A review of crosslinked fracturing fluids prepared with produced water

Abstract

The rapidly increasing implementations of oilfield technologies such as horizontal wells and multistage hydraulic fracturing, particularly in unconventional formations, have expanded the need for fresh water in many oilfield locations. In the meantime, it is costly for services companies and operators to properly dispose large volumes of produced water, generated annually at about 21 billion barrels in the United States alone. The high operating costs in obtaining fresh water and dealing with produced water have motivated scientists and engineers, especially in recent years, to use produced water in place of fresh water to formulate well treatment fluids. The objective of this brief review is to provide a summary of the up-to-date technologies of reusing oilfield produced water in preparations of a series of crosslinked fluids implemented mainly in hydraulic fracturing operations. The crosslinked fluids formulated with produced water include borate-and metal-crosslinked guar and derivatized guar fluids, as well as other types of crosslinked fluid systems such as crosslinked synthetic polymer fluids and crosslinked derivatized cellulose fluids. The borate-crosslinked guar fluids have been successfully formulated with produced water and used in oilfield operations with bottomhole temperatures up to about 250 °F. The produced water sources involved showed total dissolved solids (TDS) up to about 115,000 mg/L and hardness up to about 11,000 mg/L. The metal-crosslinked guar fluids prepared with produced water were successfully used in wells at bottomhole temperatures up to about 250 °F, with produced water TDS up to about 300,000 mg/L and hardness up to about 44,000 mg/L. The Zr-crosslinked carboxymethyl hydroxypropyl guar (CMHPG) fluids have been successfully made with produced water and implemented in operations with bottomhole temperatures at about 250+ °F, with produced water TDS up to about 280,000 mg/L and hardness up to about 91,000 mg/L. In most of the cases investigated, the produced water involved was either untreated, or the treatments were minimum such as simple filtration without significantly changing the concentrations of monovalent and divalent ions in the water. Due to the compositional similarity (high salinity and hardness) between produced water and seawater, crosslinked fluids formulated with seawater for offshore and onshore jobs were also included. The crosslinked guar and derivatized guar fluids have been successfully formulated with seawater for operations at bottomhole temperatures up to about 300 °F. Operating costs have been significantly reduced when produced water or seawater is used to formulate fracturing fluids in place of fresh water. With various challenges and limitations still existing, the paper emphasizes the needs for new developments and further expansion of produced water reuse in oilfield operations.

Keywords

Produced water / Produced water reuse / Seawater / Fracturing fluid / Crosslinked fluid / Borate crosslinker / Metal crosslinker / Guar / Derivatized guar

Acknowledgments

The Authors would like to thank Aramco Services Company and Saudi Aramco for permission to publish this paper.

References

[1] C.E. Clark, J.A. Veil, Produced Water Volumes and Management Practices in the United States, ANL/EVS/R-09/1, Prepared by Environmental Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory, 2009.

[2] L. Gandossi, U. Von Estorff, An Overview of Hydraulic Fracturing and Other Formation Stimulation Technologies for Shale Gas Production e Update, 2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.2790/379646. EUR 26347.

[3] Energy-Water Nexus,Information on the Quantity, Quality, and Management of Water Produced during Oil and Gas Production, GAO-12-156, by United States Government Accountability Office, 2012.

[4] Management of Produced Water from Oil and Gas Wells, Paper #2-17, Prepared by the Technology Subgroup of the Operations & Environment Task Group, Working Document of the NPC (National Petroleum Council) North American Resource Development Study, 2011.

[5] D.V.S. Gupta, P.S. Carman, R. Venugopal, A Stable Fracturing Fluid for Produced Water Applications, 2012. SPE 159837.

[6] K. Benko, J. Drewes, Produced water in the western United States: geographical distribution, occurrence, and composition, Environ. Eng. Sci. 25 (2) (2008) 239-246.

[7] J.A. Salvato, N.L. Nemerow, F.J. Agardy,Environmental Engineering, fifth ed., John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, New Jersey, 2003.

[8] A.P. Bunger, J. McLennan, R. Jeffrey, Effective and Sustainable Hydraulic Fracturing, InTech, 2013.

[9] M.G. Puder, J.A. Veil, Options, methods and costs for offsite commercial disposal of oil and gas exploration and production wastes, SPE Proj. Fac. Constr. 2 (4) (2007) 1-6.

[10] G.E. King, Hydraulic Fracturing 101: What Every Representative, Environmentalist, Regulator, Reporter, Investor, University Researcher, Neighbor and Engineer Should Know about Estimating Frac Risk and Improving Frac Performance in Unconventional Gas and Oil Wells, 2012. SPE 152596.

