A review of hydrogen technologies and engineering solutions for railway vehicle design and operations

Abstract

Interest in hydrogen-powered rail vehicles has gradually increased worldwide over recent decades due to the global pressure on reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, technology availability, and multiple options of power supply. In the past, research and development have been primarily focusing on light rail and regional trains, but the interest in hydrogen-powered freight and heavy haul trains is also growing. The review shows that some technical feasibility has been demonstrated from the research and experiments on proof-of-concept designs. Several rail vehicles powered by hydrogen either are currently operating or are the subject of experimental programmes. The paper identifies that fuel cell technology is well developed and has obvious application in providing electrical traction power, while hydrogen combustion in traditional IC engines and gas turbines is not yet well developed. The need for on-board energy storage is discussed along with the benefits of energy management and control systems.

References

[1.] Koseki T. Technologies for saving energy in railway operation: general discussion on energy issues concerning railway technology. IEEJ Trans Electr Electron Eng 2010, 5 285-290

[2.] Wikipedia (2021) Diesel locomotive. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_locomotive. Accessed 22 Jan 2021

[3.] Siddiqui O, Dincer I. A review on fuel cell-based locomotive powering options for sustainable transportation. Arab J Sci Eng 2019, 44 677-693

[4.] Jones WD. Hydrogen on track. IEEE Spectr 2006, 43 8 10-13

[5.] Hoffrichter A (2019) Hydrogen-rail (hydrail) development. Paper presented at H2@Rail Workshop, Lansing, MI. 27 Mar 2019.

[6.] Verdict Media Limited (2021) Railway technology: cordia iLint regional train. https://www.railway-technology.com/projects/coradia-ilint-regional-train/. Accessed 20 April 2021

[7.] Gallucci M (2019) Hydrogen trains roll into service: A new hybrid locomotive signals a growing push for zero-emission rail technologies. IEEE Spectrum, 6 Aug 2019.

[8.] Miller AR, Peters J, Smith BE, Velev OA. Analysis of fuel cell hybrid locomotives. J Power Sources 2006, 157 855-861

[9.] Hoffrichter A (2013) Hydrogen as an energy carrier for railway traction. Dissertation, The University of Birmingham.

[10.] Hoffrichter A, Hillmansen S, Roberts C (2010) Review and assessment of hydrogen propelled railway vehicles. In: IET conference on railway traction systems, Birmingham. 13–15 Apr 2010, pp 1–5

[11.] Haseli Y, Naterer GF, Dincer I. Comparative assessment of greenhouse gas mitigation of hydrogen passenger trains. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2008, 33 1788-1796

[12.] Hollingsworth B, Cook A (1996) The great book of trains. Salamander Books Ltd

[13.] Spiryagin M, Cole C, Sun YQ, McClanachan M, Spiryagin V, McSweeney T (2014) Design and simulation of rail vehicles. CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group, Boca Rotan

[14.] Spiryagin M, Wolfs P, Cole C, Spiryagin V, Sun YQ, McSweeney T (2016) Design and Simulation of Heavy Haul Locomotives and Trains. CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group, Boca Rotan

[15.] Raj AK. Futuristic and trendy eco-friendly emission-free hydrogen-oxygen fuel cell powered electric motor propelled automobiles and commuter locomotives. J Autom Auto Eng 2019, 4 3 22-26

[16.] Furuta R, Kawasaki J, Kondo K. Hybrid traction technologies with energy storage devices for nonelectrified railway lines. IEE J Trans Electr Electron Eng 2010, 5 291-297

[17.] Barbosa FC (2019) Fuel cell rail technology review: a tool for an autonomous rail electrifying strategy. In: Proceedings of the 2019 joint rail conference, Snowbird, UT, 9–12 Apr 2019

[18.] Din T, Hillmansen S, Ellis R. Energy consumption and carbon dioxide emissions analysis for a concept design of a hydrogen hybrid railway vehicle. IET Electrical Syst Transp 2018, 8 2 112-121

[19.] Washing EM, Pulugurtha SS. Energy demand and emission production comparison of electric, hydrogen and hydrogen-hybrid light rail trains. Int J Rail Transp 2016, 4 1 55-70

[20.] Hoffrichter A, Hillmansen S, Roberts C. Conceptual propulsion system design for a hydrogen-powered regional train. IET Electrical Syst Transp 2016, 6 2 55-66

[21.] Miller AR, Hess KS, Barnes DL, Erickson TL. System design of a large fuel cell hybrid locomotive. J Power Sources 2007, 173 935-942

