Simulation of wheel and rail profile wear: a review of numerical models

Abstract

The development of numerical models able to compute the wheel and rail profile wear is essential to improve the scheduling of maintenance operations required to restore the original profile shapes. This work surveys the main numerical models in the literature for the evaluation of the uniform wear of wheel and rail profiles. The standard structure of these tools includes a multibody simulation of the wheel–track coupled dynamics and a wear module implementing an experimental wear law. Therefore, the models are classified according to the strategy adopted for the worn profile update, ranging from models performing a single computation to models based on an online communication between the dynamic and wear modules. Nevertheless, the most common strategy nowadays relies on an iteration of dynamic simulations in which the profiles are left unchanged, with co-simulation techniques often adopted to increase the computational performances. Work is still needed to improve the accuracy of the current models. New experimental campaigns should be carried out to obtain refined wear coefficients and models, while strategies for the evaluation of both longitudinal and transversal wear, also considering the effects of tread braking, should be implemented to obtain accurate damage models.

References

[1.] Tunna J, Sinclair J, Perez J. A Review of wheel wear and rolling contact fatigue. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2007, 221 2 271-289

[2.] Donzella G, Faccoli M, Ghidini A, Mazzù A, Roberti R. The competitive role of wear and RCF in a rail steel. Eng Fract Mech 2005, 72 2 287-308

[3.] Piotrowski J, Chollet H. Wheel–rail contact models for vehicle system dynamics including multi–point contact. Veh Syst Dyn 2005, 43 6–7 455-483

[4.] Blanco-Lorenzo J, Santamaria J, Vadillo EG, Correa N. On the influence of conformity on wheel–rail rolling contact mechanics. Tribol Int 2016, 103 647-667

[5.] Sawley K, Wu H. The formation of hollow-worn wheels and their effect on wheel/rail interaction. Wear 2005, 258 7 1179-1186

[6.] Alizadeh Kaklar J, Ghajar R, Tavakkoli H. Modelling of nonlinear hunting instability for a high-speed railway vehicle equipped by hollow worn wheels. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part K J Multi body Dyn 2016, 230 4 553-567

[7.] Nielsen JCO, Johansson A. Out-of-round railway wheels-a literature survey. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2000, 214 2 79-91

[8.] Nielsen J (2009) Out-of-round railway wheels. In: Lewis R, Olofsson U (eds) Wheel-Rail interface handbook. Woodhead Publishing, pp 245–279

[9.] Sato Y, Matsumoto A, Knothe K. Review on rail corrugation studies. Wear 2002, 253 1 130-139

[10.] Grassie SL (2009) Rail corrugation. In: Lewis R, Olofsson U (eds) Wheel-rail interface handbook. Woodhead Publishing, pp 349–376

[11.] Zhai W, Jin X, Wen Z, Zhao X. Wear problems of high-speed wheel/rail systems: observations, causes, and countermeasures in China. Appl Mech Rev 2020, 72 6

[12.] Sun Y, Guo Y, Zhai W (2019) Prediction of rail non-uniform wear—influence of track random irregularity. Wear 420–421:235–244

[13.] Sichani MS, Bezin Y (2018) Differential wear modelling—effect of weld-induced material inhomogeneity on rail surface quality. Wear 406–407:43–52

[14.] Bosso N, Zampieri N (2020) Numerical stability of co-simulation approaches to evaluate wheel profile evolution due to wear. Int J Rail Transp 8(2):159–179

[15.] Ashby MF, Lim SC. Wear-mechanism maps. Scr Metall Mater 1990, 24 5 805-810

[16.] Dearden J. The wear of steel rails : a review of the factors involved. Proc Inst Civ Eng 1954, 3 5 456-481

[17.] Dearden J. The wear of steel rails and tyres in railway service. Wear 1960, 3 1 43-59

[18.] Beagley TM. Severe wear of rolling/sliding contacts. Wear 1976, 36 3 317-335

[19.] Bolton PJ, Clayton P, McEwen IJ. Wear of rail and tire steels under rolling/sliding conditions. Tribol Trans 1982, 25 1 17-24

