Anaerobic digestion enhanced by biochar additives for effective treatment of industrial wastewater containing refractory organic matters: a comprehensive review

Abstract

With industrialization accelerating and carbon emissions rising in recent years, the treatment of industrial wastewater containing refractory organic compounds must align with goals of energy conservation and emission reduction under the principle of carbon neutrality. Integrating anaerobic digestion (AD) with biochar (BC) presents a promising biological approach to mitigating the inhibitory effects of pollutants in wastewater treatment. By simultaneously utilizing waste biomass resources, the integration of these two sustainable biotechnologies within the biochar-anaerobic digestion (BC-AD) process not only enhances bioenergy recovery but also contributes substantially to the reduction of carbon emissions. This study addresses key challenges in the anaerobic treatment of industrial wastewater and introduces BC in terms of its functional applications, modification techniques, performance benefits, and prospects for achieving carbon neutrality. Experimental findings demonstrate that BC contributes significantly to maintaining neutral pH by regulating hydraulic retention time (HRT) and organic loading rate (OLR). The study presents a novel framework for the BC-AD process in treating industrial wastewater, emphasizing its potential to suppress refractory organics and eliminate toxic inorganics. By examining practical applications and identifying the challenges associated with large-scale implementation, this study improves the development and deployment of this integrated biotechnology. The primary objective is to encourage further investigation and industrial adoption of the BC-AD approach for low-carbon and environmentally sustainable wastewater treatment. Special emphasis is placed on the modification and application of BC to improve pollutant degradation and bioenergy recovery within AD systems, thereby underscoring its promise as an innovative solution aligned with carbon neutrality goals.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Anaerobic digestion / Biochar / Methane fermentation / Industrial wastewater / Refractory organic matter

Highlight

	● Integration of biochar and AD enables enhanced treatment of industrial wastewater.
	● BC-AD process exhibits carbon-neutral potential in industrial wastewater treatment.
	● BC facilitates anaerobic degradation of organic matters in industrial wastewater.
	● Modified BC applied in anaerobic biotechnology is a direction of future researches.
	● Future development for BC-AD biotechnology should involve with economics and LCA.

References

[1] Abdulbaki Danhassan U, Zhang X, Qi R Y, Ali M M, Sheng K C, Lin H J. (2022). Nickel-catalyzed mesoporous biochar for enhanced adsorptive oxidation of aqueous sulfide: an investigation of influencing factors and mechanisms. Bioresource Technology, 362: 127877

[2] Abhishek K, Shrivastava A, Vimal V, Gupta A K, Bhujbal S K, Biswas J K, Singh L, Ghosh P, Pandey A, Sharma P, Kumar M. (2022). Biochar application for greenhouse gas mitigation, contaminants immobilization and soil fertility enhancement: a state-of-the-art review. Science of the Total Environment, 853: 158562

[3] Achi C G, Hassanein A, Lansing S. (2020). Enhanced biogas production of cassava wastewater using zeolite and biochar additives and manure co-digestion. Energies, 13(2): 491

[4] Ahmad H A, Ahmad S, Cui Q J, Wang Z B, Wei H W, Chen X, Ni S Q, Ismail S, Awad H M, Tawfik A. (2022). The environmental distribution and removal of emerging pollutants, highlighting the importance of using microbes as a potential degrader: a review. Science of the Total Environment, 809: 151926

[5] Ahmad S, Liu L N, Zhang S C, Tang J C. (2023). Nitrogen-doped biochar (N-doped BC) and iron/nitrogen co-doped biochar (Fe/N co-doped BC) for removal of refractory organic pollutants. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 446: 130727

[6] Ahmar Siddiqui M, Parnthong J, Kungsanant S, Chavadej S, Chaiprapat S. (2022). Influences of specific surfactant structures on biohydrogen production from oily wastewater in batch and continuous anaerobic dark fermentation. Bioresource Technology, 360: 127617

[7] AhmedJThakur AGoyalA (2021). Industrial wastewater and its toxic effects. In: Shah M P, ed. Biological Treatment of Industrial Wastewater. London: The Royal Society of Chemistry

[8] Ahmed M J, Hameed B H. (2018). Adsorption behavior of salicylic acid on biochar as derived from the thermal pyrolysis of barley straws. Journal of Cleaner Production, 195: 1162–1169

[9] Ajiboye T O, Oyewo O A, Onwudiwe D C. (2021). Simultaneous removal of organics and heavy metals from industrial wastewater: a review. Chemosphere, 262: 128379

[10] Alom J, Hasan M S, Asaduzaman M, Alam M T, Belhaj D, Selvaraj R, Hossain M A, Zargar M, Ahmed M B. (2023). Catalytical performance of heteroatom doped and undoped carbon-based materials. Catalysts, 13(5): 823

[11] Alvillo-Rivera A J, Garrido-Hoyos S E, Rosano-Ortega G. (2023). Optimization of factors for the biological treatment of free and complexed cyanide. Processes, 11(7): 2063

[12] Anderson A, Anbarasu A, Pasupuleti R R, Manigandan S, Praveenkumar T R, Aravind Kumar J. (2022). Treatment of heavy metals containing wastewater using biodegradable adsorbents: a review of mechanism and future trends. Chemosphere, 295: 133724

[13] AneraoPSalwatkar GKumarMPandeyASinghL (2022). Physical treatment for biochar modification: opportunities, limitations and advantages. In: Ramola S, Mohan D, Masek O, Méndez A, Tsubota T, eds. Engineered Biochar: Fundamentals, Preparation, Characterization and Applications. Singapore: Springer, 49–64

[14] Arora J, Ranjan A, Chauhan A, Biswas R, Rajput V D, Sushkova S, Mandzhieva S, Minkina T, Jindal T. (2022). Surfactant pollution, an emerging threat to ecosystem: approaches for effective bacterial degradation. Journal of Applied Microbiology, 133(3): 1229–1244

[15] Ashworth D J, Schmidt M P, Ibekwe A M. (2023). Performance of acid- and base-modified biochars for the removal of antibiotics from water under dynamic conditions. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 11(6): 111616

[16] BollMEstelmann SHeiderJ (2020). Catabolic pathways and enzymes involved in the anaerobic degradation of monocyclic aromatic compounds. In: Boll M, ed. Anaerobic Utilization of Hydrocarbons, Oils, and Lipids. Cham: Springer, 85–133

[17] Cai F R, Lei L R, Li Y M, Chen Y C. (2021). A review of aerobic granular sludge (AGS) treating recalcitrant wastewater: refractory organics removal mechanism, application and prospect. Science of the Total Environment, 782: 146852

[18] Chai Q W, Lu L, Lin Y, Ji X Q, Yang C P, He S Y, Zhang D. (2018). Effects and mechanisms of anionic and nonionic surfactants on biochar removal of chromium. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 25(19): 18443–18450

[19] Chalaris M, Gkika D A, Tolkou A K, Kyzas G Z. (2023). Advancements and sustainable strategies for the treatment and management of wastewaters from metallurgical industries: an overview. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 30(57): 119627–119653

[20] Chaturvedi P, Giri B S, Shukla P, Gupta P. (2021). Recent advancement in remediation of synthetic organic antibiotics from environmental matrices: challenges and perspective. Bioresource Technology, 319: 124161

[21] Che L X, Yang B, Tian Q, Xu H. (2022). Iron-based biochar derived from waste-activated sludge enhances anaerobic digestion of synthetic salty organic wastewater for methane production. Bioresource Technology, 345: 126465

[22] Chen A C, Guan X H, Pang Z J, Li Z M, Ke X, Wei G R, Qin Z, Chen Y, Wu H Z, Qiu G L. . (2023a). Function and direction of cyanide in coking wastewater: from water treatment to environmental migration. ACS ES&T Water, 3(12): 3980–3991

[23] Chen H B, Gao Y R, Li J H, Fang Z, Bolan N, Bhatnagar A, Gao B, Hou D Y, Wang S S, Song H. . (2022). Engineered biochar for environmental decontamination in aquatic and soil systems: a review. Carbon Research, 1(1): 4

[24] Chen J, Wang C, Pan Y, Farzana S S, Tam N F Y. (2018). Biochar accelerates microbial reductive debromination of 2,2′4,4′-tetrabromodiphenyl ether (BDE-47) in anaerobic mangrove sediments. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 341: 177–186

[25] Chen L, Fang W, Liang J S, Nabi M, Cai Y J, Wang Q Y, Zhang P Y, Zhang G M. (2023b). Biochar application in anaerobic digestion: performances, mechanisms, environmental assessment and circular economy. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 188: 106720

[26] Chen N W, Zhang X B, Du Q, Wang H Z, Wang Z W, Ren J Z, Li H X, Guo W S, Ngo H H. (2024a). An in-situ biochar-enhanced anaerobic membrane bioreactor for swine wastewater treatment under various organic loading rates. Journal of Environmental Sciences, 146: 304–317