[11] C.T. Montgomery, M.B. Smith, Hydraulic fracturing: history of an enduring technology, J. Petrol. Tech. 62 (12) (2010) 26-32.

[12] J.K. Fink, Oil Field Chemicals, Gulf Professional Publishing, Elsevier Science, Burlington, MA, 2003.

[13] M. Samuel, R.J. Card, E.B. Nelson, J.E. Brown, P.S. Vinod, H.L. Temple, Q. Qu,D. Fu, Polymer-free Fluid for Hydraulic Fracturing, 1997. SPE 38622.

[14] S. Kefi, J. Lee, T. Pope, P. Sullivan, E. Nelson, A. Hernandez, T. Olsen, M. Parlar, B. Powers, A. Roy, A. Wilson, A. Twynam, Expanding applications for viscoelastic surfactants, Oilfield Rev. 16 (4) (2004) 10-23.

[15] G.A. Al-Muntasheri, A critical review of hydraulic fracturing fluids over the last decade, SPE Prod. Oper. 29 (4) (2014) 243-260.

[16] T.T. Palisch, M. Vincent, P.J. Handren, Slickwater Fracturing: Food for Thought, 2008. SPE 115766.

[17] J. Weaver, E. Schmelzl, M. Jamieson, G. Schiffner, New Fluid Technology Allows Fracturing without Internal Breakers, 2002. SPE 75690.

[18] R.L. Whistler, J.N. BeMiller, Industrial Gums:Polysaccharides and Their Derivatives, third ed.ed., Academic Press, San Diego, CA, 1993.

[19] L.R. Kern,Method and Composition for Formation Fracturing, 1962. US Patent No. 3058909.

[20] R. Barati, J. Liang, A review of fracturing fluid systems used for hydraulic fracturing of oil and gas wells, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 131 (16) (2014) 40735.

[21] P. Rae,G. di Lullo, Fracturing Fluids and Breaker Systems -A Review of the State-of-the-art, 1996. SPE 37359.

[22] K.K. Chong, W.V. Grieser, A. Passman, H.C. Tamayo, N. Modeland, B.E. Burke, A Completions Guide Book to Shale-play Development: A Review of Successful Approaches toward Shale-play Stimulation in the Last Two Decades, 2010. SPE 133874.

[23] P.S. Patel, C.J. Robart, M. Ruegamer, A. Yang,Analysis of US Hydraulic Fracturing Fluid System and Proppant Trends, 2014. SPE 168645.

[24] M. Reed, S. Johnsen, Produced Water 2: Environmental Issues and Mitigation Technologies, Plenum Press, New York, 1996.

[25] L. Li, C.I. Ezeokonkwo, L. Lin, K.E. Eliseeva, W. Kallio, C.L. Boney, P.R. Howard, M.M. Samuel, Well Treatment Fluids Prepared with Oilfield Produced Water: Part II, 2010. SPE 133379.

[26] J. Veil, Produced Water Volumes and Management Practices in 2012, Prepared for the Ground Water Protection Council (GWPC), 2015.

[27] P.L. Younger, Groundwater in the Environment:an Introduction, Blackwell Publishing, Malden, MA, 2007.

[28] P. Boschee, Produced and flowback water recycling and reuse: economics, limitations, and technology, Oil Gas. Facil. 3 (1) (2014) 16-22.

[29] K.S. Bankole, M. Blauch, Applications of oilfield produced formation water for fracturing fluid, Res. J. Appl. Sci. Eng. Technol. 7 (11) (2014) 2208-2216.

[30] D.D. Schmidt, B.A. Mackay, B.L. Williams, F.E. Beck, A.B. Bell, B.W. Mcmahon, H. Bradley, E.G. Lian, Overcoming Obstacles for Produced Water in Bakken Well Stimulations, 2015. SPE 173372.

[31] B. McMahon, B. MacKay, A. Mirakyan,First 100% Reuse of Bakken Produced Water in Hybrid Treatments Using Inexpensive Polysaccharide Gelling Agents, 2015. SPE 173783.

[32] S. Kakadjian, J. Thompson, R. Torres, Fracturing Fluids from Produced Water, 2015. SPE 173602.

[33] J.A. Veil, C.E. Clark, Produced water volume estimates and management practices, SPE Prod. Oper. 26 (03) (2011) 234-239.

[34] B. Ruyle, F.E. Fragachan,Quantifiable Costs Savings by Using 100% Raw Produced Water in Hydraulic Fracturing, 2015. SPE 177135.

