Solid Brønsted acidity boosts adsorption reactivity of nano-adsorbent for water decontamination

Highlights

● Nanoconfinement growth produces metastable ZrP with dual Lewis and Brønsted acidity.

● Lewis acid sites’ adsorption affinity rises with reduced outer electron density.

● Brønsted acidity suppresses competitive OH⁻ adsorption onto Lewis acidic sites.

● Brønsted acidity enhances silicate resistance, enabling refreshment of the used ZrP.

Abstract

Despite the development of various Lewis acidic nano-adsorbents for fluoride removal through inner-sphere coordination, strong competition for hydroxyl ions still hinders efficient water defluoridation. In addition, the critical issue of polysilicate scaling that results from the ubiquitous silicates must be addressed. To tackle these issues, an alternative approach to enhancing adsorption reactivity by modifying nano-adsorbents with dual Lewis and Brønsted acidity is proposed. The feasibility of this approach is demonstrated by growing zirconium phosphate (ZrP) inside a gel-type anion exchanger, N201, to produce nanocomposite ZrP@N201, in which the confined ZrP contained an otherwise metastable amorphous phase with Lewis acidic Zr⁴⁺ sites and Brønsted acidic monohydrogen phosphate groups (–O₃POH). Compared with the Lewis acidic nano-zirconium oxide analog (HZO@N201), ZrP@N201 exhibited a greatly improved adsorption capacity (117.9 vs. 52.3 mg/g-Zr) and mass transfer rate (3.56 × 10⁻⁶ vs. 4.55 × 10⁻⁷ cm/s), while bulk ZrP produced a thermodynamically stable α-phase with Brønsted acidity that exhibited negligible adsorption capability toward fluoride. The enhanced defluoridation activity of ZrP@N201 is attributed to Brønsted acidity and the increased outer electron density of Zr⁴⁺ sites, as corroborated using XPS and solid-state NMR analysis. Moreover, Brønsted acidity strengthens the resistance of ZrP@N201 to silicate, allowing its full regeneration during cyclic defluoridation. Column tests demonstrated 3–10 times the amount of clean water from (waste) for ZrP@N201 as compared to both HZO@N201 and the widely used activated aluminum oxide. This study highlights the potential of developing nano-adsorbents with dual acidities for various environmental remediation applications.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

Nanocomposite / Selective adsorption / Fluoride removal / Dual Lewis and Brønsted acidity / Regeneration

References

[1] Ahmed I, Mondol M M H, Jung M J, Lee G H, Jhung S H. (2023). MOFs with bridging or terminal hydroxo ligands: applications in adsorption, catalysis, and functionalization. Coordination Chemistry Reviews, 475: 214912

[2] Alhassan S I, Huang L, He Y, Yan L, Wu B, Wang H. (2021). Fluoride removal from water using alumina and aluminum-based composites: a comprehensive review of progress. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 51(18): 2051–2085

[3] Campos-Pereira H, Kleja D B, Sjöstedt C, Ahrens L, Klysubun W, Gustafsson J P. (2020). The adsorption of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) onto ferrihydrite is governed by surface charge. Environmental Science & Technology, 54(24): 15722–15730

[4] Chen J, Yang R, Zhang Z, Wu D. (2022). Removal of fluoride from water using aluminum hydroxide-loaded zeolite synthesized from coal fly ash. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 421: 126817

[5] Cheng S, Qian J, Zhang X, Lu Z, Pan B. (2023). Commercial gel-type ion exchange resin enables large-scale production of ultrasmall nanoparticles for highly efficient water decontamination. Engineering, 23: 149–156

[6] Cherukumilli K, Delaire C, Amrose S, Gadgil A J. (2017). Factors governing the performance of bauxite for fluoride remediation of groundwater. Environmental Science & Technology, 51(4): 2321–2328

[7] ChowdhuryS R, YanfulE K, PrattA R (2012). Chemical states in XPS and Raman analysis during removal of Cr(VI) from contaminated water by mixed maghemite–magnetite nanoparticles. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 235–236: 246–256 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2012.07.054

[8] Du M, Zhang Y, Wang Z, Lv M, Tang A, Yu Y, Qu X, Chen Z, Wen Q, Li A. (2022). Insight into the synthesis and adsorption mechanism of adsorbents for efficient phosphate removal: exploration from synthesis to modification. Chemical Engineering Journal, 442: 136147