[22.] Peng F, Chen W, Liu Z, Li Q, Dai C. System integration of China’s first proton exchange membrane fuel cell locomotive. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2014, 39 13886-13893

[23.] Zhang W, Li J, Xu L, Ouyang M. Optimization for a fuel cell/battery/capacity tram with equivalent consumption minimization strategy. Energy Convers Manage 2017, 134 59-69

[24.] Wikipedia (2021) Fuel cell. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_cell. Accessed 11 Jan 2021

[25.] Schroeder DJ, Majumdar P. Feasibility analysis for solid oxide fuel cells as a power source for railroad road locomotives. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2010, 35 11308-11314

[26.] Carrette L, Friedrich KA, Stimming U. Fuel cells—fundamentals and applications. Fuel Cells 2001, 1 1 5-39

[27.] Wang Y, Chen KS, Mishler J, Cho SC, Adroher XC. A review of polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells: technology, applications, and needs on fundamental research. Appl Energy 2011, 88 4 981-1007

[28.] Sopian K, Daud WW. Challenges and future developments in proton exchange membrane fuel cells. Renew Energy 2006, 31 719-727

[29.] Kordesch K, Hacker V, Gsellmann J . Alkaline fuel cells applications. J Power Sources 2000, 86 1 162-165

[30.] Bidault F, Brett DJL, Middleton PH, Brandon NP. Review of gas diffusion cathodes for alkaline fuel cells. J Power Sources 2009, 187 1 39-48

[31.] US Department of Energy (2021) Comparison of fuel cell technologies. https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/comparison-fuel-celltechnologies. Accessed 28 Jan 2021

[32.] Yedavalli K, Guo L, Zinger DS. Simple control system for a switcher locomotive hybrid fuel cell power system. IEEE Trans Ind Appl 2011, 47 6 2384-2390

[33.] Brenscheidt T, Janowitz K, Salge HJ, Wendt H, Brammer F. Performance of ONSI PC25 PAFC cogeneration plant. Int J Hydrogen Energy 1998, 23 1 53-56

[34.] Chen X, Wang Y, Zhao Y, Zhou Y. A study of double functions and load matching of a phosphoric acid fuel cell/heat-driven refrigerator hybrid system. Energy 2016, 101 359-365

[35.] Baron R, Wejrzanowski T, Szabłowski Ł . Dual ionic conductive membrane for molten carbonate fuel cell. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2018, 43 16 8100-8104

[36.] Jienkulsawad P, Saebea D, Patcharavorachot Y, Kheawhom S. Arpornwichanop A (2018) Analysis of a solid oxide fuel cell and a molten carbonate fuel cell integrated system with different configurations. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2018, 43 2 932-942

[37.] Guo L, Yedavalli K, Zinger D. Design and modeling of power system for a fuel cell hybrid switcher locomotive. Energy Convers Manage 2011, 52 1406-1413

[38.] People’s Daily (2010) China introduces first light-rail locomotive with new-energy fuel cells (29 Nov. 2010). http://en.people.cn/90001/90776/90882/7215009.html. Accessed 10 Jan 2021

[39.] Foster M (2017) Caltrain 2.0–Hydrogen Fuel Cell EMUs. https://www.mikeforster.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Caltrain-2.0-Hydrogen-Fuel-Cell-EMUs-Mike-Forster-v3.2.pdf. Accessed 20 Apr 2021

[40.] Sarma U, Ganguly S (2017) Determination of rating requirement for fuel-cell-battery hybrid energy system to substitute the diesel locomotives of Indian railway. In: 14th IEEE India Council International Conference (INDICON), Roorkee, India, pp 1–6

[41.] Sarma U, Ganguly S (2018) Modelling and cost-benefit analysis of PEM fuel-cell-battery hybrid energy system for locomotive application. In: 2018 Technologies for smart-city energy security and power (ICSESP), Bhubaneswar, India, pp 1–5

[42.] Zhang G, Chen W, Li Q. Modeling, optimization and control of a FC/battery hybrid locomotive based on ADVISOR. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2017, 42 18568-18583

[43.] Zheng CH, Oh CE, Park YI, Cha SW. Fuel economy evaluation of fuel cell hybrid vehicles based on equivalent fuel consumption. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2012, 37 1790-1796

