Presentation of machine learning methods to determine the most important factors affecting road traffic accidents on rural roads

Abstract

The purpose of this research was to develop statistical and intelligent models for predicting the severity of road traffic accidents (RTAs) on rural roads. Multiple Logistic Regression (MLR) was used to predict the likelihood of RTAs. For more accurate prediction, Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) and Radius Basis Function (RBF) neural networks were applied. Results indicated that in MLR, the model obtained from the backward method with the correct percent of 84.7% and R² value of 0.893 was the best method for predicting the likelihood of RTAs. Also, MLR showed that the variables of not paying attention to the front not paying attention to the frontroad ahead, followed byand then vehicle-motorcycle/bike accidents were the greatest problems. Among the models, MLP had a better performance, so that the prediction accuracy of MLR, MLP, and RBF were 84.7%, 96.7%, and 92.1%, respectively. MLP model, due to higher accuracy, showed that the variable of reason of accident had the highest effect on the prediction of accidents, and considering MLR results, the variables of not paying attention to the front and then vehicle-motorcycle/bike accidents had the most influence on the occurrence of accidents. Therefore, motorcyclists and cyclists are more prone to accidents, and appropriate solutions should be adopted to enhance their safety.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

safety / rural accidents / multiple logistic regression / artificial neural networks

References

[1] Banstola A, Kigozi J, Barton P, Mytton J. Economic burden of road traffic injuries in Nepal. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2020, 17( 12): 4571

[2] Zou Y, Zhang Y, Cheng K. Exploring the impact of climate and extreme weather on fatal traffic accidents. Sustainability (Basel), 2021, 13( 1): 390

[3] World Health Organization. Global Status Report on Road Safety 2018. 2018

[4] Heydari S, Hoseinzadeh A, Ghaffarpasand F, Hedjazi A, Zarenezhad M, Moafian G, Aghabeigi M R, Foroutan A, Sarikhani Y, Peymani P, Ahmadi S M, Joulaei H, Dehghankhalili M, Lankarani K B. Epidemiological characteristics of fatal traffic accidents in Fars province, Iran: A community-based survey. Public Health, 2013, 127( 8): 704– 709

[5] K Abledu J, Abledu G. Multiple logistic regression analysis of predictors of musculoskeletal disorders and disability among bank workers in Kumasi. Journal of Ergonomics, 2012, 2( 4): 2

[6] Wang H Y, Peng J, Wang B K, Lu X, Zheng J Z, Wang K J, Tu X M, Feng C Y. Inconsistency between univariate and multiple logistic regressions. Shanghai Archives of Psychiatry, 2017, 29( 2): 124

[7] Zhang H, Xing H, Yao D, Liu L, Xue D, Guo F. The multiple logistic regression recognition model for mine water inrush source based on cluster analysis. Environmental Earth Sciences, 2019, 78( 20): 612

[8] Kwigizile V, Sando T, Chimba D. Inconsistencies of ordered and unordered probability models for pedestrian injury severity. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2011, 2264( 1): 110– 118

[9] Garrido R, Bastos A, de Almeida A, Elvas J P. Prediction of road accident severity using the ordered probit model. Transportation Research Procedia, 2014, 3 : 214– 223

[10] Fountas G, Anastasopoulos P C. Analysis of accident injury-severity outcomes: The zero-inflated hierarchical ordered probit model with correlated disturbances. Analytic Methods in Accident Research, 2018, 20 : 30– 45

[11] Piedra-Bonilla E B, da Cunha D A, Braga M J. Climate variability and crop diversification in Brazil: An ordered probit analysis. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2020, 256 : 120252

[12] Barua U, Tay R. Severity of urban transit bus crashes in Bangladesh. Journal of Advanced Transportation, 2010, 44( 1): 34– 41

[13] Yasmin S, Eluru N, Ukkusuri S V. Alternative ordered response frameworks for examining pedestrian injury severity in New York City. Journal of Transportation Safety & Security, 2014, 6( 4): 275– 300

[14] Zeng Q, Gu W, Zhang X, Wen H, Lee J, Hao W. Analyzing freeway crash severity using a Bayesian spatial generalized ordered logit model with conditional autoregressive priors. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2019, 127 : 87– 95

[15] Azimi G, Rahimi A, Asgari H, Jin X. Severity analysis for large truck rollover crashes using a random parameter ordered logit model. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2020, 135 : 105355

[16] Ye F, Lord D. Comparing three commonly used crash severity models on sample size requirements: Multinomial logit, ordered probit and mixed logit models. Analytic Methods in Accident Research, 2014, 1 : 72– 85

[17] Haleem K, Alluri P, Gan A. Analyzing pedestrian crash injury severity at signalized and non-signalized locations. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2015, 81 : 14– 23

[18] Chen F, Chen S, Ma X. Analysis of hourly crash likelihood using unbalanced panel data mixed logit model and real-time driving environmental big data. Journal of Safety Research, 2018, 65 : 153– 159

[19] Liu P, Fan W. Exploring injury severity in head-on crashes using latent class clustering analysis and mixed logit model: A case study of North Carolina. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2020, 135 : 105388

