Replace Platinum for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction in the Cathode of Proton Exchange Membrane Water Electrolyzers

Abstract

The growing global energy demand and environmental concerns like greenhouse gas emissions call for clean energy solutions. Hydrogen energy, with high caloric value and low environmental impact, is a promising alternative, especially when produced via proton exchange membrane water electrolysis (PEMWE). This process relies on the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and oxygen evolution reaction (OER), both requiring efficient electrocatalysts. Platinum (Pt), the most effective HER catalyst, is limited by high cost and scarcity, prompting research into Pt alternatives like ruthenium-based, transition metal derivatives, and metal-free catalysts that balance cost, efficiency, and stability. This review explores HER mechanisms, Pt-free catalyst innovations, and the impact of structural and interfacial electrode optimization on performance of HER in acidic media. It also examines electrochemical evaluation techniques, material characterization, and the role of machine learning in catalyst design. By providing a framework for Pt-free HER catalyst development, this review supports advancements in efficient and sustainable hydrogen energy technologies.

Keywords

hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) / proton exchange membrane water electrolyzer (PEMWE) / electrocatalysts / platinum (Pt) alternatives / transition metal derivatives / nonmetal derivatives

References

[1] Z. Zhao, H. Chen, W. Zhang, et al., “Defect Engineering in Carbon Materials for Electrochemical Energy Storage and Catalytic Conversion,” Materials Advances 4 (2023): 835-867.

[2] K. Zhang, X. Liang, and L. Wang, “Status and Perspectives of Key Materials for PEM Electrolyzer,” Nano Research Energy 1 (2022): e9120032.

[3] F. Jiang, Y. Li, and Y. Pan, “Design Principles of Single-Atom Catalysts for Oxygen Evolution Reaction: From Targeted Structures to Active Sites,” Advanced Materials (2024): 36.

[4] T. Wang, P. Wang, W. Zang, et al., “Nanoframes of Co₃O₄-Mo₂N Heterointerfaces Enable High-Performance Bifunctionality Toward both Electrocatalytic HER and OER,” Advanced Functional Materials 32 (2022): 2107382.

[5] D. C. Nguyen, T. L. Luyen Doan, S. Prabhakaran, et al., “Hierarchical Co and Nb Dual-doped MoS₂ Nanosheets Shelled Micro-TiO₂ Hollow Spheres as Effective Multifunctional Electrocatalysts for HER, OER, and ORR,” Nano Energy 82 (2021): 105750.

[6] F.-Y. Chen, Z.-Y. Wu, Z. Adler, and H. Wang, “Stability Challenges of Electrocatalytic Oxygen Evolution Reaction: From Mechanistic Understanding to Reactor Design,” Joule 5 (2021): 1704-1731.

[7] D. Zhou, P. Li, X. Lin, et al., “Layered Double Hydroxide-based Electrocatalysts for the Oxygen Evolution Reaction: Identification and Tailoring of Active Sites, and Superaerophobic Nanoarray Electrode Assembly,” Chemical Society Reviews 50 (2021): 8790-8817.

[8] J. N. Tiwari, S. Sultan, C. W. Myung, et al., “Multicomponent Electrocatalyst With Ultralow Pt Loading and High Hydrogen Evolution Activity,” Nature Energy 3 (2018): 773-782.

[9] B. Hinnemann, P. G. Moses, J. Bonde, et al., “Biomimetic Hydrogen Evolution:  MoS₂ Nanoparticles as Catalyst for Hydrogen Evolution,” Journal of the American Chemical Society 127 (2005): 5308-5309.

[10] T. F. Jaramillo, K. P. Jørgensen, J. Bonde, J. H. Nielsen, S. Horch, and I. Chorkendorff, “Identification of Active Edge Sites for Electrochemical H₂ Evolution From MoS₂ Nanocatalysts,” Science 317 (2007): 100-102.

[11] E. J. Popczun, J. R. Mckone, C. G. Read, et al., “Nanostructured Nickel Phosphide as an Electrocatalyst for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Journal of the American Chemical Society 135 (2013): 9267-9270.

[12] J. Kibsgaard, C. Tsai, and K. Chan, “Designing an Improved Transition Metal Phosphide Catalyst for Hydrogen Evolution Using Experimental and Theoretical Trends,” Energy & Environmental Science 8 (2015): 3022-3029.

[13] A. A. Feidenhans'l, Y. N. Regmi, C. Wei, D. Xia, J. Kibsgaard, and L. A. King, “Precious Metal Free Hydrogen Evolution Catalyst Design and Application,” Chemical Reviews 124 (2024): 5617-5667.

[14] H. Wu, Q. Huang, Y. Shi, J. Chang, and S. Lu, “Electrocatalytic Water Splitting: Mechanism and Electrocatalyst Design,” Nano Research 16 (2023): 9142-9157.

[15] N. A. Khan, G. Rahman, T. M. Nguyen, et al., “Recent Development of Nanostructured Nickel Metal-Based Electrocatalysts for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction: A Review,” Topics in Catalysis 66 (2023): 149-181.

[16] W. Zhai, Y. Ma, D. Chen, J. C. Ho, Z. Dai, and Y. Qu, “Recent Progress on the Long-term Stability of Hydrogen Evolution Reaction Electrocatalysts,” INFOMAT 4 (2022).

[17] L. Zhang, Y. Jia, X. Yan, and X. Yao, “Activity Origins in Nanocarbons for the Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Small 14 (2018): 1800235.

