Cerebral organoids and organoid intelligence: ethical challenges and governance pathway

References

[1] Bitar M , Barry G . Building a Human Brain for Research. Front Mol Neurosci 2020; 13(22): 22

[2] Bi FC , Yang XH , Cheng XY , Deng WB , Guo XL , Yang H , Wang Y , Li J , Yao Y . Optimization of cerebral organoids: a more qualified model for Alzheimer’s disease research. Transl Neurodegener 2021; 10(1): 27

[3] Lancaster MA , Knoblich JA . Generation of cerebral organoids from human pluripotent stem cells. Nat Protoc 2014; 9(10): 2329–2340

[4] Blue R , Miranda SP , Gu BJ , Chen HI . A primer on human brain organoids for the neurosurgeon. Neurosurgery 2020; 87(4): 620–629

[5] Giandomenico SL , Lancaster MA . Probing human brain evolution and development in organoids. Curr Opin Cell Biol 2017; 44: 36–43

[6] Smirnova L , Morales Pantoja IE , Hartung T . Organoid intelligence (OI)—the ultimate functionality of a brain microphysiological system. ALTEX 2023; 40(2): 191–203

[7] Smirnova L , Caffo BS , Gracias DH , Huang Q , Morales Pantoja IE , Tang B , Zack DJ , Berlinicke CA , Boyd JL , Harris TD , Johnson EC , Kagan BJ , Kahn J , Muotri AR , Paulhamus BL , Schwamborn JC , Plotkin J , Szalay AS , Vogelstein JT , Worley PF , Hartung T . Organoid intelligence (OI): the new frontier in biocomputing and intelligence-in-a-dish. Front Sci 2023; 1: 1017235

[8] Cai H , Ao Z , Tian C , Wu Z , Liu H , Tchieu J , Gu M , Mackie K , Guo F . Brain organoid reservoir computing for artificial intelligence. Nat Electron 2023; 6(12): 1032–1039

[9] Gao X , Wang Y , Chen X , Gao S . Interface, interaction, and intelligence in generalized brain-computer interfaces. Trends Cogn Sci 2021; 25(8): 671–684

[10] Lavazza A , Reichlin M . Human brain organoids: why there can be moral concerns if they grow up in the lab and are transplanted or destroyed. Camb Q Healthc Ethics 2023; 32(4): 582–596

[11] McKeown A . Cerebral organoid research ethics and pinning the tail on the donkey. Camb Q Healthc Ethics 2023; 32(4): 1–13

[12] Kataoka M , Gyngell C , Savulescu J , Sawai T . The donation of human biological material for brain organoid research: The problems of consciousness and consent. Sci Eng Ethics 2024; 30(1): 3

[13] Lavazza A , Chinaia AA . Human cerebral organoids: the ethical stance of scientists. Stem Cell Res Ther 2023; 14(1): 59

[14] Lavazza A . What (or sometimes who) are organoids? And whose are they. J Med Ethics 2019; 45(2): 144–145

[15] Gulimiheranmu M , Li S , Zhou J . In vitro recapitulation of neuropsychiatric disorders with pluripotent stem cells-derived brain organoids. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2021; 18(23): 12431

[16] Wadan AS . Organoid intelligence and biocomputing advances: current steps and future directions. Brain Organoid Syst Neurosci J. 2025; 3: 8–14

[17] Kaye J , Whitley EA , Lund D , Morrison M , Teare H , Melham K . Dynamic consent: a patient interface for twenty-first century research networks. Eur J Hum Genet 2015; 23(2): 141–146

[18] Agrafiotis I Creese S Goldsmith M Formalising requirements for a biobank case study using a logic for consent and revocation. In: Camenisch J, Crispo B, Fischer-Hübner S, Leenes R, Russello G. Privacy and Identity Management for Life. Privacy and Identity 2011. IFIP Advances in Information and Communication Technology, vol 375. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. 232–244

[19] Mamo N , Martin GM , Desira M , Ellul B , Ebejer JP . Dwarna: a blockchain solution for dynamic consent in biobanking. Eur J Hum Genet 2020; 28(5): 609–626

[20] Budin-Ljøsne I , Teare HJ , Kaye J , Beck S , Bentzen HB , Caenazzo L , Collett C , D’Abramo F , Felzmann H , Finlay T , Javaid MK , Jones E , Katić V , Simpson A , Mascalzoni D . Dynamic consent: a potential solution to some of the challenges of modern biomedical research. BMC Med Ethics 2017; 18(1): 4

[21] Prictor M , Teare HJA , Kaye J . Equitable participation in biobanks: the risks and benefits of a “dynamic consent” approach. Front Public Health 2018; 6: 253

[22] Li S , Wang M , Zhou J . Brain organoids: a promising living biobank resource for neuroscience research. Biopreserv Biobank 2020; 18(2): 136–143

[23] Munsie M , Hyun I , Sugarman J . Ethical issues in human organoid and gastruloid research. Development 2017; 144(6): 942–945