[20] Chang L Y. Analysis of freeway accident frequencies: Negative binomial regression versus artificial neural network. Safety Science, 2005, 43( 8): 541– 557

[21] Abdulhafedh A. Crash frequency analysis. Journal of Transportation Technologies, 2016, 6( 4): 169– 180

[22] Mokhtarimousavi S, Anderson J C, Azizinamini A, Hadi M. Factors affecting injury severity in vehicle-pedestrian crashes: A day-of-week analysis using random parameter ordered response models and artificial neural networks. International Journal of Transportation Science and Technology, 2020, 9( 2): 100– 115

[23] Riviere C, Lauret P, Ramsamy J F M, Page Y. A Bayesian neural network approach to estimating the energy equivalent speed. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2006, 38( 2): 248– 259

[24] Xie Y, Lord D, Zhang Y. Predicting motor vehicle collisions using Bayesian neural network models: An empirical analysis. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2007, 39( 5): 922– 933

[25] de Oña J, Mujalli R O, Calvo F J. Analysis of traffic accident injury severity on Spanish rural highways using Bayesian networks. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2011, 43( 1): 402– 411

[26] Behbahani H, Amiri A M, Imaninasab R, Alizamir M. Forecasting accident frequency of an urban road network: A comparison of four artificial neural network techniques. Journal of Forecasting, 2018, 37( 7): 767– 780

[27] Zhu W, Miao J, Hu J, Qing L. Vehicle detection in driving simulation using extreme learning machine. Neurocomputing, 2014, 128 : 160– 165

[28] Parsa A B, Taghipour H, Derrible S, Mohammadian A K. Real-time accident detection: Coping with imbalanced data. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2019, 129 : 202– 210

[29] Yu B, Chen Y, Bao S, Xu D. Quantifying drivers’ visual perception to analyze accident-prone locations on two-lane mountain highways. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2018, 119 : 122– 130

[30] Omrani H. Predicting travel mode of individuals by machine learning. Transportation Research Procedia, 2015, 10 : 840– 849

[31] Slimani N, Slimani I, Sbiti N, Amghar M. Traffic forecasting in Morocco using artificial neural networks. Procedia Computer Science, 2019, 151 : 471– 476

[32] Amin S. Backpropagation––Artificial Neural Network (BP-ANN): Understanding gender characteristics of older driver accidents in West Midlands of United Kingdom. Safety Science, 2020, 122 : 104539

[33] Amiri A M, Sadri A, Nadimi N, Shams M. A comparison between Artificial Neural Network and Hybrid Intelligent Genetic Algorithm in predicting the severity of fixed object crashes among elderly drivers. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2020, 138 : 105468

[34] Richter T, Ruhl S, Ortlepp J, Bakaba E. Prevention of overtaking accidents on two-lane rural roads. Transportation Research Procedia, 2016, 14 : 4140– 4149

[35] Lombardo L, Cama M, Conoscenti C, Märker M, Rotigliano E. Binary logistic regression versus stochastic gradient boosted decision trees in assessing landslide susceptibility for multiple-occurring landslide events: Application to the 2009 storm event in Messina (Sicily, southern Italy). Natural Hazards, 2015, 79( 3): 1621– 1648

[36] Saeidi S, Mohammadzadeh M, Salmanmahiny A, Mirkarimi S H. Performance evaluation of multiple methods for landscape aesthetic suitability mapping: A comparative study between Multi-Criteria Evaluation, Logistic Regression and Multi-Layer Perceptron neural network. Land Use Policy, 2017, 67 : 1– 12

[37] Wang S H, Zhan T M, Chen Y, Zhang Y, Yang M, Lu H M, Wang H N, Liu B, Phillips P. Multiple sclerosis detection based on biorthogonal wavelet transform, RBF kernel principal component analysis, and logistic regression. IEEE Access: Practical Innovations, Open Solutions, 2016, 4 : 7567– 7576

[38] Yu H, Tao J, Qin C, Liu M, Xiao D, Sun H, Liu C. A novel constrained dense convolutional autoencoder and DNN-based semi-supervised method for shield machine tunnel geological formation recognition. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2022, 165 : 108353

[39] Jin Y, Qin C, Tao J, Liu C. An accurate and adaptative cutterhead torque prediction method for shield tunneling machines via adaptative residual long-short term memory network. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2022, 165 : 108312

[40] Zhou W, Liu J, Lei J, Yu L, Hwang J N. GMNet: Graded-feature multilabel-learning network for RGB-thermal urban scene semantic segmentation. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 2021, 30 : 7790– 7802

[41] Li Y, Che P, Liu C, Wu D, Du Y. Cross-scene pavement distress detection by a novel transfer learning framework. Computer-Aided Civil and Infrastructure Engineering, 2021, 36( 11): 1398– 1415

[42] Lv Z, Li Y, Feng H, Lv H. Deep Learning for security in digital twins of cooperative intelligent transportation systems. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, 2021, 1– 10

[43] Alizadeh Kharazi B, Behzadan A H. Flood depth mapping in street photos with image processing and deep neural networks. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 2021, 88 : 101628