[27] Chen S, Qin C X, Wang T, Chen F Y, Li X L, Hou H B, Zhou M. (2019a). Study on the adsorption of dyestuffs with different properties by sludge-rice husk biochar: adsorption capacity, isotherm, kinetic, thermodynamics and mechanism. Journal of Molecular Liquids, 285: 62–74

[28] Chen W F, Meng J, Han X R, Lan Y, Zhang W M. (2019b). Past, present, and future of biochar. Biochar, 1(1): 75–87

[29] Chen W S, Zhao B L, Guo Y P, Guo Y J, Zheng Z H, Pak T, Li G T. (2021). Effect of hydrothermal pretreatment on pyrolyzed sludge biochars for tetracycline adsorption. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 9(6): 106557

[30] Chen Y Q, Wang Y Z, Xie H Y, Cao W Z, Zhang Y L. (2023c). Varied promotion effects and mechanisms of biochar on anaerobic digestion (AD) under distinct food-to-microorganism (F/M) ratios and biochar dosages. Waste Management, 155: 118–128

[31] Chen Z H, Ding Q L, Ning X, Song Z L, Gu J, Wang X J, Sun W, Qian X, Hu T, Wei S M. . (2024b). Fe-Mn binary oxides improve the methanogenic performance and reduce the environmental health risks associated with antibiotic resistance genes during anaerobic digestion. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 469: 133921

[32] Chen Z L, Guo Y C, Luo L, Liu Z G, Miao W, Xia Y. (2024c). A critical review of hydrochar based photocatalysts by hydrothermal carbonization: synthesis, mechanisms, and applications. Biochar, 6(1): 74

[33] Cheng D L, Ngo H H, Guo W S, Chang S W, Nguyen D D, Nguyen Q A, Zhang J, Liang S. (2021). Improving sulfonamide antibiotics removal from swine wastewater by supplying a new pomelo peel derived biochar in an anaerobic membrane bioreactor. Bioresource Technology, 319: 124160

[34] Cheng Q P, Xu C X, Huang W W, Jiang M, Yan J T, Fan G Z, Zhang J, Chen K, Xiao B, Song G S. (2020). Improving anaerobic digestion of piggery wastewater by alleviating stress of ammonia using biochar derived from rice straw. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 19: 100948

[35] Chiappero M, Norouzi O, Hu M Y, Demichelis F, Berruti F, Di Maria F, Mašek O, Fiore S. (2020). Review of biochar role as additive in anaerobic digestion processes. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 131: 110037

[36] Choudhury A, Lansing S. (2021). Adsorption of hydrogen sulfide in biogas using a novel iron-impregnated biochar scrubbing system. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 9(1): 104837

[37] Cui D Z, Zhang M, Wang J Q, Wang H, Zhao M. (2020). Effect of quinoid redox mediators during azo dye decolorization by anaerobic sludge: considering the catalyzing mechanism and the methane production. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 202: 110859

[38] Cui L Q, Liu Y M, Yan J L, Hina K, Hussain Q, Qiu T J, Zhu J Y. (2022). Revitalizing coastal saline-alkali soil with biochar application for improved crop growth. Ecological Engineering, 179: 106594

[39] Dai C B, Yang L B, Wang J, Li D Z, Zhang Y L, Zhou X F. (2022). Enhancing anaerobic digestion of pharmaceutical industries wastewater with the composite addition of zero valent iron (ZVI) and granular activated carbon (GAC). Bioresource Technology, 346: 126566

[40] Dai Y J, Zhang N X, Xing C M, Cui Q X, Sun Q Y. (2019). The adsorption, regeneration and engineering applications of biochar for removal organic pollutants: a review. Chemosphere, 223: 12–27

[41] Del Rio D D F, Sovacool B K, Griffiths S, Bazilian M, Kim J, Foley A M, Rooney D. (2022). Decarbonizing the pulp and paper industry: a critical and systematic review of sociotechnical developments and policy options. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 167: 112706

[42] Deng Z X, Sun C D, Ma G Y, Zhang X Z, Guo H B, Zhang T, Zhang Y L, Hu Y, Li D P, Li Y Y. . (2025a). Anaerobic treatment of nitrogenous industrial organic wastewater by carbon–neutral processes integrated with anaerobic digestion and partial nitritation/anammox: critical review of current advances and future directions. Bioresource Technology, 415: 131648

[43] Deng Z X, Sun C D, Ma G Y, Zhang X Z, Guo H B, Zhang T, Zhou X F, Zhang Y L, Hu Y, Li D P. . (2025b). Anaerobic treatment of refractory industrial organic wastewater: a review of bioenergy recovery and low-carbon nitrogen removal toward carbon neutrality. Journal of Water Process Engineering, 72: 107515

[44] Dong Y, Zhang X, Wang X, Xie C H, Liu J T, Cheng Y D, Yue Y M, You X W, Li Y Q. (2024). Modified biochar affects CO₂ and N₂O emissions from coastal saline soil by altering soil pH and elemental stoichiometry. Science of the Total Environment, 954: 176283

[45] Donoso-Bravo A, Sadino-Riquelme M C, Valdebenito-Rolack E, Paulet D, Gómez D, Hansen F. (2022). Comprehensive ADM1 extensions to tackle some operational and metabolic aspects in anaerobic digestion. Microorganisms, 10(5): 948

[46] Dutta D, Arya S, Kumar S. (2021). Industrial wastewater treatment: current trends, bottlenecks, and best practices. Chemosphere, 285: 131245

[47] Edbey K, Kumar M, El-Hashani A, Alarfi H, Kumar D, Bhattarai A. (2024). Interaction of anionic dye ethyl orange and cationic CnTAC surfactants: a multi technique investigation. Journal of Molecular Liquids, 407: 125166

[48] Enerdate(2024). World Energy & Climate Statistics-Yearbook, 2024. Grenoble: Enerdate

[49] Eniola J O, Kumar R, Barakat M A, Rashid J. (2022). A review on conventional and advanced hybrid technologies for pharmaceutical wastewater treatment. Journal of Cleaner Production, 356: 131826

[50] Esmaeeli A, Sarrafzadeh M H, Zeighami S, Kalantar M, Bariki S G, Fallahi A, Asgharnejad H, Ghaffari S B. (2023). A comprehensive review on pulp and paper industries wastewater treatment advances. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 62(21): 8119–8145

[51] Ewuzie U, Saliu O D, Dulta K, Ogunniyi S, Bajeh A O, Iwuozor K O, Ighalo J O. (2022). A review on treatment technologies for printing and dyeing wastewater (PDW). Journal of Water Process Engineering, 50: 103273

[52] Faheem J K, Du S H, Kim M A, Hassan S, Irshad J G. (2020). Application of biochar in advanced oxidation processes: supportive, adsorptive, and catalytic role. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 27(30): 37286–37312

[53] Fan Q W, Song C Y, Fu P. (2024). Advances in the improvement of the quality and efficiency of biomass-derived porous carbon: a comprehensive review on synthesis strategies and heteroatom doping effects. Journal of Cleaner Production, 452: 142169

[54] Fan W, Shen X L, Zhu Z L, Liu X C, Zhang H, Qiu Y L, Yin D Q. (2025). Research progress on biochar materials for new pollutants removal in the aquatic environment: a mini-review. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 19(3): 33

[55] Fan Y Q, Tan X W, Huang Y, Hao T W, Chen H, Yi X, Li D P, Pan Y, Li Y, Kong Z. (2022). Chemical oxygen demand and nitrogen removal from real membrane-manufacturing wastewater by a pilot-scale internal circulation reactor integrated with partial nitritation-anammox. Bioresource Technology, 364: 128116

[56] Foong S Y, Liew R K, Yang Y F, Cheng Y W, Yek P N Y, Wan Mahari W A, Lee X Y, Han C S, Vo D V N, Van Le Q. . (2020). Valorization of biomass waste to engineered activated biochar by microwave pyrolysis: progress, challenges, and future directions. Chemical Engineering Journal, 389: 124401

[57] Franchi O, Bovio P, Ortega-Martínez E, Rosenkranz F, Chamy R. (2018). Active and total microbial community dynamics and the role of functional genes bamA and mcrA during anaerobic digestion of phenol and p-cresol. Bioresource Technology, 264: 290–297

[58] Gao B, Wang Y, Huang L, Liu S M. (2021). Study on the performance of HNO₃-modified biochar for enhanced medium temperature anaerobic digestion of food waste. Waste Management, 135: 338–346

[59] Gao R L, Xiang L, Hu H Q, Fu Q L, Zhu J, Liu Y H, Huang G Y. (2020). High-efficiency removal capacities and quantitative sorption mechanisms of Pb by oxidized rape straw biochars. Science of the Total Environment, 699: 134262

