Design and operational considerations for selective catalytic reduction technologies at coal-fired boilers

Abstract

By the end of 2010, China had approximately 650 GW of coal-fired electric generating capacity producing almost 75% of the country’s total electricity generation. As a result of the heavy reliance on coal for electricity generation, emissions of air pollutants, such as nitrogen oxides (NO_x), are increasing. To address these growing emissions, the Ministry of Environmental Protection (MEP) has introduced new NO_x emission control policies to encourage the installation of selective catalytic reduction (SCR) technologies on a large number of coal-fired electric power plants. There is, however, limited experience with SCR in China. It is therefore useful to explore the lessons from the use of SCR technologies in other countries. This paper provides an overview of SCR technology performance at coal-fired electric power plants demonstrating emission removal rates between 65% and 92%. It also reviews the design and operational challenges that, if not addressed, can reduce the reliability, performance, and cost-effectiveness of SCR technologies. These challenges include heterogeneous flue gas conditions, catalyst degradation, ammonia slip, sulfur trioxide (SO₃) formation, and fouling and corrosion of plant equipment. As China and the rest of the world work to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions from parasitic load and urea-to-ammonia conversion may also become more important. If these challenges are properly addressed, SCR can reliably and effectively remove up to 90% of NO_x emissions at coal-fired power plants.

Key words： nitrogen oxides (NO_x); coal; selective catalytic reduction (SCR); air pollution control

References

1 China Electricity Council (CEC). 2011 Annual Development Report of China’s Power Industry. Beijing: CEC, 2011 (in Chinese)

2 Zhao Y, Wang S, Duan L, Lei Y, Cao P, Hao J. Primary air pollutant emissions of coal-fired power plants in China: current status and future prediction. Atmospheric Environment, 2008, 42(36): 8442-8452

3 Ministry of Environmental Protection (MEP). Report on the State of the Environment in China. Beijing: MEP, 2009.

4 US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Nitrogen: Multiple and Regional Impacts. Washington, DC: EPA, 2002

5 US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). NO_x Budget Trading Program 2008 Emission, Compliance, and Market Analyses. Washington, DC: EPA, 2009

6 US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Review of the National Ambient Air Quality Standards for Ozone: Policy Assessment of Scientific and Technical Information. Research Triangle Park, NC: EPA, 2007

7 US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Policy Assessment for the Review of the Particulate Matter National Ambient Air Quality Standards. Research Triangle Park, NC: EPA, 2011

8 Pope C A 3rd, Ezzati M, Dockery D W. Fine-particulate air pollution and life expectancy in the United States. New England Journal of Medicine, 2009, 360(4): 376-386

PMID

9 Butler T J, Likens G E, Vermeylen F M, Stunder B J B. The relation between NO_x emissions and precipitation NO3- in the eastern USA. Atmospheric Environment, 2003, 37(15): 2093-2104

10 Streets D G, Fu J S, Jang C J, Hao J, He K, Tang X, Zhang Y, Wang Z, Li Z, Zhang Q, Wang L, Wang B, Yu C. Air quality during the 2008 Beijing Olympic games. Atmospheric Environment, 2007, 41(3): 480-492

11 Wang X, Manning W, Feng Z, Zhu Y. Ground-level ozone in China: distribution and effects on crop yields. Environmental Pollution, 2007, 147(2): 394-400

PMID

12 Chan C K, Yao X. Air pollution in mega cities in China. Atmospheric Environment, 2008, 42(1): 1-42

13 Xu J, Zhang Y, Fu J S, Zheng S, Wang W. Process analysis of typical summertime ozone episodes over the Beijing area. The Science of the Total Environment, 2008, 399(1-3): 147-157

PMID

14 Zhang J, Mauzerall D L, Zhu T, Liang S, Ezzati M, Remais J V. Environmental health in China: progress towards clean air and safe water. Lancet, 2010, 375(9720): 1110-1119

PMID

15 Tan J H, Duan J C, Chen D H, Wang X H, Guo S J, Bi X H, Sheng G Y, He K B, Fu J M. Chemical characteristics of haze during summer and winter in Guangzhou. Atmospheric Research, 2009, 94(2): 238-245

16 Tan J, Duan J, He K, Ma Y, Duan F, Chen Y, Fu J. Chemical characteristics of PM_2.5 during a typical haze episode in Guangzhou. Journal of Environmental Sciences (China), 2009, 21(6): 774-781

