1 Introduction
Layered alkali titanates is a class of layered solids composed of titania/titanic acid nanosheets and charge neutralizing alkali cations, which can be exchanged with various inorganic and organic cations, in the interlayer space [
1]. Due to the unique nanostructures and the chemical characteristics associated with the structures, layered alkali titanates are regarded as a unique type of nanostructured titania. From the nanostructures, the large surface area can be used for the reactions and, in order to take benefits of this aspect, exposure of the surface of nanosheets has been reported by the exfoliation and pillaring [
1,
2]. The particle morphology (from platy particles to whisker and nanotubes) determined from the nanostructures and the variation of the synthetic methods is another characteristics of layered alkali titanates, which is not easily available for common titania (anatase and rutile).
Taking the advantage of the characteristic features mentioned above, layered alkali titanates/titanic acids have been used in applications such as battery [
3], solar cell [
4], ion exchange/adsorption/separation [
5], catalysis [
6], and other functional materials. Layered alkali titanates have been expected as candidates for photocatalytic applications including decomposition of toxic organic pollutants, water splitting, CO
2 reduction, and chemical syntheses, because of the large surface area based on the nanosheets and possible spatial separation of active sites (distinct charge separation). To design the performances of the materials and to find new functions, the preparation of layered alkali titanates and the hybridization with a variety of guest species have been extensively investigated [
2,
7,
8]. Layered alkali titanates have been converted to protonated forms by treating them with an acidic solution [
9]. The collection of metal and organic cations from aqueous environments by ion exchange reactions has been reported using pristine layered alkali titanates and their protonated forms. In addition to the cation exchange of layered alkali titanates, the functionalization has been examined by the intercalation [
10,
11], the exfoliation and subsequent re-stacking [
12,
13], and the pillaring [
14]. Titanate nanosheets have been obtained by the exfoliation of layered alkali titanates through the ion exchange with appropriate organoammonium ions, which is a colloidal form of the titanates and can be processed by layer-by-layer assembly to obtain films. Porous heterostructured particles were obtained by re-stacking the exfoliated nanosheets with guest species to be connected [
15]. The adsorbed metal ions have been converted to compound particles such as oxide [
14] and sulfide [
16,
17]. A variety of nanostructured titanium oxides and their hybrids have been constructed from layered alkali titanates as shown in Fig. 1. Nanostructures of the hybrids have been designed by the selection of host and guest as well as the synthetic methods to control the functions (Fig. 2). There are several layered alkali titanates, whose structures and properties have been examined and, depending on the structure, the ion exchange, optical, electronic, and colloidal properties are known to vary. If compared with lepidocrocite-type layered titanates [
7], A
2Ti
nO
2n+1-type layered alkali titanates (Na
2Ti
3O
7, K
2Ti
4O
9, and Cs
2Ti
5O
11) possess a higher cation exchange capacity, which makes them promising as adsorbents and solid electrolytes for possible large adsorption/storage capacity. In addition, the titanate sheet of Na
2Ti
3O
7, K
2Ti
4O
9, and Cs
2Ti
5O
11 is not molecularly flat due to TiO
6 octahedra blocks being stepped every three, four, and five, respectively. In the present review, the attention will be focused on the three layered alkali titanates, Na
2Ti
3O
7, K
2Ti
4O
9, and Cs
2Ti
5O
11, because of the useful structural characteristics, the morphology of the particles, and chemical reactivities, for the application in energy and environmental issues with a special emphasis on adsorption and photocatalysis. Recent developments of layered alkali titanates and their hybrids on the synthesis, modification, structure/morpho-logy, and applications are summarized.
2 Structures of layered alkali titanates
Layered alkali titanates with a general formula of A
2Ti
nO
2n+1 are composed of nanosheets consisting of TiO
6 octahedral units connected by corners and edges sharing, and the interlayer alkali ion for compensating the negative charge of the titanate sheets. K
2Ti
2O
5 and Cs
2Ti
2O
5 are composed of sheets of TiO
5 unit connected by corners sharing, and interlayer alkali ion. The crystal structure of K
2Ti
2O
5, Na
2Ti
3O
7, K
2Ti
4O
9, Cs
2Ti
5O
11, Na
2Ti
6O
13, and K
2Ti
6O
13 are shown in Fig. 3. The crystal structures of layered alkali titanates are monoclinic, and belong to space groups P2
1/m for Na
2Ti
3O
7 [
18] and C
2/m for K
2Ti
2O
5 [
19], K
2Ti
4O
9 [
10], Cs
2Ti
5O
11 [
20], Na
2Ti
6O
13 [
21], and K
2Ti
6O
13 [
22]. The titanate sheets form zigzag ribbons extend in the direction of the
b axis of layered alkali titanates. The ribbons are connected by sharing corners of octahedra to form staggered sheets. The titanate sheets stack in the direction of the
a axis and the stacking is different in layered alkali titanates (Na
2Ti
3O
7, K
2Ti
4O
9, and Cs
2Ti
5O
11). The sequence of the titanate sheets is AAA for Na
2Ti
3O
7 and ABA for K
2Ti
4O
9 and Cs
2Ti
5O
11 [
23,
24]. For ABA stacking in K
2Ti
4O
9, the neighboring layers shift relative to each other titanate sheets in the
b axis, so that there are two kinds of interlayer spacings. The potassium ions (K(I)) are accommodated in the interlayer space of the titanate sheets [(Ti
4O
9)
2‒]. Half of K(I) in K
2Ti
4O
9 are located at the level of
y = 1/4 in one interlayer region and the rest are at
y = 3/4 in the other interlayer region. In the case of Na
2Ti
3O
7, sodium ions (Na(I)) are located at the levels of
y = 1/4 and 3/4 in the same interlayer space. For Na
2Ti
6O
13 and K
2Ti
6O
13, the titanate sheets are connected in the direction of
a axis by sharing the corners between the titanate sheets to form interstitial tunnels, which are filled by alkali ions (Figs. 3(b) and 3(c)). The interlayer cations of layered alkali titanates have been exchanged with various metal ions and cationic molecules to from intercalation compounds.