[60] Guo S F, Li Y Q, Wang Y R, Wang L N, Sun Y F, Liu L N. (2022a). Recent advances in biochar-based adsorbents for CO₂ capture. Carbon Capture Science & Technology, 4: 100059

[61] Guo X X, Liu H T, Zhang J. (2020). The role of biochar in organic waste composting and soil improvement: a review. Waste Management, 102: 884–899

[62] GuoZ DJalalah MAlsareiiS AHarrazF AThakurN SalamaE S (2022b). Biochar addition augmented the microbial community and aided the digestion of high-loading slaughterhouse waste: active enzymes of bacteria and archaea. Chemosphere, 309(Pt 1): 136535

[63] Hassan M, Naidu R, Du J H, Liu Y J, Qi F J. (2020). Critical review of magnetic biosorbents: their preparation, application, and regeneration for wastewater treatment. Science of the Total Environment, 702: 134893

[64] Hei S, Xu H, Liu B M, Zhu X Z, Zhang S, Zhang X, Li R W, Huang X. (2022). Enhanced pre-treatment of sepiolite on coal gasification wastewater: performance and adsorption mechanism. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 440: 129842

[65] Hu B W, Ai Y J, Jin J, Hayat T, Alsaedi A, Zhuang L, Wang X K. (2020). Efficient elimination of organic and inorganic pollutants by biochar and biochar-based materials. Biochar, 2(1): 47–64

[66] Hu Y, Shi C, Ma H Y, Wu J, Kobayashi T, Xu K Q. (2021). Biofilm formation enhancement in anaerobic treatment of high salinity wastewater: effect of biochar/Fe addition. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 9(4): 105603

[67] Huang D D, Wang N, Bai X Y, Chen Y K, Xu Q Y. (2022). The influencing mechanism of O₂, H₂O, and CO₂ on the H₂S removal of food waste digestate-derived biochar with abundant minerals. Biochar, 4(1): 71

[68] Hung C M, Chen C W, Huang C P, Dong C D. (2022). Metal-free single heteroatom (N, O, and B)-doped coconut-shell biochar for enhancing the degradation of sulfathiazole antibiotics by peroxymonosulfate and its effects on bacterial community dynamics. Environmental Pollution, 311: 119984

[69] Hussain Z, Arslan M, Shabir G, Malik M H, Mohsin M, Iqbal S, Afzal M. (2019). Remediation of textile bleaching effluent by bacterial augmented horizontal flow and vertical flow constructed wetlands: a comparison at pilot scale. Science of the Total Environment, 685: 370–379

[70] Jeyaraj S G, Hemavarshini S, Gg K S, Aravind J. (2024). Biochar-mediated removal of various pollutants from the environment. Physical Sciences Reviews, 9(11): 3409–3431

[71] Jia L, Cheng P, Yu Y, Chen S H, Wang C X, He L, Nie H T, Wang J C, Zhang J C, Fan B G, Jin Y. (2023). Regeneration mechanism of a novel high-performance biochar mercury adsorbent directionally modified by multimetal multilayer loading. Journal of Environmental Management, 326: 116790

[72] Jiang B N, Tian J, Chen H J, Zheng H M, Xu Z Y, Lin Y Q. (2022a). Heavy metals migration and antibiotics removal in anaerobic digestion of swine manure with biochar addition. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 27: 102735

[73] Jiang Q, Wu P, Zhang X D, Zhang Y, Cui M H, Liu H B, Liu H. (2022b). Deciphering the effects of engineered biochar on methane production and the mechanisms during anaerobic digestion: surface functional groups and electron exchange capacity. Energy Conversion and Management, 258: 115417

[74] Jiao F F, Zhang X Z, Zhang T, Hu Y, Lu R, Ma G Y, Chen T, Guo H B, Li D P, Pan Y. . (2024). Insights into carbon-neutral treatment of rural wastewater by constructed wetlands: a review of current development and future direction. Environmental Research, 262: 119796

[75] JohnNFathima P SHarshaV SPaulN MNishaP (2023). Physical conversion of biomass: dewatering, drying, size reduction, densification, and separation. In: Thomas S, Hosur M, Pasquini D, Chirayil C J, eds. Handbook of Biomass. Singapore: Springer, 1–28

[76] JyotiRDhanker SKumarMShakyaSSinghT HussainA (2024)Singh. Biochar: a sustainable way to enhance soil fertility, crop yield and to mitigate global warming. In: Yasheshwar, Mishra A K, Kumar M, eds. Recent Advancements in Sustainable Agricultural Practices: Harnessing Technology for Water Resources, Irrigation and Environmental Management. Singapore: Springer, 331–352

[77] Kamali M, Aminabhavi T M, Tarelho L A C, Hellemans R, Cuypers J, Capela I, Costa M E V, Dewil R, Appels L. (2022a). Acclimatized activated sludge for enhanced phenolic wastewater treatment using pinewood biochar. Chemical Engineering Journal, 427: 131708

[78] Kamali M, Sweygers N, Al-Salem S, Appels L, Aminabhavi T M, Dewil R. (2022b). Biochar for soil applications-sustainability aspects, challenges and future prospects. Chemical Engineering Journal, 428: 131189

[79] Karimi M, Shirzad M, Silva J A C, Rodrigues A E. (2022). Biomass/Biochar carbon materials for CO₂ capture and sequestration by cyclic adsorption processes: a review and prospects for future directions. Journal of CO₂ Utilization, 57: 101890

[80] Kaur G, Johnravindar D, Wong J W C. (2020). Enhanced volatile fatty acid degradation and methane production efficiency by biochar addition in food waste-sludge co-digestion: a step towards increased organic loading efficiency in co-digestion. Bioresource Technology, 308: 123250

[81] Ke X, Wei T, Wei G R, Chen A C, Cheng X Q, Li Z M, Qin Z, Pang Z J, Pan J M, Chen Y. . (2023). Integrated process for zero discharge of coking wastewater: a hierarchical cycle-based innnovation. Chemical Engineering Journal, 457: 141257

[82] Khalid Z B, Siddique M N I, Nayeem A, Adyel T M, Ismail S B, Ibrahim M Z. (2021). Biochar application as sustainable precursors for enhanced anaerobic digestion: a systematic review. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 9(4): 105489

[83] Khan M D, Singh A, Khan M Z, Tabraiz S, Sheikh J. (2023). Current perspectives, recent advancements, and efficiencies of various dye-containing wastewater treatment technologies. Journal of Water Process Engineering, 53: 103579

[84] Kishor R, Purchase D, Saratale G D, Saratale R G, Ferreira L F R, Bilal M, Chandra R, Bharagava R N. (2021). Ecotoxicological and health concerns of persistent coloring pollutants of textile industry wastewater and treatment approaches for environmental safety. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 9(2): 105012

[85] Kjellerup B V, Nijenhuis I, Rossetti S. (2022). Editorial: thematic issue on anaerobic biological dehalogenation. FEMS Microbiology Ecology, 98(11): fiac108

[86] Kong Z, Li L, Kurihara R, Kubota K, Li Y Y. (2018). Anaerobic treatment of N, N-dimethylformamide-containing wastewater by co-culturing two sources of inoculum. Water Research, 139: 228–239

[87] Kong Z, Li L, Xue Y, Yang M, Li Y Y. (2019). Challenges and prospects for the anaerobic treatment of chemical-industrial organic wastewater: a review. Journal of Cleaner Production, 231: 913–927

[88] Kumar Mishra R, Jaya Prasanna Kumar D, Narula A, Minnat Chistie S, Ullhas Naik S. (2023). Production and beneficial impact of biochar for environmental application: a review on types of feedstocks, chemical compositions, operating parameters, techno-economic study, and life cycle assessment. Fuel, 343: 127968

[89] Kumar V, Verma P. (2023). A critical review on environmental risk and toxic hazards of refractory pollutants discharged in chlorolignin waste of pulp and paper mills and their remediation approaches for environmental safety. Environmental Research, 236: 116728

[90] Kushwaha R, Singh R S, Mohan D. (2023). Comparative study for sorption of arsenic on peanut shell biochar and modified peanut shell biochar. Bioresource Technology, 375: 128831

[91] Lan W J, Zhao X X, Wang Y X, Jin X, Ji J T, Cheng Z J, Yang G X, Li H, Chen G Y. (2024). Research progress of biochar modification technology and its application in environmental remediation. Biomass and Bioenergy, 184: 107178

[92] Lefèvre E, Bossa N, Gardner C M, Gehrke G E, Cooper E M, Stapleton H M, Hsu-Kim H, Gunsch C K. (2018). Biochar and activated carbon act as promising amendments for promoting the microbial debromination of tetrabromobisphenol A. Water Research, 128: 102–110

[93] Lei Z, Zhang S X, Wang L X, Li Q, Li Y Y, Wang X C, Chen R. (2022). Biochar enhances the biotransformation of organic micropollutants (OMPs) in an anaerobic membrane bioreactor treating sewage. Water Research, 223: 118974

