Mechanism and control factors of hydrate plugging in multiphase liquid-rich pipeline flow systems: A review

Abstract

There is nothing illogical in the concept that hydrates are easily formed in oil and gas pipelines owing to the low-temperature and high-pressure environment, although requiring the cooperation of flow rate, water content, gas-liquid ratio, and other specific factors. Therefore, hydrate plugging is a major concern for the hydrate slurry pipeline transportation technology. In order to further examine potential mechanisms underlying these processes, the present paper listed and analyzed the significant research efforts specializing in the mechanisms of hydrate blockages in the liquid-rich system, including oil-based, water-based, and partially dispersed systems (PD systems), in gathering and transportation pipelines. In addition, it summarized the influences of fluid flow and water content on the risk of hydrate blockage and discussed. In general, flow rate was implicated in the regulation of blockage risk through its characteristic to affect sedimentation tendencies and flow patterns. Increasing water content can potentiate the growth of hydrates and change the oil-water dispersion degree, which causes a transition from completely dispersed systems to PD systems with a higher risk of clogging. Reasons of diversity of hydrate plugging mechanism in oil-based system ought to be studied in-depth by combining the discrepancy of water content and the microscopic characteristics of hydrate particles. At present, it is increasingly necessary to expand the application of the hydrate blockage formation prediction model in order to ensure that hydrate slurry mixed transportation technology can be more maturely applied to the natural gas industry transportation field.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

hydrate / flow rate / water content / mechanism of pipeline blockage / rich liquid phase system

References

[1] Gaurav B, Goh M N, Arumuganainar S E K. . Ultra-rapid uptake and the highly stable storage of methane as combustible ice. Energy and Environmental Science, 2020, 13( 12): 4946– 4961

[2] Song S, Shi B, Yu W. . Study on the optimization of hydrate management strategies in deepwater gas well testing operations. Journal of Energy Resources Technology, 2020, 142( 3): 033002

[3] Shi G, Song S, Shi B. . A new transient model for hydrate slurry flow in oil-dominated flowlines. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 2021, 196 : 108003

[4] Shi B, Song S, Chen Y. . Status of natural gas hydrate flow assurance research in China: a review. Energy and Fuels, 2021, 35( 5): 3611– 3658

[5] Song S, Shi B, Yu W. . A new methane hydrate decomposition model considering intrinsic kinetics and mass transfer. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2019, 361 : 1264– 1284

[6] Hao W, Wang J, Fan S. . Evaluation and analysis method for natural gas hydrate storage and transportation processes. Energy Conversion and Management, 2008, 49( 10): 2546– 2553

[7] Veluswamy H P, Kumar R, Linga P. Hydrogen storage in clathrate hydrates: current state of the art and future directions. Applied Energy, 2014, 122 : 112– 132

[8] Kubota H, Shimizu K, Tanaka Y. . Thermodynamic properties of R13 (CClF₃), R23 (CHF₃), R152a (C₂H₄F₂), and propane hydrates for desalination of sea water. Journal of Chemical Engineering of Japan, 1984, 17( 4): 423– 429

[9] Yang M, Song Y, Jiang L. . Effects of operating mode and pressure on hydrate-based desalination and CO₂ capture in porous media. Applied Energy, 2014, 135 : 504– 511

[10] Cai J, Xu C, Xia Z. . Hydrate-based methane separation from coal mine methane gas mixture by bubbling using the scale-up equipment. Applied Energy, 2017, 204 : 1526– 1534

[11] Zhong D, Ding K, Lu Y. . Methane recovery from coal mine gas using hydrate formation in water-in-oil emulsions. Applied Energy, 2016, 162 : 1619– 1626

[12] Xie N, Tan C, Yang S. . Conceptual design and analysis of a novel CO₂ hydrate-based refrigeration system with cold energy storage. ACS Sustainable Chemistry and Engineering, 2019, 7( 1): 1502– 1511

[13] Liu Z, Liu W, Lang C. . Viscosity investigation on metastable hydrate suspension in oil-dominated systems. Chemical Engineering Science, 2021, 238 : 116608

[14] Li X, Xu C, Chen Z. . Tetra-n-butyl ammonium bromide semi-clathrate hydrate process for post-combustion capture of carbon dioxide in the presence of dodecyl trimethyl ammonium chloride. Energy, 2010, 35( 9): 3902– 3908