[20.] Bolton PJ, Clayton P. Rolling—sliding wear damage in rail and tyre steels. Wear 1984, 93 2 145-165

[21.] Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce RS. Wear mechanisms and transitions in railway wheel steels. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part J J Eng Tribol 2004, 218 6 467-478

[22.] Zakharov S, Komarovsky I, Zharov I. Wheel flange/rail head wear simulation. Wear 1998, 215 1 18-24

[23.] Olofsson U, Telliskivi T. Wear, plastic deformation and friction of two rail steels—a full–scale test and a laboratory study. Wear 2003, 254 1 80-93

[24.] Olofsson U, Lyu Y. Open system tribology in the wheel–rail contact—a literature review. Appl Mech Rev 2017, 69 6

[25.] Wang W, Lewis R, Yang B, Guo L, Liu Q, Zhu M (2016) Wear and damage transitions of wheel and rail materials under various contact conditions. Wear 362–363:146–152

[26.] Braghin F, Bruni S, Lewis R (2009) Railway wheel wear. In: Lewis R, Olofsson U (eds) Wheel–rail interface handbook. Woodhead Publishing, pp 172–210

[27.] Fries RH, Dávila CG. Analytical methods for wheel and rail wear prediction. Veh Syst Dyn 1986, 15 1–3 112-125

[28.] Lewis R, Olofsson U. Mapping rail wear regimes and transitions. Wear 2004, 257 7 721-729

[29.] Bosso N. Zampieri N (2014) Experimental and numerical simulation of wheel–rail adhesion and wear using a scaled roller rig and a real–time contact code. Shock Vib 2014, 2 1-14

[30.] Bosso N, Somà A, Zampieri N (2016) Bridge cranes wheels and rails: Wear analysis. In: the International Conference on Railway Technology: Research, Development and Maintenance, Cagliari pp 1–14

[31.] Ramalho A. Wear modelling in rail–wheel contact. Wear 2015, 330–331 524-532

[32.] Cremona MA, Liu B, Hu Y, Bruni S, Lewis R. Predicting railway wheel wear under uncertainty of wear coefficient, using universal kriging. Reliab Eng Syst Saf 2016, 154 49-59

[33.] McEwen IJ, Harvey RF (1986) Interpretation of wheel/rail wear numbers. Railway Technical Centre, Derby

[34.] Lewis R, Braghin F, Ward A, Bruni S, Dwyer-Joyce R, Bel Knani K, Bologna P (2003) Integrating dynamics and wear modelling to predict railway wheel profile evolution. In: the 6th International Conference on Contact Mechanics and Wear of Rail/Wheel Systems CM2003, Gothenburg pp 7–16

[35.] Tassini N, Quost X, Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce R, Ariaudo C, Kuka N. A numerical model of twin disc test arrangement for the evaluation of railway wheel wear prediction methods. Wear 2010, 268 5 660-667

[36.] Zobory I. Prediction of Wheel/Rail Profile Wear. Veh Syst Dyn 1997, 28 2–3 221-259

[37.] Krause H, Poll G. Wear of wheel–rail surfaces. Wear 1986, 113 1 103-122

[38.] Jendel T. Prediction of wheel profile wear—comparisons with field measurements. Wear 2002, 253 1 89-99

[39.] Archard JF. Contact and rubbing of flat surfaces. J Appl Phys 1953, 24 8 981-988

[40.] Archard JF, Hirst W, Allibone TE. The wear of metals under unlubricated conditions. Proc R Soc Lond A 1956, 236 1206 397-410

[41.] Peng B, Iwnicki S, Shackleton P, Crosbee D. Comparison of wear models for simulation of railway wheel polygonization. Wear 2019, 436–437

[42.] De Arizon J, Verlinden O, Dehombreux P. Prediction of wheel wear in urban railway transport: comparison of existing models. Veh Syst Dyn 2007, 45 9 849-866