[94] Li D, Wen Q X, Chen Z Q. (2023). Enhanced anaerobic biodegradation of typical phenolic compounds in coal gasification wastewater (CGW) using biochar: focusing on the hydrolysis-acidification process and microbial community succession. Environmental Research, 237: 116964

[95] Li D, Wen Q X, Chen Z Q. (2024a). Effects of Fe/Fe–Mn oxides loaded biochar on anaerobic degradation of typical phenolic compounds in coal gasification wastewater: performance and mechanism. Bioresource Technology, 394: 130308

[96] Li D, Wen Q X, Chen Z Q. (2024b). Electric field coupled with Fe₃O₄ modified biochar to enhance anaerobic degradation of phenolic compounds in coal gasification wastewater (CGW). Separation and Purification Technology, 342: 126950

[97] Li J B, Wu S Q, Zhang W M, Pan B C, Hua M. (2024c). Enhanced anaerobic digestion for energy recovery from brewery wastewater employing nano zero-valent iron loaded biochar prepared by residual sludge. Chemical Engineering Journal, 499: 156466

[98] Li J H, Zhang M, Ye Z Y, Yang C M. (2019a). Effect of manganese oxide-modified biochar addition on methane production and heavy metal speciation during the anaerobic digestion of sewage sludge. Journal of Environmental Sciences, 76: 267–277

[99] Li L C, Zou D S, Xiao Z H, Zeng X Y, Zhang L Q, Jiang L B, Wang A D, Ge D B, Zhang G L, Liu F. (2019b). Biochar as a sorbent for emerging contaminants enables improvements in waste management and sustainable resource use. Journal of Cleaner Production, 210: 1324–1342

[100] Li R H, Wang J J, Gaston L A, Zhou B Y, Li M L, Xiao R, Wang Q, Zhang Z Q, Huang H, Liang W. . (2018). An overview of carbothermal synthesis of metal–biochar composites for the removal of oxyanion contaminants from aqueous solution. Carbon, 129: 674–687

[101] Li R, Wang B, Niu A P, Cheng N, Chen M, Zhang X Y, Yu Z B, Wang S S. (2022a). Application of biochar immobilized microorganisms for pollutants removal from wastewater: a review. Science of the Total Environment, 837: 155563

[102] Li Y J, Li C, Wang Z B, Liu Y T, Jia Y H, Li F, Ren R J, Ikhlaq A, Kumirska J, Siedlecka E M. . (2024d). Navigating the complexity of pharmaceutical wastewater treatment by “effective strategy, emerging technology, and sustainable solution”. Journal of Water Process Engineering, 63: 105404

[103] Li Y, Zhong W Z, Ning Z F, Feng J, Niu J R, Li Z X. (2022b). Effect of biochar on antibiotic resistance genes in the anaerobic digestion system of antibiotic mycelial dreg. Bioresource Technology, 364: 128052

[104] Lin Z, Wu W J, Yang C H, Yang G Q, Wu W L, Wei T, Huang F C, Li H J, Ren L, Liang Y Q. . (2024). Mechanisms of biochar assisted di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP) biodegradation in tomato rhizosphere by metabolic and metagenomic analysis. Chemosphere, 353: 141520

[105] Liu C, Wang W D, Wu R, Liu Y, Lin X, Kan H, Zheng Y W. (2020a). Preparation of acid- and alkali-modified biochar for removal of methylene blue pigment. ACS Omega, 5(48): 30906–30922

[106] Liu C, Zhang H X. (2022). Modified-biochar adsorbents (MBAs) for heavy-metal ions adsorption: a critical review. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 10(2): 107393

[107] Liu G P, Liu S M, Yang J, Zhang X Y, Lu L H, Xu H X, Ye S J, Wu J C, Jiang J D, Qiao W J. (2024a). Complete biodegradation of tetrabromobisphenol a through sequential anaerobic reductive dehalogenation and aerobic oxidation. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 470: 134217

[108] Liu H D, Xu G R, Li G B. (2020b). The characteristics of pharmaceutical sludge-derived biochar and its application for the adsorption of tetracycline. Science of the Total Environment, 747: 141492

[109] Liu H Y, Xu Y, Chen X, Wang X K, Wang H, Dai X H. (2024b). MOF-based materials facilitate efficient anaerobic digestion of organic wastes: integrating substrate bioavailability and microbial syntrophism. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 18(8): 105

[110] Liu H Y, Xu Y, Li L, Yuan S J, Geng H, Tang Y F, Dai X H. (2022a). A novel green composite conductive material enhancing anaerobic digestion of waste activated sludge via improving electron transfer and metabolic activity. Water Research, 220: 118687

[111] Liu L M, Chen Z, Zhang J W, Shan D, Wu Y, Bai L M, Wang B Q. (2021a). Treatment of industrial dye wastewater and pharmaceutical residue wastewater by advanced oxidation processes and its combination with nanocatalysts: a review. Journal of Water Process Engineering, 42: 102122

[112] Liu Q, Meki K, Zheng H, Yuan Y F, Shao M Y, Luo X X, Li X Y, Jiang Z X, Li F M, Xing B S. (2023). Biochar application in remediating salt-affected soil to achieve carbon neutrality and abate climate change. Biochar, 5(1): 45

[113] Liu S C, Xie Z L, Zhu Y T, Zhu Y M, Jiang Y, Wang Y J, Gao H J. (2021b). Adsorption characteristics of modified rice straw biochar for Zn and in-situ remediation of Zn contaminated soil. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 22: 101388

[114] Liu W J, Jiang H, Yu H Q. (2019). Emerging applications of biochar-based materials for energy storage and conversion. Energy & Environmental Science, 12(6): 1751–1779

[115] Liu X S, Liu Y J, Yang Z Z. (2022b). Research progresses on phenols and ammonia nitrogen recovery and treatment methods in coal chemical wastewater (CCW). Environmental Technology Reviews, 11(1): 226–242

[116] Liu Y H, Chen Y N, Li Y P, Chen L, Jiang H J, Li H, Luo X L, Tang P, Yan H Q, Zhao M Y. . (2022c). Fabrication, application, and mechanism of metal and heteroatom co-doped biochar composites (MHBCs) for the removal of contaminants in water: a review. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 431: 128584

[117] Liu Z C, Khan T A, Islam M A, Tabrez U. (2022d). A review on the treatment of dyes in printing and dyeing wastewater by plant biomass carbon. Bioresource Technology, 354: 127168

[118] Lokesh S, Kim J, Zhou Y W, Wu D P, Pan B, Wang X L, Behrens S, Huang C H, Yang Y. (2020). Anaerobic dehalogenation by reduced aqueous biochars. Environmental Science & Technology, 54(23): 15142–15150

[119] Łomża P, Krucoń T, Tabernacka A. (2023). Potential of microbial communities to perform dehalogenation processes in natural and anthropogenically modified environments: a metagenomic study. Microorganisms, 11(7): 1702

[120] Lv L Y, Yin B B, Zhang D Y, Ji W B, Liang J S, Liu X Y, Gao W F, Sun L, Ren Z J, Zhang G M. . (2024). Synchronous reinforcement azo dyes decolorization and anaerobic granular sludge stability by Fe, N co-modified biochar: enhancement based on extracellular electron transfer. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 480: 135836

[121] Ma H Y, Hu Y, Wu J, Kobayashi T, Xu K Q, Kuramochi H. (2022). Enhanced anaerobic digestion of tar solution from rice husk thermal gasification with hybrid upflow anaerobic sludge-biochar bed reactor. Bioresource Technology, 347: 126688

[122] Ma P Y, Yin B B, Wu M H, Han M D, Lv L Y, Li W G, Zhang G M, Ren Z J. (2024a). Synergistic enhancement of microbes-to-pollutants and inter-microbes electron transfer by Fe, N modified ordered mesoporous biochar in anaerobic digestion. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 476: 135030

[123] Ma W W, Zhang X Q, Han H J, Shi X Q, Kong Q P, Yu T, Zhao F. (2024b). Overview of enhancing biological treatment of coal chemical wastewater: new strategies and future directions. Journal of Environmental Sciences, 135: 506–520

[124] Man K Y, Chow K L, Man Y B, Mo W Y, Wong M H. (2021). Use of biochar as feed supplements for animal farming. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 51(2): 187–217

[125] Manga M, Aragón-Briceño C, Boutikos P, Semiyaga S, Olabinjo O, Muoghalu C C. (2023). Biochar and its potential application for the improvement of the anaerobic digestion process: a critical review. Energies, 16(10): 4051

[126] Mao J E, Chen H Y, Xu X Y, Zhu L. (2024). Assessing greenhouse gas emissions from the printing and dyeing wastewater treatment and reuse system: potential pathways towards carbon neutrality. Science of the Total Environment, 927: 172301

[127] MariSelvam SParamasivanB (2022). Microwave assisted carbonization and activation of biochar for energy-environment nexus: a review. Chemosphere, 286(Pt 1): 131631