[18] H. Wang, W. Fu, X. Yang, et al., “Recent Advancements in Heterostructured Interface Engineering for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction Electrocatalysis,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A 8 (2020): 6926-6956.

[19] S. Anantharaj, S. R. Ede, K. Sakthikumar, K. Karthick, S. Mishra, and S. Kundu, “Recent Trends and Perspectives in Electrochemical Water Splitting With an Emphasis on Sulfide, Selenide, and Phosphide Catalysts of Fe, Co, and Ni: A Review,” ACS Catalysis 6 (2016): 8069-8097.

[20] Y. Shi and B. Zhang, “Recent Advances in Transition Metal Phosphide Nanomaterials: Synthesis and Applications in Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Chemical Society Reviews 45 (2016): 1529-1541.

[21] S. A. Shah, X. Shen, M. Xie, et al., “Nickel@Nitrogen-Doped Carbon@MoS₂ Nanosheets: An Efficient Electrocatalyst for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Small 15 (2019): 1804545.

[22] M. Lao, K. Rui, G. Zhao, et al., “Platinum/Nickel Bicarbonate Heterostructures towards Accelerated Hydrogen Evolution Under Alkaline Conditions,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition 58 (2019): 5432-5437.

[23] Md. N. Islam, M. M. Hossain, S. S. Maktedar, et al., “Ce-Doped TiO₂ Fabricated Glassy Carbon Electrode for Efficient Hydrogen Evolution Reaction in Acidic Medium,” Chemistry - An Asian Journal 19 (2024).

[24] K. K. Joshi, P. M. Pataniya, G. R. Bhadu, and C. K. Sumesh, “Cu₂CoSnS₄ electrocatalyst Embedded Paper Working Electrodes for Efficient, Stable, pH Universal, and Large-current-density Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 49 (2024): 829-842.

[25] Z. Chen, N. Han, R. Zheng, Z. Ren, W. Wei, and B.-J. Ni, “Design of Earth-abundant Amorphous Transition Metal-based Catalysts for Electrooxidation of Small Molecules: Advances and Perspectives,” SusMat 3 (2023): 290-319.

[26] Y. Li, A. Feng, and L. Dai, “Progress on the Design of Electrocatalysts for Large-Current Hydrogen Production by Tuning Thermodynamic and Kinetic Factors,” Advanced Functional Materials 34 (2024).

[27] F. Zhou, Y. Zhou, G.-G. Liu, C.-T. Wang, and J. Wang, “Recent Advances in Nanostructured Electrocatalysts for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Rare Metals 40 (2021): 3375-3405.

[28] W. Feng, W. Zhang, Q. Lin, et al., “Metal-support Interactions of 2D Carbon-based Heterogeneous Catalysts for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A 12 (2024): 18866-18878.

[29] J. Lin, X.u Wang, Z. Zhao, et al., “Design of pH-universal Electrocatalysts for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Carbon Energy 6 (2024).

[30] R. Xi, Y. Li, Y. Zhang, P. Wang, and D. Hu, “Effects of Activation Method on Biomass Carbon-based Materials Used for Electrochemical Hydrogen Evolution Reaction Catalyst,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 51 (2024): 1-19.

[31] S. Km, B. M. Praveen, and B. K. Devendra, “A Review on Corrosion Inhibitors: Types, Mechanisms, Electrochemical Analysis, Corrosion Rate and Efficiency of Corrosion Inhibitors on Mild Steel in an Acidic Environment,” Results in Surfaces and Interfaces 16 (2024): 100258.

[32] S. Zhou, L. Shi, Y. Li, T. Yang, and S. Zhao, “Metal-Organic Framework-Based Electrocatalysts for Acidic Water Splitting,” Advanced Functional Materials 34 (2024).

[33] J. Ryu and D. W. Lee, “Tailoring Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic Microenvironments for Gas-liquid-solid Triphase Electrochemical Reactions,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A 12 (2024): 10012-10043.

[34] S.-Y. Bae, J. Mahmood, I.-Y. Jeon, and J.-B. Baek, “Recent Advances in Ruthenium-based Electrocatalysts for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Nanoscale Horizons 5 (2020): 43-56.

[35] J. Dai, Y. Zhu, H. A. Tahini, et al., “Single-phase Perovskite Oxide With Super-exchange Induced Atomic-scale Synergistic Active Centers Enables Ultrafast Hydrogen Evolution,” Nature Communications 11 (2020).

[36] J. Mahmood, F. Li, S.-M. Jung, et al., “An Efficient and pH-universal Ruthenium-based Catalyst for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Nature Nanotechnology 12 (2017): 441-446.

[37] J. Yu, Q. He, G. Yang, W. Zhou, Z. Shao, and M. Ni, “Recent Advances and Prospective in Ruthenium-Based Materials for Electrochemical Water Splitting,” ACS Catalysis 9 (2019): 9973-10011.

[38] D. H. Kweon, M. S. Okyay, S.-J. Kim, et al., “Ruthenium Anchored on Carbon Nanotube Electrocatalyst for Hydrogen Production With Enhanced Faradaic Efficiency,” Nature Communications 11 (2020).

[39] Y. Jiang, T.-W. Huang, H.-L. Chou, et al., “Revealing and Magnifying Interfacial Effects Between Ruthenium and Carbon Supports for Efficient Hydrogen Evolution,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A 10 (2022): 17730-17739.

