Evaluation on the anisotropic brittleness index of shale rock using geophysical logging

Abstract

The brittleness index plays a significant role in the hydraulic fracturing design and wellbore stability analysis of shale reservoirs. Various brittleness indices have been proposed to characterize the brittleness of shale rocks, but almost all of them ignored the anisotropy of the brittleness index. Therefore, uniaxial compression testing integrated with geophysical logging was used to provide insights into the anisotropy of the brittleness index for Longmaxi shale, the presented method was utilized to assess brittleness index of Longmaxi shale formation for the interval of 3155-3175 m in CW-1 well. The results indicated that the brittleness index of Longmaxi shale showed a distinct anisotropy, and it achieved the minimum value at β = 45°-60°. As the bedding angle increased, the observed brittleness index (BI_{2_β}) decreased firstly and increased then, it achieved the lowest value at β = 40°-60°, and it is consistent with the uniaxial compression testing results. Compared to the isotropic brittleness index (β = 0°), the deviation of the anisotropic brittleness index ranged from 10% to 66.7%, in other words, the anisotropy of brittleness index cannot be ignored for Longmaxi shale. Organic matter content is one of the main intrinsic causes of shale anisotropy, and the anisotropy degree of the brittleness index generally increases with the increase in organic matter content. The present work is valuable for the assessment of anisotropic brittleness for hydraulic fracturing design and wellbore stability analysis.

Keywords

Shale rock / Brittleness / Brittleness index / Anisotropy / Transverse isotropy / Geophysical logging

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the post-doctoral project of Petrochina Southwest Oil & Gas Field Company “Research on Deep Shale Geomechanics and Effective Fracturing Factors” (Grant No. 20210302-31), the Program of Introducing Talents of Discipline to Chinese Universities (111 Plan) (Grant No. D18016), the Sichuan Science and Technology Program (Grant No. 2020JDJQ0055), the Nanchong-SWPU Science and Technology Strategic Cooperation Foundation (Grant No. SXHZ033), the Youth Scientific and Technological Innovation Team Foundation of SWPU (Grant No. 2019CXTD09).

References

[1] Q. Wang, X. Chen, A.N. Jha, H. Rogers, Natural gas from shale formationethe evolution, evidences and challenges of shale gas revolution in United States, Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 30 (2014) 1-28.

[2] J. Zhang, B. Xu, H. Nie, Z. Wang, T. Lin, Exploration potential of shale gas resources in China, Nat. Gas. Ind. 28 (6) (2008) 136-140.

[3] C. Zou, D. Dong, Y. Wang, X. Li, J. Huang, S. Wang, Q. Guan, C. Zhang, H. Wang, H. Liu, W. Bai, F. Liang, W. Lin, Q. Zhao, D. Liu, Z. Yang, P. Liang, S. Sun, Z. Qiu, Shale gas in China: characteristics, challenges and prospects (I), Petrol. Explor. Dev. 42 (6) (2015) 753-767.

[4] C. Zou, D. Dong, Y. Wang, X. Li, J. Huang, S. Wang, Q. Guan, C. Zhang, H. Wang, H. Liu, W. Bai, F. Liang, W. Lin, Q. Zhao, D. Liu, Z. Yang, P. Liang, S. Sun, Z. Qiu, Shale gas in China: characteristics, challenges and prospects (II), Petrol. Explor. Dev. 43 (2) (2016) 182-196.

[5] H. Zhao, W. Li, H. Pu, K. Yang, Formation applicability analysis of stimulated reservoir volume fracturing and case analysis, Petroleum 7 (2) (2021) 160-167.

[6] T. Ma, P. Chen, J. Zhao, Overview on vertical and directional drilling technologies for the exploration and exploitation of deep petroleum resources, Geomech. Geophys. Geoenergy Geo Res 2 (4) (2016) 365-395.

[7] M. Bai, Why are brittleness and fracability not equivalent in designing hydraulic fracturing in tight shale gas reservoirs, Petroleum 2 (1) (2016) 1-19.

[8] X. Cao, M. Wang, J. Kang, S. Wang, Y. Liang, Fracturing technologies of deep shale gas horizontal wells in the Weirong Block, southern Sichuan Basin, Nat. Gas. Ind. B 7 (1) (2020) 64-70.

[9] T. Ma, P. Chen, Study of meso-damage characteristics of shale hydration based on CT scanning technology, Petrol. Explor. Dev. 41 (2) (2014) 249-256.

[10] H. Nie, Q. Chen, G. Zhang, C. Sun, P. Wang, Z. Lu, An overview of the characteristic of typical WufengeLongmaxi shale gas fields in the Sichuan Basin, China, Nat. Gas. Ind. B 8 (3) (2021) 217-230.

[11] L. Huang, X. Liu, J. Xiong, L. Liang, Experimental on the pore structure characteristics of Longmaxi Formation shale in southern Sichuan Basin, China, Petroleum 7 (2) (2021) 135-141.

