Effect of Occupational Extremely Low-Frequency Electromagnetic Field Exposure on the Thyroid Gland of Workers: A Prospective Study

Abstract

Objective

The aim of this study was to investigate the biological effects of occupational extremely low-frequency electromagnetic field (ELF-EMF) exposure on the thyroid gland.

Methods

We conducted a prospective analysis of 85 workers (exposure group) exposed to an ELF-EMF (100 μT, 10–100 Hz) produced by the electromagnetic aircraft launch system and followed up on thyroid function indices, immunological indices, and color Doppler images for 3 years. Additionally, 116 healthy volunteers were randomly selected as controls (control group), the thyroid function of whom was compared to the exposure group.

Results

No significant difference was observed in thyroid function between the exposure and control groups. During the follow-up of the exposure group, the serum free triiodothyronine (FT3) level was found to slowly decrease and free thyroxine (FT4) level slowly increase with increasing exposure time. However, no significant difference was found in thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) over the three years, and no significant difference was observed in the FT3, FT4 and TSH levels between different exposure subgroups. Furthermore, no significant changes were observed in thyroid autoantibody levels and ultrasound images between subgroups or over time.

Conclusion

Long-term exposure to ELF-EMF may promote thyroid secretion of T4 and inhibit deiodination of T4 to T3. ELF-EMF has no significant effect on thyroid immune function and morphology.

Keywords

extremely low-frequency electromagnetic field / thyroid function / thyroid autoantibody / thyroid ultrasound / thyroid nodule

References

[1] ZhouSA, UesakaM. Bioelectrodynamics in living organisms. Int J Eng Sci, 2006, 44(1): 67-92

[2] BolandA, DelapierreD, MossayD, et al.. Effect of intermittent and continuous exposure to electromagnetic fields on cultured hippocampal cells. Bioelectromagnetics, 2002, 23(2): 97-105

[3] MigaultL, PielC, CarlesC, et al.. Maternal cumulative exposure to extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields and pregnancy outcomes in the Elfe cohort. Environ Int, 2018, 112: 165-173

[4] DinizP, SoejimaK, ItoG. Nitric oxide mediates the effects of pulsed electromagnetic field stimulation on the osteoblast proliferation and differentiation. Nitric Oxide, 2002, 7(1): 18-23

[5] WeiY, XiaolinH, TaoS. Effects of extremely low-frequency-pulsed electromagnetic field on different-derived osteoblast-like cells. Electromagn Biol Med, 2008, 27(3): 298-311

[6] IvancsitsS, DiemE, PilgerA, et al.. Induction of DNA strand breaks by intermittent exposure to extremely-low-frequency electromagnetic fields in human diploid fibroblasts. Mutat Res, 2002, 519(1–2): 1-13

[7] HuGL, ChiangH, ZengQL, et al.. ELF magnetic field inhibits gap junctional intercellular communication and induces hyperphosphorylation of connexin43 in NIH3T3 cells. Bioelectromagnetics, 2001, 22(8): 568-573

[8] MarinoAA, WolcottRM, ChervenakR, et al.. Nonlinear response of the immune system to power-frequency magnetic fields. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol, 2000, 279(3): R761-768

[9] MarinoAA, WolcottRM, ChervenakR, et al.. Nonlinear dynamical law governs magnetic field induced changes in lymphoid phenotype. Bioelectromagnetics, 2001, 22(8): 529-546

[10] KarimiA, Ghadiri MoghaddamF, ValipourM. Insights in the biology of extremely low-frequency magnetic fields exposure on human health. Mol Biol Rep, 2020, 47(7): 5621-5633

[11] IARC. Working Group on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans, Non-Ionizing Radiation, Part 1: Static and extremely low-frequency (ELF) electric and magnetic fields. IARC Monogr Eval Carcinog Risks Hum, 2002, 80: 1-395

[12] KheifetsL, SwansonJRoosliM. Childhood Leukemia and Extremely Low-Frequency Magnetic Fields: Critical Evaluation of Epidemiologic Evidence Using Hill’s Framework. Epidemiology of Electromagnetic Fields, 2014, New York, CRC Press: 141-160

[13] AhlbomA, DayN, FeychtingM, et al.. A pooled analysis of magnetic fields and childhood leukaemia. Br J Cancer, 2000, 83(5): 692-698

[14] KheifetsL, AhlbomA, CrespiCM, et al.. Pooled analysis of recent studies on magnetic fields and childhood leukaemia. Br J Cancer, 2010, 103(7): 1128-1135

[15] KheifetsL, MonroeJ, VergaraX, et al.. Occupational electromagnetic fields and leukemia and brain cancer: an update to two meta-analyses. J Occup Environ Med, 2008, 50(6): 677-688

[16] SinhaRK. Chronic non-thermal exposure of modulated 2450 MHz microwave radiation alters thyroid hormones and behavior of male rats. Int J Radiat Biol, 2008, 84(6): 505-513

[17] HajizadehR, MehriA, RazaviSMH, et al.. Effect of occupational exposure to extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields on level of thyroid hormones effective on fatigue. Iran Occup Health J, 2019, 16(1): 1-12

[18] LopeV, Pérez-GómezB, AragonésN, et al.. Occupational exposure to ionizing radiation and electromagnetic fields in relation to the risk of thyroid cancer in Sweden. Scand J Work Environ Health, 2006, 32(4): 276-284

[19] de VochtF. Interpretation of Timetrends (1996–2017) of the Incidence of Selected Cancers in England in Relation to Mobile Phone Use as a Possible Risk Factor. Bioelectromagnetics, 2021, 42(8): 609-615

[20] FioreM, Oliveri ContiG, CaltabianoR, et al.. Role of Emerging Environmental Risk Factors in Thyroid Cancer: A Brief Review. Int J Environ Res Public Health, 2019, 16(7): 1185

[21] VaccarellaS, FranceschiS, BrayF, et al.. Worldwide Thyroid-Cancer Epidemic? The Increasing Impact of Overdiagnosis. N Engl J Med, 2016, 375(7): 614-617

[22] MariottiS, Beck-PeccozP, FeingoldS, et al.Physiology of the Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Thyroid Axis, 2022

[23] KuntH, Şentürk, GönülY, et al.. Effects of electromagnetic radiation exposure on bone mineral density, thyroid, and oxidative stress index in electrical workers. Onco Targets Ther, 2016, 9: 745-754

[24] Chinese Society of Endocrinology CAssociation EGoSBoCMCancer HaNOCoCAA. Guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of thyroid nodules and differentiated thyroid carcinoma. Chin J Nucl Med Mol Imaging, 2013, 33(2): 96-115

[25] Engineers IoEaE. IEEE Recommended Practice for Measurements and Computations of Electric, Magnetic, and Electromagnetic Fields with Respect to Human Exposure to Such Fields, 0 Hz to 100 kHz. IEEE Std C95.3.1™-2010, 20101-101

[26] AminAI, HegazyNM, IbrahimKS, et al.. Thyroid Hormone Indices in Computer Workers with Emphasis on the Role of Zinc Supplementation. Open Access Maced J Med Sci, 2016, 4(2): 296-301

[27] RajkovicV, MatavuljM, GledicD, et al.. Evaluation of rat thyroid gland morphophysiological status after three months exposure to 50 Hz electromagnetic field. Tissue Cell, 2003, 35(3): 223-231

[28] RajkovicV, MatavuljM, JohanssonO. Studies on the synergistic effects of extremely low-frequency magnetic fields and the endocrine-disrupting compound atrazine on the thyroid gland. Int J Radiat Biol, 2010, 86(12): 1050-1060

[29] AslJF, LarijaniB, ZakerkishM, et al.. The possible global hazard of cell phone radiation on thyroid cells and hormones: a systematic review of evidences. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int, 2019, 26(18): 18017-18031

[30] AlkayyaliT, OchubaO, SrivastavaK, et al.. An Exploration of the Effects of Radiofrequency Radiation Emitted by Mobile Phones and Extremely Low Frequency Radiation on Thyroid Hormones and Thyroid Gland Histopathology. Cureus, 2021, 13(8): e17329

[31] RosadoMM, SimkóM, MattssonMO, et al.. Immune-Modulating Perspectives for Low Frequency Electromagnetic Fields in Innate Immunity. Front Public Health, 2018, 6: 85

[32] Bagheri HosseinabadiM, KhanjaniN, MirzaiiM, et al.. DNA damage from long-term occupational exposure to extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields among power plant workers. Mutat Res, 2019, 846: 403079

[33] ZhangY, LaiJ, RuanG, et al.. Meta-analysis of extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields and cancer risk: a pooled analysis of epidemiologic studies. Environ Int, 2016, 88: 36-43

[34] KatoI, YoungA, LiuJ, et al.. Electric Blanket Use and Risk of Thyroid Cancer in the Women’s Health Initiative Observational Cohort. Women Health, 2015, 55(7): 829-841

[35] WangH, TangX, LiW, et al.. Enhanced osteogenesis of bone marrow stem cells cultured on hydroxyapatite/collagen I scaffold in the presence of low-frequency magnetic field. J Mater Sci Mater Med, 2019, 30(8): 89

[36] RossCL, AngDC, Almeida-PoradaG. Targeting Mesenchymal Stromal Cells/Pericytes (MSCs) With Pulsed Electromagnetic Field (PEMF) Has the Potential to Treat Rheumatoid Arthritis. Front Immunol, 2019, 10: 266

[37] VadalàM, Morales-MedinaJC, VallelungaA, et al.. Mechanisms and therapeutic effectiveness of pulsed electromagnetic field therapy in oncology. Cancer Med, 2016, 5(11): 3128-3139