[40] S. Pérez-Rodríguez, D. Sebastián, M. J. Lázaro, and E. Pastor, “Stability and Catalytic Properties of Nanostructured Carbons in Electrochemical Environments,” Journal of Catalysis 355 (2017): 156-166.

[41] M. Wu, Y. Fan, Y. Huang, et al., “Synergistic Ru/RuO₂ Heterojunctions Stabilized by Carbon Coating as Efficient and Stable Bifunctional Electrocatalysts for Acidic Overall Water Splitting,” Nano Research 17 (2024): 6931-6939.

[42] H. Wang, H. Zhang, Y. Huang, et al., “Strain in Copper/Ceria Heterostructure Promotes Electrosynthesis of Multicarbon Products,” ACS Nano 17 (2023): 346-354.

[43] X. Yu, F. Yan, Y. Zhao, et al., “A Heterostructure of Interlayer-expanded 1T Phase MoS₂ and Spherical MoO₂ for Efficient and Stable Hydrogen Evolution,” Applied Catalysis B 343 (2024): 123534.

[44] D. Jeon, D. Y. Kim, and H. Kim, “Electrochemical Evolution of Ru-Based Polyoxometalates Into Si,W-Codoped RuO_X for Acidic Overall Water Splitting,” Advanced Materials (2024): 36.

[45] W. Chen, W. Wei, and F. Li, “Tunable Built-In Electric Field in Ru Nanoclusters-Based Electrocatalyst Boosts Water Splitting and Simulated Seawater Electrolysis,” Advanced Functional Materials 34 (2024).

[46] Y. Wu, R. Yao, K. Zhang, Q. Zhao, J. Li, and G. Liu, “RuO₂/CeO₂ Heterostructure Anchored on Carbon Spheres as a Bifunctional Electrocatalyst for Efficient Water Splitting in Acidic media,” Chemical Engineering Journal 479 (2024): 147939.

[47] J. Zhu, Y. Guo, F. Liu, et al., “Regulative Electronic States Around Ruthenium/Ruthenium Disulphide Heterointerfaces for Efficient Water Splitting in Acidic Media,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition 60 (2021): 12328-12334.

[48] L. Zhang, H. Jang, Y. Wang, et al., “Exploring the Dominant Role of Atomic- and Nano-Ruthenium as Active Sites for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction in both Acidic and Alkaline Media,” Advancement of Science 8 (2021): 2004516.

[49] T. Wang, L. Guo, Z. Jiang, et al., “Ru-Pincer Complex-Bridged Cu-Porphyrin Polymer for Robust (Photo)Electrocatalytic H₂ Evolution via Single-Atom Active Sites,” Advanced Functional Materials 31 (2021): 2107290.

[50] J.-S. Li, M.-J. Huang, Y.-W. Zhou, et al., “RuP₂-based Hybrids Derived From MOFs: Highly Efficient pH-universal Electrocatalysts for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A 9 (2021): 12276-12282.

[51] H. Zhang, W. Zhou, X. F. Lu, T. Chen, and X. W. Lou, “Implanting Isolated Ru Atoms Into Edge-Rich Carbon Matrix for Efficient Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution,” Advanced Energy Materials 10 (2020).

[52] A. M. Harzandi, S. Shadman, M. Ha, et al., “Immiscible bi-metal Single-atoms Driven Synthesis of Electrocatalysts Having Superb Mass-activity and Durability,” Applied Catalysis B 270 (2020): 118896.

[53] D. Chen, R. Yu, D. Wu, et al., “Anion-modulated Molybdenum Oxide Enclosed Ruthenium Nano-capsules With Almost the Same Water Splitting Capability in Acidic and Alkaline media,” Nano Energy 100 (2022): 107445.

[54] B. Yang, J. Xu, D. Bin, et al., “Amorphous Phosphatized Ruthenium-iron Bimetallic Nanoclusters With Pt-Like Activity for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Applied Catalysis B 283 (2021): 119583.

[55] Y. Feng, W. Feng, J. Wan, et al., “Spherical vs. planar: Steering the Electronic Communication Between Ru Nanoparticle and Single Atom to Boost the Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution Activity both in Acid and Alkaline,” Applied Catalysis B 307 (2022): 121193.

[56] S. Zhao, S.-F. Hung, and L. Deng, “Constructing Regulable Supports via Non-stoichiometric Engineering to Stabilize Ruthenium Nanoparticles for Enhanced pH-universal Water Splitting,” Nature Communications (2024): 15.

[57] Y. Wei, G. Xu, Y. Wei, et al., “Temperature-controlled Synthesis of Heterostructured Ru-Ru₂P Nanoparticles Embedded in Carbon Nanofibers for Highly Efficient Hydrogen Production,” Science China Materials 65 (2022): 2675-2684.

[58] L. Li, C. Liu, S. Liu, et al., “Phase Engineering of a Ruthenium Nanostructure Toward High-Performance Bifunctional Hydrogen Catalysis,” ACS Nano 16 (2022): 14885-14894.

[59] Z. Wang, K. Chi, and S. Yang, “Optimizing the Electronic Structure of Atomically Dispersed Ru Sites With CoP for Highly Efficient Hydrogen Evolution in both Alkaline and Acidic Media,” Small 19 (2023).

[60] B. Lu, L. Guo, and F. Wu, “Ruthenium Atomically Dispersed in Carbon Outperforms Platinum Toward Hydrogen Evolution in Alkaline media,” Nature Communications 10 (2019).