[15] Li X, Xu C, Chen Z. . Hydrate-based pre-combustion carbon dioxide capture process in the system with tetra-n-butyl ammonium bromide solution in the presence of cyclopentane. Energy, 2011, 36( 3): 1394– 1403

[16] Hammerschmidt E G. Formation of gas hydrates in natural gas transmission lines. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry, 1934, 26( 8): 851– 855

[17] Stern L A, Circone S, Kirby S H. . Temperature, pressure, and compositional effects on anomalous or “self” preservation of gas hydrates. Canadian Journal of Physics, 2003, 81( 1−2): 271– 283

[18] Lv X, Zuo J, Liu Y. . Experimental study of growth kinetics of CO₂ hydrates and multiphase flow properties of slurries in high pressure flow systems. RSC Advances, 2019, 9( 56): 32873– 32888

[19] Yang M, Song Y, Ruan X. . Characteristics of CO₂ hydrate formation and dissociation in glass beads and silica gel. Energies, 2012, 5( 4): 925– 937

[20] Zhang H, Du J, Wang Y. . Investigation into THF hydrate slurry flow behaviour and inhibition by an anti-agglomerant. RSC Advances, 2018, 8( 22): 11946– 11956

[21] Merlin F, Guitouni H, Mouhoubi H. . Adsorption and heterocoagulation of nonionic surfactants and latex particles on cement hydrates. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2005, 281( 1): 1– 10

[22] Aman Z M, Koh C A. Interfacial phenomena in gas hydrate systems. Chemical Society Reviews, 2016, 45( 6): 1678– 1690

[23] Wang F, Chen P, Li X. . Effect of colloidal silica on the hydration behavior of calcium aluminate cement. Materials, 2018, 11( 10): 1849

[24] Song S Liu Z Zhou L, . Research progress on hydrate plugging in multiphase mixed rich-liquid transportation pipelines. Frontiers in Energy, 2020, online, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11708-020-0688-x

[25] Joshi S V, Grasso G A, Lafond P G. . Experimental flowloop investigations of gas hydrate formation in high water cut systems. Chemical Engineering Science, 2013, 97 : 198– 209

[26] Fidel-Dufour A, Gruy F, Herri J M. Rheology of methane hydrate slurries during their crystallization in a water in dodecane emulsion under flowing. Chemical Engineering Science, 2006, 61( 2): 505– 515

[27] van der Hofstadt M, Fabregas R, Millan-Solsona R. . Internal hydration properties of single bacterial endospores probed by electrostatic force microscopy. ACS Nano, 2016, 10( 12): 11327– 11336

[28] Taylor C J, Dieker L E, Miller K T. . Micromechanical adhesion force measurements between tetrahydrofuran hydrate particles. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2007, 306( 2): 255– 261

[29] Yang S O, Kleehammer D M, Huo Z. . Temperature dependence of particle-particle adherence forces in ice and clathrate hydrates. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2004, 277( 2): 335– 341

[30] Orr F M, Scriven L E, Rivas A P. Pendular rings between solids: meniscus properties and capillary force. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 1975, 67( 4): 723– 742

[31] Liu C, Zhang C, Zhou C. . Effects of the solidification of capillary bridges on the interaction forces between hydrate particles. Energy and Fuels, 2020, 34( 4): 4525– 4533

[32] Aman Z M, Brown E P, Sloan E D. . Interfacial mechanisms governing cyclopentane clathrate hydrate adhesion/cohesion. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics, 2011, 13( 44): 19796– 19806

[33] Palermo T Fidel-Dufour A Maurel P, . Model of hydrates agglomeration–application to hydrates formation in an acidic crude oil. In: 12th International Conference on Multiphase Production Technology, Barcelona, Spain, 2005

[34] Shi B, Ding L, Li W. . Investigation on hydrates blockage and restart process mechanisms of CO₂ hydrate slurry flow. Asia-Pacific Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2018, 13( 3): e2193

[35] Liu Z, Vasheghani Farahani M, Yang M. . Hydrate slurry flow characteristics influenced by formation, agglomeration and deposition in a fully visual flow loop. Fuel, 2020, 277 : 118066