[128] Martínková L, Bojarová P, Sedova A, Křen V. (2023). Recent trends in the treatment of cyanide-containing effluents: comparison of different approaches. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 53(3): 416–434

[129] Mendes H C, Kelbert M, Michels C, Soares H M. (2024). Exploring sustainable pathways for cyanide biodegradation in cassava waste: insights into methodologies, microbial degradation, and emerging technologies. Journal of Water Process Engineering, 64: 105594

[130] Menzel T, Neubauer P, Junne S. (2020). Role of microbial hydrolysis in anaerobic digestion. Energies, 13(21): 5555

[131] Micoli L, Di Rauso Simeone G, Turco M, Toscano G, Rao M A. (2023a). Anaerobic digestion of olive mill wastewater in the presence of biochar. Energies, 16(7): 3259

[132] Micoli L, Di Rauso Simeone G, Turco M, Toscano G, Rao M A. (2023b). Biochar enhances anaerobic digestion of olive mill wastewater. Chemical Engineering Transactions, 99: 85–90

[133] Mo R R, Guo W J, Batstone D, Makinia J, Li Y M. (2023). Modifications to the anaerobic digestion model no. 1 (ADM1) for enhanced understanding and application of the anaerobic treatment processes – a comprehensive review. Water Research, 244: 120504

[134] Mohammed Z, Jeelani S, Rangari V. (2021). Low temperature plasma treatment of rice husk derived hybrid silica/carbon biochar using different gas sources. Materials Letters, 292: 129678

[135] Moharrery L, Otadi M, Miraly N, Rezaei Zangeneh M M, Amiri R. (2019). Degradation of toluidine red, an oil soluble azo dye by Halomonas strain IP8 at alkaline condition. Chemical Engineering Communications, 206(1): 61–68

[136] Molaey R, Appels L, Yesil H, Tugtas A E, Çalli B. (2024). Sustainable heavy metal removal from sewage sludge: a review of bioleaching and other emerging technologies. Science of the Total Environment, 955: 177020

[137] Murtaza G, Ahmed Z, Dai D Q, Iqbal R, Bawazeer S, Usman M, Rizwan M, Iqbal J, Akram M I, Althubiani A S. . (2022). A review of mechanism and adsorption capacities of biochar-based engineered composites for removing aquatic pollutants from contaminated water. Frontiers in Environmental Science, 10: 1035865

[138] Nguyen D L T, Binh Q A, Nguyen X C, Huyen Nguyen T T, Vo Q N, Nguyen T D, Phuong Tran T C, Hang Nguyen T A, Kim S Y, Nguyen T P. . (2021). Metal salt-modified biochars derived from agro-waste for effective congo red dye removal. Environmental Research, 200: 111492

[139] Ni Z L, Zhou L L, Lin Z Y, Kuang B, Zhu G F, Jia J B, Wang T. (2023). Iron-modified biochar boosts anaerobic digestion of sulfamethoxazole pharmaceutical wastewater: performance and microbial mechanism. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 452: 131314

[140] Okeke E S, Ezeorba T P C, Okoye C O, Chen Y, Mao G H, Feng W W, Wu X Y. (2022). Environmental and health impact of unrecovered API from pharmaceutical manufacturing wastes: a review of contemporary treatment, recycling and management strategies. Sustainable Chemistry and Pharmacy, 30: 100865

[141] Olaya-Abril A, Biełło K, Rodríguez-Caballero G, Cabello P, Sáez L P, Moreno-Vivián C, Luque-Almagro V M, Roldán M D. (2024). Bacterial tolerance and detoxification of cyanide, arsenic and heavy metals: holistic approaches applied to bioremediation of industrial complex wastes. Microbial Biotechnology, 17(1): e14399

[142] Oliveira F R, Surendra K C, Jaisi D P, Lu H, Unal-Tosun G, Sung S, Khanal S K. (2020). Alleviating sulfide toxicity using biochar during anaerobic treatment of sulfate-laden wastewater. Bioresource Technology, 301: 122711

[143] Oon Y L, Ong S A, Ho L N, Wong Y S, Dahalan F A, Oon Y S, Teoh T P, Lehl H K, Thung W E. (2020). Constructed wetland–microbial fuel cell for azo dyes degradation and energy recovery: influence of molecular structure, kinetics, mechanisms and degradation pathways. Science of the Total Environment, 720: 137370

[144] Oriez V, Peydecastaing J, Pontalier P Y. (2020). Lignocellulosic biomass mild alkaline fractionation and resulting extract purification processes: conditions, yields, and purities. Clean Technologies, 2(1): 91–115

[145] Ortiz-Medina J, Wang Z P, Cruz-Silva R, Morelos-Gomez A, Wang F, Yao X D, Terrones M, Endo M. (2019). Defect engineering and surface functionalization of nanocarbons for metal-free catalysis. Advanced Materials, 31(13): 1805717

[146] Palani G, Arputhalatha A, Kannan K, Lakkaboyana S K, Hanafiah M M, Kumar V, Marella R K. (2021). Current trends in the application of nanomaterials for the removal of pollutants from industrial wastewater treatment: a review. Molecules, 26(9): 2799

[147] Palmer M, Hatley H. (2018). The role of surfactants in wastewater treatment: impact, removal and future techniques: a critical review. Water Research, 147: 60–72

[148] Pan J T, Ma J Y, Zhai L M, Luo T, Mei Z L, Liu H B. (2019). Achievements of biochar application for enhanced anaerobic digestion: a review. Bioresource Technology, 292: 122058

[149] Pan X F, Lv N, Cai G J, Zhou M D, Wang R M, Li C X, Ning J, Li J J, Li Y L, Ye Z L. . (2021). Carbon-and metal-based mediators modulate anaerobic methanogenesis and phenol removal: focusing on stimulatory and inhibitory mechanism. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 420: 126615

[150] Paritosh K, Hackula A. (2024). Decarbonising distillery wastewater treatment: experimental investigation of biochar-assisted anaerobic conversion and financial assessment. Energy Conversion and Management, 318: 118893

[151] Paritosh K, Kesharwani N. (2024). Biochar mediated high-rate anaerobic bioreactors: a critical review on high-strength wastewater treatment and management. Journal of Environmental Management, 355: 120348

[152] Pariyar P, Kumari K, Jain M K, Jadhao P S. (2020). Evaluation of change in biochar properties derived from different feedstock and pyrolysis temperature for environmental and agricultural application. Science of the Total Environment, 713: 136433

[153] Paździor K, Bilińska L, Ledakowicz S. (2019). A review of the existing and emerging technologies in the combination of AOPs and biological processes in industrial textile wastewater treatment. Chemical Engineering Journal, 376: 120597

[154] Phoon B L, Ong C C, Mohamed Saheed M S, Show P L, Chang J S, Ling T C, Lam S S, Juan J C. (2020). Conventional and emerging technologies for removal of antibiotics from wastewater. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 400: 122961

[155] Pimviriyakul P, Wongnate T, Tinikul R, Chaiyen P. (2020). Microbial degradation of halogenated aromatics: molecular mechanisms and enzymatic reactions. Microbial Biotechnology, 13(1): 67–86

[156] Qiu B B, Shao Q N, Shi J C, Yang C H, Chu H Q. (2022). Application of biochar for the adsorption of organic pollutants from wastewater: modification strategies, mechanisms and challenges. Separation and Purification Technology, 300: 121925

[157] Qiu L, Deng Y F, Wang F, Davaritouchaee M, Yao Y Q. (2019). A review on biochar-mediated anaerobic digestion with enhanced methane recovery. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 115: 109373

[158] Qu J H, Shi J J, Wang Y H, Tong H, Zhu Y J, Xu L S, Wang Y F, Zhang B, Tao Y, Dai X, Zhang H, Zhang Y. (2022). Applications of functionalized magnetic biochar in environmental remediation: a review. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 434: 128841

[159] Rajoria S, Vashishtha M, Sangal V K. (2022). Treatment of electroplating industry wastewater: a review on the various techniques. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 29(48): 72196–72246

[160] Ren S J, Tong Z Y, Yong X Y, Xi Y L, Liu F W, Zhou J. (2024). The new strategies of using nitrogen and iron modified hydrochar to enhance methane production during co-anaerobic digestion of cow manure and corn straw. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 12(5): 114127

[161] Saif I, Thakur N, Zhang P, Zhang L H, Xing X H, Yue J W, Song Z Z, Nan L, Yujun S, Usman M, Salama E S, Li X K. (2022). Biochar assisted anaerobic digestion for biomethane production: microbial symbiosis and electron transfer. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 10(3): 107960

[162] Sánchez E, Herrmann C, Maja W, Borja R. (2021). Effect of organic loading rate on the anaerobic digestion of swine waste with biochar addition. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 28(29): 38455–38465