PMID

17 Hu M, Wu Z, Slanina J, Lin P, Liu S, Zeng L. Acidic gases, ammonia and water-soluble ions in PM_2.5 at a coastal site in the Pearl River Delta, China. Atmospheric Environment, 2008, 42(25): 6310-6320

18 Zhao X, Zhang X, Xu X, Xu J, Meng W, Pu W. Seasonal and diurnal variations of ambient PM_2.5 concentration in urban and rural environments in Beijing. Atmospheric Environment, 2009, 43(18): 2893-2900

19 Ye B, Ji X, Yang H, Yao X, Chan C K, Cadle S H, Chan T, Mulawa P A. Concentration and chemical composition of PM_2.5 in Shanghai for a 1-year period. Atmospheric Environment, 2003, 37(4): 499-510

20 Song Y, Tang X, Xie S, Zhang Y, Wei Y, Zhang M, Zeng L, Lu S.Source apportionment of PM_2.5 in Beijing in 2004. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 2007, 146(1,2): 124-130

21 Zhao Y, Duan L, Xing J, Larssen T, Nielsen C P, Hao J. Soil acidification in China: is controlling SO₂ emissions enough? Environmental Science & Technology, 2009, 43(21): 8021-8026

PMID

22 Meng Z Y, Xu X B, Wang T, Zhang X Y, Yu X L, Wang S F, Lin W L, Chen Y Z, Jiang Y A, An X Q. Ambient sulfur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, and ammonia at ten background and rural sites in China during 2007-2008. Atmospheric Environment, 2010, 44(21-22): 2625-2631

23 Zhang Y, Liu X J, Fangmeier A, Goulding K T W, Zhang F S. Nitrogen inputs and isotopes in precipitation in the north China plain. Atmospheric Environment, 2008, 42(7): 1436-1448

24 Shen J L, Tang A H, Liu X J, Fangmeier A, Goulding K T W, Zhang F S. High concentrations and dry deposition of reactive nitrogen species at two sites in the North China Plain. Environmental Pollution, 2009, 157(11): 3106-3113

PMID

25 Ministry of Environmental Protection (MEP). Emission Standard for Air Pollutants from Thermal Power Plants. GB 13223-1996, Beijing: MEP, 1996, (in Chinese)

26 Ministry of Environmental Protection (MEP). Emission Standard for Air Pollutants from Thermal Power Plants. GB 13223-2003, Beijing: MEP, 2003 (in Chinese)

27 Ministry of Environmental Protection (MEP). Emission Standard for Air Pollutants from Thermal Power Plants. GB 13223-2011, Beijing: MEP, 2011 (in Chinese)

28 Wen J B. Report on the Work of the Government 2011. Beijing: National People’s Congress, 2011 (in Chinese)

29 Ministry of Environmental Protection (MEP). Notice of Issuance of Fossil-Fired Power Plant’s NO_x Emission Prevention and Control Policy. Beijing: MEP, 2010 (in Chinese)

30 Srivastava R K, Hall R E, Khan S, Culligan K, Lani B W. Nitrogen oxides emission control options for coal-fired electric utility boilers. Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association, 2005, 55(9): 1367-1388

PMID

31 Radojevic M. Reduction of nitrogen oxides in flue gases. Environmental Pollution, 1998, 102( Suppl 1): 685-689

32 Wu Z. NO_x Control for Pulverized Coal Fired Power Stations. London: IEA Clean Coal Centre, 2002

33 Kitto J B, Stultz S C. Steam: Its Generation and Use. Barberton, Ohio: Babcock & Wilcox Company, 2005

34 Nalbandian H. NO_xControl for Coal-fired Plant. London: IEA Clean Coal Centre, 2009

35 Sloss L. Nitrogen Oxides Control Technology Factbook. Norwich, NY: William Andrew Publishing, 1992

36 Chu P, Downs B, Holmes B. Sorbent and ammonia injection at economizer temperatures upstream of a economizer temperatures upstream of a high—temperature baghouse. Environment and Progress, 1990, 9(3): 149-155

37 Nalbandian H. Economics of Retrofit Air Pollution Control Technologies. London: IEA Clean Coal Centre, 2006

38 Erickson C A, Staudt J E. Selective catalytic reduction system performance and reliability review. In: Proceedings of the power plant air pollutant control “MEGA” symposium 2006. Baltimore, MD: Air and Waste Management Association, 2006

39 Institute of Clean Air Companies (ICAC). Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) for Controlling NO_x Emissions from Fossil Fuel Fired Electric Power Plants. Washington, DC: ICAC, 2009