[12] H. Nie, Z. He, G. Liu, W. Du, R. Wang, G. Zhang, Genetic mechanism of highquality shale gas reservoirs in the WufengeLongmaxiFms in the Sichuan Basin, Nat. Gas. Ind. B 8 (1) (2021) 24-34.

[13] S. Chen, C. Zhang, X. Li, Y. Zhang, X. Wang, Simulation of methane adsorption in diverse organic pores in shale reservoirs with multi-period geological evolution, Int. J. Coal. Sci. Technol. 8 (5) (2021) 844-855.

[14] K. Chen, J. Li, X. Tang, J. Shen, P. Wang, J. Peng, Key geological factors for shale gas accumulation in the WufengeLongmaxi Fms in the central Yangtze area, Nat. Gas. Ind. B 8 (1) (2021) 1-12.

[15] Y. Jiang, Y. Fu, J. Xie, D. Dong, K. Zhou, X. Cheng, L. Qi, H. Zhang, C. Chen, T. Ma, Y. Gu, Development trend of marine shale gas reservoir evaluation and a suitable comprehensive evaluation system, Nat. Gas. Ind. B 7 (3) (2020) 205-214.

[16] J. Gui, T. Ma, P. Chen, H. Yuan, Z. Guo, Anisotropic damage to hard brittle shale with stress and hydration coupling, Energies 11 (4) (2018) 926.

[17] Z. Xiao, S. Jia, X. Qi, Y. Dai, F. Lü, L. Jia, C. Wen, Hydraulic-mechanical-chemical coupling evaluation for progressive failure of hard brittle shale wellbore, J. Cent. S. Univ. 50 (10) (2019) 2464-2480.

[18] R.M. Holt, E. Fjær, J.F. Stenebråten, O.M. Nes, Brittleness of shales: relevance to borehole collapse and hydraulic fracturing, J. Petrol. Sci. Eng. 131 (2015) 200-209.

[19] D. Zhang, P.G. Ranjith, M.S.A. Perera, The brittleness indices used in rock mechanics and their application in shale hydraulic fracturing: a review, J. Petrol. Sci. Eng. 143 (2016) 158-170.

[20] F. Meng, L.N.Y. Wong, H. Zhou, Rock brittleness indices and their applications to different fields of rock engineering: a review, J. Rock Mech. Geotech. Eng. 13 (1) (2021) 221-247.

[21] E. Rybacki, T. Meier, G. Dresen, What controls the mechanical properties of shale rocks?ePart II: Brittleness, J. Petrol. Sci. Eng. 144 (2016) 39-58.

[22] C.H. Sondergeld, K.E. Newsham, J.T. Comisky, M.C. Rice, C.S. Rai, Petrophysical considerations in evaluating and producing shale gas resources, in: SPE Unconventional Gas Conference. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA, February 2010, pp. 23-25.

[23] F.P. Wang, J.F. Gale, Screening criteria for shale-gas systems, Gulf coast Assoc. Geol. Soc. Trans. 59 (2009) 779-793.

[24] G.C. Xu, G.H. Zhong, B. Xie, T.J. Huang, Petrophysical experiment-based logging evaluation method of shale brittleness, Nat. Gas. Ind. 34 (12) (2014) 38-45.

[25] R. Rickman, M.J. Mullen, J.E. Petre, W.V. Grieser, D. Kundert, A practical use of shale petrophysics for stimulation design optimization: all shale plays are not clones of the Barnett Shale,in:SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Denver, Colorado, USA, September 2008, pp. 21-24.

[26] X. Jin, S.N. Shah, J.C. Roegiers, B. Zhang, Fracability evaluation in shale reservoirs-An integrated petrophysics and geomechanics approach, in: SPE Hydraulic Fracturing Technology Conference, The Woodlands, Texas, USA, February 2014, pp. 4-6.

[27] H. Diao, Rock mechanical properties and brittleness evaluation of shale reservoir, Acta Petrol. Sin. 29 (9) (2013) 3300-3306.

[28] Z. Liu, Z. Sun, New brittleness indexes and their application in shale/clay gas reservoir prediction, Petrol. Explor. Dev. 42 (1) (2015) 129-137.

[29] B. Tarasov, Y. Potvin, Universal criteria for rock brittleness estimation under triaxial compression, Int. J. Rock Mech. Min. Sci. 59 (2013) 57-69.

[30] H. Munoz, A. Taheri, E.K. Chanda, Fracture energy-based brittleness index development and brittleness quantification by pre-peak strength parameters in rock uniaxial compression, Rock Mech. Rock Eng. 49 (12) (2016) 4587-4606.

[31] K.I. Rahimzadeh, M. Ameri, H. Molladavoodi, Shale brittleness evaluation based on energy balance analysis of stress-strain curves, J. Petrol. Sci. Eng. 167 (2018) 1-19.