[44.] Unlubayir C, Nemeth T, Meishner F, Peng H, Deng K, Sauer DU (2019). Simulation model with an optimal operation strategy for a hybrid train powered by a battery and a fuel cell. In: 2019 IEEE vehicle power and propulsion conference (VPPC), Hanoi, Vietnam, pp 1–5

[45.] Mendoza DS, Acevedo P, Jaimes JS, Solano J (2019) Energy management of a dual-mode locomotive based on the energy sources characteristics. In: 2019 IEEE vehicle power and propulsion conference (VPPC), Hanoi, Vietnam, pp 1–4

[46.] Torreglosa JP, Jurado F, Garcia P, Fernández LM. Hybrid fuel cell and battery tramway control based on an equivalent consumption minimization strategy. Control Eng Pract 2011, 19 1182-1194

[47.] Garcia P, Torreglosa JP, Fernández LM, Jurado F. Viability study of a FC-battery-SC tramway controlled by equivalent consumption minimization strategy. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2012, 37 9368-9382

[48.] Piraino F, Fragiacomo P. Design of an equivalent consumption minimization strategy-based control in relation to the passenger number for a fuel cell tram propulsion. Energies 2020, 13 4010

[49.] Shang W, Yu S, Zhang G, Li Q, Chen W (2017) Fuel cell hybrid locomotive system based on equivalent consumption minimization strategy. In: 2017 Chinese automation congress (CAC), Jinan, 20–22 Oct 2017, pp 2457–2461

[50.] Hong Z, Han Y, Li Q, Chen W, (2016) Design of energy management system for fuel cell/supercapacitor hybrid locomotive. In: 2016 IEEE vehicle power and propulsion conference (VPPC), Hangzhou, 17–20 Oct 2016, pp 1–5

[51.] Jiang Z, Chen W, Dai C, Cheng Z (2010) Optimal Energy Management for a Fuel Cell Hybrid Locomotive. In: 2010 Seventh international conference on fuzzy systems and knowledge discovery (FSKD 2010), Yantai, China, pp 1320–1323.

[52.] Peng F, Zhao Y, Chen T, Zhang X, Chen W, Zhou D, Li Q. Development of robust suboptimal real-time power sharing strategy for modern fuel cell based hybrid tramways considering operational uncertainties and performance degradation. Appl Energy 2018, 226 503-521

[53.] García P, Torreglosa JP, Fernández LM, Jurado F. Control strategies for high-power electric vehicles powered by hydrogen fuel cell, battery and supercapacitor. Expert Syst Appl 2013, 40 4791-4804

[54.] Guo Y, Dai X, Jermsittiparsert K, Razmjooy N. An optimal configuration for a battery and PEM fuel cell-based hybrid energy system using developed Krill herd optimization algorithm for locomotive application. Energy Rep 2020, 6 885-894

[55.] Ajayan S, Selvakumar AI (2020) Implementation of firefly algorithm in optimal sizing of proton exchange membrane fuel cell -battery hybrid locomotive. Int J Renew Energy Res, 10(2)

[56.] Zhang H, Yang J, Zhang J, Song P, Xu X. A firefly algorithm optimization-based equivalent consumption minimization strategy for fuel cell hybrid light rail vehicle. Energies 2019, 12 2665

[57.] Li Q, Chen W, Liu Z, Guo A, Huang J. Nonlinear multivariable modeling of locomotive proton exchange membrane fuel cell system. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2014, 39 13777-13786

[58.] Wang X, Li Q, Wang T, Han Y, Chen W (2019). Optimized energy management strategy based on sqp algorithm for pemfc hybrid locomotive. In: 2019 IEEE transportation electrification conference and expo, Asia-Pacific (ITEC Asia-Pacific), Seogwipo-si, Korea (South), pp 1–5

[59.] Hong Z, Li Q, Han Y, Shang W, Zhu Y, Chen W. An energy management strategy based on dynamic power factor for fuel cell/battery hybrid locomotive. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2018, 43 3261-3272

[60.] D'Ovidio G, Ometto A, Valentini O. A novel predictive power flow control strategy for hydrogen city rail train. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2020, 45 4922-4931

[61.] Hong Z, Zhu Y, Shang W, Li Q, Chen W (2017) Research of energy management strategy for fuel cell/battery hybrid locomotive. In: 2017 IEEE transportation electrification conference and expo, Asia-Pacific (ITEC Asia-Pacific), Harbin, pp 1–5

[62.] Yan Y, Li Q, Huang W, Chen W. Operation optimization and control method based on optimal energy and hydrogen consumption for the fuel cell/supercapacitor hybrid tram. IEEE Trans Ind Electron 2021, 68 2 1342-1352

[63.] Yuan Z, Li H, Yousefi H (2021) Optimal hydrogen consumption of fuel cell-based locomotive using speed trajectory optimization by Improved Pathfinder algorithm. J Clean Prod 278:123430.