[43.] Pombo J, Ambrósio J, Pereira M, Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce R, Ariaudo C, Kuka N. Development of a wear prediction tool for steel railway wheels using three alternative wear functions. Wear 2011, 271 1 238-245

[44.] Lewis R, Kuka N, Ariaudo C, Dwyer-Joyce R, Tassini N, Quost X (2008) Predicting railway wheel wear starting from multi-body analysis: a preliminary study. In: the IEEE/ASME/ASCE 2008 Joint Rail Conference, Wilmington (DE), pp 79–87

[45.] Feldmeier C, Li H, Yamazaki Y, Kato T, Fujimoto T, Kondo O, Sugiyama H. Prediction of the wheel profile wear using railroad vehicle dynamics simulation: comparison of simulation and test results. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part K J Multi body Dyn 2018, 232 2 224-236

[46.] Fries RH, Dávila CG. Wheel wear predictions for tangent track running. J Dyn Syst Meas Contr 1987, 109 4 397-403

[47.] Kalker JJ. Simulation of the development of a railway wheel profile through wear. Wear 1991, 150 1 355-365

[48.] Magel E, Kalousek J, Caldwell R. A numerical simulation of wheel wear. Wear 2005, 258 7 1245-1254

[49.] Apezetxea IS, Perez X, Casanueva C, Alonso A. New methodology for fast prediction of wheel wear evolution. Veh Syst Dyn 2017, 55 7 1071-1097

[50.] Han P, Zhang W. A new binary wheel wear prediction model based on statistical method and the demonstration. Wear 2015, 324–325 90-99

[51.] Wang S, Yan H, Liu C, Fan N, Liu X, Wang C. Analysis and prediction of high-speed train wheel wear based on SIMPACK and backpropagation neural networks. Expert Syst 2021, 38 7

[52.] Li B, Shen F, Bai L, Kho K, Zhou K. Numerical analysis of rail wear behavior in railway systems. Int J Model Opt 2019, 9 3 166-170

[53.] Li W, Wang P, Wang S, Si D, Yang D (2021) Wheel–rail wear simulation and rail cant optimisation based on railway vehicle dynamics. Int J Veh Perform 7(1–2):4–20

[54.] Sun YQ, Mandal N, Wu Q, Wolfs P, Spiryagin M (2018) Rail wear modelling concept for heavy haul locomotive study. In: the 25th International Symposium on Dynamics of Vehicles on Roads and Tracks (IAVSD 2017), Rockhampton, Queensland

[55.] Wu Q, Spiryagin M, Sun Y, Cole C. Parallel co-simulation of locomotive wheel wear and rolling contact fatigue in a heavy haul train operational environment. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2021, 235 2 166-178

[56.] Bracciali A, Megna G. Contact mechanics issues of a vehicle equipped with partially independently rotating wheelsets. Wear 2016, 366–367 233-240

[57.] Bracciali A, Megna G (2015) Contact mechanics issues of a vehicle equipped with partially independently rotating wheelsets. In: CM 2015—10th International Conference on Contact Mechanics of Wheel/Rail Systems, Colorado Springs

[58.] Zhang J, Xu B, Guan X. A combined simulation procedure for wear assessment of the HXN5 locomotive. Wear 2014, 314 1 305-313

[59.] Abeidi AS, Bosso N, Gugliotta A, Soma` A (2006) Numerical simulation of wear in railway wheel profiles. In: the ASME 8th Biennial Conference on Engineering Systems Design and Analysis, Torino, pp 963–977

[60.] Chang C, Wang C, Chen B, Li L (2009) Study on numerical analysis method to wheel/rail wear of heavy haul train. In: the 9th International Heavy Haul Conference: Heavy Haul and Innovation Development, Shanghai, pp 837–845

[61.] Chang C, Wang C, Chen B, Li L. A Study of a numerical analysis method for the wheel–rail wear of a heavy-haul train. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2010, 224 5 473-482

[62.] Bosso N, Gugliotta A, Abeidi AS. Influence of vehicle dynamics on wear of railway wheel profiles. Int J Appl Eng Res 2018, 13 6 3540-3549

