Toward sustainable lithium-ion battery industry: an integrated approach to the trilemma

Abstract

The global energy transition’s reliance on lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) faces a critical sustainability trilemma, in which the simultaneous pursuit of rapid decarbonization, resource security, and economic viability generates inherent trade-offs. This perspective highlights that the trilemma is reinforced by three interconnected systemic dilemmas: a policy-action chasm (weak enforcement), a technology-market dislocation (scalability gaps), and a temporal disequilibrium (economic misalignment). Current fragmented approaches are insufficient to address these core challenges. We propose an integrated circularity framework that aligns interventions across policy, technology, and market domains. To bridge the policy-action chasm, we advocate for smart regulations, including multilateral certification reciprocity. To mitigate the technology-market dislocation, we recommend adaptable, modular recycling systems augmented with AI. To resolve the temporal disequilibrium, we suggest market restructuring through blockchain-tracked material certificates linked to tradable environmental, social, and governance tokens. This framework provides a coordinated pathway to decouple LIB growth from dependence on virgin resources, directly tackling the root causes of the sustainability trilemma.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Lithium-ion battery industry / Resource dependency shift / Policy divergence / Sustainability trilemma / Integrated circularity framework / Policy-technology-market nexus

Highlight

	● LIB sustainability faces conflicting decarbonization, security, and economy.
	● Policy gap, technology lock-in, and market distortion block global LIB circularity.
	● A frame integrates smart regulation, modular recycling, and blockchain markets.
	● The solution decouples battery growth from virgin resource dependency.
	● This turns LIB recycling from a compliance burden into a strategic value driver.

References

[1] Ahuis M , Doose S , Vogt D , Michalowski P , Zellmer S , Kwade A . (2024). Recycling of solid-state batteries. Nature Energy, 9(4): 373–385

[2] AI (2023). State of Charge: EVs, Batteries and Battery Materials. Toronto: Adamas Intelligence

[3] Aishwarya V M , Ekren B Y , Singh T , Singh V . (2025). Integrating sustainability across the lifecycle of electric vehicle batteries: circular supply chain challenges, innovations, and global policy impacts. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 216: 115671

[4] Ali A , Al Bahrani M , Ahmed S , Islam M T , Qadir S A , Shahid M . (2025). Sustainable recycling of end-of-life electric vehicle batteries: EV battery recycling frameworks in China and the USA. Recycling, 10(2): 68

[5] Amici J , Asinari P , Ayerbe E , Barboux P , Bayle-Guillemaud P , Behm R J , Berecibar M , Berg E , Bhowmik A , Bodoardo S . et al. (2022). A roadmap for transforming research to invent the batteries of the future designed within the European large scale research initiative BATTERY 2030+. Advanced Energy Materials, 12(17): 2102785

[6] Amuta O , Yao J Q , Droese D , Kowal J . (2025). Accurate chemistry identification of lithium-ion batteries based on temperature dynamics with machine learning. Batteries, 11(6): 208

[7] Azadi M , Lèbre É , Ali S H , Steen J , Wall F . (2022). Future of battery metals supply. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 182: 106283

[8] Baars J , Domenech T , Bleischwitz R , Melin H E , Heidrich O . (2020). Circular economy strategies for electric vehicle batteries reduce reliance on raw materials. Nature Sustainability, 4(1): 71–79

[9] Barman KHerbke PJanssen LSafo E (2024). DLT-based verifiable receipt credentials for traceability in EV battery supply chains. In: Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Service-Oriented System Engineering (SOSE). Shanghai: IEEE, 74–79

[10] CAAM (2025). Information Release Conference in December 2024. Beijing: China Association of Automobile Manufacturers

[11] CABIA (2025). Power Battery Data from January to December 2024. Beijing: China Automotive Battery Industry Alliance

[12] Cheng Z H , Yu X J . (2024). China’s carbon emissions trading system and energy directed technical change. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 105: 107417