[36] Aspenes G, Dieker L E, Aman Z M. . Adhesion force between cyclopentane hydrates and solid surface materials. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2010, 343( 2): 529– 536

[37] Balakin B V, Hoffmann A C, Kosinski P. . Turbulent flow of hydrates in a pipeline of complex configuration. Chemical Engineering Science, 2010, 65( 17): 5007– 5017

[38] Hernandez O C. Investigation of hydrate slurry flow in horizontal pipelines. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Tulsa: The University of Tulsa, 2006

[39] Kwak G H, Lee K, Lee B R. . Quantification of the risk for hydrate formation during cool down in a dispersed oil-water system. Korean Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2017, 34( 7): 2043– 2048

[40] Aman Z M, Leith W J, Grasso G A. . Adhesion force between cyclopentane hydrate and mineral surfaces. Langmuir: the ACS Journal of Surfaces and Colloids, 2013, 29( 50): 15551– 15557

[41] Doron P, Simkhis M, Barnea D. Flow of solid-liquid mixtures in inclined pipes. International Journal of Multiphase Flow, 1997, 23( 2): 313– 323

[42] Grasso G. Investigation of hydrate formation and transportability in multiphase flow systems. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Golden: Colorado School of Mines, 2015

[43] Hu S, Kim T H, Park J G. . Effect of different deposition mediums on the adhesion and removal of particles. Journal of the Electrochemical Society, 2010, 157( 6): H662

[44] Turner D J. Clathrate hydrate formation in water-in-oil dispersions. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Golden: Colorado School of Mines, 2005

[45] Turner D J, Miller K T, Sloan E D. Methane hydrate formation and an inward growing shell model in water-in-oil dispersions. Chemical Engineering Science, 2009, 64( 18): 3996– 4004

[46] Taylor C J, Miller K T, Koh C A. . Macroscopic investigation of hydrate film growth at the hydrocarbon/water interface. Chemical Engineering Science, 2007, 62( 23): 6524– 6533

[47] Sum A K, Koh C A, Sloan E D. Developing a comprehensive understanding and model of hydrate in multiphase flow: from laboratory measurements to field applications. Energy and Fuels, 2012, 26( 7): 4046– 4052

[48] Ding L, Shi B, Wang J. . Hydrate deposition on cold pipe walls in water-in-oil (W/O) emulsion systems. Energy and Fuels, 2017, 31( 9): 8865– 8876

[49] Song G, Li Y, Wang W. . Investigation of hydrate plugging in natural gas+diesel oil+water systems using a high-pressure flow loop. Chemical Engineering Science, 2017, 158 : 480– 489

[50] Akhfash M, Boxall J A, Aman Z M. . Hydrate formation and particle distributions in gas-water systems. Chemical Engineering Science, 2013, 104 : 177– 188

[51] Majid A A, Lee W, Srivastava V. . Experimental investigation of gas-hydrate formation and particle transportability in fully and partially dispersed multiphase-flow systems using a high-pressure flow loop. SPE Journal, 2018, 23( 3): 937– 951

[52] Sloan D Koh C Sum A K, . Natural Gas Hydrates in Flow Assurance. Burlington: Gulf Professional Publishing, 2010

[53] Majid A A Lee W Srivastava V, . The study of gas hydrate formation and particle transportability using a high pressure flowloop. In: Offshore Technology Conference, Houston, Texas, USA, 2016

[54] Vijayamohan P. Experimental investigation of gas hydrate formation, plugging and transportability in partially dispersed and water continuous systems. Dissertation for the Doctoral Degree. Golden: Colorado School of Mines, 2015

[55] Akhfash M, Aman Z M, Ahn S Y. . Gas hydrate plug formation in partially-dispersed water-oil systems. Chemical Engineering Science, 2016, 140 : 337– 347

[56] Arjmandi M Tohidi B Danesh A, . Is subcooling the right driving force for testing low-dosage hydrate inhibitors? Chemical Engineering Science, 2005, 60( 5): 1313− 1321

[57] Vysniauskas A, Bishnoi P R. A kinetic study of methane hydrate formation. Chemical Engineering Science, 1983, 38( 7): 1061– 1072