[35] P. Das, S. Konale, R. Kothamasu, Effect of Salt Concentration on Base-Gel Viscosity of Different Polymers Used in Stimulation Fluid Systems, 2014. SPE 167786.

[36] A. Haghshenas, H.A. Nasr-El-Din, Effect of Dissolved Solids on Reuse of Produced Water in Hydraulic Fracturing Jobs, 2014. SPE 168614.

[37] N. Esmaeilirad, S. White, C. Terry, A. Prior, K. Carlson, Influence of inorganic ions in recycled produced water on gel-based hydraulic fracturing fluid viscosity, J. Pet. Sci. Eng. 139 (2016) 104-111.

[38] L. Li, Q. Qu, H. Sun, J. Zhou, M. Legemah, How Extremely High-TDS Produced Water Compositions Affect Selection of Fracturing Fluid Additives, 2015. SPE 173746.

[39] P. Horner, J.A. Anderson, M. Thompson, Mobile Clarification for Re-use of Unconventional Oil and Gas Produced Water to Reduce Costs and Minimize Environmental Footprint, 2013. SPE 168736.

[40] J. Younker, S.Y. Lee, G.A. Gagnon, M.E. Walsh, Atlantic Canada Offshore R&D: Treatment of Oilfield Produced Water by Chemical Coagulation and Electrocoagulation, 2011. OTC 22003.

[41] P.D. Lord, R. LeBas, Treatment enables high-TDS water use as base fluid for hydraulic fracturing, J. Petrol. Tech. 65 (06) (2013) 30-33.

[42] J.W. Farrell, T. Baudendistel, M. Kidder, Water-flexible Fracturing Systems, 2015. SPE 178699.

[43] L. Li, P.R. Howard, M.D. Parris, B. Lungwitz, C.L. Boney, K.W. England, R.D. Hutchins, J. Li,Treatment and Reuse of Oilfield Produced Water, 2008. US Patent Application No. 20080287323 A1.

[44] L. Li, K.E. Eliseeva, V. Eliseev, O.A. Bustos, K.W. England, P.R. Howard, C.L. Boney, M.D. Parris, S.A. Ali, Well Treatment Fluids Prepared with Oilfield Produced Water, 2009. SPE 124212.

[45] A. Fedorov, A. Cox, Addressing the Water Issues of Tomorrow, 2013. SPE 167229.

[46] E. Lopez, T. Nelson, D.M. Bishop,Achieving a Stable Native Guar Boron Crosslink in 100% Produced Water, 2015. SPE 173735.

[47] J.C. Bonapace, M. Giglio, J. Moggia, M. Krenz, Water Conservation: Reducing Freshwater Consumption by Using Produced Water for Base Fluid in Hydraulic Fracturing-case Histories in Argentina, 2012. SPE 151819.

[48] J.C. Bonapace, Water Management for Tight and Shale Reservoir: A Review of what Has Been Learned and what Should Be Considered for Development in Argentina, 2015. SPE 174119.

[49] S. Kakadjian, J. Thompson, R. Torres, A. Pontifes, A. Rodriguez, Y.A. Hamlat, Permian Frac Systems Using Produced Water, 2015. SPE 172811.

[50] R.C. Ropp, Encyclopedia of the Alkaline Earth Compounds, Elsevier, Oxford, UK, 2013.

[51] A.R. Hasan, C.S. Kabir, Fluid Flow and Heat Transfer in Wellbores, Society of Petroleum Engineers, Richardson, TX, 2002.

[52] B. McMahon, B. MacKay, A. Mirakyan,Method of Reusing Untreated Produced Water in Hydraulic Fracturing, US Patent Application No. 20160230082 A1, 2016.

[53] F. Huang, R.S. Gundewar, D.L. Steed, B.W. Loughridge, Feasibility of Using Produced Water for Crosslinked Gel-based Hydraulic Fracturing, 2005. SPE 94320.

[54] R.A. Lebas, P. Lord, D. Luna, T.W. Shahan, Development and Use of High-TDS Recycled Produced Water for Crosslinked-gel-based Hydraulic Fracturing, 2013. SPE 163824.

[55] Q. Qu, L. Li, H. Sun, M. Legemah, J. Zhou,Well Treatment Methods and Fluids, US Patent Application No. 20150240149 A1, 2015.

[56] J. Zhou, M. Legemah, B. Beall, H. Sun, Q. Qu, Alternative Polysaccharide Fracturing Fluids for Harsh Reservoir Conditions, 2013. SPE 167033.

