Acceptability of physical examination by male doctors in medical care: Taking breast palpation as an example

Abstract

In this study, we conducted an investigation among medical workers, patients and college students concerning their acceptability of breast palpation performed by male doctors (hereinafter referred to as “acceptability”, or “the examination”, respectively, if not otherwise indicated), to get the information about their acceptability and reasons for accepting or declining the examination among the three population. A questionnaire investigation was conducted in 500 patients with breast diseases, 700 students of medical colleges, and 280 medical workers working in hospitals. The subjects were asked to choose between two options: accept or do not accept (the examination). The subjects were asked to fill out the questionnaire forms on free and anonymous basis and the questionnaire forms were collected on spot, immediately after completion. The questionnaires collected were coded, sorted out and checked. Data of the eligible questionnaires were input into Epidata software and analyzed by SPSS. Upon the establishment of the database, the intra-group data were tested by utilizing χ² test. Among 1480 questionnaires, 1293 (90.41%) questionnaires were retrieved. Our results showed that 56.78% of patients reported that they could accept breast palpation by male doctors. About 59.66% of medical staff expressed their acceptance of the examination, but only 35.03% of students said the examination. On the basis of this study, we were led to conclude that the examination is not well accepted by different populations, and therefore, (1) medical professionals and administrators should pay attention to the gender-related ethics in their practice and the feeling of patients should be respected when medical examinations involve private or sensitive body parts; (2) to this end, related departments should be properly staffed with doctors of both sexes, and this is especially true of the departments involving the examination or treatment of private or sensitive body parts; (3) health education should, among other things, include helping female patients to overcome the fear and anxiety in such examinations. This is of great importance since some women may miss the opportunity to get timely diagnosis.

Keywords

breast palpation / breast examination / patient-selecting-doctor / medical ethics / acceptability

References

[1] The Ministry of Health, the State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Opinions on implementing “patient- selecting-doctor” to promote internal reform of medical institutions. Chin Rural Health Manage (Chinese), 2000,20(8):13

[2] LVY. Present status of “patient-selecting-doctor”. J Psychol Doct (Chinese), 2012, 6: 416-417

[3] WangXY. Ethics significance of “patient-selecting- doctor”. Chin Med Ethics (Chinese), 2001, 14(2): 32-33

[4] HuSJ. Advantages and disadvantages of “patient- selecting-doctor”. Chin Med Ethics (Chinese), 2002, 15(1): 44-45

[5] YinLY, FuBE, LiFY. Efficacy of propofol in painless artificial abortion: an analysis of 5600 cases. Guide Chin Med: J Med (Chinese), 20052-3

[6] HeB, ZhouWW. Effects of the anesthetist gender on propofol dosage in painless abortion. Mod Med Health (Chinese), 2012, 28(6): 855-856

[7] CuiY. Adverse effects of propofol in painless artificial abortion. Hainan Medical J (Chinese), 2009, 20(3): 64-65

[8] AlehagenS, WijmaB, LundbergU, et al. . Fear, pain and stress hormones during childbirth. J Psychosom Obstet Gynaecol, 2005, 26(3): 153-165 PMID: 16295513

[9] TangY, NieX, ZhuGQ. Influence of preoperative anxiety on target controlled infusion anesthesia with propofol and fentanyl in patients undergoing painless artificial abortion. J Clin Anesthesiol (Chinese), 2009, 25(2): 140-141

[10] Anhui Med J (in Chinese), 2011, 32(9

[11] DingSM, ZhangJE. Pressure during molybdenum target radiography of women after breast augmentation. J Practical Radiol (Chinese), 2007, 2311): 1524-1525

[12] BrickerSRW. Hallucinations after propofol. Anaesthesia, 1988, 43(2): 170-171

[13] Saint-MaurieeC. Propofol in pediatric anesthesia. Cah Anesthesiol, 1991, 39(6): 411-420

[14] GongYL. Social medicine (Chinese), 2001, People’s Medical Publishing House, Beijing, 11-25

[15] WangZY, XuXH, ZuoCC, et al. . How to understand and carry out “patient-selecting-doctor”. Chin Health Serv Manage (Chinese), 2001, 3: 147-149

[16] LiuJ. Face-to-face interaction between female patients and male doctors. Health Horizon, 2005, 2: 36-37

[17] GaoH, HeZZ. “Patient-selecting-doctor” mode is important for the development of hospitals. Chin Health Serv Manage, 2001, 22(3): l6-l7

[18] TaoJ, CaiQH. Thinking “patient-selecting-doctor” under new circumstances. Chin Hosp Manage (Chinese), 2011, 31(5): 11-12

[19] YuJ, ZhangMX, JinJG, et al. . Deepening and perfecting the “patient-selecting-doctor” mode. Chin Health Serv Manage (Chinese), 2002, 18(6): 340-342

[20] WuYM. Analysis of “patient-selecting-doctor”. Mod J Integr Tradit Chin West Med, 2002, 11(15): 1526-1527

[21] HanJ, ZhengPY. Analysis of patient mindset after “patient- selecting-doctor” and triage skills. J Qilu Nursing (Chinese), 2001, 7(6): 474-475

[22] Ou YX. Rational thinking in “doctor-selecting-patient”. Chin Lawyer (Chinese), 2002(4):63–64

[23] ChenXL, ZhangSC. Some problems in implementation of “doctor-selecting-patient”. Chin Health Serv Manage (Chinese), 2001, 17(2): 82-83

[24] XuYH. Analysis of the pros and cons of “patient- selecting-doctor” and the countermeasures. Chin J Hosp Adm (Chinese), 2001, 17(6): 337-338

[25] YaoW. Analysis of the disadvantages of “patient-selecting- doctor” and the countermeasures. Soft Sci Health (Chinese), 2000, 14(6): 292-293

[26] ShenK, YaoW. Disadvantages of “patient-selecting-doctor” and the coping strategies. Chin Health Serv Manage (Chinese), 2001, 17(11): 660-661

[27] Chin Med Ethics (Chinese), 2002, 15(5

[28] ZhangT. Informed consent right of patients and particular intervention of doctors. Chin Med Ethics (Chinese), 2001, 2: 8-10

[29] FuJ. Relationship between informed consent right of patients and leading decision-making power of physicians. Med Philos (Chinese), 2003, 246): 43-45

[30] XiaYY. Misunderstanding of informed consent right from the perspective of the history of informed consent right. Soft Sci Health, 2007, 21(2): 155-157

[31] LuoJY, ZengR. “Doctor-selecting-patient” and role conversion of doctors. J Chin Physician (Chinese), 2004, 6(10): 1