3 Preparation
The preparation of layered alkali titanates has been done by the solid-state reaction [
18–
20,
23,
25,
26], the flux method [
27,
28], and the hydrothermal reaction [
29–
35]. The layered alkali titanates (Na
2Ti
3O
7 [
18], Tl
2Ti
4O
9 [
10], K
2Ti
4O
9 [
23] and Cs
2Ti
5O
11 [
20]) were prepared by solid-state reactions in 1980. The starting materials for the solid-state reaction were stable phases such as anatase TiO
2, K
2CO
3, Na
2CO
3, and Cs
2CO
3 for mixing under ambient conditions. The mixture of the starting materials was activated by heating to obtain thermodynamically stable phases (target phase). Excess alkali metal may be necessary to compensate the evaporation of alkali metal during heating. For example, Na
2Ti
3O
7 was prepared by the solid-state reaction between Na
2CO
3 and anatase TiO
2 at a molar ratio of 1:2 at 1000°C, where large excess Na from stoichiometry was used [
18]. Yang et al. [
36] investigated the effect of the particle size of the starting materials on the formation of Na
2Ti
3O
7 as summarized in Table 1. Single phase Na
2Ti
3O
7 was obtained by heating at 800°C in air for 8 h, when anatase TiO
2 with a particle size of 20 nm was used as the Ti source. On the other hand, anatase TiO
2 with a size of >1 µm gave the single phase Na
2Ti
3O
7 with larger particle size after the solid-state reaction with Na
2CO
3 at 800°C for 40 h as shown in Fig. 4. The preparation of layered alkali titanate was also examined by using starting materials with a higher chemical reactivity. Bao et al. [
37,
38] prepared K
2Ti
4O
9 by heating the mixture of K
2CO
3 and TiO
2·
nH
2O, which was obtained by the hydrolysis of titanyl sulfate in hot water, at the molar ratio of K
2O and TiO
2 of 1:3 at 920°C for 10 h.
One dimensionally anisotropic particles were seen irrespective of the synthetic methods, while the size of layered alkali titanates depends on the methods of the preparation. The layered alkali titanates with fibrous and elongated rectangular shape with the particle length of sub-micrometer to micrometer scale were obtained by the solid-state reaction and the flux method [
18,
20,
23,
27,
28]. On the other hand, the hydrothermal synthesis of layered alkali titanates gave tubular shaped particles with the diameter of a few tens of nanometer and micrometer scale in the length [
29,
33,
34]. The particle morphology of K
2Ti
4O
9 is whisker with a diameter of 1.0–2.0 µm and a length of 10–50 µm as shown in Fig. 5. Fibrous particles were obtained for Cs
2Ti
5O
11, which was prepared by heating the mixture of Cs
2CO
3 and anatase TiO
2 at a molar ratio of 1:4 at 1000°C for 20 h [
20,
25].
Flux materials (such as V
2O
5, PbO, Bi
2O
3 and K
2MoO
4) were used to induce the melting/dissolution of the starting materials. Subsequent crystallization during cooling process was done to control the phase as well as the particle size/shape of the product. For example, the K
2Ti
6O
13 fiber was prepared by using K
2CO
3-V
2O
5 flux at different molar ratios as summarized in Table 2 [
27]. The shape and length of the K
2Ti
6O
13 particles obtained by the flux method were significantly affected by the fraction of flux as shown in Fig. 6 [
27]. The K
2Ti
6O
13 needle was formed from the flux at the weight ratio of Bi
2O
3/K
2Ti
6O
13 = 0.7 to 1.5 and PbO/K
2Ti
6O
13 = 0.7 to 2 [
27]. Impurity (or minor phase) phases were also formed depending on the cooling rate. K
2Ti
6O
13 co-existed with K
2Ti
4O
9 when the melt was quenched from 1150°C to room temperature, while K
2Ti
4O
9 and K
2Ti
2O
5 were formed by slow cooling at the cooling rate of 16°C/h from 1150°C to 950°C and then quenched to room temperature [
26–
28]. The crystals of Na
2Ti
3O
7 with the length of 0.1–0.3 mm were obtained by the crystallization from the melt of Na
2CO
3, TiO
2, and GeO
2 at 950°C (Fig. 7) [
39]. K
2Ti
4O
9 and K
2Ti
6O
13 were obtained from the mixture of (K
2O)
1/4·TiO
2 and K
2MoO
4 at a molar ratio of 30:70 [
40]. The fraction of K
2Ti
4O
9 and K
2Ti
6O
13 depended on the reaction temperature. The mixture of 50% K
2Ti
4O
9 and 50% K
2Ti
6O
13 formed by heating at 1100°C for 60 min, while K
2Ti
4O
9 was obtained as single phase by heating at 950°C for 60 min. The mixed phases of the layered alkali titanates have been reported by the flux method [
26–
28,
39,
40].