[61] T. Gao, X. Tang, X. Li, et al., “Understanding the Atomic and Defective Interface Effect on Ruthenium Clusters for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” ACS Catalysis 13 (2023): 49-59.

[62] G. Zhou, S. Zhang, Y. Zhu, et al., “Manipulating the Rectifying Contact Between Ultrafine Ru Nanoclusters and N-Doped Carbon Nanofibers for High-Efficiency pH-Universal Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution,” Small 19 (2023): 2206781.

[63] D. Li, Y. Liu, Z. Liu, J. Yang, C. Hu, and L. Feng, “Electrochemical Hydrogen Evolution Reaction Efficiently Catalyzed by Ru-N Coupling in Defect-rich Ru/G-C₃N₄ Nanosheets,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A 9 (2021): 15019-15026.

[64] X. Zou and Y. Zhang, “Noble Metal-free Hydrogen Evolution Catalysts for Water Splitting,” Chemical Society Reviews 44 (2015): 5148-5180.

[65] C. C. Weng, J. T. Ren, and Z. Y. Yuan, “Transition Metal Phosphide-Based Materials for Efficient Electrochemical Hydrogen Evolution: A Critical Review,” Chemsuschem 13 (2020): 3357-3375.

[66] P. Chen, J. Ye, H. Wang, L. Ouyang, and M. Zhu, “Recent Progress of Transition Metal Carbides/Nitrides for Electrocatalytic Water Splitting,” Journal of Alloys and Compounds 883 (2021): 160833.

[67] L. Yang, X. Yuan, Y. Dong, S. Qian, and C. Zhu, “Hierarchical Nanowires of MoS₂@Transition Metal Sulfide Heterostructures for Efficient Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry 964 (2024): 118342.

[68] M. A. Lukowski, A. S. Daniel, F. Meng, A. Forticaux, L. Li, and S. Jin, “Enhanced Hydrogen Evolution Catalysis From Chemically Exfoliated Metallic MoS₂ Nanosheets,” Journal of the American Chemical Society 135 (2013): 10274-10277.

[69] J. Gupta, D. Das, P. H. Borse, and B. V. Sarada, “In Situ Pd-doped MoS₂ Nanosheets as an HER Electrocatalyst for Enhanced Electrocatalytic Water Splitting,” SE&F 8 (2024): 1526-1539.

[70] F. Rasool, B. M. Pirzada, M. Misbah Uddin, et al., “Interfacial Engineering of ZnS-ZnO Decorated MoS₂ Supported on 2D Ti₃C₂T_x MXene Sheets for Enhanced Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 59 (2024): 63-73.

[71] X. Wang, C. Li, S. Sun, and S. Hu, “Enhanced Activity in Industrial Hydrogen Evolution Reaction on NiS/NiCoP by Sulfur Vacancy Coupled With Transition Metal Doping,” Electrochimica Acta 498 (2024): 144695.

[72] P. Sundara Venkatesh, N. Kannan, M. Ganesh Babu, G. Paulraj, and K. Jeganathan, “Transition Metal Doped MoS₂ Nanosheets for Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 47 (2022): 37256-37263.

[73] H. D. Mai, P. M. Park, G.-N. Bae, et al., “Metallic Cobalt/Cobalt Sulfide Hetero-nanostructures Embedded Within N-doped Graphitic Carbon Nanocages for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A 12 (2024): 4761-4769.

[74] A. T. Aqueel Ahmed, S. Sekar, S. Lee, H. Im, V. Preethi, and A. S. Ansari, “Nitrogen-doped Cobalt Sulfide as an Efficient Electrocatalyst for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction in Alkaline and Acidic media,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 47 (2022): 40340-40348.

[75] Z.-F. Huang, J. Song, K. Li, et al., “Hollow Cobalt-Based Bimetallic Sulfide Polyhedra for Efficient all-pH-Value Electrochemical and Photocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution,” Journal of the American Chemical Society 138 (2016): 1359-1365.

[76] P. M. Pataniya, V. Patel, P. Sahatiya, D. J. Late, and C. K. Sumesh, “Hydrogen Evolution Reaction in Acidic and Basic Medium on Robust Cobalt Sulphide Electrocatalyst,” Surf Interface 34 (2022): 102319.

[77] S. M. El-Refaei, P. A. Russo, and N. Pinna, “Recent Advances in Multimetal and Doped Transition-Metal Phosphides for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction at Different pH Values,” ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 13 (2021): 22077-22097.

[78] A. Eftekhari, “Electrocatalysts for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 42 (2017): 11053-11077.

[79] Y. Pan, Y. Lin, Y. Chen, Y. Liu, and C. Liu, “Cobalt Phosphide-based Electrocatalysts: Synthesis and Phase Catalytic Activity Comparison for Hydrogen Evolution,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A 4 (2016): 4745-4754.

[80] G. Li, J. Yu, J. Jia, et al., “Cobalt-Cobalt Phosphide Nanoparticles@Nitrogen-Phosphorus Doped Carbon/Graphene Derived From Cobalt Ions Adsorbed Saccharomycete Yeasts as an Efficient, Stable, and Large-Current-Density Electrode for Hydrogen Evolution Reactions,” Advanced Functional Materials 28 (2018): 1801332.

[81] A. R. J. Kucernak and V. N. Naranammalpuram Sundaram, “Nickel Phosphide: The Effect of Phosphorus Content on Hydrogen Evolution Activity and Corrosion Resistance in Acidic Medium,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A 2 (2014): 17435-17445.