[9] Du Y, Qiu S, Zhang X, Nie G. (2020). Nanoconfined hydrous titanium oxides with excellent acid stability for selective and efficient removal of As(V) from acidic wastewater. Chemical Engineering Journal, 400: 125907

[10] Fan Q, Bao G, Chen X, Meng Y, Zhang S, Ma X. (2022). Iron nanoparticles tuned to catalyze CO₂ electroreduction in acidic solutions through chemical microenvironment engineering. ACS Catalysis, 12(13): 7517–7523

[11] Fang Z, Deng Z, Liu A, Zhang X, Lv L, Pan B. (2021a). Enhanced removal of arsenic from water by using sub-10 nm hydrated zirconium oxides confined inside gel-type anion exchanger. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 414: 125505

[12] Fang Z, Li Z, Zhang X, Pan S, Wu M, Pan B. (2021b). Enhanced arsenite removal from silicate-containing water by using redox polymer-based Fe(III) oxides nanocomposite. Water Research, 189: 116673

[13] Gong H, Zhou C, Cui Y, Dai S, Zhao X, Luo R, An P, Li H, Wang H, Hou Z. (2020). Direct transformation of glycerol to propanal using zirconium phosphate‐supported bimetallic catalysts. ChemSusChem, 13(18): 4954–4966

[14] Gould N S, Li S, Cho H J, Landfield H, Caratzoulas S, Vlachos D, Bai P, Xu B. (2020). Understanding solvent effects on adsorption and protonation in porous catalysts. Nature Communications, 11(1): 1060

[15] Han H, Rafiq M K, Zhou T, Xu R, Mašek O, Li X. (2019). A critical review of clay-based composites with enhanced adsorption performance for metal and organic pollutants. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 369: 780–796

[16] Indris S, Heitjans P, Roman H E, Bunde A. (2000). Nanocrystalline versus microcrystalline Li₂O:B₂O₃ composites: anomalous ionic conductivities and percolation theory. Physical Review Letters, 84(13): 2889–2892

[17] Iriel A, Bruneel S P, Schenone N, Cirelli A F. (2018). The removal of fluoride from aqueous solution by a lateritic soil adsorption: kinetic and equilibrium studies. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 149: 166–172

[18] Kang D, Yu X, Ge M, Lin M, Yang X, Jing Y. (2018). Insights into adsorption mechanism for fluoride on cactus-like amorphous alumina oxide microspheres. Chemical Engineering Journal, 345: 252–259

[19] Keyikoglu R, Khataee A, Yoon Y. (2022). Layered double hydroxides for removing and recovering phosphate: recent advances and future directions. Advances in Colloid and Interface Science, 300: 102598

[20] Kong L, Tian Y, Pang Z, Huang X, Li M, Yang R, Li N, Zhang J, Zuo W. (2019). Synchronous phosphate and fluoride removal from water by 3D rice-like lanthanum-doped La@MgAl nanocomposites. Chemical Engineering Journal, 371: 893–902

[21] Lei X, Lian Q, Zhang X, Karsili T K, Holmes W, Chen Y, Zappi M E, Gang D D. (2023). A review of PFAS adsorption from aqueous solutions: current approaches, engineering applications, challenges, and opportunities. Environmental Pollution, 321: 121138

[22] Levenstein R, Hasson D, Semiat R. (1996). Utilization of the Donnan effect for improving electrolyte separation with nanofiltration membranes. Journal of Membrane Science, 116(1): 77–92

[23] Li Q, Chen Z, Wang H, Yang H, Wen T, Wang S, Hu B, Wang X. (2021). Removal of organic compounds by nanoscale zero-valent iron and its composites. Science of the Total Environment, 792: 148546

[24] Lin J Y, Chen Y L, Hong X Y, Huang C, Huang C P. (2020). The role of fluoroaluminate complexes on the adsorption of fluoride onto hydrous alumina in aqueous solutions. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 561: 275–286

[25] Liufu S C, Xiao H N, Li Y P. (2005). Adsorption of polyelectrolyte on the surface of ZnO nanoparticles and the stability of colloidal dispersions. Chinese Science Bulletin, 50(15): 1570–1575

[26] Luo J, Luo X, Crittenden J, Qu J, Bai Y, Peng Y, Li J. (2015). Removal of antimonite (Sb(III)) and antimonate (Sb(V)) from aqueous solution using carbon nanofibers that are decorated with zirconium oxide (ZrO₂). Environmental Science & Technology, 49(18): 11115–11124