The TiO
2 (anatase) powder is usually used as the starting material for the syntheses of layered alkali titanates by the hydrothermal method [
32,
41–
43]. The starting mixtures were dissolved at autogenous pressure [
29–
31]. The fibrous particles of Na
2Ti
3O
7 with a particle length of 20–100 μm and a width smaller than 1 μm were obtained by the hydrothermal reaction of TiO
2 and aqueous solution of NaOH at a concentration lower than 3 mol/L, at a temperature above 400°C, and a pressure above 17 MPa [
29]. Parameters such as pH of the starting solution and the composition are known to determine the product, while the composition of the product is difficult to be precisely controlled [
30]. The temperature for the syntheses affected the aggregation of the titanate nanotubes in addition to the structure of the titanate [
33,
34]. Titanate nanotubes were obtained by heating rutile TiO
2 with NaOH at a concentration of 10 mol/L and a temperature of 150°C, while the titanate nanorods was formed at 180°C for 48 h as shown by the TEM images (Fig. 8). A bundle of titanate nanotube was observed when the preparation was done at 180°C for 5 h. After prolonged to the reaction for 30 h, the bundle turned into a rod with nanotubes attached on the outer surface as shown in Fig. 9 [
33]. Flower-like layered sodium titanate was prepared by hydrothermal method in a weakly alkaline medium, where NaCl was claimed to act as a morphology directing agent [
44]. The formation of flower-like layered sodium titanate depended on NaCl concentration, as shown in Fig. 10. Layered alkali titanates with fibrous or tubular particle morphology were prepared by utilizing the hydrothermal method and the particle size of a micrometer in length and a few tens to hundreds of nanometers in width was obtained [
29–
35].
In general, one dimensionally anisotropic shaped particles of the layered alkali titanates were obtained while the particle size and shape largely depend on the methods of preparation. The layered alkali titanates particles with fibrous/whisker and elongated rectangular shapes of submicrometer to micrometer scale in size were obtained by the solid-state reaction and flux method [
18–
20,
23,
25–
28], while the hydrothermal synthesis of the layered alkali titanates gave tubular shape in nanometer size [
29–
34]. A comparison of the preparation methods is given in Table 3.
4 Characteristics of layered titanates
Adsorptive and (photo)catalytic properties of layered titanate have been modified by the functionalization through cation exchange and nanoparticle immobilization, which are introduced in Section 4 as cation exchange, complexation with metallic nanoparticles, and hybridization with semiconductor nanoparticles.
4.1 Cation exchange
The ion exchange of metal ions on layered alkali titanates has been examined in order to take advantage of the high cation exchange capacity (CEC) of some layered alkali titanates. The theoretical cation exchange capacity of Na
2Ti
3O
7, K
2Ti
4O
9, and Cs
2Ti
5O
11 calculated from the chemical formula are 6.63, 4.83, and 2.94 meq/g, which are quite high compared with layered silicates such as smectites (0.6–1.2 meq/g), magadiite (2.0 meq/g) [
2]. The high cation exchange capacity is an advantageous aspect for the application on the concentration of novel and toxic metal ions from aqueous environments and the materials design based on the layered titanates.
The ion exchange of the layered alkali titanates with several metal ions such as Ag(I), Cu(II), Sr(II), Br(II), Pb(II), Cd(II), Eu(III), Cr(III), and Ce(III) has been reported [
45–
52]. The quantitative ion exchange of Na
2Ti
3O
7 with mono, di and trivalent ions (proton, NH
4+, Mg(II), Ni(II), Co(II), and Al(III)) was studied by Ikenaga et al. [
53]. The preferential adsorption of proton from acidic aqueous solution containing Ni(II) and Al(III) was reported compared with Ni(II) and Al(III), while the ion exchange between Na
2Ti
3O
7 and the monovalent ions (proton and NH
4+) gave H
2Ti
3O
7 and (NH
4)
2Ti
3O
7, respectively. The intercalation was examined by XRD to observe the change of basal spacing (Fig. 11) [
53]. The adsorption of metal from aqueous solution has been investigated and the adsorption isotherms have been used to understand the interaction. Liu et al. reported the efficient concentration of Hg(II) from aqueous solution on flower-like Na
2Ti
3O
7 by the L-type adsorption isotherm shown in Fig. 12 [
54].
Proton exchange of Na
2Ti
3O
7, K
2Ti
4O
9, and Cs
2Ti
5O
11 was done by treating the titanates in the HCl solution to obtain H
2Ti
3O
7, H
2Ti
4O
9·H
2O, and H
2Ti
5O
11·3H
2O [
9,
23,
55–
58]. The ion exchange of the protonic forms of layered alkali titanates with cations such as Li(I), Na(I), K(I), Rb(I), Cs(I), Ag(I), Ba(II), Co(II), Cu(II), Fe(II), Ni(II), Cd(II), Zn(II), Co(II), Pb(II), Sr(II), Br(II), Ca(II), Mg(II), Mn(III), La(III), Gd(III), Eu(III), Tb(III), Lu(III), NH
4+, and alkylammonium has been reported [
11,
23,
45,
55,
57–
69]. The ion exchange of protonic forms of titanates with alkali ions was influenced by the pH and ionic radii of alkali metals [
55,
56]. The ion exchange of H
2Ti
3O
7 with Na(I) required a pH higher than 11 as shown in Fig. 13. The ion exchange of H
2Ti
3O
7 with Li(I), Na(I), and K(I) was about 63%, 43%, and 11% of CEC of H
2Ti
3O
7 (7.76 meq/g) after the reaction for 3 days at room temperature (Fig. 14). The degree of ion exchange decreased when the ionic radii of alkali metals was larger [
55]. The ionic radii of Li(I), Na(I), and K(I) are 0.74, 1.02, and 1.38 Å, respectively [
70].
