Three-dimensional seismic face stability of shield tunnels in undrained clay

Abstract

Tunnel face stability has received increasing research interest over the past few decades. However, computing time-efficient and safe three-dimensional solutions under seismic loading is still an unsolved problem, while case studies indicate that seismic loading can be one critical destabilizing factor affecting tunnel stability. The primary objective of this work is to fill this gap in knowledge by providing compromising and computationally efficient solutions, along with their respective lower and upper bounds, to compute face stability under seismic conditions. The analyses employ the finite element limit analysis method to evaluate the limit support pressure in undrained clay, considering horizontal pseudo-static seismic forces pointing outwards from the face. Moreover, the analyses employ both constant and linearly increasing shear strengths with depth. The results are summarized as dimensionless stability charts and tables to facilitate their interpretation and future use for tunnel design. A new design equation has been developed to evaluate the stability of the tunnel face considering the effect of seismic forces. Additionally, the effects of different parameters on the shape of the failure mechanism have been investigated by analysing the distribution of shear dissipation.

Keywords

Tunnel face stability / Finite element limit analysis / Undrained clay / Seismic stability

Declaration of Competing Interest

Rafael Jimenez is an editorial board member for Underground Space and was not involved in the editorial review or the decision to publish this article. All authors declare that there are no competing interests.

Acknowledgement

This research was funded, in part, by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation under Grant PID2019-108060RB-I00.

References

[1] Alagha, A. S. N., & Chapman, D. N. (2019). Numerical modelling of tunnel face stability in homogeneous and layered soft ground. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 94, 103096.

[2] Anagnostou, G., & Ková ri, K. (1994). The face stability of slurry-shielddriven tunnels. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 9(2), 165-174.

[3] Augarde, C. E., Lyamin, A. V., & Sloan, S. W. (2003). Stability of an undrained plane strain heading revisited. Computers and Geotechnics, 30, 419-430.

[4] Bishop, J. F. W. (1953). On the complete solution to problems of deformation of a plastic-rigid material. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 2(1), 43-53.

[5] Bobet, A. (2003). Effect of pore water pressure on tunnel support during static and seismic loading. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 18(4), 377-393.

[6] Broms, B. B., & Bennermark, H. (1967). Stability of clay at vertical opening. Journal of the Soil Mechanics and Foundations Division, 93(1), 71-97.

[7] Butterfield, R. (1999). Dimensional analysis for geotechnical engineers. Géotechnique, 49(3), 357-366.

[8] Casciaro, R., & Carlo, A. (1970). Limit analysis of plates as a minimax problem. G. del Genio Civ. Feb. Pt. I, May pt. II. (in Italian).

[9] Casciaro, R., & Cascini, L. (1982). A mixed formulation and mixed finite elements for limit analysis. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 18(2), 211-243.

[10] Chakraborty, D., & Kumar, J. (2013). Stability of a long unsupported circular tunnel in soils with seismic forces. Natural Hazards, 68, 419-431.

[11] Chambon, P., & Corte, J. F. (1994). Shallow tunnels in cohesionless soil: Stability of tunnel face. Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, 120(7), 1148-1165.

[12] Chen, R. P., Tang, L. J., Ling, D. S., & Chen, Y. M. (2011). Face stability analysis of shallow shield tunnels in dry sandy ground using the discrete element method. Computers and Geotechnics, 38(2), 187-195.

[13] Chen, W. F., & Liu, X. L. (1990). Limit analysis in soil mechanics. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Elsevier.

[14] Chen, Z. Y., & Shen, H. (2014). Dynamic centrifuge tests on isolation mechanism of tunnels subjected to seismic shaking. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 42, 67-77.

[15] Davis, E. H., Gunn, M. J., Mair, R. J., & Seneviratne, H. N. (1980). The stability of shallow tunnels and underground openings in cohesive material. Géotechnique, 30(4), 397-416.

[16] Day, R. W. (2002). Geotechnical earthquake engineering handbook. The McGraw-Hill Companies Inc..

[17] Dowding, C. H., & Rozan, A. (1978). Damage to rock tunnels from earthquake shaking. Journal of the Geotechnical Engineering Division, 104(2), 175-191.

[18] Ellstein, R. A. (1986). Heading failure of lined tunnels in soft soils. Tunnels & Tunnelling, 18, 51-54.

[19] Esmaeilzadeh Seylabi, E., Jeong, C., Dashti, S., Hushmand, A., & Taciroglu, E. (2018). Seismic response of buried reservoir structures: A comparison of numerical simulations with centrifuge experiments. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 109, 89-101.

[20] Han, K. H., Zhang, C. P., & Zhang, D. L. (2016). Upper-bound solutions for the face stability of a shield tunnel in multilayered cohesivefrictional soils. Computers and Geotechnics, 79, 1-9.