[82] A. B. Silva, M. Medina, L. A. Goulart, and L. H. Mascaro, “One-step Electrodeposited Nickel Phosphide Electrode for pH-universal Electrochemical Hydrogen Production,” Electrochimica Acta 475 (2024): 143679.

[83] D. Liu, G. Xu, H. Yang, H. Wang, and B. Y. Xia, “Rational Design of Transition Metal Phosphide-Based Electrocatalysts for Hydrogen Evolution,” Advanced Functional Materials 33 (2023): 2208358.

[84] L. K. Putri, B.-J. Ng, R. Y. Z. Yeo, W.-J. Ong, A. R. Mohamed, and S.-P. Chai, “Engineering Nickel Phosphides for Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution: A Doping Perspective,” Chemical Engineering Journal 461 (2023): 141845.

[85] A. Parra-Puerto, K. L. Ng, K. Fahy, A. E. Goode, M. P. Ryan, and A. Kucernak, “Supported Transition Metal Phosphides: Activity Survey for HER, ORR, OER, and Corrosion Resistance in Acid and Alkaline Electrolytes,” ACS Catalysis 9 (2019): 11515-11529.

[86] Y. Qian, Y. Sun, F. Zhang, et al., “In Situ Construction of Layered Transition Metal Phosphides/Sulfides Heterostructures for Efficient Hydrogen Evolution in Acidic and Alkaline media,” Chemical Engineering Journal 490 (2024): 151693.

[87] E. Soltani, M. B. Gholivand, and M. Amiri, “Introduction of Manganese-iron Phosphide as Hydrogen Evolution Reaction Electrocatalyst Based on Their Poly Aspartic Acid Complexes,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 51 (2024): 269-280.

[88] J. F. Callejas, C. G. Read, E. J. Popczun, J. M. McEnaney, and R. E. Schaak, “Nanostructured Co₂P Electrocatalyst for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction and Direct Comparison With Morphologically Equivalent CoP,” Chemistry of Materials 27 (2015): 3769-3774.

[89] J. F. Callejas, C. G. Read, C. W. Roske, N. S. Lewis, and R. E. Schaak, “Synthesis, Characterization, and Properties of Metal Phosphide Catalysts for the Hydrogen-Evolution Reaction,” Chemistry of Materials 28 (2016): 6017-6044.

[90] G. Li, Y. Sun, J. Rao, et al., “Carbon-Tailored Semimetal MoP as an Efficient Hydrogen Evolution Electrocatalyst in both Alkaline and Acid Media,” Advanced Energy Materials 8 (2018): 1801258.

[91] Y. Yang, X. Feng, Z. Liu, et al., “Enhanced Hydrogen Evolution Activity of Phosphorus-Rich Tungsten Phosphide by Cobalt Doping: A Comprehensive Study of the Active Sites and Electronic Structure,” ChemElectroChem 8 (2021): 1658-1664.

[92] R. A. Mir, S. Upadhyay, and O. P. Pandey, “A Review on Recent Advances and Progress in Mo₂C@C: A Suitable and Stable Electrocatalyst for HER,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 48 (2023): 13044-13067.

[93] W.-F. Chen, J. T. Muckerman, and E. Fujita, “Recent Developments in Transition Metal Carbides and Nitrides as Hydrogen Evolution Electrocatalysts,” Chemical Communications 49 (2013): 8896.

[94] H. Vrubel and X. Hu, “Molybdenum Boride and Carbide Catalyze Hydrogen Evolution in both Acidic and Basic Solutions,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition 51 (2012): 12703-12706.

[95] B. M. Tackett, W. Sheng, and J. G. Chen, “Opportunities and Challenges in Utilizing Metal-Modified Transition Metal Carbides as Low-Cost Electrocatalysts,” Joule 1 (2017): 253-263.

[96] M. Fan, J. Guo, G. Fang, et al., “Microwave-pulse Assisted Synthesis of Tunable Ternary-doped 2D Molybdenum Carbide for Efficient Hydrogen Evolution,” Chemical Synthesis 4 (2024).

[97] A. Huang, H. Huang, and F. Wang, “Mo₂C-Based Ceramic Electrode With High Stability and Catalytic Activity for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction at High Current Density,” Small 20 (2024).

[98] S. Zhang, X. Zhang, Y. Rui, R. Wang, and X. Li, “Recent Advances in Non-precious Metal Electrocatalysts for pH-universal Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” GEE 6 (2021): 458-478.

[99] M. Sun, Y. Li, S. Wang, Z. Wang, Z. Li, and T. Zhang, “Non-precious Metal-based Heterostructure Catalysts for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction: Mechanisms, Design Principles, and Future Prospects,” Nanoscale 15 (2023): 13515-13531.

[100] L. He, G. Yu, Y. Cheng, N. Wang, and W. Hu, “Non-precious Metal-based Catalysts for Water Electrolysis to Produce H₂ Under Industrial Conditions,” Materials Chemistry Frontiers 7 (2023): 5661-5692.

[101] C. Hu, R. Paul, Q. Dai, and L. Dai, “Carbon-based Metal-free Electrocatalysts: From Oxygen Reduction to Multifunctional Electrocatalysis,” Chem. Soc. Rev. 50 (2021): 11785-11843.