[64.] Li Q, Yang H, Han Y, Li M, Chen W. A state machine strategy based on droop control for an energy management system of PEMFC-battery supercapacitor hybrid tramway. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2016, 41 16148-16159

[65.] Li Q, Wang T, Dai C, Chen W, Ma L. Power management strategy based on adaptive droop control for a fuel cell-battery-supercapacitor hybrid tramway. IEEE Trans Veh Technol 2018, 67 7 5658-5670

[66.] Wu C, Chen J, Xu C, Liu Z. Real-time adaptive control of a fuel cell/battery hybrid power system with guaranteed stability. IEEE Trans Control Syst Technol 2017, 25 4 1394-1405

[67.] Peng H, Li J, Löwenstein L, Hameyer K (2020) A scalable, causal, adaptive energy management strategy based on optimal control theory for a fuel cell hybrid railway vehicle. Appl Energy 267:114987

[68.] Dincer I, Zamfirescu C. A review of novel energy options for clean rail applications. J Nat Gas Sci Eng 2016, 28 461-478

[69.] Miller A, Berg GVD, Barnes DL, Eisele RI, Tanner DM, Vallely JM, Lassiter DA, (2012). Fuel cell technology in underground mining. The Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy Platinum 2012. https://www.911metallurgist.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Fuel-cell-technology-in-underground-mining.pdf. Accessed 15 Apr 2021

[70.] Martinez AS, Brouwer J, Samuelsen GS. Feasibility study for SOFC-GT hybrid locomotive power: part I. Development of a dynamic 3.5MW SOFC-GT FORTRAN model. J Power Sources 2012, 213 203-217

[71.] Martinez AS, Brouwer J, Samuelsen GS. Feasibility study for SOFC-GT hybrid locomotive power: part II. System packaging and operating route simulation. J Power Sources 2012, 213 358-374

[72.] Ahrend P, Azizi A, Brouwer J, Samuelsen GS (2019) A solid oxide fuel cell-gas turbine hybrid system for a freight rail application. In: Proceedings of the ASME 2019, 13th international conference on energy sustainability, Bellevue, WA, USA, 14–17 July 2019

[73.] Murray-Smith D (2020) Modelling and simulation of hybrid electric trains powered by hydrogen fuel cells and batteries for routes in the highlands of Scotland: preliminary results. In: Technical Report for the Scottish Association of Public Transport.

[74.] Murray-Smith D (2020) Design options for hybrid trains powered by hydrogen fuel cells and batteries for routes in the highlands of Scotland: results for the case of a three-coach multiple-unit train. In: Technical Report for the Scottish Association of Public Transport.

[75.] Piraino F, Fragiacomo P (2020) A multi-method control strategy for numerically testing a fuel cell-battery-supercapacitor tramway. Energy Conver Manag, 225:113481

[76.] Abdelrahman AS, Attia Y, Woronowicz K, Youssef MZ. Hybrid fuel cell/battery rail car: a feasibility study. IEEE Trans Transp Electrific 2016, 2 4 493

[77.] Longo M, Brenna M, Zaninelli D, Ceraolo M, Lutzemberger G and Poli D (2019) Fuel-cell based propulsion systems for hybrid railcars. In: IEEE Milan Power Tech, Milan, Italy, pp 1–6

[78.] Li Q, Huang W, Chen W, Yan Y, Shang W, Li M. Regenerative braking energy recovery strategy based on Pontryagin's minimum principle for fell cell/supercapacitor hybrid locomotive. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2019, 44 5454-5461

[79.] Emadi A, Williamson SS, Khaligh A. Power electronics intensive solutions for advanced electric, hybrid electric, and fuel cell vehicular power systems. IEEE Trans Power Electron 2006, 21 3 567-577

[80.] Coombe D, Fisher D, Hoffrichter A, Kent S . Development and design of a narrow-gauge hydrogen-hybrid locomotive. Proc IMechE Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2016, 230 1 181-192

[81.] Tsukahara K, Kondo K (2013) A study on methods to design and select energy storage devices for fuel cell hybrid powered railway vehicles, In: IECON 2013—39th annual conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society, Vienna, pp 4534–4539