[57] J. Zhou, M. Legemah, H. Sun, B. Beall, Q. Qu,Well Treatment Fluids and Methods, US Patent Application No. 20150041139 A1, 2015.

[58] N. Gaillard, A. Thomas, C. Favero, Novel Associative Acrylamide-based Polymers for Proppant Transport in Hydraulic Fracturing Fluids, 2013. SPE 164072.

[59] L. Li, H. Sun, Q. Qu, H.V. Le, M. Ault, J. Zhou, M.C. Guerin, M. Legemah, D. Smith, High-temperature Fracturing Fluids Prepared with Extremely High-TDS and Hard Produced Water, 2014. SPE 170607.

[60] L. Li, H. Sun, Q. Qu, M.P. Mehle, M.G. Ault, A. Morse, J. Zhou, D.D. Smith, High-temperature Fracturing Fluids Using Produced Water with Extremely High TDS and Hardness, 2014. IPTC 17797.

[61] G.H. Monreal, S.O. N'Guessan, P. McElfresh, A New Generation of Efficient Fracturing Fluids for High Total Dissolved Solids Applications, 2014. SPE 168192.

[62] G.A. Stahl, D.N. Schulz, Water-soluble Polymers for Petroleum Recovery, Springer, New York, 1988.

[63] S.A. Ali, W.M. Pickering, B.C. Sketchler, R.J. Powell, P.C. Harris, S.K. Smith, S. Vitthal, Offshore frac packs benefit from seawater-based borate fluid, Oil Gas. J. 96 (39) (1998) 49-62.

[64] R.J. Powell, M.A. McCabe, B.F. Slabaugh, J.M. Terracina,T. McPike, Gulf of Mexico Frac-and-pack Treatments Using a New Fracturing Fluid System, 1998. SPE 39897.

[65] V.V. Tran, L.D. Duong, D.Q. Nguyen, A. Makmun, L.T. Tran, L.K. Teng, E.V. Feng, Vietnam Offshore Operator Improved Production after Fracturing by Pumping Proppant Utilizing Seawater-based Fluid, 2015. SPE 176149.

[66] H. Le, R. Wood, New frac fluid enhances options for offshore wells, Ocean. Ind. 27 (2) (1992) 49-52.

[67] P.C. Harris,D. van Batenburg, A Comparison of Freshwater-and Seawaterbased Borate-crosslinked Fracturing Fluids, 1998. SPE 50777.

[68] A.S. de Kruijf, L.P. Roodhart, D.R. Davies, Relation between chemistry and flow mechanics of borate crosslinked fracturing fluids, SPE Prod. Facil. 8 (3) (1993) 165-170.

[69] J.M. Bagzis, C.D. Wehunt, E.B. Neubauer, R.P. Jansson, R. Tjoonk, L.N. Roueche, B. Scarborough, Optimized Hydraulic Fracturing Improves Oil Production in the N'Dola Field, Offshore Angola, 1998. SPE 49108.

[70] M.E. Langford, B. Holland, C.A. Green, B. Bocaneala, M.R. Norris, Offshore Horizontal Well Fracturing: Operational Optimization in the Southern North Sea, 2013. SPE 166550.

[71] Y. Gao, Y. Shi, F. Zhou, M. Xu, X. Yang, C. Xiong, X. Han, Development and Application of Continuously Mixing Seawater-based Fracturing Fluid System, 2015. SPE 176494.

[72] T. AlMubarak, M. AlKhaldi, A. AlGhamdi, Design and Application of High Temperature Seawater Based Fracturing Fluids in Saudi Arabia, 2016. OTC-26822.

[73] L.K. Vo, B. Sparks, C. Parton, J. Cortez, T. Green, Novel Low-residue High Brine Fracturing Fluid, 2014. AAD--14-FTCE-36.

[74] L. Li, G.A. Al-Muntasheri, F. Liang, Nanomaterials-enhanced Hightemperature Fracturing Fluids Prepared with Untreated Seawater, 2016. SPE 181283.

[75] A.N. Martin, S. Austin, A. Glennie, J. Martinez, S. Bradford,Lessons Learned from 27 Years' Experience of Stimulation Vessel Design and Operation -A Case Study, 2013. SPE 166243.

[76] B. Bocaneala, C. Barrett, B. Holland, M.E. Langford, K. McIntosh, G. Nitters, M.R. Norris, K. Orski, The Evolution of Completion Practices and Reservoir Stimulation Techniques in the North Sea, 2015. SPE 175443.

[77] M.S. Van Domelen, R.C. Jacquier,M.W. Sanders, State-of-the-Art Fracturing in the North Sea, 1995. OTC 7890.