[102] Y. Zheng, Y. Jiao, L. H. Li, et al., “Toward Design of Synergistically Active Carbon-Based Catalysts for Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution,” ACS Nano 8 (2014): 5290-5296.

[103] Y. Zhu, S. Murali, W. Cai, et al., “Graphene and Graphene Oxide: Synthesis, Properties, and Applications,” Advanced Materials 22 (2010): 3906-3924.

[104] T. Li, T. Hu, L. Dai, and C. M. Li, “Metal-free Photo- and Electro-catalysts for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A 8 (2020): 23674-23698.

[105] N. Murugan, S. Thangarasu, S. B. Seo, et al., “N-doped Defect-rich Porous Carbon Nanosheets Framework From Renewable Biomass as Efficient Metal-free Bifunctional Electrocatalysts for HER and OER Application,” Renewable Energy 222 (2024): 119801.

[106] H. He, Y. Zhang, W. Zhang, et al., “Porous Carbon Nanofibers Derived From Silk Fibroin Through Electrospinning as N-Doped Metal-Free Catalysts for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction in Acidic and Alkaline Solutions,” ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 14 (2022): 834-849.

[107] X. Yue, S. Huang, Y. Jin, and P. K. Shen, “Nitrogen and Fluorine Dual-doped Porous Graphene-nanosheets as Efficient Metal-free Electrocatalysts for Hydrogen-evolution in Acidic media,” Catalysis Science & Technology 7 (2017): 2228-2235.

[108] H. Wu, Z. Chen, F. Xiao, et al., “Tunable Doping of N and S in Carbon Nanotubes by Retarding Pyrolysis-gas Diffusion to Promote Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution,” Chemical Communications 55 (2019): 10011-10014.

[109] F. Xiao, Z. Chen, H. Wu, et al., “Phytic Acid-guided Ultra-thin N,P co-doped Carbon Coated Carbon Nanotubes for Efficient all-pH Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution,” Nanoscale 11 (2019): 23027-23034.

[110] H.-X. Zhong, Q. Zhang, J. Wang, et al., “Engineering Ultrathin C₃N₄ Quantum Dots on Graphene as a Metal-Free Water Reduction Electrocatalyst,” ACS Catalysis 8 (2018): 3965-3970.

[111] C. Wang, S. Bai, and Y. Xiong, “Recent Advances in Surface and Interface Engineering for Electrocatalysis,” Chinese Journal of Catalysis 36 (2015): 1476-1493.

[112] L. Feng, Y. Yuan, and B. Yan, “Halogen Hydrogen-bonded Organic Framework (XHOF) Constructed by Singlet Open-shell Diradical for Efficient Photoreduction of U(VI),” Nature Communications 13 (2022).

[113] H. Ding, C. Su, J. Wu, et al., “Highly Crystalline Iridium-Nickel Nanocages With Subnanopores for Acidic Bifunctional Water Splitting Electrolysis,” Journal of the American Chemical Society 146 (2024): 7858-7867.

[114] I. Ahmed, S. G. Dastider, R. Biswas, A. Roy, K. Mondal, and K. K. Haldar, “Co₃O₄/WO₃/C Nanorods With Porous Structures as High-Performance Electrocatalysts for Water Splitting,” ACS Applied Nano Materials 7 (2024): 4035-4050.

[115] D. Li, Z. Guo, R. Zhao, et al., “An Efficient Cerium Dioxide Incorporated Nickel Cobalt Phosphide Complex as Electrocatalyst for All-pH Hydrogen Evolution Reaction and Overall Water Splitting,” Journal of Colloid & Interface Science 653 (2024): 1725-1742.

[116] M. K. Kim, B. Lamichhane, B. Song, et al., “Enhancing Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution of MoS₂ Enabled by Electrochemical Cation Implantation for Simultaneous Surface-defect and Phase Engineering,” Applied Catalysis B Environment and Energy 352 (2024): 124037.

[117] Y. Zhang, Y. Lin, T. Duan, and L. Song, “Interfacial Engineering of Heterogeneous Catalysts for Electrocatalysis,” Materials Today 48 (2021): 115-134.

[118] G. Zhang, A. Wang, L. Niu, et al., “Interfacial Engineering to Construct Antioxidative Pd₄S/Pd₃P_0.95 Heterostructure for Robust Hydrogen Production at High Current Density,” Advanced Energy Materials 12 (2022): 2103511.

[119] A. Sadhukhan, A. Karmakar, and K. Koner, “Functionality Modulation toward Thianthrene-based Metal-Free Electrocatalysts for Water Splitting,” Advanced Materials (2024): 36.

[120] J. Wang, “Controlling Dynamic Reconstruction Chemistry for Superior Oxygen-evolving Catalysts,” Chemistry (Weinheim An Der Bergstrasse, Germany) (2023): 1645-1657.

[121] J. Wang, Y. Zhang, and Y. Wang, “Heterostructure Boosts a Noble-metal-free Oxygen-evolving Electrocatalyst in Acid,” Energy & Environmental Science 17 (2024): 5972-5983.

[122] M. Wang, Z. Wang, Y. Zhang, et al., “Regulating Reconstruction Activity of Cobalt Electrode for Optimized Water Oxidation,” ACS Energy Letters 9 (2024): 5502-5508.

[123] J. Wang, S.-J. Kim, J. Liu, et al., “Redirecting Dynamic Surface Restructuring of a Layered Transition Metal Oxide Catalyst for Superior Water Oxidation,” Nature Catalysis 4 (2021): 212-222.

