Active suspension in railway vehicles: a literature survey
Bin Fu, Rocco Libero Giossi, Rickard Persson, Sebastian Stichel, Stefano Bruni, Roger Goodall
Railway Engineering Science ›› 2020, Vol. 28 ›› Issue (1) : 3-35.
Active suspension in railway vehicles: a literature survey
Since the concept of active suspensions appeared, its large possible benefits has attracted continuous exploration in the field of railway engineering. With new demands of higher speed, better ride comfort and lower maintenance cost for railway vehicles, active suspensions are very promising technologies. Being the starting point of commercial application of active suspensions in rail vehicles, tilting trains have become a great success in some countries. With increased technical maturity of sensors and actuators, active suspension has unprecedented development opportunities. In this work, the basic concepts are summarized with new theories and solutions that have appeared over the last decade. Experimental studies and the implementation status of different active suspension technologies are described as well. Firstly, tilting trains are briefly described. Thereafter, an in-depth study for active secondary and primary suspensions is performed. For both topics, after an introductory section an explanation of possible solutions existing in the literature is given. The implementation status is reported. Active secondary suspensions are categorized into active and semi-active suspensions. Primary suspensions are instead divided between acting on solid-axle wheelsets and independently rotating wheels. Lastly, a brief summary and outlook is presented in terms of benefits, research status and challenges. The potential for active suspensions in railway applications is outlined.
[1.] |
|
[2.] |
|
[3.] |
|
[4.] |
|
[5.] |
|
[6.] |
|
[7.] |
|
[8.] |
Mei TX, Zaeim A, Li H (2020) Control of railway wheelsets – a semi-active approach. In: Klomp M, Bruzelius F, Nielsen J, Hillemyr A (eds) Advances in dynamics of vehicles on roads and tracks. IAVSD 2019. Lecture Notes in mechanical engineering. Springer, Cham
|
[9.] |
Van Dorn W, Beemer P (1938) Suspension for vehicles. US Patent
|
[10.] |
Anon. “Tilting Train”. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tilting. Accessed 2019
|
[11.] |
Anon. “Talgo”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talgo. Accessed 2019
|
[12.] |
|
[13.] |
Talgo. “Talgo XXI”. http://www.talgo.es/pdf/T21ingles.pdf. Accessed 2019
|
[14.] |
|
[15.] |
|
[16.] |
|
[17.] |
|
[18.] |
|
[19.] |
Facchinetti A, Di Gialleonardo E, Resta F, Bruni S, Brundisch V (2011) Active control of secondary airspring suspension. In: Proceedings of the 22nd international symposium dynamics of vehicles on roads tracks (IAVSD 2011), pp 1–7
|
[20.] |
|
[21.] |
|
[22.] |
|
[23.] |
|
[24.] |
|
[25.] |
|
[26.] |
|
[27.] |
|
[28.] |
CEN; EN12299. Railway applications—ride comfort for passengers—measurement and evaluation 2009 Brussels British Standard
|
[29.] |
Method for Assessing Raiding Quality of Vehicle (April 1977), Report C116/RP 8, Office for Research and Experiments, Utrecht, Netherlands
|
[30.] |
Orvnäs A (2010) Methods for reducing vertical carbody vibrations of a rail vehicle: a literature survey
|
[31.] |
|
[32.] |
Orvnäs A, Stichel S, Persson R (2011) Aspects of using active vertical secondary suspension to improve ride comfort. In: Proceedings of the 22nd international symposium on dynamics of vehicle on roads and tracks (IAVSD 2011), pp 1–6
|
[33.] |
Hammood H, Mei TX (2017) Gain-sheduling control for railway vehicle semi-active suspension. In: Proceedings of the 25th international symposium on dynamics of vehicle on roads and tracks (IAVSD 2017), pp 893–899
|
[34.] |
