Progress in use of surfactant in nearly static conditions in natural gas hydrate formation

Abstract

Natural gas hydrate is an alternative energy source with a great potential for development. The addition of surfactants has been found to have practical implications on the acceleration of hydrate formation in the industrial sector. In this paper, the mechanisms of different surfactants that have been reported to promote hydrate formation are summarized. Besides, the factors influencing surfactant-promoted hydrate formation, including the type, concentration, and structure of the surfactant, are also described. Moreover, the effects of surfactants on the formation of hydrate in pure water, brine, porous media, and systems containing multiple surfactants are discussed. The synergistic or inhibitory effects of the combinations of these additives are also analyzed. Furthermore, the process of establishing kinetic and thermodynamic models to simulate the factors affecting the formation of hydrate in surfactant-containing solutions is illustrated and summarized.

Keywords

gas hydrate / kinetic hydrate promoter / compounding / model / surfactant / mechanism

References

[1] Semenov M Y, Ivanova I K, Koryakina V V. Peculiarities of natural gas hydrate formation from ice in reactors under high pressure. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 2018, 193: 012061

[2] Bhade P, Phirani J. Effect of geological layers on hydrate dissociation in natural gas hydrate reservoirs. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2015, 26: 1549–1560

[3] Ding L, Shi B, Liu Y, Song S, Wang W, Wu H, Gong J. Rheology of natural gas hydrate slurry: effect of hydrate agglomeration and deposition. Fuel, 2019, 239: 126–137

[4] Kumar A, Bhattacharjee G, Kulkarni B D, Kumar R. Role of surfactants in promoting gas hydrate formation. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 2015, 54(49): 12217–12232

[5] Pan Z, Liu Z, Zhang Z, Shang L, Ma S. Effect of silica sand size and saturation on methane hydrate formation in the presence of SDS. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2018, 56: 266–280

[6] Pan Z, Wang Z, Zhang Z, Ma G, Zhang L, Huang Y. Natural gas hydrate formation dynamics in a diesel water-in-oil emulsion system. Petroleum Science and Technology, 2018, 36(20): 1649–1656

[7] Sloan E D Jr. Fundamental principles and applications of natural gas hydrates. Nature, 2003, 426(6964): 353–359

[8] Yang Y, He Y, Zheng Q. An analysis of the key safety technologies for natural gas hydrate exploitation. Advances in Geo-Energy Research, 2017, 1(2): 100–104

[9] Koryakina V V, Ivanova I K, Semenov M E. Oil emulsions as medium of natural gas hydrate formation. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 2018, 193: 012035

[10] Wang Z, Ma G, Shang L, Zhang L. Effect of a nonionic surfactant on the formation of natural gas hydrate in a diesel emulsion system. Petroleum Science and Technology, 2018, 36(23): 2017–2023

[11] Sun X, Liu D, Chang D, Wang W, Pan Z. Analysis of natural gas hydrate formation in sodium dodecyl sulfate and quartz sand complex system under saline environment. Petroleum Science and Technology, 2018, 36(14): 1073–1079

[12] Koh D Y, Kang H, Lee J W, Park Y, Kim S J, Lee J, Lee J Y, Lee H. Energy-efficient natural gas hydrate production using gas exchange. Applied Energy, 2016, 162: 114–130

[13] Makogon Y F. Natural gas hydrates—a promising source of energy. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2010, 2(1): 49–59

[14] Chaturvedi E, Prasad N, Mandal A. Enhanced formation of methane hydrate using a novel synthesized anionic surfactant for application in storage and transportation of natural gas. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2018, 56: 246–257

[15] Sloan E D. Clathrate hydrates: the other common solid water phase. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 2000, 39(9): 3123–3129

[16] Hosseini M, Ghozatloo A, Shariaty-Niassar M. Effect of CVD graphene on hydrate formation of natural gas. Journal of Nanostructure in Chemistry, 2015, 5(2): 219–226

[17] Khodaverdiloo K R, Erfani A, Peyvandi K, Varaminian F. Synergetic effects of polyacrylamide and nonionic surfactants on preventing gas hydrate formation. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2016, 30: 343–349

[18] Fan S, Yang L, Lang X, et al. Kinetics and thermal analysis of methane hydrate formation in aluminum foam, Chemical Engineering Science, 2012, 82: 185–193