[27] Meenakshi R C. (2006). Fluoride in drinking water and its removal. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 137(1): 456–463

[28] Mohapatra M, Anand S, Mishra B K, Giles D E, Singh P. (2009). Review of fluoride removal from drinking water. Journal of Environmental Management, 91(1): 67–77

[29] Pan B, Xu J, Wu B, Li Z, Liu X. (2013). Enhanced removal of fluoride by polystyrene anion exchanger supported hydrous zirconium oxide nanoparticles. Environmental Science & Technology, 47(16): 9347–9354

[30] Pan Y, Liu C J, Ge Q. (2008). Adsorption and protonation of CO₂ on partially hydroxylated γ-Al₂O₃ surfaces: a density functional theory study. Langmuir, 24(21): 12410–12419

[31] Pica M, Donnadio A, Casciola M. (2018). From microcrystalline to nanosized α-zirconium phosphate: synthetic approaches and applications of an old material with a bright future. Coordination Chemistry Reviews, 374: 218–235

[32] Pillai P, Dharaskar S, Sinha M K, Sillanpää M, Khalid M. (2020). Iron oxide nanoparticles modified with ionic liquid as an efficient adsorbent for fluoride removal from groundwater. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 19: 100842

[33] Podgorski J, Berg M. (2022). Global analysis and prediction of fluoride in groundwater. Nature Communications, 13(1): 4232

[34] Qiu H, Ye M, Zhang M D, Zhang X, Zhao Y, Yu J. (2021). Nano-hydroxyapatite encapsulated inside an anion exchanger for efficient defluoridation of neutral and weakly alkaline water. ACS ES&T Engineering, 1(1): 46–54

[35] Qu X, Zhai P, Shi L, Qu X, Bilal A, Han J, Yu X. (2023). Distribution, enrichment mechanism and risk assessment for fluoride in groundwater: a case study of Mihe-Weihe River Basin, China. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 17(6): 70

[36] Ravi M, Sushkevich V L, Van Bokhoven J A. (2020). Towards a better understanding of Lewis acidic aluminium in zeolites. Nature Materials, 19(10): 1047–1056

[37] Rengarajan G T, Enke D, Steinhart M, Beiner M. (2008). Stabilization of the amorphous state of pharmaceuticals in nanopores. Journal of Materials Chemistry, 18(22): 2537–2539

[38] Shen D, Song Y, Chen X, Zhou Y, Li H, Pan J. (2022). Fabricating ultrafine zirconium oxide based composite sorbents in “soft confined space” for efficiently removing fluoride from environmental water. Chemical Engineering Journal, 444: 136199

[39] Smith R C, Li J Z, Padungthon S, Sengupta A K. (2015). Nexus between polymer support and metal oxide nanoparticles in hybrid nanosorbent materials (HNMs) for sorption/desorption of target ligands. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 9(5): 929–938

[40] Tangjitjaroenkit S, Pranudta A, Chanlek N, Nguyen T T, Kuster A T, Kuster A C, El-Moselhy M M, Padungthon S. (2021). Fluoride removal by hybrid cation exchanger impregnated with hydrated Al(III) oxide nanoparticles (HCIX-Al) with novel closed-loop recyclable regeneration system. Reactive & Functional Polymers, 169: 105067

[41] Tao W, Zhong H, Pan X, Wang P, Wang H, Huang L. (2020). Removal of fluoride from wastewater solution using Ce-AlOOH with oxalic acid as modification. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 384: 121373

[42] ten Elshof J E, Yuan H, Gonzalez Rodriguez P. (2016). Two-dimensional metal oxide and metal hydroxide nanosheets: synthesis, controlled assembly and applications in energy conversion and storage. Advanced Energy Materials, 6(23): 1600355

[43] Theiss F L, Couperthwaite S J, Ayoko G A, Frost R L. (2014). A review of the removal of anions and oxyanions of the halogen elements from aqueous solution by layered double hydroxides. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 417: 356–368

[44] Wang G, Yan T, Shen J, Zhang J, Zhang D. (2021). Capacitive removal of fluoride ions via creating multiple capture sites in a modulatory heterostructure. Environmental Science & Technology, 55(17): 11979–11986

[45] Wang X M, Li N, Li J Y, Feng J J, Ma Z, Xu Y T, Sun Y C, Xu D M, Wang J, Gao X L. . (2019a). Fluoride removal from secondary effluent of the graphite industry using electrodialysis: optimization with response surface methodology. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 13(4): 51