[63.] Pearce TG, Sherratt ND. Prediction of wheel profile wear. Wear 1991, 144 1 343-351

[64.] Szabó A, Zobory I. On deterministic and stochastic simulation of wheel and rail profile wear process. Period Polytech Transp Eng 1998, 26 1–2 3-17

[65.] Szabó A, Zobory I. On simulation of wheel/rail wear in metro operation. Period Polytech Transp Eng 2002, 30 1–2 3-19

[66.] Jendel T, Berg M. Prediction of wheel profile wear. Veh Syst Dyn 2002, 37 sup1 502-513

[67.] Enblom R, Berg M. Simulation of railway wheel profile development due to wear—influence of disc braking and contact environment. Wear 2005, 258 7 1055-1063

[68.] Li Y, Ren Z, Enblom R, Stichel S, Li G. Wheel wear prediction on a high-speed train in China. Int J Vehicle Mech Mobility 2019, 58 12 1839-1858

[69.] Dirks B, Enblom R. Prediction model for wheel profile wear and rolling contact fatigue. Wear 2011, 271 1 210-217

[70.] Enblom R, Stichel S. Industrial implementation of novel procedures for the prediction of railway wheel surface deterioration. Wear 2011, 271 1 203-209

[71.] Dirks B, Enblom R, Berg M. Prediction of wheel profile wear and crack growth—comparisons with measurements. Wear 2016, 366–367 84-94

[72.] Hossein Nia S, Casanueva C, Stichel S. Prediction of RCF and wear evolution of iron-ore locomotive wheels. Wear 2015, 338–339 62-72

[73.] Hossein-Nia S, Sichani MS, Stichel S, Casanueva C. Wheel life prediction model—an alternative to the FASTSIM algorithm for RCF. Veh Syst Dyn 2018, 56 7 1051-1071

[74.] Enblom R, Berg M. Proposed procedure and trial simulation of rail profile evolution due to uniform wear. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2008, 222 1 15-25

[75.] Braghin F, Bruni S, Resta F. Wear of railway wheel profiles: a comparison between experimental results and a mathematical model. Veh Syst Dyn 2002, 37 Sup1 478-489

[76.] Shen ZY, Hedrick JK, Elkins JA. A comparison of alternative creep force models for rail vehicle dynamic analysis. Veh Syst Dyn 1983, 12 1–3 79-83

[77.] Lewis R, Cavalletti M, Dwyer-Joyce RS, Ward A, Bruni S, Bel Knani K, Bologna P (2002) Railway wheel wear predictions with ADAMS/Rail. In: the MSC. ADAMS European User Conference, London

[78.] Ward A, Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce RS. Incorporating a railway wheel wear model into multi-body simulations of wheelset dynamics. Tribology Series 2003, 41 367-376

[79.] Braghin F, Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce RS, Bruni S. A mathematical model to predict railway wheel profile evolution due to wear. Wear 2006, 261 11 1253-1264

[80.] Jin X, Wen Z, Xiao X, Zhou Z. A numerical method for prediction of curved rail wear. Multibody SysDyn 2007, 18 4 531-557

[81.] Jin X, Xiao X, Wen Z, Guo J, Zhu M. An investigation into the effect of train curving on wear and contact stresses of wheel and rail. Tribol Int 2009, 42 3 475-490

[82.] Igeland A, Ilias H. Rail head corrugation growth predictions based on non-linear high frequency vehicle/track interaction. Wear 1997, 213 1 90-97

[83.] Li X, Jin X, Wen Z, Cui D, Zhang W. A new integrated model to predict wheel profile evolution due to wear. Wear 2011, 271 1 227-237

[84.] Li X, Yang T, Zhang J, Cao Y, Wen Z, Jin X. Rail wear on the curve of a heavy haul line—Numerical simulations and comparison with field measurements. Wear 2016, 366–367 131-138

[85.] Friedman JH. A variable span smoother 1984 Lab for computational statistics Stanford Univ CA