40 Pritchard S, DiFrancesco C, Kaneko S, Kobayashi N, Suyama K, Lida K. Optimizing SCR catalyst design and performance for coal-fired boilers. In: EPA/EPRI Joint Symposium on Stationary Combustion NO_x Control. Kansas City, Kansas: EPRI, 1995

41 Cichanowicz J E, Muzio L J. Twenty-five years of SCR evolution: implications for US application and operation. In: Proceedings of the Power Plant Air Pollutant Control “MEGA” Symposium 2001. Baltimore, Maryland: Air and Waste Management Association, 2001

42 Rogers K J. Mixing performance characterization for optimization and development on SCR applications. In: DOE 2003 Conference on SCR/SNCR for NO_x Control. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania: DOE, 2003

43 Strege J R, Zygarlicke C J, Folkedahl B C, McCollor D P. SCR deactivation in a full-scale cofired utility boiler. Fuel, 2008, 87(7): 1341-1347

44 Wang J. Selective catalytic reduction (SCR). In: 2nd U.S.-China NO_x and SO₂ Control Workshop. Dalian: MOST, 2005

45 Bartholomew C H. Mechanisms of catalyst deactivation. Applied Catalysis A: General, 2001, 212(1,2): 17-60

46 Srivastava R K, Miller C A, Erickson C, Jambhekar R. Emissions of sulfur trioxide from coal-fired power plants. Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association, 2004, 54(6): 750-762

PMID

47 Menasha J, Dunn-Rankin D, Muzio L, Stallings J. Ammonium bisulfate formation temperature in a bench-scale single-channel air preheater. Fuel, 2011, 90(7): 2445-2453

48 Sobolewski H, Jancauskas J, Harrell M, Hartenstein H, Martin M. Large particle ash (LPA) screen retrofits at coal-fired units in Indiana and Ohio. In: 2006 US DOE Environmental Controls Conference. Pittsburgh, PA. Washington: DOE, 2006

49 Connell D P, Locke J E, Abrams R F, Beittel R. The Greenridge multi-pollutant control project: performance and cost results from the first year of operation. In: Proceedings of the Power Plant Air Pollutant Control “MEGA” Symposium 2008. Baltimore, Maryland: Air and Waste Management Association, 2008

50 Senior C L, Lignell D O, Sarofim A F, Mehta A. Modeling arsenic partitioning in coal-fired power plants. Combustion and Flame, 2006, 147(3): 209-221

51 Staudt J E, Engelmeyer T, Weston W H, Sigling R. The impact of arsenic on coal fired power plants equipped with SCR. In: ICAC Forum. Houston, Texas: Institute for Clean Air Companies, 2002

52 Wang M, Zheng B, Wang B, Li S, Wu D, Hu J. Arsenic concentrations in Chinese coals. Science of the Total Environment, 2006, 357(1-3): 96-102

PMID

53 Zhao Y, Zhang J, Huang W, Wang Z, Li Y, Song D, Zhao F, Zheng C. Arsenic emission during combustion of high arsenic coals from southwestern Guizhou, China. Energy Conversion and Management, 2008, 49(4): 615-624

54 He B, Liang L, Jiang G. Distributions of arsenic and selenium in selected Chinese coal mines. Science of the Total Environment, 2002, 296(1-3): 19-26

PMID

55 Staudt J E, Engelmeyer A J. SCR catalyst management strategies-modeling and experience. In: Proceedings of COAL-GEN 2003. Columbus, Ohio: PennWell, 2003

56 taudt J E. Minimizing the impact of SCR catalyst on total generating cost through effective catalyst management. In: Proceedings of the ASME Power Conference. Baltimore, Maryland: ASME, 2004

57 Chothani C, Morey R. Ammonium bisulfate (ABS) measurement for NO_x control and air heater protection. In: Proceedings of the Power Plant Air Pollutant Control “MEGA” Symposium 2008. Baltimore, Maryland: Air and Waste Management Association, 2008

58 Wright T, DeLallo M. Increased SO₃ and ammonia slip from SCR: balancing air heater deposits, ammonia in effluent discharge, and SO₃ plume. In: Proceedings of 2002 Conference on Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) and Selective Non-catalytic Reduction (SNCR) for NO_x Control. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania: National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL), 2002

59 Schmidtchen P A, Hatern M J, Lombardi D E, Wajer M. High activity magnesia use for SCR related SO₃ problems. In: Proceedings of 2002 Conference on Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) and Selective Non-catalytic Reduction (SNCR) for NO_x Control. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania: National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL), 2002