Wang et al. examined the competitive adsorption of Pb(II), Cd(II), and Cr(III) on Na
2Ti
3O
7 nanotubes to find the ion selectivity as Pb(II)>Cd(II)>Cr(III) [
49]. The selective and irreversible adsorption of Hg(II) from aqueous solution on a flower-like Na
2Ti
3O
7 was investigated to show the high selectivity of Hg(II) in the presence of Mg(II) and Ca(II) [
54]. The competitive ion exchange of Mn(II) and Gd(III) on H
2Ti
3O
7 was examined to show the selectivity order of Gd(III)>Mn(II) [
60]. Recently, the ion exchange of layered alkali titanates with several alkali metal halides has been obtained by solid-state reaction at room temperature [
71]. The adsorbed amount of metal ions and the understanding of the sequence of the ion exchange from aqueous solution on layered titanates are still worth further investigation.
The intercalation of a cationic dye into the interlayer space of layered titanates has been reported for the purposes of photosensitization and photofunctional materials design [
72]. The dimethylviologen cation was intercalated into the interlayer space of K
2Ti
4O
9 to show photoinduced charge transfer, which is demonstrated by the color change from colorless to blue (photochromism) by the UV irradiation to the powder sample [
73]. Some cationic cyanine dyes were intercalated into Na
2Ti
3O
7 and Cs
0.7Ti
1.98□0.02O
4 (□ represents vacancy) by cation exchange reactions using the alkylammonium-exchanged forms as the intermediates [
74,
75]. The alkylammonium exchanged forms were used as the precursor of organic derivates of the layered titanates [
76,
77]. On the other hand, macrocyclic compounds were used to accelerate the ion exchange of K
2Ti
4O
9 [
78,
79].
4.2 Complexation with metallic nanoparticles
Nanoparticles of Pt and Pd have been synthesized from the adsorbed metal ions in/on the layered alkali titanates [
62,
80]. Pt nanoparticles have been prepared by the ion exchange of the alkali ions of the layered titanates (A
2Ti
3O
7, A= Li(I), Na(I) and K(I)) with Pt complexes ([Pt(NH
3)
2]
2+) and the subsequent reduction of the adsorbed [Pt(NH
3)
2]
2+ by the heat treatment under H
2. The Pt nanoparticles located on the internal and external surfaces of the titanate nanotube (Fig. 15(a)) [
80]. The particle size of the Pt nanoparticles was around 0.5–1.5 nm as shown in Fig. 15(b). The deposition of Pd nanoparticles on H
2Ti
3O
7 nanotubes was done by the ion exchange of Pd(II) in acidic solution at room temperature and subsequent reduction [
62]. The particle size distribution of the spheroidal particle of Pd was in the range of 1.9–4.8 nm. Spatial distribution of Pd nanoparticles depended on the Pd (II) loading as shown in Fig. 16. The nonuniform deposition of Pd nanoparticles was seen at the Pd(II) loading of 4.75% (mass fraction), while the distribution of Pd nanoparticles was more uniform at the Pd(II) loading of 6.97 and 8.86% (mass fraction).
4.3 Hybridization with semiconductor nanoparticles
The metal ions adsorbed on layered titanates have been converted to semiconductor particle such as oxides and sulfides. Marques et al. reported the intercalation of Ce(IV) and Ce(III) on Na
2Ti
3O
7 by the ion exchange with aqueous solution of (NH
4)
2Ce(NO
3)
6 and the subsequent formation of CeO
2 particles on the external surface of the titanate nanotube [
81]. The amount of CeO
2 nanoparticles on the surface of the titanate nanotube increased as the Ce concentration of the starting solution increased, and the relation is summarized in Fig. 17. SiO
2- and Al
2O
3-pillared Ti
4O
9 were prepared by the ion exchange of K
2Ti
4O
9 with alkylammonium cation and subsequent reactions with tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS) and aqueous solution of aluminum hydroxide oligomers [Al
13O
4(OH)
24(H
2O)
12]
7+, respectively, followed by the calcination at 500°C under O
2 [
82,
83]. The pillaring of K
2Ti
4O
9 with TiO
2 particles was examined by the reaction alkylammonium-Ti
4O
9 with TiO
2 sol and subsequent decomposition of alkylammonium ions by UV irradiation in water [
84]. The RuO
2 supported Na
2Ti
3O
7 was prepared by the impregnation of dodecacarbonyltriruthenium (Ru
3(CO)
12) from tetahydrofuran followed by the reduction at 400°C under H
2 and the subsequent oxidation in air at 400°C [
85]. The TEM images (Fig. 18) indicated that the immobilized RuO
2 particle had spherical shape with the size of 2–3 nm.
Nanoparticles of
γ-Fe
2O
3 was incorporated in H
2Ti
3O
7 nanotubes by the self-assembly of
γ-Fe
2O
3 nanoparticles and H
2Ti
3O
7 nanotubes in water at pH 6.5 [
86]. The
γ-Fe
2O
3 nanoparticles were attached on H
2Ti
3O
7 bundles at both ends of the nanotubes and the free
γ-Fe
2O
3 nanoparticles were presented when the fraction of
γ-Fe
2O
3 nanoparticles increased to 25% (mass fraction) as shown by the TEM images (Fig. 19). Lin et al. prepared CdS-pillared H
2Ti
3O
7 by the self-assembly of exfoliated titanate nanosheets and CdS sol through the electrostatic interactions [
87]. The CdS-pillared H
2Ti
3O
7 showed a microporous structure as characterized by the XRD patterns (with the basal spacing of 2.60 nm, corresponded to the interlayer space of 1.82 nm) and the N
2 adsorption/desorption isotherms (Fig. 20). The CdS-pillared H
2Ti
3O
7 at a CdS:Ti
3O
72‒ molar ratio of 1:1, 1:2, and 1:3 exhibited a bimodal pore size distribution at 2.3 and 4.6 nm, corresponding to the interlayer space of the CdS pillared titanate and the interparticle space between the nanohybrids [
87].
