A Risk-Based Analysis of Design Practices in Regard to Passenger Hazard Exposure in Open Mass Transit Stations

Abstract

Design practices in regard to passenger hazard exposure in mass transit stations that are directly open to the atmosphere, so-called open stations, are the focus of this study. The benchmarking exercise intends to provide a comprehensive review regarding the application of existing international and national design codes, standards, and guidelines in terms of their ability to mitigate hazards at key points of contact (POC) between passengers and station, such as walking surfaces, stairs, lifts, escalators, and wayfinding, during normal and emergency conditions. By adopting the safety-related risk assessment model, the benchmarking exercise uses national Thai station design practices as a baseline in order to identify applicable national codes, standards, and guidelines, and to conduct a parallel comparative analysis with respect to their international counterparts in order to identify, rank, and evaluate the potential impacts of missing regulations and practices. The analysis shows that a number of station environment-related risks appear along the different paths of egress and at different POC that must be addressed. With the application of Thai national codes, standards, and guidelines alone, the designer is still susceptible to design decisions that do not reduce risk levels. It was also found that more than half of the risks in paths of egress remain undesirable or intolerable after the design, and thus pose a threat of injury to passengers and create growing concerns for operators. Based on the findings of the study, a recommendation can be made for the use of a design handbook for stations by ranking different existing standards in accordance with their importance to the design endeavor, with legal support from involved parties.

Keywords

Station design standards / Passenger hazards in station / Station design practice / Station safety / Passenger safety / Risk analysis

References

[1] International Federation of Consulting Engineers (FIDIC) (1999) FIDIC red book: conditions of contract for construction for building and engineering works designed by the employer, Switzerland

[2] Aslaksen E, DeLamare M, Fehon K, Godau R, Knott A, Kouassi A, Liefde J (2013) Guide for the application of systems engineering in large infrastructure projects. International Council on Systems Engineering (INCOSE)

[3] Bangkok Metropolitan Authority (2544) Building Code for Public Buildings, Engineering Institute of Thailand (EIT), TH

[4] International Electrotechnical Commission - IEC 62278 (2002) Railway applications—The specification and demonstration of reliability, availability, maintainability and safety (RAMS)

[5] National Fire Protection Agency - NFPA 130 (2017) Standard for fixed guideway transit and rail passenger services

[6] National Fire Protection Agency - NFPA 101 (2018) Life safety code

[7] Cafiso S, Graziano AD, Blasi ND. Risk assessment on railway transportation of hazardous materials. WIT Trans Ecol Environ, 2006, 91: 97-106.

[8] Dinmohammadi F, Alkal B, Shafiee M, Berenguer C, Labib A. Risk evaluation of railway rolling stock failures using FMECA technique: a case study of passenger door system. Urban Rail Transit, 2016, 2(3–4): 128-145

[9] Berrado A, El-Koursi EM, Cherkaoui A, Khaddour M. A framework for risk management in railway sector: application to road-rail level crossings. Open Transp J, 2011, 5: 34-44

[10] Jo HJ, Hwang JG, Kim YK. Risk assessment method for guaranteeing safety in the train control system. WIT Trans Built Environ, 2007, 96: 567-576

[11] Occupational Safety and Health Administration - OSHA 29 CFR 1910 (1999) Occupational safety and health standards

[12] American Society for Testing and Materials - ASTM F 1673 (2013) Standard practice for safe walking surfaces

[13] Morrey ML (2007) A study of the slip characteristics of natural and manmade stone flooring materials. Research Report 529, Health and Safety Executive (HSE)

[14] Ministry of Transport (2013) Arrangement facilitation in building or vehicles and logistics for handicapped

[15] Ministerial Regulation No. 55 (2000) Issued pursuant to the Building Control Act, 1979

[16] Ministry of Railways (Railway Board) (2009) Manual for standards and specifications for railway stations, vol 1, India