[13] CI (2023). Cobalt Uses. London: Cobalt Institute

[14] CI (2024). Cobalt Market Report 2023. London: Cobalt Institute

[15] CSL (2003). Electronic Waste Recycling Act of 2003. Sacramento: California State Legislature

[16] DOE (2021). Long Duration Storage Shot: An Introduction. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Energy

[17] DOE (2023). Biden-Harris Administration announces $3.5 Billion to Strengthen Domestic Battery Manufacturing. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Energy

[18] Dong Z Y , Hao H , Sun X , Xun D Y , Dou H , Geng J X , Liu M , Deng Y F , Zhao F Q A , Liu Z W . (2024). Projecting future critical material demand and recycling from China's electric passenger vehicles considering vehicle segment heterogeneity. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 207: 107691

[19] DOT (2023). Federal register: notice of proposed rulemaking - clean vehicle credits under sections 25E and 30D; Transfer of credits; Critical minerals and battery components. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of the Treasury

[20] E S S , Niu B , Liu J , Yuan Y L , Xiao J F , Xu Z M . (2025). Intelligent metal recovery from spent Li-ion batteries: machine learning breaks the barriers of traditional optimizations. Green Chemistry, 27(9): 2478–2492

[21] ECCC (2022). 2030 Emissions Reduction Plan: Canada’s Next Steps to Clean Air and a Strong Economy. Gatineau: Environment and Climate Change Canada

[22] EVTank (2025a). White Paper on China Lithium-ion Battery Recycling, Dismantling and Cascade Utilization Industry Development (2025). Beijing: Ivy Institute of Economics

[23] EVTank (2025b). White Paper on the Development of China’s Lithium-ion Battery Industry (2025). Beijing: Ivy Institute of Economics

[24] GGII (2023). Analysis of 156 Waste Power Battery Whitelist Enterprises. Shenzhen: Gaogong Industry Institute

[25] Giosuè C , Marchese D , Cavalletti M , Isidori R , Conti M , Orcioni S , Ruello M L , Stipa P . (2021). An exploratory study of the policies and legislative perspectives on the end-of-life of lithium-ion batteries from the perspective of producer obligation. Sustainability, 13(20): 11154

[26] GOSC (2024). Opinions of the General Office of the State Council on Accelerating the Construction of Waste Recycling System. Beijing: General Office of the State Council of the People’s Republic of China, GOSF [2024] No. 7

[27] Guo Y , Fraser T , Silveira S . (2025). The role of financial incentives in promoting electric light commercial vehicles in the United States. Energy Policy, 199: 114526

[28] Han J , Chen Q S , Yang X S , Long T , Xing J Y , Li Q , Zhao H Q , Shi M J , Pan Z J . (2023). Current situation of cobalt resources and analysis of supply and demand situation in the next 5–10 years. Geology in China, 50(3): 743–755

[29] Hao J C , Hao J Y , Liu D F , He L H , Liu X H , Zhao Z W , Zhao T Y , Xu W H . (2024). Maximizing resource recovery: a green and economic strategy for lithium extraction from spent ternary batteries. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 472: 134472

[30] IEA (2022). Global EV Outlook 2022. Paris: International Energy Agency

[31] IEA (2024). Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2024. Paris: International Energy Agency

[32] Jenn A , Springel K , Gopal A R . (2018). Effectiveness of electric vehicle incentives in the United States. Energy Policy, 119: 349–356

[33] Kucukvar M , Onat N C , Kutty A A , Abdella G M , Bulak M E , Ansari F , Kumbaroglu G . (2022). Environmental efficiency of electric vehicles in Europe under various electricity production mix scenarios. Journal of Cleaner Production, 335: 130291

[34] Kuku M . (2025). Value-added energy storage by harnessing spent Lithium-ion battery components toward high-performance asymmetric supercapacitor electrodes. Rare Metals, 44(12): 10954–10966

[35] Li J J, Wang Z X, Li H, Jiao J L (2024). Which policy can effectively promote the formal recycling of power batteries in China? Energy, 299: 131445