The dehydration/dehydroxylation of the proton exchanged forms, H
2Ti
3O
7, H
2Ti
4O
9, and H
2Ti
5O
11, resulting in the formation of a metastable form of titania, TiO
2(B), which was transformed to anatase and then rutile by further thermal treatment at higher temperatures [
23,
56,
88,
89]. The dehydration of the titanic acids was claimed to proceed through the following three steps: condensation of layered titanate nanosheets as the layers join together through corner-sharing TiO
6 octahedra (endothermic reaction), formation of TiO
2(B) intermediate (exothermic reaction), and low energy transformation of TiO
2(B) [
88]. The formation of TiO
2(B) depended on the original structure of the layered titanates while the crystallinity of the TiO
2(B) depended on the length of the connection of TiO
6 octahedra and the temperature of dehydration [
88].
5 Applications of layered alkali titanates and their hybrids
The applications of layered alkali titanate and their hybrids related to environment and energy issues are discussed in this section. The application includes adsorbent of metal ions, photocatalysts for water treatment and artificial photosyntheses (H2 and/or O2 production and CO2 reduction) as summarized in Table 4.
5.1 Adsorbents
The adsorption of target metal ions from water for the water purification and collection of useful metal ions has been reported using layered alkali titanates. Zou et al. prepared Zr-doped Na
2Ti
3O
7 with a porous core of an ultrafine nanofiber for the removal of multiple heavy metal ions such as Pb(II), Cd(II), Cu(II), and Sr(II) [
90]. The adsorption isotherms with the Langmuir model and the adsorption kinetic curves of Pb(II), Cd(II), Cu(II), and Sr(II) on Zr-doped Na
2Ti
3O
7 are shown in Fig. 21. The adsorbed amounts of Pb(II), Cu(II), and Cd(II) were 2.91, 2.56, and 2.10 mmol/g, which corresponded to the removal efficiency of 100% within 20, 10 and 20 min, respectively. The removal efficiency of Sr(II) was 77% within 60 min (1.59 mmol/g). The layered titanates (H
xNa
2‒xTi
3O
7) prepared by the hydrothermal reaction were used to concentrate Cu(II) and Cd(II) from aqueous solutions [
50]. The maximum adsorbed amounts of Cu(II) and Cd(II) were 120 mg/g and 210 mg/g, respectively. Cs
2Ti
5O
11 and Na
2Ti
3O
7 were used to concentrate Cd(II) from aqueous solution [
91]. Cd(II) was collected by the ion-exchange for Cs
2Ti
5O
11 and the formation of CdCO
3 accompanied with the proton-Na(I) exchange for Na
2Ti
3O
7. The maximum collected Cd(II) amounts were 1.28 mmol/g Cs
2Ti
5O
11 and 1.16 mmol/g Na
2Ti
3O
7. The collection of In(III) in aqueous solution was also possible by using Na
2Ti
3O
7 [
92] and the collected In(III) existed as In(OH)
3 on the surface of the layered titanate. The maximum collected In(III) amount for Na
2Ti
3O
7 was 2.0 mmol/g, which is quite high if compared with those achieved by common ion exchangers.
The Na
2Ti
3O
7 nanofibers were used to remove divalent radioactive and heavy metal ions such as Sr(II) (0.63 mmol/g), Ba(II) (0.95 mmol/g), and Pb(II) (1.35 mmol/g) from wastewater [
46]. The selective adsorption of Sr(II), Ba(II), and Pb(II) over Na by the Na
2Ti
3O
7 nanofibers was achieved in the presence of excess of Na(I).
5.2 Photocatalyst
5.2.1 Pristine layered alkali titanates and their protonated forms
Some layered alkali titanates are useful photocatalysts for water splitting and the oxidation of organic molecules in water under UV irradiation [
93‒98]. Shibata et al. examined the H
2 production from the aqueous methanol solution using Na
2Ti
3O
7, K
2Ti
2O
5, K
2Ti
4O
9, K
2Ti
6O
13 and proton exchange forms of the layered alkali titanates with and without the Pt deposition as photocatalysts [
93]. The layered alkali titanates were synthesized by solid-state reactions and the proton exchanged forms were prepared by treating the layered alkali titanates with the aqueous solution of H
2SO
4. The K
2Ti
2O
5 and the proton exchanged form (H
2Ti
2O
5) exhibited a high activity of H
2 production for the samples with and without Pt deposition. The photocatalytic H
2 production of layered cesium titanates (Cs
2Ti
2O
5, Cs
2Ti
5O
11, and Cs
2Ti
6O
13) was examined by Kudo and Kondo [
94]. The Cs
2Ti
2O
5 composed of TiO
5 units showed a higher photocatalytic H
2 production activity from aqueous methanol solution than those from Cs
2Ti
5O
11 and Cs
2Ti
6O
11, which are composed of TiO
6 units. In addition to the break-down approach [
95], a small sized layered titanate was obtained by lowering reaction temperature of the solid-state reaction [
99]. Ogawa et al. [
99] reported improved dispersion and photocatalytic activity of the small sized titanate (0.2 µm) obtained by lower temperature synthesis (600°C), if compared with that (30 µm) prepared by reported synthetic conditions (800°C–1000°C), leading to the reduced light scattering and the larger surface area for the substance. K
2Ti
6O
13 fibers, which were prepared by flux synthesis, showed a photocatalytic active by UV irradiation for H
2 production from aqueous methanol solution [
100]. The H
2 production rate of 298 µmol/(h·g) was reported for K
2Ti
6O
13 fibers without co-catalyst. K
2Ti
6O
13 after Rh loading as co-catalyst was able to catalyze water vapor into H
2 by the UV irradiation at the rate of 18 µmol/(h·g) [
101].