[21] Hashash, Y. M. A., Hook, J. J., Schmidt, B., & I-Chiang Yao, J. (2001). Seismic design and analysis of underground structures. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 16(4), 247-293.

[22] Huang, M. S., Li, S., Yu, J., & Tan, J. Q. W. (2018a). Continuous field based upper bound analysis for three-dimensional tunnel face stability in undrained clay. Compuers and Geotechnics, 94, 207-213.

[23] Huang, M. S., Tang, Z., Zhou, W. X., & Yuan, J. Y. (2018b). Upper bound solutions for face stability of circular tunnels in nonhomogeneous and anisotropic clays. Computers and Geotechnics, 98, 189-196.

[24] Huang, Q., Zou, J. F., & Qian, Z. H. (2020). Seismic stability analysis of tunnel face in purely cohesive soil by a pseudo-dynamic approach. Geomechanics and Engineering, 23(1), 1-13.

[25] Ibrahim, E., Soubra, A. H., Mollon, G., Raphael, W., Dias, D., & Reda, A. (2015). Three-dimensional face stability analysis of pressurized tunnels driven in a multilayered purely frictional medium. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 49, 18-34.

[26] Iida, H., Hiroto, T., Yoshida, N., & Iwafuji, M. (1996). Damage to Daikai subway station. Soils and Foundations, 36, 283-300.

[27] Jearsiripongkul, T., Keawsawasvong, S., Banyong, R., Seehavong, S., Sangjinda, K., Thongchom, C., Chavda, J. T., & Ngamkhanong, C. (2022). Stability evaluations of unlined horseshoe tunnels based on extreme learning neural network. Computation, 10(6), 81.

[28] Keawsawasvong, S., & Ukritchon, B. (2022). Design equation for stability of a circular tunnel in anisotropic and heterogeneous clay. Underground Space, 7(1), 76-93.

[29] Keawsawasvong, S., Sorawit, S., & Chayut, N. (2022). Application of artificial neural networks for predicting the stability of rectangular tunnels in Hoek-Brown rock masses. Frontiers in Built Environment, 8, 837745.

[30] Keshavarz, A., Beygi, M., & Vali, R. (2019). Undrained seismic bearing capacity of strip footing placed on homogeneous and heterogeneous soil slopes by finite element limit analysis. Computers and Geotechnics, 113, 103094.

[31] Kimura, T., & Mair, R. J. (1981). Centrifugal testing of model tunnels in soft clay. In Proceedings of the 10th International Conference on Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering (pp.319-322).

[32] Klar, A., Osman, A. S., & Bolton, M. (2007). 2D and 3D upper bound solutions for tunnel excavation using ‘elastic’ flow fields. International Journal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics, 31(12), 1367-1374.

[33] Konagai, K., Takatsu, S., Kanai, T., Fujita, T., Ikeda, T., & Johansson, J. (2009). Kizawa tunnel cracked on 23 October 2004 Mid-Niigata earthquake: An example of earthquake-induced damage to tunnels in active-folding zones. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 29, 394-403.

[34] Kontoe, S., Zdravkovic, L., Potts, D. M., & Menkiti, C. O. (2008). Case study on seismic tunnel response. Canadian Geotechnical Journal, 45, 1743-1764.

[35] Krabbenhoft, K., Lyamin, A. V., Hjiaj, M., & Sloan, S. W. (2005). A new discontinuous upper bound limit analysis formulation. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 63(7), 1069-1088.

[36] Krabbenhoft, K., Lyamin, A. V., & Sloan, S. W. (2007). Formulation and solution of some plasticity problems as conic programs. International Journal of Solids and Structures, 44(5), 1533-1549.

[37] Krinitzsky, E. L., Gould, J. P., & Edinger, P. H. (1993). Fundamentals of earthquake-resistant construction.

[38] John Wiley & Sons Inc. Leca, E., 1990). Upper and lower bound solutions for the face stability of shallow circular tunnels in frictional material. Géotechnique, 40(4), 581-606.

[39] Li, W., Zhang, C. P., Zhang, D. L., Ye, Z. J., & Tan, Z. B. (2022). Face stability of shield tunnels considering a kinematically admissible velocity field of soil arching. Journal of Rock Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering, 14(2), 505-526.

[40] Lyamin, A. V. (1999). Three-dimensional lower bound limit analysis using nonlinear programming. [Doctoral dissertation, The University of Newcastle, Australia].

[41] Lyamin, A. V., & Sloan, S. W. (2002). Lower bound limit analysis using non-linear programming. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 55(5), 573-611.

[42] Lysmer, J. (1970). Limit analysis of plane problems in soil mechanics. Journal of the Soil Mechanics and Foundations Division, 96, 1311-1334.