[36] Lin J , Zhang X D , Fan E S , Chen R J , Wu F , Li L . (2023). Carbon neutrality strategies for sustainable batteries: from structure, recycling, and properties to applications. Energy & Environmental Science, 16(3): 745–791

[37] Liu Q N, Hu Z, Li W J, Zou C, Jin H L, Wang S, Chou S L, Dou S X (2021). Sodium transition metal oxides: the preferred cathode choice for future sodium-ion batteries? Energy & Environmental Science, 14(1): 158–179

[38] Machín A , Morant C , Márquez F . (2024). Advancements and challenges in solid-state battery technology: an in-depth review of solid electrolytes and anode innovations. Batteries, 10(1): 29

[39] Martin G , Rentsch L , Höck M , Bertau M . (2017). Lithium market research – global supply, future demand and price development. Energy Storage Materials, 6: 171–179

[40] MIIT (2025)NDRC MEE MT MC SAMR . Industry Standard Conditions for the Comprehensive Utilization of Waste Power Batteries for New Energy Vehicles. Beijing: Ministry of Industry and Information Technology of the People’s Republic of China, National Development and Reform Commission, Ministry of Ecology and Environment of the People’s Republic of China, Ministry of Transport of the People’s Republic of China, Ministry of Commerce of the People’s Republic of China, State Administration for Market Regulation, [2025] No. 73

[41] MOE (2022). 2030 National Implementation Plan for Greenhouse Gas Reduction Targets (NDC). Seoul: Ministry of Environment of the Republic of Korea, No. 2022–224

[42] NDRC (2022)NEA . Implementation Plan for New Energy Storage Development Under the 14th Five-Year Plan. Beijing: National Development and Reform Commission, National Energy Administration, No. 2022–209

[43] Neumann J , Petranikova M , Meeus M , Gamarra J D , Younesi R , Winter M , Nowak S . (2022). Recycling of lithium-ion batteries—current state of the art, circular economy, and next generation recycling. Advanced Energy Materials, 12(17): 2102917

[44] OJEU (2023). Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 July 2023 concerning batteries and waste batteries, amending Directive 2008/98/EC and Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 and repealing Directive 2006/66/EC (Text with EEA relevance). Luxembourg: Official Journal of the European Union, (EU) 2023/1542

[45] Park S , Jeong S Y , Lee T K , Park M W , Lim H Y , Sung J , Cho J , Kwak S K , Hong S Y , Choi N S . (2021). Replacing conventional battery electrolyte additives with dioxolone derivatives for high-energy-density lithium-ion batteries. Nature Communications, 12(1): 838

[46] SMM (2024). China Cobalt Market Report 2024. Shanghai: Shanghai Metals Market

[47] SNE (2023). Global EV and Battery Monthly Tracker. Seongnam-si: SNE Research

[48] Tan J , Keiding J K . (2024). Mapping the cobalt and lithium supply chains for e-mobility transition: significance of overseas investments and vertical integration in evaluating mineral supply risks. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 209: 107788

[49] Tian Y , Lin C , Meng X F , Yu X , Li H L , Xiong R . (2025). Accelerated commercial battery electrode-level degradation diagnosis via only 11-point charging segments. eScience, 5(1): 100325

[50] UNEP (2024). Global Resources Outlook 2024: Bend the Trend-Pathways to a Liveable Planet as Resource Use Spikes. Kenya: United Nations Environment Programme

[51] USC (2021). Public Law 117-58-Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. Washington, DC: U.S. Congress

[52] USGS (2021). Mineral Commodity Summaries 2021. Reston: U.S. Geological Survey

[53] USGS (2025). Mineral Commodity Summaries 2025. Reston: U.S. Geological Survey

[54] Usiskin R , Lu Y X , Popovic J , Law M , Balaya P , Hu Y S , Maier J . (2021). Fundamentals, status and promise of sodium-based batteries. Nature Reviews Materials, 6(11): 1020–1035

[55] van Gaalen J M , Chris Slootweg J . (2025). From critical raw materials to circular raw materials. ChemSusChem, 18(2): e202401170