5.2.2 Metal-doped titanates nanosheets
Rh-doped titanate nanosheets ([Ti
3–xRh
xO
7]
2–) were synthesized by solid-state reaction between Na
2CO
3, anatase TiO
2, and Rh
2O
3 mixture followed by the exfoliation through acid-base reaction [
102]. The shift in the absorption edge to a longer wavelength was found on the Rh-doped titanate nanosheets if compared with pristine titanate, corresponding to the role of 4d level of Rh
3+ or Rh
4+, which are thought to be doped in the titanate framework (Fig. 22). Figure 22 shows the H
2 evolution from the Rh-doped titanate nanosheets. In the presence of triethylamine (TEA), the Rh-doped titanate nanosheet (Rh:Ti= 1%(mole fraction)) exhibited the H
2 evolution at the rates of 1040 and 302 µmol/(h·g) by UV irradiation (>220 nm) and near UV irradiation (>340 nm), respectively, which were approximately 25 and 7.5 times greater than those by undoped titanate nanosheets.
Microwave-assisted hydrothermal treatment of TiO
2 precursor in the presence of yttrium nitrate solution from highly alkaline media and subsequent proton exchange reaction was done to obtain Y-doped titanic acid nanotubes (H
2Y
xTi
2–xO
5·H
2O). As a result, the band gap narrowing by about 0.28 eV and inducing anatase/rutile phase to form H
2Y
xTi
2–xO
5·H
2O/anatase/rutile heterostructure were observed [
103]. By the 1% (mass fraction) Y-doping, H
2 production from aqueous methanol solution by the UV-visible light irradiation for 7 h was higher by a factor of 5.5 compared to H
2Ti
2O
5·H
2O, which was attributed to the enhanced light harvesting (smaller band gap) and effective charge separation. The rates were increased from 72 µmol/(h·g) (H
2Y
xTi
2–xO
5·H
2O/anatase/rutile) to 6660, 11660, and 5280 µmol/(h·g) after the loading of Ni, Cu, and Co by the
in situ photoreduction method, respectively.
5.2.3 Titania derived from protonated layered titanates
Phase transformation of protonated layered titanates (H
2Ti
nO
2n+1) to crystalline titania (anatase, rutile, TiO
2(B), brookite) occurs by the heat treatment and the product phases depended on the type of the protonated layered titanates, impurities and heat treatment conditions. The photocatalytic activity of H
2Ti
2O
5 depended on the heat treatment temperature of H
2Ti
2O
5, where the H
2Ti
2O
5 heated at 350°C showed the highest H
2 production activity, which was explained as a result of the transformation of the layered titanate to anatase [
93]. Layered structure of titanates also favored the homogeneous substitution of oxygen by nitrogen, led to a band-to-band visible-light excitation [
104]. N-doped anatase TiO
2 with oxygen vacancies was prepared by the heat treatment of H
2Ti
2O
5·H
2O mesoporous assembly containing N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) in air [
105]. The N-doped anatase thus prepared showed a photocatalytic activity for the H
2 production at the rate of 1035 µmol/(h·g) from methanol-water solution under solar light irradiation (solar simulator). The action spectrum for the H
2 evolution on the photocatalyst exhibited the negligible visible light response photocatalysis (>400 nm) and thus, suggested that the inducing of oxygen vacancies mediated by the N doping played the role in the enhanced charge separation and photocatalytic efficiency. Depending on the heat treatment temperature, mesoporous TiO
2(B) nanobelts were obtained by the heat treatment of H
2Ti
3O
7 nanotubes in air at 450°C, while anatase nanobelts were obtained by annealing at 750°C [
106]. Mesoporous TiO
2(B) nanobelts after Pt loading exhibited a H
2 evolution capability from aqueous methanol solution with the rate of 9375 µmol/(h·g), which was higher than that of anatase TiO
2 nanobelts (4030 µmol/(h·g)) by solar light irradiation. Calcination of H
2Ti
3O
7 nanotubes in air under various conditions (temperature and time) was investigated to prepare a series of anatase TiO
2 nanorods. Reduction of specific surface area of anatase nanorods, irrespective of the crystallinity (crystallite size derived by Scherrer’s equation), was observed as a result of sintering at a higher temperature and/or longer time. Anatase nanorods calcined at 600°C (optimal condition) exhibited the H
2 evolution rates of 8700, 30000, 39000 µmol/(h·g) from ethanol-water solution by UV irradiation after loading with Au, Pd, and Pd-Au, respectively [
107]. The calcination of protonated-trititanate nanosheets and nanotubes (obtained by hydrothermal reaction) at 450°C–550°C has been reported to obtain anatase/TiO
2(B) heterostructures [
108–
110]. The anatase/TiO
2(B) heterostructures prepared by heating protonated-trititanate nanotubes at 550°C, exhibited a H
2 production activity of 21.72 mmol/g after 2 h of solar light irradiation (about 1.16 and 10 times over P25 and that heated at 350°C). The efficient H
2 production was claimed to be due to the synergistic effect of the high surface area and the promoted electron-hole separation between anatase and TiO
2(B) interface, which were supported by the specific surface area, photoluminescence, and decay time from transient photovoltage spectra [
109].