[43] Ma, S. K., Duan, Z. B., Huang, Z., Liu, Y., & Shao, Y. (2022). Study on the stability of shield tunnel face in clay and clay-gravel stratum through large-scale physical model tests with transparent soil. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 119, 104199.

[44] Mair, R.J., & Taylor, R. N. (1999). Bored tunnelling in the urban environments. In Proceedings of Fourteenth International Conference on Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering. Hamburg, Germany (pp.2353-2385).

[45] Makdisi, F. I., & Seed, H. B. (1978). Simplified procedure for estimating dam and embankment earthquake-induced deformations. Journal of the Geotechnical Engineering Division, 104(7), 849-867.

[46] Mollon, G., Dias, D., & Soubra, A. H. (2013). Range of the safe retaining pressures of a pressurized tunnel face by a probabilistic approach. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 139(11), 1954-1967.

[47] Mollon, G., Dias, D., & Soubra, A. H. (2012). Continuous velocity fields for collapse and blowout of a pressurized tunnel face in purely cohesive soil. International Journal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics, 37(13), 2061-2083.

[48] Mollon, G., Dias, D., & Soubra, A. H. (2010). Face stability analysis of circular tunnels driven by a pressurized shield. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 136, 215-229.

[49] Mollon, G., Dias, D., & Soubra, A. H. (2011). Rotational failure mechanisms for the face stability analysis of tunnels driven by a pressurized shield. Internationa Journal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics, 35(12), 1363-1388.

[50] Nagtegaal, J. C., Parks, D. M., & Rice, J. R. (1974). On numerically accurate finite element solutions in the fully plastic range. Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 4(2), 153-177.

[51] Nash, D. F. T., Powell, J. J. M., & Lloyd, I. M. (1992). Initial investigations of the soft clay test site at Bothkennar. Géotechnique, 42(2), 163-181.

[52] Ngamkhanong, C., Keawsawasvong, S., Jearsiripongkul, T., Cabangon, L. T., Payan, M., Sangjinda, K.,... Thongchom, C. (2022). Data- Driven prediction of stability of rock tunnel heading: An application of machine learning models. Infrastructures, 7(11), 148.

[53] OptumCE. (2022). Optum computational engineering (Optum G3). Denmark.

[54] Owen, G. N., & Scholl, R. E. (1981). Earthquake engineering of large underground structures. Report No. FHWA-RD-80-195, FHWA, Washington D. C.

[55] Pan, Q. J., & Dias, D. (2018). Three-dimensional static and seismic stability analysis of a tunnel face driven in weak rock masses. International Journal of Geomechanics, 18(6), 1-10.

[56] Perazzelli, P., Leone, T., & Anagnostou, G. (2014). Tunnel face stability under seepage flow conditions. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 43, 459-469.

[57] Power, M., Rosidi, D., & Kaneshiro, J. Y. (1998). Seismic vulnerability of tunnels and underground structures revisited. In Proceedings of North American Tunneling’98. Balkema, Newport Beach, California (pp. 243- 250).

[58] Raj, D., Singh, Y., & Shukla, S. K. (2018). Seismic bearing capacity of strip foundation embedded in c-/ soil slope. International Journal of Geomechanics, 18(7), 04018076.

[59] Saada, Z., Maghous, S., & Garnier, D. (2013). Pseudo-static analysis of tunnel face stability using the generalized Hoek-Brown strength criterion. International Journal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics, 37(18), 3194-3212.

[60] Sahoo, J. P., & Kumar, J. (2014). Stability of a circular tunnel in presence of pseudostatic seismic body forces. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 42, 264-276.

[61] Sahoo, J. P., & Kumar, J. (2012). Seismic stability of a long unsupported circular tunnel. Computers and Geotechnics, 44, 109-115.

[62] Schofield, A. N. (1980). Cambridge geotechnical centrifuge operations. Géotechnique, 30(3), 227-268.

[63] Seed, H. B. (1979). Considerations in the earthquake-resistant design of earth and rockfill dams. Géotechnique, 29(3), 215-263.

[64] Senent, S., & Jimenez, R. (2015). A tunnel face failure mechanism for layered ground, considering the possibility of partial collapse. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 47, 182-192.

[65] Senent, S., Mollon, G., & Jimenez, R. (2013). Tunnel face stability in heavily fractured rock masses that follow the Hoek-Brown failure criterion. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, 60, 440-451.

[66] Senent, S., Yi, C., & Jimenez, R. (2020). An upper bound solution for tunnel face stability analysis considering the free span. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 103, 103515.

[67] Shiau, J., Keawsawasvong, S., & Seehavong, S. (2022). Stability of unlined elliptical tunnels in rock masses. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering, 55, 7307-7330.