[86.] Shi Z, Zhu S, Rindi A, Meli E. Development and validation of a wear prediction model for railway applications including track flexibility. Wear 2021, 486–487

[87.] Malvezzi M, Meli E, Falomi S, Rindi A. Determination of wheel–rail contact points with semianalytic methods. Multibody SysDyn 2008, 20 4 327-358

[88.] Aceituno JF, Wang P, Wang L, Shabana AA. Influence of rail flexibility in a wheel/rail wear prediction model. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2017, 231 1 57-74

[89.] Wang P, Gao L. Numerical simulation of wheel wear evolution for heavy haul railway. J Central South Univ 2015, 22 1 196-207

[90.] Shadfar M, Molatefi H. A study on transient wear behavior of new freight wheel profiles due to two points contact in curve negotiation. J Theor Appl Mech 2017, 55 2 621-634

[91.] Pires AC, Pacheco LA, Dalvi IL, Endlich CS, Queiroz JC, Antoniolli FA, Santos GFM. The effect of railway wheel wear on reprofiling and service life. Wear 2021, 477

[92.] Smetanka L, Hrček S, Šťastniak P. Investigation of railway wheelset profile wear by using computer simulation. MATEC Web Conf 2019, 254 2A 02041

[93.] Zhu A, Yang S, Li Q, Yang J, Fu C, Zhang J, Yao D. Research on prediction of metro wheel wear based on integrated data-model-driven approach. IEEE Access 2019, 7 178153-178166

[94.] Pombo J, Quost X, Tassini N, Ambrósio J, Pereira M, Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce R, Ariaudo C, Kuka N. A railway wheel wear prediction tool based on multibody software. J Theor Appl Mech 2008, 48 3 751-770

[95.] Pombo J, Ambrósio J, Pereira M, Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce R, Ariaudo C, Kuka N. A study on wear evaluation of railway wheels based on multibody dynamics and wear computation. Multibody SysDyn 2010, 24 3 347-366

[96.] Pombo J, Ambrósio J, Pereira M, Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce R, Ariaudo C, Kuka N. A railway wheel wear prediction tool based on a multibody software. J Theor Appl Mech 2010, 48 3 751-770

[97.] Bevan A, Molyneux-Berry P, Eickhoff B, Burstow M. Development and validation of a wheel wear and rolling contact fatigue damage model. Wear 2013, 307 1 100-111

[98.] Auciello J, Ignesti M, Malvezzi M, Meli E, Rindi A. Development and validation of a wear model for the analysis of the wheel profile evolution in railway vehicles. Veh Syst Dyn 2012, 50 11 1707-1734

[99.] Auciello J, Ignesti M, Marini L, Meli E, Rindi A. Development of a model for the analysis of wheel wear in railway vehicles. Meccanica 2013, 48 3 681-697

[100.] Ignesti M, Innocenti A, Marini L, Meli E, Rindi A. Development of a wear model for the wheel profile optimisation on railway vehicles. Veh Syst Dyn 2013, 51 9 1363-1402

[101.] Ignesti M, Innocenti A, Marini L, Meli E, Rindi A. A numerical procedure for the wheel profile optimisation on railway vehicles. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part J J Eng Tribol 2013, 228 2 206-222

[102.] Ignesti M, Innocenti A, Marini L, Meli E, Rindi A, Toni P. Wheel profile optimization on railway vehicles from the wear viewpoint. Int J Non Linear Mech 2013, 53 41-54

[103.] Ignesti M, Marini L, Meli E, Rindi A. Development of a model for the prediction of wheel and rail wear in the railway field. J Comput Nonlinear Dyn 2012, 7 4

[104.] Ignesti M, Malvezzi M, Marini L, Meli E, Rindi A. Development of a wear model for the prediction of wheel and rail profile evolution in railway systems. Wear 2012, 284–285 1-17

[105.] Innocenti A, Marini L, Meli E, Pallini G, Rindi A. Development of a wear model for the analysis of complex railway networks. Wear 2014, 309 1 174-191