5.2.4 Metal-exchanged titanates
The layered alkali titanates have been functionalized by the ion exchange for visible light responsive photocatalyst. The Sn(II) ion exchanged forms of K
2Ti
2O
5 and K
2Ti
4O
9 were active photocatalyst for H
2 production from aqueous methanol solutions by visible light irradiation [
96]. The visible light absorption of Sn(II) intercalated K
2Ti
2O
5 and K
2Ti
4O
9 was explained as the electronic transition from an electron donor level consisting of Sn 5s orbitals to the conduction band consisting of Ti 3d orbitals. Mesoporous Co(II) intercalated layered titanate formed by the self-assembly of Co(II) and titanate nanosheets ([Ti
4O
9]
2‒) was active photocatalyst for the decomposition of MB by visible light irradiation [
111]. The Co(II) gave visible light response due to the electronic transition from the valence band consisting of O 2p orbitals to the electron acceptor level consisting of Co 3d and Ti d orbitals.
5.2.5 Nanoparticles immobilized titanates
Layered titanates have been functionalized by the hybridization with nanoparticles of metals and metal oxides such as Pt and RuO
2 which are expected to act as co-catalysts for H
2 and O
2 production, respectively. H
2 production from water by K
2Ti
4O
9, H
2Ti
4O
9, and the titanate nanosheets (designated as TBA
2Ti
4O
9), which were obtained by using tetrabutylammonium ion for the exfoliation of H
2Ti
4O
9, has been reported by UV irradiation in the presence of methanol [
13]. The H
2 production activity of K
2Ti
4O
9, H
2Ti
4O
9, and TBA
2Ti
4O
9 increased after Pt deposition. The layered titanates after Pt deposition were active for the O
2 production from aqueous AgNO
3 solution, and the results are shown in Fig. 23 [
13]. The photocatalytic water splitting by RuO
2/Na
2Ti
3O
7 was active under UV irradiation, while the smaller particle size of RuO
2/Na
2Ti
3O
7 exhibited a higher activity than that by larger sized RuO
2 particle as shown in Fig. 24 [
85]. Pt nanoparticles were deposited on the layered titanate nanotubes (M
2-xH
xTi
3O
7, M is Li(I), Na(I), K(I), and Cs(I)) by impregnation for photocatalytic H
2 production from neat alcohol [
97]. The electron transfer between the layered titanates nanotube and Pt nanoparticles was accelerated and the particle size of Pt nanoparticles were larger for the layered titanate nanotubes with larger alkali metal ions. The electron density on Pt nanoparticles affected the reduction of proton and the rate of H
2 production, while the larger particle size of Pt nanoparticles, which had excessive accumulation of the electron, led to the increase of the electron-hole recombination and reduced H
2 production.
SiO
2-pillared H
2Ti
4O
9 prepared by the intercalation of organosilanes into the interlayer space of K
2Ti
4O
9 followed by the calcination was applied for the photodegradation of methylene blue (MB) under UV irradiation [
83]. The SiO
2-pilared H
2Ti
4O
9 showed a higher MB adsorbed amount compared with H
2Ti
4O
9 and K
2Ti
4O
9 due to the higher surface area, which was shown by N
2 adsorption desorption isotherms (Fig. 25), and the degradation of MB by using SiO
2-pilared H
2Ti
4O
9 was also faster than those by H
2Ti
4O
9 and K
2Ti
4O
9. TiO
2 intercalated Pt/H
2Ti
4O
9 was capable of splitting water into H
2 and O
2 by UV irradiation at 60°C, producing 0.3 mmol of H
2 over 5 h [
84].
Cd
1‒xZn
xS/K
2Ti
4O
9 was used for the decomposition of Rhodamine B (abbreviated as RhB) by visible light irradiation [
112]. The photocatalytic activity depended on Zn content and the loading amount of Cd
0.8Zn
0.2S. Cd
0.8Zn
0.2S/K
2Ti
4O
9 with a 30% (mass fraction) Cd
0.8Zn
0.2S exhibited the highest photocatalytic activity as shown in Fig. 26. WO
3 and Rh nanoparticles were deposited on a protonated titanate nanotube (H
2Ti
3O
7) to prepare a ternary photocatalyst by microwave-assisted hydrothermal method. The ternary photocatalyst was active for H
2 evolution from water using 2-propanol as sacrificial donor under UV light and visible light [
113]. Combining Rh and WO
3 on titanate nanotubes (with the optimal content of 0.5% (mass fraction) Rh: 3% (mass fraction) WO
3: H
2Ti
3O
7), enhanced H
2 production and stability during repeated cycles were achieved if compared with those for Rh supported- or WO
3 supported-titanate nanotubes. The deposition of Rh nanoparticles onto WO
3/titanate significantly improved H
2 production to achieve a rate of 4680 and 1740 µmol/(h·g) by UV (365 nm) and visible light (450 nm) irradiation, respectively, which were higher than those (1320 and 260 µmol/(h·g)) from WO
3/titanate. WO
3 was explained to act as a stabilizer to prevent the collapsing of titanate nanostructure during the repeated uses.