[124] J. Ni, Z. Shi, Y. Wang, et al., “Development of Noble Metal-free Electrocatalysts towards Acidic Water Oxidation: From Fundamental Understanding to state-of-the-art Catalysts,” Escience (2024): 100295.

[125] L. Li, Z. Qin, L. Ries, et al., “Role of Sulfur Vacancies and Undercoordinated Mo Regions in MoS₂ Nanosheets Toward the Evolution of Hydrogen,” ACS Nano 13 (2019): 6824-6834.

[126] H. Xue, A. Meng, T. Yang, Z. Li, and C. Chen, “Controllable Oxygen Vacancies and Morphology Engineering: Ultra-high HER/OER Activity Under Base-acid Conditions and Outstanding Antibacterial Properties,” Journal of Energy Chemistry 71 (2022): 639-651.

[127] H. Sun, Z. Yan, F. Liu, W. Xu, F. Cheng, and J. Chen, “Self-Supported Transition-Metal-Based Electrocatalysts for Hydrogen and Oxygen Evolution,” Advanced Materials 32 (2020): 1806326.

[128] S. Bolar, S. Shit, P. Samanta, et al., “Conducting Scaffold Supported Defect Rich 3D rGO-CNT/MoS₂ Nanostructure for Efficient HER Electrocatalyst at Variable pH,” Composites Part B Engineering 230 (2022): 109489.

[129] F. Yu, H. Zhou, and Y. Huang, “High-performance Bifunctional Porous Non-noble Metal Phosphide Catalyst for Overall Water Splitting,” Nature Communications 9 (2018).

[130] S. Li, Y. Liu, Y. Wu, et al., “Tungsten Promoted Nickel Phosphide Nanosheets Supported on Carbon Cloth: An Efficient and Stable Bifunctional Electrocatalyst for Overall Water Splitting,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 46 (2021): 37152-37161.

[131] M. Kim, M. A. R. Anjum, M. Lee, B. J. Lee, and J. S. Lee, “Activating MoS₂ Basal Plane With Ni₂P Nanoparticles for Pt-Like Hydrogen Evolution Reaction in Acidic Media,” Advanced Functional Materials 29 (2019): 1809151.

[132] T. Wang, P. Chang, Z. Sun, X. Wang, J. Tao, and L. Guan, “Interface Prompted Highly Efficient Hydrogen Evolution of MoS₂/CoS₂ Heterostructures in a Wide pH Range,” Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 25 (2023): 13966-13977.

[133] Q. He, Y. Zhou, H. Shou, et al., “Synergic Reaction Kinetics Over Adjacent Ruthenium Sites for Superb Hydrogen Generation in Alkaline Media,” Advanced Materials 34 (2022): 2110604.

[134] C. Zeng, J. Zhang, L. Xia, et al., “Self-tuned Interfacial Charges Induced by Protonated Transition Metal Heterostructure for Efficiently Acidic Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Chemical Engineering Journal 476 (2023): 146387.

[135] I. K. Mishra, H. Zhou, and J. Sun, “Hierarchical CoP/Ni₅P₄/CoP Microsheet Arrays as a Robust pH-universal Electrocatalyst for Efficient Hydrogen Generation,” Energy & Environmental Science 11 (2018): 2246-2252.

[136] J. Sun, M. Ren, L. Yu, et al., “Highly Efficient Hydrogen Evolution From a Mesoporous Hybrid of Nickel Phosphide Nanoparticles Anchored on Cobalt Phosphosulfide/Phosphide Nanosheet Arrays,” Small 15 (2019): 1804272.

[137] M. Jin, X. Zhang, S. Niu, et al., “Strategies for Designing High-Performance Hydrogen Evolution Reaction Electrocatalysts at Large Current Densities Above 1000 mA cm⁻²,” ACS Nano 16 (2022): 11577-11597.

[138] S. Gong, Y. Meng, Z. Jin, H.-Y. Hsu, M. Du, and F. Liu, “Recent Progress on the Stability of Electrocatalysts Under High Current Densities Toward Industrial Water Splitting,” ACS Catalysis 14 (2024): 14399-14435.

[139] S. Zhao, Y. Yang, and Z. Tang, “Insight Into Structural Evolution, Active Sites, and Stability of Heterogeneous Electrocatalysts,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition 61 (2022).

[140] W. Gou, Y. Wang, M. Zhang, X. Tan, Y. Ma, and Y. Qu, “A Review on Fundamentals for Designing Stable Ruthenium-based Catalysts for the Hydrogen and Oxygen Evolution Reactions,” Chinese Journal of Catalysis 60 (2024): 68-106.

[141] P. Xiao, Y. Yan, X. Ge, Z. Liu, J.-Y. Wang, and X. Wang, “Investigation of Molybdenum Carbide Nano-rod as an Efficient and Durable Electrocatalyst for Hydrogen Evolution in Acidic and Alkaline media,” Applied Catalysis B 154-155 (2014): 232-237.

[142] S. Padmapriya, S. Harinipriya, K. Jaidev, V. Sudha, D. Kumar, and S. Pal, “Storage and Evolution of Hydrogen in Acidic Medium by Polyaniline,” International Journal of Energy Research 42 (2018): 1196-1209.

[143] K. Fan, H. Zou, Y. Lu, et al., “Direct Observation of Structural Evolution of Metal Chalcogenide in Electrocatalytic Water Oxidation,” ACS Nano 12 (2018): 12369-12379.