[19] Vysniauskas A, Bishnoi P R. A kinetic study of methane hydrate formation. Chemical Engineering Science, 1983, 38(7): 1061–1072

[20] Ohmura R, Kashiwazaki S, Shiota S, Tsuji H, Mori Y H. Structure-I and structure-H hydrate formation using water spraying. Energy & Fuels, 2002, 16(5): 1141–1147

[21] Kuhs W F, Staykova D K, Salamatin A N. Formation of methane hydrate from polydisperse ice powders. Journal of Physical Chemistry B, 2006, 110(26): 13283–13295

[22] Kezirian M T, Phoenix S L. Natural gas hydrates to enable the safe, sustainable, and economical production of offshore petroleum reserves. In: Offshore Technology Conference, Houston TX, USA, 2018

[23] Wang F, Guo G, Luo S J, Guo R B. Preparation of –SO₃⁻-coated nanopromoters for methane hydrate formation: effects of the existence pattern of –SO₃⁻ groups on the promotion efficiency. Journal of Materials Chemistry. A, Materials for Energy and Sustainability, 2017, 5(6): 2640–2648

[24] Song Y M, Wang F, Guo G, Luo S J, Guo R B. Amphiphilic-polymer-coated carbon nanotubes as promoters for methane hydrate formation. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering, 2017, 5(10): 9271–9278

[25] Link D D, Ladner E P, Elseni H A, Taylor C E. Formation and dissociation studies for optimizing the uptake of methane by methane hydrates. Fluid Phase Equilibria, 2003, 211(1): 1–10

[26] Israelachvili J N, McGuiggan P M. Forces between surfaces in liquids. Science, 1988, 241(4867): 795–800

[27] Zhang P, Wu Q, Mu C, Chen X. Nucleation mechanisms of CO₂ hydrate reflected by gas solubility. Scientific Reports, 2018, 8(1): 10441–10452

[28] Kalogerakis N, Jamaluddin A K M, Dholabhaii P D, Bishnoi P R. Effect of surfactants on hydrate formation kinetics. In: SPE International Symposium on Oilfield Chemistry, New Orleans, LA, LSA, 1993

[29] Lo C, Zhang J, Somasundaran P, Lee J W. Investigations of surfactant effects on gas hydrate formation via infrared spectroscopy. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2012, 376(1): 173–176

[30] Tang J, Zeng D, Wang C, Chen Y, He L, Cai N. Study on the influence of SDS and THF on hydrate-based gas separation performance. Chemical Engineering Research & Design, 2013, 91(9): 1777–1782

[31] Mel'nikov V P, Nesterov A N, Feklistov V V. Formation of gas hydrates in the presence of additives consisting of surface-active substances. Chemistry in the Interests of Sustainable Development, 1998, 6: 97–102 (in Russian)

[32] Tajima H, Kiyono F, Yamasaki A. Direct observation of the effect of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) on the gas hydrate formation process in a static mixer. Energy & Fuels, 2010, 24(1): 432–438

[33] Okutani K, Kuwabara Y, Mori Y H. Surfactant effects on hydrate formation in an unstirred gas/liquid system: amendments to the previous study using HFC-32 and sodium dodecyl sulfate. Chemical Engineering Science, 2007, 62(14): 3858–3860

[34] Asaoka T, Ikeda K. Observation of the growth characteristics of gas hydrate in the quiescent-type formation method using surfactant. Journal of Crystal Growth, 2017, 478: 1–8

[35] Zhong Y, Rogers R E. Surfactant effects on gas hydrate formation. Chemical Engineering Science, 2000, 55(19): 4175–4187

[36] Irvin G, Li S, Simmons B, John V, McPHERSON G A R Y, Max M, Pellenbarg R. Control of gas hydrate formation using surfactant systems: underlying concepts and new applications. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2000, 912(1): 515–526

[37] Zhang B, Wu Q, Sun D. Effect of surfactant Tween on induction time of gas hydrate formation. Journal of China University of Mining and Technology, 2008, 18(1): 18–21

[38] Bhattacharjee G, Kushwaha O S, Kumar A, Khan M Y, Patel J N, Kumar R. Effects of micellization on growth kinetics of methane hydrate. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 2017, 56(13): 3687–3698