60 Sutton M A, Erisman J W, Dentener F, Möller D. Ammonia in the environment: from ancient times to the present. Environmental Pollution, 2008, 156(3): 583-604

PMID

61 Apsimon H, Kruse M, Bell J, 0. Kruse M, Bell J N B. Ammonia emissions and their role in acid deposition. Atmospheric Environment, 1987, 21(9): 1939-1946

62 Zhao P, Zhu T, Liang B, Hu M, Kang L, Gong J. Characteristics of mass distributions of aerosol particle and its inorganic water-soluble ions in summer over a suburb farmland in Beijing. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering in China, 2007, 1(2): 159-165

63 Louie P K K, Chow J C, Chen L W A, Watson J G, Leung G, Sin D W M. PM_2.5 chemical composition in Hong Kong: urban and regional variations. The Science of the Total Environment, 2005, 338(3): 267-281

PMID

64 Louie P K K, Watson J G, Chow J C, Chen A, Sin D W M, Lau A K H. Seasonal characteristics and regional transport of PM_2.5 in Hong Kong. Atmospheric Environment, 2005, 39(9): 1695-1710

65 Lai S C, Zou S C, Cao J J, Lee S C, Ho K F. Characterizing ionic species in PM_2.5 and PM₁₀ in four Pearl River Delta cities, south China. Journal of Environmental Sciences (China), 2007, 19(8): 939-947

PMID

66 Hu M, Wu Z, Slanina J, Lin P, Liu S, Zeng L. Acidic gases, ammonia and water-soluble ions in PM_2.5 at a coastal site in the Pearl River Delta, China. Atmospheric Environment, 2008, 42(25): 6310-6320

67 He K, Yang F, Ma Y, Zhang Q, Yao X, Chan C K, Cadle S, Chan T, Mulawa P. The characteristics of PM_2.5 in Beijing, China. Atmospheric Environment, 2001, 35(29): 4959-4970

68 Ye B, Ji X, Yang H, Yao X, Chan C K, Cadle S H, Chan T, Mulawa P A. Concentration and chemical composition of PM_2.5 in Shanghai for a 1-year period. Atmospheric Environment, 2003, 37(4): 499-510

69 Kai Z, Yuesi W, Tianxue W, Yousef M, Frank M. Properties of nitrate, sulfate and ammonium in typical polluted atmospheric aerosols (PM₁₀) in Beijing. Atmospheric Research, 2007, 84(1): 67-77

70 Zhao D W, Wang A P. Estimation of anthropogenic ammonia emissions in Asia. Atmospheric Environment, 1994, 28(4): 689-694

71 Zhang Y, Dore A J, Ma L, Liu X J, Ma W Q, Cape J N, Zhang F S. Agricultural ammonia emissions inventory and spatial distribution in the North China Plain. Environmental Pollution, 2010, 158(2): 490-501

PMID

72 Forzatti P, Nova I, Beretta A. Catalytic properties in deNO_x and SO₂-SO₃ reactions. Catalysis Today, 2000, 56(4): 431-441

73 Ritzenthaler D P. SO₃ control: AEP pioneers and refines trona injection process for SO₃ mitigation. 2007-<month>03</month>-<day>01</day>, http://www.coalpowermag.com/plant_design/SO3-Control-AEP-Pioneers-and-Refines-Trona-Injection-Process-for-SO3-Mitigation_29.html

74 Drbal L, Westra K, Boston P. Power Plant Engineering. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1995

75 Graus W H J, Worrell E. Effects of SO₂ and NO_x control on energy-efficiency power generation. Energy Policy, 2007, 35(7): 3898-3908

76 Bhattacharya S, Peters H J, Fisher J, Spencer H W III. Urea to ammonia (U2A) systems: operation and process chemistry. In: Proceedings of the power plant air pollutant control “MEGA” symposium 2003. Washington, DC: Air and Waste Management Association, 2003

77 Spencer H W III, Peters H J, Hankins W. Design considerations for generating ammonia from urea for NO_x control with SCRs. In: 2007 (100th) A&WMA Annual Conference. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania: Air and Waste Management Association, 2007

78 Solomon S, Qin D, Manning M, Chen Z, Marquis M, Averyt K B, Tignor M, Miller H L, eds. Climate Change 2007: the Physical Science Basis. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2007

79 Heck R M. Catalytic abatement of nitrogen oxides-stationary applications. Catalysis Today, 1999, 53(4): 519-523