[144] Z. Qiu, Y. Ma, and T. Edvinsson, “In operando Raman Investigation of Fe Doping Influence on Catalytic NiO Intermediates for Enhanced Overall Water Splitting,” Nano Energy 66 (2019): 104118.

[145] W. Cheng, H. Su, and Q. Liu, “Tracking the Oxygen Dynamics of Solid-Liquid Electrochemical Interfaces by Correlative in Situ Synchrotron Spectroscopies,” Accounts of Chemical Research 55 (2022): 1949-1959.

[146] J. Wang, C.-S. Hsu, and T.-S. Wu, “In Situ X-ray Spectroscopies Beyond Conventional X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy on Deciphering Dynamic Configuration of Electrocatalysts,” Nature Communications 14 (2023).

[147] T. Li, O. Kasian, S. Cherevko, et al., “Atomic-scale Insights Into Surface Species of Electrocatalysts in Three Dimensions,” Nature Catalysis 1 (2018): 300-305.

[148] J. G. Rivera, R. Garcia-Garcia, E. Coutino-Gonzalez, and G. Orozco, “Electrochemical Study in Acid Aqueous Solution and Ex-situ X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy Analysis of Metallic Rhenium Surface,” Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry 893 (2021): 115297.

[149] M. R. Nellist, F. A. L. Laskowski, J. Qiu, et al., “Potential-sensing Electrochemical Atomic Force Microscopy for in Operando Analysis of Water-splitting Catalysts and Interfaces,” Nature Energy 3 (2017): 46-52.

[150] U. Arshad, S. A. A. Taqvi, and A. Buang, “Experimental Analysis and Data-driven Machine Learning Modelling of the Minimum Ignition Temperature (MIT) of Aluminium Dust,” Fuel 324 (2022): 124569.

[151] S. Waqas, N. Y. Harun, U. Arshad, et al., “Optimization of Operational Parameters Using RSM, ANN, and SVM in Membrane Integrated With Rotating Biological Contactor,” Chemosphere 349 (2024): 140830.

[152] J. Li, N. Wu, and J. Zhang, “Machine Learning-Assisted Low-Dimensional Electrocatalysts Design for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Nano-Micro Letters (2023): 15.

[153] Y. Lv, G. Chen, R. Ma, J. Yong Lee, and B. Kang, “Hybrid Scheme of DFT and Machine Learning to Accelerate the Design of Graphyne Nanoribbons as Electrocatalysts for the ORR and HER,” Fuel 357 (2024): 130017.

[154] Y. Haghshenas, W. P. Wong, D. Gunawan, et al., “Predicting the Rates of Photocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution Over Cocatalyst-deposited TiO₂ Using Machine Learning With Active Photon Flux as a Unifying Feature,” EES Catalysis 2 (2024): 612-623.

[155] M. Tamtaji, M. Kazemeini, and J. Abdi, “DFT and Machine Learning Studies on a Multi-functional Single-atom Catalyst for Enhanced Oxygen and Hydrogen Evolution as Well as CO₂ Reduction Reactions,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 80 (2024): 1075-1083.

[156] R. Bakır, C. Orak, and A. Yüksel, “Optimizing Hydrogen Evolution Prediction: A Unified Approach Using Random Forests, lightGBM, and Bagging Regressor Ensemble Model,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 67 (2024): 101-110.

[157] U. Arshad, S. A. A. Taqvi, and A. Buang, “Modelling of the Minimum Ignition Temperature (MIT) of Corn Dust Using Statistical Analysis and Artificial Neural Networks Based on the Synergistic Effect of Concentration and Dispersion Pressure,” Process Safety and Environmental Protection 147 (2021): 742-755.

[158] U. Arshad, S. A. A. Taqvi, A. Buang, and A. Awad, “SVM, ANN, and PSF Modelling Approaches for Prediction of Iron Dust Minimum Ignition Temperature (MIT) Based on the Synergistic Effect of Dispersion Pressure and Concentration,” Process Safety and Environmental Protection 152 (2021): 375-390.

[159] A. A. Malik, R. Rusli, S. Nazir, R. H. Wong, and U. Arshad, “Grid-based Assessment of Hydrogen Leakages for an Offshore Process to Improve the Design and human Performance,” Process Safety Progress 43 (2024).

[160] J. A. Keith, V. Vassilev-Galindo, B. Cheng, et al., “Combining Machine Learning and Computational Chemistry for Predictive Insights into Chemical Systems,” Chemical Reviews 121 (2021): 9816-9872.

[161] F. Strieth-Kalthoff, F. Sandfort, M. H. S. Segler, and F. Glorius, “Machine Learning the Ropes: Principles, Applications and Directions in Synthetic Chemistry,” Chemical Society Reviews 49 (2020): 6154-6168.

[162] J. Zheng, S. Wang, and S. Deng, “Accelerating the Screening of Modified MA₂Z₄ Catalysts for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction by Deep Learning-Based Local Geometric Analysis,” Energy & Environment Materials 7 (2024).

[163] M. V. Jyothirmai, R. Dantuluri, P. Sinha, B. M. Abraham, and J. K. Singh, “Machine-Learning-Driven High-Throughput Screening of Transition-Metal Atom Intercalated G-C₃N₄/MX₂ (M = Mo, W; X = S, Se, Te) Heterostructures for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 16 (2024): 12437-12445.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2025 The Author(s). SusMat published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd. on behalf of Sichuan University.