[56] Wang J X , Ji H C , Li J F , Liang Z , Chen W , Zhu Y F , Ji G J , Shi R Y , Zhou G M , Cheng H M . (2024a). Direct recycling of spent cathode material at ambient conditions via spontaneous lithiation. Nature Sustainability, 7(10): 1283–1293

[57] Wang J X , Ma J , Zhuang Z F , Liang Z , Jia K , Ji G J , Zhou G M , Cheng H M . (2024b). Toward direct regeneration of spent lithium-ion batteries: a next-generation recycling method. Chemical Reviews, 124(5): 2839–2887

[58] Wang S J , Cheng Y . (2021). Current status and development trends of European new energy vehicles. Journal of Automotive Safety and Energy, 12(2): 135–149

[59] Wang Z , Wang Y , Gong Y D , Zhan J Z . (2024c). Cooperate or not? Strategic analysis of formal and informal recyclers under different retired power battery recycling market structures. Computers & Industrial Engineering, 193: 110294

[60] Woo J , Fatima R , Kibert C J , Newman R E , Tian Y F , Srinivasan R S . (2021). Applying blockchain technology for building energy performance measurement, reporting, and verification (MRV) and the carbon credit market: a review of the literature. Building and Environment, 205: 108199

[61] Xiao C C , Yan L Q , Gao H P , Dou Z O , Xie X , Chen Y S . (2024). Selective separation and recovery of Co(II) and Ni(II) from lithium-ion battery using Cyanex 272 adsorptive membrane. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 18(12): 148

[62] Xiao J F , Lu J Q , Niu B , Liu X H , Hong J M , Xu Z M . (2025a). Ex-ante life cycle evaluation of spent lithium-ion battery recovery: modeling of complex environmental and economic impacts. Environmental Science and Ecotechnology, 23: 100490

[63] Xiao J F , Niu B , Li P W , Chen W Q , Xu Z M . (2025b). From lithium-last technology to lithium-first technology: technical mapping and collaborative strategies for sustainable lithium-ion battery recycling. Green Chemistry, 27(35): 10291–10315

[64] Xu A D (2023). New energy metals nickel, cobalt, lithium resource security situation and policy recommendations. Resource Recycling, (11): 24–26, 41

[65] Xu P P , Dai Q , Gao H P , Liu H D , Zhang M H , Li M Q , Chen Y , An K , Meng Y S , Liu P . et al. (2020). Efficient direct recycling of lithium-ion battery cathodes by targeted healing. Joule, 4(12): 2609–2626

[66] Yan J , Qian J , Li Y , Li L , Wu F , Chen R J . (2024). Toward sustainable lithium iron phosphate in lithium-ion batteries: regeneration strategies and their challenges. Advanced Functional Materials, 34(44): 2405055

[67] Yang X G , Liu T , Wang C Y . (2021). Thermally modulated lithium iron phosphate batteries for mass-market electric vehicles. Nature Energy, 6(2): 176–185

[68] Zhang T W , Dao J , Wang J S , Guo Y Z , Wan R D , Li C P , Zhou X , Zhang Z F . (2024). Highly efficient recovery of waste LiNi_xCo_yMn_zO₂ cathode materials using a process involving pyrometallurgy and hydrometallurgy. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 18(2): 25

[69] Zhao S L , Han Y , Zhou Q , Xia X Q . (2025). Collaborative management of battery manufacturer responsibility in electric vehicle production with ESG due diligence. Journal of Cleaner Production, 486: 144591

[70] Zhou H W , Yang Y Y , Li W , Mckechnie J , Thiede S , Wang P . (2024). EU’s recycled content targets of lithium-ion batteries are likely to compromise critical metal circularity. One Earth, 7(7): 1288–1300

[71] Zong Y H , Yao P F , Zhang X H , Wang J , Song X L , Zhao J , Wang Z L , Zheng Y . (2023). Material flow analysis on the critical resources from spent power lithium-ion batteries under the framework of China's recycling policies. Waste Management, 171: 463–472

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Higher Education Press 2026