[44] Alizadeh B Li D Zhang Z Behzadan A H. Feasibility study of urban flood mapping using traffic signs for route optimization. 2021, arXiv:2109.11712

[45] Yamany M S, Saeed T U, Volovski M, Ahmed A. Characterizing the performance of interstate flexible pavements using artificial neural networks and random parameters regression. Journal of Infrastructure Systems, 2020, 26( 2): 04020010

[46] Fawcett T. An introduction to ROC analysis. Pattern Recognition Letters, 2006, 27( 8): 861– 874

[47] Abdelwahab H T, Abdel-Aty M A. Development of artificial neural network models to predict driver injury severity in traffic accidents at signalized intersections. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2001, 1746( 1): 6– 13

[48] Chimba D, Sando T. The prediction of highway traffic accident injury severity with neuromorphic techniques. Advances in Transportation Studies, 2009, 19 : 17– 26

[49] Abdelwahab H T, Abdel-Aty M A. Artificial neural networks and logit models for traffic safety analysis of toll plazas. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2002, 1784( 1): 115– 125

[50] Delen D, Sharda R, Bessonov M. Identifying significant predictors of injury severity in traffic accidents using a series of artificial neural networks. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2006, 38( 3): 434– 444

[51] Siskind V, Steinhardt D, Sheehan M, O’Connor T, Hanks H. Risk factors for fatal crashes in rural Australia. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2011, 43( 3): 1082– 1088

[52] Yan X, Radwan E, Abdel-Aty M. Characteristics of rear-end accidents at signalized intersections using multiple logistic regression model. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2005, 37( 6): 983– 995

[53] Shrestha P P Shrestha K J. Factors associated with crash severities in built-up areas along rural highways of Nevada: A case study of 11 towns. Journal of Traffic and Transportation Engineering (English Edition), 2017, 4(1): 96− 102

[54] Sherafati F, Rad E H, Afkar A, Gholampoor-Sigaroodi R, Sirusbakht S. Risk factors of road traffic accidents associated mortality in northern iran: A single center experience utilizing oaxaca blinder decomposition. Bulletin of Emergency and Trauma, 2017, 5( 2): 116

[55] Casado-Sanz N, Guirao B, Gálvez-Pérez D. Population ageing and rural road accidents: Analysis of accident severity in traffic crashes with older pedestrians on Spanish crosstown roads. Research in Transportation Business & Management, 2019, 30 : 100377

[56] Intini P, Berloco N, Colonna P, Ranieri V, Ryeng E. Exploring the relationships between drivers’ familiarity and two-lane rural road accidents: A multi-level study. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2018, 111 : 280– 296

[57] Pourfalatoun S, Miller E E. User perceptions of automated Truck-Mounted attenuators: Implications on work zone safety. Traffic Injury Prevention, 2021, 22( 5): 413

[58] Miller E E Pourfalatoun S. Evaluating the Human-Automated Maintenance Vehicle Interaction for Improved Safety and Facilitating Long-Term Trust. Denver: Applied Research and Innovation Branch, 2021

[59] Waseem M, Ahmed A, Saeed T U. Factors affecting motorcyclists’ injury severities: An empirical assessment using random parameters logit model with heterogeneity in means and variances. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2019, 123 : 12– 19

[60] Chen S, Saeed T U, Alinizzi M, Lavrenz S, Labi S. Safety sensitivity to roadway characteristics: A comparison across highway classes. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 2019, 123 : 39– 50

[61] Ahmad N Ahmed A Wali B Saeed T U. Exploring factors associated with crash severity on motorways in Pakistan. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers—Transport, 2020

[62] Chen S, Saeed T U, Alqadhi S D, Labi S. Safety impacts of pavement surface roughness at two-lane and multi-lane highways: Accounting for heterogeneity and seemingly unrelated correlation across crash severities. Transportmetrica A: Transport Science, 2019, 15( 1): 18– 33

[63] Chen S, Saeed T U, Labi S. Impact of road-surface condition on rural highway safety: A multivariate random parameters negative binomial approach. Analytic Methods in Accident Research, 2017, 16 : 75– 89

[64] Saeed T U, Hall T, Baroud H, Volovski M J. Analyzing road crash frequencies with uncorrelated and correlated random-parameters count models: An empirical assessment of multilane highways. Analytic Methods in Accident Research, 2019, 23 : 100101

[65] Tong D, Yuan Y, Wang X. The coupled relationships between land development and land ownership at China’s urban fringe: A structural equation modeling approach. Land Use Policy, 2021, 100 : 104925

[66] Dong H, Zhao B, Deng Y. Instability phenomenon associated with two typical high speed railway vehicles. International Journal of Non-linear Mechanics, 2018, 105 : 130– 145

[67] Bie Y, Ji J, Wang X, Qu X. Optimization of electric bus scheduling considering stochastic volatilities in trip travel time and energy consumption. Computer-Aided Civil and Infrastructure Engineering, 2021, 36( 12): 1530– 1548

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Higher Education Press 2022