[68] Shiau, J., & Keawsawasvong, S. (2022). Producing undrained stability factors for various tunnel shapes. International Journal of Geomechanics, 22(8), 06022017.

[69] Sirimontree, S., Keawsawasvong, S., Ngamkhanong, C., Seehavong, S., Sangjinda, K., Jearsiripongkul, T., Thongchom, C., & Nuaklong, P. (2022). Neural network-based prediction model for the stability of unlined elliptical tunnels in cohesive-frictional soils. Buildings, 12(4), 444.

[70] Skempton, A. W. (1957). Discussion of ‘‘The planning and design of the new Hong Kong Airport”. Proceedings of The Institution of Civil Engineer, 7(2), 305-307.

[71] Sloan, S. W. (2013). Geotechnical stability analysis. Géotechnique, 63(7), 531-571.

[72] Sloan, S. W., & Kleeman, P. W. (1995). Upper bound limit analysis using discontinuous velocity fields. Computer Methods Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 127(1-4), 293-314.

[73] Takano, D., Otani, J., & Mukunoki, T. (2006). Application of X-ray CT on boundary value problems in geotechnical engineering: Research on tunnel face failure. In Proceedings of GeoCongress 2006. ASCE, Reston, VA, USA. https://doi.org/10.1061/40803(187)52.

[74] Taniguchi, E., & Sasaki, Y. (1985). Back analysis of landslide due to Naganoken Seibu Earthquake of September 14, 1984. In Proceedings of 11th International Conference on Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering. Sanfrancisco (pp. 1-55).

[75] Terzaghi, K. (1950). Mechanism of landslides. In Application of Geology to Engineering Practice. Geological Society of America, USA (pp.83-123).

[76] Tsinidis, G., de Silva, F., Anastasopoulos, I., Bilotta, E., Bobet, A., Hashash, Y. M. A.,... Fuentes, R. (2020). Seismic behaviour of tunnels: From experiments to analysis. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 99, 103334.

[77] Tu, S. Q., Li, W., Zhang, C. P., & Chen, W. (2023). Effect of inclined layered soils on face stability in shield tunneling based on limit analysis. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 131, 104773.

[78] Ukritchon, B., & Keawsawasvong, S. (2019). Lower bound solutions for undrained face stability of plane strain tunnel headings in anisotropic and non-homogeneous clays. Computers and Geotechnics, 112, 204-217.

[79] Ukritchon, B., Yingchaloenkitkhajorn, K., & Keawsawasvong, S. (2017). Three-dimensional undrained tunnel face stability in clay with a linearly increasing shear strength with depth. Computers and Geotechnics, 88, 146-151.

[80] Vermeer, P. A., Ruse, N., & Marcher, T. (2002). Tunnel heading stability in drained ground. Felsbau, 20, 6.

[81] Wang, J. N. (1993). Seismic design of tunnels:A state-of-the-art approach. New York: Parsons Brinckerhoff Quade & Douglas.

[82] Wang, W. L., Wang, T. T., Su, J. J., Lin, C. H., Seng, C. R., & Huang, T. H. (2001). Assessment of damage in mountain tunnels due to the Taiwan Chi-Chi earthquake. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 16(3), 133-150.

[83] Wong, K. S., Ng, C. W. W., Chen, Y. M., & Bian, X. C. (2012). Centrifuge and numerical investigation of passive failure of tunnel face in sand. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 28, 297-303.

[84] Yi, C., Senent, S., & Jimenez, R. (2019). Effect of advance drainage on tunnel face stability using limit analysis and numerical simulations. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 93, 103105.

[85] Yu, H. S. (2006). Plasticity and geotechnics: Advances in Mechanics and Mathematics. Springer. Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4757-4435-4.

[86] Yu, H. T., Chen, J. T., Bobet, A., & Yuan, Y. (2016). Damage observation and assessment of the Longxi tunnel during the Wenchuan earthquake. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 54, 102-116.

[87] Zhang, C. P., Li, W., Zhu, W. J., & Tan, Z. B. (2020). Face stability analysis of a shallow horseshoe-shaped shield tunnel in clay with a linearly increasing shear strength with depth. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 97, 103291.

[88] Zhang, F., Gao, Y. F., Wu, Y. X., & Wang, Z. X. (2018a). Face stability analysis of large-diameter slurry shield-driven tunnels with linearly increasing undrained strength. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 78, 178-187.

[89] Zhang, F., Gao, Y. F., Wu, Y. X., & Zhang, N. (2018b). Upper-bound solutions for face stability of circular tunnels in undrained clays. Géotechnique, 69(7), 655-658.

[90] Zouain, N., Herskovits, J., Borges, L. A., & Feijoóo, R. A. (1993). An iterative algorithm for limit analysis with nonlinear yield functions. International Journal of Solids and Structures, 30(10), 1397-1417.