[32] J. Zuo, J. Wang, Y. Jiang, Macro/meso failure behavior of surrounding rock in deep roadway and its control technology, Int. J. Coal. Sci. Technol. 6 (3) (2019) 301-319.

[33] B.H. Kim, G. Walton, M.K. Larson, S. Berry, Investigation of the anisotropic confinement-dependent brittleness of a Utah coal, Int. J. Coal. Sci. Technol. 8 (2) (2021) 274-290.

[34] J. Gui, P. Chen, T. Ma, The spatial distribution of elastic parameters of orthotropic rocks, J. Southwest Petrol. Univ. (Sci. Technol. Ed.) 41 (3) (2019) 13-28.

[35] T. Ma, Q.B. Zhang, P. Chen, C. Yang, J. Zhao, Fracture pressure model for inclined wells in layered formations with anisotropic rock strengths, J. Petrol. Sci. Eng. 149 (2017) 393-408.

[36] T. Ma, B. Wu, J. Fu, Q. Zhang, P. Chen, Fracture pressure prediction for layered formations with anisotropic rock strengths, J. Nat. Gas Sci. Eng. 38 (2017) 485-503.

[37] T. Ma, Y. Liu, P. Chen, B. Wu, J. Fu, Z. Guo, Fracture-initiation pressure prediction for transversely isotropic formations, J. Petrol. Sci. Eng. 176 (2019) 821-835.

[38] T. Ma, N. Peng, Z. Zhu, Q. Zhang, C. Yang, J. Zhao, Brazilian tensile strength of anisotropic rocks: review and new insights, Energies 11 (2) (2018) 304.

[39] A. Jamshidi, M. Torabi-Kaveh, M.R. Nikudel, Effect of anisotropy on the strength and brittleness indices of laminated sandstone, Iran. J. Sci. Technol. Trans. A-Science 45 (3) (2021) 927-936.

[40] Z. Hou, C. Yang, X. Wei, L. Wang, Y. Wei, F. Xu, H. Wang, Experimental study on the brittle characteristics of Longmaxi formation shale, J. China Coal Soc. 41 (5) (2016) 1188-1196.

[41] Z. Geng, M. Chen, Y. Jin, S. Yang, Z. Yi, X. Fang, X. Du, Experimental study of brittleness anisotropy of shale in triaxial compression, J. Nat. Gas Sci. Eng. 36 (2016) 510-518.

[42] H. Wang, D. Liu, Z. Huang, G. Yuan, X. Lü, J. Niu, Z. Zhao, X. Shi, Mechanical properties and brittleness evaluation of layered shale rock, J. Eng. Geol. 25 (6) (2017) 1414-1423.

[43] J. Zhang, C. Ai, Y. Li, J. Zeng, D. Qiu, Brittleness evaluation index based on energy variation in the whole process of rock failure, Chin. J. Rock Mech. Eng. 36 (6) (2017) 1326-1340.

[44] T. Ma, N. Peng, G. Zhu, P. Chen, H. Xia, Experimental investigation of anisotropic brittleness under confining pressure for gas shale rocks, in: 53rd US Rock Mechanics Geomechanics Symposium, New York, USA, June, 2019, pp. 23-26.

[45] Y. Liu, T. Ma, H. Wu, P. Chen, Investigation on mechanical behaviors of shale cap rock for geological energy storage by linking macroscopic to mesoscopic failures, J. Energy Storage 29 (2020), 101326.

[46] J. Gui, T. Ma, P. Chen, Rock physics modeling of transversely isotropic shale: an example of the Longmaxi formation in the Sichuan basin, Chin. J. Geophys. 63 (11) (2020) 4188-4204.

[47] T. Ma, J. Gui, P. Chen, Logging evaluation on mechanical-damage characteristics of the vicinity of the wellbore in tight reservoirs, J. Pet. Explor. Prod. Technol. 11 (8) (2021) 3213-3224.

[48] Z. Liu, L. Song, C. Wang, T. Sun, X. Yang, X. Li, Evaluation method of the least horizontal principal stress by logging data in anisotropic fast formation, Petrol. Explor. Dev. 44 (5) (2017) 745-752.

[49] J. Walsh, B. Sinha, A. Donald, Formation anisotropy parameters using borehole sonic data, in: SPWLA 47th Annual Logging Symposium, Veracruz, Mexico, USA, 4-7 June 2006.

[50] D. Denney, Improving horizontal completions in heterogeneous tight shales, J. Petrol. Technol. 64 (10) (2012) 126-130.

[51] C. Yao, M.G. Cai, Analytical expression of TI elastie tensor with arbitrary orientation, Chin. J. Geophys. 52 (9) (2009) 2345-2348.

[52] G.C. Wu, X.L. Zhao, J. Tang, Z.Y. Du, First-order perturbation approximation of transversely isotropic (TI) rock elastic modulus, Sci. China Earth Sci. 60 (9) (2017) 1645-1654.