[24] Urzì O , Gasparro R , Costanzo E , De Luca A , Giavaresi G , Fontana S , Alessandro R . Three-dimensional cell cultures: the bridge between in vitro and in vivo models. Int J Mol Sci 2023; 24(15): 12046

[25] Kataoka MTS . The ethical and legal challenges of human foetal brain tissue-derived organoids: at the intersection of science, ethics, and regulation. EMBO Rep 2024; 25(4): 1700–1703

[26] Prasad M , Kumar R , Buragohain L , Kumari A , Ghosh M . Organoid technology: a reliable developmental biology tool for organ-specific nanotoxicity evaluation. Front Cell Dev Biol 2021; 9: 696668

[27] Lancaster MA , Renner M , Martin CA , Wenzel D , Bicknell LS , Hurles ME , Homfray T , Penninger JM , Jackson AP , Knoblich JA . Cerebral organoids model human brain development and microcephaly. Nature 2013; 501(7467): 373–379

[28] Fair SR , Julian D , Hartlaub AM , Pusuluri ST , Malik G , Summerfied TL , Zhao G , Hester AB , Ackerman WE IV , Hollingsworth EW , Ali M , McElroy CA , Buhimschi IA , Imitola J , Maitre NL , Bedrosian TA , Hester ME . Electrophysiological maturation of cerebral organoids correlates with dynamic morphological and cellular development. Stem Cell Reports 2020; 15(4): 855–868

[29] Diner S . Potential consciousness of human cerebral organoids: on similarity-based views in precautionary discourse. Neuroethics 2023; 16: 23

[30] Niikawa T , Hayashi Y , Shepherd J , Sawai T . Human brain organoids and consciousness. Neuroethics 2022; 15: 5

[31] Jeziorski E , J L , Brandt C , R AR . Brain organoids, consciousness, ethics and moral status. Brain organoids, consciousness, ethics and moral status. Semin Cell Dev Biol 2023; 144: 97–102

[32] Montoya I , Montoya D . What is it like to be a brain organoid? phenomenal consciousness in a biological neural network. Entropy (Basel) 2023; 25(9): 1328

[33] Koplin JJ . Weighing the moral status of brain organoids and research animals. Bioethics 2024; 38(5): 410–418

[34] Hayashi Y , Sato R . The unity of consciousness and the practical ethics of neural organoid research. Neuroethics 2025; 18: 3

[35] Boyd JL , Lipshitz N . Dimensions of consciousness and the moral status of brain organoids. Neuroethics 2024; 17: 5

[36] Bayne T , Seth AK , Massimini M . Are there islands of awareness. Trends Neurosci 2020; 43(1): 6–16

[37] Arnason G , Pichl A , Ranisch R . Ethical issues in cerebral organoid research. Camb Q Healthc Ethics 2023; 32(4): 515–517

[38] Lavazza A. . Potential ethical problems with human cerebral organoids: consciousness and moral status of future brains in a dish. Brain Res 2021; 1750: 147146

[39] Owen M , Hight D , Hudetz AG . Human brain organoids and the mereological fallacy. Neuroethics 2025; 18(1): 8

[40] Sawai T , Sakaguchi H , Thomas E , Takahashi J , Fujita M . The ethics of cerebral organoid research: being conscious of consciousness. Stem Cell Reports 2019; 13(3): 440–447

[41] Nuffield Council on Bioethics. Neural organoids in research: ethical considerations [Policy briefing]. 2024

[42] Revah O , Gore F , Kelley KW , Andersen J , Sakai N , Chen X , Li MY , Birey F , Yang X , Saw NL , Baker SW , Amin ND , Kulkarni S , Mudipalli R , Cui B , Nishino S , Grant GA , Knowles JK , Shamloo M , Huguenard JR , Deisseroth K , Pașca SP . Maturation and circuit integration of transplanted human cortical organoids. Nature 2022; 610(7930): 319–326

[43] Trujillo CAGao RNegraes PDGu JBuchanan JPreissl SWang AWu WHaddad GGChaim IADomissy AVandenberghe MDevor AYeo GWVoytek BMuotri AR. Complex oscillatory waves emerging from cortical organoids model early human brain network development. Cell Stem Cell 2019; 25(4): 558–569.e7

[44] Koplin J , Massie J . Lessons from Frankenstein 200 years on: brain organoids, chimaeras and other ‘monsters’. J Med Ethics 2021; 47(8): 567–571

[45] Barnhart AJ , Dierickx K . A tale of two chimeras: applying the six principles to human brain organoid xenotransplantation. Camb Q Healthc Ethics 2023; 32(4): 555–571

[46] Erler A . Human brain organoid transplantation: testing the foundations of animal research ethics. Neuroethics 2024; 17: 20

[47] Kataoka M , Gyngell C , Savulescu J , Sawai T . The ethics of human brain organoid transplantation in animals. Neuroethics 2023; 16: 27

[48] Tanibe T , Watanabe T , Oguchi M , Iijima K , Ota K . The psychological process underlying attitudes toward human-animal chimeric brain research: an empirical investigation. Neuroethics 2024; 17: 15

