Punching test for mechanical characterization of asphalt railway sub-ballast

Abstract

The use of asphalt mixtures for sub-ballast layers in railway infrastructure, which is becoming a preferred design solution in in the high-speed and high-capacity lines in some European countries and in the United States, offers several structural, functional and economic benefits. The assessment of physical–mechanical characteristics of these mixtures still occurs with methods that are well-established in the road paving industry, though these methods are not consistently capable of highlighting the peculiarities of the railway operations, such as the ballast/sub-ballast interaction and the granular behavior of the overlying unbound layer. Specifically, the interface between the crushed stone elements of the ballast bed and the underlying asphalt layer deserves specific attention. Thus, this study presents a new conceived experimental method for the mechanical characterization of mixes intended for asphalt sub-ballast, based on punching test. The test employs an adaptive indentation plate (AIP), which was designed to replicate the interaction between ballast particles and the sub-ballast. Cylindrical asphalt specimens (ϕ150 mm) were subjected to vertical point loads using the AIP, considering different temperatures (5, 20, 35 °C) and deformation rates (5.08, 25.4, 50.8 mm/min). The validation of the experimental procedure involved the analysis of two asphalt mixes of different stiffness, which conformed to the Italian standard for asphalt sub-ballast. The results showed that the punching test offers an effective evaluation of resistance to plastic deformation and additional information on the indentation phenomenon, which is not currently considered in existing specifications. This approach could be used alongside standard tests to better evaluate the performance of different materials in railway sub-ballast applications.

Keywords

Bituminous sub-ballast / Asphalt indentation / Track stability / Ballasted track / Railway maintenance

References

[1] Buonanno A, Mele R (2000) The use of bituminous mix sub-ballast in the Italian state railways. In: Proceedings of the papers submitted for review at 2nd Eurasphalt and Eurobitume Congress. Barcelona, pp 203–211

[2] European Asphalt Pavement Association (2021) Asphalt in railway tracks asphalt in railway tracks EAPA technical review. Breukelen

[3] Xiao X, Cai D, Lou L, et al. . Application of asphalt based materials in railway systems: a review. Constr Build Mater. 2021, 304 124630

[4] La Placa A, Autelitano F, Neduzha L, et al. . Roles and functions of asphalt sub-ballast in the modern maintenance of the European railways. Int J Transp Sci Technol. 2025

[5] Ramirez Cardona D, Di BH, Sauzeat C, et al. . Designs, application and performances of asphalt/bituminous trackbeds in European, Asian, and African countries. Transp Res Rec. 2020, 2674(11): 245-262

[6] Indraratna B, Singh M, Nguyen TT. The mechanism and effects of subgrade fluidisation under ballasted railway tracks. Railw Eng Sci. 2020, 28(2): 113-128

[7] Rete Ferroviaria Italiana (2020) RFI DTC SI CS SP IFS 009 E: Capitolato generale tecnico di appalto delle opere civili. Parte II-Sezione 13. (General technical specifications for the procurement of civil works. Part II-Section 13). Rome

[8] Administrador De Infraestructuras Ferroviarias (2023) Pliego de prescripciones técnicas particulares tipo. Módulo de obra civil. Parte 2 (PPT9-0-1.0) (Specific standard technical specifications. Civil works module. Part 2). Madrid

[9] Société nationale des chemins de fer Réseau (2018) IG90260-Conception et dimensionnement des Plateformes Ferroviaires Nouvelles Pour voie ballasteé (Design and sizing of new rail platforms for ballasted track). Saint-Denis

[10] American Railway Engineering and Maintenance-of-Way Association (2017) AREMA manual for railway engineering. Lanham

[11] Suhr B, Butcher TA, Lewis R, et al. . Friction and wear in railway ballast stone interfaces. Tribol Int. 2020, 151 106498

[12] Rete Ferroviaria Italiana (2020) RFI DTC SI GE SP IFS 002 D: Capitolato tecnico di appalto delle opere civili. Parte II-Sezione 17-Pietrisco per massicciata ferroviaria (Technical specifications for the procurement of civil works. Part II-Section 17-Aggregate for railway ballast). Rome

[13] British Standards Institution (2013) Aggregates for railway ballast. BS EN 13450:2013

[14] Shi C, Fan Z, Connolly DP, et al. . Railway ballast performance: recent advances in the understanding of geometry, distribution and degradation. Transp Geotech. 2023, 41 101042

[15] Bondarenko I, Lukoševičius V, Keršys R, et al. . Innovative trends in railway condition monitoring. Transp Res Procedia. 2024, 77: 10-17

[16] Esveld C. Modern railway track. 20012Zaltbommel, MRT Productions

[17] Xu L, Sun D, Ma J, et al. . Applications of depth-sensing indentation on asphalt materials: a review. Constr Build Mater. 2021, 268 121195

[18] Hafezzadeh R, Autelitano F, Giuliani F. Performance-related methods for the characterization of cold mix patching materials used in asphalt pavements maintenance. Case Stud Constr Mater. 2023, 19: e02600

[19] Fadil H, Jelagin D, Partl MN. Spherical indentation test for quasi-non-destructive characterisation of asphalt concrete. Mater Struct. 2022, 55: 102

[20] European Organisation for Technical Assessment (EOTA) (2020) European Assessment Document (EAD) 030675-00-0107: Liquid applied bridge deck waterproofing kits

[21] Branson JM, Dersch MS, de Oliveira Lima A, et al. . Analysis of geometric ballast plate for laboratory testing of resilient track components. Transp Geotech. 2019, 20 100240

[22] Xu Y, Han H, Ning N, et al. . Ballast loading plate design and mechanical behavior of under ballast mats. Constr Build Mater. 2022, 325 126486

[23] Castillo-Mingorance JM, Sol-Sánchez M, Moreno-Navarro F, et al. . High performance bituminous sub-ballast for improving the structural behaviour and durability of railway track substructure. Mater Struct. 2021, 54: 1-15

[24] Ramón López J, Felipo J, Sánchez F et al (2013) Nuevo sistema de vía en placa bituminosa (proyecto Bituvia). New bituminous ballastless track system (Bituvia project). Madrid

[25] Guo Y, Xie J, Fan Z, et al. . Railway ballast material selection and evaluation: a review. Constr Build Mater. 2022, 344 128218

[26] Merusi F, Giuliani F. Intrinsic resistance to non-reversible deformation in modified asphalt binders and its relation with specification criteria. Constr Build Mater. 2011, 25(8): 3356-3366

[27] Blanc J, Khairallah D, Ramirez D, et al. . Monitoring of railway structures with bituminous and granular sub-layers: assessment after four years of use. Constr Build Mater. 2022, 336 127515

[28] Franesqui García MÁ, Giuliani F. New European specifications for characterising asphalt bitumens in relation to plastic deformation. Carreteras. 2007, 4: 62-74

[29] Fares A, Zayed T, Abdelkhalek S, et al. . Rutting measurement in asphalt pavements. Autom Constr. 2024, 161 105358

Funding

Project funded under the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP), Mission 4 Component 2 Investment 1.4 - Call for tender No. 3138 of 16/12/2021 of Italian Ministry of University and Research funded by the European Union – NextGenerationEU(Project code CN00000023)

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)