[163] Sarfaraz Q, Silva L S D, Drescher G L, Zafar M, Severo F F, Kokkonen A, Dal Molin G, Shafi M I, Shafique Q, Solaiman Z M. (2020). Characterization and carbon mineralization of biochars produced from different animal manures and plant residues. Scientific Reports, 10(1): 955

[164] SarmahMBorgohain ASaikiaJDekaDMalakarH KharePKarak T (2023). Physical activation and nanoscale transformation of biochar using different mechanochemical techniques. In: Mishra D, Singh R, Khare P, eds. Biochar-based Nanocomposites for Contaminant Management: Synthesis, Contaminants Removal, and Environmental Sustainability. Cham: Springer, 21–32

[165] Sarubbo L A, Silva M D G C, Durval I J B, Bezerra K G O, Ribeiro B G, Silva I A, Twigg M S, Banat I M. (2022). Biosurfactants: production, properties, applications, trends, and general perspectives. Biochemical Engineering Journal, 181: 108377

[166] Selvaraj V, Swarna Karthika T, Mansiya C, Alagar M. (2021). An over review on recently developed techniques, mechanisms and intermediate involved in the advanced azo dye degradation for industrial applications. Journal of Molecular Structure, 1224: 129195

[167] ShahH HAmin MPepeFMancusiEFareedA G (2023). Overview of environmental and economic viability of activated carbons derived from waste biomass for adsorptive water treatment applications. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 30: 121238

[168] Shaheen S M, Ullah H, Wu Y J, Mosa A, Fang Y R, Shi Y, Liu J, Kumar M, Zhang H, Zhang B G, Li R H, Wang J X, Antoniadis V, Lee S S, Rinklebe J. (2025). Remediation of emerging inorganic contaminants in soils and water using pristine and engineered biochar: a review. Biochar, 7(1): 34

[169] Shanmuganathan R, Sibtain Kadri M, Mathimani T, Hoang Le Q, Pugazhendhi A. (2023). Recent innovations and challenges in the eradication of emerging contaminants from aquatic systems. Chemosphere, 332: 138812

[170] Sharma P, Tripathi S, Vadakedath N, Chandra R. (2021). In-situ toxicity assessment of pulp and paper industry wastewater on Trigonella foenum-graecum L: potential source of cytotoxicity and chromosomal damage. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 21: 101251

[171] Sharma P, Vaiwala R, Parthasarathi S, Patil N, Verma A, Waskar M, Raut J S, Basu J K, Ayappa K G. (2022). Interactions of surfactants with the bacterial cell wall and inner membrane: revealing the link between aggregation and antimicrobial activity. Langmuir, 38(50): 15714–15728

[172] Shi M Z, Liu C G, Wang Y M, Zhao Y, Wei Z M, Zhao M Y, Song C H, Liu Y. (2021). Nitrate shifted microenvironment: driven aromatic-ring cleavage microbes and aromatic compounds precursor biodegradation during sludge composting. Bioresource Technology, 342: 125907

[173] Shi S N, Liu J X, Xu J, Zeng Q Z, Hou Y, Jiang B. (2019). Effects of biochar on the phenol treatment performance and microbial communities shift in sequencing batch reactors. Water Research, 161: 1–10

[174] Shi Y S, Liu M L, Li J Y, Yao Y L, Tang J C, Niu Q G. (2022). The dosage-effect of biochar on anaerobic digestion under the suppression of oily sludge: performance variation, microbial community succession and potential detoxification mechanisms. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 421: 126819

[175] Song Y F, Zhang Z H, Liu Y B, Peng F Y, Feng Y J. (2024). Enhancement of anaerobic treatment of antibiotic pharmaceutical wastewater through the development of iron-based and carbon-based materials: a critical review. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 479: 135514

[176] Song Y L, Wang L J, Qiang X, Gu W H, Ma Z L, Wang G C. (2023). An overview of biological mechanisms and strategies for treating wastewater from printing and dyeing processes. Journal of Water Process Engineering, 55: 104242

[177] Sonkar M, Kumar V, Dutt D. (2021). A novel sequence batch treatment of wastewater using Bacillus sp. IITRDVM-5 mixing with paper mill and sewage sludge powders. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 21: 101288

[178] Sutar S, Patil P, Jadhav J. (2022). Recent advances in biochar technology for textile dyes wastewater remediation: a review. Environmental Research, 209: 112841

[179] Sutradhar S, Mondal A, Kuehne F, Krueger O, Rakshit S K, Kang K. (2024). Comparison of oil-seed shell biomass-based biochar for the removal of anionic dyes—characterization and adsorption efficiency studies. Plants, 13(6): 820

[180] Tang R, Zhang M, Li X. (2024). A novel strategy combining hydrogenotrophic methanogens' bioaugmentation and biochar biostimulation for simultaneous polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon biodegradation and bioenergy recovery. RSC Advances, 14(33): 23710–23719

[181] Tara N, Arslan M, Hussain Z, Iqbal M, Khan Q M, Afzal M. (2019). On-site performance of floating treatment wetland macrocosms augmented with dye-degrading bacteria for the remediation of textile industry wastewater. Journal of Cleaner Production, 217: 541–548

[182] Tawfik A, Alhajeri N S, Elsamadony M, Meng F G. (2024). Mitigation of pharmaceutical wastewater toxicity in anaerobic reactors using metal-modified biochar. ACS ES&T Engineering, 4(12): 2987–3000

[183] Tayibi S, Monlau F, Marias F, Cazaudehore G, Fayoud N E, Oukarroum A, Zeroual Y, Barakat A. (2021). Coupling anaerobic digestion and pyrolysis processes for maximizing energy recovery and soil preservation according to the circular economy concept. Journal of Environmental Management, 279: 111632

[184] Tomczyk A, Sokołowska Z, Boguta P. (2020). Biochar physicochemical properties: pyrolysis temperature and feedstock kind effects. Reviews in Environmental Science and Bio/Technology, 19(1): 191–215

[185] Tong S Q, Chen D, Mao P, Jiang X B, Sun A W, Xu Z X, Liu X D, Shen J Y. (2022). Synthesis of magnetic hydrochar from Fenton sludge and sewage sludge for enhanced anaerobic decolorization of azo dye AO7. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 424: 127622

[186] UN-Water(2024). Progress on Wastewater Treatment-2024 Update. Geneva: UN-Water Publications

[187] Vimal V, Patel M, Mohan D. (2019). Aqueous carbofuran removal using slow pyrolyzed sugarcane bagasse biochar: equilibrium and fixed-bed studies. RSC Advances, 9(45): 26338–26350

[188] Vítězová M, Kohoutová A, Vítěz T, Hanišáková N, Kushkevych I. (2020). Methanogenic microorganisms in industrial wastewater anaerobic treatment. Processes, 8(12): 1546

[189] WanJWangG H LiangW YPeng CZhangWFuR B (2022). Is biochar a reliable catalyst for activating peroxydisulfate? Damage of biochar during catalytic process. Chemosphere, 303(Pt 3): 135240

[190] Wang G J, Li Q, Li Y, Xing Y, Yao G F, Liu Y Z, Chen R, Wang X C. (2020a). Redox-active biochar facilitates potential electron tranfer between syntrophic partners to enhance anaerobic digestion under high organic loading rate. Bioresource Technology, 298: 122524

[191] Wang G Y, Cui C H, Wang Y Q, Pang J W, Yang S S, Wu C D, Fang R, Zhang L Y, Ren N Q, Ding J. (2024a). Enhancement of the anaerobic biodegradation efficiency of azo dye by anthraquinone-loaded biochar biofilm: factors affecting biofilm formation and the enhancement mechanism. Biochar, 6(1): 95

[192] Wang G Y, Ding J, He L, Wu T, Ding M Q, Pang J W, Liu L M, Gao X L, Zhang L Y, Ren N Q, Yang S S. (2023a). Enhanced anaerobic degradation of azo dyes by biofilms supported by novel functionalized carriers. Bioresource Technology, 378: 129013

[193] Wang G Y, Yang S S, Ding J, Chen C X, Zhong L, Ding L, Ma M, Sun G S, Huang Z L, Ren N Q. (2021). Immobilized redox mediators on modified biochar and their role on azo dye biotransformation in anaerobic biological systems: mechanisms, biodegradation pathway and theoretical calculation. Chemical Engineering Journal, 423: 130300

[194] Wang J J, Li W S, Zhao Z R, Musoke F S N, Wu X G. (2022a). Ultrasonic activated biochar and its removal of harmful substances in environment. Microorganisms, 10(8): 1593

[195] Wang J L, Wang S Z. (2019). Preparation, modification and environmental application of biochar: a review. Journal of Cleaner Production, 227: 1002–1022

[196] Wang L L, Li Y Y, Yi X S, Yang F, Wang D X, Han H J. (2023c). Dissimilatory manganese reduction facilitates synergistic cooperation of hydrolysis, acidogenesis, acetogenesis and methanogenesis via promoting microbial interaction during anaerobic digestion of waste activated sludge. Environmental Research, 218: 114992