Sugahara Y, Kojima T, Akami Y, Igarashi Y (2016) Development of a vertical semi-active suspension system using variable hydraulic dampers. In: Proceedings of the 15th international conference on railway engineering design and operation (CR 2016)
|
[35.] |
Yusof MdH, Goodall R, Dixon R (2011) Controller strategies for active secondary suspension actuators. In: Proceedings of the 22nd international symposium on dynamics of vehicle on roads and tracks (IAVSD 2011)
|
[36.] |
|
[37.] |
|
[38.] |
|
[39.] |
|
[40.] |
Sugahara Y, Takigami T, Koganei R (2009) Suppression of vertical bending vibration in railway car bodies by primary suspension damping control (results of running tests using shinkansen vehicles). In: Proceedings of the 21st international symposium on dynamics of vehicle on roads and tracks (IAVSD 2009), pp 1–12
|
[41.] |
|
[42.] |
|
[43.] |
|
[44.] |
|
[45.] |
|
[46.] |
Gong D, Zhou J, Sun W, Goodall R (2011) Effects of active primary suspension on vertical ride quality control of flexible car body and its comparison with those of active secondary suspension. In: Proceedings of the 22nd international symposium on dynamics of vehicles on roads tracks (IAVSD 2011), vol 1, no 1, pp 1–6
|
[47.] |
|
[48.] |
|
[49.] |
Hirata T, Takahashi R (1993) H_inf control of railroad vehicle active suspension. In: Proceedings of the 32nd conference on decision and control, pp 2937–2942
|
[50.] |
|
[51.] |
|
[52.] |
Kamada T, Mikazuki T, Nagai M (2011) Active vibration suppression of railway vehicle by air actuators. In: Proceedings of the 22nd international symposium on dynamics of vehicle on roads and tracks (IAVSD 2011), pp 1–6
|
[53.] |
Kamada T, Makino T (2013) Active vertical elastic vibration suppression of railway vehicle by air spring suspension. In: Proceedings of the 23rd international symposium on dynamics of vehicle on roads and tracks (IAVSD 2013), pp 1–7
|
[54.] |
|
[55.] |
|
[56.] |
|
[57.] |
|
[58.] |
|
[59.] |
|
[60.] |
Allen DH (1994) Active bumpstop hold-off device. In: Proc IMechE conference Railtech 94, p. paper C478/5/013
|
[61.] |
|
[62.] |
|
[63.] |
|
[64.] |
|
[65.] |
Hudha K, Harun MH, Harun MH, Jamaluddin H (2011) Lateral suspension control of railway vehicle using semi-active magnetorheological damper. In: 2011 IEEE intelligent vehicles symposium (IV), No. IV, pp 728–733
|
[66.] |
|
[67.] |
|
[68.] |
|
[69.] |
|
[70.] |
|
[71.] |
|
[72.] |
|
[73.] |
Trafikverket. “Gröna Tåget. http://www.gronataget.se. Accessed 2019
|
[74.] |
|
[75.] |
|
[76.] |
|
[77.] |
|
[78.] |
Sasaki K, Kamoshita S, Enomoto M (2002) A design and bench test of multi-modal active suspension of railway vehicle. In: Proceedings of IECON’94—20th annual conference of IEEE industrial electronics, vol 3, pp 2011–2016
|
[79.] |
|
[80.] |
|
[81.] |
Goto O (2013) Development of active suspension system with electromechanical actuators for railway vehicles
|
[82.] |
|
[83.] |
|
[84.] |
|
[85.] |
|
[86.] |
|
[87.] |
|
[88.] |
|
[89.] |
|
[90.] |
|
[91.] |
|
[92.] |
|
[93.] |
|
[94.] |
|
[95.] |
Fu B, Bruni S (2020) Fault-tolerant analysis for active steering actuation system applied on conventional Bogie vehicle. In: Klomp M, Bruzelius F, Nielsen J, Hillemyr A (eds) Advances in dynamics of vehicles on roads and tracks. IAVSD 2019. Lecture notes in mechanical engineering. Springer, Cham
|
[96.] |
|
[97.] |
|
[98.] |
|
[99.] |
|
[100.] |
|
[101.] |
|
[102.] |
|
[103.] |
|
[104.] |
|
[105.] |
|
[106.] |
|
[107.] |
|
[108.] |
|
[109.] |
|
[110.] |
Giossi RL, Persson R, Stichel S (2020) Gain scaling for active wheelset steering on innovative two-axle vehicle. In: Klomp M, Bruzelius F, Nielsen J, Hillemyr A (eds) Advances in dynamics of vehicles on roads and tracks. IAVSD 2019. Lecture notes in mechanical engineering. Springer, Cham
|
[111.] |
|
[112.] |
|
[113.] |