[58] Lv X F, Shi B H, Wang Y. . Experimental study on hydrate induction time of gas-saturated water-in-oil emulsion using a high-pressure flow loop. Oil and Gas Science and Technology – Revue d'IFP Energies Nouvelles, 2015, 70( 6): 1111– 1124

[59] Liu Y, Shi B, Ding L. . Investigation of hydrate agglomeration and plugging mechanism in low-wax-content water-in-oil emulsion systems. Energy and Fuels, 2018, 32( 9): 8986– 9000

[60] Peytavy J L, Monfort J P, Gaillard C. Investigation of methane hydrate formation in a recirculating flow loop: modeling of the kinetics and tests of efficiency of chemical additives on hydrate inhibition. Oil and Gas Science and Technology, 1999, 54( 3): 365– 374

[61] Lv X, Shi B, Wang Y. . Study on gas hydrate formation and hydrate slurry flow in a multiphase transportation system. Energy and Fuels, 2013, 27( 12): 7294– 7302

[62] Zhang S, Pan Z, Shang L. . Analysis of influencing factors on the kinetics characteristics of carbon dioxide hydrates in high pressure flow systems. Energy and Fuels, 2021, 35( 19): 16241– 16257

[63] Urdahl O, Lund A, Mørk P. . Inhibition of gas hydrate formation by means of chemical additives—I. Development of an experimental set-up for characterization of gas hydrate inhibitor efficiency with respect to flow properties and deposition. Chemical Engineering Science, 1995, 50( 5): 863– 870

[64] Andersson V, Gudmundsson J S. Flow properties of hydrate-in-water slurries. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2006, 912( 1): 322– 329

[65] Lachance J W, Talley L D, Shatto D P. . Formation of hydrate slurries in a once-through operation. Energy and Fuels, 2012, 26( 7): 4059– 4066

[66] Talaghat M R. Experimental investigation of induction time for double gas hydrate formation in the simultaneous presence of the PVP and l-Tyrosine as kinetic inhibitors in a mini flow loop apparatus. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2014, 19 : 215– 220

[67] Melchuna A Cameirão A Ouabbas Y, . Transport of hydrate slurry at high water cut. In: The 8 th International Conference on Gas Hydrates, Beijing, China, 2014

[68] Vijayamohan P Majid A Chaudhari P, . Hydrate modeling & flow loop experiments for water continuous & partially dispersed systems. In: Offshore Technology Conference, Houston, Texas, USA, 2014

[69] Ding L, Shi B, Lv X. . Hydrate formation and plugging mechanisms in different gas-liquid flow patterns. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 2017, 56( 14): 4173– 4184

[70] Clain P, Delahaye A, Fournaison L, et al. Rheological properties of tetra- n-butylphosphonium bromide hydrate slurry flow. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2012, 193–194: 112−122

[71] Peng B, Chen J, Sun C. . Flow characteristics and morphology of hydrate slurry formed from (natural gas+diesel oil/condensate oil+water) system containing anti-agglomerant. Chemical Engineering Science, 2012, 84 : 333– 344

[72] Yan K, Sun C, Chen J. . Flow characteristics and rheological properties of natural gas hydrate slurry in the presence of anti-agglomerant in a flow loop apparatus. Chemical Engineering Science, 2014, 106 : 99– 108

[73] Shi B, Ding L, Liu Y. . Hydrate slurry flow property in W/O emulsion systems. RSC Advances, 2018, 8( 21): 11436– 11445

[74] Srivastava V, Eaton M W, Koh C A. . Quantitative framework for hydrate bedding and transient particle agglomeration. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 2020, 59( 27): 12580– 12589

[75] Liu W, Hu J, Li X. . Assessment of hydrate blockage risk in long-distance natural gas transmission pipelines. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2018, 60 : 256– 270

[76] Rao I, Koh C A, Sloan E D. . Gas hydrate deposition on a cold surface in water-saturated gas systems. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 2013, 52( 18): 6262– 6269

[77] di Lorenzo M, Aman Z M, Kozielski K. . Underinhibited hydrate formation and transport investigated using a single-pass gas-dominant flowloop. Energy and Fuels, 2014, 28( 11): 7274– 7284

[78] Ding L, Shi B, Lv X. . Hydrate formation and plugging mechanisms in different gas-liquid flow patterns. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 2017, 56( 14): 4173– 4184