[39] Di Profio P, Arca S, Germani R, Savelli G. Surfactant promoting effects on clathrate hydrate formation: are micelles really involved? Chemical Engineering Science, 2005, 60(15): 4141–4145

[40] Zhang J S, Lee S, Lee J W. Does SDS micellize under methane hydrate-forming conditions below the normal Krafft point? Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2007, 315(1): 313–318

[41] Choudhary N, Hande V R, Roy S, Chakrabarty S, Kumar R. Effect of sodium dodecyl sulfate surfactant on methane hydrate formation: a molecular dynamics study. Journal of Physical Chemistry B, 2018, 122(25): 6536–6542

[42] Meng H, Guo R, Wang F, Luo S, Xu H. Effect of different surfactants on methane hydrate formation. Renewable Energy Resources, 2017, 3: 329–336 (in Chinese)

[43] Qin X, Wu Q, Zhang B. Effect of sodium dodecyl sulfate on the process of methane hydrate formation. Chemistry (Weinheim an der Bergstrasse, Germany), 2006, 69(7): 519–523

[44] Koh C A, Westacott R E, Zhang W, Hirachand K, Creek J L, Soper A K. Mechanisms of gas hydrate formation and inhibition. Fluid Phase Equilibria, 2002: 143–151

[45] Wu M, Wang S, Liu H. A study on inhibitors for the prevention of hydrate form ation in gas transmission pipeline. Journal of Natural Gas Chemistry, 2007, 16(1): 81–85

[46] Chong Z R, Yang S H B, Babu P, Linga P, Li X S. Review of natural gas hydrates as an energy resource: prospects and challenges. Applied Energy, 2016, 162: 1633–1652

[47] Karaaslan U, Uluneye E, Parlaktuna M. Effect of an anionic surfactant on different type of hydrate structures. Journal of Petroleum Science Engineering, 2002, 35(1–2): 49–57

[48] Liu Z, Song Y, Liu W, Lang C, Zhao J, Li Y. Formation of methane hydrate in oil-water emulsion governed by the hydrophilic and hydrophobic properties of non-ionic surfactants. Energy & Fuels, 2019, 33(6): 5777–5784

[49] Mankowich A M. Physicochemical properties of surfactants. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry, 1953, 45(12): 2759–2766

[50] Wang L, Wang S L, Kang T T. Surfactant effect of promoting research on hydrate formation. Advanced Materials Research, 2015, 1092–1093: 220–225

[51] Xie Y, Yang L, Liu D, Meng Y. Research in surfactant effect on promoting gas hydrates formation. Journal of Refrigeration, 2016, 3: 35–41 (in Chinese)

[52] keshavarz Moraveji M, Ghaffarkhah A, Sadeghi A. Effect of three representative surfactants on methane hydrate formation rate and induction time. Egyptian Journal of Petroleum, 2017, 26(2): 331–339

[53] Rauh F, Pfeiffer J, Mizaikoff B. Infrared spectroscopy on the role of surfactants during methane hydrate formation. RSC Advances, 2017, 7(62): 39109–39117

[54] Zhang C S, Fan S S, Liang D Q, Guo K H. Effect of additives on formation of natural gas hydrate. Fuel, 2004, 83(16): 2115–2121

[55] Zhou S D, Yu Y S, Zhang X P, Wang S L, Zhang G Z. Investigation on the effect of surfactant on surface tension of liquids for gas hydrate formation. Natural Gas Chemical Industry, 2013, 38: 42–45

[56] Karaaslan U, Parlaktuna M. Surfactants as hydrate promoters? Energy & Fuels, 2000, 14(5): 1103–1107

[57] Karaaslan U, Parlaktuna M. Promotion effect of polymers and surfactants on hydrate formation rate. Energy & Fuels, 2002, 16(6): 1413–1416

[58] Wang F, Jia Z Z, Luo S J, Fu S F, Wang L, Shi X S, Wang C S, Guo R B. Effects of different anionic surfactants on methane hydrate formation. Chemical Engineering Science, 2015, 137: 896–903

[59] Okutani K, Kuwabara Y, Mori Y H. Surfactant effects on hydrate formation in an unstirred gas/liquid system: an experimental study using methane and sodium alkyl sulfates. Chemical Engineering Science, 2008, 63(1): 183–194