[106.] Ignesti M, Innocenti A, Marini L, Meli E, Rindi A. Development of a model for the simultaneous analysis of wheel and rail wear in railway systems. Multibody SysDyn 2014, 31 2 191-240

[107.] Butini E, Marini L, Meli E, Panconi S, Rindi A, Romani B (2018) A new wear model considering wheel–rail conformal contact. In: the First International Conference on Rail Transportation (ICRT 2017), Chengdu, pp 237–249

[108.] Butini E, Marini L, Meacci M, Meli E, Rindi A, Zhao XJ, Wang WJ. An innovative model for the prediction of wheel–rail wear and rolling contact fatigue. Wear 2019, 436–437

[109.] Tao G, Du X, Zhang H, Wen Z, Jin X, Cui D. Development and validation of a model for predicting wheel wear in high-speed trains. J Zhejiang Univ Sci A 2017, 18 8 603-616

[110.] Sichani MS, Enblom R, Berg M. An alternative to FASTSIM for tangential solution of the wheel–rail contact. Veh Syst Dyn 2016, 54 6 748-764

[111.] Ye Y, Sun Y, Dongfang S, Shi D, Hecht M. Optimizing wheel profiles and suspensions for railway vehicles operating on specific lines to reduce wheel wear: a case study. Multibody SysDyn 2021, 51 1 91-122

[112.] Ding J, Li F, Huang Y, Sun S, Zhang L. Application of the semi-Hertzian method to the prediction of wheel wear in heavy haul freight car. Wear 2014, 314 1 104-110

[113.] Pradhan S, Samantaray AK, Bhattacharyya R. Application of semi-Hertzian approach to predict the dynamic behavior of railway vehicles through a wear evolution model. J Fric Wear 2017, 38 6 437-443

[114.] Pradhan S, Samantaray AK, Bhattacharyya R. Prediction of railway wheel wear and its influence on the vehicle dynamics in a specific operating sector of Indian railways network. Wear 2018, 406–407 92-104

[115.] Pradhan S, Samantaray A, Bhattacharyya R. Multi-step wear evolution simulation method for the prediction of rail wheel wear and vehicle dynamic performance. SIMULATION 2019, 95 5 441-459

[116.] Meghoe A, Loendersloot R, Bosman R, Tinga T (2018) Rail wear estimation for predictive maintenance: a strategic approach. In: the PHM Society European Conference, Utrecht

[117.] Tao G, Ren D, Wang L, Wen Z, Jin X. Online prediction model for wheel wear considering track flexibility. Multibody SysDyn 2018, 44 3 313-334

[118.] Tao G, Wen Z, Guan Q, Zhao X, Luo Y, Jin X. Locomotive wheel wear simulation in complex environment of wheel–rail interface. Wear 2019, 430–431 214-221

[119.] Kaiser I, Poll G, Vinolas J (2022) Modelling the impact of structural flexibility of wheelsets and rails on the wheel–rail contact and the wear. Wear 504–505:203445

[120.] Enblom R, Berg M. Impact of non-elliptic contact modelling in wheel wear simulation. Wear 2008, 265 9 1532-1541

[121.] Tao G, Wen Z, Zhao X, Jin X. Effects of wheel–rail contact modelling on wheel wear simulation. Wear 2016, 366–367 146-156

[122.] Lewis R, Dwyer-Joyce RS, Olofsson U, Pombo J, Ambrósio J, Pereira M, Ariaudo C, Kuka N. Mapping railway wheel material wear mechanisms and transitions. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2010, 224 3 125-137

[123.] Walia MS, Vernersson T, Lundén R, Blennow F, Meinel M. Temperatures and wear at railway tread braking: field experiments and simulations. Wear 2019, 440–441

[124.] Chen S, Zhao G, Wang H, Tao G, Wen Z, Wu L. Study of wheel wear influenced by tread temperature rising during tread braking. Wear 2019, 438–439

[125.] Pradhan S, Samantaray AK. A recursive wheel wear and vehicle dynamic performance evolution computational model for rail vehicles with tread brakes. Vehicles 2019, 1 1 88-115