Can the Shanghai LNG Price Index indicate Chinese market? An econometric investigation using price discovery theory

Abstract

China became the world’s second largest liquefied natural gas (LNG) importer in 2018 but has faced extremely high import costs due to a lack of bargaining power. Assessments of the Shanghai LNG Price Index, first released in 2015, are vital for improving the understanding of these cost dynamics. This paper, using the LNG price index data from the Shanghai Petroleum and Gas Exchange (SHPGX) coupled with domestic and international LNG prices from July 1, 2015 to December 31, 2018, estimates several econometric models to evaluate the long-term and short-term equilibriums of the Shanghai LNG Price Index, the responses to market information shocks and the leading or lagging relationships with LNG and alternative energy prices from other agencies. The results show that the LNG price index of the SHPGX has already exhibited a long-term equilibrium and short-term adjustment mechanisms to reflect the average price level and market movements, but the market information transparency and price discovery efficiency of the index are still inadequate. China’s LNG market is still relatively independent of other natural gas markets, and marketization reforms are under way in China. The influence of the SHPGX LNG price index on the trading decisions of market participants is expected to improve with further development of China’s LNG reforms, the formation of a natural gas entry-exit system, and the increasing liquidity of the hub.

Key words： liquefied natural gas; price index; Shanghai Petroleum and Gas Exchange; price discovery; market reforms

Acknowledgments

This work was financially supported by the Postdoctoral Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 2018M641289), the Science Foundation of China University of Petroleum Beijing (No. ZX20200109), and the China Scholarship Council.

References

1 Dong C, Dong X, Jiang Q, Dong K, Liu G. What is the probability of achieving the carbon dioxide emission targets of the Paris Agreement? Evidence from the top ten emitters. Science of the Total Environment, 2018, 622–623: 1294–1303

2 Toichi T. Development of the natural gas market in the Asia-Pacific region. ASEAN Economic Bulletin, 1989, 6(2): 149–156

3 Dong C, Dong X, Gehman J, Lefsrud L. Using BP neural networks to prioritize risk management approaches for China’s unconventional shale gas industry. Sustainability, 2017, 9(6): 979

4 Dong K, Sun R, Dong C, Li H, Zeng X, Ni G. Environmental Kuznets curve for PM_2.5 emissions in Beijing, China: what role can natural gas consumption play? Ecological Indicators, 2018, 93: 591–601

5 Samah Zaki NAJI, Ammar Ali ABD. Sensitivity analysis of using diethanolamine instead of methyldiethanolamine solution for GASCO’s Habshan acid gases removal plant. Frontiers in Energy, 2019, 13(2): 317–324

6 China’s National Development and Reform Commission. 2019–11–29, available at website of ndrc.gov.cn

7 BP. BP statistical review of world energy. 2019–6-20, available at website of bp.com

8 Wang Z, Jiang Q, Dong X, China’s Oil and Gas Industry Development Analysis and Outlook Report Blue Book (2018–2019). Beijing: China Petrochemical Press, 2019

9 China’s General Administration of Customs. Statistical bulletin (6). 2019–1-14, available at website of customs.gov.cn

10 Tong X, Zheng J, Fang B. Strategic analysis on establishing a natural gas trading hub in China. Natural Gas Industry B, 2014, 1(2): 210–220

11 Shi X, Padinjare Variam H M. Gas and LNG trading hubs, hub indexation and destination flexibility in East Asia. Energy Policy, 2016, 96: 587–596

12 Vivoda V. LNG import diversification and energy security in Asia. Energy Policy, 2019, 129: 967–974

13 Johnson O. The Price Reporters: a Guide to PRAS and Commodity Benchmarks. New York: Routledge, 2017

14 Garbade K D, Silber W L. Price movements and price discovery in futures and cash markets. Review of Economics and Statistics, 1983, 65(2): 289–297

15 Oellermann C M, Brorsen B W, Farris P L. Price discovery for feeder cattle. Journal of Futures Markets, 1989, 9(2): 113–121

16 Bopp A E, Lady G M. A comparison of petroleum futures versus spot prices as predictors of prices in the future. Energy Economics, 1991, 13(4): 274–282