[60] Daimaru T, Yamasaki A, Yanagisawa Y. Effect of surfactant carbon chain length on hydrate formation kinetics. Journal of Petroleum Science Engineering, 2007, 56(1–3): 89–96

[61] Zhao J L, Ma G Y, Pan Z. Influences of alkyl polyglucoside on formation of methane hydrate. Chemical Engineering (China), 2018, 9: 17–22 (in Chinese)

[62] Posteraro D, Ivall J, Maric M, Servio P. New insights into the effect of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) concentration on methane hydrate growth. 2. Liquid phase methane mole fraction. Chemical Engineering Science, 2015, 126: 91–98

[63] Zhang L, Zhang X, Wang S, Zhou S, Wang L. Effect of composite surfactant on surface tension of gas hydrate formation liquid. Petrochemical Technology, 2013, 42: 1224–1228 (in Chinese)

[64] Verrett J, Servio P. Evaluating surfactants and their effect on methane mole fraction during hydrate growth. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 2012, 51(40): 13144–13149

[65] Salako O, Lo C, Couzis A, Somasundaran P, Lee J W. Adsorption of Gemini surfactants onto clathrate hydrates. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2013, 412: 1–6

[66] Khokhar A A, Gudmundsson J S, Sloan E D. Gas storage in structure H hydrates. Fluid Phase Equilibria, 1998, 150–151: 383–392

[67] Liu J, Ma G Y, Pan Z, Shang L Y, Yang F, Tan F Z. Experiment on formation and decomposition of methane hydrate. Chemical Engineering, 2015, 43: 35–40 (in Chinese)

[68] Ke W, Svartaas T M, Kvaløy J T, Kosberg B R. Inhibition–promotion: dual effects of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) on structure-II hydrate nucleation. Energy & Fuels, 2016, 30(9): 7646–7655

[69] ZareNezhad B, Mottahedin M, Varaminian F. Effects of process variables on the initial gas hydrate formation rate: the case of ethane hydrate formation in the absence or presence of SDS kinetic promoter. Journal of Molecular Liquids, 2014, 198: 57–62

[70] ZareNezhad B, Mottahedin M, Varaminian F. Experimental and theoretical investigations on the enhancement of methane gas hydrate formation rate by using the kinetic additives. Petroleum Science and Technology, 2015, 33(8): 857–864

[71] Ganji H, Manteghian H M, Rahimi Mofrad. Effect of mixed compounds on methane hydrate formation and dissociation rates and storage capacity. Fuel Processing Technology, 2007, 88(9): 891–895

[72] Ganji H, Manteghian M, Sadaghiani zadeh K, Omidkhah M R, Rahimi Mofrad H. Effect of different surfactants on methane hydrate formation rate, stability and storage capacity. Fuel, 2007, 86(3): 434–441

[73] ZareNezhad B, Varaminian F. A unified approach for description of gas hydrate formation kinetics in the presence of kinetic promoters in gas hydrate converters. Energy Conversion and Management, 2013, 73: 144–149

[74] Shi Q, Wang S, Yu H, Zhao S. Study on surfactivity of natural gas hydrate solution. Natural Gas Chemical Industry, 2011, 36(4): 17–20 (in Chinese)

[75] Sun Z, Wang R, Ma R, Guo K, Fan S. Natural gas storage in hydrates with the presence of promoters. Energy Conversion and Management, 2003, 44(17): 2733–2742

[76] Sun Z G, Ma R, Wang R Z, Guo K H, Fa S S. Experimental studying of additives effects on gas in hydrates. Energy & Fuels, 2003, 17(5): 1180–1185

[77] Zhou S D, Wang S L, Zhang G Z. Effect of different surfactants on gas hydrate formation. Advanced Materials Research, 2013, 645: 146–149

[78] Du J, Li H, Wang L. Effects of ionic surfactants on methane hydrate formation kinetics in a static system. Advanced Powder Technology, 2014, 25(4): 1227–1233

[79] Jiménez-Ángeles F, Firoozabadi A. Hydrophobic hydration and the effect of NaCl salt in the adsorption of hydrocarbons and surfactants on clathrate hydrates. ACS Central Science, 2018, 4(7): 820–831