[82.] Fragiacomo P, Piraino F. Numerical modelling of a PEFC powertrain system controlled by a hybrid strategy for rail urban transport. J Energy Storage 2018, 17 474-484

[83.] Sarma U, Ganguly S. Determination of the component sizing for the PEM fuel cell-battery hybrid energy system for locomotive application using particle swarm optimization. J Energy Storage 2018, 19 247-259

[84.] Fragiacomo P, Piraino F. Fuel cell hybrid powertrains for use in Southern Italian railways. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2019, 44 27930-27946

[85.] Cho I, Lee B, Park S, Ryu J, Kim J. Designing high-voltage and large-capacity battery packs for fuel-cell hybrid railroad propulsion system. Electronics 2020, 9 8 1259

[86.] Fragiacomo P, Piraino F. Energy performance of a FC hybrid system for rail vehicle propulsion. Energy Procedia 2017, 126 1051-1058

[87.] Abbas M, Cho I, Kim J. Reliability-constrained optimal sizing and rechargeable battery selection for improved load distribution in a fuel-cell hybrid railway propulsion system. Energy Convers Manag 2019, 196 15 1167-1179

[88.] Hoffrichter A, Fisher P, Tutcher J, Hillmansen S, Roberts C. Performance evaluation of the hydrogen-powered prototype locomotive ‘Hydrogen Pioneer’. J Power Sources 2014, 250 120-127

[89.] Chen W, Peng F, Liu Z, Li Q, Dai C. System integration of China’s first PEMFC locomotive. J Mod Transp 2013, 21 3 163-168

[90.] Yan Y, Li Q, Chen W, Su B, Liu J, Ma L. Optimal energy management and control in multimode equivalent energy consumption of FC/supercapacitor of hybrid electric tram. IEEE Trans Ind Electron 2019, 66 8 6065-6076

[91.] Akhoundzadeh MH, Raahemifar K, Panchal S, Samadani E, Haghi E, Fraser R, Fowler M. A conceptualized hydrail powertrain: a case study of the union pearson express route. World Electric Veh J 2019, 10 32

[92.] Miller AR, Erickson TL, James Dippo L, Eisele RI, Johnson MD, Lambrecht T (2011) Hydrogen fuel-cell locomotive: switching and power-to-grid demonstrations. In: 9th World congress on railway research, Lille, France, 22–26 May 2011

[93.] Li Q, Chen Z, Liu W, Li M, Ma L. Development of energy management system based on a power sharing strategy for a fuel cell-battery-supercapacitor hybrid tramway. J Power Sources 2015, 279 267-280

[94.] Deng K, Peng H, Dirkes S, Gottschalk J, Ünlübayir C, Thul A, Lowenstein L, Pischinger S, Hameyer K (2021) An adaptive PMP-based model predictive energy management strategy for fuel cell hybrid railway vehicles. eTransportation 7:100094.

[95.] Hogerwaard J, Dincer I. Comparative efficiency and environmental impact assessments of a hydrogen assisted hybrid locomotive. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2016, 41 6894-6904

[96.] Hoffrichter A, Miller AR, Hillmansen S, Roberts C. Well-to-wheel analysis for electric, diesel and hydrogen traction for railways. Transp Res Part D 2012, 17 28-34

[97.] Marin GD, Naterer GF, Gabriel K. Rail transportation by hydrogen vs. electrification e case study for Ontario, Canada, II: energy supply and distribution. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2010, 35 6097-6107

[98.] Zhang W, Li J, Xu L, Ouyang M, Liu Y, Han Q, Li K. Comparison study on life-cycle costs of different trams powered by fuel cell systems and others. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2016, 41 16577-16591

[99.] Cuda P, Dincer I, Naterer CF. Hydrogen utilization in various transportation modes with emissions comparisons for Ontario, Canada. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2012, 37 634-643

[100.] Zenith F, Isaac R, Hoffrichter A, Thomassen MS, Møller-Holst S. Techno-economic analysis of freight railway electrification by overhead line, hydrogen and batteries: case studies in Norway and USA. Proc IMechE Part F J Rail Rapid Transit 2020, 234 7 791-802

[101.] Logana KG, Nelsonb JD, McLellanc BC, Hastingsa A (2020) Electric and hydrogen rail: potential contribution to net zero in the UK, Transp Res Part D, 87:102523

[102.] Li Y, Corder GD, McLellan BC. Transport in the minerals industry—contributions to greenhouse gas emissions and potential for mitigation. Miner Eng 2011, 24 1430-1439