[46] Wang Z, Chen Y, Wang L, Zheng J, Fan Y, Zhang S. (2023). Rapid and efficient removal of toxic ions from water using Zr-based MOFs@PIM hierarchical porous nanofibre membranes. Chemical Engineering Journal, 452: 139198

[47] Wang Z, Jiang Y, Yi X, Zhou C, Rawal A, Hook J, Liu Z, Deng F, Zheng A, Hunger M. . (2019b). High population and dispersion of pentacoordinated AlV species on the surface of flame-made amorphous silica-alumina. Science Bulletin, 64(8): 516–523

[48] Xia G, Li L, Guo Z, Gu Q, Guo Y, Yu X, Liu H, Liu Z. (2013). Stabilization of NaZn(BH₄)₃via nanoconfinement in SBA-15 towards enhanced hydrogen release. Journal of Materials Chemistry. A, Materials for Energy and Sustainability, 1(2): 250–257

[49] Yan Q, Lian C, Huang K, Liang L, Yu H, Yin P, Zhang J, Xing M. (2021). Constructing an acidic microenvironment by MoS₂ in heterogeneous Fenton reaction for pollutant control. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 60(31): 17155–17163

[50] Zhang J, Tian C, Xu Y, Chen J, Xiao L, Wu G, Jin F. (2023a). Effective removal of fluorine ions in phosphoric acid by silicate molecular sieve synthesized by hexafluorosilicic acid. Separation and Purification Technology, 305: 122395

[51] Zhang P, Li Y, Zhang Y, Hou R, Zhang X, Xue C, Wang S, Zhu B, Li N, Shao G. (2020a). Photogenerated electron transfer process in heterojunctions: in situ irradiation XPS. Small Methods, 4(9): 2000214

[52] Zhang Q, Du X, Ma X, Hao X, Guan G, Wang Z, Xue C, Zhang Z, Zuo Z. (2015). Facile preparation of electroactive amorphous α-ZrP/PANI hybrid film for potential-triggered adsorption of Pb²⁺ ions. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 289: 91–100

[53] Zhang X, Shen J, Pan S, Qian J, Pan B. (2020b). Metastable zirconium phosphate under nanoconfinement with superior adsorption capability for water treatment. Advanced Functional Materials, 30(12): 1909014

[54] Zhang X, Zhang L, Li Z, Jiang Z, Zheng Q, Lin B, Pan B. (2017). Rational design of antifouling polymeric nanocomposite for sustainable fluoride removal from NOM-Rich water. Environmental Science & Technology, 51(22): 13363–13371

[55] Zhang X Q, Trinh T T, van Santen R A, Jansen A P. (2011). Mechanism of the initial stage of silicate oligomerization. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 133(17): 6613–6625

[56] Zhang Y, De Azambuja F, Parac-Vogt T N. (2021). The forgotten chemistry of group(IV) metals: a survey on the synthesis, structure, and properties of discrete Zr(IV), Hf(IV), and Ti(IV) oxo clusters. Coordination Chemistry Reviews, 438: 213886

[57] Zhang Y, Wang L, Zhang R, He C, Jia L, Wang X, Feng X, Jiang T, Xie B, Ma X. . (2023b). Steering electron density of Zr sites using ligand effect in Bio-beads for efficient defluoridation. Advanced Functional Materials, 33(20): 2213999

[58] Zhao X, Zhang Y, Pan S, Zhang X, Zhang W, Pan B. (2021). Utilization of gel-type polystyrene host for immobilization of nano-sized hydrated zirconium oxides: a new strategy for enhanced phosphate removal. Chemosphere, 263: 127938

[59] Zhou G, Yang L, Luo C, Liu H, Li P, Cui Y, Liu L, Yu X, Zeng Q, Chen J. . (2019). Low-to-moderate fluoride exposure, relative mitochondrial DNA levels, and dental fluorosis in Chinese children. Environment International, 127: 70–77

Acknowledgements

We greatly appreciate the financial support from the National Key Research and Development Program of China (No. 2022YFC3205300) and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 22122604).

Conflict of Interest

The author Bingcai Pan is an Editorial Board Member of Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering. The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Electronic Supplementary Material

Supplementary material is available in the online version of this article at https://doi.org/10.1007/s11783-024-1841-2 and is accessible for authorized users.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 Higher Education Press 2024