[80] Eastman M J. Surfactant enhanced methane hydrate growth in quiescent sodium chloride solutions. Disseration for the Master’s Degree. Irvine: University of California, Irvine, 2016

[81] Zhang Q, Wu Q, Zhang H. Effect of propane and NaCl-SDS solution on nucleation process of mine gas hydrate. Journal of Chemistry, 2017: 1059109

[82] Delroisse H, Torré J P, Dicharry C. Effect of a hydrophilic cationic surfactant on cyclopentane hydrate crystal growth at the water/cyclopentane interface. Crystal Growth & Design, 2017, 17(10): 5098–5107

[83] Ma S, Pan Z, Li P, Wu Y, Li B, Kang J, Zhang Z. Experimental study on preparation of natural gas hydrate by crystallization. China Petroleum Processing and Petrochemical Technology, 2017, 19(1): 106–113 (in Chinese)

[84] Abdi-Khanghah M, Adelizadeh M, Naserzadeh Z, Barati H. Methane hydrate formation in the presence of ZnO nanoparticle and SDS: application to transportation and storage. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2018, 54: 120–130

[85] Cui Y, Lu C, Wu M, Peng Y, Yao Y, Luo W. Review of exploration and production technology of natural gas hydrate. Advances in Geo-Energy Research, 2018, (1): 53–62

[86] Rezaei E, Manteghian M, Tamaddondar M. Kinetic study of ethylene hydrate formation in presence of graphene oxide and sodium dodecyl sulfate. Journal of Petroleum Science Engineering, 2016, 147: 857–863

[87] Kakati H, Mandal A, Laik S. Promoting effect of Al₂O₃/ZnO-based nanofluids stabilized by SDS surfactant on CH₄+C₂H₆+C₃H₈ hydrate formation. Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry, 2016, 35: 357–368

[88] Palodkar A V, Jana A K. Fundamental of swapping phenomena in naturally occurring gas hydrates. Scientific Reports, 2018, 8(1): 16563

[89] Yousif M H, Abass H H, Selim M S, Sloan E D. Experimental and theoretical investigation of methane-gas-hydrate dissociation in porous media. SPE Reservoir Engineering, 1991, 6(1): 69–76

[90] Cha S B, Ouar H, Wildeman T R, Sloan E D. A third-surface effect on hydrate formation. Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1988, 92(23): 6492–6494

[91] Xu Z, Zhou Z, Du P, Cheng X. Effects of nano-silica on hydration properties of tricalcium silicate. Construction & Building Mate-rials, 2016, 125: 1169–1177

[92] Dicharry C, Duchateau C, Asbaï H, Broseta D, Torré J P. Carbon dioxide gas hydrate crystallization in porous silica gel particles partially saturated with a surfactant solution. Chemical Enginee-ring Science, 2013, 98: 88–97

[93] Nesterov A N, Reshetnikov A M, Manakov A Y, Adamova T P. Synergistic effect of combination of surfactant and oxide powder on enhancement of gas hydrates nucleation. Journal of Energy Chemistry, 2017, 26(4): 808–814

[94] Liu Z, Pan Z, Zhang Z, Liu P, Shang L, Li B. Effect of porous media and sodium dodecyl sulphate complex system on methane hydrate formation. Energy & Fuels, 2018, 32(5): 5736–5749

[95] Mohammadi A, Manteghian M, Haghtalab A, Mohammadi A H, Rahmati-Abkenar M. Kinetic study of carbon dioxide hydrate formation in presence of silver nanoparticles and SDS. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2014, 237: 387–395

[96] Mohammadi A. Effect of SDS, silver nanoparticles, and SDS plus silver nanoparticles on methane hydrate semicompletion time. Petroleum Science and Technology, 2017, 35(15): 1542–1548

[97] Moraveji M K, Golkaram M, Davarnejad R. Effect of CuO nanoparticle on dissolution of methane in water. Journal of Molecular Liquids, 2013, 180: 45–50

[98] Wang F, Luo S J, Fu S F, Jia Z Z, Dai M, Wang C S, Guo R B. Methane hydrate formation with surfactants fixed on the surface of polystyrene nanospheres. Journal of Materials Chemistry. A, Materials for Energy and Sustainability, 2015, 3(16): 8316–8323