|
[114.] |
|
[115.] |
|
[116.] |
|
[117.] |
|
[118.] |
Ishiguri K, Shimoda K, Yamanaga Y, Kamoshita S, Ishige M (2011) Analysis of failsafe hydraulic actuation system using passive relief valves; application for power assisting devices. In: Proceedings of the 8th JFPS international symposium of fluid power, pp 413–418
|
[119.] |
|
[120.] |
CRRC. CETROVO carbon-fibre metro vehicles. https://railway-news.com/crrc-global-release-cetrovo-carbon-fibre-metro-vehicles/. Accessed 2019
|
[121.] |
Bombardier. TWINDEXX double-deck trains. https://www.railway-technology.com/projects/bombardier-twindexx-double-deck-trains/. Accessed 2019
|
[122.] |
Goodall R, Mei TX (2001) Mechatronic strategies for controlling railway wheelsets with independently rotating wheels. In: 2001 IEEE/ASME international conference on advanced intelligent mechatronics. Proceedings (Cat. No.01TH8556), vol 1, no. July, pp 225–230
|
[123.] |
|
[124.] |
Kurzeck B, Valente L (2011) A novel mechatronic running gear: concept, simulation and scaled roller rig testing. In: 9th world congress railway research, pp 1–10
|
[125.] |
Meyer A (2016) Wheel sets or independently rotating wheels—from theory to practice. Siemens AG, pp 1–12
|
[126.] |
|
[127.] |
Sugiyama H, Matsumura R, Suda Y, Ezaki H (1882) Analysis of independently rotating wheel system using multibody dynamics approach. In: Volume 4: 7th international conference on multibody systems, nonlinear dynamics, and control, parts A, B and C, pp 1875–1882
|
[128.] |
|
[129.] |
|
[130.] |
Aknin P, Ayasse JB, Devallez A (1992) Active steering of railway wheelsets. In: Proceedings of the 12th IAVSD conference
|
[131.] |
|
[132.] |
|
[133.] |
Suda Y (2008) The possibility of a new concept of self-steering truck with independently rotating wheels. J-RAIL 2008, pp 473–476
|
[134.] |
|
[135.] |
|
[136.] |
|
[137.] |
|
[138.] |
|
[139.] |
Liang B, Iwnicki SD (2007) An experimental study of independently rotating wheels for railway vehicles. In: 2007 International conference on mechatronics and automation, pp 2282–2286
|
[140.] |
|
[141.] |
|
[142.] |
|
[143.] |
|
[144.] |
|
[145.] |
|
[146.] |
|
[147.] |
|
[148.] |
Heckmann A, Daniel L, Grether G, Keck A (2017) From scaled experiments of mechatronic guidance to multibody simulations of DLR’s next generation train set. In: Proceedings of the 25th international symposium on dynamics of vehicle on roads and tracks (IAVSD 2017)
|
[149.] |
Grether G, Heckmann A, Looye G (2020) Lateral guidance cntrol using information of preceding wheel pairs. In: Klomp M, Bruzelius F, Nielsen J, Hillemyr A (eds) Advances in dynamics of vehicles on roads and tracks. IAVSD 2019. Lecture notes in mechanical engineering. Springer, Cham
|
[150.] |
|
[151.] |
|
[152.] |
|
[153.] |
|
[154.] |
Michitsuji Y, Shiga R, Suda Y, Lin S, Makishima S (2017) Dynamics of vehicles on roads and tracks. In: Proceedings of the 25th international symposium on dynamics of vehicle on roads and tracks (IAVSD 2017), vol 2, pp 993–998
|
[155.] |
Michitsuji Y, Mizuno K, Suda Y, Lin S, Makishima S (2020) Curving performance evaluation of EEF bogie with inclined wheel axles using scale model vehicle. In: Klomp M, Bruzelius F, Nielsen J, Hillemyr A (eds) Advances in dynamics of vehicles on roads and tracks. IAVSD 2019. Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering. Springer, Cham
|
[156.] |
Liu X, Goodall R, Iwnicki S (2020) A direct control approach for automatic steering and stability of motorized independently-rotating wheels. In: Klomp M, Bruzelius F, Nielsen J, Hillemyr A (eds) Advances in Dynamics of Vehicles on Roads and Tracks. IAVSD 2019. Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering. Springer, Cham
|
[157.] |
|
[158.] |
|
[159.] |
|
[160.] |
|
[161.] |
|
/
〈 |
|
〉 |