten von Mauerwersbauten unter Erdbebeneinwirkung, T.H. Darmstadt, 1986

[29] Lourenço P B, Rots J G. A multi-surface model for the analysis of masonry structures. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 1997, 123(7): 660–668

[30] Ottosen N. A failure criterion for concrete. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 1977, 103(4): 527–535

[31] Grünthal G. European Macroseismic Scale 1998 (EMS-98). Centre Européen de Géodynamique et de Séismologie, Luxembourg, Luxembourg, 1998

[32] Karantoni F, Tsionis G, Lyrantzaki F, Fardis M N. Seismic Fragility of regular masonry buildings for in-plane and out-of-plane failure. Earthquakes and Structures, 2014, 6(6): 689–713

[33] Marques R, Lourenço P B. Unreinforced and confined masonry buildings in seismic regions: Validation of macro-element models and cost analysis. Engineering Structures, 2014, 64: 52–67

Acknowledgements

We thank Sotirios Valkaniotis for providing Fig. 1.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2017 Higher Education Press and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg