Multisensory Exercise Improves Balance in People with Balance Disorders: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Objective

To examine the effect of multisensory exercise on balance disorders.

Methods

PubMed, Scopus and Web of Science were searched to identify eligible studies published before January 1, 2020. Eligible studies included randomized control trials (RCTs), non-randomized studies, case-control studies, and cohort studies. The methodological quality of the included studies was evaluated using JBI Critical Appraisal Checklists for RCTs and for Quasi-Experimental Studies by two researchers independently. A narrative synthesis of intervention characteristics and health-related outcomes was performed.

Results

A total of 11 non-randomized studies and 9 RCTs were eligible, including 667 participants. The results supported our assumption that multisensory exercise improved balance in people with balance disorders. All of the 20 studies were believed to be of high or moderate quality.

Conclusion

Our study confirmed that multisensory exercise was effective in improving balance in people with balance disorders. Multisensory exercises could lower the risk of fall and enhance confidence level to improve the quality of life. Further research is needed to investigate the optimal strategy of multisensory exercises and explore the underlying neural and molecular mechanisms of balance improvement brought by multisensory exercises.

Keywords

multisensory exercises / multisensory integration / balance / systematic review

References

[1] AlexanderNB. Postural control in older adults. J Am Geriatr Soc, 1994, 42(1): 93-108

[2] WoollacottMH, TangPF. Balance control during walking in the older adult: research and its implications. Phys Ther, 1997, 77(6): 646-660

[3] GoldiePA, BachTM, EvansOM. Force platform measures for evaluating postural control: reliability and validity. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 1989, 70(7): 510-517

[4] DistefanoLJ, ClarkMA, PaduaDA. Evidence supporting balance training in healthy individuals: a systemic review. J Strength Cond Res, 2009, 23(9): 2718-2731

[5] Yim-ChiplisPK, TalbotLA. Defining and measuring balance in adults. Biol Res Nurs, 2000, 1(4): 321-331

[6] JhJTaylorJ, HolmesG, WalsheFMRSelected writings of John Hughlings Jackson, 1932, London, Hodder and Stoughton: 2

[7] NuttJG, MarsdenCD, ThompsonPD. Human walking and higher-level gait disorders, particularly in the elderly. Neurology, 1993, 43(2): 268-279

[8] BergK. Balance and its measure in the elderly: A review. Physiotherapy Canada, 1989, 41(5): 240-246

[9] RossatA, FantinoB, NitenbergC, et al.. Risk factors for falling in community-dwelling older adults: which of them are associated with the recurrence of falls?. J Nutr Health Aging, 2010, 14(9): 787-791

[10] WHO (2018) Falls. WHO Fact Sheets. https://www.who.int/en/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/falls

[11] PellicerMG, LusarAC, CasanovasJM, et al.. Effectiveness of a multimodal exercise rehabilitation program on walking capacity and functionality after a stroke. J Exerc Rehabil, 2017, 13(6): 666-675

[12] CohenHS, KimballKT. Decreased ataxia and improved balance after vestibular rehabilitation. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 2004, 130(4): 418-425

[13] HuMH, WoollacottMH. Multisensory training of standing balance in older adults: I. Postural stability and one-leg stance balance. J Gerontol, 1994, 49(2): M52-61

[14] CostaPB, GravesBS, WhitehurstM, et al.. The acute effects of different durations of static stretching on dynamic balance performance. J Strength Cond Res, 2009, 23(1): 141-147

[15] American College of Sports M. American College of Sports Medicine position stand. Progression models in resistance training for healthy adults. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 2009, 41(3): 687-708

[16] LamFM, HuangMZ, LiaoLR, et al.. Physical exercise improves strength, balance, mobility, and endurance in people with cognitive impairment and dementia: a systematic review. J Physiother, 2018, 64(1): 4-15

[17] WhitneySL, AlghwiriAA, AlghadirA. An overview of vestibular rehabilitation. Handb Clin Neurol, 2016, 137: 187-205

[18] HallCD, CoxLC. The role of vestibular rehabilitation in the balance disorder patient. Otolaryngol Clin North Am, 2009, 42(1): 161-169

[19] CruzJ, MarquesA, BarbosaAL, et al.. Effects of a motor and multisensory-based approach on residents with moderate-to-severe dementia. Am J Alzheimers Dis Other Demen, 2011, 26(4): 282-289

[20] AllisonLK, KiemelT, JekaJJ. Sensory-Challenge Balance Exercises Improve Multisensory Reweighting in Fall-Prone Older Adults. J Neurol Phys Ther, 2018, 42(2): 84-93

[21] SteinBE, MeredithMA. Multisensory integration. Neural and behavioral solutions for dealing with stimuli from different sensory modalities. Ann N Y Acad Sci, 1990, 608: 51-65 discussion −70

[22] Barry E. Stein BaR. Neural development of multisensory integration. Multisensory Perception, 2020:57–87

[23] TjernströmF, ZurO, JahnK. Current concepts and future approaches to vestibular rehabilitation. J Neurol, 2016, 263(Suppl 1): S65-70

[24] LeeAC, MageeDJ. Multisensory Training for Postural Sway Control in Non-Injured Elderly Females. J Fundam Appl Sci, 2017, 9: 1116-1131

[25] BayoukJF, BoucherJP, LerouxA. Balance training following stroke: effects of task-oriented exercises with and without altered sensory input. Int J Rehabil Res, 2006, 29(1): 51-59

[26] MoherD, LiberatiA, TetzlaffJ, et al.. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med, 2009, 6(7): e1000097

[27] Tufanaru CMZ, Aromataris E, Campbell J, et al. In: Aromataris E, Munn Z, eds. Chapter 3: Systematic reviews of effectiveness. Australia: 2020. Available from https://synthesismanual.jbi.global

[28] FungA, LaiEC, LeeBC. Usability and Validation of the Smarter Balance System: An Unsupervised Dynamic Balance Exercises System for Individuals With Parkinson’s Disease. IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng, 2018, 26(4): 798-806

[29] YelnikAP, Le BretonF, ColleFM, et al.. Rehabilitation of balance after stroke with multisensorial training: a single-blind randomized controlled study. Neurorehabil Neural Repair, 2008, 22(5): 468-476

[30] MccoySW, JirikowicT, PriceR, et al.. Virtual Sensorimotor Balance Training for Children With Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders: Feasibility Study. Phys Ther, 2015, 95(11): 1569-1581

[31] MoreiraNB, GonçalvesG, Da SilvaT, et al.. Multisensory exercise programme improves cognition and functionality in institutionalized older adults: A randomized control trial. Physiother Res Int, 2018, 23(2): e1708

[32] AiCL, SciencesA. Multisensory training for postural sway control in non-injured elderly females. J Fundam Appl Sci, 2017, 9(6S): 1116-1131

[33] MissaouiB, ThoumieP. Balance training in ataxic neuropathies. Effects on balance and gait parameters. Gait Posture, 2013, 38(3): 471-476

[34] KristinsdottirEK, BaldursdottirB. Effect of multi-sensory balance training for unsteady elderly people: pilot study of the “Reykjavik model”. Disabil Rehabil, 2014, 36(14): 1211-1218

[35] O’callaghanG, O’dowdA, StapletonJ, et al.. Changes in Regional Brain Grey-Matter Volume Following Successful Completion of a Sensori-Motor Intervention Targeted at Healthy and Fall-Prone Older Adults. Multisens Res, 2018, 31(3–4): 317-344

[36] AlfieriFM, RibertoM, GatzLS, et al.. Functional mobility and balance in community-dwelling elderly submitted to multisensory versus strength exercises. Clin Interv Aging, 2010, 5: 181-185

[37] HackneyME, HallCD, EchtKV, et al.. Multimodal Exercise Benefits Mobility in Older Adults With Visual Impairment: A Preliminary Study. J Aging Phys Act, 2015, 23(4): 630-639

[38] KuttyNAM, MajidaNJDC. Effects of Multisensory Training on Balance and Gait in Persons with Type 2 Diabetes: A Randomised Controlled Trial. Disab CBR Inclus Develop, 2013, 24(2): 79-97

[39] KaraB, KahramanT, TomrukMS, et al.. The Effects of a Postural Balance Training Program on Balance, Gait and Health-Related Quality of Life in Patients with Essential Tremor. Turk Noroloji Dergisi, 2018, 2018(1): 43-48

[40] DavisJR, CarpenterMG, TschanzR, et al.. Trunk sway reductions in young and older adults using multi-modal biofeedback. Gait Posture, 2010, 31(4): 465-472

[41] AllumJH, CarpenterMG, HorslenBC, et al.. Improving impaired balance function: real-time versus carry-over effects of prosthetic feedback. Annu Int Conf IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 2011, 2011: 1314-1318

[42] HafströmA, MalmströmEM, TerdènJ, et al.. Improved Balance Confidence and Stability for Elderly After 6 Weeks of a Multimodal Self-Administered Balance-Enhancing Exercise Program: A Randomized Single Arm Crossover Study. Gerontol Geriatr Med, 2016, 2: 2333721416644149

[43] KimJ, SonJ, KoN, et al.. Unsupervised virtual reality-based exercise program improves hip muscle strength and balance control in older adults: a pilot study. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 2013, 94(5): 937-943

[44] BellomoRG, IodiceP, SavoiaV, et al.. Balance and posture in the elderly: an analysis of a sensorimotor rehabilitation protocol. Int J Immunopathol Pharmacol, 2009, 22(3 Suppl): 37-44

[45] LimSB, HorslenBC, DavisJR, et al.. Benefits of multi-session balance and gait training with multi-modal biofeedback in healthy older adults. Gait Posture, 2016, 47: 10-17

[46] NematollahiA, KamaliF, GhanbariA, et al.. Improving Balance in Older People: A Double-Blind Randomized Clinical Trial of Three Modes of Balance Training. J Aging Phys Act, 2016, 24(2): 189-195

[47] NashnerLM, PetersJF. Dynamic posturography in the diagnosis and management of dizziness and balance disorders. Neurol Clin, 1990, 8(2): 331-349

[48] PodsiadloD, RichardsonS. The timed “Up & Go”: a test of basic functional mobility for frail elderly persons. J Am Geriatr Soc., 1991, 32: 142-148

[49] BergK, Wood-DauphineeS, WilliamsJI, et al.. Measuring balance in the elderly: preliminary development of an instrument. Physiotherapy Canada, 1989, 41(2): 304-311

[50] YelnikA, BonanI. Clinical tools for assessing balance disorders. Neurophysiol Clin, 2008, 38(6): 439-445

[51] PowellLE, MyersAM. The Activities-specific Balance Confidence (ABC) Scale. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci, 1995, 50a(1): M28-34

[52] ArkadirD, LouisED. The balance and gait disorder of essential tremor: what does this mean for patients?. Ther Adv Neurol Disord, 2013, 6(4): 229-236

[53] PetersR. Ageing and the brain. Postgrad Med J, 2006, 82(964): 84-88

[54] RosanoC, AizensteinH, BrachJ, et al.. Special article: gait measures indicate underlying focal gray matter atrophy in the brain of older adults. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci, 2008, 63(12): 1380-1388

[55] Stein BeMMThe Merging of the Senses, 1993, Cambridge, MA, MIT Press

[56] GhazanfarAA, SchroederCE. Is neocortex essentially multisensory?. Trends Cogn Sci, 2006, 10(6): 278-285

[57] JenkinsHA, FurmanJM, GulyaAJ, et al.. Dysequilibrium of aging. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 1989, 100(4): 272-282

[58] KatsarkasA. Dizziness in aging: a retrospective study of 1194 cases. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 1994, 110(3): 296-301

[59] WoollacottM, Shumway-CookA. Attention and the control of posture and gait: a review of an emerging area of research. Gait Posture, 2002, 16(1): 1-14

[60] HorakFB, NashnerLM, DienerHC. Postural strategies associated with somatosensory and vestibular loss. Exp Brain Res, 1990, 82(1): 167-177

[61] ChoiI, LeeJY, LeeSH. Bottom-up and top-down modulation of multisensory integration. Curr Opin Neurobiol, 2018, 52: 115-122

[62] TalsmaD. Predictive coding and multisensory integration: an attentional account of the multisensory mind. Front Integr Neurosci, 2015, 9: 19

[63] TalsmaD, SenkowskiD, Soto-FaracoS, et al.. The multifaceted interplay between attention and multisensory integration. Trends Cogn Sci, 2010, 14(9): 400-410

[64] Le MerreP, EsmaeiliV, CharriereE, et al.. Reward-Based Learning Drives Rapid Sensory Signals in Medial Prefrontal Cortex and Dorsal Hippocampus Necessary for Goal-Directed Behavior. Neuron, 2018, 97(1): 83-91 e5

[65] CarasML, SanesDH. Top-down modulation of sensory cortex gates perceptual learning. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 2017, 114(37): 9972-9977

[66] LiW, PiechV, GilbertCD. Perceptual learning and top-down influences in primary visual cortex. Nat Neurosci, 2004, 7(6): 651-657

[67] ReynoldsJH, ChelazziL. Attentional modulation of visual processing. Annu Rev Neurosci, 2004, 27: 611-647

[68] AnsonE, JekaJ. Perspectives on Aging Vestibular Function. Front Neurol, 2015, 6: 269

[69] LordSR. Visual risk factors for falls in older people. Age Ageing, 2006, 35(Suppl 2): ii42-ii5

[70] ZhouL, ZhouW, ZhangS, et al.. BDNF signaling in the rat cerebello-vestibular pathway during vestibular compensation: BDNF signaling in vestibular compensation. FEBS J, 2015, 282(18): 3579-3591

[71] ZhouW, ZhouLQ, ShiH, et al.. Expression of glycine receptors and gephyrin in rat medial vestibular nuclei and flocculi following unilateral labyrinthectomy. Int J Mol Med, 2016, 38(5): 1481-1489

[72] RogersME, RogersNL, TakeshimaN, et al.. Methods to assess and improve the physical parameters associated with fall risk in older adults. Prev Med, 2003, 36(3): 255-264

[73] BeanJF, VoraA, FronteraWR. Benefits of exercise for community-dwelling older adults. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 2004, 85(7): S31-42 Suppl 3quiz S3–4

[74] NagyE, Feher-KissA, BarnaiM, et al.. Postural control in elderly subjects participating in balance training. Eur J Appl Physiol, 2007, 100(1): 97-104

[75] ShafferSW, HarrisonAL. Aging of the somatosensory system: a translational perspective. Phys Ther, 2007, 87(2): 193-207

[76] ZhangSL, ZhuYT, TianE, et al.. Impaired Multisensory Integration Predisposes the Elderly People to Fall: A Systematic Review. Front Neurosci, 2020, 14: 411