17 Schultz E, Swieringa J. Price discovery in European natural gas markets. Energy Policy, 2013, 61: 628–634

18 Bekiros S D, Diks C G. The relationship between crude oil spot and futures prices: cointegration, linear and nonlinear causality. Energy Economics, 2008, 30(5): 2673–2685

19 Yousefi S, Weinreich I, Reinarz D. Wavelet-based prediction of oil prices. Chaos, Solitons, and Fractals, 2005, 25(2): 265–275

20 Chang C, Lee C. Do oil spot and futures prices move together? Energy Economics, 2015, 50: 379–390

21 Schultz E, Swieringa J. Catalysts for price discovery in the European Union emissions trading system. Journal of Banking & Finance, 2014, 42(5): 112–122

22 Tse Y, Booth G G. Information shares in international oil futures markets. International Review of Economics & Finance, 1997, 6(1): 49–56

23 Lien D, Shrestha K. Hedging effectiveness comparisons: a note. International Review of Economics & Finance, 2008, 17(3): 391–396

24 Zhao L T, Yan J L, Cheng L, Wang Y. Empirical study of the functional changes in price discovery in the Brent crude oil market. Energy Procedia, 2017, 142: 2917–2922

25 Moosa I A, Silvapulle P. The price-volume relationship in the crude oil futures market some results based on linear and nonlinear causality testing. International Review of Economics & Finance, 2000, 9(1): 11–30

26 Kaufmann R K, Ullman B. Oil prices, speculation, and fundamentals: interpreting causal relations among spot and futures prices. Energy Economics, 2009, 31(4): 550–558

27 Alzahrani M, Masih M, Altiti O. Linear and nonlinear Granger causality between oil spot and futures prices: a wavelet based test. Journal of International Money and Finance, 2014, 48: 175–201

28 Park H, Mjelde J W, Bessler D A. Price interactions and discovery among natural gas spot markets in North America. Energy Policy, 2008, 36(1): 290–302

29 Asche F, Misund B, Sikveland M. The relationship between spot and contract gas prices in Europe. Energy Economics, 2013, 38: 212–217

30 Ghoddusi H. Integration of physical and futures prices in the US natural gas market. Energy Economics, 2016, 56: 229–238

31 Shrestha K. Price discovery in energy markets. Energy Economics, 2014, 45: 229–233

32 Caporin M, Fontini F. The long-run oil-natural gas price relationship and the shale gas revolution. Energy Economics, 2017, 64: 511–519

33 Stern J, Rogers H V. The Dynamics of a Liberalised European Gas Market. Oxford: Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, 2014

34 Stern J, Rogers H V. The Transition to Hub-Based Gas Pricing in Continental Europe. Oxford: Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, 2011

35 Heather P. European Traded Gas Hubs: a Decade of Change. Oxford: Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, 2019

36 Heather P. “A Hub for Europe” The Iberian promise? Oxford: Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, 2019

37 Heather P. The Evolution of European Traded Gas Hubs. Oxford: Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, 2015

38 Heather P. Continental European Gas Hubs: Are they fit for purpose? Oxford: Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, 2012

39 Heather P, Petrovich B. European Traded Gas Hubs: an Updated Analysis on Liquidity, Maturity and Barriers to Market Integration. Oxford: Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, 2017

40 Petrovich B. European Gas Hubs Price Correlation: Barriers to Convergence? Oxford: Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, 2014

41 Stern J. International gas pricing in Europe and Asia: a crisis of fundamentals. Energy Policy, 2014, 64: 43–48

42 Zhang D Y, Shi M, Shi X P. Oil indexation, market fundamentals, and natural gas prices: an investigation of the Asian premium in natural gas trade. Energy Economics, 2018, 69: 33–41

43 Wang T, Zhang D, Ji Q, Shi X. Market reforms and determinants of import natural gas prices in China. Energy, 2020, 196: 117105

44 Kim Y. Obstacles to the creation of gas trading hubs and a price index in Northeast Asia. Geosystem Engineering, 2019, 22(2): 59–71

45 Gao T. Econometric Analysis Methods and Modeling. Beijing: Tsinghua University Press, 2006

46 Li Z, Pan W. Econometrics. 4th ed. Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2015

47 Michael P M. Econometrics: A Modern Introduction. Beijing: Machinery Industry Press, 2009

48 Miriello C, Polo M. The development of gas hubs in Europe. Energy Policy, 2015, 84: 177–190