[79] Ding L, Shi B, Liu Y. . Rheology of natural gas hydrate slurry: effect of hydrate agglomeration and deposition. Fuel, 2019, 239 : 126– 137

[80] Davies S R, Boxali J A, Koh C A. . Predicting hydrate-plug formation in a subsea tieback. SPE Production and Operations, 2009, 24( 4): 573– 578

[81] Kinnari K, Hundseid J, Li X. . Hydrate management in practice. Journal of Chemical and Engineering Data, 2015, 60( 2): 437– 446

[82] Charlton T B, di Lorenzo M, Zerpa L E. . Simulating hydrate growth and transport behavior in gas-dominant flow. Energy and Fuels, 2018, 32( 2): 1012– 1023

[83] Moradpour H, Chapoy A, Tohidi B. Bimodal model for predicting the emulsion-hydrate mixture viscosity in high water cut systems. Fuel, 2011, 90( 11): 3343– 3351

[84] Liu X, Flemings P B. Dynamic multiphase flow model of hydrate formation in marine sediments. Journal of Geophysical Research, 2007, 112( B3): B03101

[85] Oroskar A R, Turian R M. The critical velocity in pipeline flow of slurries. AIChE Journal, 1980, 26( 4): 550– 558

[86] Boxall J A, Koh C A, Sloan E D. . Droplet size scaling of water-in-oil emulsions under turbulent flow. Langmuir: the ACS Journal of Surfaces and Colloids, 2012, 28( 1): 104– 110

[87] Saffman P G. The lift on a small sphere in a slow shear flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 1965, 22( 2): 385– 400

[88] Richter A, Nikrityuk P A. Drag forces and heat transfer coefficients for spherical, cuboidal and ellipsoidal particles in cross flow at sub-critical Reynolds numbers. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2012, 55( 4): 1343– 1354

[89] Zerpa L E, Sloan E D, Koh C. . Hydrate risk assessment and restart-procedure optimization of an offshore well using a transient hydrate prediction model. Oil and Gas Facilities, 2012, 1( 5): 49– 56

[90] Wang W, Fan S, Liang D. . A model for estimating flow assurance of hydrate slurry in pipelines. Journal of Natural Gas Chemistry, 2010, 19( 4): 380– 384

[91] Chaudhari P, Zerpa L E, Sum A K. A correlation to quantify hydrate plugging risk in oil and gas production pipelines based on hydrate transportability parameters. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2018, 58 : 152– 161

[92] Chen Y, Gong J, Shi B. . Investigation into methane hydrate reformation in water-dominated bubbly flow. Fuel, 2020, 263 : 116691

[93] Brown G O. The history of the darcy-weisbach equation for pipe flow resistance. In: American Society of Civil Engineers Environmental and Water Resources History Sessions at ASCE Civil Engineering Conference and Exposition 2002, Washington, D.C.. 2002, 34– 43

[94] Camargo R, Palermo T, Sinquin A. . Rheological characterization of hydrate suspensions in oil dominated systems. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2006, 912( 1): 906– 916

[95] Camargo R Palermo T. Rheological properties of hydrate suspensions in an asphaltenic crude oil. In: Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Gas Hydrates, Yokohama, Japan, 2002

[96] Eskin D, Scarlett B. Model of the solids deposition in hydrotransport: an energy approach. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 2005, 44( 5): 1284– 1290

[97] Wu Y, Shang L, Pan Z. . Gas hydrate formation in the presence of mixed surfactants and alumina nanoparticles. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2021, 94 : 104049

[98] Zhang S Shang L Zhou L, . Hydrate deposition model and flow assurance technology in gas-dominant pipeline transportation systems: a review. Energy & Fuels, 2022, 36(4): 1747-1775

[99] Qin Y, Shang L, Lv Z. . Rapid formation of methane hydrate in environment-friendly leucine-based complex system. Energy, 2022, 254 : 124214

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the Doctoral Research Start-up Fund Project of Liaoning Province (2019-BS-159), the Scientific Research Fund Project of Liaoning Education Department (L2019024), and the Key Scientific Research Project of Liaoning Provincial Department of Education (L2020002).

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2022 Higher Education Press