Extracting H
2 from hydrogen-rich chemical substances (such as ammonia borane and ammonium phosphates) is a useful means of hydrogen storage due to its high hydrogen content (up to 19% (mass fraction), 148.2 kg/m
3 in the case of ammonia borane). H
2 is released from the compounds by thermolysis in solid state, from aqueous solution in the presence of appropriate catalysts, for thermohydrolysis and photocatalytic hydrolysis. H
2 evolution by light irradiation was reported using titania- and titanate-based materials for photocatalytic hydrolysis of ammonia borane [
114–
116] and ammonium phosphates [
117,
118]. The photocatalytic hydrolysis of ammonia borane on reduced graphene oxide coupled with Na
2Ti
3O
7 microspheres (rGO/Na
2Ti
3O
7) by visible light irradiation was improved compared to those by pristine rGO and Na
2Ti
3O
7, suggesting a possible synergistic effect of the hybridization between rGO and Na
2Ti
3O
7. The suppression of the charge recombination by rGO and the photothermal effect of rGO can contribute to the accelerated H
2 release by the rGO/Na
2Ti
3O
7 microspheres (Fig. 27) [
119]. The ion exchange of Na
2Ti
3O
7 nanotubes with Fe and Co ions was done using the solution mixture of ferrous sulfate and cobalt sulfate to obtain FeCo-exchanged Ti
3O
7. A superior photocatalytic activity was observed for FeCo-exchanged Ti
3O
7 (Fe:Co weight ratio of 3:7) toward tri-ammonium phosphate hydrolysis by sun light for an hour to give the H
2 production of 348200 µmol/(h·g
salt·g
cat) (salt means the dry tri-ammonium phosphate) if compared with those for pristine TiO
2 (80200 µmol/(h·g
salt·g
cat), Fe-exchanged Ti
3O
7 (223200 µmol/(h·g
salt·g
cat)), and co-exchanged Ti
3O
7 (196400 µmol/(h·g
salt·g
cat)) [
118]. The enhancement was explained by the extension of the absorption to visible light region by the incorporation of Fe and Co ions.
A ternary photocatalyst (CdS/(Cu-TNTs)) obtained by sequential deposition of metallic copper (Cu(0)) and CdS quantum dots onto sodium trititanate nanotubes (Na
xH
2‒xTi
3O
7) was reported to convert CO
2 and water into C1–C3 hydrocarbons (e.g., CH
4, C
2H
6, C
3H
8, C
2H
4, and C
3H
6) upon visible light irradiation (>420 nm) as shown in Fig. 28 [
120]. It was explained that, by visible light irradiation, photogenerated electrons in CdS were transported to metallic Cu through the titanate nanotube as a solid mediator and reduced CO
2 to C1–C3 hydrocarbons, on the contrary, holes oxidized water (Fig. 28(a)). In addition, the role of remaining Na in the interlayer space of the titanate was also discussed (Fig. 28(b)), where the increment of interlayer Na(I) promoted C2–C3 production due to specific surface area increasing as well as some impact on the formation of surface-bound carbonate as confirmed by DRIFT.
Wei et al. reported a morphology-dependent photocatalytic activity of octahedral anatase particles (OAPs) obtained by hydrothermal treatment of K
2Ti
8O
17 nanowires for oxidative decomposition of acetic acid from water by UV irradiation. The photocatalytic activity was enhanced for the sample with a higher OAP content, correlated to slower time-resolved microwave conductivity (TRMC) signal decay, i.e., slower recombination of charge carriers (e
−/h
+) probably due to lower content of deep electron traps (Fig. 29) [
121].
5.3 Other applications
Layered titanates have been considered as a negative electrode material. The Li(I) insertion behavior of H
2Ti
3O
7 nanotubes was reported. The H
2Ti
3O
7 nanotube exhibited a large capacity at an initial capacity of 282.2 mAh/g over a potential range of 2.5–1.0 V [
132]. Li
2Ti
3O
7 was prepared by the ion exchange of Na
2Ti
3O
7 in molten LiNO
3/LiCl [
133]. The reversible Li(I) intercalation and deintercalations was in a voltage range of 1.5–2.0 V (versus Li/Li(I)) and the initial Li(I) intercalation capacity of Li
2Ti
3O
7 was 147 mAh/g. The capacity of Li
2Ti
3O
7 decreased from 147 to 70 mAh/g during the initial 10 cycles (Fig. 30). Na
2Ti
3O
7 was reported as an effective low voltage material for Na(I) battery because its reversed ability uptakes 2 Na(I) per formula unit with a capacity of 200 mAh/g at an average potential of 0.3 V versus Na(I)/Na(0) [
134]. The intensity of the XRD patterns of the Na
2Ti
3O
7 trended to decrease when the diffraction patterns of Na
4Ti
3O
7 were found after the reduction, and the intensity of Na
2Ti
3O
7 increased by the reversed process as shown in Fig. 31.
6 Conclusions and future perspectives
The preparation, characterization, and function/functionalization of layered alkali titanates were summarized with the special emphasis on Na2Ti3O7, K2Ti4O9, and Cs2Ti5O11. The cation exchange of the interlayer cations has been used to concentrate various metal cations from water, where very large capacity has been expected and achieved to some extent. Combining the advantages of the nanostructure (nanosheet based structure, with potentially large surface area), materials design on Na2Ti3O7, K2Ti4O9, and Cs2Ti5O11 has been done for applications such as electrode and adsorbent. A wide range of morphological variation (achieved by the synthetic methods and conditions as well as by the post synthetic treatments) with anisotropic particles from nanometer to micrometer scales and their suspension and films made application of the layered titanates more versatile. The application as photocatalysts is one of the important directions and morphological variation and the hybridization achieved by the chemical reactivities of the layered titanates has been reported. New, simple, and eco-friendly hybridization methods of layered titanates-based materials are worth developing to control the structure of the hybrids, which may not be available by other reported methods, as well as to obtain improved/new functions. Comprehensive understanding to describe the synthesis-structure and the structure-property relationships is also required. Further systematic studies on the effects of the compositional, morphological variation, and the hybridization are worth conducting, in order to establish the potential of the layered alkali titanates and other related layered transition metal oxides.