[197] Wang L W, Deng J Y, Yang X D, Hou R J, Hou D Y. (2023b). Role of biochar toward carbon neutrality. Carbon Research, 2(1): 2

[198] Wang L W, Ok Y S, Tsang D C W, Alessi D S, Rinklebe J, Mašek O, Bolan N S, Hou D Y. (2022b). Biochar composites: emerging trends, field successes and sustainability implications. Soil Use and Management, 38(1): 14–38

[199] Wang L, Wang Y J, Ma F, Tankpa V, Bai S S, Guo X M, Wang X. (2019). Mechanisms and reutilization of modified biochar used for removal of heavy metals from wastewater: a review. Science of the Total Environment, 668: 1298–1309

[200] Wang R K, Peng P B, Song G K, Zhao Z H, Yin Q Q. (2022c). Effect of corn stover hydrochar on anaerobic digestion performance of its associated wastewater. Environmental Pollution, 315: 120430

[201] Wang T, Lv N, Pan X F, Li C X, Zhu G F. (2020b). Process performance and microbial community functional structure in a thermophilic anaerobic baffled reactor coupled with biocatalysed electrolysis. Environmental Technology, 41(12): 1535–1545

[202] Wang Y F, Chen Z B, Hu D X, Jiang L W, Cui S M, Zhuang S Y, Yan J T, Dong J, Han F, Jiang B. . (2024c). Optimization of ethylene thiourea, cyanide, and heavy metals removal and gas production enhancement in organosulfur pesticide wastewater using ferromagnetic biochar in anaerobic membrane bioreactor. Chemical Engineering Journal, 496: 153785

[203] Wang Y Q, Ding J, Pang J W, Wu C D, Sun H J, Fang R, Ren N Q, Yang S S. (2024b). Promotion of anaerobic biodegradation of azo dye RR2 by different biowaste-derived biochars: characteristics and mechanism study by machine learning. Bioresource Technology, 396: 130383

[204] Wang Y, Wan S G, Yu W L, Yuan D, Sun L. (2022d). The role of Fe₃O₄@biochar as electron shuttle in enhancing the biodegradation of gaseous para-xylene by aerobic surfactant secreted strains. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 438: 129475

[205] Wang Z H, Li Z Y, Zhang Y C, Fu P. (2024d). Carbon-based catalysts for hydrodeoxygenation of biomass derivatives: a review of heteroatom doping strategies. Molecular Catalysis, 569: 114539

[206] Wei Y M, Chen L Y, Jiao G Z, Wen Y, Liao Q, Zhou H L, Tang S J. (2023). Enhanced removal of metal-cyanide complexes from wastewater by Fe-impregnated biochar: adsorption performance and removal mechanism. Chemosphere, 331: 138719

[207] Wei Y, Shen C Y, Xie J L, Bu Q. (2020). Study on reaction mechanism of superior bamboo biochar catalyst production by molten alkali carbonates pyrolysis and its application for cellulose hydrolysis. Science of the Total Environment, 712: 136435

[208] Weinrich S, Nelles M. (2021). Systematic simplification of the Anaerobic Digestion Model No. 1 (ADM1) – model development and stoichiometric analysis. Bioresource Technology, 333: 125124

[209] Wen J H Z, Wang B D, Dai Z D, Shi X S, Jin Z H, Wang H L, Jiang X. (2023). New insights into the green cement composites with low carbon footprint: the role of biochar as cement additive/alternative. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 197: 107081

[210] Wu P, Ata-Ul-Karim S T, Singh B P, Wang H L, Wu T L, Liu C, Fang G D, Zhou D M, Wang Y J, Chen W F. (2019). A scientometric review of biochar research in the past, 20 years (1998–2018). Biochar, 1(1): 23–43

[211] Xi R F, Li Y Y, Zhang Y, Wang P, Hu D M. (2024). Effects of activation method on biomass carbon-based materials used for electrochemical hydrogen evolution reaction catalyst. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 51: 1–19

[212] Xia D P, Niu Y X, Tian J X, Su X B, Wei G Q, Jian K, Wang Z Z, Zhang Y W, Zhao W Z. (2024). Degradation metabolic pathway of low-rank coal using single hydrolytic bacteria. Fuel, 364: 130917

[213] Xia J H, Li Y, Jiang X B, Chen D, Shen J Y. (2023). Enhanced 4-bromophenol anaerobic biodegradation in electricity-stimulated anaerobic system: the key role of humic acid in reshaping microbial eco-interrelations and functions. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 453: 131426

[214] Xiao F, Bedane A H, Zhao J X, Mann M D, Pignatello J J. (2018). Thermal air oxidation changes surface and adsorptive properties of black carbon (char/biochar). Science of the Total Environment, 618: 276–283

[215] Xu C X, Ding Y Y, Liu J C, Huang W W, Cheng Q P, Fan G Z, Yan J T, Zhang S X, Song G S, Xiao B. (2023). Anaerobic digestion of sulphate wastewater mediated by biochar. Environmental Technology, 44(11): 1667–1678

[216] Xu R, Zhao Y H, Han Q Z, Ning P G, Cao H B, Wen H. (2020). Computer-aided blended extractant design and screening for co-extracting phenolic, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and nitrogen heterocyclic compounds pollutants from coal chemical wastewater. Journal of Cleaner Production, 277: 122334

[217] Yan S W, Yu W, Yang T, Li Q, Guo J H. (2022). The adsorption of corn stalk biochar for Pb and Cd: preparation, characterization, and batch adsorption study. Separations, 9(2): 22

[218] Yang F, Zhang S S, Sun Y Q, Du Q, Song J P, Tsang D C W. (2019a). A novel electrochemical modification combined with one-step pyrolysis for preparation of sustainable thorn-like iron-based biochar composites. Bioresource Technology, 274: 379–385

[219] Yang L, Liu Y J, Li C, Li P F, Zhang A N, Liu Z, Wang Z, Wei C X, Yang Z Z, Li Z H. (2024). Optimizing carbon sources regulation in the biochemical treatment systems for coal chemical wastewater: aromatic compounds biodegradation and microbial response strategies. Water Research, 256: 121627

[220] Yang L, Liu Y J, Li C, Liu Z, Liu X S, Wei C X, Yang Z Z, Zhang A N. (2022). Biodegradation time series characteristics and metabolic fate of different aromatic compounds in the biochemical treatment process of coal chemical wastewater. Bioresource Technology, 361: 127688

[221] Yang L, Liu Y J, Zhang A N, Liu Z, Yang Z Z, Wei C X, Li Z H. (2023). Cumulative effects and metabolic characteristics of aromatic compounds in microbial cells during the biochemical treatment process of coal chemical wastewater. Chemical Engineering Journal, 471: 144307

[222] Yang Q L, Gao Y, Ke J, Show P L, Ge Y H, Liu Y H, Guo R X, Chen J Q. (2021a). Antibiotics: an overview on the environmental occurrence, toxicity, degradation, and removal methods. Bioengineered, 12(1): 7376–7416

[223] Yang S, Chen Z Q, Wen Q X. (2021b). Impacts of biochar on anaerobic digestion of swine manure: methanogenesis and antibiotic resistance genes dissemination. Bioresource Technology, 324: 124679

[224] Yang X D, Wan Y S, Zheng Y L, He F, Yu Z B, Huang J, Wang H L, Ok Y S, Jiang Y S, Gao B. (2019b). Surface functional groups of carbon-based adsorbents and their roles in the removal of heavy metals from aqueous solutions: a critical review. Chemical Engineering Journal, 366: 608–621

[225] Yang Z Y, Sun H Y, Zhao Q, Kurbonova M, Zhang R H, Liu G Q, Wang W. (2020). Long-term evaluation of bioaugmentation to alleviate ammonia inhibition during anaerobic digestion: process monitoring, microbial community response, and methanogenic pathway modeling. Chemical Engineering Journal, 399: 125765

[226] Yao B, Liu M, Tang T T, Hu X, Yang C Y, Chen Y. (2023). Enhancement of anaerobic digestion of ciprofloxacin wastewater by nano zero-valent iron immobilized onto biochar. Bioresource Technology, 385: 129462

[227] Yao B, Liu M, Yu L Q, Ni Q H, Yuan C J, Hu X, Feng H R, Zhang J, Chen Y. (2024). Mechanism of biochar in alleviating the inhibition of anaerobic digestion under ciprofloxacin press. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 480: 135949

[228] Ye Q Q, Li Q H, Li X. (2022). Removal of heavy metals from wastewater using biochars: adsorption and mechanisms. Environmental Pollutants and Bioavailability, 34(1): 385–394