[99] Rogers R, Zhang G, Dearman J, Woods C. Investigations into surfactant/gas hydrate relationship. Journal of Petroleum Science Engineering, 2007, 56(1–3): 82–88

[100] Liu G Q, Wang F, Luo S J, Xu D Y, Guo R B. Enhanced methane hydrate formation with SDS-coated Fe₃O₄ nanoparticles as promoters. Journal of Molecular Liquids, 2017, 230: 315–321

[101] de Deugd R M, Jager M D, de Swaan Arons J. Mixed hydrates of methane and water–soluble hydrocarbons modeling of empirical results. AIChE Journal, 2001, 47(3): 693–704

[102] Kakati H, Mandal A,Laik S. Effect of SDS/THF on thermodynamic and kinetic properties of formation of hydrate from a mixture of gases (CH₄+C₂H₆+C₃H₈) for storing gas as hydrate. Journal of Energy Chemistry, 2016, 25(3): 409–417

[103] Lirio C F D S, Pessoa F L P, Uller A M C. Storage capacity of carbon dioxide hydrates in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and tetrahydrofuran (THF). Chemical Engineering Science, 2013, 96: 118–123

[104] Cai J, Xu C G, Chen Z Y, Li X S. Recovery of methane from coal-bed methane gas mixture via hydrate-based methane separation method by adding anionic surfactants. Energy Sources. Part A, Recovery, Utilization, and Environmental Effects, 2018, 40(9): 1019–1026

[105] Partoon B, Javanmardi J. Effect of mixed thermodynamic and kinetic hydrate promoters on methane hydrate phase boundary and formation kinetics. Journal of Chemical & Engineering Data, 2013, 58(3): 501–509

[106] Fazlali A, Kazemi S A, Keshavarz-Moraveji M, Mohammadi A H. Impact of different surfactants and their mixtures on methane-hydrate formation. Energy Technology (Weinheim), 2013, 1(8): 471–477

[107] Renault-Crispo J S, Servio P. Methane gas hydrate kinetics with mixtures of sodium dodecyl sulphate and tetrabutylammonium bromide. Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, 2018, 96(7): 1620–1626

[108] Mech D, Sangwai J. Investigations on the formation kinetics of semiclathrate hydrate of methane in an aqueous solution of tetra-n-butyl ammonium bromide and sodium dodecyl sulfate in porous media. Energy Sources. Part A, Recovery, Utilization, and Environmental Effects, 2018, 40(20): 2415–2422

[109] Mainusch S, Peters C J, de Swaan Arons J, Javanmardi J, Moshfeghian M. Experimental determination and modeling of methane hydrates in mixtures of acetone and water. Journal of Chemical & Engineering Data, 1997, 42(5): 948–950

[110] Pieroen P A. Gas hydrates–approximate relations between heat of formation, composition and equilibrium temperature lowering by “inhibitors”. Recueil des Travaux Chimiques des Pays-Bas, 2010, 74: 995–1002

[111] Moshfeghian M, Maddox R N. Method predicts hydrates for high-pressure gas streams. Oil & Gas Journal, 1993, 91(35): 78

[112] Zhang J S, Lee S, Lee J W. Kinetics of methane hydrate formation from SDS solution. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 2007, 46(19): 6353–6359

[113] Karimi R, Varaminian F, Izadpanah A A, Mohammadi A H. Effects of different surfactants on the kinetics of ethane-hydrate formation: experimental and modeling studies. Energy Technology (Weinheim), 2013, 1(9): 530–536

[114] Karimi R, Varaminian F, Izadpanah A A. Study of ethane hydrate formation kinetics using the chemical affinity model with and without presence of surfactants. Journal of Non-Equilibrium Thermodynamics, 2014, 39(4): 219–229

[115] Karimi R, Varaminian F, Izadpanah A A, Mohammadi A H. Effects of two surfactants sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and polyoxyethylene (20) sorbitan monopalmitate (Tween^(R)40) on ethane hydrate formation kinetics: experimental and modeling studies. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2014, 21: 193–200

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the Doctoral Research Start-up Fund Project of Liaoning Province, China (No. 2019-BS-159).

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2020 Higher Education Press