[49] Shriver AJ , John TM . Neuroethics and animals: report and recommendations from the university of pennsylvania animal research neuroethics workshop. ILAR J 2019; 60(3): 424–433

[50] Savulescu J , Sawai T . Animus: human-embodied animals. J Med Ethics 2024; 50(11): 725–728

[51] Chen HI , Wolf JA , Blue R , Song MM , Moreno JD , Ming G , Song H . Transplantation of human brain organoids: Revisiting the science and ethics of brain chimeras. Cell Stem Cell 2019; 25(4): 462–472

[52] Kagan BJ , Kitchen AC , Tran NT , Habibollahi F , Khajehnejad M , Parker BJ , Bhat A , Rollo B , Razi A , Friston KJ . In vitro neurons learn and exhibit sentience when embodied in a simulated game-world. Neuron 2022; 110(23): 3952–3969.e8

[53] Haselager DR , Boers SN , Jongsma KR , Vinkers CH , Broekman ML , Bredenoord AL . Breeding brains? Patients’ and laymen’s perspectives on cerebral organoids. Regen Med 2020; 15(12): 2351–2360

[54] Milford SR , Shaw D , Starke G . Playing brains: the ethical challenges posed by silicon sentience and hybrid intelligence in dishbrain. Sci Eng Ethics 2023; 29(6): 38

[55] Wu X , Chen Y , Kreutz A , Silver B , Tokar EJ . Pluripotent stem cells for target organ developmental toxicity testing. Toxicol Sci 2024; 199(2): 163–171

[56] Ballav SRanjan ASur SBasu S Organoid intelligence: bridging artificial intelligence for biological computing and neurological insights. In: Basu S, Ranjan A, Sur S. Technologies in Cell Culture—A Journey from Basics to Advanced Applications. IntechOpen, 2024

[57] Presley A , Samsa LA , Dubljević V . Media portrayal of ethical and social issues in brain organoid research. Philos Ethics Humanit Med 2022; 17: 8

[58] Kataoka M , Lee TL , Sawai T . The legal personhood of human brain organoids. J Law Biosci 2023; 10(1): lsad007

[59] Ide K , Matsuoka N , Fujita M . Ethical aspects of brain organoid research in news reports: an exploratory descriptive analysis. Medicina (Kaunas) 2021; 57(6): 532

[60] Villanueva II , Eom D , Cate AR , Krause NM , Scheufele DA , Brossard D . Emerging debates about breakthrough science: Understanding the interplay of values and cognition in shaping attitudes on human brain organoids. Sci Commun 2025; 47(5): 599–632

[61] Julian K , Yuhasz N , Hollingsworth E , Imitola J . The “growing” reality of the neurological complications of global “stem cell tourism”. Semin Neurol 2018; 38(2): 176–181

[62] Wolff H . Patentability of brain organoids derived from iPSC—a legal evaluation with interdisciplinary aspects. Neuroethics 2024; 17: 7

[63] Organisation for Economic Co-operationDevelopment . Recommendation of the council on responsible innovation in neurotechnology. OECD Publishing. 2019

[64] ISSCR . ISSCR Guidelines for Stem Cell Research and Clinical Translation. 2021

[65] Jongsma KR , Bredenoord AL . Ethics parallel research: an approach for (early) ethical guidance of biomedical innovation. BMC Med Ethics 2020; 21(1): 81

[66] Blumenthal-Barby J . Rethinking theory in bioethics. Hastings Cent Rep 2022; 52(4): 44–45

[67] China Ethical Guidelines for Human Organoid Research. 2025

[68] Han YP , Fan LL , Xue Y . A sustainable balance between innovation and risk: how the “right to science” affects China’s medical biotechnology regulatory policy. Comput Struct Biotechnol J 2024; 24: 306–313

[69] Nuffield Council on Bioethics. Research using neural organoids: ethical considerations [Policy briefing note]. 2024

[70] Farahany NA , Greely HT , Hyman S , Koch C , Grady C , Pașca SP , Sestan N , Arlotta P , Bernat JL , Ting J , Lunshof JE , Iyer EPR , Hyun I , Capestany BH , Church GM , Huang H , Song H . The ethics of experimenting with human brain tissue. Nature 2018; 556(7702): 429–432

[71] Oh SA , Kim EY . Organoid global regulatory policy: a cross-sectional study. Drug Targets and Therapeutics. 2024; 3(2): 169–176

[72] Ersdal G , Aven T . Risk informed decision-making and its ethical basis. Reliab Eng Syst Saf 2008; 93(2): 197–205

[73] National Institutes of Health. NIH guidelines on human stem cell research. U. S. Department of Health and Human Services. 2009

[74] Miura Y , Li MY , Revah O , Yoon SJ , Narazaki G , Pașca SP . Engineering brain assembloids to interrogate human neural circuits. Nat Protoc 2022; 17(1): 15–35

[75] Qian X , Song H , Ming GL . Brain organoids: advances, applications and challenges. Development 2019; 146(8): dev166074

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Higher Education Press