[229] Yuan Y Y, Hu X Y, Chen H B, Zhou Y Y, Zhou Y F, Wang D B. (2019). Advances in enhanced volatile fatty acid production from anaerobic fermentation of waste activated sludge. Science of the Total Environment, 694: 133741

[230] Zhang C, Yang X, Tan X J, Wan C L, Liu X. (2022a). Sewage sludge treatment technology under the requirement of carbon neutrality: recent progress and perspectives. Bioresource Technology, 362: 127853

[231] Zhang J X, Chua Q W, Mao F J, Zhang L, He Y L, Tong Y W, Loh K C. (2019). Effects of activated carbon on anaerobic digestion – methanogenic metabolism, mechanisms of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes removal. Bioresource Technology Reports, 5: 113–120

[232] Zhang L F, Zhang Q, Wang Y P, Cui X, Liu Y H, Ruan R, Wu X D, Cao L P, Zhao L T, Zheng H L. (2023b). Preparation and application of metal-modified biochar in the purification of micro-polystyrene polluted aqueous environment. Journal of Environmental Management, 347: 119158

[233] Zhang L Q, Chen Z K, Zhu S S, Li S G, Wei C H. (2023a). Effects of biochar on anaerobic treatment systems: some perspectives. Bioresource Technology, 367: 128226

[234] Zhang M, Wang Y C. (2020). Effects of Fe-Mn-modified biochar addition on anaerobic digestion of sewage sludge: biomethane production, heavy metal speciation and performance stability. Bioresource Technology, 313: 123695

[235] Zhang X Y, Gu J, Liu Y. (2022b). Necessity of direct energy and ammonium recovery for carbon neutral municipal wastewater reclamation in an innovative anaerobic MBR-biochar adsorption-reverse osmosis process. Water Research, 211: 118058

[236] Zhang X Z, Fan Y Q, Hao T W, Chen R, Zhang T, Hu Y, Li D P, Pan Y, Li Y Y, Kong Z. (2023c). Insights into current bio-processes and future perspectives of carbon-neutral treatment of industrial organic wastewater: a critical review. Environmental Research, 241: 117630

[237] Zhang X Z, Hao T W, Zhang T, Hu Y, Lu R, Li D P, Pan Y, Li Y Y, Kong Z. (2024a). Towards energy conservation and carbon reduction for wastewater treatment processes: a review of carbon-neutral anaerobic biotechnologies. Journal of Water Process Engineering, 59: 105026

[238] Zhang X Z, Ma G Y, Chen T, Yan C R, Chen Y H, Wang Q Y, Peng X Y, Xu W J, Hao T W, Zhang T. . (2024b). Towards carbon-neutral biotechnologies for rural wastewater: a review of current treatment processes and future perspectives. Journal of Water Process Engineering, 58: 104773

[239] Zhang Y K, Cao L, Fu H B, Zhang M, Meng J, Althakafy J T, Abo-Dief H M, El-Bahy S M, Zhang Y S, Wei H H. . (2022c). Effect of sulfamethazine on anaerobic digestion of manure mediated by biochar. Chemosphere, 306: 135567

[240] Zhang Y Y, He M J, Wang L, Yan J H, Ma B, Zhu X H, Ok Y S, Mechtcherine V, Tsang D C W. (2022d). Biochar as construction materials for achieving carbon neutrality. Biochar, 4(1): 59

[241] Zhang Y Y, Zhang J C, Chen K D, Shen S R, Hu H W, Chang M L, Chen D C, Wu Y F, Yuan H R, Wang Y Z. (2023d). Engineering banana-peel-derived biochar for the rapid adsorption of tetracycline based on double chemical activation. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 190: 106821

[242] Zhang Y, Zheng Y L, Yang Y C, Huang J S, Zimmerman A R, Chen H, Hu X, Gao B. (2021). Mechanisms and adsorption capacities of hydrogen peroxide modified ball milled biochar for the removal of methylene blue from aqueous solutions. Bioresource Technology, 337: 125432

[243] Zhang Z S, Li C X, Wang G, Yang X Y, Zhang Y X, Wang R M, Angelidaki I, Miao H F. (2023e). Mechanistic insights into Fe₃O₄-modified biochar relieving inhibition from erythromycin on anaerobic digestion. Journal of Environmental Management, 344: 118459

[244] Zhang Z, Zhang C H, Yang Y, Zhang Z W, Tang Y H, Su P D, Lin Z W. (2022e). A review of sulfate-reducing bacteria: metabolism, influencing factors and application in wastewater treatment. Journal of Cleaner Production, 376: 134109

[245] Zhao S N, Wu Y H, Yao Y L, Li J Y, Niu Q G. (2022). Biochar assisted cellulose anaerobic digestion under the inhibition of dodecyl dimethyl benzyl ammonium chloride: dose-response kinetic assays, performance variation, potential promotion mechanisms. Journal of Environmental Management, 312: 114934

[246] Zhao W X, Yang H Z, He S F, Zhao Q L, Wei L L. (2021a). A review of biochar in anaerobic digestion to improve biogas production: performances, mechanisms and economic assessments. Bioresource Technology, 341: 125797

[247] Zhao Z S, Cao Y, Li S Y, Zhang Y B. (2021b). Effects of biowaste-derived biochar on the electron transport efficiency during anaerobic acid orange 7 removal. Bioresource Technology, 320: 124295

[248] Zhao Z S, Zhang G Y, Zhang Y B, Dou M, Li Y. (2020). Fe₃O₄ accelerates tetracycline degradation during anaerobic digestion: synergistic role of adsorption and microbial metabolism. Water Research, 185: 116225

[249] Zheng M Q, Han H J, Shi J X, Zhang Z W, Ma W C, Xu C Y. (2021). Metagenomic analysis of aromatic ring-cleavage mechanism in nano-Fe₃O₄@activated coke enhanced bio-system for coal pyrolysis wastewater treatment. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 414: 125387

[250] Zheng M Q, Shi J X, Xu C Y, Han Y X, Zhang Z W, Han H J. (2020). Insights into electroactive biofilms for enhanced phenolic degradation of coal pyrolysis wastewater (CPW) by magnetic activated coke (MAC): metagenomic analysis in attached biofilm and suspended sludge. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 395: 122688

[251] Zheng T, Ouyang S H, Zhou Q X. (2023). Synthesis, characterization, safety design, and application of NPs@BC for contaminated soil remediation and sustainable agriculture. Biochar, 5(1): 5

[252] Zhou J J, Zhang S S, Shi H J, Qiang J, Dong H, Liu H H. (2024). Hydrothermal synthesis of analcime from construction waste bricks and its adsorption mechanism for Pb²⁺. Water, Air, & Soil Pollution, 235(3): 186

[253] Zhou L, Chi T Y, Zhou Y Y, Chen H, Du C Y, Yu G L, Wu H P, Zhu X F, Wang G L. (2021a). Stimulation of pyrolytic carbon materials as electron shuttles on the anaerobic transformation of recalcitrant organic pollutants: a review. Science of the Total Environment, 801: 149696

[254] Zhou M D, Li C X, Zhao L X, Ning J, Pan X F, Cai G J, Zhu G F. (2021b). Synergetic effect of nano zero-valent iron and activated carbon on high-level ciprofloxacin removal in hydrolysis-acidogenesis of anaerobic digestion. Science of the Total Environment, 752: 142261

[255] Zhou Y, Ji B H, Jiang M, Jin Y Y, Chang J J. (2023). Performance and microbial community features of tidal-flow biochar-amended constructed wetlands treating sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-containing greywater. Journal of Cleaner Production, 396: 136545

[256] Zhu K Y, Zhang L, Mu L, Ma J, Li C J, Li A M. (2019). Anaerobic digestion of surfactant and lipid co-existing organic waste: focusing on the antagonistic enhancement. Chemical Engineering Journal, 371: 96–106

[257] Zhu L, Tong L H, Zhao N, Wang X, Yang X X, Lv Y Z. (2020). Key factors and microscopic mechanisms controlling adsorption of cadmium by surface oxidized and aminated biochars. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 382: 121002

[258] Zhuang H F, Shi J X, Shan S D, Ping L F, Zhang C G. (2020). Enhanced anaerobic treatment of azo dye wastewater via direct interspecies electron transfer with Fe₃O₄/sludge carbon. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 45(53): 28476–28487

[259] Zieliński M, Kazimierowicz J, Dębowski M. (2023). Advantages and limitations of anaerobic wastewater treatment—technological basics, development directions, and technological innovations. Energies, 16(1): 83

[260] Zoroufchi Benis K, Motalebi Damuchali A, Soltan J, Mcphedran K N. (2020). Treatment of aqueous arsenic: a review of biochar modification methods. Science of the Total Environment, 739: 139750

[261] Zubbri N A, Mohamed A R, Kamiuchi N, Mohammadi M. (2020). Enhancement of CO₂ adsorption on biochar sorbent modified by metal incorporation. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 27(11): 11809–11829

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Higher Education Press 2025